Perturbed folding kinetics of circularly permuted RNAs with altered topology

The folding pathway of the Tetrahymena ribozyme correlates inversely with the sequence distance between native interactions, or contact order. The rapidly folding P4-P6 domain has a low contact order, while the slowly folding P3-P7 region has a high contact order. To examine the role of topology and contact order in RNA folding, we screened for circular permutants of the ribozyme that retain catalytic activity. Permutants beginning in the P4-P6 domain fold 5 to 20 times more slowly than the wild-type ribozyme. By contrast, 50% of a permuted RNA that disjoins a non-native interaction in P3 folds tenfold faster than the wild-type ribozyme. Hence, the probability of rapidly folding to the native state depends on the topology of tertiary domains.     

Relative orientation of RNA helices in a group 1 ribozyme determined by helix extension electron microscopy.

The relative orientation of helical elements in a folded RNA molecule provides key information about its three-dimensional architecture. We have developed a method that involves extending peripheral helices of an RNA, mounting for electron microscopy in the absence of protein and measuring interhelical angles. As a control, extended anticodon and acceptor stems of tRNA(Phe) were found to form a 92 +/- 20 degrees angle, consistent with the X-ray structure. Single, double and triple extensions (50-80 bp) of helical elements P2.1, P6b and P8 of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme did not alter its catalytic activity. The measured angle between P6b and P8 is consistent with the Michel-Westhof structural model, while the P2.1-P6b and P2.1-P8 angles allow P2.1 to be positioned in the model. The angle distributions of the ribozyme are broader than those of the tRNA, which may reflect the dynamics of the RNA. Helix extension allows low-resolution electron microscopy to provide much higher resolution information about the disposition of helical elements in RNA. It should be applicable to diverse RNAs and ribonucleoprotein complexes.     

Kinetic pathway for folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme revealed by three UV-inducible crosslinks.

The kinetics of RNA folding were examined in the L-21 ribozyme, an RNA enzyme derived from the self-splicing Tetrahymena intron. Three UV-inducible crosslinks were mapped, characterized, and used as indicators for the folded state of the ribozyme. Together these data suggest that final structures are adopted first by the P4-P6 independently folding domain and only later in a region that positions the P1 helix (including the 5' splice site), a region whose folding is linked to that of a portion of the catalytic core. At intermediate times, a non-native structure forms in the region of the triple helical scaffold, which connects the major folding domains. At 30 degrees C, the unfolded ribozyme passes through these stages with a half-life of 2 min from the time magnesium cations are provided. At higher temperatures, the half-life is shortened but the order of events is unchanged. Thermal melting of the fully folded ribozyme also revealed a multi-stage process in which the steps of folding are reversed: the kinetically slowest structure is the least stable and melts first. These structures of the ribozyme also bind Mg2+ cooperatively and their relative affinity for binding seems to be a major determinant in the order of events during folding. Na+ can also substitute for Mg2+ to give rise to the same crosslinkable structures, but only at much higher concentrations. Specific binding sites for Mg2+ may make this cation particularly efficient at electrostatic stabilization during folding of these ribozyme structures.     

Fast folding of a ribozyme by stabilizing core interactions: evidence for multiple folding pathways in RNA

Folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme under physiological conditions in vitro is limited by slow conversion of long-lived intermediates to the active structure. These intermediates arise because the most stable domain of the ribozyme folds 10-50 times more rapidly than the core region containing helix P3. Native gel electrophoresis and time-resolved X-ray-dependent hydroxyl radical cleavage revealed that mutations that weaken peripheral interactions between domains accelerated folding fivefold, while a point mutation that stabilizes P3 enabled 80 % of the mutant RNA to reach the native conformation within 30 seconds at 22 degrees C. The P3 mutation increased the folding rate of the catalytic core as much as 50-fold, so that both domains of the ribozyme were formed at approximately the same rate. The results show that the ribozyme folds rapidly without significantly populating metastable intermediates when native interactions in the ribozyme core are stabilized relative to peripheral structural elements.     

The loop B domain is physically separable from the loop A domain in the hairpin ribozyme.

