Pollination ecology of Silene acutifolia (Caryophyllaceae): floral traits variation and pollinator attraction

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The floral display influences the composition of pollinators interacting with a plant species. Geographic and temporal variation in pollinator composition complicates the understanding of the evolutionary consequences of floral display variation. This paper analyses the relationships between Silene acutifolia, a hermaphroditic perennial herb, and its pollinators, based on field studies in the north-west of Spain. METHODS: Studies were conducted over three years (1997-1999). Firstly, the main pollinators of this species were determined for two years in one population. Secondly, pollen limitation in fruit and seed production was analysed by supplementary hand pollinations, and counting the pollen grains and tubes growing in styles for two different-sized populations. Finally, the effect of flower size and number on the rate of visitation and total seed number was examined for 15 marked plants. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The primary pollinators were long-tongued insects, including Hymenoptera, Lepidoptera and Diptera, but the composition and visitation frequencies differed between years. Pollen limitation occurred in one of the years of study. There was between-population variation in the number of pollen grains and pollen tubes found in styles, suggesting pollen limitation in one population. Overall, pollinators visited plants with more open flowers more frequently, and pollinated more flowers within these plants. Conversely, petal and calyx sizes had no effect on insect visitation. Plants with higher rates of visits produced higher number of seeds, suggesting that pollinator-mediated limitation of seed and fruit production may be important in some years.     

Intra-inflorescence variation in floral traits and reproductive success of the hermaphrodite Silene acutifolia

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Intraspecific variation in floral components and reproductive success is often located at the intra-individual level. The arrangement of flowers within inflorescences may explain a great deal of this variation. The variation in number of ovules, fruit set, number of seeds per fruit, seed set, seed weight and seed germination is investigated at different positions within the inflorescence of Silene acutifolia. METHODS: Data were obtained in natural populations, and germination experiments were conducted in a germination chamber. KEY RESULTS: The number of ovules, fruit set, number of seeds, seed set and seed weight, showed a significant decline from early (primary) position to later (tertiary) position. The patterns of intra-inflorescence variation were consistent in different populations and years of study. Seed germination showed an opposite pattern, seeds from primary position showed the lowest germination percentages and seeds from tertiary position the highest, although the effect of position on germination was only marginally significant. There was significant among-population variation in number of ovules per flower. Fruit set also varied significantly among populations, with lower fruit set in the smaller and more isolated population. No significant among-population differences were detected in number of seeds per fruit and seed set. Seeds from the smallest and more isolated population (Arnado) were the lightest. Seed germination showed strong differences between populations, seeds from Arnado started to germinate later, and showed the lowest final germination percentages. CONCLUSIONS: Architectural effects or resource competition are the most commonly proposed hypothesis to explain these patterns. Data suggest that there is less pollen available to pollinate tertiary flowers, and that there is not enough outcross pollen in Arnado. The germination percentages suggest that there is variation in the source of pollen within inflorescences, with high probability of receiving outcross pollen in flowers from primary position, and higher probability of geitonogamous crosses in tertiary flowers.     

花颜色和花气味的量化研究方法

花颜色和花气味是花部构成的重要内容。在已开展的传粉生态学研究中对二者的报道主要是描述性的,而其量化研究可以为揭示传粉机制提供有力的实验证据。本文主要介绍了花颜色的测量和标定方法,包括比色卡、分光色差仪和便携式光谱仪等;花气味的采集方法,包括动态顶空套袋-吸附采集法、吸附-溶剂洗脱法和固相微萃取法等;花气味的检测和分析方法,包括气相色谱-质谱联用仪分析和电子鼻型超速气相色谱仪分析等;以及昆虫行为学实验方法,包括气相色谱-昆虫触角电位联用技术、Y型嗅觉仪和飞行箱实验等。科研人员可以根据实验材料的特点和实验目的选择适合的量化研究方法。     

