Dynamic nuclear reorganization during genome remodeling of Tetrahymena

The single-celled ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila possesses two versions of its genome, one germline, one somatic, contained within functionally distinct nuclei (called the micronucleus and macronucleus, respectively). These two genomes differentiate from identical zygotic copies. The development of the somatic nucleus involves large-scale DNA rearrangements that eliminate 15 to 20 Mbp of their germline-derived DNA. The genomic regions excised are dispersed throughout the genome and are largely composed of repetitive sequences. These germline-limited sequences are targeted for removal from the genome by a RNA interference (RNAi)-related machinery that directs histone H3 lysine 9 and 27 methylation to their associated chromatin. The targeting small RNAs are generated in the micronucleus during meiosis and then compared against the parental macronucleus to further enrich for germline-limited sequences and ensure that only non-genic DNA segments are eliminated. Once the small RNAs direct these chromatin modifications, the DNA rearrangement machinery, including the chromodomain proteins Pdd1p and Pdd3p, assembles on these dispersed chromosomal sequences, which are then partitioned into nuclear foci where the excision events occur. This DNA rearrangement mechanism is Tetrahymena's equivalent to the silencing of repetitive sequences by the formation of heterochromatin. The dynamic nuclear reorganization that occurs offers an intriguing glimpse into mechanisms that shape nuclear architecture during eukaryotic development.     

Transposon Domestication versus Mutualism in Ciliate Genome Rearrangements

Ciliated protists rearrange their genomes dramatically during nuclear development via chromosome fragmentation and DNA deletion to produce a trimmer and highly reorganized somatic genome. The deleted portion of the genome includes potentially active transposons or transposon-like sequences that reside in the germline. Three independent studies recently showed that transposase proteins of the DDE/DDD superfamily are indispensible for DNA processing in three distantly related ciliates. In the spirotrich Oxytricha trifallax, high copy-number germline-limited transposons mediate their own excision from the somatic genome but also contribute to programmed genome rearrangement through a remarkable transposon mutualism with the host. By contrast, the genomes of two oligohymenophorean ciliates, Tetrahymena thermophila and Paramecium tetraurelia, encode homologous PiggyBac-like transposases as single-copy genes in both their germline and somatic genomes. These domesticated transposases are essential for deletion of thousands of different internal sequences in these species. This review contrasts the events underlying somatic genome reduction in three different ciliates and considers their evolutionary origins and the relationships among their distinct mechanisms for genome remodeling.     

Interconversion of Germline-Limited and Somatic DNA in a Scrambled Gene

Ciliates have a somatic and a germline nucleus; after sexual conjugation a new somatic nucleus forms from the new zygotic germline nucleus. Formation of the somatic nucleus involves precise elimination of a large portion of DNA sequences from the germline. Here we compare the architecture of the germline and somatic versions of the actin I gene in two geographically isolated strains of Stylonychia lemnae. We show that the structure of the germline gene is surprisingly mercurial, with the distinction between germline-limited and somatic sequences variable over the course of evolution. This is, to our knowledge, the first example of evolutionary swapping of retained versus deleted sequences during ciliate development, with sequences deleted during development that are specifically retained in another strain.     

Cytosine methylation and hydroxymethylation mark DNA for elimination in Oxytricha trifallax

Background

Cytosine methylation of DNA is conserved across eukaryotes and plays important functional roles regulating gene expression during differentiation and development in animals, plants and fungi. Hydroxymethylation was recently identified as another epigenetic modification marking genes important for pluripotency in embryonic stem cells.

Results

Here we describe de novo cytosine methylation and hydroxymethylation in the ciliate Oxytricha trifallax. These DNA modifications occur only during nuclear development and programmed genome rearrangement. We detect methylcytosine and hydroxymethylcytosine directly by high-resolution nano-flow UPLC mass spectrometry, and indirectly by immunofluorescence, methyl-DNA immunoprecipitation and bisulfite sequencing. We describe these modifications in three classes of eliminated DNA: germline-limited transposons and satellite repeats, aberrant DNA rearrangements, and DNA from the parental genome undergoing degradation. Methylation and hydroxymethylation generally occur on the same sequence elements, modifying cytosines in all sequence contexts. We show that the DNA methyltransferase-inhibiting drugs azacitidine and decitabine induce demethylation of both somatic and germline sequence elements during genome rearrangements, with consequent elevated levels of germline-limited repetitive elements in exconjugant cells.

