The linear no-threshold model does not hold for low-dose ionizing radiation

Almost all of the data on the biological effects of ionizing radiation come from studies of high doses. However, the human population is unlikely to be exposed to such doses. Regulatory limits for radiation exposure are based on the linear no-threshold model, which predicts that the relationship between biological effects and radiation dose is linear, and that any dose has some effect. Chromosomal changes are an important effect of ionizing radiation because of their role in carcinogenesis. Here we exposed pKZ1 mice to single whole-body X-radiation doses as low as 1 microGy. We observed three different phases of response: (1) an induction of inversions at ultra-low doses, (2) a reduction below endogenous inversion frequency at low doses, and (3) an induction of inversions again at higher doses. These results do not fit a linear no-threshold model, and they may have implications for the way in which regulatory standards are presently set and for understanding radiation effects.     

Study of external low irradiation dose effects on induction of chromosome aberrations in Pisum sativum root tip meristem

The effects of low doses of ionizing radiation have been a matter of important debate over the last few years. The point of discussion concerns the validity of the linear dose-response extrapolation for low doses, used by international organizations, to establish radio-protection norms. Here, we contributed to this discussion by investigating the induction of chromosome aberrations by low to moderate doses ranging from 0 to 10 Gy in root meristem cells of 6-day-old Pisum plantlets. After acute irradiation of plantlets by a (60)Co source, the percentage of root tip meristem cells displaying chromosome aberrations was estimated immediately after irradiation and after 20 h recovery time. The dose-effect curves show non-linear responses, especially in the low dose range (0- 1 Gy), which is of particular interest. After 20 h of recovery, a steep increase of aberrations was observed for cells exposed to 0.4 Gy, followed by a plateau for doses until 1 Gy. There was an irradiation effect on plant growth during the first and second generations, showing the persistence of cell division anomalies as a long term effect of acute irradiation. This result suggests the induction of a genomic instability.Our results, in agreement with some obtained in animals, show rather non-linear dose-effect responses, with notably higher biological effects of low doses than expected.     

International Commission for Protection against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. ICPEMC publication No. 13. The need for biological risk assessment in reaching decisions about carcinogens

The prudent assumption that carcinogen bioassays in rodents predict for human carcinogenicity is examined. It is suggested that in certain cases, as for example the induction of tumors against a high incidence in controls, or in situations in which high dose toxicity may be a critical factor in the induction of cancer, the probability that animal bioassays predict for humans may be low. The term 'biological risk assessment' is introduced to describe that part of risk assessment concerned with the relevance of specific animal results to the induction of human cancer. Biological risk assessment, which is almost entirely dependent on an understanding of carcinogenesis mechanisms, is an important addition to present mathematical modeling used to predict the effects of animal carcinogens that have been demonstrated after high dose exposure, to the effects of the much smaller doses to which humans are perceived to be exposed. Evidence for the conclusions reached by biological risk assessment may sometimes be supported by a careful review of human epidemiological data.     

The dose response relationship obtained at constant irradiation times for the induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes by cobalt-60 gamma rays

Summary The induction of unstable chromosome aberrations in human peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed in vitro to protracted doses of cobalt-60 radiation is presented. Four dose response curves have been produced using constant exposure times of 1, 3, 6, and 12 h. The data fit well to the linear quadratic model and the yield coefficients have been compared with those obtained for acute (< 10 min) exposure. The quadratic coefficient is dependent on irradiation time and decreases approximately as predicted by Lea and Catcheside'sG-function hypothesis. The possibility of a small proportion of much longer lived breaks is discussed. For purposes of biological dosimetry it is sufficient to assume a mean time of 2 h and a single exponential function for the repair of lesions when relating the effects of brief and protracted exposure.     

The effect of riboxine on prophage induction and the survival of bacterial cultures exposed to gamma irradiation

In experiments with lysogenic cultures Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Escherichia coli K-12 proposed as a test for biological indication of relatively low doses of gamma-radiation, it was shown that when estimated by the criterion of prophage induction riboxine had a radioprotective action at nonlethal radiation doses. At the same time, when estimated by the criterion of the survival rate, riboxine produced the radioprotective effect at rather high radiation doses (survival rate of less than 10 per cent). It is suggested that riboxine is involved in the cell repair processes.     

