DNA recognition by DNase I

Bovine pancreatic DNase I shows a strong preference for double-stranded substrates and cleaves DNA with strongly varying cutting rates suggesting that the enzyme recognises sequence-dependent structural variations of the DNA double helix. The complicated cleavage pattern indicates that several local as well as global helix parameters influences the cutting frequency of DNase I at a given bond. The high resolution crystal structures of two DNase I-DNA complexes showed that the enzyme binds tightly in the minor groove, and to the sugar-phosphate backbones of both strands, and thereby induces a widening of the minor groove and a bending towards the major grooves. In agreement with biochemical data this suggests that flexibility and minor groove geometry are major parameters determining the cutting rate of DNase I. Experimental observations showing that the sequence environmental of a dinucleotide step strongly affects its cleavage efficiency can be rationalized by that fact that six base pair are in contact with the enzyme. Mutational analysis based on the structural results has identified critical residues for DNA binding and cleavage and has lead to a proposal for the catalytic mechanism.     

The influence of the exocyclic pyrimidine 5-methyl group on DNAse I cleavage and sequence recognition by drugs

Incorporation of modified nucleotides into DNA, using the PCR, has allowed us to probe the influence that the exocyclic 5-methyl group of pyrimidines has on DNAse I cleavage and sequence recognition by drugs. The results show that removal of the methyl group from the major groove, made possible by substituting uridine for thymidine, allows DNAse I to cleave more readily at AT-rich regions compared to normal DNA. By contrast, addition of an extra methyl group, contrived by substituting 5-methylcytidine for normal cytidine, allows DNAse I to cleave more readily at GC-rich regions compared to normal DNA. In the cutting pattern of DNA containing both uridine and 5-methyl cytosine, we find the cleavage characteristics of both the single-substituted DNA species combined. Thus, the presence or absence of the exocyclic 5-methyl group in the major groove has a strong influence on the relative intensity of cleavage of phosphodiester bonds by DNAse I. These nucleotide substitutions can also influence the sequence-selective binding of drugs to DNA. Whereas removal of the methyl group (replacement of T with U) generally has little effect on sequence recognition by a variety of drugs, addition of a methyl group (replacement of C with M) generates new binding sites for some intercalators, namely daunomycin, DACA and SN16713.     

DNase I susceptibility of bent DNA and its alteration by ditercalinium and distamycin

The bending of kinetoplast DNA from Crithidia fasciculata is thought to be related to the periodic distribution of AA or TT cluster sequences. The sensitivity to DNase I of the two strands of this DNA was analyzed at nucleotide resolution by sequencing gel electrophoresis. The effect on the DNase I cleavage pattern of two drugs, ditercalinium and distamycin, that are able to remove bending was analyzed. The same analysis was done on a pBR 322 DNA fragment of random sequence as a control. The periodic distribution of the AA or TT clusters in the bent DNA fragment was first analyzed by computing the autocorrelation function of the AA or TT clusters in the bent DNA fragment. It is shown that the AT tracts are on average 10.5 base pairs apart. This value is almost identical with that of the B-DNA helix pitch in solution [10.5 (Wang, 1979); 10.6 +/- 0.1 (Rhodes & Klug, 1980)]. To reveal the periodic pattern of DNase I cleavage on this bent DNA, alone or in presence of drugs, the cross correlation between the different bands obtained from DNAse I cleavage and the presence of AA or TT sequences was computed. This shows that GC and mixed sequences are the most sensitive regions. These data also suggest that there is a periodic fluctuation in the width of the minor groove in the bent fragment. Ditercalinium and distamycin alter the DNase I cutting pattern of the bent DNA fragment but in an inverse fashion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Deoxyribonuclease I footprinting reveals different DNA binding modes of bifunctional platinum complexes

Deoxyribonuclease I (DNase I) footprinting methodology was used to analyze oligodeoxyribonucleotide duplexes containing unique and single, site-specific adducts of trinuclear bifunctional platinum compound, [{trans-PtCl(NH3)2}2 mu-trans-Pt(NH3)2{H2N(CH2)6NH2}2]4+ (BBR3464) and the results were compared with DNase I footprints of some adducts of conventional mononuclear cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II) (cisplatin). These examinations took into account the fact that the local conformation of the DNA at the sites of the contacts of DNase I with DNA phosphates, such as the minor groove width and depth, sequence-dependent flexibility and bendability of the double helix, are important determinants of sequence-dependent binding to and cutting of DNA by DNase I. It was shown that various conformational perturbations induced by platinum binding in the major groove translated into the minor groove, allowing their detection by DNase I probing. The results also demonstrate the very high sensitivity of DNase I to DNA conformational alterations induced by platinum complexes so that the platinum adducts which induce specific local conformational alterations in DNA are differently recognized by DNase I.     

