Restricted movement of lipid and aqueous dyes through pores formed by influenza hemagglutinin during cell fusion

The fusion of cells by influenza hemagglutinin (HA) is the best characterized example of protein-mediated membrane fusion. In simultaneous measurements of pairs of assays for fusion, we determined the order of detectable events during fusion. Fusion pore formation in HA-triggered cell-cell fusion was first detected by changes in cell membrane capacitance, next by a flux of fluorescent lipid, and finally by flux of aqueous fluorescent dye. Fusion pore conductance increased by small steps. A retardation of lipid and aqueous dyes occurred during fusion pore fluctuations. The flux of aqueous dye depended on the size of the molecule. The lack of movement of aqueous dyes while total fusion pore conductance increased suggests that initial HA-triggered fusion events are characterized by the opening of multiple small pores: the formation of a "sieve".     

Hemagglutinin-induced fusion of HAb2 and PLC cells: dynamics of fusion pore conductance

Infection of cells with influenza virus is mediated by the virus envelope protein hemagglutinin (HA) which induces fusion of viral and target membranes. Earlier we showed using fluorescent microscopy that HAb2 cells expressing HA on their plasma membranes fused with PLC cells when pH of the external medium was decreased to -5. In the present work we used double whole-cell recording to monitor the intercellular conductance in HAb2/PLC cell pairs during fusion. In approximately 40% of cell pairs the pH drop induced the intercellular conductance, which we interpret as the formation of a fusion pore. The following stages of the conductance growth were distinguished: initial fluctuations near zero (flicker), a subsequent slow increase up to 1-4 nS and a final rapid increase up to 10-100 nS (complete fusion). The first detectable intercellular conductance change (opening of a fusion pore) was accompanied by an increase in the conductances of both HAb2 and PLC cell membrane. This observation suggests that the early pore complex should be leaky. The dynamics of the intercellular conductance appeared to depend upon the voltage difference between the fusing HAb2 and PLC cells: voltages higher than 40 mV facilitated the conductance growth.     

Patch clamp studies of single intact secretory granules.

The membrane of secretory granules is involved in the molecular events that cause exocytotic fusion. Several of the proteins that have been purified from the membrane of secretory granules form ion channels when they are reconstituted in lipid bilayers and, therefore, have been thought to form part of the molecular structure of the exocytotic fusion pore. We have used the patch clamp technique to study ion conductances in single isolated secretory granules from beige mouse mast cells. We found that the membrane of the intact granule had a conductance of < 50 pS. No abrupt changes in current corresponding to the opening and closing of ion channels were observed, even under conditions where exocytotic fusion occurred. However, mechanical tension or a large voltage pulse caused the breakdown of the granule membrane resulting in the abrupt opening of a pore with an ion conductance of about 1 nS that fluctuated rapidly and could expand to an immeasurably large conductance or close completely. Surprisingly, the behavior of these pores resembled the pattern of conductance changes of exocytotic fusion pores observed in degranulating beige mast cells. This similarity supports the view that the earliest fusion pore is formed upon the breakdown of a bilayer such as that formed during hemifusion.     

The initial fusion pore induced by baculovirus GP64 is large and forms quickly

The formation of the fusion pore is the first detectable event in membrane fusion (Zimmerberg, J., R. Blumenthal, D.P. Sarkar, M. Curran, and S.J. Morris. 1994. J. Cell Biol. 127:1885-1894). To date, fusion pores measured in exocytosis and viral fusion have shared features that include reversible closure (flickering), highly fluctuating semistable stages, and a lag time of at least several seconds between the triggering and the pore opening. We investigated baculovirus GP64- induced Sf9 cell-cell fusion, triggered by external acid solution, using two different electrophysiological techniques: double whole-cell recording (for high time resolution, model-independent measurements), and the more conventional time-resolved admittance recordings. Both methods gave essentially the same results, thus validating the use of the admittance measurements for fusion pore conductance calculations. Fusion was first detected by abrupt pore formation with a wide distribution of initial conductance, centered around 1 nS. Often the initial fusion pore conductance was stable for many seconds. Fluctuations in semistable conductances were much less than those of other fusion pores. The waiting time distribution, measured between pH onset and initial pore appearance, fits best to a model with many (approximately 19) independent elements. Thus, unlike previously measured fusion pores, GP64-mediated pores do not flicker, can have large, stable initial pore conductances lasting up to a minute, and have typical lag times of < 1 s. These findings are consistent with a barrel-shaped model of an initial fusion pore consisting of five to eight GP64 trimers that is lined with lipid.     

