The Microflora of Milking Equipment Cleansed by Chemical Methods

S ummary : The incidence of the main types of bacteria among 2,856 isolated on Yeastrel-milk agar incubated at 30° from 121 rinses of dairy equipment cleansed by chemical methods, showed that micrococci were dominant in low colony count (<10⁴/ft²) rinses of equipment treated by immersion cleaning in caustic soda or cleansed in detergent-hypochlorite solutions, whereas nonpigmented Gram-negative rods were dominant in low count rinses of equipment cleansed with detergent-sterilizers containing quaternary ammonium compounds. Gram-negative rods were dominant and streptococci frequent in high count (<2·5 × 10⁵/ft²) rinses irrespective of the chemical used. A high proportion of the streptococci and coli-aerogenes organisms gave acid reactions in litmus milk after 72 h at 22°, many of the anaerogenic Gram-negative rods and several of the aerobic sporeformers gave proteolytic reactions, whereas the majority of the micrococci, corynebacteria and other asporogenous Gram-positive rods showed no change. Bacteria isolated from high count rinses were more active in producing milk spoilage reactions at 22° than those isolated from low count rinses.     

ADVISORY MICROBIOLOGICAL STANDARDS AND TOLERANCES FOR RAW MILK

SUMMARY: To study the value of recent modifications of microbiological tests used for advisory purposes, samples of tuberculin tested milk, taken at weekly intervals over a 5 year period from the Trawscoed Experimental Husbandry Farm and selected at random during a 12 months period from farms in Wales, were examined by a temperature compensated keeping quality test at 22°, colony count on Yeastrel milk agar in 3 days at 30° and coli-aerogenes colony count on violet red bile agar in 20–24 hr at 30°.
The results show that milk produced and handled under hygienic conditions can be expected to have colony counts of less than 2 × 10⁴/ml and coli-aerogenes colony counts less than 10/ml when examined within 18 hr of milking.     

THE ASSESSMENT OF THE BACTERIOLOGICAL CONDITION OF MILK BOTTLES

SUMMARY: A study of the relative values of a number of bacteriological tests for assessing the condition of milk bottles indicated that the colony count of the bottle rinse solution on yeastrel milk agar incubated for 4 days at 30°, combined with a clot-on-boiling test applied to 1 ml. of rinse in 9 ml. of sterile milk after incubation for 72 hr. at 19–20°, gave the most useful results.
The mean of the ratios of colony counts at 30° to those at 37° was 15·1, while it was as high as 22·9 for rinses with 37° of over 600 for an unsatisfactory bottle should be retained when the test is done at 30°. The thermoduric colony count of rinses of milk bottles, even when laboratory pasteurized in milk, did not provide any additional information to that given by the colony count at 30° made without pasteurization. A high proportion of the organisms in bottle rinses survived laboratory pasteurization in milk, the survival rate being highest in efficiently treated bottles.
The clot-on-boiling test gave results in general agreement with colony counts and served to indicate the potential influence of badly contaminated bottles on the keeping quality of milk placed in them. A substantial proportion of rinses with satisfactory colony counts reduced methylene blue within 48 hr. at 19–20°.
Colony counts at 37° were on the average much lower for bottles treated with steam than for bottles submitted to detergent treatment in various types of bottle washing machines. Treatment of bottles by steam or hypochlorite was more efficiently done on the farms than at the dairies.     

The Microflora of Steam Sterilized Milking Equipment

S ummary : The classification of 1,466 bacteria, isolated on Yeastrel-milk agar incubated at 30° from 68 rinses of steam sterilized dairy equipment taken at five farms, showed that micrococci were dominant, with corynebacteria and aerobic sporeforming rods frequent, representatives of these three groups constituting 73% of the isolates. The microflora was characterized by the dominance of organisms which were relatively inactive in milk. Typical milk souring organisms such as lactic streptococci and coli-aerogenes organisms were rarely isolated, but anaerogenic Gram-negative rods resembling Achromobacter, Pseudomonas and Flavobacterium were not uncommon on milking machine clusters and on a cooling unit. The glass recorder jars contained a relatively high proportion of sporeformers.     

Thermoduric and Psychrotrophic Organisms on Poorly Cleansed Milking Plants and Farm Bulk Milk Tanks

S ummary . Poorly cleansed pipeline milking plants gave much higher total and thermoduric colony counts than the internal surfaces of refrigerated farm bulk milk tanks, higher counts being recorded for milking plants after circulation cleaning than after cleansing by the acidified boiling water (ABW) method. Psychrotrophic counts were highest for farm milk tanks and lowest for milking plants cleansed by the ABW method. There was much variation in the proportion of thermoduric and psychrotrophic organisms in the total bacterial content of milking plants determined at 30°, thermodurics being much more prevalent in 21% of the rinses and psychrotrophs in 16%. Both groups formed about equal proportions in 9% of the pipeline rinses. The bacterial content of the farm bulk milk tanks was characterized by many psychrotrophs and few thermodurics.     

