Ontogeny of the appendicularian <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oikopleura dioica</Emphasis> (Tunicata,Chordata) reveals characters similar to ascidian larvae with sessile adults

Appendicularians have always occupied a central role in considerations of tunicate and chordate evolution. Two hypotheses have been proposed – one holds that appendicularia represents the sister taxon to the remaining tunicates, the other suggests that appendicularians were derived from an ascidian-like ancestor. In the present study I report results from electron microscopic investigation of larval tunicates including the first electron microscopic investigation of the tail of the early ontogenetic appendicularian “Streckform” and discuss their phylogenetic implications. The early “Streckform” of Oikopleura dioica Fol, 1872 is invested with an extracellular covering that consists of an inner electron-light layer and an electron-dense outermost layer. In addition, the extracellular covering forms fin blades. Because these traits are shown to be similar to the tunic of different ascidian larvae, the extracellular covering in early appendicularian embryos is suggested to be homologous to the larval tunic of ascidian larvae. Overall, the tail of early developmental stages of appendicularians consists of a mosaic of apomorphic and plesiomorphic features. The straight, continuous endodermal strand was inherited from a common chordate ancestor whereas the finlets of larvae, consisting of extracellular material, were inherited from a common tunicate ancestor. The horizontal orientation of the tail as a whole was inherited from the last common ancestor of appendicularians and aplousobranch ascidians, and the discovered floating extension at the posterior tip of the tail is unique to the holoplanktonic Oikopleura dioica. These findings support the hypothesis that Appendicularia is derived from a sessile, ascidian-like ancestor.     

Ascidians and the plasticity of the chordate developmental program

Little is known about the ancient chordates that gave rise to the first vertebrates, but the descendants of other invertebrate chordates extant at the time still flourish in the ocean. These invertebrates include the cephalochordates and tunicates, whose larvae share with vertebrate embryos a common body plan with a central notochord and a dorsal nerve cord. Tunicates are now thought to be the sister group of vertebrates. However, research based on several species of ascidians, a diverse and wide-spread class of tunicates, revealed that the molecular strategies underlying their development appear to diverge greatly from those found in vertebrates. Furthermore, the adult body plan of most tunicates, which arises following an extensive post-larval metamorphosis, shows little resemblance to the body plan of any other chordate. In this review, we compare the developmental strategies of ascidians and vertebrates and argue that the very divergence of these strategies reveals the surprising level of plasticity of the chordate developmental program and is a rich resource to identify core regulatory mechanisms that are evolutionarily conserved in chordates. Further, we propose that the comparative analysis of the architecture of ascidian and vertebrate gene regulatory networks may provide critical insight into the origin of the chordate body plan.     

The history of a developmental stage: metamorphosis in chordates

Metamorphosis displays a striking diversity in chordates, a deuterostome phylum that comprises vertebrates, urochordates (tunicates), and cephalochordates (amphioxus). In anuran amphibians, the tadpole loses its tail, develops limbs, and undergoes profound changes at the behavioral, physiological, biochemical, and ecological levels. In ascidian tunicates, the tail is lost and the head tissues are drastically remodeled into the adult animal, whereas in amphioxus, the highly asymmetric larva transforms into a relatively symmetric adult. This wide diversity has led to the proposal that metamorphosis evolved several times independently in the different chordate lineages during evolution. However, the molecular mechanisms involved in metamorphosis are largely unknown outside amphibians and teleost fishes, in which metamorphosis is regulated by the thyroid hormones (TH) T3 and T4 binding to their receptors (thyroid hormone receptors). In this review, we compare metamorphosis in chordates and then propose a unifying definition of the larva-to-adult transition, based on the conservation of the role of THs and some of their derivatives as the main regulators of metamorphosis. According to this definition, all chordates (if not, all deuterostomes) have a homologous metamorphosis stage during their postembryonic development. The intensity and the nature of the morphological remodeling varies extensively among taxa, from drastic remodeling like in some ascidians or amphibians to more subtle events, as in mammals.     