Membrane flux through the pore formed by a fusogenic viral envelope protein during cell fusion

We have investigated the mechanism of cell fusion mediated by HA, the fusogenic hemagglutinin of the Influenza viral envelope. Single erythrocytes (RBCs) were attached to fibroblasts expressing the HA on their cell surface, and fusion of the paired cells was triggered by rapid acidification. The RBC membrane was stained with fluorescent lipid, and the fusion-induced escape of lipid into the fibroblast was observed by quantitative image analysis. At the same time, the formation of an aqueous connection (i.e., the fusion pore) between the two cells was monitored electrically. Within minutes after acidification, an electrical conductance between the two cells appeared abruptly as the fusion pore opened, and then increased gradually as the pore dilated. Later, fluorescent lipid diffused into the fibroblast, approaching equilibrium over the next 5-20 min. No lipid flux was seen while the pore conductance remained 0.5 nS or less. Evidently lipid flux requires a threshold pore size. Our finding suggests that the smallest and earliest fusion pores are surrounded by a ring of protein. A fusion pore expands by breaking this ring and recruiting lipid into its circumference.     

Minimum Membrane Bending Energies of Fusion Pores

Membranes fuse by forming highly curved intermediates, culminating in structures described as fusion pores. These hourglass-like figures that join two fusing membranes have high bending energies, which can be estimated using continuum elasticity models. Fusion pore bending energies depend strongly on shape, and the present study developed a method for determining the shape that minimizes bending energy. This was first applied to a fusion pore modeled as a single surface and then extended to a more realistic model treating a bilayer as two monolayers. For the two-monolayer model, fusion pores were found to have metastable states with energy minima at particular values of the pore diameter and bilayer separation. Fusion pore energies were relatively insensitive to membrane thickness but highly sensitive to spontaneous curvature and membrane asymmetry. With symmetrical bilayers and monolayer spontaneous curvatures of ?0.1 nm^?1 (a typical value) separated by 6 nm (closest distance determined by repulsive hydration forces), fusion pore formation required 43–65 kT. The pore radius of ~2.25 nm fell within the range estimated from conductance measurements. With bilayer separation >6 nm, fusion pore formation required less energy, suggesting that protein scaffolds can promote fusion by bending membranes toward one another. With nonzero spontaneous monolayer curvature, the shape that minimized the energy change during fusion pore formation differed from the shape that minimized its energy after it formed. Thus, a nascent fusion pore will relax spontaneously to a new shape, consistent with the experimentally observed expansion of nascent fusion pores during viral fusion.     

Fusion pore conductance: experimental approaches and theoretical algorithms.

Time-resolved admittance measurements provide the basis for studies showing that membrane fusion occurs through the formation and widening of an initially small pore, linking two previously separated aqueous compartments. Here we introduce modifications to this method that correct the cell-pipette (source) admittance for attenuation and phase shifts produced by electrophysiological equipment. Two new approaches for setting the right phase angle are discussed. The first uses the displacement of a patch-clamp amplifier C-slow potentiometer for the calculation of phase. This calculation is based on amplitudes of observed and expected (theoretical) changes in the source admittance. The second approach automates the original phase adjustment, the validity of which we prove analytically for certain conditions. The multiple sine wave approach is modified to allow the calculation of target cell membrane parameters and the conductance of the fusion pore. We also show how this technique can be extended for measurements of the resting potential of the first (voltage-clamped) membrane. We introduce an algorithm for calculation of fusion pore conductance despite a concurrent change in the resistance of the clamped membrane. The sensitivity of the capacitance restoration algorithm to phase shift errors is analyzed, and experimental data are used to demonstrate the results of this analysis. Finally, we show how the phase offset can be corrected "off-line" by restoring the shape of the capacitance increment.     