The Microflora of Hand Washed Milk Bottles

S ummary . The examination of a series of 713 milk bottles cleansed by hand washing at producer-retailer farm dairies showed that though nearly 60% attained satisfactory bacteriological standards, about 30% gave high colony counts (>600/bottle), while coli-aerogenes organisms were found in 17% and milk spoilage organisms in 25% of them. The microflora of efficiently cleansed bottles, with colony counts of <200/bottle, was dominated by micrococci and aerobic sporeforming rods. Only 3.7% of the 259 cultures from these bottles gave acid reactions in litmus milk in 72 h at 22°. Inefficiently cleansed bottles, with colony counts of >600/bottle, had quite a different type of microflora which was usually dominated by Gram negative rods (achromobacteria, nonfluorescent pseudomonads and flavobacteria). A much higher proportion (19%) of the 393 cultures from these bottles gave acid reactions in litmus milk.     

THE BACTERIOLOGY OF FARM WATER SUPPLIES: A STUDY OF THE COLONY COUNT IN 72 HOURS AT 22°

SUMMARY: The colony count at 22° of farm water supplies from springs and wells was mainly composed of biochemically inactive, non-pigmented, Gram-negative rods. Water from a stream polluted with farmyard sewage showed a similar dominance of Gram-negative rods, but orange or yellow pigmented colonies were more abundant. There were few 37° positive coli-aerogenes bacteria in either the farm water supplies or the sewage polluted stream, and Bact. coli type I was rare.
A high proportion of the bacteria from farm water supplies fermented milk in 3 days at 22°; a third developed acid, 15% proteolysis and 6.4% ropiness.
Contamination of pure spring water with surface soil from a heavily grazed pasture resulted in a hundredfold increase in colony count with aerobic sporing rods replacing Gram-negative rods as the dominant organisms, but coli-aerogenes bacteria were absent.     

THE DETERMINATION OF THE COLI-AEROGENES CONTENT OF MILK AND DAIRY EQUIPMENT BY PLATING ON VIOLET RED BILE AGAR INCUBATED AT 30°

SUMMARY: Violet red bile agar (VRB) incubated at 30° for 20–24 hr was as good an indicator of coli-aerogenes bacteria in milk as MacConkey's broth. A high proportion (82%) of the large, deep red colonies considered to be formed by coli-aerogenes bacteria were confirmed as such. A British brand of dehydrated VRB agar was as suitable as an American brand of this medium for determining the coli-aerogenes content of milk. All the strains of typical coli-aerogenes bacteria tested formed red colonies. In a small proportion of cases the diameter was less than 0·5 mm. The only other milk bacteria which formed colonies resembling those of coli-aerogenes organisms were some acid forming strains of Gram-negative rods. Coli-aerogenes bacteria, determined on VRB agar at 30°, generally constituted only a small proportion of the microflora of fresh raw milk and of farm dairy equipment.     

STUDIES OF THE BACTERIAL CONTENT OF WASHED MILK CANS

SUMMARY: Colony counts at 30° were greater than 10 times those at 37° in a high proportion of rinses of washed milk cans, the difference being most marked in those containing milk scale, where 58% of the colony counts at 30° exceeded 10⁶/can. A high proportion of the microflora was composed of thermoduric bacteria. Of 895 cultures from the milk scale, 33% were micrococci, 28% corynebacteria, 22% streptococci, and 9% were Gram-negative rods. Though aerobic sporing rods constituted only 5% of the microflora of the milk scale, they were present in large numbers and unsatisfactorily washed cans probably constitute one of the main sources of these organisms in milk.     

A COMPARISON OF 30° AND 37° AS INCUBATION TEMPERATURES IN THE PRESUMPTIVE COLIAEROGENES TEST FOR RAW AND PASTEURIZED MILK

SUMMARY: Incubation at 30° and 37° for the presumptive coli-aerogenes test for raw and pasterurized milk has been investigated. There were more positives at the lower temperature and it is suggested that in this test, incubation at 30° might provide a much better guide to the hygienic quality of both raw and pasterurized milk. The ability of the coli-aerogenes bacteria studied to ferment lactose in MacConkey's broth at 30° but not at 37° was found to be a stable factor which was unchanged by prolonged storage on agar slopes at room temperature or on continued incubation in MacConkey's broth at temperatures above the optimum for lactose fermentation.     