Amphioxus and tunicates as evolutionary model systems

One important question in evolutionary biology concerns the origin of vertebrates from invertebrates. The current consensus is that the proximate ancestor of vertebrates was an invertebrate chordate. Today, the invertebrate chordates comprise cephalochordates (amphioxus) and tunicates (each a subphylum in the phylum Chordata, which also includes the vertebrate subphylum). It was widely accepted that, within the chordates, tunicates represent the sister group of a clade of cephalochordates plus vertebrates. However, recent studies suggest that the evolutionary positions of tunicates and cephalochordates should be reversed, the implications of which are considered here. We also review the two major groups of invertebrate chordates and compare relative advantages (and disadvantages) of each as model systems for elucidating the origin of the vertebrates.     

Evolutionary crossroads in developmental biology: the tunicates

The tunicates, or urochordates, constitute a large group of marine animals whose recent common ancestry with vertebrates is reflected in the tadpole-like larvae of most tunicates. Their diversity and key phylogenetic position are enhanced, from a research viewpoint, by anatomically simple and transparent embryos, compact rapidly evolving genomes, and the availability of powerful experimental and computational tools with which to study these organisms. Tunicates are thus a powerful system for exploring chordate evolution and how extreme variation in genome sequence and gene regulatory network architecture is compatible with the preservation of an ancestral chordate body plan.     

Tunicate tails, stolons, and the origin of the vertebrate trunk

Tunicates are primitive chordates that develop a transient 'tail' in the larval stage that is generally interpreted as a rudimentary version of the vertebrate trunk. Not all tunicates have tails, however. The groups that lack them, salps and pyrosomes, instead have a trunk-like reproductive stolon located approximately where the tail would otherwise be. In salps, files of blastozooids are formed along the sides of the stolon. The tail and caudal trunk in more advanced chordates could have evolved from a stolon of this type, an idea referred to here as the 'stolon hypothesis'. This means the vertebrate body could be a composite structure, since there is the potential for each somite to incorporate elements originally derived from a complete functional zooid. If indeed this has occurred, it should be reflected in some fashion in gene expression patterns in the vertebrate trunk. Selected morphological and molecular data are reviewed to show that they provide some circumstantial support for the stolon hypothesis. The case would be stronger if it could be demonstrated that salps and/or pyrosomes are ancestral to other tunicates. The molecular phylogenies so far available generally support the idea of a pelagic ancestor, but offer only limited guidance as to which of the surviving pelagic groups most closely resembles it. The principal testable prediction of the stolon hypothesis is that head structures (or their homologues) should be duplicated in series in the trunk in advanced chordates, and vice versa, i.e. trunk structures should occur in the head. The distribution of both rhabdomeric photoreceptors and nephridia in amphioxus conform with this prediction. Equally striking is the involvement of the Pax2 gene in the development of both the inner ear and nephric ducts in vertebrates. The stolon hypothesis would explain this as a consequence of the common origin of otic capsules and excretory ducts from atrial rudiments: from the paired rudiments of the parent oozooid in the case of the otic capsule (these express Pax2 according to recent ascidian data), and from tubular rudiments in the stolon in the case of the excretory ducts.     

Enhancer evolution in chordates: Lessons from functional analyses of cephalochordate cis-regulatory modules

Chordates comprise three major groups, cephalochordates (amphioxus), tunicates (urochordates), and vertebrates. Since cephalochordates were the early branching group, comparisons between amphioxus and other chordates help us to speculate about ancestral chordates. Here, I summarize accumulating data from functional studies analyzing amphioxus cis-regulatory modules (CRMs) in model systems of other chordate groups, such as mice, chickens, clawed frogs, fish, and ascidians. Conservatism and variability of CRM functions illustrate how gene regulatory networks have evolved in chordates. Amphioxus CRMs, which correspond to CRMs deeply conserved among animal phyla, govern reporter gene expression in conserved expression domains of the putative target gene in host animals. In addition, some CRMs located in similar genomic regions (intron, upstream, or downstream) also possess conserved activity, even though their sequences are divergent. These conservative CRM functions imply ancestral genomic structures and gene regulatory networks in chordates. However, interestingly, if expression patterns of amphioxus genes do not correspond to those of orthologs of experimental models, some amphioxus CRMs recapitulate expression patterns of amphioxus genes, but not those of endogenous genes, suggesting that these amphioxus CRMs are close to the ancestral states of chordate CRMs, while vertebrates/tunicates innovated new CRMs to reconstruct gene regulatory networks subsequent to the divergence of the cephalochordates. Alternatively, amphioxus CRMs may have secondarily lost ancestral CRM activity and evolved independently. These data help to solve fundamental questions of chordate evolution, such as neural crest cells, placodes, a forebrain/midbrain, and genome duplication. Experimental validation is crucial to verify CRM functions and evolution.     

