Crystal Structures of a Group II Chaperonin Reveal the Open and Closed States Associated with the Protein Folding Cycle

Chaperonins are large protein complexes consisting of two stacked multisubunit rings, which open and close in an ATP-dependent manner to create a protected environment for protein folding. Here, we describe the first crystal structure of a group II chaperonin in an open conformation. We have obtained structures of the archaeal chaperonin from Methanococcus maripaludis in both a peptide acceptor (open) state and a protein folding (closed) state. In contrast with group I chaperonins, in which the equatorial domains share a similar conformation between the open and closed states and the largest motions occurs at the intermediate and apical domains, the three domains of the archaeal chaperonin subunit reorient as a single rigid body. The large rotation observed from the open state to the closed state results in a 65% decrease of the folding chamber volume and creates a highly hydrophilic surface inside the cage. These results suggest a completely distinct closing mechanism in the group II chaperonins as compared with the group I chaperonins.     

Localization of prefoldin interaction sites in the hyperthermophilic group II chaperonin and correlations between binding rate and protein transfer rate

Prefoldin is a molecular chaperone that captures a protein-folding intermediate and transfers it to a group II chaperonin for correct folding. The manner by which prefoldin interacts with a group II chaperonin is poorly understood. Here, we have examined the prefoldin interaction site in the archaeal group II chaperonin, comparing the interaction of two Thermococcus chaperonins and their mutants with Pyrococcus prefoldin by surface plasmon resonance. We show that the mutations of Lys250 and Lys256 of Thermococcus alpha chaperonin residues to Glu residues increase the affinity to Pyrococcus prefoldin to the level of Thermococcus beta chaperonin and Pyrococcus chaperonin, indicating that their Glu250 and Glu256 residues of the helical protrusion region are responsible for relatively stronger binding to Pyrococcus prefoldin than Thermococcus alpha chaperonin. Since the putative chaperonin binding sites in the distal ends of Pyrococcus prefoldin are rich in basic residues, electrostatic interaction seems to be important for their interaction. The substrate protein transfer rate from prefoldin correlates well with its affinity for chaperonin.     

Chaperonins from an Antarctic archaeon are predominantly monomeric: crystal structure of an open state monomer

Archaea are abundant in permanently cold environments. The Antarctic methanogen, Methanococcoides burtonii, has proven an excellent model for studying molecular mechanisms of cold adaptation. Methanococcoides burtonii contains three group II chaperonins that diverged prior to its closest orthologues from mesophilic Methanosarcina spp. The relative abundance of the three chaperonins shows little dependence on organism growth temperature, except at the highest temperatures, where the most thermally stable chaperonin increases in abundance. In vitro and in vivo, the M. burtonii chaperonins are predominantly monomeric, with only 23-33% oligomeric, thereby differing from other archaea where an oligomeric ring form is dominant. The crystal structure of an N-terminally truncated chaperonin reveals a monomeric protein with a fully open nucleotide binding site. When compared with closed state group II chaperonin structures, a large-scale ≈ 30° rotation between the equatorial and intermediate domains is observed resulting in an open nucleotide binding site. This is analogous to the transition observed between open and closed states of group I chaperonins but contrasts with recent archaeal group II chaperonin open state ring structures. The predominance of monomeric form and the ability to adopt a fully open nucleotide site appear to be unique features of the M. burtonii group II chaperonins.     

Review: nucleotide binding to the thermoplasma thermosome: implications for the functional cycle of group II chaperonins

Structural information on group II chaperonins became available during recent years from electron microscopy and X-ray crystallography. Three conformational states have been identified for both archaeal and eukaryotic group II chaperonins: an open state, a spherical closed conformation, and an intermediate asymmetric bullet-shaped form. However, the functional cycle of group II chaperonins appears less well understood, although major principles are conserved when compared to group I chaperonins: binding of the substrate polypeptide to the apical domains of the open state and MgATP-driven conformational changes that result in encapsulation of the substrate where folding can proceed presumably in the closed ring of the bullet-shaped form. Binding of the transition state analogue MgADP-AlF3-H2O in the crystal structure of the Thermoplasma acidophilum thermosome suggests that the closed geometry is the enzymatically active conformation that performs ATP hydrolysis. Domain movements observed by electron microscopy suggest a coupling of ATP hydrolysis and domain movement similar to that in the GroE system. The hydrophilic interior of the closed thermosome corresponds to the cis-ring of the asymmetric GroEL-GroES complex implicated in protein folding.     