Bacteriological Examination of Pipeline Milking Machines by Rinsing the Entire System

The results of bacteriological examination of rinses of the entire systems of 12 pipeline milking machines were compared with a similar examination of the milk collected while they were used for milking. The machines were cleaned in three different ways and showed varying degrees of complexity. There was a close correlation between the results when the milk was collected with the maximum of cleanliness during milking. This is attributed to the localization of most of the micro-organisms present in the milking machine in the junctions and complex parts of the machine and not on the surface of the equipment, so they are removed with the same efficiency by cold water or warm milk. The number of micro-organisms retrieved by water during successive rinses (or by the milk during milking) decreased at a rate which depended either on the level of initial contamination of the equipment, its design or on the types of micro-organisms present. Recommendations are made for the interpretation of the results of rinsing.     

COLD-TOLERANT FERMENTATIVE GRAM-NEGATIVE ORGANISMS FROM MEAT AND OTHER SOURCES

SUMMARY: From various chilled meats, twenty-eight strains of coli-aerogenes bacteria and one Aeromonas were isolated which grew well at +1±5° and some at −1±5°. The optimum growth temperature for most of these strains was nearer 37° than 30°. Nine strains (including the Aeromonas ) fermented lactose rapidly, the remainder slowly or not at all. All the strains which fermented lactose rapidly with the production of gas gave positive presumptive coli-aerogenes tests in MacConkey's broth at 30°, but only five were positive at 37°; none was positive at 44°. Because such organisms can attain populations of millions/cm², they could confuse the interpretation of presumptive coli-aerogenes tests made on chilled meat.     

COLI-AEROGENES BACTERIA IN FARM WATER SUPPLIES

SUMMARY: A series of 825 cultures of coli-aerogenes bacteria isolated at 30° and a series of 735 cultures isolated at 37° from 645 samples of farm water supplies were classified according to the recommendations of the Coliform Sub-Committee of the Society for Applied Bacteriology (Report, 1949). Klebsiella constituted 50% of the cultures isolated at 30°, whereas Escherichia coli I was the dominant type, forming 57%, among the cultures isolated at 37°. It would thus appear that isolation at 30° is as selective for Klebsiella as isolation at 37° is for Escherichia . Coli-aerogenes organisms, mainly 37° negative strains of Citrobacter freundii I and K. cloacae , were found in waters of high sanitary quality derived from protected springs and wells; but the coli-aerogenes microflora of polluted water was dominated by E. coli I, which formed 43% of the isolates at 30° and 76% of those at 37°. The results for a series of fortnightly samples from 11 farm water supplies showed a marked seasonal variation in the incidence of different types isolated at 30°; E. coli I formed a higher proportion in summer than in winter, while 37° negative strains of Klebsiella and Citrobacter formed a higher proportion in winter than in summer.     

SOME BIOCHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF FRESHLY ISOLATED STRAINS OF THE GENUS SERRATIA

SUMMARY: Many of 110 strains of Serratia , isolated from soil, water, milk and dairy equipment, were biochemically closely related to the coli-aerogenes bacteria. Acid and gas was formed from glucose in 14 days at 30° by 53% and from lactose and MacConkey's broth by about 40%. All except one strain gave——++ IMViC reactions.
An inverse relationship was observed between depth of pigmentation and carbohydrate fermentation. Complete loss of pigment in mutant strains was not uncommon, and was associated with loss of proteolytic properties and increase of saccharolytic activity.
The majority of the strains had psychrophilic characteristics: 75% grew at 3–5°. Most strains showed moderate growth at 37°, but only 7 formed red pigment at that temperature.
All strains resembled Serratia marcescens in morphology, containing minute coccoid rods smaller than those of coli-aerogenes bacteria.     

THE MULTIPLICATION OF COLI-AEROGENES BACTERIA IN MILK STORED AT 3–5°

SUMMARY: When 108 samples of individual farm milk supplies were held at 3—5° for 72 hr, 35·2% showed increases in coli-aerogenes organisms of over one-hundredfold and 10·2% increases of more than one-thousandfold. The coli-aerogenes microflora after refrigeration was dominated by Klebsiella cloacae and K. aerogenes I. While some strains of all the coli-aerogenes types isolated showed growth, though sometimes scanty, on yeast-dextrose agar in 5 days at 3—5°, the majority of the strains of K. cloacae showed luxuriant growth under these conditions and can be considered as typical facultative psychrophiles of milk.     