A conserved non-reproductive GnRH system in chordates

Gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) is a neuroendocrine peptide that plays a central role in the vertebrate hypothalamo-pituitary axis. The roles of GnRH in the control of vertebrate reproductive functions have been established, while its non-reproductive function has been suggested but less well understood. Here we show that the tunicate Ciona intestinalis has in its non-reproductive larval stage a prominent GnRH system spanning the entire length of the nervous system. Tunicate GnRH receptors are phylogenetically closest to vertebrate GnRH receptors, yet functional analysis of the receptors revealed that these simple chordates have evolved a unique GnRH system with multiple ligands and receptor heterodimerization enabling complex regulation. One of the gnrh genes is conspicuously expressed in the motor ganglion and nerve cord, which are homologous structures to the hindbrain and spinal cord of vertebrates. Correspondingly, GnRH receptor genes were found to be expressed in the tail muscle and notochord of embryos, both of which are phylotypic axial structures along the nerve cord. Our findings suggest a novel non-reproductive role of GnRH in tunicates. Furthermore, we present evidence that GnRH-producing cells are present in the hindbrain and spinal cord of the medaka, Oryzias latipes, thereby suggesting the deep evolutionary origin of a non-reproductive GnRH system in chordates.     

Building divergent body plans with similar genetic pathways

Deuterostome animals exhibit widely divergent body plans. Echinoderms have either radial or bilateral symmetry, hemichordates include bilateral enteropneust worms and colonial pterobranchs, and chordates possess a defined dorsal-ventral axis imposed on their anterior-posterior axis. Tunicates are chordates only as larvae, following metamorphosis the adults acquire a body plan unique for the deuterostomes. This paper examines larval and adult body plans in the deuterostomes and discusses two distinct ways of evolving divergent body plans. First, echinoderms and hemichordates have similar feeding larvae, but build a new adult body within or around their larvae. In hemichordates and many direct-developing echinoderms, the adult is built onto the larva, with the larval axes becoming the adult axes and the larval mouth becoming the adult mouth. In contrast, indirect-developing echinoderms undergo radical metamorphosis where adult axes are not the same as larval axes. A second way of evolving a divergent body plan is to become colonial, as seen in hemichordates and tunicates. Early embryonic development and gastrulation are similar in all deuterostomes, but, in chordates, the anterior-posterior axis is established at right angles to the animal-vegetal axis, in contrast to hemichordates and indirect-developing echinoderms. Hox gene sequences and anterior-posterior expression patterns illuminate deuterostome phylogenetic relationships and the evolution of unique adult body plans within monophyletic groups. Many genes that are considered vertebrate 'mesodermal' genes, such as nodal and brachyury T, are likely to ancestrally have been involved in the formation of the mouth and anus, and later were evolutionarily co-opted into mesoderm during vertebrate development.     

Morphogenetic mechanisms forming the notochord rod: The turgor pressure-sheath strength model

The notochord is a defining feature of chordates. During notochord formation in vertebrates and tunicates, notochord cells display dynamic morphogenetic movement, called convergent extension, in which cells intercalate and align at the dorsal midline. However, in cephalochordates, the most basal group of chordates, the notochord is formed without convergent extension. It is simply developed from mesodermal cells at the dorsal midline. This suggests that convergent extension movement of notochord cells is a secondarily acquired developmental attribute in the common ancestor of olfactores (vertebrates + tunicates), and that the chordate ancestor innovated the notochord upon a foundation of morphogenetic mechanisms independent of cell movement. Therefore, this review focuses on biological features specific to notochord cells, which have been well studied using clawed frogs, zebrafish, and tunicates. Attributes of notochord cells, such as vacuolation, membrane trafficking, extracellular matrix formation, and apoptosis, can be understood in terms of two properties: turgor pressure of vacuoles and strength of the notochord sheath. To maintain the straight rod-like structure of the notochord, these parameters must be counterbalanced. In the future, the turgor pressure-sheath strength model, proposed in this review, will be examined in light of quantitative molecular data and mathematical simulations, illuminating the evolutionary origin of the notochord.     

