Endogenous ethylene production is a potential problem in the measurement of nitrogenase activity associated with excised corn and sorghum roots

Endogenous ethylene production was evaluated as a source of ethylene during acetylene reduction assays with freshly collected roots of field-grown corn, Zea mays L. cv Funks G-4646, and sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench. cv CK-60A. Ethylene production was not detected when roots were incubated in air without acetylene. The presence of endogenous ethylene production was confirmed when roots were incubated anaerobically and in the presence of 40 millimolar sodium hydrosulfite. Ethylene oxidase activity was also associated with excised roots. The rate of ethylene oxidation was higher than the rates of ethylene accumulation during either acetylene reduction assays or anaerobic incubations. These results indicate that the procedure of incubating roots of grasses in air to monitor endogenous ethylene production is not a valid control in acetylene reduction studies with grasses. The presence of endogenous ethylene production during acetylene reduction assays was demonstrated by using either CO to inhibit nitrogenase activity or chloramphenicol to inhibit nitrogenase synthesis in freshly excised roots.     

Nitrogenase Activity Associated with Roots and Stems of Field-Grown Corn (Zea mays L.) Plants

Corn (Zea mays L.) plants were assayed for nitrogenase activity (C₂H₂ reduction) during early ear development. Hybrid corn and inbred lines were grown separately at two experimental fields in New Jersey. Acetylene-dependent ethylene production was observed a few hours after harvest, from the field, on intact plants, root-soil cores, lower stem segments, and excised roots, all assayed under air and not preincubated previously. Incubation of excised roots at 1% O₂ resulted in lower rates of C₂H₂ reduction. The time course of C₂H₂ reduction by excised roots, assayed in air, was similar for all genotypes studied (two hybrids, eight inbreds, and a cross of corn × teosinte) and indicated that a long preincubation at reduced O₂ is not absolutely required for early detection of nitrogenase activity. Isolation of N₂-fixing bacteria from within the roots and stems, together with the diurnal fluctuation of nitrogenase activity in response to day/night cycles, were indicative of a close association with plant function. Collectively, the results provided strong evidence for the occurrence of nitrogenase activity associated with corn plants growing in a temperate climate and dependent upon indigenous N₂-fixing bacteria.     

Endorhizal and Exorhizal Acetylene-reducing Activity in a Grass (Spartina alterniflora Loisel.)-Diazotroph Association

Earlier studies indicated that bacteria responsible for nitrogenase activity of some grasses are located inside the roots. Those studies were conducted with excised roots in which a long, unexplained “lag phase” occurred before initiation of nitrogenase activity. When hydroponically maintained Spartina alterniflora Loisel. was incubated in a two-compartment system with acetylene, ethylene was produced following, at most, a 2-hour lag in both the upper (shoot) and lower (roots + water) phases. Ethylene production in the upper phase not attributable to leaf-associated acetylene-reducing activity or to diffusion of ethylene from around the roots is considered to represent “endorhizal acetylene-reducing activity,” the internally produced ethylene diffusing into the upper phase via the lacunae. Ethylene produced in the lower phase is designated “exorhizal acetylene-reducing activity.” The endorhizal acetylene-reducing activity, in comparison to exorhizal activity, was relatively insensitive to additions of HgCl₂, NH₄Cl, or carbon sources to the lower phase. Post-lag acetylene-reducing activity of roots excised from plants growing in soil responded to additions in a manner similar to that of endorhizal acetylene-reducing activity, whereas post-lag acetylene-reducing activity of rhizosphere soil responded in a manner similar to that of exorhizal acetylene-reducing activity.     

Ontogenetic Variation of Nitrogenase, Nitrate Reductase, and Glutamine Synthetase Activities in Oryza sativa

