The statistical analysis of potato anther culture data

Methods for the production and utilisation of haploids have been developed for a range of crop plants. Genetical and environmental factors are known to influence both the rate of haploid induction and the mode of regeneration. Investigations designed to examine the parameters that influence haploid production from anthers are usually based on the overall percentage of responding anthers. Previous studies have rarely taken into account the frequency or distribution of anther culture response within a potato flower. In this paper the binomial, poisson and multiplicative binomial distributions are used for the first time to describe the distribution of anther culture response within a Solanum tuberosum flower.     

Phenotypic characterization and bulk segregant analysis of anther culture response in two backcross families of diploid potato

Two diploid (2n=2x=24) backcross potato populations (PBCp, and CBC) were characterized for anther culture response (ACR). PBCp (Solanum phureja Juz. & Buk. genotype 1-3 × CP2) and CBC (CP2 × S. chacoense Bitt. genotype 80-1) resulted from a cross between CP2 (intermediate ACR) and its parents, S. chacoense 80-1(low ACR) and S. phureja 1-3 (high ACR). Three components of ACR were initially investigated: embryos per anther (EPA), embryo regeneration rate and percent monoploids (2n=1x=12) among regenerants. EPA was selected for further characterization because of its relative stability. In a series of studies of EPA on a total of 44 genotypes within CBC, nine high (mean EPA=2.5) and ten low (mean EPA=0.02) selections were made. In PBCp, ten high (mean EPA= 4.7) and ten low (mean EPA= 0.05) selections were made from 67 genotypes. High and low selections were used for bulk segregant analysis to screen 214 RAPD primers as candidate markers linked to EPA. Bands amplified by OPQ-10 and OPZ-4 were associated in coupling and repulsion, respectively, to ACR in PBCp. A band amplified by OPW-14 primer was associated in coupling to ACR in CBC. One-way ANOVAs using presence/absence of each candidate band to classify additional genotypes in each population verified association of the markers with EPA.     

Effect of maltose on the response of potato anthers in culture

Anthers of the Solanum tuberosum genotype H3703 were cultured on medium containing equimolar concentrations of sucrose or maltose. It was found that significantly more pollen embryos became plants after culture on maltose and hence the yield of plants per 100 anthers cultured increased significantly. Mechanisms by which carbohydrate source may influence response to anther culture are discussed.     

Influence of 2,4-d and lactose on pollen embryogenesis in anther culture of potato

Anthers of diploid genotypes of Solanum tuberosum capable of androgenesis were cultured on different media to examine the effect on induction of pollen embryogenesis of 2,4-d and lactose. Anthers cultured in callogenic medium with 2,4-d and sucrose produced pollen derived embryoids only exceptionally. When sucrose was replaced by lactose the frequency of embryogenesis was as high or higher than in embryogenic auxin-free medium. Substitution of lactose for sucrose in the embryogenic medium had no effect. Supplementing the embryogenic medium with 2,4-d strongly reduced the frequency of pollen embryoids in the presence of sucrose but not with lactose.Abbreviations 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid     

Manipulation of division symmetry and developmental fate in cultures of potato microspores

The effect of media composition on microspore culture was investigated in one tetraploid and two diploid potatoes. The viability of microspores isolated from 4.5 to 5 mm buds was in the range of 33 to 52%. In media for anther culture, microspores showed no further development and lost viability within 2 days. In M1 medium containing mineral components, sucrose, uridine, cytidine, myo-inositol, glutamine and lactalbumin hydrolysate, 18 to 37% of microspores underwent mitosis within 14 days. Up to 95% of the divisions were symmetric and produced equal nuclei. Some symmetrically divided microspores eventually produced structures with 3 to 10 nuclei. The proportion of the total microspore population producing multinuclear structures reached 9% in diploid clones responsive to anther culture and 1 to 2% in recalcitrant cv. Borka. Symmetric mitoses in M1 medium were induced in the presence of glutamine and lactalbumin hydrolysate. Nucleosides and myo-inositol had no effect on microspore division. In the absence of all organic components except sucrose, most mitoses were asymmetric, formation of multinuclear structures was reduced and most pollen accumulated starch indicative of gametophytic fate. In complete M1 medium, starch accumulation was suppressed. Suppression also occurred in asymmetrically divided microspores, indicating a direct inhibition of pollen development independent of the mode of microspore division. This inhibitory effect of M1 medium might present a stress which triggers the induction of symmetric microspore division and subsequent formation of multinuclear structures. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Initiation and culture of potato tuber callus tissue with picloram