Tumor induction and life shortening in BC3F1 female mice at low doses of fast neutrons and X rays

Extension of previous investigations at this laboratory regarding life shortening and tumor induction in the mouse has provided more complete dose-response information in the low dose region of X rays and neutrons. A complete observation of survival and late pathology has been carried out on over 2000 BC3F1 female mice irradiated with single doses of 1.5 MeV neutrons (0.5, 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 cGy) and, for comparison, of X rays (4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256 cGy). Data analysis has shown that a significant life shortening is observable only for individual neutron doses not lower than 8 cGy. Nevertheless, assuming a linear nonthreshold form for the overall dose-effect relationships of both radiation qualities, an RBE value of 12.3 is obtained for the 1.5 MeV neutrons. The induction of solid tumors by neutrons becomes statistically significant at individual doses from 8 cGy and by X rays for doses larger than 1 Gy. Linear dependence on neutron dose appears adequate to interpret the data at low doses. A separate analysis of ovarian tumor induction substantiates the hypothesis of a threshold dose for the X rays, while this is not strictly needed to interpret the neutron data. A trend analysis conducted on the neoplasm incidence confirms the above findings. Death rates have been analyzed, and a general agreement between the shift to earlier times of these curves and tumor induction was found.     

Lung carcinomas in Sprague-Dawley rats after exposure to low doses of radon daughters, fission neutrons, or gamma rays

The effectiveness of radon-daughter inhalation and irradiation with fission neutrons and gamma rays in the induction of lung carcinomas in Sprague-Dawley rats at low doses is compared. Earlier reports which compared radon-daughter inhalations and neutron irradiations over a wider range of doses were based on dosimetry for the radon-daughter inhalations which has recently been found to be faulty. In the present analysis, low-dose experiments were designed to derive revised equivalence ratios between radon-daughter exposures, and fission neutron or gamma irradiations. The equivalence is approximately 15 working level months (WLM) of radon daughters to 10 mGy of neutrons (the earlier value was 30 WLM to 10 mGy). The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons is 50 or more at a gamma-ray dose of 1 Gy. In these experiments with low doses and exposures, the lifetime incidences can be estimated from the raw incidences, while the derivation of the time dependence of the prevalence is essential for the estimation of RBE values and equivalence ratios.     

The effect of dose rate on radiation-induced neoplastic transformation in vitro by low doses of low-LET radiation

The dependence of the incidence of radiation-induced cancer on the dose rate of the radiation exposure is a question of considerable importance to the estimation of risk of cancer induction by low-dose-rate radiation. Currently a dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF) is used to convert high-dose-rate risk estimates to low dose rates. In this study, the end point of neoplastic transformation in vitro has been used to explore this question. It has been shown previously that for low doses of low-LET radiation delivered at high dose rates, there is a suppression of neoplastic transformation frequency at doses less than around 100 mGy. In the present study, dose-response curves up to a total dose of 1000 mGy have been generated for photons from (125)I decay (approximately 30 keV) delivered at doses rates of 0.19, 0.47, 0.91 and 1.9 mGy/min. The results indicate that at dose rates of 1.9 and 0.91 mGy/min the slope of the induction curve is about 1.5 times less than that measured at high dose rate in previous studies with a similar quality of radiation (28 kVp mammographic energy X rays). In the dose region of 0 to 100 mGy, the data were equally well fitted by a threshold or linear no-threshold model. At dose rates of 0.19 and 0.47 mGy/min there was no induction of transformation even at doses up to 1000 mGy, and there was evidence for a possible suppressive effect. These results show that for this in vitro end point the DDREF is very dependent on dose rate and at very low doses and dose rates approaches infinity. The relative risks for the in vitro data compare well with those from epidemiological studies of breast cancer induction by low- and high-dose-rate radiation.     