The relationship between the rates of nitrogenase, nitrate reductase, and glutamine synthetase activities, and plant ontogeny in rice (Oryza sativa L.), cultivar `M9', grown in salt marsh sediment with and without nitrate treatment was studied. In both treatments, nitrogenase activity measured as the immediate linear rate of acetylene reduction by bacteria associated with the roots varied with plant age. In control plants, the nitrogenase activity developed during the vegetative stage, peaked during early reproductive growth and then declined. The application of 10 kilograms N per hectare as KNO₃ once every 2 weeks delayed the development of and decreased the nitrogenase activity. The nitrogenase activity in both treatments developed as leaf nitrate reductase activity declined. The per cent nitrogen of roots was negatively correlated with the rates of acetylene reduction during the life cycles of control and nitrate-treated plants. This suggests that the concentration of combined nitrogen in the plants controlled the development and rate of root-associated nitrogenase activity. During reproductive growth, no nitrate reductase activity was detected in the roots from either treatment. In control plants, the patterns of nitrogenase activity and glutamine synthetase activity in the roots were similar. Thus, rice roots have the potential to assimilate ammonia while fixing N₂. During the vegetative and early reproductive stages of growth, the development of maximal rates of nitrogenase activity coincided with an increase of total nitrogen of the plants in both treatments.     

Further Errors in the Acetylene Reduction Assay: Effects of Plant Disturbance

A flow-through gas system was used to study the effects of disturbanceon nitrogenase (acetylene reduction) activity of nodulated rootsystems of soyabean (Glycine max) and white clover (Trifoliumrepens). Detopping plus removal of the rooting medium (by shaking)produced a substantial decrease in maximum nitrogenase activity.This response is due to a reduction in oxygen flux to the bacteroidscaused by an increase in the oxygen diffusion resistance ofthe nodule. The decrease in maximum nitrogenase activity wasmuch smaller for roots subjected to detopping only. Thus, theeffect of root shaking is more important than that of shootremoval. The effect of detopping plus root shaking on nitrogenase activityoccurred whether the plants were equilibrated and assayed at25°C or 15°C. However, the effect of disturbance onthe oxygen diffusion resistance of the nodules, and thus onnitrogenase activity, was greater at the higher temperature.At the lower temperature the oxygen diffusion resistance ofthe nodules had already been increased in response to the reducedrequirement for oxygen. These nodules were less susceptibleto the effects of disturbance. Thus, comparisons of the effectsof equilibration temperature on nitrogenase activity produceddifferent results depending on whether intact or disturbed systemswere used. With intact systems activity was lower at the lowertemperature but with detopped/shaken roots the lowest activityoccurred at the higher temperature. It is concluded that the use of detopped/shaken roots can producesubstantial errors in the acetylene reduction assay, which makesthe assay invalid even when used for comparative purposes. However,comparisons with rates of ¹⁵N₂ fixation and H₂ production showthat accurate measurements of nitrogenase activity can be obtainedfrom maximum rates of acetylene reduction by intact plants ina flow-through gas system. The continued use of assay proceduresin which cumulated ethylene production from disturbed systemsis measured in closed vessels must be questioned. Key words: Nodules, acetylene, nitrogenase activity     

Physiology of Root-Associated Nitrogenase Activity in Oryza sativa

An intact method for measuring immediately linear rates of acetylene reduction was used to investigate the relationship between temperature, pH, O₂ concentration, and light intensity with the rate of root-associated nitrogenase activity in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Nitrogenase activity varied over a temperature range of 10 to 50°C and optimal rates of acetylene reduction were recorded at 35°C. Nitrogenase activity was also influenced by the pH of the liquid surrounding the roots prior to assay. Maximal rates of acetylene reduction were recorded over a pH range from 5.8 to 7.5. Nitrogenase activity was significantly reduced by concentrations of O₂ 0.5% (v/v) or more when the intact plant assay method was used, and no optimum was detected. However, when the plant tops were removed and the cut ends sealed from the atmosphere for 4 hours, acetylene reduction rates were maximal at 0.25% O₂ (v/v). When plants were moved from sunlight (1,400 microeinsteins per square meter per second) to shade (9.6) root-associated nitrogenase activity at 35° C significantly decreased 15 min later to one-fourth the rate and recovered upon return to sunlight. When the light intensity reaching the leaf canopy was progressively reduced from 1,050 to 54 microeinsteins per square meter per second the rate of root-associated nitrogenase activity decreased from 550 ± 135 to 192 ± 55 nanomoles ethylene per gram dry root per hour. The study suggests that the rate of root-associated nitrogenase activity in rice at constant temperature may well be mediated by variations in the concentration of O₂ resulting from changes in the rate of photosynthesis as well as variations in the rate of transport of photosynthate.     