Cryo-EM structure of a group II chaperonin in the prehydrolysis ATP-bound state leading to lid closure

Chaperonins are large ATP-driven molecular machines that mediate cellular protein folding. Group II chaperonins use their "built-in lid" to close their central folding chamber. Here we report the structure of an archaeal group II chaperonin in its prehydrolysis ATP-bound state at subnanometer resolution using single particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). Structural comparison of Mm-cpn in ATP-free, ATP-bound, and ATP-hydrolysis states reveals that ATP binding alone causes the chaperonin to close slightly with a ～45° counterclockwise rotation of the apical domain. The subsequent ATP hydrolysis drives each subunit to rock toward the folding chamber and to close the lid completely. These motions are attributable to the local interactions of specific active site residues with the nucleotide, the tight couplings between the apical and intermediate domains within the subunit, and the aligned interactions between two subunits across the rings. This mechanism of structural changes in response to ATP is entirely different from those found in group I chaperonins.     

Mechanism of nucleotide sensing in group II chaperonins

Group II chaperonins mediate protein folding in an ATP-dependent manner in eukaryotes and archaea. The binding of ATP and subsequent hydrolysis promotes the closure of the multi-subunit rings where protein folding occurs. The mechanism by which local changes in the nucleotide-binding site are communicated between individual subunits is unknown. The crystal structure of the archaeal chaperonin from Methanococcus maripaludis in several nucleotides bound states reveals the local conformational changes associated with ATP hydrolysis. Residue Lys-161, which is extremely conserved among group II chaperonins, forms interactions with the γ-phosphate of ATP but shows a different orientation in the presence of ADP. The loss of the ATP γ-phosphate interaction with Lys-161 in the ADP state promotes a significant rearrangement of a loop consisting of residues 160-169. We propose that Lys-161 functions as an ATP sensor and that 160-169 constitutes a nucleotide-sensing loop (NSL) that monitors the presence of the γ-phosphate. Functional analysis using NSL mutants shows a significant decrease in ATPase activity, suggesting that the NSL is involved in timing of the protein folding cycle.     

Multiple states of a nucleotide-bound group 2 chaperonin

Chaperonin action is controlled by cycles of nucleotide binding and hydrolysis. Here, we examine the effects of nucleotide binding on an archaeal group 2 chaperonin. In contrast to the ordered apo state of the group 1 chaperonin GroEL, the unliganded form of the homo-16-mer Methanococcus maripaludis group 2 chaperonin is very open and flexible, with intersubunit contacts only in the central double belt of equatorial domains. The intermediate and apical domains are free of contacts and deviate significantly from the overall 8-fold symmetry. Nucleotide binding results in three distinct, ordered 8-fold symmetric conformations--open, partially closed, and fully closed. The partially closed ring encloses a 40% larger volume than does the GroEL-GroES folding chamber, enabling it to encapsulate proteins up to 80 kDa, in contrast to the fully closed form, whose cavities are 20% smaller than those of the GroEL-GroES chamber.     

Gly-345 plays an essential role in Pyrococcus furiosus chaperonin function

Compared to the group I chaperonins, such as Escherichia coli GroEL, which facilitate protein folding, many aspects of the functional mechanism of archaeal group II chaperonins are unclear. Sequence homology between the chaperonin from Pyrococcus furiosus (PfCPN) and other group II chaperonins, together with the homo-oligomeric nature of PfCPN, suggest that PfCPN may serve as a model to clarify the role of the homologous position Gly-345 in the chaperonin-mediated protein folding. Here, we show that the purified chaperonin mutant in which the conserved residue Gly-345 is replaced by Asp (G345D) displays only about 25% ATP/ADP hydrolysis activities of the wild-type in the presence of Co²⁺ and has a reduced capacity to promote folding of denatured malate dehydrogenase in vitro. This may be a reflection that Gly-345 plays an essential role in conformational change and protein refolding by archaeal group II chaperonins.     

