Superoxide dismutase: the balance between prevention and induction of oxidative damage

Cu,Zn-superoxide dismutase (SOD1) has been shown to be effective in several free radical mediated diseases, although some studies have pointed toward SOD1 toxicity at a high concentrations. In the present study, the balance between prevention and induction of damage by SOD1 has been investigated both in vitro and in vivo. In vitro superoxide was generated using xanthine/xanthine oxidase. In vivo superoxide was generated using the redox cycling compound doxorubicin. Furthermore, we determined the pharmacokinetics of lecithinized SOD1 (PC-SOD) in order to compare the results obtained in vivo with those obtained in vitro. It was found that in vitro high concentrations of SOD1 induce hydroxylation of coumarin 3-carboxylic acid (3-CCA). This could be caused by a peroxidative action of SOD1 or formation of the highly reactive hydroxyl radicals. Any signs of toxicity are absent in vivo because these concentrations are not reached. It can be concluded that SOD1 possesses a large therapeutic window and application of SOD1 or its derivatives for strengthening the body's defenses against oxidative stress in a variety of pathologies seems safe.     

Superoxide dismutase 1 protects retinal cells from oxidative damage

Bolstering the endogenous oxidative damage defense system is a good strategy for development of treatments to combat neurodegenerative diseases in which oxidative damage plays a role. A first step in such treatment development is to determine the role of various components of the defense system in cells that degenerate. In this study, we sought to determine the role of superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) in two models of oxidative damage-induced retinal degeneration. In one model, paraquat is injected into the vitreous cavity and then enters retinal cells and generates reactive oxygen species (ROS) that cause progressive retinal damage. Assessment of retinal function with serial electroretinograms (ERGs) showed that sod1 -/- mice were much more sensitive than sod1 +/+ mice to the damaging effects of paraquat, while sod1 +/- mice showed intermediate sensitivity. Compared to sod1 +/+ mice, sod1 -/- mice showed greater paraquat-induced oxidative damage and apoptosis. In the second model, mice were exposed to hyperoxia for several weeks, and sod1 -/- mice showed significantly greater reductions in ERG amplitudes than sod1 +/+ mice. In both of these models, transgenic mice carrying a sod1 transgene driven by a beta-actin promoter showed less oxidative stress-induced reduction in ERG amplitudes. These data demonstrate that SOD1 protects retinal cells against paraquat- and hyperoxia-induced oxidative damage and suggest that overexpression of SOD1 should be considered as one component of ocular gene therapy to prevent oxidative damage-induced retinal degeneration.     

Repair of oxidative DNA damage

Cellular genomes suffer extensive damage from exogenous agents and reactive oxygen species formed during normal metabolism. The MutT homologs (MutT/MTH) remove oxidized nucleotide precursors so that they cannot be incorporated into DNA during replication. Among many repair pathways, the base excision repair (BER) pathway is the most important cellular protection mechanism responding to oxidative DNA damage. The 8-oxoG glycosylases (Fpg or MutM/OGG) and the MutY homologs (MutY/MYH) glycosylases along with MutT/MTH protect cells from the mutagenic effects of 8-oxoG, the most stable and deleterious product known caused by oxidative damage to DNA. The key enzymes in the BER process are DNA glycosylases, which remove different damaged bases by cleavage of the N-glycosylic bonds between the bases and the deoxyribose moieties of the nucleotide residues. Biochemical and structural studies have demonstrated the substrate recognition and reaction mechanism of BER enzymes. Cocrystal structures of strated the substrate recognition and reaction mechanism of BER enzymes. Cocrystal structures of several glycosylases show that the substrate base flips out of the sharply bent DNA helix and the minor groove is widened to be accessed by the glycosylases. To complete the repair after glycosylase action, the apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) site is further processed by an incision step, DNA synthesis, an excision step, and DNA ligation through two alternative pathways. The short-patch BER (1-nucleotide patch size) and long-patch BER (2–6-nucleotide patch size) pathways need AP endonuclease to generate a 3′ hydroxyl group but require different sets of enzymes for DNA synthesis and ligation. Protein-protein interactions have been reported among the enzymes involved in BER. It is possible that the successive players in the repair pathway are assembled in a complex to perform concerted actions. The BER pathways are proposed to protect cells and organisms from mutagenesis and carcinogenesis.     