Comparing Time Course Profiles of Immediate Acetylene Reduction by Grasses and Legumes

The time course profiles of C₂H₂ reduction by intact Scirpus olneyi (bulrush), Oryza sativa (rice) and Spartina alterniflora (cordgrass) with roots in atmospheres of N₂ and 30-day-old Glycine max (soybean) in air were all immediately linear. This is the first report of immediately linear rates of C₂H₂ reduction by grass roots removed from soil. The immediately linear profile of C₂H₂ reduction by soil-free grass roots was achieved by preventing contact between the roots and air. Roots of soybeans and S. olneyi receiving pretreatments of O₂ above normal environmental levels for 15 min before assay exhibited a short delay in C₂H₂ reduction. These initially nonlinear rates of C₂H₂ reduction are attributable to transient O₂ inhibition of nitrogenase. Initial nonlinear rates of C₂H₂ reduction were also observed with immature soybean plants and with intact plant assays of O. sativa and S. olneyi in which C₂H₂ was injected into cylinders surrounding the plant tops. These results indicate that, apart from O₂ inhibition of nitrogenase, the diffusion of C₂H₂ and C₂H₄ between the nitrogen-fixing sites and the sampling ports may cause initial nonlinear rates of C₂H₂ reduction. We conclude that in situ plant-associated nitrogenase activity should result in immediate reduction of C₂H₂ and that linear rates are observed when the proper assay conditions are used. Our data suggest that nitrogen fixation is closely associated with the roots of S. olneyi, O. sativa, and S. alterniflora growing in salt marsh sediment.     

Effect of soil temperature on nitrogen fixation on roots of rice and reed

Summary The relation of nitrogenase activity (ethylene evolution) to soil temperature or incubation temperature of roots was determined on two genera of swamp plants, namely rice (Oryza sativa) cultivated in tropical climate and reed (Phragmites communis) grown in temperate regions. For both intact rice plants and excised rice roots the optimum temperature was 35°C. On excised roots nitrogenase activity responded more sensitivity to changes in temperature. In contrast to intact rice plants no ethylene evolution occurred on excised roots at 17 and 44°C. On reed roots temperature optimum was between 26 and 30°C which is clearly lower than on rice (35°C). The temperature range in which nitrogen fixation occurred was, however, similar to that of rice, although on a lower level. The results suggest a higher potential of the tropics for associative N₂ fixation, while in cooler climates the lower temperatures appear to be a major limiting factor.     

Effect of temperature on h(2) evolution and acetylene reduction in pea nodules and in isolated bacteroids

Nitrogenase (EC 1.7.99.2) activity in pea (Pisum savitum) nodules formed after infection with Rhizobium leguminosarum (lacking uptake hydrogenase) was measured as acetylene reduction, H₂ evolution in air and H₂ evolution in Ar:O₂. With detached roots the relative efficiency, calculated from acetylene reduction, showed a decrease (from 55 to below 0%) with increasing temperature. With excised nodules and isolated bacteroids similar results were obtained. However, the relative efficiency calculated from H₂ evolution in Ar:O₂ was unaffected by temperature. Measurements on both excised nodules and isolated bacteroids showed a marked difference between acetylene reduction and H₂ evolution in Ar:O₂ with increased temperature, indicating that either acetylene reduction or H₂ evolution in Ar:O₂ are inadequate measures of nitrogenase activity at higher temperature.     

Nitrogenase activity in the rhizosphere of sugar cane and some other tropical grasses

Summary Roots of sugar cane had considerable nitrogenase activity and produced up to 5 n moles ethylene/h/g root by the reduction of acetylene. The rhizosphere soil and soil mid-way between the cane rows also reduced acetylene.Beijerinckia indica was abundant on roots and in the soil. Nitrogenase activity was also associated with roots ofPanicum maximum,Pennisetum purpureum andCymbopogon citratus.     

