Protein-DNA footprinting by endcapped duplex oligodeoxyribonucleotides

Oligodeoxyribonucleotides (5'-phosphorylated) of varying lengths were capped using a polyamide linker to form thermodynamically stable, endcapped DNA duplexes containing 8-14 bp. We have employed these endcapped DNA duplexes as tools to determine the DNA footprint of T4 DNA ligase. By high-performance liquid chromatography and PAGE analysis of the ligation mixtures of the endcapped DNA duplexes, we have found that by varying the lengths and the position of the nick, we can determine the minimal DNA-binding site as well as the mode of binding (symmetrical or asymmetrical binding) by the enzyme. The results of the study revealed that a 11 bp endcapped duplex was the shortest duplex effectively ligated. Dependence of ligation efficiency on nick position demonstrates that T4 DNA ligase bound asymmetrically to its DNA substrate. The use of a set of thermodynamically stable endcapped deoxyribonucleoside duplexes as a tool to elucidate the DNA footprint provides an efficient strategy for footprinting, which avoids ambiguities associated with chemical and biochemical footprinting methods.     

The Inhibitory Effect of Non-Substrate and Substrate DNA on the Ligation and Self-Adenylylation Reactions Catalyzed by T4 DNA Ligase

DNA ligases are essential both to in vivo replication, repair and recombination processes, and in vitro molecular biology protocols. Prior characterization of DNA ligases through gel shift assays has shown the presence of a nick site to be essential for tight binding between the enzyme and its dsDNA substrate, with no interaction evident on dsDNA lacking a nick. In the current study, we observed a significant substrate inhibition effect, as well as the inhibition of both the self-adenylylation and nick-sealing steps of T4 DNA ligase by non-nicked, non-substrate dsDNA. Inhibition by non-substrate DNA was dependent only on the total DNA concentration rather than the structure; with 1 μg/mL of 40-mers, 75-mers, or circular plasmid DNA all inhibiting ligation equally. A >15-fold reduction in T4 DNA ligase self-adenylylation rate when in the presence of high non-nicked dsDNA concentrations was observed. Finally, EMSAs were utilized to demonstrate that non-substrate dsDNA can compete with nicked dsDNA substrates for enzyme binding. Based upon these data, we hypothesize the inhibition of T4 DNA ligase by non-nicked dsDNA is direct evidence for a two-step nick-binding mechanism, with an initial, nick-independent, transient dsDNA-binding event preceding a transition to a stable binding complex in the presence of a nick site.     

T4-DNA ligase: substrate properties of synthetic DNA-duplexes with structural anomalies

Structural defects, affecting T4 DNA ligase function, were revealed with the help of synthetic DNA duplexes, containing modifications at single nick. Changes of configuration at C2' and C3' atoms of furanose in the acceptor terminus lead to total blocking of the nick sealing activity of T4 DNA ligase. On the contrary, substitution of 3'-terminal deoxyribonucleotide for ribonucleotide doesn't affect the enzyme's action. The duplex looses all of it's substrate activity if the next from the nick G.C pair is substituted for the noncomplementary G.C pair. In DNA duplexes containing an unpaired base in the nick, elimination of the extrahelical nucleotide proceeds the ligation step. In these cases the duplex substrate activity decreases depending on the extent of extrahelical base stacking into the double stranded DNA.     

Effects of base mismatches on joining of short oligodeoxynucleotides by DNA ligases.

The requirement for Watson-Crick base pairing surrounding a nick in duplex DNA to be sealed by DNA ligase is the basis for oligonucleotide ligation assays that distinguish single base mutations in DNA targets. Experiments in a model system demonstrate that the minimum length of oligonucleotide that can be joined differs for different ligases. Thermus thermophilus (Tth) DNA ligase is unable to join any oligonucleotide of length six or less, while T4 DNA ligase and T7 DNA ligase are both able to join hexamers. The rate of oligonucleotide ligation by Tth DNA ligase increases between heptamer and nonamer. Mismatches which cause the duplex to be shortened by fraying, at the end distal to the join, slow the ligation reaction. In the case of Tth DNA ligase, mismatches at the seventh and eighth position 5'to the nick completely inhibit the ligation of octamers. The results are relevant to mechanisms of ligation.     