Relative biological efficiency for the induction of various gene mutations in normal and enriched with 10B Tradescantia cells by neutrons from 252Cf source

The effectiveness of neutrons from a Californium-252 source in the induction of various abnormalities in the Tradescantia clone 4430 stamen hair cells (Trad-SH assay) were studied. A special attention was paid to check whether any enhancement in effects is visible in the cells enriched with boron ions. Inflorescences, normal or pretreated with chemicals containing boron, were irradiated in the air with neutrons from a 252Cf source at KAERI, Taejon, Korea. To estimate the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of the beam under the study, numbers of Tradescantia inflorescence without chemical pretreatment were irradiated with various doses of X-rays. The ranges of radiation doses used for neutrons were 0-1.0Gy and for X-rays 0-0.5Gy. Following the culturing according to standard procedures screening of gene and lethal mutations in somatic cells of stamen hairs was done in the extended period, between days 7 and 19 after exposures. Maximal RBE values for the induction of pink, colorless and lethal mutations were evaluated from comparison of the slopes in linear parts of the dose response curves obtained after irradiation with X-rays and californium source. The RBE(max) value or the induction of gene mutation was estimated as 7.2 comparing the value 5.6 in the studies reported earlier. The comparison of dose-response curves and its alteration, due to changes in the cells and plants environment during and after irradiation, explains the observed differences. Inflorescence pretreated with borax responded to neutrons differently depending on the biological end points. Although, for the induction of pink mutations no significant difference was observed, though, in the case of cell lethality, pretreated with boron ion plants have shoved a statistically significant increase of the RBE value from 5.5 to 34.7, and in the case of colorless mutations from 1.6 to 5.6.     

Heavy charged particles produce a bystander effect via cell-cell junctions.

Radiation-induced damage to living cells results from either a direct hit to cellular DNA, or from indirect action which leads to DNA damage from radiation produced radicals. However, in recent years there is evidence that biological effects such as cell killing, mutation induction, chromosomal damage and modification of gene expression can occur in a cell population exposed to low doses of alpha particles. In fact these doses are so low that not all cells in the population will be hit directly by the radiation. Using a precision alpha-particle microbeam, it has been recently demonstrated that irradiated target cells can induce a bystander mutagenic response in neighboring "bystander" cells which were not directly hit by alpha particles. Furthermore, these results suggest that gap-junction mediated cell-to-cell communication plays a critical role in this bystander phenomenon. The purpose of this section is to describe recent studies on bystander biological effects. The recent work described here utilized heavy charged particles for irradiation, and investigated the role of gap-junction mediated cell-cell communication in this phenomenon.     

Long-term exposure to hexavalent chromium inhibits expression of tumor suppressor genes in cultured cells and in mice

We have used mouse hepatoma cells in culture to study acute, short-term high-dose effects of hexavalent chromium on gene regulation directed by the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon benzo[a]pyrene (BaP). We find that the mixture engages three major signaling pathways: (i) activation of detoxification genes; (ii) induction of signal transduction effectors; and (iii) epigenetic modification of chromatin marks. Preliminary results in mice exposed to mixtures of low doses of Cr(VI) plus BaP indicate that all three pathways are likely to be engaged also in long-term effects resulting from exposure to environmentally relevant doses of the mixture that inhibit the expression of tumor suppressor genes. Given the toxicity and carcinogenicity of these mixtures, we expect that a two-way analytical approach, from cells in culture to biological effects in vivo and vice versa, will provide a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms responsible for the biological effects of mixtures. By focusing both the in vivo and the in vitro work into long-term, low-dose, environmentally relevant exposures, we expect to develop much needed information pertinent to the type of diseases found in human populations exposed to mixtures of environmental toxicants.     

