Native electrophoretic techniques to identify protein–protein interactions

Permanent protein–protein interactions are commonly identified by co‐purification of two or more protein components using techniques like co‐immunoprecipitation, tandem affinity purification and native electrophoresis. Here we focus on blue‐native electrophoresis, clear‐native electrophoresis, high‐resolution clear‐native electrophoresis and associated techniques to identify stable membrane protein complexes and detergent‐labile physiological supercomplexes. Hints for dynamic protein–protein interactions can be obtained using two‐hybrid techniques but not from native electrophoresis and other protein isolation techniques except after covalent cross‐linking of interacting proteins in vivo prior to protein separation.     

Features and applications of blue-native and clear-native electrophoresis

1-D native electrophoresis is used for the separation of individual proteins, protein complexes, and supercomplexes. Stable and labile protein-protein interactions can be identified depending on detergent and buffer conditions. 1-D native gels are immediately applicable for in-gel detection of fluorescent-labeled proteins and for in-gel catalytic activity assays. 1-D native gels and blots are used to determine native mass and oligomeric state of membrane proteins. Protein extracts from 1-D native gels are used for generation of antibodies, for proteomic work, and for advanced structural investigations. 2-D separation of subunits of protein complexes by SDS-PAGE is mostly used for immunological and proteomic studies. Following the discussion of these general features, specific applications of native electrophoresis techniques in various research fields are highlighted: immunological and receptor studies, biogenesis and assembly of membrane protein complexes, protein import into organelles, dynamics of proteasomes, proteome and subproteome investigations, the identification and quantification of mitochondrial alterations in apoptosis, carcinogenesis, and neurodegenerative disorders like Parkinson's disease, Alzheimer's disease, and the vast variety of mitochondrial encephalomyopathies.     

Analysis of membrane protein complexes by blue native PAGE

Blue native polyacryamide gel electrophoresis is a special case of native electrophoresis for high resolution separation of enzymatically active protein complexes from tissue homogenates and cell fractions. The method is powerful between 10 and 10,000 kDa. Also membrane protein complexes are separated well after solubilization of complexes with mild neutral detergents. The separation principle relies on binding of Coomassie blue G250 which provides negative charges to the surface of the protein. During migration to the anode, protein complexes are separated according to molecular mass and/or size and high resolution is obtained by the decreasing pore size of a polyacrylamide gradient gel. The principles of 2-dimensional blue native sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis are presented here together with a practical step-by-step guide to performing the method in the laboratory.     

Oligomeric state of membrane transport proteins analyzed with blue native electrophoresis and analytical ultracentrifugation

Blue native electrophoresis is used widely for the analysis of non-dissociated protein complexes with respect to composition, oligomeric state and molecular mass. However, the effects of detergent or dye binding on the mass and stability of the integral membrane proteins have not been studied. By comparison with analytical ultracentrifugation, we have evaluated whether the oligomeric state of membrane transport proteins is reflected reliably with blue native electrophoresis. For the analysis we have used two well-characterized transporters, that is, the major facilitator superfamily protein LacS and the phosphotransferase system EII(Mtl). For another member of the major facilitator superfamily, the xyloside transporter XylP from Lactobacillus pentosus, the complete analysis of the quaternary structure determined by analytical ultracentrifugation and freeze-fracture electron microscopy is presented.Our experiments show that during blue native electrophoresis the detergent bound to the proteins is replaced by the amphipathic Coomassie brilliant blue (CBB) dye. The mass of the bound CBB dye was quantified. Provided this additional mass of bound CBB dye is accounted for and care is taken in the choice and concentration of the detergent used, the mass of LacS, XylP and EII(Mtl) and four other membrane (transport) proteins could be deduced within 10 % error. Our data underscore the fact that the oligomeric state of many membrane transport proteins is dimeric.     

