Nanoscale analysis of supported lipid bilayers using atomic force microscopy

During the past 15 years, atomic force microscopy (AFM) has opened new opportunities for imaging supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) on the nanoscale. AFM offers a means to visualize the nanoscale structure of SLBs in physiological conditions. A unique feature of AFM is its ability to monitor dynamic events, like bilayer alteration, remodelling or digestion, upon incubation with various external agents such as drugs, detergents, proteins, peptides, nanoparticles, and solvents. Here, we survey recent progress made in the area.     

Local mobility in lipid domains of supported bilayers characterized by atomic force microscopy and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is used to examine mobility of labeled probes at specific sites in supported bilayers consisting of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) lipid domains in 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC). Those sites are mapped beforehand with simultaneous atomic force microscopy and submicron confocal fluorescence imaging, allowing characterization of probe partitioning between gel DPPC and disordered liquid DOPC domains with corresponding topography of domain structure. We thus examine the relative partitioning and mobility in gel and disordered liquid phases for headgroup- and tailgroup-labeled GM1 ganglioside probes and for headgroup- and tailgroup-labeled phospholipid probes. For the GM1 probes, large differences in mobility between fluid and gel domains are observed; whereas unexpected mobility is observed in submicron gel domains for the phospholipid probes. We attribute the latter to domain heterogeneities that could be induced by the probe. Furthermore, fits to the FCS data for the phospholipid probes in the DOPC fluid phase require two components (fast and slow). Although proximity to the glass substrate may be a factor, local distortion of the probe by the fluorophore could also be important. Overall, we observe nonideal aspects of phospholipid probe mobility and partitioning that may not be restricted to supported bilayers.     

Atomic force microscopy of supported lipid bilayers

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are widely used in biophysical research to investigate the properties of biological membranes and offer exciting prospects in nanobiotechnology. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has become a well-established technique for imaging SLBs at nanometer resolution. A unique feature of AFM is its ability to monitor dynamic processes, such as the interaction of bilayers with proteins and drugs. Here, we present protocols for preparing dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC/DPPC) bilayers supported on mica using small unilamellar vesicles and for imaging their nanoscale interaction with the antibiotic azithromycin using AFM. The entire protocol can be completed in 10 h.     

Immunogold localisation of P-glycoprotein in supported lipid bilayers by transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy

In this study, purified P-glycoprotein molecules, a membrane drug pump responsible for the multidrug resistance phenomenon, were incorporated in model membranes deposited onto solid supports, according to the method described by Puu and Gustafson (1997). The insertion of proteins into planar supported model membranes is of interest, as the films are fundamental in biosensor applications and for the investigation of how proteins conform and aggregate in a lipid environment. In our investigation, two model membranes were prepared by transferring liposomes containing P-glycoprotein to different hydrophobic supports: (a) thin amorphous carbon films; (b) Langmuir–Blodgett lipid monolayers on mica. After the labelling of P-glycoprotein with two well-characterised monoclonal antibodies, MM4.17 and MRK-16, samples (a) were observed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and samples (b) by atomic force microscopy (AFM).The comparative analysis performed by TEM and AFM allowed us to demonstrate the successful insertion of P-glycoprotein in the model membranes and their stability under different environmental conditions (vacuum, air and water). P-glycoprotein appeared to maintain, after purification and insertion in lipid bilayers, a good part of its conformational features as shown by the P-glycoprotein segments bearing the specific monoclonal antibody epitopes.     