Determination of floral organ type in cultured Silene shoot apices

Shoot apices of the long day plant, Silene coeli-rosa , were cultured on a basal medium (+3% sucrose) in non-inductive short days (SD) following their excision from plants which had been exposed to long day (LD) treatments in order to examine the period for determination of each floral whorl. In response to the inductive LD treatments, the pattern of whorl formation in vitro reflected their normal appearance in Silene : sepals, stamens 1–5, petals, stamens 6–10 and carpels, although the number of apices initiating each whorl was lower in vitro compared with apices in vivo. However, supplementing the medium with 7 instead of 3% sucrose corrected this deficiency and, for the first time, resulted in apices initiating floral whorls in SD. The interval between the shortest treatment to result in whorl initiation in vitro, 4 LD (which also resulted in 50% flowering in vivo), and the treatment which gave 50% initiation of the corresponding whorl in vitro, was taken to be the period for determination of that whorl. The determination times on the 3% medium were: sepals (2 days), stamens 1–5 (3 days), petals (3 days), stamens 6–10 (4 days) and carpels (4 days); all of these periods shortened to about 1 day on the 7% medium. Tissue culture did not perturb the pattern of initiation of each whorl since apices excised and cultured from plants which had received 7 LD + 2 SD, exhibited each whorl over the same time scale as those of intact plants which received the same treatment. The data are consistent with a sequential determination and initiation of each whorl in the order that they appear normally in Silene . Synchronisation of cell division, as represented by peaks of the mitotic index and G₂/G₁ ratios on day 8 (7 LD + 2 SD), did not occur in vitro but the mitotic index did not descend to zero, further emphasising that tissue culture did not perturb the Silene apex.     

Experimental control of floral reversion in isolated shoot apices of the long-day plant Silene coeli-rosa

The fate of shoot meristems of the long day (LD) plant Silene coeli-rosa in culture was examined (complete, reverted or arrested flowers) to establish whether these different patterns were related to a particular stage of morphogenesis and the extent to which the fate of the pattern was regulated by either added plant growth regulators (PGRs) or changing the carbohydrate source in the medium. In particular, the frequency of reversion was measured to test the stability of the determined state for each whorl. The plants were given various inductive treatments (4–7 LD, 7 LD + 1 to 3 SD) and the apices were explained onto Murashige-Skoog medium supplemented with 3% sucrose (controls) ± IAA, ± kinetin, ± GA₃ or onto the basal medium containing 1 or 3% sucrose, glucose or fructose or 7% sucrose. The apices were examined 12 weeks later. When the data were pooled from all inductive treatments, IAA resulted in more reversions, GA₃ caused more arrested flowers while kinetin hardly affected the pattern of meristem fate compared with the controls. However, each PGR treatment did not perturb the pattern of organ formation for those apices that formed either arrested or complete flowers. The time for determination (days) of the earlier formed whorls (determination times for the controls in brackets): sepals (2), stamens 1–5 (3) and petals (3), was shortened by about a day in all PGR treatments whereas the corresponding times for the later formed whorls: stamens 6–10 (4) and carpels (4), were either lengthened to 5 days or unaffected. The response of the apices to the various sugars was simply a reflection of concentration. Hence, more complete flowers formed at 7 or 3% and more flowers were arrested at 1 % regardless of the sugar moiety. However, the frequency of reversion was similar on each of the media. Pooling all data from all treatments enabled a statistical analysis of the pattern of reversion and the pattern of arrest. Reversion was more common from apices which exhibited the later-formed whorls (stamens 6–10 and carpels) than from the earlier whorls. Moreover, the stronger the inductive treatment the less frequent was reversion. The most common stage of arrest was at the stamen 6–10 whorl and this was particularly so for the GA₃ treatment. The data indicated that reversion could occur from any whorl, which suggests that determination of each whorl is independent of the next. This conclusion is underlined by the more frequent occurrence of reversion from the carpel whorl. However, the longer the inductive treatment the less likelihood of reversion; this suggests that in Silene, the floral stimulus is required continuously to stabilise the determined state of each whorl and to ensure smooth completion of floral morphogenesis.     