Peptide repair of oxidative DNA damage

Guanyl radical species are produced in DNA by electron removal caused by ionizing radiation, photoionization, oxidation, or photosensitization. DNA guanyl radicals can be reduced by electron donation from mild reducing agents. Important biologically relevant examples are the redox active amino acids cysteine, cystine, methionine, tryptophan, and tyrosine. We have quantified the reactivity of derivatives of these amino acids with guanyl radicals located in plasmid DNA. The radicals were produced by electron removal using the single electron oxidizing agent (SCN)(2)(*)(-). Disulfides (cystine) are unreactive. Thioethers (methionine), thiols (cysteine), and phenols (tyrosine) react with rate constants in the range 10(4)-10(6), 10(5)-10(6), and 10(5)-10(6) dm(3) mol(-1) s(-1), respectively. Indoles (tryptophan) are the most reactive with rate constants of 10(7)-10(8) dm(3) mol(-1) s(-1). Selenium analogues of amino acids are over an order of magnitude more reactive than their sulfur equivalents. Increasing positive charge is associated with a ca. 10-fold increase in reactivity. The results suggest that amino acid residues located close to DNA (for example, in DNA binding proteins such as histones) might participate in the repair of oxidative DNA damage.     

Experimental study of oxidative DNA damage

Animal experiments allow the study of oxidative DNA damage in target organs and the elucidation of dose-response relationships of carcinogenic and other harmful chemicals and conditions as well as the study of interactions of several factors. So far the effects of more than 50 different chemical compounds have been studied in animal experiments mainly in rats and mice, and generally with measurement of 8-oxodG with HPLC-EC. A large number of well-known carcinogens induce 8-oxodG formation in liver and/or kidneys. Moreover several animal studies have shown a close relationship between induction of dative DNA damage and tumour formation.

In principle the level of oxidative DNA damage in an organ or cell may be studied by measurement of modified bases in extracted DNA by immunohistochemical visualisation, and from assays of strand breakage before and after treatment with repair enzymes. However, this level is a balance between the rates of damage and repair. Until the repair rates and capacity can be adequately assessed the rate of damage can only be estimated from the urinary excretion of repair products albeit only as an average of the entire body.

A number of model compounds have been used to induce oxidative DNA damage in experimental animals. The hepatocarcinogen 2-nitropropane induces up to 10-fold increases in 8-oxodG levels in rat liver DNA. The level of 8-oxodG is also increased in kidneys and bone marrow but not in the testis. By means of 2-nitropropane we have shown correspondence between the increases in 8-oxodG in target organs and the urinary excretion of 8-oxodG and between 8-oxodG formation and the comet assay in bone marrow as well potent preventive effects of extracts of Brussels sprouts. Others have shown similar effects of green tea extracts and its components. Drawbacks of the use of 2-nitropropane as a model for oxidative DNA damage relate particularly to formation of 8-aminoguanine derivatives that may interfere with HPLC-EC assays and have unknown consequences. Other model compounds for induction of oxidative DNA damage, such as ferric nitriloacetate, iron dextran, potassium bromate and paraquat, are less potent and/or more organ specific.

Inflammation and activation of an inflammatory response by phorbol esters or E. coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) induce oxidative DNA damage in many target cells and enhance benzene-induced DNA damage in mouse bone marrow.

Experimental studies provide powerful tools to investigate agents inducing and preventing oxidative damage to DNA and its role in carcinogenesis. So far, most animal experiments have concerned 8-oxodG and determination of additional damaged bases should be employed. An ideal animal model for prevention of oxidative DNA damage has yet to he developed.     

Tomato consumption modulates oxidative DNA damage in humans.

Consumption of a single serving of tomatoes by healthy human volunteers was sufficient to alter levels of oxidative DNA base damage in white cell DNA within 24 h. Levels of the mutagenic oxidized purine base 8-hydroxyguanine decreased, especially in those subjects whose initial levels of this base were higher than the mean. However, total DNA base damage remained unchanged since levels of 8-hydroxyadenine rose. The ability of tomato consumption to modulate oxidative DNA damage in the short term may indicate why daily consumption of fruits and vegetables is beneficial in decreasing cancer incidence.     

DNA damage responses to oxidative stress

The DNA damage response is a hierarchical process. DNA damage is detected by sensor proteins such as the MRN complex that transmit the information to transducer proteins such as ATM and ATR, which control the damage response through the phosphorylation of effector proteins. The extent of the DNA damage determines cell fate: cell cycle arrest and DNA repair or the activation of apoptotic pathways. In aerobic cells, reactive oxygen species (ROS) are generated as a by-product of normal mitochondrial activity. If not properly controlled, ROS can cause severe damage to cellular macromolecules, especially the DNA. We describe here some of the cellular responses to alterations in the cellular redox state during hypoxia or oxidative stress. Oxidative damage in DNA is repaired primarily via the base excision repair (BER) pathway which appears to be the simplest of the three excision repair pathways. To allow time for DNA repair, the cells activate their cell cycle checkpoints, leading to cell cycle arrest and preventing the replication of damage and defective DNA.     