X-ray structure of the DNase I-d(GGTATACC)2 complex at 2.3 A resolution.

The crystal structure of a complex between DNase I and the self-complementary octamer duplex d(GGTATACC)2 has been solved using the molecular replacement method and refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 18.8% for all data between 6.0 and 2.3 A resolution. In contrast to the structure of the DNase I-d(GCGATCGC)2 complex solved previously, the DNA remains uncleaved in the crystal. The general architecture of the two complexes is highly similar. DNase I binds in the minor groove of a right-handed DNA duplex, and to the phosphate backbones on either side over five base-pairs, resulting in a widening of the minor groove and a concurrent bend of the DNA away from the bound enzyme. There is very little change in the structure of the DNase I on binding the substrate. Many other features of the interaction are conserved in the two complexes, in particular the stacking of a deoxyribose group of the DNA onto the side-chain of a tyrosine residue (Y76), which affects the DNA conformation and the binding of an arginine side-chain in the minor groove. Although the structures of the DNA molecules appear at first sight rather similar, detailed analysis reveals some differences that may explain the relative resistance of the d(GGTATACC)2 duplex to cleavage by DNase I: whilst some backbone parameters are characteristic of a B-conformation, the spatial orientation of the base-pairs in the d(GGTATACC)2 duplex is close to that generally observed in A-DNA. These results further support the hypothesis that the minor-groove width and depth and the intrinsic flexibility of DNA are the most important parameters affecting the interaction. The disposition of residues around the scissile phosphate group suggests that two histidine residues, H134 and H252, are involved in catalysis.     

DNA conformational analysis in solution by uranyl mediated photocleavage.

Uranyl mediated photocleavage of double stranded DNA is proposed as a general probing for DNA helix conformation in terms of minor groove width/electronegative potential. Specifically, it is found that A/T-tracts known to constitute strong distamycin binding sites are preferentially photocleaved by uranyl in a way indicating strongest uranyl binding at the center of the minor groove of the AT-region. The A-tracts of kinetoplast DNA show the highest reactivity at the 3'-end of the tract--as opposed to cleavage by EDTA/Fell--in accordance with the minor groove being more narrow at this end. Finally, uranyl photocleavage of the internal control region (ICR) of the 5S-RNA gene yields a cleavage modulation pattern fully compatible with that obtained by DNase I which also--in a more complex way--senses DNA minor groove width.     

The influence of the 2-amino group of guanine on DNA conformation. Uranyl and DNase I probing of inosine/diaminopurine substituted DNA.

The conformation of the DNA helix is supposed to be a critical element in site-specific recognition by ligands both large and small. Groove width is one important measure of the conformation which varies with the local nucleotide composition, perhaps because of the presence of a purine 2-amino group on G.C base pairs. We have probed DNA with G-->inosine (I) and/or A-->diaminopurine (DAP) substitutions to see whether the location of the purine 2-amino group can indeed affect the minor groove width. At acid pH, the reactivity towards uranyl nitrate is modulated in substituted DNA quite differently from natural DNA, consistent with a marked narrowing of the minor groove at sites of G-->I substitution and widening at sites of A-->DAP replacement. The latter exerts the dominant effect. The expected changes in conformation are equally evident in the patterns of susceptibility to DNase I cleavage, but not to hydroxyl radical attack. Nuclease cleavage is maximal in normal and substituted DNA at regions of inferred moderate groove width which are generally little affected by the nucleotide substitutions. Consistent with models of sequence-dependent cutting by DNase I we find that the presence of a purine 2-amino group on the base pair three places upstream of the cutting site has a profound influence on the rate of reaction.     

Differences in the accessibility of methylated and unmethylated DNA to DNase I.

DNase I binds in the minor groove of DNA and is used as an enzymatic tool to investigate the interaction of proteins with DNA. Here we show that the major groove located 5-methyldeoxycytidine can enhance or inhibit the cleavage rates of DNA by DNase I. This effect may be caused in part by changes in DNA structure affecting the accessibility of the minor groove of DNA to DNase I.     