Gender polymorphism in flowers of Silene vulgaris (Moench) Garcke (Caryophyllaceae)

Silene vulgaris occurs in Israel as a stolonifcrous tetraploid which forms mostly sexually polymorphic populations. Fully hermaphrodite and fully male-sterile plants are linked by a range of intermediate forms which are gynomonoecious and bear hermaphrodite, male-sterile, and partially male-sterile flowers. Male-sterile flowers differ from hermaphrodite ones by having a narrower calyx, a shorter corolla, a thicker style, and a considerably larger stigmatic area with longer papillae which are more markedly bulbous basally. In individual anthers of hermaphrodite flowers, diameters of stained pollen grains showed a continuous variation from 36 to 80 μm with a modal value of 56. About 30% of pollen was found to be non-stainable. Reduction in male fertility occurs at different levels, from small or inviable pollen grains through abortion of single anthers, abortion of entire androecia, and through different degrees of gynomonoecy to totally male-sterile individuals. The proportion of stainable pollen to ovules in hermaphrodite flowers alone was found to be less than 100. From the data presented, less than a third of all ovules produced in the different kinds of flower develop into seeds. This may reflect an inadequacy of pollen, which the local population of S. vulgaris can tolerate because of its stoloniferous habit.     

Climate and clinal variation in seed morphology of the white campion, Silene latifolia (Caryophyllaceae)

Silene latifolia (white campion) is widespread in W Eurasia and shows clinal variation in seed morphology. Two extensive parapatric races, within which seed morphology changes gradually with geographic distance, are separated by a transition zone where the morphological gradient is steeper. A sample of seeds from across the species' native range was scored for morphological characters and analysed using detrended correspondence analysis ordination and multiple regression, in order to simplify mapping of the variation pattern and to investigate statistical relationships with climatic variables. The transition zone, as defined by ordination scores, follows the convolutions of the 0C isotherm for January mean temperature along its entire length from N Europe to the Middle East. January temperature proved to be a highly significant predictor of seed morphology even after the removal of simple spatial trends. Although the origins of comparable large-scale clines have often been interpreted in historical terms, the result reported here supports a role for climatic selection in maintaining the existing variation pattern.     

Comparison between mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA variation in the native range of Silene vulgaris

A detailed survey of mitochondrial and chloroplast diversity in eight populations of Silene vulgaris from Central Europe was conducted for comparison with previously published data on diversity from S. vulgaris populations in the introduced range. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) variation around the coxI gene was assessed with Southern blotting/restriction fragment length polymorphism methods. Chloroplast variation was assessed by sequencing the intergenic spacer separating the trnH and psbA genes. Thirty mtDNA haplotypes and 24 chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) haplotypes were found within 86 individuals. The overall genetic diversity h (0.941 for mitochondrial, and 0.893 for chloroplast markers) and within-population diversity were higher than reported in previous population studies of S. vulgaris in the USA and Europe. The frequency of private alleles was surprisingly high - more than 90% for both kinds of markers. Most of our populations were large and located in relatively undisturbed meadows, whereas surveys in Virginia consisted of smaller roadside populations. The slow rate of population turnover in European populations is discussed as a factor responsible for the relatively high diversity of S. vulgaris in undisturbed areas of its native range. Association between mtDNA and cpDNA haplotypes was also demonstrated. Finally, gender and mtDNA haplotype were associated in the Alps populations, where females were very rare.     

Sexual dimorphism in the quantitative-genetic architecture of floral, leaf, and allocation traits in Silene latifolia

Many species exhibit sexual dimorphism in a variety of characters, and the underlying genetic architecture of dimorphism potentially involves sex-specific differences in the additive-genetic variance-covariance matrix (G) of dimorphic traits. We investigated the quantitative-genetic structure of dimorphic traits in the dioecious plant Silene latifolia by estimating G (including within-sex matrices, G(m), G(f), and the between-sex variance-covariance matrix, B), and the phenotypic variance-covariance matrix (P) for seven traits. Flower number was the most sexually dimorphic trait, and was significantly genetically correlated with all traits within each sex. Negative genetic correlations between flower size and number suggested a genetic trade-off in investment, but positive environmental correlations between the same traits resulted in no physical evidence for a trade-off in the phenotype. Between-sex genetic covariances for homologous traits were always greater than 0 but smaller than 1, showing that some, but not all, of the variation in traits is caused by genes or alleles with sex-limited expression. Using common principal-components analysis (CPCA), a maximum-likelihood (ML) estimation approach, and element-by-element comparison to compare matrices, we found that G(m) and G(f) differed significantly in eigenstructure because of dissimilarity in covariances involving leaf traits, suggesting the presence of variation in sex-limited genes with pleiotropic effects and/or linkage between sex-limited loci. The sex-specific structure of G is expected to cause differences in the correlated responses to selection within each sex, promoting the further evolution and maintenance of dimorphism.     