Enumeration and Localization of N2-Fixing Bacteria Associated with Roots of Spartina alterniflora Loisel

Numbers and possible locations of N₂-fixing bacteria were investigated in roots of Spartina alterniflora Loisel, which support nitrogenase activity in the undisturbed native habitat. N₂-fixing bacteria were recovered in cultures both from S. alterniflora roots and from the surrounding sediment, and they formed a greater proportion of the bacteria recovered from root homogenates than from salt-marsh sediment. N₂-fixing bacteria were recovered in high numbers from the rhizoplane of S. alterniflora after roots were treated with 1 or 5% chloramine-T for 1 h or with 1% NaOCl for 1 or 2 h. Immersing S. alterniflora roots in 5% NaOCl for 1 h was more effective in distinguishing bacteria inside the roots since this treatment nearly eliminated N₂-fixing bacteria recoverable from the rhizoplane, although high numbers of N₂-fixing bacteria were recovered from homogenates of roots treated with 5% NaOCl for 1 h. However, this treatment was less effective with roots of Zea mays L. (Funks G4646) and Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench (CK-60 A), indicating that techniques to surface sterilize roots should be evaluated for different plants. Bacteria were observed by light and electron microscopy inter- and intracellularly in the cortex and in the aerenchyma of S. alterniflora roots. This study clearly shows that bacteria, including N₂ fixers, colonize the interior of roots of S. alterniflora growing in a Chesapeake Bay, Maryland, salt marsh.     

Biological dinitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) associated with Florida mangroves

Biological dinitrogen fixation in mangrove communities of the Tampa Bay region of South Florida was investigated using the acetylene reduction technique. Low rates of acetylene reduction (0.01 to 1.84 nmol of C(2)H(4)/g [wet weight] per h) were associated with plant-free sediments, while plant-associated sediments gave rise to slightly higher rates. Activity in sediments increased greatly upon the addition of various carbon sources, indicating an energy limitation for nitrogenase (C(2)H(2)) activity. In situ determinations of dinitrogen fixation in sediments also indicated low rates and exhibited a similar response to glucose amendment. Litter from the green macroalga, Ulva spp., mangrove leaves, and sea grass also gave rise to significant rates of acetylene reduction.Higher rates of nitrogenase activity (15 to 53 nmol of C(2)H(4)/g [wet weight] per h were associated with washed excised roots of three Florida mangrove species [Rhizophora mangle L., Avicennia germinans (L) Stern, and Laguncularia racemosa Gaertn.] as well as with isolated root systems of intact plants (11 to 58 mug of N/g [dry weight] per h). Following a short lag period, root-associated activity was linear and did not exhibit a marked response to glucose amendment. It appears that dinitrogen-fixing bacteria in the mangrove rhizoplane are able to use root exudates and/or sloughed cell debris as energy sources for dinitrogen fixation.     

Relative Efficacy of Different Alfalfa Cultivar-Rhizobium meliloti Strain Combinations for Symbiotic Nitrogen Fixation

Five Rhizobium meliloti isolates known to have different capabilities for expression of nitrogenase activity under symbiotic conditions were used to inoculate four representative Medicago sativa cultivars under aseptic conditions. Nitrogenase activities and respiratory activity were measured for whole plants and excised nodules. Dry weights and nodule numbers were also recorded after 4 weeks of growth in plastic pouches on a nitrogen-free nutrient medium. Hydrogen evolution and acetylene reduction rates were used to calculate the fraction of reducing power allocated to dinitrogen reduction. Although the efficiency of the system defined in this way was poorly correlated with plant yield, a very high linear correlation was obtained between yield and the algebraic product of nitrogenase activity and efficiency. High correlation (r > 0.78) was obtained between respiration and nitrogenase activity for whole plants as well as for excised nodules. Nodular respiration accounted for between 10 and 20% of the total plant dark respiration. The four test cultivars exhibited significantly different symbiotic responses to the inocula, although trends in potential for expression of the nitrogenase system by the five R. meliloti strains were evident. There was significant interaction between the host plant and symbiont in determining nitrogenase activity and yield. This screening method allows quantitative discrimination between effective and ineffective host-inoculum combinations.     

Growth and nitrogen fixation inAlnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn. under carbon dioxide enrichment of the root atmosphere