Radioadaptive response: An implication for the biological consequences of low dose-rate exposure to radiations

Radioadaptive response provides a considerable impact on the risk assessment of low-dose and low dose-rate exposures to ionizing radiations. The cells previously exposed to low doses of radiations become resistant to the induction of mutations, chromosome aberrations and cell killing by the subsequent doses but more susceptible to malignant transformation. The reaction kinetics of radioadaptive response were incorporated into a modelling of biological consequences of protracted low dose-rate exposures to radiations. The model is also consistent with the low dose-rate effects on spermatogonial mutations and translocations in the experimental animals and inverse dose-rate effects of morphological transformation in cultured cells.     

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of ionizing radiations become refractory to high doses of radiation as well as to chemical mutagens that induce double-strand breaks in DNA

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of ionizing radiation from incorporated tritiated thymidine or from X-rays become less susceptible to the induction of chromatid breaks by high doses of X-rays. This response can be induced by 0.01 Gy (1 rad) of X-rays, and has been attributed to the induction of a repair mechanism that causes the restitution of X-ray-induced chromosome breaks. Because the major lesions responsible for the induction of chromosome breakage are double-strand breaks in DNA, attempts have been made to see if the repair mechanism can affect various types of clastogenic lesions induced in DNA by chemical mutagens and carcinogens. When cells exposed to 0.01 Gy of X-rays or to low doses of tritiated thymidine were subsequently challenged with high doses of tritiated thymidine or bleomycin, which can induce double-strand breaks in DNA, or mitomycin C, which can induce cross-links in DNA, approximately half as many chromatid breaks were induced as expected. When, on the other hand, the cells were challenged with the alkylating agent methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), which can produce single-strand breaks in DNA, approximately twice as much damage was found as was induced by MMS alone. The results indicate that prior exposure to 0.01 Gy of X-rays reduces the number of chromosome breaks induced by double-strand breaks, and perhaps even by cross-links, in DNA, but has the opposite effect on breaks induced by the alkylating agent MMS. The results also show that the induced repair mechanism is different from that observed in the adaptive response that follows exposure to low doses of alkylating agents.     

Review and perspective on the use of mixed-function oxygenase enzymes in biological monitoring

It is often suggested that changes in simple biochemical/physiological responses may be useful for predicting the impacts of pollutants at population and community levels of biological organization. There are serious conceptual constraints to such a thesis and its seems likely that such simple responses can go no further than serving as early warning systems for delineating potential areas of pollutant impact--areas which (if shown to be significant in size) can then be subjected to more detailed population and community type studies. Environmental testing is a prerequisite for any response suggested to have value as a biological monitoring index and the induction of mixed-function oxygenase (MFO) enzymes has now been validated in a large number of field studies worldwide. Investigations have progressed from documenting induction near localized sources of hydrocarbon contamination to more diffuse sources of mixed organic pollution originating from industrial and domestic sources. Studies in the Great Lakes and Europe have demonstrated that the induction of MFO enzymes is a biological response of sufficient sensitivity to discriminate water quality differences over broad geographical areas. We suggest that as an early warning system, the induction of these enzymes can fulfill the requirement of "most sensitive biological response" for assessing a variety of organic pollution conditions. Given the high level of sensitivity of the MFO enzyme response, negative as well as positive field trials can be of value in addressing concerns about the toxicological significance of "high-profile" chemicals (and potent inducers) such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and organochlorines. MFO enzyme induction can also be an economical tool for environmental managers for reacting to real or perceived concerns about pollution such as effects on commercial fish stocks at sites of petroleum hydrocarbon development in the oceans.     

Interaction of far- and near-ultraviolet radiation. The occurrence of photo-augmentation and photo-recovery in cultured mammalian cells

Guided by the phenomena of photo-augmentation and photo-recovery, which have been described with respect to the induction of erythema in human skin, experiments were undertaken with cultured mammalian cells to study whether irradiation with far- and near-ultraviolet radiation results in an interaction at the cellular level with respect to cell survival and induction of mutations. Evidence was found for both photo-augmentation and photo-recovery. Photo-augmentation (more than an additive effect) was observed for cell survival when the long-wave ultraviolet irradiation (UVA) preceded the short-wave ultraviolet irradiation (UVB). Photo-recovery (less than an additive effect) was observed for cell survival if the UVA was given after or simultaneously with the UVB. The latter effect, however, was strongly influenced by dose: doses of UVA higher than 20 000 J/m2 no longer lead to photo-recovery in cell survival. For mutation induction, reduction in mutant frequency appears indicated for both combinations of UVA and UVB and for high and low doses of UVA.     