COLI-AEROGENES BACTERIA FROM FARM DAIRY EQUIPMENT AND RAW MILK

SUMMARY: A series of 1,040 cultures of coli-aerogenes bacteria isolated at 30° from farm dairy equipment and raw milk was classified according to the recommendations of the Coliform Sub-Committee of the Society for Applied Bacteriology (Report, 1949). The distribution of species and types isolated from milk did not differ materially from that for dairy equipment, Klebsiella cloacae, K. aerogenes and Citrobacter freundii being the dominant species, while the incidence of Escherichia coli was relatively low. There was no marked seasonal incidence of any type, though E. coli I formed a slightly higher proportion of the coli-aerogenes microflora in winter, whereas K. aerogenes I was slightly higher in summer. Many of the cultures of the dominant types, K. cloacae, K. aerogenes I and Cit. freundii I, did not form acid and gas from lactose in two days at 37°. Consequently 37° negative, anaerogenic and paracolon strains constituted a relatively high proporton (49%) of the coli-aerogenes microflora.     

THERMODURIC ORGANISMS IN MILK. PART V. A SIMPLIFIED TESTING TECHNIQUE

SUMMARY: Thermoduric colony counts at 30° of laboratory pasteurized milk determined by the roll tube or agar strip methods were lower than those obtained by the standard Petri plate method. The differences in colony count were not of such magnitude, however, as to be likely to result in many errors in grading if a thermoduric bacterial content of greater than 10⁴/ml is accepted as an index of unsatisfactory cleansing of dairy equipment.
The three methods examined were simpler and more economical than the Petri plate technique, but the agar strip method, as described, using the standard loop, was the simplest and gave a sufficiently reliable estimate of the thermoduric colony count for advisory purposes.     

THE RAPID IDENTIFICATION OF ESCHERICHIA COLI I BY THE PRODUCTION AT 44° OF BOTH INDOLE AND GAS FROM LACTOSE

SUMMARY: The modification of the 44° test proposed by Mackenzie, Taylor & Gilbert (1948) is useful for the rapid identification of Escherichia coli I in water and foods. False positive tests caused by other coli-aerogenes bacteria, or by their association with other organisms, can be considered rare. Only a few E. coli I fail to produce indole or ferment lactose at 44°, and further confirmation for routine purposes is necessary only when the results at 44° are discordant, e.g. indole positive-lactose negative or indole negative-lactose positive.     

Growth of Bacteria on Meat at Room Temperatures

The development of spoilage flora and the growth of individual psychrotrophs and pathogens on meat held at 20 or 30°C were studied. Under aerobic conditions psychrotrophic pseudomonads accounted for 60% of the spoilage flora at 20°C, but <20% at 30°C where they were displaced by species of Acinetobacter and Enterobacteriaceae which included both mesophilic and psychrotrophic strains. Mesophiles dominated the anaerobic spoilage flora at 30°C when clostridia were the major species, but at 20° the flora contained mesophiles and psychrotrophs in similar proportions and was dominated by Enterobacteriaceae. These results were largely predictable from the growth rate data for individual organisms.
Interactions between species occurred more frequently at 20°C than at 30°C. When pathogenic species were grown at 20 or 30°Cin competition with equal numbers of psychrotrophic spoilage organisms, no interactions were observed. When pathogens were grown in competition with high numbers of psychrotrophs, only Lactobacillus growing anaerobically inhibited Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli , but other pathogens were inhibited to varying degrees depending on the competing species and the incubation conditions. In general, the degree of inhibition was greater at 20 than at 30°C and facultative organisms were more susceptible under anaerobic than aerobic conditions. It appears that the cumulative stresses of low pH, suboptimal temperatures and competition with large numbers of saprophytic organisms can inhibit many of the pathogens likely to be present on meat. The organisms least affected by the conditions on meat surfaces, Salmonella and Esch. coli , are likely to be the main hazards on meat of normal pH held at room temperatures.     

FURTHER OBSERVATIONS ON THE BACTERIAL CONTENT OF WATER IN WATERCRESS BEDS

SUMMARY: Observations on two watercress beds in Kent have confirmed previous findings (Jones & Baker, 1955) that even in comparatively well-protected beds the coli-aerogenes content of the water may be high in summer. They have also shown that in spite of circumstances which would lead one to expect pollution, as in the case of one bed, the coli-aerogenes content can be low in winter. The season appears to influence the content in the water of coli-aerogenes bacteria, pectate liquefying bacteria and those capable of growing at 37°, but in the case of those growing at 22° other factors can play a more important part, as higher counts were not uncommon in winter. Seasonal effects were less marked with inlet samples; they were less influenced by atmospheric temperature, and little extraneous contamination occurred. Numbers increased as the sampling point moved from inlet to outlet.