Mutagenesis of the DNA binding residues in bovine pancreatic DNase 1: an investigation into the mechanism of sequence discrimination by a sequence selective nuclease.

The sequence selectivity of DNase 1 cleavage has been investigated by site-directed mutagenesis of a chemically synthesised gene. Two key DNA binding residues have been conservatively altered (Y76F and R41K) or have had their side-chains truncated (Y76A and R41A) and the effect on the cleavage of tyr T promoter DNA has been noted. It would appear from these studies that DNase 1 is not sensitive to minor groove width via these DNA-contacting residues, and it is suggested that DNA helical stiffness is a controlling parameter in determining DNase 1 sequence selectivity.     

103 Probing DNA shape and methylation state on a genomic scale with DNase I

DNA binding proteins find their cognate sequences within genomic DNA through recognition of specific chemical and structural features. Here, we demonstrate that high-resolution DNase I cleavage profiles can provide detailed information about the shape and chemical modification status of genomic DNA. Analyzing millions of DNA-backbone hydrolysis events on naked genomic DNA, we show that the intrinsic rate of cleavage by DNase I closely tracks the width of the minor groove. Integration of these DNase I cleavage data with bisulfite sequencing data for the same cell type genome reveals that the cleavage directly adjacent to CpG dinucleotides is enhanced at least eight-fold by cytosine methylation. This phenomenon we show is attributable to methylation-induced narrowing of the minor groove. Furthermore, we demonstrate that it enables simultaneous mapping of DNase I hypersensitivity and regional DNA methylation levels using dense in vivo cleavage data. Taken together, our results suggest a general mechanism through which CpG methylation can modulate protein–DNA interaction strength via the remodeling of DNA shape.     

DNA intramolecular triplexes containing dT --> dU substitutions: unfolding energetics and ligand binding

We used a combination of optical and calorimetric techniques to investigate the incorporation of deoxythymidine --> deoxyuridine (dT --> dU) substitutions in the duplex and third strand of the parallel intramolecular triplex d(A(7)C(5)T(7)C(5)T(7)) (ATT). UV and differential scanning calorimetry melting experiments show that the incorporation of two substitutions yielded triplexes with lower thermal stability and lower unfolding enthalpies. The enthalpies decrease with an increase in salt concentration, indirectly yielding a heat capacity effect, and the magnitude of this effect was lower for the substituted triplexes. The combined results indicate that the destabilizing effect is due to a decrease in the level of stacking interactions. Furthermore, the minor groove ligand netropsin binds to the minor groove and to the hydrophobic groove, created by the double chain of thymine methyl groups in the major groove of these triplexes. Binding of netropsin to the minor groove yielded thermodynamic profiles similar to that of a DNA duplex with a similar sequence. However, and relative to ATT, binding of netropsin to the hydrophobic groove has a decreased binding affinity and lower binding enthalpy. This shows that the presence of uridine bases disrupts the hydrophobic groove and lowers its cooperativity toward ligand binding. The overall results suggest that the stabilizing effect of methyl groups may arise from the combination of both hydrophobic and electronic effects.     

Molecular determinants for DNA minor groove recognition: design of a bis-guanidinium derivative of ethidium that is highly selective for AT-rich DNA sequences

The phenanthridinium dye ethidium bromide is a prototypical DNA intercalating agent. For decades, this anti-trypanosomal agent has been known to intercalate into nucleic acids, with little preference for particular sequences. Only polydA-polydT tracts are relatively refractory to ethidium intercalation. In an effort to tune the sequence selectivity of known DNA binding agents, we report here the synthesis and detailed characterization of the mode of binding to DNA of a novel ethidium derivative possessing two guanidinium groups at positions 3 and 8. This compound, DB950, binds to DNA much more tightly than ethidium and exhibits distinct DNA-dependent absorption and fluorescence properties. The study of the mode of binding to DNA by means of circular and electric linear dichroism revealed that, unlike ethidium, DB950 forms minor groove complexes with AT sequences. Accurate quantification of binding affinities by surface plasmon resonance using A(n)T(n) hairpin oligomer indicated that the interaction of DB950 is over 10-50 times stronger than that of ethidium and comparable to that of the known minor groove binder furamidine. DB950 interacts weakly with GC sites by intercalation. DNase I footprinting experiments performed with different DNA fragments established that DB950 presents a pronounced selectivity for AT-rich sites, identical with that of furamidine. The replacement of the amino groups of ethidium with guanidinium groups has resulted in a marked gain of both affinity and sequence selectivity. DB950 provides protection against DNase I cleavage at AT-containing sites which frequently correspond to regions of enhanced cleavage in the presence of ethidium. Although DB950 maintains a planar phenanthridinium chromophore, the compound no longer intercalates at AT sites. The guanidinium groups of DB950, just like the amidinium group of furamidine (DB75), are the critical determinants for recognition of AT binding sites in DNA. The chemical modulation of the ethidium exocyclic amines is a profitable option to tune the nucleic acid recognition properties of phenylphenanthridinium dyes.     