Chemical reactions in double-stranded nucleic acids. III. Synthesis of terminal inverted repeats of the IS1 element

Three 35 bp-DNA duplexes have been assembled from synthetic oligonucleotides by means of DNA ligase or 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide in two parallel series of experiments. The "top" strands of these duplexes correspond either to the imperfect (natural) or perfect terminal inverted repeats of the IS1. Tm of DNA duplexes composed of 2 to 6 different oligonucleotides were investigated by UV spectroscopy. It was shown that DNA ligase effectively joined oligonucleotides even under conditions of DNA duplex instability. However, there is a minimum duplex size (within the range of 9-15 bp) below which the enzymatic ligation is ineffective. Chemical assembly of duplexes took place only if the double helix was stable. The yield was 50% after two successive ligation cycles. Efficiency of the chemical ligation depends on the nature of the nucleotide units to be joined.     

Two DNA-binding and nick recognition modules in human DNA ligase III

Human DNA ligase III contains an N-terminal zinc finger domain that binds to nicks and gaps in DNA. This small domain has been described as a DNA nick sensor, but it is not required for DNA nick joining activity in vitro. In light of new structural information for mammalian ligases, we measured the DNA binding affinity and specificity of each domain of DNA ligase III. These studies identified two separate, independent DNA-binding modules in DNA ligase III that each bind specifically to nicked DNA over intact duplex DNA. One of these modules comprises the zinc finger domain and DNA-binding domain, which function together as a single DNA binding unit. The catalytic core of ligase III is the second DNA nick-binding module. Both binding modules are required for ligation of blunt ended DNA substrates. Although the zinc finger increases the catalytic efficiency of nick ligation, it appears to occupy the same binding site as the DNA ligase III catalytic core. We present a jackknife model for ligase III that posits conformational changes during nick sensing and ligation to extend the versatility of the enzyme.     

Nick recognition by DNA ligases

Phage T7 DNA ligase seals nicked DNA substrates and is a representative member of the ATP-dependent class of DNA ligases. Although the catalytic mechanism of DNA ligases has been delineated, little is known about the nature of nick recognition by these enzymes. Here, we show that T7 ligase discriminates, at the nick-binding step, between nicks containing either a 5'-phosphate or a 5'-OH. T7 ligase binds preferentially to phosphorylated nicks and catalyses the sealing reaction. We also show using DNA footprinting studies, that T7 ligase binds asymmetrically to nicks as a monomer, with the protein interface covering between 12 and 14 bp of DNA. Based on molecular modelling studies we propose a structural model of the ligase-DNA complex consistent with these and other data. Using photo-crosslinking and site-directed mutagenesis we have identified two residues, K238 and K240, critical for the transadenylation and nick-sealing reactions. Sequence conservation and structural analysis supports the premise that these two lysine residues are critical for both nucleotide binding and DNA nick recognition. The implications of these results on the ligation mechanism are discussed.     

Deinococcus radiodurans RNA ligase exemplifies a novel ligase clade with a distinctive N-terminal module that is important for 5'-PO4 nick sealing and ligase adenylylation but dispensable for phosphodiester formation at an adenylylated nick

Deinococcus radiodurans RNA ligase (DraRnl) is a template-directed ligase that seals nicked duplexes in which the 3′-OH strand is RNA. DraRnl is a 342 amino acid polypeptide composed of a C-terminal adenylyltransferase domain fused to a distinctive 126 amino acid N-terminal module (a putative OB-fold). An alanine scan of the C domain identified 9 amino acids essential for nick ligation, which are located within nucleotidyltransferase motifs I, Ia, III, IIIa, IV and V. Seven mutants were dysfunctional by virtue of defects in ligase adenylylation: T163A, H167A, G168A, K186A, E230A, F281A and E305A. Four of these were also defective in phosphodiester formation at a preadenylylated nick: G168A, E230A, F281A and E305A. Two nick sealing-defective mutants were active in ligase adenylylation and sealing a preadenylylated nick, thereby implicating Ser185 and Lys326 in transfer of AMP from the enzyme to the nick 5′-PO₄. Whereas deletion of the N-terminal domain suppressed overall nick ligation and ligase adenylylation, it did not compromise sealing at a preadenylylated nick. Mutational analysis of 15 residues of the N domain identified Lys26, Gln31 and Arg79 as key constituents. Structure–activity relationships at the essential residues were determined via conservative substitutions. We propose that DraRnl typifies a new clade of polynucleotide ligases. DraRnl homologs are detected in several eukaryal proteomes.     