Factors contributing to chromosome damage in lymphocytes of cigarette smokers

Cigarette smoking is generally believed to be responsible for a substantial number of human health problems. However, the causal relationship between smoking, the induction of biological effects and the extent of health problems among smokers have not been fully documented. Using the recently developed lymphocyte micronucleus (MN) assay, we have evaluated the chromosome aberration frequencies in 67 cigarette smokers and 59 matched non-smoking control subjects. We found that the mean MN frequency (per 100 cells) in the smokers was slightly higher than that found in the non-smokers (0.71 +/- 0.23 and 0.58 +/- 0.05 respectively; p less than 0.08). Factors which contribute to the expression of chromosome aberrations were also investigated. A significant age-dependent increase in MN frequencies was observed in both groups (p less than 0.05). Linear regression analysis showed that the age-dependent effects among smokers (r = 0.54; p less than 0.02) was further enhanced by cigarette consumption (r = 0.62; p less than 0.005). Consumption of low potency 'one-a-day' type multivitamins had no effect on MN frequencies in either sex of non-smokers and in the 1 male smoker who took multivitamins but vitamin intake consistently reduced the MN frequencies among female smokers. Using a challenge assay, fidelity of DNA repair was evaluated. Lymphocytes from both smokers and non-smokers were irradiated with single doses of 0 or 100 cGy of X-rays or with double doses of 100 cGy of X-rays each separated by 15 or 60 min (100/15 or 100/60). Chromosome translocation frequencies were consistently higher after irradiation in lymphocytes from smokers than in those from non-smokers. Statistically significant differences were detected when the cells were irradiated with the double doses of 100 cGy X-rays each separated by 60 min (p less than 0.05). These data suggest that lymphocytes from smokers made more mistakes in the repair of DNA damage than cells from non-smokers. Our studies provide new insights into the genotoxic effects of cigarette smoke and new information which may be useful for understanding the mechanisms for induction of health problems from smoking.     

Radiation-induced mitotic and meiotic aneuploidy in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A number of genetic systems are described which in yeast may be used to monitor the induction of chromosome aneuploidy during both mitotic and meiotic cell division. Using these systems we have been able to demonstrate the induction of both monosomic and trisomic cells in mitotically dividing cells and disomic spores in meiotically dividing cells after both UV light and X-ray exposure. The frequency of UV-light-induced monosomic colonies were reduced by post-treatment with photoreactivity light and both UV-light- and X-ray-induced monosomic colonies were reduced by liquid holding post-treatment under non-nutrient conditions. Both responses indicate an involvement of DNA-repair mechanisms in the removal of lesions which may lead to monosomy in yeast. This was further confirmed by the response of an excision-defective yeast strain which showed considerably increased sensitivity to the induction of monosomic colonies by UV-light treatment at low doses. Yeast cultures irradiated at different stages of growth showed variation in their responses to both UV-light and X-rays, cells at the exponential phase of growth show maximum sensitivity to the induction of monosomic colonies at low doses whereas stationary phase cultures showed maximum induction of monosomic colonies at high does. The frequencies of X-ray-induced chromosome aneuploidy during meiosis leading to the production of disomic spores was shown to be dependent upon the stage of meiosis at which the yeast cells were exposed to radiation. Cells which had proceeded beyond the DNA synthetic stage of meiosis were shown to produce disomic spores at considerably lower radiation doses than those cells which had only recently been inoculated into sporulation medium. The results obtained suggest that the yeast sustem may be suitable for the study of sensitivities of the various stages of meiotic cell division to the induction of chromosome aneuploidy after radiation exposure.     