The effects of aeration of the N-free rooting medium with elevated CO₂ on (a) acetylene reduction by perlite-grown plants and (b) N₂-fixation and long-term growth of nutrient solution-grown plants were determined for nodulatedAlnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn. In the former experiments, roots of intact plants were incubated in acetylene in air in darkened glass jars for 3 hr, followed by a further 3 hr incubation period in air enriched with CO₂ (0–5%). During incubation, the CO₂ content of the jars increased by 0.17% per hour due to respiration of the root system, so that the CO₂ content at 3 hr was 0.5%. Additional enrichment of the rooting medium gas-phase with CO₂ equivalent to 1.1% and 1.75% CO₂ of the gas volume significantly increased nitrogenase activity (ethylene production) by 55% and 50% respectively, while enrichment with greater than 2.5% CO₂ decreased activity. In contrast, ethylene production by control plants, where CO₂ was not added to the assay jars, decreased by 8% over the assay period. In long-term growth experiments, nodulated roots of intactAlnus glutinosa plants were sealed into jars containing N-free nutrient solution (pH 6.3) and aerated with air, or air containing elevated levels of CO₂ (1.5% and 5%). Comparison of the appearance of CO₂-treated with air treated plants suggested that 1.5% CO₂ stimulated plant growth. However, at harvest after 5 or 6 weeks variability between plants masked the significance of differences in plant dry weight. A significant increase of 33% in total nitrogen of plants aerated with 1.5% CO₂, compared with air-treated plants, was demonstrated, broadly in line with the short-term increase in acetylene reducing activity observed following incubations with similar CO₂ concentrations. Shoot dry weight was not affected significantly by long-term exposure to 5% CO₂, the main effect on growth being a 20% reduction in dry weight of the root system, possibly through inhibition of root system respiration. However, in contrast to the inhibitory effects of high CO₂ on acetylene reduction there was no significant effect on the amounts of N₂ fixed.     

Role of nitrogen assimilation in seed development of soybean

A nondestructive acetylene reduction assay for nitrogenase activity of soybean (Glycine max L. Merr) field plots is presented. Plots consisted of 120 × 150 × 30 centimeter boxes containing 65 plants. The plants were grown in a medium grade sand under controlled nutrient, moisture, and root temperature conditions. Acetylene at a concentration of 10 milliliters per liter was circulated through manifolds in the chambers; equilibration required 5 minutes, and activity was linear with time. Optimum growth and assay environments resulted in activity of 70 micromoles ethylene per plant per hour. Plant development and yield were comparable to soil-grown companion plots.

The well accepted hypothesis that developing seeds deprive the nodules of carbohydrate was not substantiated. The nondestructive acetylene reduction profile did not decline until 30 days after the onset of seed development (R-5). This result was consistent with reports from the literature which indicated that 60% of seasonal nitrogen was fixed after R-5. Further, a high correlation shown between integrated seasonal acetylene reduction and yield (r = 0.999) suggested a cooperative relationship between the roots and shoot. A reduction in source:sink ratio (60% defoliation) after R-5 had no effect on acetylene reduction. This showed that neither an increase in sink demand by the pods nor a carbon shortage during podfill decreased dinitrogen fixation. A conceptual model relating seed growth with carbon and nitrogen assimilation is proposed.

     

Nitrogenase Activity Associated with Halodule wrightii Roots

Nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) associated with roots of the seagrass Halodule wrightii was measured offshore near Beaufort and Moorhead City, N.C. Rates of acetylene reduction were higher in aerobic than in anaerobic assays and were linear for up to 5 days. The temperature range for acetylene reduction was 15 to 35°C with a maximum activity at 35°C. Nitrogenase activity was shown to vary seasonally with highest activities occurring during warmer summer months (23 μg of N₂ fixed per m² per day). At in situ temperature, nitrogenase activities associated with surface-sterilized and non-surface-sterilized roots were similar. One morphological bacterial type was isolated from surface-sterilized roots and identified as Klebsiella pneumoniae type 4B.     

Nitrogen Fixation Associated with Rinsed Roots and Rhizomes of the Eelgrass Zostera marina

Nitrogen fixation was associated with the rinsed roots and rhizomes of the seagrass, Zostera marina L. Nitrogenase activity (acetylene reduction) was greater on rhizomes compared to roots, and on older roots and rhizomes relative to younger tissue. Compared to aerobic assays, anaerobic or microaerobic conditions enhanced the rate of acetylene reduction by rhizomes with attached roots, with the highest activity (100 nanomoles per gram dry weight per hour) occurring at pO₂ = 0.01 atmosphere. Addition of glucose, sucrose, or succinate also increased the rate of acetylene reduction under anaerobic conditions, with glucose providing the most stimulation. In one experiment, comparison of acetylene reduction assays with ¹⁵N₂ incorporation yielded a ratio of about 2.6:1. Seagrass communities are thought to be limited by the availability of nitrogen and, therefore, nitrogenase activity directly associated with their roots and rhizomes suggests the possibility of a N₂-fixing flora which may subsidize their nutritional demand for nitrogen.     