Cytochrome c adsorption to supported, anionic lipid bilayers studied via atomic force microscopy

The adsorption of membrane-associated protein cytochrome c to anionic lipid bilayers of dioleoyl phosphatidylglycerol was studied in low ionic strength physiological buffer using atomic force microscopy. The bilayers were supported on polylysinated mica. The formation of stable, single lipid bilayers was confirmed by imaging and force spectroscopy. Upon addition of low concentrations of cytochrome c, protein molecules were not topographically visible on the lipid bilayer-buffer interface. However, the forces required to punch through the bilayer by indentation using the atomic force microscopy probe were significantly lower after protein adsorption, which suggest that the protein inserts into the bilayer. Moreover, the apparent thickness of the bilayer remained unchanged after cytochrome c adsorption. Yet, mass spectroscopy and visible light absorption spectroscopy confirmed the presence of cytochrome c in the lipid bilayers. These results suggest that 1), cytochrome c inserts into the bilayer and resides in its hydrophobic core; 2), cytochrome c insertion changes the mechanical properties of the bilayer significantly; and 3), bilayer force spectroscopy may be a useful tool in investigating lipid-protein interactions.     

Ripples and the formation of anisotropic lipid domains: imaging two-component supported double bilayers by atomic force microscopy

Direct visualization of the fluid-phase/ordered-phase domain structure in mica-supported bilayers composed of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine/1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine mixtures is performed with atomic force microscopy. The system studied is a double bilayer supported on a mica surface in which the top bilayer (which is not in direct contact with the mica) is visualized as a function of temperature. Because the top bilayer is not as restricted by the interactions with the surface as single supported bilayers, its behavior is more similar to a free-standing bilayer. Intriguing straight-edged anisotropic fluid-phase domains were observed in the fluid-phase/ordered-phase coexistence temperature range, which resemble the fluid-phase/ordered-phase domain patterns observed in giant unilamellar vesicles composed of such phospholipid mixtures. With the high resolution provided by atomic force microscopy, we investigated the origin of these anisotropic lipid domain patterns, and found that ripple phase formation is directly responsible for the anisotropic nature of these domains. The nucleation and growth of fluid-phase domains are found to be directed by the presence of ripples. In particular, the fluid-phase domains elongate parallel to the ripples. The results show that ripple phase formation may have implications for domain formation in biological systems.     

Modification of supported lipid membranes by atomic force microscopy

The atomic force microscope (AFM) was used to structurally modify supported lipid bilayers in a controlled quantitative manner. By increasing the force applied by the AFM tip, lipid was removed from the scanned area, leaving a cut through the lipid bilayer. Cuts were repaired with the AFM by scanning the region with a controlled force and driving lipid back into the cut. A slow self-annealing of cuts was also observed.     

Lateral diffusion in planar lipid bilayers: a fluorescence recovery after photobleaching investigation of its modulation by lipid composition, cholesterol, or alamethicin content and divalent cations.

In spite of the fact that planar lipid bilayers are still the best-suited artificial membrane system for the study of reconstituted ion channels and receptors, data dealing with their physical characterization, especially as regards dynamics, are scanty. A combined electrical and optical chamber was designed and allowed fluorescence recovery after photobleaching recovery curves to be recorded from stable virtually solvent-free bilayers. D, the lateral diffusion coefficient of N-(7-nitrobenzoyl-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl)-1,2-dihexadecanoyl-sn- glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine, was found to be relatively insensitive to the phospholipid composition (headgroup, chain unsaturation, etc.), whereas inclusion of 33-50% cholesterol in the membrane reduced D by a factor of 2. Divalent cations significantly reduced D of negatively charged bilayers. These results compare well with data gathered on other model and natural systems. In addition, the incorporation of the voltage-dependent pore-former alamethicin did slightly reduce lipid lateral mobility. This study demonstrates the feasibility of such experiments with planar bilayers, which are amenable to physical constraints, and thus offers new opportunities for systematic studies of structure-function relationships in membrane-associating molecules.     