Callus cultures of 7 potato cultivars were initiated from tuber tissue and maintained on Gelrite-solidified media with 1–20 M picloram as the only PGR. Ten M picloram was the optimal concentration for callus induction. By 4–6 weeks after explanting, there was sufficient callus produced for subculture to maintenance media which contained 1–20 M picloram as the only PGR. When grown in the dark at 25°C, subcultured callus typically increased 10-fold in wet weight in 4–5 weeks. The callus produced was friable and a light grey to cream color. Callus cultures were used to establish cell suspension cultures. Callus and cell suspension cultures have been maintained for over 2 years on the picloram containing media.Abbreviations BA benzyladenine - 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - MS Murashige-Skoog - NAA naphthaleneacetic acid - PGR plant growth regulator Research paper #9053 of the Idaho Agricultural Experiment Station.     

The influence of culture conditions on anther culture response of commercial varieties of Solanum tuberosum L.

The effect of media manipulatioss, temperature pretreatment, carbohydrate source, and seasonal variation on tetraploid potato anther cultures was investigated. The anther culture responses of three commercial Nordic potato varieties from Scandinavia and two from Germany were compared on different media manipulations. With most of the varieties, solid MS media gave better yields than other published media manipulations. Pretreatments at +6°C and at +30°C were studied on Pito and Danva varieties. The +6°C pretreatment and no pretreatment had the same effect on the anther culture response of cv. Pito, while with cv. Danva pretreatment at +6°C promoted embryogenesis. The +30°C pretreatment had no positive effect on anther culture response on either cultivar. The effect of maltose, melibiose and mannitol individually and in combination with sucrose were compared to normal sucrose medium in cv. Pito anther cultures. Anthers incubated on normal sucrose medium gave the highest embryoid and plant yields; the second highest plant yields were obtained on pure maltose medium. Strong seasonal variation was observed throughout the year in cv. Pito anther cultures. The percentage of anthers producing embryoids ranged from 15–20% during September and October to just 1–3% from February through May. The annual average embryoid production rate was 6.18%.     

Variations in response to high temperature treatments in anther culture of Brussels sprouts

The level, time of application and duration of the high temperature treatment necessary for embryo production from Brussels sprouts anther culture were examined. The effects of 29, 32, 35, and 38°C given for 24 h immediately following removal of the anthers from the bud, were tested on different cultivars, on different plants within the cultivars and on different occasions for each plant. Most embryos were produced following 32 and 35°C, very few following 30°C and none following 38°C. Although there was a tendency for some cultivars to respond better to one or other of the two more favourable temperatures, this varied considerably between individual plants. Plant to plant variation was also seen in the overall level of the response, although responsiveness tended to decline with successive samplings of the same plant. Experiments with cultivars Hal and Gower suggested that high temperature was required for at least 12 h after anther removal, but beyond that time the optimum period varied from plant to plant. If the excised anthers were held at 25°C for 16 h or more with Hal or 24 h or more with Gower before being exposed to the high temperature treatment, embrogenesis tended to be reduced. It is suggested that apparent non-responsiveness in anther culture may result to a large extent from the specific conditions that are used during the anther culture process.     

In vitro induction of pollen embryos and plantlets in Aesculus carnea Hayne through anther culture

Uninuclear microspores in red horse chestnut anther cultures formed pollen embryos and plantlents in MS agar medium supplemented with varying 2,4-D concentrations (1.0, 1.5 or 2.0 mg l^-1) and 1.0 mg l^-1 Kin. The highest number of embryogenic anthers (38%) was obtained in MS medium containing 1.0 mg l^-1 of each 2,4-D and Kin. The ability of pollen embryos to germinate was closely correlated with normal embryo morphology and was influenced by hormone content in the medium (MS+;1.0 mg l^-1 IAA+1.0 mg l^-1 GA₃+0.1 mg l^-1 Kin+400 mg l^-1 glutamine). Pollen embryos and plantlets had the haploid chromosome number (x=n=40). Cytological examinations demonstrated pollen dimorphism of this Aesculus species.Abbreviations AC activated charcoal - 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - IAA indole-3-acetic acid - Kin 6-furfurylaminopurine - GA₃ gibberellic acid - MS Murashige and Skoog     