The composition of the Bacillus subtilis aerobic respiratory chain supercomplexes

Bacillus subtilis has a bifurcated respiratory chain composed of a cytochrome branch and a quinol oxidase branch. The respiratory complexes of this bacterium have been elucidated mostly by the analysis of the genome and by the isolation of individual complexes. The supramolecular organization of this respiratory chain is not known. In this work, we have analyzed the organization of the supercomplex in membranes isolated from B. subtilis grown in aerobic conditions in a medium with 3?% succinate. We used two different native electrophoretic techniques, clear native electrophoresis (CNE) and blue native electrophoresis (BNE). Using a heme-specific stain and Coomassie blue stain with in-gel activity assays followed by mass spectrometry, we identified the proteins resolved in both the first and second dimensions of the electrophoreses to detect the supercomplexes. We found that complexes b ( 6 ) c and caa ( 3 ) form a very high molecular mass supercomplex with the membrane-bound cytochrome c ( 550 ) and with ATP synthase. Most of the ATP synthase was found as a monomer. Succinate dehydrogenase was identified within a high molecular band between F(0)F(1) and F(1) and together with nitrate reductase. The type-2 NADH dehydrogenase was detected within a low molecular mass band. Finally, the quinol oxidase aa ( 3 ) seems to migrate as an oligomer of high molecular mass.     

Visible fluorescent detection of proteins in polyacrylamide gels without staining

2,2,2-Trichloroethanol (TCE) incorporated into polyacrylamide gels before polymerization provides fluorescent visible detection of proteins in less than 5min of total processing time. The tryptophans in proteins undergo an ultraviolet light-induced reaction with trihalocompounds to produce fluorescence in the visible range so that the protein bands can be visualized on a 300-nm transilluminator. In a previous study trichloroacetic acid or chloroform was used to stain polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) gels for protein visualization. This study shows that placing TCE in the gel before electrophoresis can eliminate the staining step. The gel is removed from the electrophoresis apparatus and placed on a transilluminator and then the protein bands develop their fluorescence in less than 5min. In addition to being rapid this visualization method provides detection of 0.2microg of typical globular proteins, which for some proteins is slightly more sensitive than the standard Coomassie brilliant blue (CBB) method. Integral membrane proteins, which do not stain well with CBB, are visualized well with the TCE in-gel method. After TCE in-gel visualization the same gel can then be CBB stained, allowing for complementary detection of proteins. In addition, visualization with TCE in the gel is compatible with two-dimensional PAGE, native PAGE, Western blotting, and autoradiography.     

An Update on Protein Stains: Amido Black,Coomassie Blue G,and Coomassie Blue R

Samples of amido black, Coomassie blue G, and Coomassie blue R obtained over a number of years were tested for dye content, impurities, and effectiveness for staining proteins after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and for protein dye-binding assays. Some impurities produced reactions resembling metachromasia with specific proteins, although instances of true metachromatic staining are also reported. Several simple assays are given for determining dye content and relative levels of impurities. Recommendations are made for selecting batches of commercial dyes which are most likely to perform satisfactorily.     

An Update on Protein Stains: Amido Black, Coomassie Blue G, and Coomassie Blue R

Samples of amido black, Coomassie blue G, and Coomassie blue R obtained over a number of years were tested for dye content, impurities, and effectiveness for staining proteins after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and for protein dye-binding assays. Some impurities produced reactions resembling metachromasia with specific proteins, although instances of true metachromatic staining are also reported. Several simple assays are given for determining dye content and relative levels of impurities. Recommendations are made for selecting batches of commercial dyes which are most likely to perform satisfactorily.     

Dimethylformamide interferes with Coomassie dye staining of proteins on blue native gel electrophoresis

Blue native gel electrophoresis (BN–PAGE) is used extensively for characterization of mitochondrial respiratory complexes and uses the binding of Coomassie brilliant blue G-250 to visualize proteins. Oxidative modification of sulfhydryl groups of such proteins can be evaluated by labeling with iodoacetamide conjugated to biotin (BIAM) and detected with streptavidin peroxidase on Western blots following BN–PAGE. However, dissolving BIAM in dimethylformamide, a recommended solvent, reduces Coomassie blue G staining to proteins during BN–PAGE. This interference is prevented by dissolving BIAM in dimethyl sulfoxide. Precautions in the use of the dye for protein staining subsequent to BIAM labeling are discussed.     

In-gel digestion of proteins for internal sequence analysis after one- or two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.