Determining diffusion coefficients in inhomogeneous tissues using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching

Diffusion plays an important role in the transport of nutrients and signaling molecules in cartilaginous tissues. Diffusion coefficients can be measured by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). Available methods to analyze FRAP data, however, assume homogeneity in the environment of the bleached area and neglect geometrical restrictions to diffusion. Hence, diffusion coefficients in inhomogeneous materials, such as most biological tissues, cannot be assessed accurately. In this study, a new method for analyzing data from FRAP measurements has been developed, which is applicable to inhomogeneous tissues. It is based on a fitting procedure of the intensity recovery after photobleaching with a two-dimensional finite element analysis, which includes Fick's law for diffusion. The finite element analysis can account for distinctive diffusivity in predefined zones, which allows determining diffusion coefficients in inhomogeneous samples. The method is validated theoretically and experimentally in both homogeneous and inhomogeneous tissues and subsequently applied to the proliferation zone of the growth plate. Finally, the importance of accounting for inhomogeneities, for appropriate assessment of diffusivity in inhomogeneous tissues, is illustrated.     

Mechanical properties of pore-spanning lipid bilayers probed by atomic force microscopy

We measure the elastic response of a free-standing lipid membrane to a local indentation by using an atomic force microscope. Starting point is a planar gold-coated alumina substrate with a chemisorbed 3-mercaptopropionic acid monolayer displaying circular pores of very well defined and tunable size, over which bilayers composed of N,N,-dimethyl-N,N,-dioctadecylammonium bromide or 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane chloride were spread. Centrally indenting these "nanodrums" with an atomic force microscope tip yields force-indentation curves, which we quantitatively analyze by solving the corresponding shape equations of continuum curvature elasticity. Since the measured response depends in a known way on the system geometry (pore size, tip radius) and on material parameters (bending modulus, lateral tension), this opens the possibility to monitor local elastic properties of lipid membranes in a well-controlled setting.     

Enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of the supported phospholipid bilayers studied by atomic force microscopy

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is employed to reveal the morphological changes of the supported phospholipid bilayers hydrolyzed by a phospholipase A₂ (PLA₂) enzyme in a buffer solution at room temperature. Based on the high catalytic selectivity of PLA₂ toward l-enantiomer phospholipids, five kinds of supported bilayers made of l- and d-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholines (DPPC), including l-DPPC (upper leaflet adjacent to solution)/l-DPPC (bottom leaflet) (or l/l in short), l/d, d/l, d/d, and racemic ld/ld, were prepared on a mica surface in gel-phase, to explicate the kinetics and mechanism of the enzyme-induced hydrolysis reaction in detail. AFM observations for the l/l bilayer show that the hydrolysis rate for l-DPPC is significantly increased by PLA₂ and most of the hydrolysis products desorb from substrate surface in 40 min. As d-enantiomers are included in the bilayer, the hydrolysis rate is largely decreased in comparison with the l/l bilayer. The time used to hydrolyze the as-prepared bilayers by PLA₂ increases in the sequence of l/l, l/d, ld/ld, and d/l (d/d is inert to the enzyme action). d-enantiomers in the enantiomer hybrid bilayers remain on the mica surface at the end of the hydrolysis reaction. It was confirmed that the hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by PLA₂ preferentially occurs at the edges of pits or defects on the bilayer surface. The bilayer structures are preserved during the hydrolysis process. Based on these observations, a novel kinetics model is proposed to quantitatively account for the PLA₂-catalyzed hydrolysis of the supported phospholipid bilayers. The model simulation demonstrates that PLA₂ mainly binds with lipids at the perimeter of defects in the upper leaflet and leads to a hydrolysis reaction, yielding species soluble to the solution phase. The lipid molecules underneath subsequently flip up to the upper leaflet to maintain the hydrophilicity of the bilayer structure. Our analysis shows that d-enantiomers in the hybrid bilayers considerably reduce the hydrolysis rate by its ineffective binding with PLA₂.     