Functional characterization of the T4 DNA ligase: a new insight into the mechanism of action.

ATP-dependent DNA ligases are essential enzymes in both DNA replication and DNA repair processes. Here we report a functional characterization of the T4 DNA ligase. One N-terminal and two C-terminal deletion mutants were expressed in Escherichia coli as histidine- tagged proteins. An additional mutant bore a substitution of Lys159 in the active site that abolished ATP binding. All the proteins were tested in biochemical assays for ATP-dependent self-adenylation, DNA binding, nick joining, blunt-end ligation and AMP- dependent DNA relaxation. From this analysis we conclude that binding to DNA is mediated by sequences at both protein ends and plays a key role in the reaction. The enzyme establishes two different complexes with DNA: (i) a transient complex (T.complex) involving the adenylated enzyme; (ii) a stable complex (S.complex) requiring the deadenylated T4 DNA ligase. The formation of an S. complex seems to be relevant during both blunt-end ligation and DNA relaxation. Moreover the inactive His-K159L substitution mutant, although unable to self-adenylate, still possesses AMP-dependent DNA nicking activity.     

Expression,purification and biochemical characterization of Methanocaldococcus jannaschii DNA ligase

We describe the biochemical characterization of Methanocaldococcus jannaschii (M. jannaschii) DNA ligase and its potential application in single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping. The recombinant M. jannaschii DNA ligase is an ATP-dependent ligase. The ligase activity was dependent on metal ions of Mg²⁺ and Mn²⁺. The optimal concentrations of ATP cofactor and Mg²⁺ ion were 0.01–2 and 10 mM, respectively. The optimal pH value for DNA ligation was 8.5. High concentrations of NaCl inhibited DNA ligation. The effects of mismatches on joining short oligonucleotides by M. jannaschii DNA ligase were fully characterized. The mismatches at the first position 5′ to the nick inhibited ligation more than those at the first position 3′ to the nick. The mismatches at other positions 5′ to the nick (3rd to 7th sites) exhibited less inhibition on ligation. However, the introduction of a C/C mismatch at the third position 5′ to the nick could completely inhibit the ligation of the terminal-mismatched nick of an oligonucleotide duplex by M. jannaschii DNA ligase. Therefore, introducing an additional mismatch at the third position 5′ to the SNP site is a more effective approach in genotyping by M. jannaschii DNA ligase.     

Footprinting of Chlorella virus DNA ligase bound at a nick in duplex DNA.

The 298-amino acid ATP-dependent DNA ligase of Chlorella virus PBCV-1 is the smallest eukaryotic DNA ligase known. The enzyme has intrinsic specificity for binding to nicked duplex DNA. To delineate the ligase-DNA interface, we have footprinted the enzyme binding site on DNA and the DNA binding site on ligase. The size of the exonuclease III footprint of ligase bound a single nick in duplex DNA is 19-21 nucleotides. The footprint is asymmetric, extending 8-9 nucleotides on the 3'-OH side of the nick and 11-12 nucleotides on the 5'-phosphate side. The 5'-phosphate moiety is essential for the binding of Chlorella virus ligase to nicked DNA. Here we show that the 3'-OH moiety is not required for nick recognition. The Chlorella virus ligase binds to a nicked ligand containing 2',3'-dideoxy and 5'-phosphate termini, but cannot catalyze adenylation of the 5'-end. Hence, the 3'-OH is important for step 2 chemistry even though it is not itself chemically transformed during DNA-adenylate formation. A 2'-OH cannot substitute for the essential 3'-OH in adenylation at a nick or even in strand closure at a preadenylated nick. The protein side of the ligase-DNA interface was probed by limited proteolysis of ligase with trypsin and chymotrypsin in the presence and absence of nicked DNA. Protease accessible sites are clustered within a short segment from amino acids 210-225 located distal to conserved motif V. The ligase is protected from proteolysis by nicked DNA. Protease cleavage of the native enzyme prior to DNA addition results in loss of DNA binding. These results suggest a bipartite domain structure in which the interdomain segment either comprises part of the DNA binding site or undergoes a conformational change upon DNA binding. The domain structure of Chlorella virus ligase inferred from the solution experiments is consistent with the structure of T7 DNA ligase determined by x-ray crystallography.     