Morphological variation and floral abnormalities in a trigger plant across a narrow altitudinal gradient

Local adaptation in alpine plants has been demonstrated across wide altitudinal gradients, but has rarely been examined across the alpine‐to‐montane transition that often encompasses only a few hundred metres. Here we characterize morphological variation in leaf and floral characteristics of the trigger plant Stylidium armeria along a narrow altitudinal gradient in the Bogong High Plains in Victoria. Across this gradient, which encompasses the high‐elevation limit of this species, linear changes were found for floral scape height, leaf length and flower number. All these traits decreased with increasing altitude, whereas the frequency of abnormal flowers increased. When plants were grown in a common garden environment, an altitudinal pattern for flower abnormalities was no longer detected. However, altitudinal patterns for leaf length and scape height were maintained, albeit weaker than in the field. This indicates heritable variation for these morphological traits; the altitudinal patterns are likely to reflect the effects of selection by environmental factors that vary with altitude. Selection pressures remain to be identified but have generated both cogradient and countergradient patterns of variation.     

Floral odour and reproductive isolation in two species of Silene

Mechanisms preventing interspecific pollination are important in closely related plant species, in particular when post-zygotic barriers are weak or absent. We investigated the role of floral odour in reproductive isolation between the two closely related species Silene latifolia and S. dioica. First, we tested whether floral odour composition and emission differed between the species. We found significant odour differences, but contrary to expectations, both species showed a rhythmic emission of the same compounds between day and night. Second, in a field experiment, odour of the two species was made more similar by applying phenylacetaldehyde to flowers. This manipulation led to higher pollen-analogue transfer between species, revealing that floral odour differences are important for maintaining reproductive isolation. We conclude that differences in single key compounds can reduce pollen transfer across species boundaries by pollinators and demonstrate that odour differences are an important component of premating floral isolation between closely related plant species.     

Floral color variation and associations with fitness‐related traits in Malva moschata (Malvaceae)

Genetic polymorphisms for floral color are interesting phenomena to study because they are likely to be maintained by opposing selective forces. Pollinator preferences may exert direct selection on floral color; however, floral color might also be the indirect target of selection through genetic associations with other traits under selection. Malva moschata (Malvaceae) is a North American species that produces either red or white flowers. In the present study, we present reflectance spectrophotometry data that characterize the nature of floral color variation in this species and show that honey bees and bumble bees should be able to distinguish between the morphs through differential sensitivity at the green (long‐wavelength) photoreceptor. Second, we use a series of phenotypic measures to investigate whether the color morphs differ with respect to other floral traits, vegetative traits or female reproductive success, and use a series of correlation analyses to infer the relative independence of color from these other traits. We found that red‐flowered morphs produced more anthers per flower and had greater leaf area, and that white‐flowered morphs had greater percentage fruit set; however, there were no reproductive success differences between the morphs. The relationship between flower size and anther number was the only correlation that differed between the morphs. Finally, a series of pollinator‐choice experiments showed that bumble bees strongly prefer red morphs in terms of visit frequency and duration, but honey bees have no preference. Taken together, our results suggest that color is rather independent of other phenotypic traits, and that honey bee abundance is likely to play a role in maintaining color variation in this system.     