Domain growth, shapes, and topology in cationic lipid bilayers on mica by fluorescence and atomic force microscopy

Domain formation in mica-supported cationic bilayers of dipalmitoyltrimethylammoniumpropane (DPTAP) and dimyristoyltrimethylammoniumpropane (DMTAP), fluorescently doped with an NBD (((7-nitro-2-1, 3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)amino)caproyl) phospholipid, was investigated with fluorescence microscopy and atomic force microscopy. Heating above the acyl chain melting temperature and cooling to room temperature resulted in nucleation and growth of domains with distinguishable patterns. Fractal patterns were found for DPTAP, whereas DMTAP domains were elongated and triangular with feathery edges. Reducing the cooling rate or probe concentration for DPTAP bilayers resulted in larger, filled-in domains with more rounded edges. However, for DMTAP, cooling rates mainly affected size and only slightly modified domain morphology. In a saline environment, the domains were dark, and the surrounding continuous region was bright and thus contained the fluorescent probe. However, as the salt concentration was decreased, the dark regions percolated (connected), resulting in bright domains. Atomic force microscopy scans along domain edges revealed that the dark regions in fluorescence images were approximately 1.4 nm thicker than the light regions. Additionally, the dark regions were of bilayer thickness, approximately 4 nm. Comparison of these results in bilayers to well-documented behavior in Langmuir monolayers has revealed many similarities (and some differences) and is therefore useful for understanding our observations and identifying possible growth mechanisms that may occur in domain formation in cell membranes or supported membrane systems.     

Size dependence of the translational diffusion of large integral membrane proteins in liquid-crystalline phase lipid bilayers. A study using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching

The translational diffusion of bovine rhodopsin, the Ca2+-activated adenosinetriphosphatase of rabbit muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum, and the acetylcholine receptor monomer of Torpedo marmorata has been examined at a high dilution (molar ratios of lipid/protein greater than or equal to 3000/1) in liquid-crystalline phase phospholipid bilayer membranes by using the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching technique. These integral membrane proteins having molecular weights of about 37 000 for rhodopsin, about 100 000 for the adenosinetriphosphatase, and about 250 000 for the acetylcholine receptor were reconstituted into membranes of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (rhodopsin and acetylcholine receptor), soybean lipids (acetylcholine receptor), and a total lipid extract of rabbit muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum (adenosinetriphosphatase). The translational diffusion coefficients of all the proteins at 310 K were found to be in the range (1-3) X 10(-8) cm2/s. In consideration of the sizes of the membrane-bound portions of these proteins, this result is in agreement with the weak dependence of the translational diffusion coefficient upon diffusing particle size predicted by continuum fluid hydrodynamic models for the diffusion in membranes [Saffman, P. G., & Delbrück, M. (1975) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 72, 3111-3113]. Lipid diffusion was also examined in th same lipid bilayers with the fluorescent lipid derivative N-(7-nitro-2,1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine. The translational diffusion coefficient for this lipid derivative was found to be in the range (9-14) X 10(-8) cm2/s at 310 K. In consideration of the dimensions of the lipid molecule, this value for the lipid diffusion coefficient is in agreement with the continuum fluid hydrodynamic model only if a near-complete slip boundary condition is assumed at the bilayer midplane. Alternatively, kinetic diffusion models [Tr?uble, H., & Sackmann. E. (1972) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 94, 4499-4510] may have to be invoked to explain the lipid diffusion behavior.     

Organization and synergistic binding of copine I and annexin A1 on supported lipid bilayers observed by atomic force microscopy

The transduction of signals across the plasma membrane of cells after receptor activation frequently involves the assembly of interacting protein molecules on the cytoplasmic face of the membrane. However, the structural organization and dynamics of the formation of such complexes has not been well defined. In this study atomic force microscopy was used to monitor the assemblies formed in vitro by two classes of calcium-dependent, membrane-binding proteins that participate in the formation of signaling complexes on membranes - the annexins and the copines. When applied to supported lipid bilayers composed of 25% brain phosphatidylserine and 75% dioleyl phosphatidylcholine in the presence of 1 mM Ca²⁺ both human annexin A1 and human copine I bound only to specialized domains that appeared to be 0.5 to 1.0 nm lower than the rest of the bilayer. These domains may be enriched in phosphatidylserine and have a more disordered structure allowing probe penetration. Confinement of the binding of the proteins to these domains may be important in the process of concentrating other signaling proteins bound to the copine or annexin. The binding of the annexin promoted the growth of the domains and created additional binding space for the copine. This may reflect a general ability of annexins to alter membrane structure in such a way that C2 domain-containing proteins like copine can bind. Copine I formed a reticular lattice composed of linear elements approximately 45 nm long on the specialized domains. This lattice might provide a scaffold for the assembly and interaction of copine target proteins in signaling complexes.     