Site-directed modification of DNA duplexes by chemical ligation.

The efficiency of chemical ligation method have been demonstrated by assembling a number of DNA duplexes with modified sugar phosphate backbone. Condensation on a tetradecanucleotide template of hexa(penta)- and undecanucleotides differing only in the terminal nucleoside residue have been performed using water-soluble carbodiimide as a condensing agent. As was shown by comparing the efficiency of chemical ligation of single-strand breaks in those duplexes, the reaction rate rises 70 or 45 times if the 3'-OH group is substituted with an amino or phosphate group (the yield of products with a phosphoramidate or pyrophosphate bond is 96-100% in 6 d). Changes in the conformation of reacting groups caused by mismatched base pairs (A.A, A.C) as well as the hybrid rU.dA pair or an unpaired base make the template-directed condensation less effective. The thermal stability of DNA duplexes was assayed before and after the chemical ligation. Among all of the modified duplexes, only the duplex containing 3'-rU in the nick was found to be a substrate of T4 DNA ligase.     

Specificity and fidelity of strand joining by Chlorella virus DNA ligase.

Chlorella virus PBCV-1 DNA ligase seals nicked duplex DNA substrates consisting of a 5'-phosphate-terminated strand and a 3'-hydroxyl-terminated strand annealed to a bridging template strand, but cannot ligate a nicked duplex composed of two DNAs annealed on an RNA template. Whereas PBCV-1 ligase efficiently joins a 3'-OH RNA to a 5'-phosphate DNA, it is unable to join a 3'-OH DNA to a 5'-phosphate RNA. The ligase discriminates at the substrate binding step between nicked duplexes containing 5'-phosphate DNA versus 5'-phosphate RNA strands. PBCV-1 ligase readily seals a nicked duplex DNA containing a single ribonucleotide substitution at the reactive 5'-phosphate end. These results suggest a requirement for a B-form helical conformation of the polynucleotide on the 5'-phosphate side of the nick. Single base mismatches at the nick exert disparate effects on DNA ligation efficiency. PBCV-1 ligase tolerates mismatches involving the 5'-phosphate nucleotide, with the exception of 5'-A:G and 5'-G:A mispairs, which reduce ligase activity by two orders of magnitude. Inhibitory configurations at the 3'-OH nucleotide include 3'-G:A, 3'-G:T, 3'-T:T, 3'-A:G, 3'-G:G, 3'-A:C and 3'-C:C. Our findings indicate that Chlorella virus DNA ligase has the potential to affect genome integrity by embedding ribonucleotides in viral DNA and by sealing nicked molecules with mispaired ends, thereby generating missense mutations.     

2′-氟取代对T7 DNA连接酶连接效率的阻滞

为更好地理解连接酶的接合机制,研究了2′-氟取代核苷酸（2′-fluorinated nucleotide, FN）对T7 DNA连接酶接合特性的影响。利用分子信标的荧光信号变化来检测连接酶接合活性。结果显示,在连接酶作用的分子信标缺口处的5′端和3′端分别进行F取代时,对T7 DNA连接酶的接合效果分别阻滞（48.7±6.7）%和（70.6±4.0）%。在取代同时发生在5′端和3′端时,接合效果被阻滞（76.6±1.3）%。动力学参数的回归显示,FN取代会导致连接反应最大速率（Vmax）降低,同时导致米氏常数Km增大,说明酶和底物之间的亲和力在取代后减小。缺口两端的碱基错配也对酶接合反应效果产生一定的阻滞效应。本研究的结果和结论使对氟取代后,T7 DNA连接酶的接合特性有了更进一步的认识,为更好地应用T7 DNA连接酶接合活性提供有力的实用依据。     

Nick sensing by vaccinia virus DNA ligase requires a 5' phosphate at the nick and occupancy of the adenylate binding site on the enzyme.