Conductive properties and gating of channels formed by syringopeptin 25A, a bioactive lipodepsipeptide from Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae, in planar lipid membranes

Syringopeptin 25A, a pseudomonad lipodepsipeptide, can form ion channels in planar lipid membranes. Pore conductance is around 40 pS in 0.1 M NaCl. Channel opening is strongly voltage dependent and requires a negative potential on the same side of the membrane where the toxin was added. These pores open and close with a lifetime of several seconds. At negative voltages, an additional pore state of around 10 pS and a lifetime of around 30 ms is also present. The voltage dependence of the rates of opening and closing of the stable pores is exponential. This allows estimation of the equivalent charge that is moved across the membrane during the process of opening at about 2.6 elementary charges. When NaCl is present, the pore is roughly 3 times more permeant for anions than for cations. The current voltage characteristic of the pore is nonlinear, i.e., pore conductance is larger at negative than at positive voltages. The maximal conductance of the pore depends on the concentration of the salt present, in a way that varies almost linearly with the conductivity of the solution. From this, an estimate of a minimal pore radius of 0.4 nm was derived.     

Ion effects on gating of the Ca(2+)-activated K+ channel correlate with occupancy of the pore.

We studied the effects of permeant ions on the gating of the large conductance Ca(2+)-activated K+ channel from rat skeletal muscle. Rb+ blockade of inward K+ current caused an increase in the open probability as though Rb+ occupancy of the pore interferes with channel closing. In support of this hypothesis, we directly measured the occupancy of the pore by the impermeant ion Cs+ and found that it strongly correlates with its effect on gating. This is consistent with the "foot-in-the-door" model of gating, which states that channels cannot close with an ion in the pore. However, because Rb+ and Cs+ not only slow the closing rate (as predicted by the model), but also speed the opening rate, our results are more consistent with a modified version of the model in which the channel can indeed close while occupied, but the occupancy destabilizes the closed state. Increasing the occupancy of the pore by the addition of other permeant (K+ and Tl+) and impermeant (tetraethylammonium) ions did not affect the open probability. To account for this disparity, we used a two-site permeation model in which only one of the sites influenced gating. Occupancy of this "gating site" interferes with channel closing and hastens opening. Ions that directly or indirectly increase the occupancy of this site will increase the open probability.     

Dynamic regulation of the large exocytotic fusion pore in pancreatic acinar cells

Loss of granule content during exocytosis requires the opening of a fusion pore between the secretory granule and plasma membrane. In a variety of secretory cells, this fusion pore has now been shown to subsequently close. However, it is still unclear how pore closure is physiologically regulated and contentious as to how closure relates to granule content loss. Here, we examine the behavior of the fusion pore during zymogen granule exocytosis in pancreatic acinar cells. By using entry of high-molecular-weight dyes from the extracellular solution into the granule lumen, we show that the fusion pore has a diameter of 29-55 nm. We further show that by 5 min after granule fusion, many granules have a closed fusion pore with evidence indicating that pore closure is a prelude to endocytosis and that in granules with a closed fusion pore the chymotrypsinogen content is low. Finally, we show that latrunculin B treatment promotes pore closure, suggesting F-actin affects pore dynamics. Together, our data do not support the classical view in acinar cells that exocytosis ends with granule collapse. Instead, for many granules the fusion pore closes, probably as a transition to endocytosis, and likely involving an F-actin-dependent mechanism.     