Interaction between floral color change and gender transition in the protandrous weed Saponaria officinalis

Natural selection has directed the evolution of floral traits so that pollinator visits are manipulated to maximize the fitness of individual plants by directing which other individual sires its seeds. In some plants, flowers change color over time and may have the ability to direct pollinators to rewarding flowers. In addition, by varying when pollen is available and when stigmas are receptive, protandrous plants can show variation in selfing rates. In this study, the association between color change and gender transition in flowers of Saponaria officinalis was examined. Anthocyanins were extracted from flowers of each gender stage to measure color using spectrophotometry. Female‐phase flowers were found to have significantly higher anthocyanin concentration than male‐phase flowers in both natural populations and experimental plots. This color change corresponded to a decrease in male sexual function, which was measured by the percentage of pollen grains stained as viable by lactophenol aniline blue and germinated on Brewbaker–Kwack media. Color change was phenotypically plastic. Plants grown in full sun had a more extensive color change than those grown in shaded experimental plots, and this effect was reversed the following year when the shading was removed. Pollinator observations documented both diurnal and nocturnal insect visitation. Fruit and seed set were equivalent on inflorescences bagged during daylight versus night, indicating that both diurnal and nocturnal insects are effective pollinators. If pollinators discriminate based on color, this could potentially reduce within‐plant floral visits and also geitonogamy. This study is the first to document flower color change and moth pollination in Saponaria officinalis.     

Inbreeding effects on progeny sex ratio and gender variation in the gynodioecious Silene vulgaris (Caryophyllaceae)

In gynodioecious species, sex expression is generally determined through cytoplasmic male sterility genes interacting with nuclear restorers of the male function. With dominant restorers, there may be an excess of females in the progeny of self-fertilized compared with cross-fertilized hermaphrodites. Moreover, the effect of inbreeding on late stages of the life cycle remains poorly explored. Here, we used hermaphrodites of the gynodioecious Silene vulgaris originating from three populations located in different valleys in the Alps to investigate the effects of two generations of self- and cross-fertilization on sex ratio and gender variation. We detected an increase in females in the progeny of selfed compared with outcrossed hermaphrodites and inbreeding depression for female and male fertility. Male fertility correlated positively with sex ratio differences between outbred and inbred progeny, suggesting that dominant restorers are likely to influence male fertility qualitatively and quantitatively in S. vulgaris. We argue that the excess of females in the progeny of selfed compared with outcrossed hermaphrodites and inbreeding depression for gamete production may contribute to the maintenance of females in gynodioecious populations of S. vulgaris because purging of the genetic load is less likely to occur.     

Toxicity of arsenate in Silene vulgaris, accumulation and degradation of arsenate-induced phytochelatins

The results presented in this paper describe the short- and long-term toxicity of arsenate in Silene vulgaris . Short-term toxicity, measured as inhibition of root elongation, depended on phosphate nutrition, arsenate being much less toxic at high phosphate supply. At low phosphate levels more arsenic was taken up by the plants. Under chronic exposure, toxicity (measured as inhibition of biomass production) did not increase with time. In addition, the accumulation of phytochelatins (PCs) as a function of toxicity and duration of exposure was studied. Short-term PC accumulation (over a 3 d period) was positively correlated with exposure. Isolation of peptide complexes from prolongedly exposed plants showed that PC₂, PC₃ and PC₄ were present, although the latter not until at least 3 d exposure. Arsenic co-eluted mainly with PC₂ and PC₃. Fractions containing PC₄ were devoid of As, probably due to dissociation of the complexes during extraction or elution. The breakdown of PCs after arresting As exposure was very slow. This could explain the continuous accumulation of PCs throughout longer periods of As exposure.     

Variation in mutation rate and polymorphism among mitochondrial genes of Silene vulgaris