Vaccinia virus DNA ligase has an intrinsic nick-sensing function. The enzyme discriminates at the substrate binding step between a DNA containing a 5' phosphate and a DNA containing a 5' hydroxyl at the nick. Further insights into nick recognition and catalysis emerge from studies of the active-site mutant K231A, which is unable to form the covalent ligase-adenylate intermediate and hence cannot activate a nicked DNA substrate via formation of the DNA-adenylate intermediate. Nonetheless, K231A does catalyze phosphodiester bond formation at a preadenylated nick. Hence, the active-site lysine of DNA ligase is not required for the strand closure step of the ligation reaction. The K231A mutant binds tightly to nicked DNA-adenylate but has low affinity for a standard DNA nick. The wild-type vaccinia virus ligase, which is predominantly ligase-adenylate, binds tightly to a DNA nick. This result suggests that occupancy of the AMP binding pocket of DNA ligase is essential for stable binding to DNA. Sequestration of an extrahelical nucleotide by DNA-bound ligase is reminiscent of the base-flipping mechanism of target-site recognition and catalysis used by other DNA modification and repair enzymes.     

The scaffold protein XRCC1 stabilizes the formation of polβ/gap DNA and ligase IIIα/nick DNA complexes in base excision repair

The base excision repair (BER) pathway involves gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by ligase IIIα. X-ray cross-complementing protein 1 (XRCC1), a nonenzymatic scaffold protein, assembles multiprotein complexes, although the mechanism by which XRCC1 orchestrates the final steps of coordinated BER remains incompletely defined. Here, using a combination of biochemical and biophysical approaches, we revealed that the polβ/XRCC1 complex increases the processivity of BER reactions after correct nucleotide insertion into gaps in DNA and enhances the handoff of nicked repair products to the final ligation step. Moreover, the mutagenic ligation of nicked repair intermediate following polβ 8-oxodGTP insertion is enhanced in the presence of XRCC1. Our results demonstrated a stabilizing effect of XRCC1 on the formation of polβ/dNTP/gap DNA and ligase IIIα/ATP/nick DNA catalytic ternary complexes. Real-time monitoring of protein–protein interactions and DNA-binding kinetics showed stronger binding of XRCC1 to polβ than to ligase IIIα or aprataxin, and higher affinity for nick DNA with undamaged or damaged ends than for one nucleotide gap repair intermediate. Finally, we demonstrated slight differences in stable polβ/XRCC1 complex formation, polβ and ligase IIIα protein interaction kinetics, and handoff process as a result of cancer-associated (P161L, R194W, R280H, R399Q, Y576S) and cerebellar ataxia-related (K431N) XRCC1 variants. Overall, our findings provide novel insights into the coordinating role of XRCC1 and the effect of its disease-associated variants on substrate-product channeling in multiprotein/DNA complexes for efficient BER.     

Characterization of proteolytic fragments of bacteriophage T7 DNA ligase.

Treatment of T7 DNA ligase with a range of proteases generates two major fragments which are resistant to further digestion. These fragments, of molecular weight 16 and 26 kDa, are derived from the N- and C-termini of the protein, respectively. The presence of ATP or a non-hydrolysable analogue, ADPNP, during limited proteolysis greatly reduces the level of digestion. The N-terminal 16 kDa region of the intact T7 ligase is labelled selectively in the presence of [alpha-32P]ATP, confirming that it contains the active site lysine residue. In common with the intact enzyme, the C-terminal portion of the protein retains the ability to band shift DNA fragments of various lengths, implicating it in DNA binding. It can also inhibit ligation by the intact protein, apparently by competing for target sites on DNA. We conclude that the N-terminal region, which contains the putative active site lysine, plays a role in the transfer of AMP from the enzyme-adenylate complex to the 5'phosphate at the nick site, while the C-terminal 26 kDa fragment appears to position the enzyme at the target site on DNA.     

Kinetics and thermodynamics of nick sealing by T4 DNA ligase.