Escherichia coli haemolysin forms voltage-dependent ion channels in lipid membranes

The action of the 107 kDa hemolysin from Escherichia coli on planar lipid membranes was investigated. We report that a single toxin molecule can form a cation-selective, ion-permeable channel of large conductance in a planar phospholipid bilayer membrane. The conductance of the pore is proportional to that of the bulk solution, indicating that the channel is filled with water. A pore diameter of about 2 nm can be evaluated. The pore formation mechanism is voltage-dependent and essentially resembles that of pore-forming colicins; this implies that opening of the channel is dependent on transfer of an electrical charge through the membrane. We propose that the physiological effects of E. coli hemolysin result from its ability to form ion channels in the membrane of attacked cells, and show that there is quantitative agreement between the effects of this toxin on model membranes and its hemolytic properties.     

Membrane permeability changes at early stages of influenza hemagglutinin-mediated fusion

While biological membrane fusion is classically defined as the leak-free merger of membranes and contents, leakage is a finding in both experimental and theoretical studies. The fusion stages, if any, that allow membrane permeation are uncharted. In this study we monitored membrane ionic permeability at early stages of fusion mediated by the fusogenic protein influenza hemagglutinin (HA). HAb2 cells, expressing HA on their plasma membrane, fused with human red blood cells, cultured liver cells PLC/PRF/5, or planar phospholipid bilayer membranes. With a probability that depended upon the target membrane, an increase of the electrical conductance of the fusing membranes (leakage) by up to several nS was generally detected. This leakage was recorded at the initial stages of fusion, when fusion pores formed. This leakage usually accompanied the "flickering" stage of the early fusion pore development. As the pore widened, the leakage reduced; concomitantly, the lipid exchange between the fusing membranes accelerated. We conclude that during fusion pore formation, HA locally and temporarily increases the permeability of fusing membranes. Subsequent rearrangement in the fusion complex leads to the resealing of the leaky membranes and enlargement of the pore.     

The wave of activation current in the egg of the medaka fish

An extracellular vibrating electrode was used to measure the ring-shaped wave of inward current, the activation current, that propagates at 10 micron/sec across the egg of the medaka fish, Oryzias latipes, from the site of sperm-egg fusion at the animal pole to the vegetal pole. This activation wave is due to a localized increase in the conductance to Na+, K+, and Ca2+ and reflects the propagated opening of these ion channels. The earliest detectable current begins to enter the animal pole 20 sec after the initiation of the fertilization potential, so the first ion movements responsible for the fertilization potential are below the resolution of the vibrating probe system. These channels are present in both the animal and vegetal hemispheres, but the magnitude of the activation current is about seven times greater in the animal hemisphere. An outward current of smaller magnitude and spread out over a larger area precedes and follows the inward current except at the point of fertilization where the current is first inward. The current direction is dependent on the external Na+ concentration, and in the more physiological solution of 10% NaCl-Yamamoto's Ringer's, its direction reverses to become outward, apparently carried by K+ efflux. Raising the external Ca2+ in this same low-Na+ medium reverses the current so that it becomes inward again and increases the propagation velocity of the wave, suggesting a Ca2+ component to the inward current. Current enters a given region on the egg's surface about 16 sec before any vesicle fusion occurs in that region. Iontophoresis of inositol-1,4,5,-trisphosphate immediately triggers egg activation with a minimum activating charge of 0.6 nC.     

Comparison of transient and successful fusion pores connecting influenza hemagglutinin expressing cells to planar membranes

Time-resolved admittance measurements were used to investigate the evolution of fusion pores formed between cells expressing influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) and planar bilayer membranes. The majority of fusion pores opened in a stepwise fashion to semistable conductance levels of several nS. About 20% of the pores had measurable rise times to nS conductances; some of these opened to conductances of approximately 500 pS where they briefly lingered before opening further to semistable conductances. The fall times of closing were statistically similar to the rise times of opening. All fusion pores exhibited semistable values of conductance, varying from approximately 2-20 nS; they would then either close or fully open to conductances on the order of 1 microS. The majority of pores closed; approximately 10% fully opened. Once within the semistable stage, all fusion pores, even those that eventually closed, tended to grow. Statistically, however, before closing, transient fusion pores ceased to grow and reversed their conductance pattern: conductances decreased with a measurable time course until a final drop to closure. In contrast, pore enlargement to the fully open state tended to occur from the largest conductance values attained during a pore's semistable stage. This final enlargement was characterized by a stepwise increase in conductance. The density of HA on the cell surface did not strongly affect pore dynamics. But increased proteolytic treatment of cell surfaces did lead to faster growth within the semistable range. Transient pores and pores that fully opened had indistinguishable initial conductances and statistically identical time courses of early growth, suggesting they were the same upon formation. We suggest that transient and fully open pores evolved from common structures with stochastic factors determining their fate.     