The influence of bud length,age of the tree and culture media on androgenesis induction inAesculus carnea Hayne anther culture

Statistical analyses of the data revealed very significant differences in androgenesis induction ofA. carnea Hayne anther culture depending on the bud length, nutrient medium composition and age of the parental tree. Significant mutual influence of all these factors was also observed. The highest number of androgenic anthers was obtained when 4 mm long buds were used. Older trees (60 and 100 yrs) gave a higher number of androgenic anthers than the younger ones (20 and 40 yrs). MS medium supplemented with 2,4-d and Kin (1 mg l^–1, each) was the most favourable for androgenesis induction. Pollen embryos (haploids and aneuploids) were formed by the division of uninuclear microspores.The highest percentage of germinated embryos and further synchronous development of the shoot and root was achieved in MS medium supplemented with IAA, GA₃ (1 mg l^–1) and activated charcoal (1%). When other germination media were used, malformations of androgenic embryos were observed.Abbreviations AC activated charcoal - H casein hydrolysate - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - IAA indole-3-acetic acid - IBA indole-3-butyric acid - BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - GA₃ gibberelic acid - Kin 6-furfurylaminopurine - MS Murashige and Skoog - T thidiazurone - N phenyl-N'-1,2,3-thiadiazol-5-ylurea - Z zeatin-6-(4-hydroxy-3-methyl-trans-2-butenylamino)purine     

Wheat anther culture: effect of genotype and environmental conditions

Twenty-two cultivars and lines of winter and spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) were studied, most for the first time, for their anther culture response. The response was genotype dependent. Plants grown in the field gave higher callus induction frequency than those grown in the greenhouse and the controlled environment chamber. Donor plants grown in a season of low drought stress as compared to a season of severe drought stress resulted in a higher frequency of callus induction. Spherical microcalli were observed in two wheat genotypes in some of only those anthers that were placed with only one loculus in contact with the medium. Wheat lines that were more responsive to anther culture were identified.     

Factors affecting variability in anther culture and in conversion of androgenic embryos ofSolanum phureja

The variation for embryo production in anther ofSolanum phureja was examined as a function of maximum greenhouse temperature prior to bud harvest and innate responsiveness among anthers within a bud. Four clones ofS. phuyreja were grown in a greenhouse under a 16-h photoperiod. The temperature was monitored continuously. Buds (60 per day on 10 days) were collected and the anthers cultured in two groups of five flasks (30 anthers per flask). In the first group, each flask contained the 30 anthers from six buds; in the second group, each flask contained one anther from each of 30 buds. Significantly smaller coefficients of variation were observed for the second group, suggesting that variation for embryogenic capcity among buds was greater than that among anthers within a bud. Variation in embryo yield as a function of greenhouse temperature was examined by stepwise regression analysis. Embryogenic capacity of one clone was adversely affected by high temperatures (31–37°C) that occurred two and seven days before bud harvest. However, similarly high temperatures appeared to enhance the androgenic response of another clone. Conversion of anther-derived embryos over three subcultures to fresh regeneration medium was examined as a function of anther donor or clone, cold pretreatment of embryos, and morphological classification of embryos. Only clonal origin significantly affected conversion rate which ranged from 12.5% to 46.0%. Conversion rate declined on each serial subculture.Abbreviations BA N⁶-benzyladenine - GA₃ gibberellic acid, IAA-indole-3-acetic acid     

Inheritance of competencies for leaf disc regeneration,anther culture,and protoplast culture in Solanum phureja and corrleations among them