We examined the different steps necessary for the enzymatic digestion of proteins in the polyacrylamide matrix after gel electrophoresis. As a result, we developed an improved method for obtaining peptides for internal sequence analysis from 1-2 micrograms of in-gel-digested proteins. The long washing-lyophilization-equilibration steps necessary to eliminate the dye, sodium dodecyl sulfate, and other gel-associated contaminants that perturb protein digestion in Coomassie blue-stained gels have been replaced by washing for 40 min with 50% acetonitrile, drying for 10 min at room temperature, and then rehydrating with a protease solution. The washing and drying steps result in a substantial reduction of the gel slice volume that, when next swollen in the protease solution, readily absorbs the enzyme, facilitating digestion. The Coomassie blue staining procedure has also been modified by reducing acetic acid and methanol concentrations in the staining solution and by eliminating acetic acid in the destaining solution. The peptides resulting from the in-gel digestion are easily recovered by passive elution, in excellent yields for structural characterization. This simple and rapid method has been successfully applied for the internal sequence analysis of membrane proteins from the rat mitochondria resolved in preparative two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.     

High-resolution Native-PAGE for membrane proteins capable of fluorescence detection and hydrodynamic state evaluation

An improved native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) method capable of evaluating the hydrodynamic states of membrane proteins and allowing in-gel fluorescence detection was established. In this method, bis(alkyl) sulfosuccinate is used to provide negative charges for detergent-solubilized membrane proteins to facilitate proper electrophoretic migration without disturbing their native hydrodynamic states. The method achieved high-resolution electrophoretic separation, in good agreement with the elution profiles obtained by size exclusion chromatography. The applicability of in-gel fluorescence detection for tagged green fluorescent protein (GFP) facilitates the analysis of samples without any purification. This method might serve as a general analytical technique for assessing the folding, oligomerization, and protein complex formation of membrane proteins.     

A high-definition native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis system for the analysis of membrane complexes

Native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) is an important technique for the analysis of membrane protein complexes. A major breakthrough was the development of blue native (BN‐) and high resolution clear native (hrCN‐) PAGE techniques. Although these techniques are very powerful, they could not be applied to all systems with the same resolution. We have developed an alternative protocol for the analysis of membrane protein complexes of plant chloroplasts and cyanobacteria, which we termed histidine‐ and deoxycholate‐based native (HDN‐) PAGE. We compared the capacity of HDN‐, BN‐ and hrCN‐PAGE to resolve the well‐studied respiratory chain complexes in mitochondria of bovine heart muscle and Yarrowia lipolytica, as well as thylakoid localized complexes of Medicago sativa, Pisum sativum and Anabaena sp. PCC7120. Moreover, we determined the assembly/composition of the Anabaena sp. PCC7120 thylakoids and envelope membranes by HDN‐PAGE. The analysis of isolated chloroplast envelope complexes by HDN‐PAGE permitted us to resolve complexes such as the translocon of the outer envelope migrating at approximately 700 kDa or of the inner envelope of about 230 and 400 kDa with high resolution. By immunodecoration and mass spectrometry of these complexes we present new insights into the assembly/composition of these translocation machineries. The HDN‐PAGE technique thus provides an important tool for future analyses of membrane complexes such as protein translocons.     

Nongradient blue native gel analysis of serum proteins and in-gel detection of serum esterase activities

The objective of the present study was to analyze serum protein complexes and detect serum esterase activities using nongradient blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE). For analysis of potential protein complexes, serum from rat was used. Results demonstrate that a total of 8 gel bands could be clearly distinguished after Coomassie blue staining, and serum albumin could be isolated nearly as a pure protein. Moreover, proteins in these bands were identified by electrospray mass spectrometry and low-energy collision induced dissociation (CID)-MS/MS peptide sequencing and the existence of serum dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase (DLDH) was confirmed. For studies of in-gel detection of esterase activities, serum from rat, mouse, and human was used. In-gel staining of esterase activity was achieved by the use of either α-naphthylacetate or β-naphthylacetate in the presence of Fast blue BB salt. There were three bands exhibiting esterase activities in the serum of both rat and mouse. In contrast, there was only one band showing esterase activity staining in the human serum. When serum samples were treated with varying concentrations of urea, esterase activity staining was abolished for all the bands except the one containing esterase 1 (Es1) protein that is known to be a single polypeptide enzyme, indicating that majority of these esterases were protein complexes or multimeric proteins. We also identified the human serum esterase as butyrylcholinesterase following isolation and partial purification using ammonium sulfate fractioning and ion exchange column chromatographies. Where applicable, demonstrations of the gel-based method for measuring serum esterase activities under physiological or pathophysiological conditions were illustrated. Results of the present study demonstrate that nongradient BN-PAGE can serve as a feasible analytical tool for proteomic and enzymatic analysis of serum proteins.     