DNase I-induced DNA conformation. 2 A structure of a DNase I-octamer complex.

The structure of a complex between DNase I and d(GCGATCGC)2 has been solved by molecular replacement and refined to an R-factor of 0.174 for all data between 6 and 2 A resolution. The nicked octamer duplexes have lost a dinucleotide from the 3' ends of one strand and are hydrogen-bonded across a 2-fold axis to form a quasi-continuous double helix of 14 base-pairs. DNase I is bound in the minor groove of the B-type DNA duplex forming contacts in and along both sides of the minor groove extending over a total of six base-pairs. As a consequence of binding of DNase I to the DNA-substrate the minor groove opens by about 3 A and the duplex bends towards the major groove by about 20 degrees. Apart from these more global distortions the bound duplex also shows significant deviations in local geometry. A major cause for the observed perturbations in the DNA conformation seems to be the stacking type interaction of a tyrosine ring (Y76) with a deoxyribose. In contrast, the enzyme structure is nearly unchanged compared to free DNase I (0.49 A root-mean-square deviations for main-chain atoms) thus providing a rigid framework to which the DNA substrate has to adapt on binding. These results confirm the hypothesis that groove width and stiffness are major factors determining the global sequence dependence of the enzyme's cutting rates. The nicked octamer present in the crystals did not allow us to draw detailed conclusions about the catalytic mechanism but confirmed the location of the active site near H134 on top of the central beta-sheets. A second cut of the DNA induced by diffusion of Mn2+ into the crystals may suggest the presence of a secondary active site in DNase I.     

Sequence-recognition and cleavage of DNA by a netropsin-phenazine-di-N-oxide conjugate

We report the synthesis, DNA-binding and cleaving properties, and cytotoxic activities of R-128, a hybrid molecule in which a bis-pyrrolecarboxamide-amidine element related to the antibiotic netropsin is covalently tethered to a phenazine-di-N-oxide chromophore. The affinity and mode of interaction of the conjugate with DNA were investigated by a combination of absorption spectroscopy, circular dichroism, and electric linear dichroism. This hybrid molecule binds to AT-rich sequences of DNA via a bimodal process involving minor groove binding of the netropsin moiety and intercalation of the phenazine moiety. The bidentate mode of binding was evidenced by linear dichroism using calf thymus DNA and poly(dA-dT).(dA-dT). In contrast, the drug fails to bind to poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC), because of the obstructive effect of the guanine 2-amino group exposed in the minor groove of this polynucleotide. DNase I footprinting studies indicated that the conjugate interacts preferentially with AT-rich sequences, but the cleavage of DNA in the presence of a reducing agent can occur at different sequences not restricted to the AT sites. The main cleavage sites were detected with a periodicity of about 10 base pairs corresponding to approximately one turn of the double helix. This suggests that the cleavage may be dictated by the structure of the double helix rather than the primary nucleotide sequence. The conjugate which is moderately toxic to cancer cells complements the tool box of reagents which can be utilized to produce DNA strand scission. The DNA cleaving properties of R-128 entreat further exploration into the use of phenazine-di-N-oxides as tools for investigating DNA structure.     

Binding of tachyplesin I to DNA revealed by footprinting analysis: significant contribution of secondary structure to DNA binding and implication for biological action.