Increase in the frequency of hepadnavirus DNA integrations by oxidative DNA damage and inhibition of DNA repair.

Persistent hepadnavirus infection leads to oxidative stress and DNA damage through increased production of toxic oxygen radicals. In addition, hepadnaviral DNA integrations into chromosomal DNA can promote the process of hepatocarcinogenesis (M. Feitelson, Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 5:275-301, 1992). While previous studies have identified preferred integration sites in hepadnaviral genomes and suggested integration mechanisms (M. A. Buendia, Adv. Cancer Res. 59:167-226, 1992; C. E. Rogler, Curr. Top. Microbiol. Immunol. 168:103-141, 1991; C. Shih et al., J. Virol. 61:3491-3498, 1987), very little is known about the effects of agents which damage chromosomal DNA on the frequency of hepadnaviral DNA integrations. Using a recently developed subcloning approach to detect stable new integrations of duck hepatitis B virus (DHBV) (S. S. Gong, A. D. Jensen, and C. E. Rogler, J. Virol. 70:2000-2007, 1996), we tested the effects of increased chromosomal DNA damage induced by H2O2, or of the disturbance in DNA repair due to the inhibition of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP), on the frequency of DHBV DNA integrations. Subclones of LMH-D21-6 cells, which replicate DHBV, were grown in the presence of various H2O2 concentrations and exhibited up to a threefold increase in viral DNA integration frequency in a dose-dependent manner. Moreover, inhibition of PARP, which plays a role in cellular responses to DNA breakage, by 3-aminobenzamide (3-AB) resulted in a sevenfold increase in the total number of new DHBV DNA integrations into host chromosomal DNA. Removal of either H2O2 or 3-AB from the culture medium in a subsequent cycle of subcloning was accompanied by a reversion back towards the original lower frequency of stable DHBV DNA integrations for LMH-D21-6 cells. These data support the hypothesis that DNA damage sites can serve as sites for hepadnaviral DNA integration, and that increasing the number of DNA damage sites dramatically increases viral integration frequency.     

Mitochondrial targeting of human DNA glycosylases for repair of oxidative DNA damage.

Oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA has been implicated in human degenerative diseases and aging. Although removal of oxidative lesions from mitochondrial DNA occurs, the responsible DNA repair enzymes are poorly understood. By expressing the epitope-tagged proteins in COS-7 cells, we examined subcellular localizations of gene products of human DNA glycosylases: hOGG1, hMYH and hNTH1. A gene encoding for hOGG1 which excises 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) from DNA generates four isoforms by alternative splicing (types 1a, 1b, 1c and 2). Three tagged isoforms (types 1b, 1c and 2) were localized in the mitochondria. Type 1a protein, which exclusively contains a putative nuclear localization signal, was sorted to the nucleus and lesser amount to the mitochondria. hMYH, a human homolog gene product of Escherichia coli mutY was mainly transported into the mitochondria. hNTH1 protein excising several pyrimidine lesions was transported into both the nucleus and mitochondria. In contrast to the three DNA glycosylases, translocation of the human major AP endonuclease (hAPE) into the mitochondria was hardly observed in COS-7 cells. These results suggest that the previously observed removal of oxidative base lesions in mitochondrial DNA is initiated by the above DNA glycosylases.     

Base-excision repair of oxidative DNA damage by DNA glycosylases

Oxidative damage to DNA caused by free radicals and other oxidants generate base and sugar damage, strand breaks, clustered sites, tandem lesions and DNA-protein cross-links. Oxidative DNA damage is mainly repaired by base-excision repair in living cells with the involvement of DNA glycosylases in the first step and other enzymes in subsequent steps. DNA glycosylases remove modified bases from DNA, generating an apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) site. Some of these enzymes that remove oxidatively modified DNA bases also possess AP-lyase activity to cleave DNA at AP sites. DNA glycosylases possess varying substrate specificities, and some of them exhibit cross-activity for removal of both pyrimidine- and purine-derived lesions. Most studies on substrate specificities and excision kinetics of DNA glycosylases were performed using oligonucleotides with a single modified base incorporated at a specific position. Other studies used high-molecular weight DNA containing multiple pyrimidine- and purine-derived lesions. In this case, substrate specificities and excision kinetics were found to be different from those observed with oligonucleotides. This paper reviews substrate specificities and excision kinetics of DNA glycosylases for removal of pyrimidine- and purine-derived lesions in high-molecular weight DNA.     