In order to understand the catalysis mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme, mutant ribozymes were constructed. The distance between the loop A domain and the loop B domain was extended by inserting various lengths of nucleotide linkers at the hinge region in cis mutants, or the domains were separated physically in a trans mutant. All the mutant ribozymes, including the trans mutant, could cleave substrate RNA at the predicted site. A cis mutant with a single nucleotide insertion exhibited cleavage activity about twice as high as that of the wild-type (wt) ribozyme. The insertion of 2-5 nucleotides (nt) gradually reduced the activity to the level of the wt ribozyme. Insertion of a longer linker, up to 11 nt, resulted in the reduction of activity to one half of that of the wt ribozyme. The ribozyme with a single nucleotide insertion at the hinge region seems to form a more suitable conformation for catalysis by three-dimensional fold-back of the loop B to loop A containing the cleavage site. The trans mutant, in which the A and B domains were physically separated, maintained a significant level of activity, suggesting that both domains are necessary for catalysis, but separable. These results demonstrate that interaction between the A and B domains results in catalysis.     

Fast formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot: a strategy for efficient folding of the catalytically active ribozyme

Formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot structure, the core of group I ribozymes, requires long-range base pairing. Study of the Tetrahymena ribozyme appreciates the hierarchical folding of the large, multidomain RNA, in which the P3-P7 core folds significantly slower than do the other domains. Here we explored the formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot of the Candida ribozyme that has been reported to concertedly fold to the catalytically active structure with a rate constant of 2 min(-1). We demonstrate that pseudoknot formation occurs during the rapid ribozyme compaction, coincident with formation of many tertiary interactions of the ribozyme. A low physiological concentration of magnesium (1.5 mM) is sufficient to fully support the pseudoknot formation. The presence of nonnative intermediates containing an unfolded P3-P7 region is evident. However, catalysis-based analysis shows these nonnative intermediates are stable and fail to convert to the catalytically active structure, suggesting that rapid pseudoknot formation is essential for folding of the active ribozyme. Interestingly, RNAstructure predicts no stable Alt P3 structure for the Candida ribozyme, but two stable Alt P3s for the Tetrahymena ribozyme, explaining the dramatic difference in folding of the P3-P7 core of these two ribozymes. We propose that rapid formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot represents a folding strategy ensuring efficient production of the catalytically active structure of group I ribozymes, which sheds new light on the mechanism of effective ribozyme folding in vivo.     

Probing the mechanisms of DEAD-box proteins as general RNA chaperones: the C-terminal domain of CYT-19 mediates general recognition of RNA

The DEAD-box protein CYT-19 functions in the folding of several group I introns in vivo and a diverse set of group I and group II RNAs in vitro. Recent work using the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme demonstrated that CYT-19 possesses a second RNA-binding site, distinct from the unwinding active site, which enhances unwinding activity by binding nonspecifically to the adjacent RNA structure. Here, we probe the region of CYT-19 responsible for that binding by constructing a C-terminal truncation variant that lacks 49 amino acids and terminates at a domain boundary, as defined by limited proteolysis. This truncated protein unwinds a six-base-pair duplex, formed between the oligonucleotide substrate of the Tetrahymena ribozyme and an oligonucleotide corresponding to the internal guide sequence of the ribozyme, with near-wild-type efficiency. However, the truncated protein is activated much less than the wild-type protein when the duplex is covalently linked to the ribozyme or single-stranded or double-stranded extensions. Thus, the active site for RNA unwinding remains functional in the truncated CYT-19, but the site that binds the adjacent RNA structure has been compromised. Equilibrium binding experiments confirmed that the truncated protein binds RNA less tightly than the wild-type protein. RNA binding by the compromised site is important for chaperone activity, because the truncated protein is less active in facilitating the folding of a group I intron that requires CYT-19 in vivo. The deleted region contains arginine-rich sequences, as found in other RNA-binding proteins, and may function by tethering CYT-19 to structured RNAs, so that it can efficiently disrupt exposed, non-native structural elements, allowing them to refold. Many other DExD/H-box proteins also contain arginine-rich ancillary domains, and some of these domains may function similarly as nonspecific RNA-binding elements that enhance general RNA chaperone activity.     

Two major tertiary folding transitions of the Tetrahymena catalytic RNA.

The L-21 Tetrahymena ribozyme, an RNA molecule with sequence-specific endoribonuclease activity derived from a self-splicing group I intron, provides a model system for studying the RNA folding problem. A 160 nucleotide, independently folding domain of tertiary structure (the P4-P6 domain) comprises about half of the ribozyme. We now apply Fe(II)-EDTA cleavage to mutants of the ribozyme to explore the role of individual structural elements in tertiary folding of the RNA at equilibrium. Deletion of peripheral elements near the 3' end of the ribozyme destabilizes a region of the catalytic core (P3-P7) without altering the folding of the P4-P6 domain. Three different mutations within the P4-P6 domain that destabilize its folding also shift the folding of the P3-P7 region of the catalytic core to higher MgCl2 concentrations. We conclude that the role of the extended P4-P6 domain and of the 3'-terminal peripheral elements is at least in part to stabilize the catalytic core. The organization of RNA into independently folding domains of tertiary structure may be common in large RNAs, including ribosomal RNAs. Furthermore, the observation of domain-domain interactions in a catalytic RNA supports the feasibility of a primitive spliceosome without any proteins.     