Conclusions

These data strongly support a functional link between cytosine DNA methylation/hydroxymethylation and DNA elimination. We identify a motif strongly enriched in methylated/hydroxymethylated regions, and we propose that this motif recruits DNA modification machinery to specific chromosomes in the parental macronucleus. No recognizable methyltransferase enzyme has yet been described in O. trifallax, raising the possibility that it might employ a novel cytosine methylation machinery to mark DNA sequences for elimination during genome rearrangements.     

Evolution of Germline-Limited Sequences in Two Populations of the Ciliate Chilodonella uncinata

Ciliates are microbial eukaryotes that separate their nuclear functions into a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. During development of the macronucleus the genome undergoes a series of reorganization events that includes the precise excision of intervening DNA. Here, we determine the architecture of four loci in the micronuclear and macronuclear genomes of the ciliate Chilodonella uncinata and compare the levels of variation in micronuclear-limited sequences to macronuclear destined sequences at two of these loci. We find that within a population, germline-limited sequences are evolving at the same rate as other putatively neutral sites, but between populations germline-limited sequences are accumulating mutations at a much faster rate than other sites. We also find evidence of macronuclear recombination and incomplete elimination of intervening DNA, which result in increased diversity in the macronuclear genome. Our results support the assertion that the unusual genomic features of ciliates can result in rapid and unpredicted patterns of diversification.     

Differential fate of plastid and mitochondrial genomes in Petunia somatic hybrids

Summary The chloroplast (cp) and mitochondrial (mt) DNAs of Petunia somatic hybrid plants, which were derived from the fusion of wild-type P. parodii protoplasts with albino P. inflata protoplasts, were analyzed by endonuclease restriction and Southern blot hybridization. Using ³²P-labelled probes that distinguished the two parental cpDNAs at a BamH1 site and at a HpaII site, only the P. parodii chloroplast genome was detected in the 10 somatic hybrid plants analyzed. To examine whether cytoplasmic mixing had resulted in rearrangement of the mitochondrial genome in the somatic hybrids, restriction patterns of purified somatic hybrid and parental mtDNAs were analyzed. Approximately 87% of those restriction fragments which distinguish the two parental genomes are P. inflata-specific. Restriction patterns of the somatic hybrid mtDNAs differ both from the parental patterns and from each other, suggesting that an interaction occurred between the parental mitochondrial genomes in the somatic fusion products which resulted in generation of the novel mtDNA patterns. Southern blot hybridization substantiates this conclusion. In addition, somatic hybrid lines derived from the same fusion product were observed to differ in mtDNA restriction pattern, reflecting a differential sorting-out of mitochondrial genomes at the time the plants were regenerated.     

Parental genomes mix in mule and human cell nuclei

Whether chromosome sets inherited from father and mother occupy separate spaces in the cell nucleus is a question first asked over 110 years ago. Recently, the nuclear organization of the genome has come increasingly into focus as an important level of epigenetic regulation. In this context, it is indispensable to know whether or not parental genomes are spatially separated. Genome separation had been demonstrated for plant hybrids and for the early mammalian embryo. Conclusive studies for somatic mammalian cell nuclei are lacking because homologous chromosomes from the two parents cannot be distinguished within a species. We circumvented this problem by investigating the three-dimensional distribution of chromosomes in mule lymphocytes and fibroblasts. Genomic DNA of horse and donkey was used as probes in fluorescence in situ hybridization under conditions where only tandem repetitive sequences were detected. We thus could determine the distribution of maternal and paternal chromosome sets in structurally preserved interphase nuclei for the first time. In addition, we investigated the distribution of several pairs of chromosomes in human bilobed granulocytes. Qualitative and quantitative image evaluation did not reveal any evidence for the separation of parental genomes. On the contrary, we observed mixing of maternal and paternal chromosome sets.     