Competence for leaf disc regeneration, anther culture, and protoplast culture was examined in the parental, F₁, and F₂ generations of a population of the diploid, cultivated, primitive potato, S. phureja (2n=2x=24). The parental pair consisted of AM3-8, an anther culture derived homozygous diploid, and NBP2, a heterozygous, field selected line. AM3-8 produced embryos in anther culture, and shoots on cultured leaf discs, but its cells did not divide after protoplast isolation. Cells of NBP2 divided to form calli and shoots in protoplast culture, but the clone did not respond to anther culture or leaf disc regeneration. All the individual plants in the F₁ generation were responsive to both anther and protoplast culture; however, there was segregation for the ability to regenerate shoots from leaf discs. The F₂ population, the result of a sib-cross, segregated for all three tissue culture competencies. Segregation data fit a one gene model for anther culture competence with the homozygous dominant genotype expressing the highest response, the heterozygote resulting in a marginal response, and the homozygous recessive resulting in no response. A two-gene model applied to the protoplast culture data, with a dominant allele at both loci required for division to occur after protoplast isolation. Leaf disc regeneration data could only be explained by a two gene model with recessive alleles at each locus required for the highest response, a dominant allele at either of the loci resulting in a marginal response, and dominant alleles at both loci resulting in no response. No significant correlation was found among these traits, implying three separate genetic mechanisms which segregate independently.Abbreviations BA N⁶-benzyladenine - GA₃ gibberellic acid - IAA indole-3-acetic acid - NAA -naphthaleneacetic acid     

In vitro induction of haploid,diploid and triploid plantlets by anther culture of Iochroma warscewiczii Regel

Pollen of Iochroma warscewiczii Regel (Solanaceae) produced embryogenic calli or embryos inside anthers cultured on Nitsch & Nitsch medium. Two distinct pathways could be recognized in this process, one involving mainly the vegetative cell, and the second starting with two equal cells in the pollen grains.In all media tested, androgenesis initiation was highest when anthers contained pollen at the first mitosis, or close to it, at inoculation. High sucrose (7%) and calcium (11.3 mM) concentrations were found to be highly desirable for the induction of androgenesis in this species. Addition of benzylaminopurine (0.5 mg l^–1) to the culture medium seems to slightly improve callus or embryo production. When all three factors were present at optimal concentrations as much as 13.9% of inoculated anthers were found to be embryogenic.Plantlet development from pollen embryos required lower sucrose (3%) and a combination of 0.1 mg l^–1 benzylaminopurine and 0.5 mg l^–1 gibberellic acid in the culture medium. Cytological analysis of 55 regenerated plantlets showed that about 49% were haploids, but diploid (ca. 49%) and triploid (ca. 2%) plants were also obtained.     

The influence of genotype and temperature pre-treatment on anther culture response in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

The influence of temperature stress pre-treatment on anther culture response has been examined in eight commercially desirable barley cultivars. Spikes were pre-treated in darkness at 4°C for periods of 0, 7, 14, 21 and 28 days. Overall, the optimum pre-treatment period was 21 days, although there were large genotype by pre-treatment interactions. The most responsive cultivar was Igri, with a mean of 38% anthers responding, and relatively little effect of pre-treatment. The greatest effect of pre-treatment was in cv. Heriot, which had 3% response with no pre-treatment and 52% response from 14 days pre-treatment.     

Histology of embryogenic responses in soybean anther culture

In order to clarify the embryogenic responses in soybean anther culture, anthers of four cultivars were cultured under known conditions to trigger androgenic response. A histological study was performed with anthers in vivo and with approximately 100 explants sampled after 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 30 and 45 days of culture. In vitro culture triggered the frequent accumulation of phenolic compounds on the locular and anther surfaces, and also caused the destruction of cells and tissues in complex structure such as the tapetum, microspores and pollen grains. Somatic embryogenesis of unicellular origin was observed from the epidermis and the middle layer, and of multicellular origin from connective calluses. No androgenic response could be observed in the anthers of these four soybean genotypes, in the medium and conditions indicated. We point out to the need of changing the approach to the study of androgenesis in soybean, either by using culture conditions unfavourable to the proliferation of diploid tissues, or by culturing isolated microspores.     