Long-range interaction between the P2.1 and P9.1 peripheral domains of the Tetrahymena ribozyme.

The Tetrahymena ribozyme possesses peripheral domains, termed P9.1 and P9.2. They are nonessential in the mechanism of the catalytic reaction but contribute to enhance the catalytic activity of the ribozyme. It has been postulated that P9.1 is capable of forming Watson-Crick base pairings with another peripheral domain, P2.1. We report here the existence of long-range base pairings between the loop regions of these two domains and show that this interaction apparently plays a role in enhancing the catalytic activity of the ribozyme.     

P5abc of the Tetrahymena ribozyme consists of three functionally independent elements.

P5abc domain of Tetrahymena LSU intron functions as an activator that is not essential for but enhances the activity of the ribozyme either when present in cis or when added in trans. This domain contains three regions (A-rich bulge, L5b, and L5c) that have been demonstrated to interact with the rest of the intron. Although these regions are presumably important for efficient activation, the role of each element is not understood in the mechanism of activation. We employed circularly permuted introns and examined the roles of each element. The results show that each of the three elements can activate the intron independently. We also found that a correlation between the activation by P5abc and the physical affinity of P5abc to the intron exists.     

Assembly of an exceptionally stable RNA tertiary interface in a group I ribozyme

Group I intron RNAs contain a core of highly conserved helices flanked by peripheral domains that stabilize the core structure. In the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme, the P4, P5, and P6 helices of the core pack tightly against a three-helix subdomain called P5abc. Chemical footprinting and the crystal structure of the Tetrahymena intron P4-P6 domain revealed that tertiary interactions between these two parts of the domain create an extensive solvent-inaccessible interface. We have examined the formation and stability of this tertiary interface by providing the P5abc segment in trans to a Tetrahymena ribozyme construct that lacks P5abc (EDeltaP5abc). Equilibrium gel shift experiments show that the affinity of the P5abc and EDeltaP5abc RNAs is exceptionally strong, with a Kd of approximately 100 pM at 10 mM MgCl2 (at 37 degrees C). Chemical and enzymatic footprinting shows that the RNAs are substantially folded prior to assembly of the complex. Solvent accessibility mapping reveals that, in the absence of P5abc, the intron RNA maintains a nativelike fold but its active-site helices are not tightly packed. Upon binding of P5abc, the catalytic core becomes more tightly packed through indirect effects of the tertiary interface formation. This two-component system facilitates quantitative examination of individual tertiary contacts that stabilize the folded intron.     

Folding path of P5abc RNA involves direct coupling of secondary and tertiary structures

Folding mechanisms in which secondary structures are stabilized through the formation of tertiary interactions are well documented in protein folding but challenge the folding hierarchy normally assumed for RNA. However, it is increasingly clear that RNA could fold by a similar mechanism. P5abc, a small independently folding tertiary domain of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I ribozyme, is known to fold by a secondary structure rearrangement involving helix P5c. However, the extent of this rearrangement and the precise stage of folding that triggers it are unknown. We use experiments and simulations to show that the P5c helix switches to the native secondary structure late in the folding pathway and is directly coupled to the formation of tertiary interactions in the A-rich bulge. P5c mutations show that the switch in P5c is not rate-determining and suggest that non-native interactions in P5c aid folding rather than impede it. Our study illustrates that despite significant differences in the building blocks of proteins and RNA, there may be common ways in which they self-assemble.     

Role of a conserved J8/7 X P4 base-triple in the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme folds into a complex three dimensional structure for performing the self-splicing reaction. Catalysis depends on its core structure comprising two helical domains, P4-P6 and P3-P7. The two domains are joined by three sets of conserved base-triple(s) and other tertiary interactions. We found that the disruption of J8/7 X P4, one such conserved base-triple, causes the catalytic ability to deteriorate without altering the folding rate. This suggests that the base-triple stabilizes the active structure of the ribozyme but plays no significant role in RNA folding. By combining the present and previous results, it can be concluded that three sets of conserved base-triples play distinct roles in the Tetrahymena ribozyme.     