Nitroxides block DNA scission and protect cells from oxidative damage.

The protective effect of cyclic stable nitroxide free radicals, having SOD-like activity, against oxidative damage was studied by using Escherichia coli xthA DNA repair-deficient mutant hypersensitive to H2O2. Oxidative damage induced by H2O2 was assayed by monitoring cell survival. The metal chelator 1,10-phenanthroline (OP), which readily intercalates into DNA, potentiated the H2O2-induced damage. The extent of in vivo DNA scission and degradation was studied and compared with the loss of cell viability. The extent of DNA breakage correlated with cell killing, supporting previous suggestions that DNA is the crucial cellular target of H2O2 cytotoxicity. The xthA cells were protected by catalase but not by superoxide dismutase (SOD). Both five- and six-membered ring nitroxides, having SOD-like activity, protected growing and resting cells from H2O2 toxicity, without lowering H2O2 concentration. To check whether nitroxides protect against O2.(-)-independent injury also, experiments were repeated under hypoxia. These nitroxides also protected hypoxic cells against H2O2, suggesting alternative modes of protection. Since nitroxides were found to reoxidize DNA-bound iron(II), the present results suggest that nitroxides protect by oxidizing reduced transition metals, thus interfering with the Fenton reaction.     

Induction of oxidative DNA damage in anaerobes

We compared oxidative DNA damage in strictly anaerobic Prevotella melaninogenica, aerotolerant anaerobic Bacteroides fragilis, and facultative anaerobic Salmonella typhimurium after exposure to O2 or H2O2. Using HPLC with electrochemical detection, we measured 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine (8OHdG) as a damage marker. O2 induced 8OHdG in P. melaninogenica but not in B. fragilis, which shows catalase activity, or in S. typhimurium. In P. melaninogenica, with catalase, O2 induced less 8OHdG; superoxide dismutase had no effect; with glucose and glucose oxidase, O2 induced more 8OHdG. H2O2 also markedly increased 8OHdG. O2 was suggested to induce 8OHdG through H2O2. O2 or H2O2 decreased survival only in P. melaninogenica. Highly sensitive to oxidative stress, P. melaninogenica could prove useful for investigating oxidative DNA damage.     

Neutrophils cause oxidative DNA damage in alveolar epithelial cells.

Inflammation has been recognized as a contributing factor in the pathogenesis of some cancers. In the lung, inflammation is characterized by an influx of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMN) that release a variety of reactive oxygen species (ROS). The aim of the present study was to investigate the direct effect of PMN on oxidative DNA damage in lung target cells. Therefore, rat alveolar epithelial cells (RLE) were coincubated with PMN or hydrogen peroxide. Known to be correlated with the incidence of cancer, 7-hydro-8-oxo-2'deoxyguanosine (8-oxodG) was used as an effect marker for oxidative damage. Viability of the RLE, when coincubated with PMN, decreased to 43%, dependent on the ratio between PMN and RLE. After washing off PMN, 8-oxodG levels were significantly increased in RLE, but the highest levels were observed in the washed off PMN fraction. In addition, to avoid washing off procedures, immunohistochemical analysis was used to measure the 8-oxodG levels specifically in the RLE and similar results were obtained. In addition, inhibitor experiments showed that antioxidants ameliorated oxidative DNA damage. Our data provide evidence that ROS released by PMN as well as H2O2, cause oxidative DNA damage in epithelial cells.     

Methamphetamine-enhanced embryonic oxidative DNA damage and neurodevelopmental deficits

Methamphetamine (METH) causes dopaminergic nerve terminal degeneration and functional deficits in adult mice, but its neurodevelopmental effects are unclear. We investigated METH-initiated oxidative DNA damage in brain during the embryonic and fetal periods, and the postnatal histological and functional consequences. Pregnant CD-1 mice were treated with a single dose of METH (20 or 40 mg/kg ip) or its saline vehicle on Gestational Day 14 or 17. METH enhanced conceptal DNA oxidation, determined by 8-oxoguanine formation, in brain and liver by at least 2-fold at 1 h (P < 0.05), and more so in some fetal brains at 4 h. After birth, motor coordination on the rotarod apparatus in the METH-exposed offspring was impaired for at least 12 weeks (P < 0.05). Unlike in adults, this postnatal functional deficit in offspring exposed in utero to METH was not associated with degeneration of striatal dopaminergic nerve terminals at 12 weeks of age determined by tyrosine hydroxylase staining, suggesting a novel pathological mechanism in utero. This is the first evidence of oxidative DNA damage in embryonic and fetal brain caused by amphetamines, leading to long-term postnatal neurodevelopmental deficits via a mechanism different from that underlying the neurodegeneration observed in METH-exposed adults.     