The Relationship between H(2) Evolution and Acetylene Reduction in Pisum sativum-Rhizobium leguminosarum Symbioses Differing in Uptake Hydrogenase Activity

Peas (Pisum sativum L.) were inoculated with strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum having different levels of uptake hydrogenase (Hup) activity and were grown in sterile Leonard jars under controlled conditions. Rates of H₂ evolution and acetylene reduction were determined for intact nodulated roots at intervals after the onset of darkness or after removal of the shoots. Hup activity was estimated using treatment plants or equivalent plants from the growth chamber, by measuring the uptake of H₂ or ³H₂ in the presence of acetylene. In all cases, the rate of H₂ evolution was a continuous function of the rate of acetylene reduction. In symbioses with no demonstrable Hup activity, H₂ evolution increased in direct proportion to acetylene reduction and the slopes were similar with the Hup⁻ strains NA502 and 128C79. Hup activity was similar in strains 128C30 and 128C52 but significantly lower in strain 128C54. With these strains, the slopes of the H₂ evolution versus acetylene reduction curves initially increased with acetylene reduction, but became constant and similar to those for the Hup⁻ strains at high rates of acetylene reduction. On these parallel portions of the curves, the decreases in H₂ evolution by Hup⁺ strains were similar in magnitude to their H₂-saturated rates of Hup activity. The curvilinear relationship between H₂ evolution and acetylene reduction for a representative Hup⁺ strain (128C52) was the same, regardless of the experimental conditions used to vary the nitrogenase activity.     

Effect of supra-ambient oxygen on nitrogenase activity (c(2)h(2)) and root respiration of soybeans and isolated soybean bacteroids

Isolated soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr. cv Wilkin) bacteroids have O₂-dependent nitrogenase activity which is strongly inhibited by supraoptimal O₂ concentrations. Oxygen-inhibited nitrogenase activity is recovered by addition of 10 millimolar sodium succinate or by lowering the O₂ concentration.

Brief treatment of roots of intact soybean plants with 1.0 atmosphere O₂ reduces nitrogenase activity (C₂H₂). There is a rapid partial recovery of activity within 2 to 3 hours, and a slower return to near normal levels by 36 hours. The drop and recovery of nitrogenase activity is accompanied by a parallel drop and increase in root respiration. There is a direct relationship between the change in respiration and the change in acetylene reduction following O₂ treatment. The O₂-mediated changes in nitrogenase activity and root respiration are not affected by the planting medium. The ratio of the change in respiration to the change in nitrogenase activity was the same in 13 soybean cultivars.

     

Consequences of Sporangial Development for Nodule Function in Root Nodules of Comptonia peregrina and Myrica gale

Frankia sp., the actinomycetous endophyte in nitrogen-fixing actinorhizal nodules, may differentiate two forms from its hyphae: vesicles and sporangia. In root nodules of Comptonia peregrina (L.) Coult. and Myrica gale L., sporangia may be either absent or present. Nitrogenase activity and symbiotic efficiency were contrasted in spore(+) and spore(−) nodules of these two host genera. Seedlings of C. peregrina nodulated with the spore(+) inoculum showed only 60% of the nitrogenase activity and 50% of the net size of their spore(−) counterparts after 12 weeks of culture. Measurements of acetylene reduction (i.e., nitrogenase activity) were coordinated with samplings of nodules for structural studies. Significant differences in acetylene reduction rates were discernible between spore(+) and spore(−) nodules commencing 4 weeks after nodulation, concomitant with the maturation of sporangia in the nodule. Spore(+) nodules ultimately reached less than half of the rate of nitrogenase activity of spore(−) nodules. Both types of nodules evolved only small amounts of molecular hydrogen, suggesting that both were equally efficient in recycling electrons lost to the reduction of hydrogen ions by nitrogenase. Respiratory cost of nitrogen fixation, expressed as the quotient of micromole CO₂ to micromole ethylene evolved by excised nodules, was significantly greater in spore(+) than in spore(−) nodules. M. gale spore(−) nodules showed variable effectivity, though all had low CO₂ to ethylene evolution ratios. M. gale spore(+) nodules resembled C. peregrina spore(+), with low effectivity and high respiratory cost for nitrogen fixation.