Analysis of 953 Human Proteins from a Mitochondrial HEK293 Fraction by Complexome Profiling

Complexome profiling is a novel technique which uses shotgun proteomics to establish protein migration profiles from fractionated blue native electrophoresis gels. Here we present a dataset of blue native electrophoresis migration profiles for 953 proteins by complexome profiling. By analysis of mitochondrial ribosomal complexes we demonstrate its potential to verify putative protein-protein interactions identified by affinity purification – mass spectrometry studies. Protein complexes were extracted in their native state from a HEK293 mitochondrial fraction and separated by blue native gel electrophoresis. Gel lanes were cut into gel slices of even size and analyzed by shotgun proteomics. Subsequently, the acquired protein migration profiles were analyzed for co-migration via hierarchical cluster analysis. This dataset holds great promise as a comprehensive resource for de novo identification of protein-protein interactions or to underpin and prioritize candidate protein interactions from other studies. To demonstrate the potential use of our dataset we focussed on the mitochondrial translation machinery. Our results show that mitoribosomal complexes can be analyzed by blue native gel electrophoresis, as at least four distinct complexes. Analysis of these complexes confirmed that 24 proteins that had previously been reported to co-purify with mitoribosomes indeed co-migrated with subunits of the mitochondrial ribosome. Co-migration of several proteins involved in biogenesis of inner mitochondrial membrane complexes together with mitoribosomal complexes suggested the possibility of co-translational assembly in human cells. Our data also highlighted a putative ribonucleotide complex that potentially contains MRPL10, MRPL12 and MRPL53 together with LRPPRC and SLIRP.     

Coupling of native liquid phase isoelectrofocusing and blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis: a potent tool for native membrane multiprotein complex separation

In this study, a new 3D native electrophoretic protocol is proposed for an exhaustive separation and identification of membrane proteins. It is based on native liquid phase isoelectrofocusing (N-LP-IEF) of protein complexes in the first dimension, followed by blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) in the second dimension, where both the pI and the molecular masses of protein complexes (2D N-LP-IEF-BN) were used to separate them in their native form. Finally, each single component can be resolved using denaturing electrophoresis (3D N-LP-IEF-BN-SDS-PAGE). The thylakoid membrane of spinach which contains four big protein complexes was chosen as a model for setting up analytical methods suitable for any membrane proteins. The pI-based MicroRotofor has a number of advantages over BN-PAGE: it does not require the addition of any chemicals, and separation of complexes is based on the protein's real physicochemical properties which inevitably change when dye is added. Results were more easily reproduced than with BN, and the pI of each native complex was also determined. Although some fractions still contained comigrating complexes after MicroRotofor, these were subsequently separated by BN for further analysis. Thus, highly hydrophobic complexes, such as ATP-synthetas and Cyt b6/f, were separated in native form as were various complexes of LHCII trimers, which have different pI but similar molecular masses. SDS-PAGE revealed almost all the subunits from the four photosynthetic complexes, indicating that by using 3D N-LP-IEF-BN-SDS-PAGE it is possible to achieve a greater degree of component identification than with 2D BN-SDS-PAGE.     

Mapping the proteome of thylakoid membranes by de novo sequencing of intermembrane peptide domains

The proteome of a membrane compartment has been investigated by de novo sequence analysis after tryptic in gel digestion. Protein complexes and corresponding protein subunits were separated by a 2-D Blue Native (BN)/SDS-PAGE system. The transmembrane proteins of thylakoid membranes from a higher plant (Hordeum vulgare L.) were identified by the primary sequence of hydrophilic intermembrane peptide domains using nano ESI-MS/MS-analysis. Peptide analysis revealed that lysine residues of membrane proteins are primarily situated in the intermembrane domains. We concluded that esterification of lysine residues with fluorescent dyes may open the opportunity to label membrane proteins still localized in native protein complexes within the membrane phase. We demonstrate that covalent labelling of membrane proteins with the fluorescent dye Cy3 allows high sensitive visualization of protein complexes after 2-D BN/SDS-PAGE. We show that pre-electrophoretic labelling of protein subunits supplements detection of proteins by post-electrophoretic staining with silver and CBB and assists in completing the identification of the membrane proteome.     