Analysis of the interaction mode between hyperthermophilic archaeal group II chaperonin and prefoldin using a platform of chaperonin oligomers of various subunit arrangements

Prefoldin is a co-chaperone that captures an unfolded protein substrate and transfers it to the group II chaperonin for completion of protein folding. Group II chaperonin of a hyperthermophilic archaeon, Thermococcus strain KS-1, interacts and cooperates with archaeal prefoldins. Although the interaction sites within chaperonin and prefoldin have been analyzed, the binding mode between jellyfish-like hexameric prefoldin and the double octameric ring group II chaperonin remains unclear. As prefoldin binds the chaperonin β subunit more strongly than the α subunit, we analyzed the binding mode between prefoldin and chaperonin in the context of Thermococcus group II chaperonin complexes of various subunit compositions and arrangements. The oligomers exhibited various affinities for prefoldins according to the number and order of subunits. Binding affinity increased with the number of Cpnβ subunits. Interestingly, chaperonin complexes containing two β subunits adjacently exhibited stronger affinities than other chaperonin complexes containing the same number of β subunits. The result suggests that all four β tentacles of prefoldin interact with the helical protrusions of CPN in the PFD–CPN complex as the previously proposed model that two adjacent PFD β subunits seem to interact with two CPN adjacent subunits.     

MtGimC, a novel archaeal chaperone related to the eukaryotic chaperonin cofactor GimC/prefoldin

Group II chaperonins in the eukaryotic and archaeal cytosol assist in protein folding independently of the GroES-like cofactors of eubacterial group I chaperonins. Recently, the eukaryotic chaperonin was shown to cooperate with the hetero-oligomeric protein complex GimC (prefoldin) in folding actin and tubulins. Here we report the characterization of the first archaeal homologue of GimC, from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum. MtGimC is a hexamer of 87 kDa, consisting of two alpha and four beta subunits of high alpha-helical content that are predicted to contain extended coiled coils and represent two evolutionarily conserved classes of Gim subunits. Reconstitution experiments with MtGimC suggest that two subunits of the alpha class (archaeal Gimalpha and eukaryotic Gim2 and 5) form a dimer onto which four subunits of the beta class (archaeal Gimbeta and eukaryotic Gim1, 3, 4 and 6) assemble. MtGimalpha and beta can form hetero-complexes with yeast Gim subunits and MtGimbeta partially complements yeast strains lacking Gim1 and 4. MtGimC is a molecular chaperone capable of stabilizing a range of non-native proteins and releasing them for subsequent chaperonin-assisted folding. In light of the absence of Hsp70 chaperones in many archaea, GimC may fulfil an ATP-independent, Hsp70-like function in archaeal de novo protein folding.     

Nucleotide specificity of an archaeal group II chaperonin from Thermococcus strain KS-1 with reference to the ATP-dependent protein folding cycle

The archaeal chaperonin-mediated folding of green fluorescent protein (GFP) was examined in the presence of various nucleotides. The recombinant alpha- and beta-subunit homo-oligomers and natural chaperonin oligomer from Thermococcus strain KS-1 exhibited folding activity with not only ATP but also with CTP, GTP, or UTP. The ADP-bound form of both recombinant and natural chaperonin had the ability to capture non-native GFP, but could not refold it in the presence of CTP, GTP or UTP until ATP was supplied. The archaeal chaperonin thus utilized ATP, but could not use other nucleoside triphosphates in the cytoplasm where ADP was present.     

Kinetics and binding sites for interaction of the prefoldin with a group II chaperonin: contiguous non-native substrate and chaperonin binding sites in the archaeal prefoldin

Prefoldin is a jellyfish-shaped hexameric co-chaperone of the group II chaperonins. It captures a protein folding intermediate and transfers it to a group II chaperonin for completion of folding. The manner in which prefoldin interacts with its substrates and cooperates with the chaperonin is poorly understood. In this study, we have examined the interaction between a prefoldin and a chaperonin from hyperthermophilic archaea by immunoprecipitation, single molecule observation, and surface plasmon resonance. We demonstrate that Pyrococcus prefoldin interacts most tightly with its cognate chaperonin, and vice versa, suggesting species specificity in the interaction. Using truncation mutants, we uncovered by kinetic analyses that this interaction is multivalent in nature, consistent with multiple binding sites between the two chaperones. We present evidence that both N- and C-terminal regions of the prefoldin beta sub-unit are important for molecular chaperone activity and for the interaction with a chaperonin. Our data are consistent with substrate and chaperonin binding sites on prefoldin that are different but in close proximity, which suggests a possible handover mechanism of prefoldin substrates to the chaperonin.     