Genome-wide analysis of genetic and epigenetic control of programmed DNA deletion

During the development of the somatic genome from the Paramecium germline genome the bulk of the copies of ∼45 000 unique, internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are deleted. IES targeting is facilitated by two small RNA (sRNA) classes: scnRNAs, which relay epigenetic information from the parental nucleus to the developing nucleus, and iesRNAs, which are produced and used in the developing nucleus. Why only certain IESs require sRNAs for their removal has been enigmatic. By analyzing the silencing effects of three genes: PGM (responsible for DNA excision), DCL2/3 (scnRNA production) and DCL5 (iesRNA production), we identify key properties required for IES elimination. Based on these results, we propose that, depending on the exact combination of their lengths and end bases, some IESs are less efficiently recognized or excised and have a greater requirement for targeting by scnRNAs and iesRNAs. We suggest that the variation in IES retention following silencing of DCL2/3 is not primarily due to scnRNA density, which is comparatively uniform relative to IES retention, but rather the genetic properties of IESs. Taken together, our analyses demonstrate that in Paramecium the underlying genetic properties of developmentally deleted DNA sequences are essential in determining the sensitivity of these sequences to epigenetic control.     

Evolution of programmed DNA rearrangements in a scrambled gene

Gene unscrambling in spirotrichous ciliates involves massive genome-wide DNA deletion and rearrangement events during development. During each sexual cycle, the somatic nucleus (macronucleus) regenerates from the germ line nucleus (micronucleus). Development of the polyploid somatic genome requires programmed DNA deletion of micronuclear-limited intragenic noncoding sequences and permutation and amplification of the protein-coding regions. Recent studies suggest that, despite novel insertions of endogenous transposon or foreign DNA into the germ line genome, ciliates possess a whole-genome surveillance system that guides the recapitulation of a functional somatic genome. This renders the germ line genome an extremely dynamic structure over evolutionary time. Here we describe the germ line and somatic architectures of the gene encoding alpha-telomere-binding protein in three early-diverging species (Holosticha sp., Uroleptus sp., and Paraurostyla weissei) and trace the natural history of DNA rearrangements in this gene in six species, including three previously studied oxytrichids. Comparisons of homologous coding regions between earlier and later diverging species provide evidence for fusion of scrambled germ line fragments as small as 24 bp during evolution, as well as simultaneous fragmentation and scrambling of the germ line locus and shifting of the boundaries between coding and noncoding DNA, leading to distinct gene architectures in each species. We infer an evolutionary recombination pathway that passes through identified intermediate species and gives rise to the observed patterns in all known species, capitalizing on their unique DNA rearrangement machinery and germ line flexibility.     

A family of DNA sequences is reproducibly rearranged in the somatic nucleus of Tetrahymena.

A small family of DNA sequences is rearranged during the development of the somatic nucleus in Tetrahymena. The family is defined by 266 bp of highly conserved sequence which restriction mapping, hybridization and sequence analysis have shown is shared by a cloned micronuclear fragment and three sequences which constitute the macronuclear family. Genomic Southern hybridization experiments indicate there are five members of the family in micronuclear DNA. All of the family members are present in whole genome homozygotes and are therefore nonallelic. The three macronuclear sequences are all present in clonal cell lines and are reproducibly generated in every developing macronucleus. The rearrangement event begins 14 hours after conjugation is initiated and is nearly completed by 16 hours.     

Nuclear transplantation in the mouse: heritable differences between parental genomes after activation of the embryonic genome

Paternal and maternal genomes apparently have complementary roles during embryogenesis in the mouse, and both are essential for development to term. However, there is no direct evidence to show that functional differences between parental genomes remain intact after activation of the embryonic genome at the 2-cell stage. In this study we demonstrate that transfer of paternal or maternal nuclei from early haploid preimplantation embryos back to fertilized eggs from which one pronucleus was removed resulted in development to term, but only if the remaining pronucleus was of the parental type opposite to the donor nucleus. Hence, functional differences between parental chromosomes are heritable and they survive activation of the embryonic genome and probable reprogramming of donor embryonic nuclei by epigenetic factors in the egg cytoplasm.     