Lipid asymmetry in DLPC/DSPC-supported lipid bilayers: a combined AFM and fluorescence microscopy study

A fundamental attribute of cell membranes is transmembrane asymmetry, specifically the formation of ordered phase domains in one leaflet that are compositionally different from the opposing leaflet of the bilayer. Using model membrane systems, many previous studies have demonstrated the formation of ordered phase domains that display complete transmembrane symmetry; but there have been few reports on the more biologically relevant asymmetric membrane structures. Here we report on a combined atomic force microscopy and fluorescence microscopy study whereby we observe three different states of transmembrane symmetry in phase-separated supported lipid bilayers formed by vesicle fusion. We find that if the leaflets differ in gel-phase area fraction, then the smaller domains in one leaflet are in registry with the larger domains in the other leaflet and the system is dynamic. In a presumed lipid flip-flop process similar to Ostwald ripening, the smaller domains in one leaflet erode away whereas the large domains in the other leaflet grow until complete compositional asymmetry is reached and remains stable. We have quantified this evolution and determined that the lipid flip-flop event happens most frequently at the interface between symmetric and asymmetric DSPC domains. If both leaflets have identical area fraction of gel-phase, gel-phase domains are in registry and are static in comparison to the first state. The stability of these three DSPC domain distributions, the degree of registry observed, and the domain immobility have biological significance with regards to maintenance of lipid asymmetry in living cell membranes, communication between inner leaflet and outer leaflet, membrane adhesion, and raft mobility.     

High-speed near-field fluorescence microscopy combined with high-speed atomic force microscopy for biological studies

BackgroundHigh-speed atomic force microscopy (HS-AFM) has successfully visualized a variety of protein molecules during their functional activity. However, it cannot visualize small molecules interacting with proteins and even protein molecules when they are encapsulated. Thus, it has been desired to achieve techniques enabling simultaneous optical/AFM imaging at high spatiotemporal resolution with high correlation accuracy.MethodsScanning near-field optical microscopy (SNOM) is a candidate for the combination with HS-AFM. However, the imaging rate of SNOM has been far below that of HS-AFM. We here developed HS-SNOM and metal tip-enhanced total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM) by exploiting tip-scan HS-AFM and exploring methods to fabricate a metallic tip on a tiny HS-AFM cantilever.ResultsIn tip-enhanced TIRFM/HS-AFM, simultaneous video recording of the two modalities of images was demonstrated in the presence of fluorescent molecules in the bulk solution at relatively high concentration. By using fabricated metal-tip cantilevers together with our tip-scan HS-AFM setup equipped with SNOM optics, we could perform simultaneous HS-SNOM/HS-AFM imaging, with correlation analysis between the two overlaid images being facilitated.ConclusionsThis study materialized simultaneous tip-enhanced TIRFM/HS-AFM and HS-SNOM/HS-AFM imaging at high spatiotemporal resolution. Although some issues remain to be solved in the future, these correlative microscopy methods have a potential to increase the versatility of HS-AFM in biological research.General significanceWe achieved an imaging rate of ~3 s/frame for SNOM imaging, more than 100-times higher than the typical SNOM imaging rate. We also demonstrated ~39 nm resolution in HS-SNOM imaging of fluorescently labeled DNA in solution.     

Molecular diffusion within sol-gel derived matrices viewed via fluorescence recovery after photobleaching.