T4 DNA ligase is an Mg2+-dependent and ATP-dependent enzyme that seals DNA nicks in three steps: it covalently binds AMP, transadenylates the nick phosphate, and catalyses formation of the phosphodiester bond releasing AMP. In this kinetic study, we further detail the reaction mechanism, showing that the overall ligation reaction is a superimposition of two parallel processes: a 'processive' ligation, in which the enzyme transadenylates and seals the nick without dissociating from dsDNA, and a 'nonprocessive' ligation, in which the enzyme takes part in the abortive adenylation cycle (covalent binding of AMP, transadenylation of the nick, and dissociation). At low concentrations of ATP (<10 microM) and when the DNA nick is sealed with mismatching base pairs (e.g. five adjacent), this superimposition resolves into two kinetic phases, a burst ligation (approximately 0.2 min(-1)) and a subsequent slow ligation (approximately 2x10(-3) min(-1)). The relative rate and extent of each phase depend on the concentrations of ATP and Mg2+. The activation energies of self-adenylation (16.2 kcal.mol(-1)), transadenylation of the nick (0.9 kcal.mol(-1)), and nick-sealing (16.3-18.8 kcal.mol(-1)) were determined for several DNA substrates. The low activation energy of transadenylation implies that the transfer of AMP to the terminal DNA phosphate is a spontaneous reaction, and that the T4 DNA ligase-AMP complex is a high-energy intermediate. To summarize current findings in the DNA ligation field, we delineate a kinetic mechanism of T4 DNA ligase catalysis.     

Nicks 3'' or 5'' to AP sites or to mispaired bases, and one-nucleotide gaps can be sealed by T4 DNA ligase.

Using synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides with 3'-OH ends and 32P-labelled 5'-phosphate ends and the technique of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, it is shown that, in the presence of the complementary polynucleotide, an AP (apurinic or apyrimidinic) site at the 3' or the 5' end of the labelled oligodeoxynucleotides does not prevent their ligation by T4 DNA ligase, although the reaction rate is decreased. This decrease is more severe when the AP site is at the 3' end; the activated intermediates accumulate showing that it is the efficiency of the adenyl-5'-phosphate attack by the 3'-OH of the base-free deoxyribose which is mostly perturbed. Using the same technique, it is shown that a mispaired base at the 3' or 5' end of oligodeoxynucleotides does not prevent their ligation. A one-nucleotide gap, limited by 3'-OH and 5'-phosphate, can also be closed by T4 DNA ligase although with difficulty; here again the activation of the 5'-phosphate end does not seem to be slowed down, but rather the 3'-OH attack of the adenyl-5'-phosphate. All these anomalous ligations take place with the nick or the gap in front of a continuous complementary strand. Blunt ends ligation of correct duplexes occurs readily; however an AP site or a mispaired base at the 3' or 5' end of one strand of the duplexes prevents ligation between these strands. But a missing nucleotide (responsible for one unpaired nucleotide protruding at the 3' or 5' end of the complementary strand) does not stop ligation of the shorter oligodeoxynucleotides between independent duplexes.     

Analysis of the DNA joining repertoire of Chlorella virus DNA ligase and a new crystal structure of the ligase-adenylate intermediate

Chlorella virus DNA ligase is the smallest eukaryotic ATP-dependent DNA ligase known; it suffices for yeast cell growth in lieu of the essential yeast DNA ligase Cdc9. The Chlorella virus ligase–adenylate intermediate has an intrinsic nick sensing function and its DNA footprint extends 8–9 nt on the 3′-hydroxyl (3′-OH) side of the nick and 11–12 nt on the 5′-phosphate (5′-PO₄) side. Here we establish the minimal length requirements for ligatable 3′-OH and 5′-PO₄ strands at the nick (6 nt) and describe a new crystal structure of the ligase–adenylate in a state construed to reflect the configuration of the active site prior to nick recognition. Comparison with a previous structure of the ligase–adenylate bound to sulfate (a mimetic of the nick 5′-PO₄) suggests how the positions and contacts of the active site components and the bound adenylate are remodeled by DNA binding. We find that the minimal Chlorella virus ligase is capable of catalyzing non-homologous end-joining reactions in vivo in yeast, a process normally executed by the structurally more complex cellular Lig4 enzyme. Our results suggest a model of ligase evolution in which: (i) a small ‘pluripotent’ ligase is the progenitor of the much larger ligases found presently in eukaryotic cells and (ii) gene duplications, variations within the core ligase structure and the fusion of new domains to the core structure (affording new protein–protein interactions) led to the compartmentalization of eukaryotic ligase function, i.e. by enhancing some components of the functional repertoire of the ancestral ligase while disabling others.