Functional characterization of the recombinant group II chaperonin alpha from Thermoplasma acidophilum

The functional characteristics of group II chaperonins, especially those from archaea, have not been elucidated extensively. Here, we performed a detailed functional characterization of recombinant chaperonin alpha subunits (16-mer) (Ta-cpn alpha) from the thermophilic archaea Thermoplasma acidophilum as a model protein of archaeal group II chaperonins. Recombinant Ta-cpn alpha formed an oligomeric ring structure similar to that of native protein, and displayed an ATP hydrolysis activity (optimal temperature: 60 degrees C) in the presence of either magnesium, manganese or cobalt ions. Ta-cpn alpha was able to bind refolding intermediates of Thermus MDH and GFP in the absence of ATP, and to promote the refolding of Thermus MDH at 50 degrees C in the presence of Mg2+-, Mn2+-, or Co2+-ATP. Ta-cpn alpha also prevented thermal aggregation of rhodanese and luciferase at 50 degrees C. Interestingly, Ta-cpn alpha in the presence of Mn2+ ion showed an increased hydrophobicity, which correlated with an increased efficiency in substrate protein binding. Our finding that Ta-cpn alpha chaperonin system displays folding assistance ability with ATP-dependent substrate release may provide a detailed look at the potential functional capabilities of archaeal chaperonins.     

Coexistence of group I and group II chaperonins in the archaeon Methanosarcina mazei

Two distantly related classes of cylindrical chaperonin complexes assist in the folding of newly synthesized and stress-denatured proteins in an ATP-dependent manner. Group I chaperonins are thought to be restricted to the cytosol of bacteria and to mitochondria and chloroplasts, whereas the group II chaperonins are found in the archaeal and eukaryotic cytosol. Here we show that members of the archaeal genus Methanosarcina co-express both the complete group I (GroEL/GroES) and group II (thermosome/prefoldin) chaperonin systems in their cytosol. These mesophilic archaea have acquired between 20 and 35% of their genes by lateral gene transfer from bacteria. In Methanosarcina mazei G?1, both chaperonins are similarly abundant and are moderately induced under heat stress. The M. mazei GroEL/GroES proteins have the structural features of their bacterial counterparts. The thermosome contains three paralogous subunits, alpha, beta, and gamma, which assemble preferentially at a molar ratio of 2:1:1. As shown in vitro, the assembly reaction is dependent on ATP/Mg2+ or ADP/Mg2+ and the regulatory role of the beta subunit. The co-existence of both chaperonin systems in the same cellular compartment suggests the Methanosarcina species as useful model systems in studying the differential substrate specificity of the group I and II chaperonins and in elucidating how newly synthesized proteins are sorted from the ribosome to the proper chaperonin for folding.     

Essential function of the built-in lid in the allosteric regulation of eukaryotic and archaeal chaperonins

Chaperonins are allosteric double-ring ATPases that mediate cellular protein folding. ATP binding and hydrolysis control opening and closing of the central chaperonin chamber, which transiently provides a protected environment for protein folding. During evolution, two strategies to close the chaperonin chamber have emerged. Archaeal and eukaryotic group II chaperonins contain a built-in lid, whereas bacterial chaperonins use a ring-shaped cofactor as a detachable lid. Here we show that the built-in lid is an allosteric regulator of group II chaperonins, which helps synchronize the subunits within one ring and, to our surprise, also influences inter-ring communication. The lid is dispensable for substrate binding and ATP hydrolysis, but is required for productive substrate folding. These regulatory functions of the lid may serve to allow the symmetrical chaperonins to function as 'two-stroke' motors and may also provide a timer for substrate encapsulation within the closed chamber.     

Group II chaperonins: new TRiC(k)s and turns of a protein folding machine.

In the past decade, the eubacterial group I chaperonin GroEL became the paradigm of a protein folding machine. More recently, electron microscopy and X-ray crystallography offered insights into the structure of the thermosome, the archetype of the group II chaperonins which also comprise the chaperonin from the eukaryotic cytosol TRiC. Some structural differences from GroEL were revealed, namely the existence of a built-in lid provided by the helical protrusions of the apical domains instead of a GroES-like co-chaperonin. These structural studies provide a framework for understanding the differences in the mode of action between the group II and the group I chaperonins. In vitro analyses of the folding of non-native substrates coupled to ATP binding and hydrolysis are progressing towards establishing a functional cycle for group II chaperonins. A protein complex called GimC/prefoldin has recently been found to cooperate with TRiC in vivo, and its characterization is under way.     