Cholesterol promotes hemifusion and pore widening in membrane fusion induced by influenza hemagglutinin

Cholesterol-specific interactions that affect membrane fusion were tested for using insect cells; cells that have naturally low cholesterol levels (< 4 mol %). Sf9 cells were engineered (HAS cells) to express the hemagglutinin (HA) of the influenza virus X-31 strain. Enrichment of HAS cells with cholesterol reduced the delay between triggering and lipid dye transfer between HAS cells and human red blood cells (RBC), indicating that cholesterol facilitates membrane lipid mixing prior to fusion pore opening. Increased cholesterol also increased aqueous content transfer between HAS cells and RBC over a broad range of HA expression levels, suggesting that cholesterol also favors fusion pore expansion. This interpretation was tested using both trans-cell dye diffusion and fusion pore conductivity measurements in cholesterol-enriched cells. The results of this study support the hypothesis that host cell cholesterol acts at two stages in membrane fusion: (1) early, prior to fusion pore opening, and (2) late, during fusion pore expansion.     

Transition from hemifusion to pore opening is rate limiting for vacuole membrane fusion

Fusion pore opening and expansion are considered the most energy-demanding steps in viral fusion. Whether this also applies to soluble N-ethyl-maleimide sensitive fusion protein attachment protein receptor (SNARE)- and Rab-dependent fusion events has been unknown. We have addressed the problem by characterizing the effects of lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) and other late-stage inhibitors on lipid mixing and pore opening during vacuole fusion. LPC inhibits fusion by inducing positive curvature in the bilayer and changing its biophysical properties. The LPC block reversibly prevented formation of the hemifusion intermediate that allows lipid, but not content, mixing. Transition from hemifusion to pore opening was sensitive to guanosine-5'-(gamma-thio)triphosphate. It required the vacuolar adenosine triphosphatase V0 sector and coincided with its transformation. Pore opening was rate limiting for the reaction. As with viral fusion, opening the fusion pore may be the most energy-demanding step for intracellular, SNARE-dependent fusion reactions, suggesting that fundamental aspects of lipid mixing and pore opening are related for both systems.     

Fusion Step-Specific Influence of Cholesterol on SNARE-Mediated Membrane Fusion

Cholesterol is a major component of biological membranes and is known to affect vesicle fusion. However, the mechanism by which cholesterol modulates SNARE-dependent intracellular fusion is not well understood. Using the fluorescence assay and dye-labeled SNAREs and the fluorescent lipids, we dissected cholesterol effects on individual fusion steps including SNARE complex formation, hemifusion, pore formation, and pore dilation. At physiological high concentrations, cholesterol stimulated hemifusion as much as 30-fold, but its stimulatory effect diminished to 10-fold and three-fold for subsequent pore formation and pore expansion at 40 mol %, respectively. The results show that cholesterol serves as a strong stimulator for hemifusion but acts as mild stimulators for pore opening and expansion. Strong stimulation of hemifusion and mild stimulation of pore formation are consistent with the fusion model based on the intrinsic negative curvature of cholesterol. However, even a milder effect of cholesterol on pore expansion is contradictory to such a simple curvature-based prediction. Thus, we speculate that cholesterol also affects the conformation of the transmembrane domains of SNAREs, which modulates the fusion kinetics.     