Significance and mechanisms of cellular regulation of the immune response

The conditions known to favor the induction of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), IgM and IgG antibody production, can be accounted for on the postulate that their precursors require the formation of different numbers of inductive complexes between their receptors, antigen, and the antigen-specific factor derived from helper T cells. The postulate that DTH precursors require the least, IgM B cells an intermediate number, and IgG precursors the most, accounts for the following facts: i) antigens with few foreign sites, for which there are relatively few helper T cell clones, induce only DTH; ii) medium doses of antigens that bear many foreign sites induce a humoral response; whereas iii) low doses that do not result in efficient collaboration induce DTH; and iv) high doses that partially block collaboration also lead to the induction of DTH. Furthermore, the conditions under which unresponsiveness can be induced at the humoral level in immunological competent animals are just those that give rise to the induction of DTH; the induction of a humoral response is also known to result in unresponsiveness at the DTH level. Therefore it seems very likely that these unresponsive states reflect the cellular regulation responsible for the exclusiveness between the induction of DTH and humoral immunity observed in the whole animal. Theoretically, this exclusiveness is due to the action of regulatory T cells. The biological significance of the way in which the induction of different classes is regulated is discussed. Experimental evidence is described that tests the following predictions: i) the class of response induced is due to the action of suppressor and repressor T cells, and ii) it is the number of inductive complexes formed that determines the class of response induced; DTH precursors require the least number and IgG precursors the most.     

Chronic morphine treatment induces oxidant and apoptotic damage in the mice liver

Recently many researchers have proposed a protective role for morphine against tumor growth and metastasis, especially through induction of apoptosis in tumoral cells. These findings may lead to underestimation of cytotoxic effects of opioid drugs which are usually expected only at high doses. The present study was conducted to clarify whether repeated morphine administration, which is commonly used for relief from chronic pain, would interfere with liver antioxidant defence and hepatocytes vitality. Morphine was injected repeatedly at doses that have been reported to relieve cancer pain and reduce tumor spread in mice (5 and 10 mg/kg/day for nine consecutive days). The changes in hepatic glutathione concentration, its synthesis pathway and enzymatic antioxidant defense revealed the pro-oxidant effects of chronic morphine treatment on the liver. None of these changes were observed in those mice that were co-treated with naltrexone (opioid antagonist) and same doses of morphine. However induction of liver conjugating enzymes following morphine treatment was not receptor mediated. Moreover, chronic morphine treatment induced hepatocytes apoptosis. Interestingly, the apoptotic changes were antagonized by co-administration of either naltrexone or thiol antioxidant. In conclusion, although hepatotoxic effects of morphine at high doses have been reported previously, our findings propose that repeated morphine administration even at lower doses would induce oxidative stress in the liver, which may contribute to induction of apoptosis in hepatocytes. Since many of the observed adverse effects were mediated by opioid receptors, our results suggest that other opioid analgesics should also be used more cautiously.     

A New Model of Biodosimetry to Integrate Low and High Doses

Biological dosimetry, that is the estimation of the dose of an exposure to ionizing radiation by a biological parameter, is a very important tool in cases of radiation accidents. The score of dicentric chromosomes, considered to be the most accurate method for biological dosimetry, for low LET radiation and up to 5 Gy, fits very well to a linear-quadratic model of dose-effect curve assuming the Poisson distribution. The accuracy of this estimation raises difficulties for doses over 5 Gy, the highest dose of the majority of dose-effect curves used in biological dosimetry. At doses over 5 Gy most cells show difficulties in reaching mitosis and cannot be used to score dicentric chromosomes. In the present study with the treatment of lymphocyte cultures with caffeine and the standardization of the culture time, metaphases for doses up to 25 Gy have been analyzed. Here we present a new model for biological dosimetry, which includes a Gompertz-type function as the dose response, and also takes into account the underdispersion of aberration-among-cell distribution. The new model allows the estimation of doses of exposures to ionizing radiation of up to 25 Gy. Moreover, the model is more effective in estimating whole and partial body exposures than the classical method based on linear and linear-quadratic functions, suggesting their effectiveness and great potential to be used after high dose exposures of radiation.