Phenotypic and cytological variation among plants derived from anther cultures ofLilium longiflorum

Summary Anther culture of the Easter Lily (Lilium longiflorum; 2n=2x=24) was attempted in order to evaluate its potential in generating haploids for the production of hybrid cultivars. The effects of genotype, temperature (low temperature treatment of buds and high temperature treatment of cultures), sucrose concentration and growth regulators were tested. The most important factors for callus induction were the genotype and the presence of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid. Pre-treatments at low or high temperature had no apparent effect, while high sucrose concentration was inhibitory. Callus was derived from 28 of the 108 genotypes tested and plants were regenerated. Phenotypic variations were observed among these regenerants. Somatic chromosome numbers were determined in 42 plants derived from 10 donor genotypes. Thirteen plants were diploid and 29 were mixoploid with chromosome numbers ranging from 11 to 26. Four of the mixoploid plants had a high proportion of cells with haploid chromosome numbers, particularly at early stages of development. Meiosis was examined in plants with flower buds. Most plants had 12 bivalents at Metaphase I, but also aneuploids were observed. Other irregularities included bridges and laggards at Anaphase I. The occurrence of high frequencies of haploid cells (up to 80%) in root tips suggests that some plants may be of gametic origin. Research was supported by the Easter Lily Research Foundation, the Ohio Floriculture Foundation, the Gloeckner Foundation and the Oregon Agricultural Experiment Station (technical paper no. 8398).     

The response of anther culture to culture temperature in Triticum aestivum

Summary The response of anther culture to culture temperature was studied in detail using many varieties, F₁ hybrids and pollen-derived lines of wheat (Triticum aestivum) as materials. The suitable culture temperature for inducing pollen callus (or embryoids) in wheat anther culture ranged from 26 °C to 30 °C, varying with genotypes. But for the great majority of wheat genotypes the suitable culture temperatures lay between 28 °C and 30°C. The most significant genotypic variation in the response to culture temperature was observed in the comparison between the culture at 33 °C for eight days followed by culture at 25 °C (or 26 °C) and the continuous culture at 25 °C (or 26 °C). This genotypic variation in the response to culture temperature is a heritable character which may be controlled by multiple genes. The effect of culture at 30 °C for eight days followed by culture at 26 °C was similar to, or in some cases, better than that of continuous culture at 28 °C, and the effect of culture at 32 °C for eight days followed by culture at 28 °C was similar to that of continuous culture at 30 °C. In the range from 26 °C to 32 °C, the overwhelming majority of pollen calli emerged before the 40th day after anther inoculation, and the higher the culture temperature, the earlier and more concentrated the emerging period of the pollen callus. The pollen callus obtained at high temperatures above 28 °C should be transferred in time onto the regeneration medium at 25°–27°C to induce shoots.     

Isolation of an amylose-free starch mutant of the potato (Solanum tuberosum L.)

Summary An amylose-free potato mutant was isolated after screening 12,000 minitubers. These minitubers had been induced on stem segments of adventitious shoots, which had been regenerated on leaf explants of a monoploid potato clone after Röntgen-irradiation. The mutant character is also expressed in subterranean tubers and in microspores. Starch granules from the mutant showed a strongly reduced activity of the granule bound starch synthase and loss of the major 60 kd protein from the starch granules.     

Heterozygous diploid plants regenerated from anther culture of F1 rice plants

Summary Plants derived from anther culture are theoretically haploid, but diploid plants are also known to arise. Anther culture-derived diploid plants are usually homozygous and are believed to be due to spontaneous doubling of chromosomes in either microsporocytes or callus cells during the culture process. However, heterozygous diploid regenerants may also arise from a) regeneration from cultured somatic cells, b) mutation occurring during or after a spontaneous doubling event, c) fusion of unlike haploid cells in chimeric callus, and d) regeneration from diploid microsporocytes resulting from aberrant meioses. This study was designed to elucidate the frequency and origin of diploid regenerants from rice anther culture. Regenerants were obtained from 11 F₁ genotypes. Progeny testing detected heterozygosity in 7 out of 211 regenerants. Each of the heterozygous regenerants were from ‘Calrose 76’/waxy ‘M-101’, Half of the diploid regenerants from this cross were heterozygous. No heterozygous regenerants arose from the other 10 F₁ genotypes. Progeny testing indicated that two of the heterozygous regenerants were as heterozygous as the F₁ plants for three parental characters. The other five regenerants exhibited decreased levels of heterozygosity. One of the heterozygous regenerants exhibited evidence of mutation for a non-parental character. However, mutation is an unlikely cause of the observed high levels of parental-type heterozygosity. No evidence for the occurrence of chimeric callus was detected, making this an unlikely cause as well. The most likely origin of the observed partial heterozygosity is regeneration from diploid microspores, which could also produce plants exhibiting complete parental-type heterozygosity.