The transition from conjugal development to the first vegetative cell division is dependent on RAD51 expression in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila

Rad51p, the eukaryotic homolog of the prokaryotic recA protein, catalyzes strand exchange between single- and double-stranded DNA and is involved in both genetic recombination and double-strand break repair in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. We have previously shown that disruption of the Tetrahymena RAD51 somatic macronuclear locus leads to defective germline micronuclear division and that conjugation of two somatic rad51 null strains results in an early meiotic arrest. We have constructed Tetrahymena strains that are capable of RAD51 expression from their parental macronuclei and are homozygous, rad51 nulls in their germline micronuclei. These rad51 null heterokaryons complete all of the early and middle stages of conjugation, including meiosis, haploid nuclear exchange, zygotic fusion, and the programmed chromosome fragmentations, sequence eliminations, and rDNA amplification that occur during macronuclear development. However, the rad51 null progeny fail to initiate the first vegetative cell division following conjugal development. Coincident with the developmental arrest is a disproportionate amplification of rDNA, despite the maintenance of normal total DNA content in the developing macronuclei. Fusion of arrested rad51 null exconjugants to wild-type cells is sufficient to overcome the arrest. Cells rescued by cytoplasmic fusion continue to divide, eventually recapitulating the micronuclear mitotic defects described previously for rad51 somatic nulls.     

Transposons that clean up after themselves

A transposon in the germline genome of the ciliate Oxytricha uses its transposase to remove itself, as well as other germline-limited DNA, from the differentiating somatic genome during development.     

Nuclear and cytoplasmic genome composition of Solanum bulbocastanum (+) S. tuberosum somatic hybrids.

Somatic hybrids between the wild incongruent species Solanum bulbocastanum (2n = 2x = 24) and S. tuberosum haploids (2n = 2x = 24) have been characterized for their nuclear and cytoplasmic genome composition. Cytologic observations revealed the recovery of 8 (near-)tetraploid and 3 hexaploid somatic hybrids. Multicolor genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) analysis was carried out to study the genomic dosage of the parental species in 5 somatic hybrids with different ploidy. The GISH procedure used was effective in discriminating parental genomes in the hybrids; most chromosomes were unambiguously colored. Two (near-)tetraploid somatic hybrids showed the expected 2:2 cultivated-to-wild genomic dosage; 2 hexaploids revealed a 4:2 cultivated-to-wild genomic dosage, and 1 hexaploid had a 2:4 cultivated-to-wild genomic dosage. Characterization of hybrid cytoplasmic genomes was performed using gene-specific primers that detected polymorphisms between the fusion parents in the intergenic regions. The analysis showed that most of the somatic hybrids inherited the plastidial and mitochondrial DNA of the cultivated parent. A few hybrids, with a rearranged mitochondrial genome (showing fragments derived from both parents), were also identified. These results confirmed the potential of somatic hybridization in producing new variability for genetic studies and breeding.     

Genome rearrangements: mother knows best!

In Paramecium, developmentally programmed genome rearrangements can be altered by the presence of homologous sequences within the maternal somatic nucleus. Newly identified RNA-binding proteins appear to mediate the transfer of homologous sequence information from the maternal to the developing somatic nucleus, facilitating epigenetic regulation of this large-scale genome reorganization.     

Parental genomes are separated throughout the cell cycle in a plant hybrid

The positions of the genomes originating from each parent were analysed in root-tip nuclei of the mature, sexual F₁ hybrid plant Hordeum vulgare (barley) x Secale africanum (a wild rye). The two genomes of the hybrid were identified in both spread and sectioned material by non-radioactive DNA:DNA in situ hybridization using labelled total genomic DNA from one parent as a proble and unlabelled total genomic DNA from the other parent to block non-specific hybridization. Complete three-dimensional reconstructions of sets of labelled sections enabled detailed analysis of the position of the genomes at interphase. The parental genomes lay in various non-intermixed configurations, including lateral and concentric arrangements. On spread preparations, the two parental genomes were found to be spatially separated throughout the cell cycle; the genome originating from H. vulgare tended to be located more centrally than that from S. africanum. This results show that the nucleus is spatially organized above the level of the DNA and chromosome at the genome level.by M.F. Trendelenburg     

Lia1p, a novel protein required during nuclear differentiation for genome-wide DNA rearrangements in Tetrahymena thermophila