Domain rotations between open, closed and bullet-shaped forms of the thermosome, an archaeal chaperonin

Three conformations of the thermosome, an archaeal group II chaperonin, have been determined by cryo-electron microscopy (EM). We describe an open form of the double-ring oligomer, a closed form and a bullet-shaped form with one ring open and the other closed. Domain movements have been deduced by docking atomic coordinates into the EM maps. The subunit apical domains, bearing the putative substrate binding sites, rotate about 30 degrees upwards and twist in the plane of the ring from the closed to the open conformation. The closed rings have their nucleotide binding pockets closed by the intermediate domains, but in the open rings, the pocket is accessible.     

Cryo-EM reveals an asymmetry in a novel single-ring viral chaperonin

Chaperonins are ubiquitously present protein complexes, which assist the proper folding of newly synthesized proteins and prevent aggregation of denatured proteins in an ATP-dependent manner. They are classified into group I (bacterial, mitochondrial, chloroplast chaperonins) and group II (archaeal and eukaryotic cytosolic variants). However, both of these groups do not include recently discovered viral chaperonins. Here, we solved the symmetry-free cryo-EM structures of a single-ring chaperonin encoded by the gene 246 of bacteriophage OBP Pseudomonas fluorescens, in the nucleotide-free, ATPγS-, and ADP-bound states, with resolutions of 4.3 Å, 5.0 Å, and 6 Å, respectively. The structure of OBP chaperonin reveals a unique subunit arrangement, with three pairs of subunits and one unpaired subunit. Each pair combines subunits in two possible conformations, differing in nucleotide-binding affinity. The binding of nucleotides results in the increase of subunits’ conformational variability. Due to its unique structural and functional features, OBP chaperonin can represent a new group.     

Differential substrate specificity of group I and group II chaperonins in the archaeon Methanosarcina mazei

Chaperonins are macromolecular machines that assist in protein folding. The archaeon Methanosarcina mazei has acquired numerous bacterial genes by horizontal gene transfer. As a result, both the bacterial group I chaperonin, GroEL, and the archaeal group II chaperonin, thermosome, coexist. A proteome‐wide analysis of chaperonin interactors was performed to determine the differential substrate specificity of GroEL and thermosome. At least 13% of soluble M. mazei proteins interact with chaperonins, with the two systems having partially overlapping substrate sets. Remarkably, chaperonin selectivity is independent of phylogenetic origin and is determined by distinct structural and biochemical features of proteins. GroEL prefers well‐conserved proteins with complex α/β domains. In contrast, thermosome substrates comprise a group of faster‐evolving proteins and contain a much wider range of different domain folds, including small all‐α and all‐β modules, and a greater number of large multidomain proteins. Thus, the group II chaperonins may have facilitated the evolution of the highly complex proteomes characteristic of eukaryotic cells.     

Varied effects of Pyrococcus furiosus prefoldin and P. furiosus chaperonin on the refolding reactions of substrate proteins

Prefoldin is a molecular chaperone found in the archaeal and eukaryotic cytosol. Prefoldin can stabilize tentatively nascent polypeptide chains or non-native forms of mainly cytoskeletal proteins, which are subsequently delivered to group II chaperonin to accomplish their precise folding. However, the detailed mechanism is not well known, especially with regard to endogenous substrate proteins. Here, we report the effects of Pyrococcus furiosus prefoldin (PfuPFD) on the refolding reactions of Pyrococcus furiosus citrate synthase (PfuCS) and Aequorea enhanced green fluorescence protein (GFPuv) in the presence or absence of Pyrococcus furiosus chaperonin (PfuCPN). We confirmed that both PfuPFD and PfuCPN interacted with PfuCS and GFPuv refolding intermediates. However, the interactions between chaperone and substrate were different for each case, as was the final effect on the refolding reaction. Effects on the refolding reaction varied from passive effects such as ATP-dependent binding and release (PfuCPN towards GFPuv) and binding which leads to folding arrest (PfuPFD towards GFPuv), to active effects such as net increase in thermal stability (PfuCPN towards PfuCS) to an active improvement in refolding yield (PfuPFD towards PfuCS). We postulate that differences in molecular interactions between substrate and chaperone lead to these differences in chaperoning effects.