A suitable matrix to host enzymes for biosensor applications should encage and retain the bioactive species, while allowing it to be accessed to exploit its catalytic properties. Sol-gel derived monoliths are promising in this aspect. Molecular diffusion was monitored using fluorescence labelled proteins and unbound fluorescence dye molecules (representative of enzyme substrates) and their interaction with and mobility within the host assessed using time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching observed via confocal microscopy.     

An ultrastructural readout of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching using correlative light and electron microscopy

Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) provides an important quantitative readout of the mobility of fluorescently tagged structures in live tissue. Here we present a protocol for visualizing FRAP signal at the ultrastructural level, permitting the nature of recovered fluorescence signal to be studied at greater resolution than afforded by conventional light microscopy. Specifically we use FRAP, fixation, photoconversion and correlative light and electron microscopy (CLEM) to examine the ultrastructural organization of mobile FM1-43-labeled vesicles in synapses of cultured hippocampal neurons. At photobleached synapses, the FRAP signal can be visualized as photoconverted electron-dense vesicles. The combination of FRAP and CLEM provides a powerful tool for examining the specific localization of imported vesicles in relation to synaptic architecture. Moreover, with the increasing availability of photoconvertible fluorophores, this approach should be readily applicable to other systems where an ultrastructural characterization of FRAP signal is desirable. After cultures are prepared and ready to use, this protocol takes 2-3 days.     

Macromolecular diffusion of biological polymers measured by confocal fluorescence recovery after photobleaching.

Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching with an unmodified confocal laser scanning microscope (confocal FRAP) was used to determine the diffusion properties of network forming biological macromolecules such as aggrecan. The technique was validated using fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-labeled dextrans and proteins (molecular mass 4-2000 kDa) at 25 degrees C and with fluorescent microspheres (207 nm diameter) over a temperature range of 5-50 degrees C. Lateral diffusion coefficients (D) were independent of the focus position, and the degree and extent of bleach. The free diffusion coefficient (Do) of FITC-aggrecan determined by confocal FRAP was 4.25 +/- 0.6 x 10(-8) cm2 s-1, which is compatible with dynamic laser light scattering measurements. It appeared to be independent of concentration below 2.0 mg/ml, but at higher concentrations (2-20 mg/ml) the self-diffusion coefficient followed the function D = Do(e)(-Bc). The concentration at which the self-diffusion coefficient began to fall corresponded to the concentration predicted for domain overlap. Multimolecular aggregates of aggrecan ( approximately 30 monomers) had a much lower free diffusion coefficient (Do = 6.6 +/- 1.0 x 10(-9) cm2 s-1) but showed a decrease in mobility with concentration of a form similar to that of the monomer. The method provides a technique for investigating the macromolecular organization in glycan-rich networks at concentrations close to those found physiologically.     

Measurement of molecular diffusion in solution by multiphoton fluorescence photobleaching recovery

Multiphoton fluorescence photobleaching recovery (MP-FPR) is a technique for measuring the three-dimensional (3D) mobility of fluorescent molecules with 3D spatial resolution of a few microns. A brief, intense flash of mode-locked laser light pulses excites fluorescent molecules via multiphoton excitation in an ellipsoidal focal volume and photobleaches a fraction. Because multiphoton excitation of fluorophores is intrinsically confined to the high-intensity focal volume of the illuminating beam, the bleached region is restricted to a known, three-dimensionally defined volume. Fluorescence in this focal volume is measured with multiphoton excitation, using the attenuated laser beam to measure fluorescence recovery as fresh unbleached dye diffuses in. The time course of the fluorescence recovery signal after photobleaching can be analyzed to determine the diffusion coefficient of the fluorescent species. The mathematical formulas used to fit MP-FPR recovery curves and the techniques needed to properly utilize them to acquire the diffusion coefficients of fluorescently labeled molecules within cells are presented here. MP-FPR is demonstrated on calcein in RBL-2H3 cells, using an anomalous subdiffusion model, as well as in aqueous solutions of wild-type green fluorescent protein, yielding a diffusion coefficient of 8.7 x 10(-7) cm(2)s(-1) in excellent agreement with the results of other techniques.