Perturbation of the hierarchical folding of a large RNA by the destabilization of its Scaffold's tertiary structure

The P4-P6 domain serves as a scaffold against which the periphery and catalytic core organize and fold during Mg2+-mediated folding of the Tetrahymena thermophila ribozyme. The most prominent structural motif of the P4-P6 domain is the tetraloop-tetraloop receptor interaction which "clamps" the distal parts of its hairpin-like structure. Destabilization of the tertiary structure of the P4-P6 domain by perturbation of the tetraloop-tetraloop receptor interaction alters the Mg2+-mediated folding pathway. The folding hierarchy of P5c approximately P4-P6 > periphery > catalytic core that is a striking attribute of the folding of the wild-type RNA is abolished. The initial steps in folding of the mutant RNA are > or =50-fold faster than those of the wild-type ribozyme with the earliest observed tertiary contacts forming around regions known to specifically bind Mg2+. The interaction between the mutant tetraloop and the tetraloop receptor appears coincidently with slowly forming catalytic core tertiary contacts. Thus, the stability conferred upon the P4-P6 domain by the tetraloop-tetraloop receptor interaction dictates the preferred folding pathway by stabilizing an early intermediate. A sub-denaturing concentration of urea diminishes the early barrier to folding the wild-type ribozyme along with complex effects on the subsequent steps of folding the wild-type and mutant RNA.     

Concurrent molecular recognition of the amino acid and tRNA by a ribozyme.

We have recently reported an in vitro-evolved precursor tRNA (pre-tRNA) that is able to catalyze aminoacylation on its own 3'-hydroxyl group. This catalytic pre-tRNA is susceptible to RNase P RNA, generating the 5'-leader ribozyme and mature tRNA. The 5'-leader ribozyme is also capable of aminoacylating the tRNA in trans, thus acting as an aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase-like ribozyme (ARS-like ribozyme). Here we report its structural characterization that reveals the essential catalytic core. The ribozyme consists of three stem-loops connected by two junction regions. The chemical probing analyses show that a U-rich region (U59-U62 in J2a/3 and U67-U68 in L3) of the ribozyme is responsible for the recognition of the phenylalanine substrate. Moreover, a GGU-motif (G70-U72) of the ribozyme, adjacent to the U-rich region, forms base pairs with the tRNA 3' terminus. Our demonstration shows that simple RNA motifs can recognize both the amino acid and tRNA simultaneously, thus aminoacylating the 3' terminus of tRNA in trans.     

Trans-splicing of a mutated glycosylasparaginase mRNA sequence by a group I ribozyme deficient in hydrolysis.

RNA reprogramming represents a new concept in correcting genetic defects at the RNA level. However, for the technique to be useful for therapy, the level of reprogramming must be appropriate. To improve the efficiency of group I ribozyme-mediated RNA reprogramming, when using the Tetrahymena ribozyme, regions complementary to the target RNA have previously been extended in length and accessible sites in the target RNAs have been identified. As an alternative to the Tetrahymena model ribozyme, the DiGIR2 group I ribozyme, derived from a mobile group I intron in rDNA of the myxomycete Didymium iridis, represents a new and attractive tool in RNA reprogramming. We reported recently that the deletion of a structural element within the P9 domain of DiGIR2 turns off hydrolysis at the 3' splice site (side reaction) without affecting self-splicing [Haugen, P., Andreassen, M., Birgisdottir, A.B. & Johansen, S.D. (2004) Eur. J. Biochem. 271, 1015-1024]. Here we analyze the potential of the modified ribozyme, deficient in hydrolysis at the 3' splice site, for application in group I ribozyme-mediated trans-splicing of RNA. The improved ribozyme catalyses both cis-splicing and trans-splicing in vitro of a human glycosylasparaginase mRNA sequence with the same efficiency as the original DiGIR2 ribozyme, but without detectable levels of the unwanted hydrolysis.     

Concerted kinetic folding of a multidomain ribozyme with a disrupted loop-receptor interaction

The free energy landscape for the folding of large, multidomain RNAs is rugged, and kinetically trapped, misfolded intermediates are a hallmark of RNA folding reactions. Here, we examine the role of a native loop-receptor interaction in determining the ruggedness of the energy landscape for folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. We demonstrate a progressive smoothing of the energy landscape for ribozyme folding as the strength of the loop-receptor interaction is reduced. Remarkably, with the most severe mutation, global folding is more rapid than for the wild-type ribozyme and proceeds in a concerted fashion without the accumulation of long-lived kinetic intermediates. The results demonstrate that a complex interplay between native tertiary interactions, divalent ion concentration, and non-native secondary structure determines the ruggedness of the energy landscape. Furthermore, the results suggest that kinetic folding transitions involving large regions of highly structured RNAs can proceed in a concerted fashion, in the absence of significant stable, preorganized tertiary structure.