The prevailing wisdom of the plant mitochondrial genome is that it has very low substitution rates, thus it is generally assumed that nucleotide diversity within species will also be low. However, recent evidence suggests plant mitochondrial genes may harbor variable and sometimes high levels of within-species polymorphism, a result attributed to variance in the influence of selection. However, insufficient attention has been paid to the effect of among-gene variation in mutation rate on varying levels of polymorphism across loci. We measured levels of polymorphism in seven mitochondrial gene regions across a geographically wide sample of the plant Silene vulgaris to investigate whether individual mitochondrial genes accumulate polymorphisms equally. We found that genes vary significantly in polymorphism. Tests based on coalescence theory show that the genes vary significantly in their scaled mutation rate, which, in the absence of differences among genes in effective population size, suggests these genes vary in their underlying mutation rate. Further evidence that among-gene variance in polymorphism is due to variation in the underlying mutation rate comes from a significant positive relationship between the number of segregating sites and silent site divergence from an outgroup. Contrary to recent studies, we found unconvincing evidence of recombination in the mitochondrial genome, and generally confirm the standard model of plant mitochondria characterized by low substitution rates and no recombination. We also show no evidence of significant variation in the strength or direction of selection among genes; this result may be expected if there is no recombination. The present study provides some of the most thorough data on plant mitochondrial polymorphism, and provides compelling evidence for mutation rate variation among genes. The study also demonstrates the difficulty in establishing a null model of mitochondrial genome polymorphism, and thus the difficulty, in the absence of a comparative approach, in testing the assumption that low substitution rates in plant mitochondria lead to low polymorphism.     

Reproductive success and variation in floral traits in the Iberian Peninsula endemic white campion <Emphasis Type="Italic">Silene marizii</Emphasis> (Caryophyllaceae)

Silene marizii (Caryophyllaceae) is a schizoendemism of the west Iberian Peninsula. The correlation between the evolution of reproductive success (as measured in terms of fruit set and seed production) and five floral traits (peduncle length, calyx length, calyx width, petal limb length, and petal limb width) was investigated in five populations of S. marizii, taking into account both intra-populational and inter-populational variability. The populations studied represented the different habitats of S. marizii over its area of distribution. None of the five traits examined was significantly and positively correlated with the number of seeds produced by the flower. An analysis was also made of how floral morphology varies with the position of the flower in the inflorescence in the five populations. The populations from higher altitudes (Caramulhino, Puerto de Menga and Peña de la Cruz) had larger peduncles, calices and petal limbs than those living at lower altitudes (Sabugal and Mangualde) All five morphometric traits, plus the number of ovules per ovary, varied significantly between flower positions on the same plant and among populations.     

Numerical analysis of infraspecific variation in European Silene alba and S. dioica(Caryophyllaceae)

Infraspecific variation among European populations of Silene alba and S. dioica was analysed by non-metric multidimensional scaling, which was applied to K-dissimilarity matrices based either on 16 seed characters or on 34 seed, flower and capsule characters. The material used for analysis consisted of 167 collections of wild seed, largely obtained from European botanic gardens, and 97 sets of mature greenhouse-grown progeny. S. alba was found to show topoclinal variation, primarily along an axis from the Iberian peninsula through central Europe to Romania. This pattern is not reflected in current taxonomic treatments. N. and N.W. European S. alba is morphologically heterogeneous and has probably been introduced from various southern sources. S. dioica shows less total variation between populations than S. alba , and consists of local ecogeographic races that intergrade at their margins. The two species are completely discriminated by seed, flower and capsule characters when used in combination, but S. alba populations from the eastern end of the cline closely approach S. dioica in seed morphology. This convergence is unlikely to be an effect of recent introgression.     

Reproduction and Pollination in Central European Populations of Silene and Saponaria Species

Flower morphology, flowering phenology, flower visitors, reproductive systems, and stigmatic receptivity of six species of Silene and Saponaria (Silene alba, S. dioica, S. vulgaris, S. nutans, S. noctiflora. Saponaria officinalis) were studied from April to October 1993 and from April to June 1994 in natural populations around Giessen in Hessen/Central Germany and, additionally, in individuals grown from seeds in the Botanical Garden of the University of Giessen. With the exception of Saponaria officinalis and S. noctiflora, all species were regularly visited and pollinated by crepuscular and nocturnal moths and hawkmoths, but only one species, S. alba, was exclusively pollinated by these night-active insects. The other species showed mixed pollination syndromes in which nocturnal and diurnal insects both promoted pollen transfer. Geitonogamy or even autogamy occurred in the gynodioecious and hermaphrodite species S. vulgaris, S. nutans, S. noctiflora, and Saponaria officinalis. Silene noctiflora, the only annual species, is pseudocleistogamous; the majority of its flowers did not open, and fruit set occurred after selfing in bud.