Steric hindrance of SNARE transmembrane domain organization impairs the hemifusion‐to‐fusion transition

SNAREs fuse membranes in several steps. Trans‐SNARE complexes juxtapose membranes, induce hemifused stalk structures, and open the fusion pore. A recent penetration model of fusion proposed that SNAREs force the hydrophilic C‐termini of their transmembrane domains through the hydrophobic core of the membrane(s). In contrast, the indentation model suggests that the C‐termini open the pore by locally compressing and deforming the stalk. Here we test these models in the context of yeast vacuole fusion. Addition of small hydrophilic tags renders bilayer penetration by the C‐termini energetically unlikely. It preserves fusion activity, however, arguing against the penetration model. Addition of large protein tags to the C‐termini permits SNARE activation, trans‐SNARE pairing, and hemifusion but abolishes pore opening. Fusion proceeds if the tags are detached from the membrane by a hydrophilic spacer or if only one side of the trans‐SNARE complex carries a protein tag. Thus, both sides of a trans‐SNARE complex can drive pore opening. Our results are consistent with an indentation model in which multiple SNARE C‐termini cooperate in opening the fusion pore by locally deforming the inner leaflets.     

Dynamin regulates the fusion pore of endo- and exocytotic vesicles as revealed by membrane capacitance measurements

BackgroundDynamin is a multidomain GTPase exhibiting mechanochemical and catalytic properties involved in vesicle scission from the plasmalemma during endocytosis. New evidence indicates that dynamin is also involved in exocytotic release of catecholamines, suggesting the existence of a dynamin-regulated structure that couples endo- to exocytosis.MethodsThus we here employed high-resolution cell-attached capacitance measurements and super-resolution structured illumination microscopy to directly examine single vesicle interactions with the plasmalemma in cultured rat astrocytes treated with distinct pharmacological modulators of dynamin activity. Fluorescent dextrans and the lipophilic plasmalemmal marker DiD were utilized to monitor uptake and distribution of vesicles in the peri-plasmalemmal space and in the cell cytosol.ResultsDynamin inhibition with Dynole™-34-2 and Dyngo™-4a prevented vesicle internalization into the cytosol and decreased fusion pore conductance of vesicles that remained attached to the plasmalemma via a narrow fusion pore that lapsed into a state of repetitive opening and closing - flickering. In contrast, the dynamin activator Ryngo™-1-23 promoted vesicle internalization and favored fusion pore closure by prolonging closed and shortening open fusion pore dwell times. Immunocytochemical staining revealed dextran uptake into dynamin-positive vesicles and increased dextran uptake into Syt4- and VAMP2-positive vesicles after dynamin inhibition, indicating prolonged retention of these vesicles at the plasmalemma.ConclusionsOur results have provided direct evidence for a role of dynamin in regulation of fusion pore geometry and kinetics of endo- and exocytotic vesicles, indicating that both share a common dynamin-regulated structural intermediate, the fusion pore.     

The nature of the voltage-dependent conductance induced by alamethicin in black lipid membranes

Summary Alamethicin induces a conductance in black lipid films which increases exponentially with voltage. At low conductance the increase occurs in discrete steps which form a pattern of five levels, the second and third being most likely. The conductance of each level is directly proportional to salt concentration, inversely proportional to solution viscosity, and nearly independent of voltage.The probability distribution of the five steps is not a function of voltage, but as the voltage is increased, more levels begin to appear. These can be explained as super-positions of the original five, both in position and relative probability.This suggests that the five levels are associated with a physical entity which we call a pore. This point of view is confirmed by the following measurements. The kinetic response of the current to a voltage step is first order, and shows an exponential increase in rate of pore formation and an exponential decrease in rate of pore disappearance with voltage. If these rates are statistical, the number of pores should fluctuate about a voltage-dependent mean. High conductance current fluctuations are too large to be explained by fluctuation in the number of pores alone. But if fluctuations among the five levels are included, the magnitude of the fluctuations at high conductance is accurately predicted.Alamethicin adsorbs reversibly to the membrane surface, and the conductance at a fixed voltage depends on the ninth power of alamethicin concentration and on the fourth power of salt concentration, in the aqueous phase. In our bacterial phosphatidyl ethanolamine membranes, alamethicin added to one side of the membrane produces elevated conductance only when the voltage on that side is increased.On leave of absence from the Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Chile, Santiago de Chile.