Extensive genome-wide rearrangements occur during somatic macronuclear development in Tetrahymena thermophila. These events are guided by RNA interference-directed chromatin modification including histone H3 lysine 9 methylation, which marks specific germ line-limited internal eliminated sequences (IESs) for excision. Several genes putatively involved in these developmental genome rearrangements were identified based on their proteins' localization to differentiating somatic nuclei, and here we demonstrate that one, LIA1, encodes a novel protein that is an essential component of the genome rearrangement machinery. A green fluorescent protein-Lia1 fusion protein exhibited dynamic nuclear localization during development that has striking similarity to that of the dual chromodomain-containing DNA rearrangement protein, Pdd1p. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments showed that Lia1p associates with Pdd1p and IES chromatin during macronuclear development. Cell lines in which we disrupted both the germ line and somatic copies of LIA1 (DeltaLIA1) grew normally but were unable to generate viable progeny, arresting late in development just prior to returning to vegetative growth. These mutant lines failed to properly form Pdd1p-containing nuclear structures and eliminate IESs despite showing normal levels of H3K9 methylation. These data indicate that Lia1p is required late in conjugation for the reorganization of the Tetrahymena genome.     

Oxytricha as a modern analog of ancient genome evolution

Several independent lines of evidence suggest that the modern genetic system was preceded by the 'RNA world' in which RNA genes encoded RNA catalysts. Current gaps in our conceptual framework of early genetic systems make it difficult to imagine how a stable RNA genome may have functioned and how the transition to a DNA genome could have taken place. Here we use the single-celled ciliate, Oxytricha, as an analog to some of the genetic and genomic traits that may have been present in organisms before and during the establishment of a DNA genome. Oxytricha and its close relatives have a unique genome architecture involving two differentiated nuclei, one of which encodes the genome on small, linear nanochromosomes. While its unique genomic characteristics are relatively modern, some physiological processes related to the genomes and nuclei of Oxytricha may exemplify primitive states of the developing genetic system.     

Organization and dynamics of satellite and telomere DNAs in Ascaris: implications for formation and programmed breakdown of compound chromosomes

In the nematode genus Ascaris the germline genome contains considerable amounts of extra DNA, which is discarded from the somatic founder blastomeres during early cleavage. In Parascaris univalens the haploid germline genome is contained in one large compound chromosome, which consists of a euchromatic region containing the somatic genome flanked by large blocks of heterochromatin. Fluorescence in situ hybridization of fractions of the germline-limited satellite DNA revealed two highly repeated sequence families establishing the entire heterochromatin (HET blocks). The repeats, a pentanucleotide, TTGCA, and a decanucleotide, TTTGTGCGTG, constitute separate segments of the HET blocks. The blocks are polymorphic in length and, hence, in copy number of the repeats, and the arrangement of the segments. The numerous sequence variants of both repeats display a disperse distribution. The type and rate of base substitutions within both repeat units depend on position. Prior to the elimination process in presomatic cells, termed chromatin diminution, the chromosomes undergo differential mitotic condensation. Interstitial 'chromatin linkers' flanking the prospective numerous somatic chromosomes remain entirely decondensed. The somatic chromosomes are released from the plurivalent chromosomes via excision of the linkers at onset of anaphase, followed by exclusion of the akinetic linker chromatin and HET blocks from the daughter nuclei. In Ascaris suum, the germline-limited satellite, which consists of one 123 bp repeat, is scattered throughout the numerous chromosomes in small heterochromatic knobs of variable sizes, residing at chromosomal ends and/or intercalary positions. The programmed breakage, which appears to proceed in a similar manner to that in P. univalens, results in the loss of all heterochromatic knobs, accompanied by an increase in chromosome number. In both species, all germline chromosomes are capped by tracts of TTAGGC repeats. In P. univalens, such telomeric tracts also occur at the termini of the euchromatic intercalary regions. Upon diminution all telomeric tracts are discarded. De novo telomere addition occurs in all somatic cell lineages of both species. The presented data shed light on the evolutionary history of chromosome aggregation and satellite DNA formation, and putative mechanisms involved in the process of site-directed breakage to reestablish stable somatic chromosomes.