Progress in the analysis of urinary oxidative DNA damage

Oxidative DNA damage has been implicated to be important in the pathogenesis of many diseases, including cancer and heart disease. The assessment of damage in various biological matrices, such as DNA, serum, and urine, is vital to understanding this role and subsequently devising intervention strategies. Despite the numerous techniques to measure oxidative DNA damage products in urine, it remains unclear what these measurements truly represent. Sources of urinary lesions may include the diet, cell death, and, of most interest, DNA repair. Were it possible to exclude the two former contributions, a noninvasive assay for DNA repair would be invaluable in the study of DNA damage and disease. This review highlights that, although progress has been made, significant work remains. Diet, cell death, and repair need continued examination to further elucidate the kinetics of lesion formation and clearance in vivo. Studies from our laboratory and others are making appreciable progress towards the interpretation of urinary lesion measurements along with the development of urinary assays to evaluate DNA repair. Upon establishment of these details, urinary oxidative DNA damage measurements may become more than a reflection of generalized oxidative stress.     

Superoxide and hydrogen peroxide in oxygen damage.

Escherichia coli were damaged and killed by exposure to hyperbaric oxygen. Lethality was measured as the decrease in the number of colonies formed upon plating the exposed cells onto rich agar. Damage was assessed by plating onto both rich and minimal agar. Cells which gave rise to visible colonies on rich but not on minimal agar were considered to be damaged. That this differential colony count was largely due to reparable damage rather than to stable mutagenesis was shown by replica plating from the rich onto the minimal agar. Most of the cells which had been unable to grow when directly plated onto minimal agar regained this ability after growth upon rich agar. Repair of the damage imposed by exposure to oxygen was thus more readily accomplished on a nutritionally rich medium. The enzymes superoxide dismutase, catalase, and peroxidase appeared to protect against oxygen damage. It is thus likely that both O₂^? and H₂O₂ are important agents of oxygen toxicity. In accord with this conclusion were the observations that augmented intracellular levels of these enzymes correlated with increased resistance towards oxygen damage, whereas increased respiratory capacity correlated with increased sensitivity towards hyperbaric oxygen.     

Mapping oxidative DNA damage at nucleotide level

DNA damage induced by reactive oxygen species (ROS) is considered an important intermediate in the pathogenesis of human conditions such as cancer and aging. By developing an oxidative-induced DNA damage mapping version of the Ligation-mediated polymerase chain reaction (LMPCR) technique, we investigated the in vivo and in vitro frequencies of DNA base modifications caused by ROS in the human p53 and PGK1 gene. Intact human male fibroblasts were exposed to 50 mM H₂O₂, or purified genomic DNA was treated with 5 mM H₂O₂, 100 μM Ascorbate, and 50 μM, 100 μM, or 100 μM of Cu(II), Fe(III), or Cr(VI) respectively. The damage pattern generated in vivo was nearly identical to the in vitro Cu(II) or Fe(III) damage patterns; damage was non-random with guanine bases heavily damaged. Cr(VI) generated an in vitro damage pattern similar to the other metal ions, although several unique thymine positions were damaged. Also, extra nuclear sites are a major contributor of metal ions (or metal-like ligands). These data show that the local probability of H₂O₂-mediated DNA damage is determined by the primary DNA sequence, with chromatin structure having a limited effect. The data suggest a model in which DNA-metal ion binding domains can accommodate different metalions. LMPCR's unique aspect is a blunt-end ligation of an asymmetric double-stranded linker, permitting exponential PCR amplification. An important factor limiting the sensitivity of LMPCR is the representation of target gene DNA relative to non-targeted genes; therefore, we recently developed a method to eliminate excess non-targeted genomic DNA. Restriction enzyme-digested genomic DNA is size fractionated by Continuous Elution Electrophoresis (CEE), capturing the target sequence of interest. The amount of target DNA in the starting material for LMPCR is enriched, resulting in a stronger amplification signal. CEE provided a 24-fold increase in the signal strength attributable to strand breaks plus modified bases created by ROS in the human p53 and PGK1 genes, detected by LMPCR. We are currently taking advantage of the enhanced sensitivity of target gene-enriched LMPCR to map DNA damage induced in human breast epithelial cells exposed to non-cytotoxic concentrations of H₂O₂.