Brain mitochondrial complex I inactivation by oxidative modification

In vitro oxidation of the brain mitochondrial complex I by the hydroxyl radical generating system ascorbate/Fe(III)/O(2) has been carried out. Complex I inactivation, by oxidation, has been studied using a method based on the resolution of proteins by blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE), followed by total protein quantification by staining with Coomassie brilliant blue, in-gel activity quantification, and quantification of oxidized proteins by labelling with DIG-hydrazide and immunodetection with an anti-DIG-AP. Quantification was carried out by densitometry procedure. Our results show that oxidation is a continuous process, increasing rapidly at the beginning, reaching a plateau after 8 h of incubation. There is practically no inactivation until a threshold value of damage is reached. Below this, the complex activity is resistant to the aggression of oxygen-reactive substances and free radicals, but once the threshold value is passed, activity is lost rapidly.     

Identification of two proteins associated with mammalian ATP synthase

Bovine mitochondrial ATP synthase commonly is isolated as a monomeric complex that contains 16 protein subunits and the natural IF(1) inhibitor protein in substoichiometric amounts. Alternatively ATP synthase can be isolated in dimeric and higher oligomeric states using digitonin for membrane solubilization and blue native or clear native electrophoresis for separation of the native mitochondrial complexes. Using blue native electrophoresis we could identify two ATP synthase-associated membrane proteins with masses smaller than 7 kDa and isoelectric points close to 10 that previously had been removed during purification. We show that in the mitochondrial membrane both proteins are almost quantitatively bound to ATP synthase. Both proteins had been identified earlier in a different context, but their association with ATP synthase was unknown. The first one had been named 6.8-kDa mitochondrial proteolipid because it can be isolated by chloroform/methanol extraction from mitochondrial membranes. The second one had been denoted as diabetes-associated protein in insulin-sensitive tissue (DAPIT), which may provide a clue for further functional and clinical investigations.     

Influence of the protein staining in the fast ultrasonic sample treatment for protein identification through peptide mass fingerprint and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight mass spectrometry

The influence of the protein staining used to visualize protein bands, after in-gel protein separation, for the correct identification of proteins by peptide mass fingerprint (PMF) after application of the ultrasonic in-gel protein protocol was studied. Coomassie brilliant blue and silver nitrate, both visible stains, and the fluorescent dyes Sypro Red and Sypro Orange were evaluated. Results obtained after comparison with the overnight in-gel protocol showed that good results, in terms of protein sequence coverage and number of peptides matched, can be obtained with anyone of the four stains studied. Two minutes of enzymatic digestion time was enough for proteins stained with coomassie blue, while 4 min was necessary when silver or Sypro stainings were employed in order to reach equivalent results to those obtained for the overnigh in-gel protein protocol. For the silver nitrate stain, the concentration of silver present in the staining solution must be 0.09% (w/v) to minimize background in the MALDI mass spectra.     

Analysis of Streptomyces coelicolor membrane proteome using two-dimensional native/native and native/sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis

Analysis of the oligomeric state of a protein may provide insights into its physiological functions. Because membrane proteins are considered to be the workhorses of energy generation and polypeptide and nutrient transportation, in this study we characterized the membrane-associated proteome of Streptomyces coelicolor by two-dimensional (2D) blue native/sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS–PAGE), high-resolution clear native/native PAGE, and native/SDS–PAGE. A total of 77 proteins were identified, and 20 proteins belonging to 15 complexes were characterized. Moreover, the resolution of high-resolution clear native/SDS–PAGE is much higher than that of blue native/SDS–PAGE. OBP (SCO5477) and BldKB (SCO5113) were identified as the main protein spots from the membrane fractions of S. coelicolor M145, suggesting that these two proteins are involved in extracellular peptide transportation. These two transporters exhibited multiple oligomeric states in the native PAGE system, which may suggest their multiple physiological functions in the development of S. coelicolor.