In view of the cationic amphipathic structure of tachyplesin I and antiparallel beta-sheet as a general DNA binding motif, DNA binding of the antimicrobial peptide has been examined. Several footprinting-like techniques using DNase I protection, dimethyl sulfate protection, and bleomycin- (BLM-) induced DNA cleavage were applied in this study. Some distinct footprints with DNase I are detected, and also the sequence-specific cleavage mode of the BLM-Fe(II) complex clearly is altered in the presence of tachyplesin I. In addition, methylation of the N-7 residue of guanine situated in the DNA major groove is not entirely inhibited (or activated) by tachyplesin I. The results suggest that tachyplesin I interacts with the minor groove of DNA duplex. Disappearance of the footprints by dithiothreitol-treated tachyplesin I and Ala-tachyplesin strongly suggests a significant contribution of secondary structure containing an antiparallel beta-sheet to the DNA binding of tachyplesin I. This is the first report on DNA interaction with a small peptide which contains a unique antiparallel beta-sheet structure. The mechanism for antimicrobial action of tachyplesin I has also been inferred.     

Conversion of bovine pancreatic DNase I to a repair endonuclease with a high selectivity for abasic sites.

Bovine pancreatic deoxyribonuclease I (DNase I) is a nuclease of relatively low specificity which interacts with DNA in the minor groove. No contacts are made between the protein and the major groove of the nucleic acid. DNase I is structurally homologous to exonuclease III, a DNA-repair enzyme with multiple activities. One of the main differences between the two enzymes is the presence of an additional alpha-helix in exonuclease III, in a position suggestive of interaction with the major groove of DNA. Recombinant DNA techniques have been used to add 14 amino acids, comprising the 10 amino acids of the exonuclease III alpha-helix flanked by a glycine rich region, to DNase I. The polypeptide has been inserted after serine 174, an amino acid on the surface of DNase I corresponding to the location of the extra alpha-helix in exonuclease III. The recombinant protein, DNase-exohelix, has been purified and its catalytic activities towards DNA investigated. The recombinant protein demonstrated a high selectivity for endonucleolytic cleavage at abasic sites in DNA, a property of exonuclease III but not native DNase I. Thus the insertion of 14 amino acids at Ser174, converts DNase I to an exonuclease III-like enzyme with DNA-repair properties.     

A comparison of the structural requirements for DNA cleavage by the isoschizomers HaeIII, BspRI and BsuRI

We have investigated the structural requirements for DNA cleavage by the isoschizomers HaeIII, BspRI and BsuRI which recognize the sequence -d(GGCC)-. For this purpose decadeoxynucleotides were synthesized by the solid-phase phosphotriester method and purified by high-performance liquid chromatography. The kinetics of cleavage of these oligodeoxynucleotides were determined for the three isoschizomers with the following results. The sequence adjacent to the recognition site strongly influences the rate of cleavage. The preference is qualitatively the same for all three enzymes: AGGCCT greater than TGGCCA greater than GGGCCC approximately equal to CGGCCG, and follows the thermal stability of the different decanucleotides. Substitutions within the recognition site, namely dI for dG and dU for dC, affect the rate of cleavage differently for the three enzymes. The results can be rationalized in terms of an interaction of HaeIII with the major and minor groove of the DNA, of BspRI mainly with the minor groove and of BsuRI with the major groove of DNA. It is obvious from our data that the mechanism of recognition of the same site is different for the three isoschizomers.     

Unusually strong binding to the DNA minor groove by a highly twisted benzimidazole diphenylether: induced fit and bound water

RT29 is a dicationic diamidine derivative that does not obey the classical "rules" for shape and functional group placement that are expected to result in strong binding and specific recognition of the DNA minor groove. The compound contains a benzimidazole diphenyl ether core that is flanked by the amidine cations. The diphenyl ether is highly twisted and gives the entire compound too much curvature to fit well to the shape of the minor groove. DNase I footprinting, fluorescence intercalator displacement studies, and circular dichroism spectra, however, indicate that the compound is an AT specific minor groove binding agent. Even more surprisingly, quantitative biosensor-surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration calorimetric results indicate that the compound binds with exceptional strength to certain AT sequences in DNA with a large negative enthalpy of binding. Crystallographic results for the DNA complex of RT29 compared to calculated results for the free compound show that the compound undergoes significant conformational changes to enhance its minor groove interactions. In addition, a water molecule is incorporated directly into the complex to complete the compound-DNA interface, and it forms an essential link between the compound and base pair edges at the floor of the minor groove. The calculated DeltaCp value for complex formation is substantially less than the experimentally observed value, which supports the idea of water being an intrinsic part of the complex with a major contribution to the DeltaCp value. Both the induced fit conformational changes of the compound and the bound water are essential for strong binding to DNA by RT29.