A new calcichordate from the Ordovician of Bohemia and its anatomy, adaptations and relationships

The paper describes a new member of a group of Lower Palaeozoic marine fossils which partly bridge the gap between echinoderms and chordates. Evidence suggests that this group included the ancestors of the vertebrates. Its members are traditionally regarded as primitive echinoderms, but are better seen as primitive chordates with echinoderm affinities. They form a basal subphylum of chordates-the Calcichordata Jefferies 1967. The Calcichordata, in accordance with an early suggestion by Gislén, are probably ancestral to all living chordates. The new calcichordate is named Reticulocarpos hanusi gen et sp. nov. It comes from the Lower Ordovician ?árka Formation (Llanvirn) of ?árka near Prague, Czechoslovakia and is placed in the family Amygdalothecidae Ubaghs 1970. It is important because of its position in the Calcichordata. This group is divided into two very different orders–the Cornuta and the Mitrata. The Cornuta are the more primitive order and gave rise to the Mitrata, which had the structure of giant, calcite-plated tunicate tadpoles. Many features show that the new species is a very advanced cornute, closely related to the stock that gave rise to the mitrates. For this reason it is important in the general history of the chordates, since some primitive mitrate was probably the latest common ancestor of the living chordate subphyla i.e. of tunicates, of amphioxus and its allies and of the vertebrates. Being a mitrate-like cornute, the new species allows the cornutes and mitrates to be compared more confidently than before. Four results are especially important. Firstly it is likely that the stem (=tail) of mitrates is equivalent only to the anterior part of the stem of cornutes. This is significant, because traditional views as to which was the upper surface in mitrates have been based on stem homologies now seen as false. Secondly Reticulocarpos hanusi is adapted to stay up on very soft mud, using only the strength of the mud for support. The mitrates, on the other hand, supported themselves on soft mud by a much more reliable method resembling buoyancy. Thirdly, the new form had paired transpharyngeal eyes which are otherwise known only in mitrates, and which are the earliest type of paired eyes in chordates. Fourthly, it becomes possible to homologize the thecal plates of cornutes with those of mitrates. Reticulocarpos hanusi represents an important phase in chordate evolution dominated by the necessity of staying up on mud by a very precarious method. During this phase many pre-adaptations for swimming were acquired. Primitive mitrates, descended from a very similar form, were probably the first chordates that could swim.     

The Exceptional “Blind” Gut of Appendicularia sicula (Appendicularia, Tunicata)

In this work, we studied for the first time the histology and ultrastructure of the gut of Appendicularia sicula and demonstrated the absence of any trace of anus. Appendicularians are small holoplanktonic tunicates, characterised by very fast ingestion and quick food transfer along their gut. The high production of faecal pellets released in the aqueous environment, associated with a high filtration rate, highlights their important role in marine ecosystems. Due to the absence of an anus, in contrast with other appendicularians, A. sicula, one of the smallest species, accumulates undigested faecal material within its body, with consequent extreme enlargement of its rectum. The gut, the epithelium of which is generally extremely reduced, is formed of an oesophagus, a globular stomach, thin proximal and mid-intestine, and a huge rectum. The latter, when filled with faecal material, may occupy most of the volume of the trunk in fully grown specimens. Although profoundly altered, the gut of these animals does show several similarities to that of Fritillaria (a genus of the same family, Fritillariidae), with which it has in common many features such as specialised mitochondrial pump cells. In A. sicula, the structural simplifications of organs seem to reach their extreme condition in comparison to other appendicularians.     

Brief review of the stylophoran debate

The "calcichordate" theory interprets an extinct group of calcite-plated invertebrates, the stylophorans, as chordates. In this theory, cornute stylophorans are interpreted as stem chordates, whereas mitrate stylophorans are primitive members of the acraniates, tunicates, and craniates. However, this theory discounts major synapomorphies between cornutes and mitrates. These groups constitute a natural, monophyletic group which is here argued to lie within the echinoderm radiation. The "calcichordate" theory is, therefore, rejected because it relies on assumption-driven hypotheses of character transformation which are supported by ambiguous, poor, or missing fossil evidence. Stylophorans may lie at the base of the echinoderm clade and primitively lack pentameral symmetry, therefore casting light on the near-ancestral body organization of the phylum.