A comparison of BRCA1 mutation analysis by direct sequencing, SSCP and DHPLC

The most sensitive screening technique for genes that predispose patients for particular cancers is direct sequencing. However, sequencing of complex genes is technically demanding, costly and time-consuming. We have tested alternate screening techniques to find a fast sensitive method for detecting alterations of DNA in the large BRCA1 gene prior to sequencing. Sequencing of this gene is particularly arduous because it lacks clearly defined mutation sites. The single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) technique is one of the most frequently used pre-screening methods but its sensitivity and efficiency is not completely satisfying. We have compared the SSCP assay with a newly developed technique called denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) to screen the BRCA1gene. We studied 23 patients at high risk for early onset breast and ovarian cancer and four controls. In these patients, a total of 113 fragments with sequence variations in the BRCA1 gene could be identified. The DHPLC technique resolved 100% of the DNA alterations that were observed in cycle sequencing. In contrast, mutation analysis by SSCP accounted for 94% of the detected variations. In addition, DHPLC screening allowed us to discriminate between different alterations in a single fragment, because of the characteristic elution profiles of the DNA molecules. Polymorphisms that were present in our samples could be predicted by means of DHPLC testing independently of sequence analysis. We conclude that DHPLC is a highly potent screening method for genetic analyses. It is highly sensitive, efficient and economical and can be automated. Electronic Publication     

Detection of DNA sequence polymorphisms by enzymatic amplification and direct genomic sequencing.

The discovery of RFLPs and their utilization as genetic markers has revolutionized research in human molecular genetics. However, only a fraction of the DNA sequence polymorphisms in the human genome affect the length of a restriction fragment and hence result in an RFLP. Polymorphisms that are not detected as RFLPs are typically passed over in the screening process though they represent a potentially important source of informative genetic markers. We have used a rapid method for the detection of naturally occurring DNA sequence variations that is based on enzymatic amplification and direct sequencing of genomic DNA. This approach can detect essentially all useful sequence variations within the region screened. We demonstrate the feasibility of the technique by applying it to the human retinoblastoma susceptibility locus. We screened 3,712 bp of genomic DNA from each of nine individuals and found four DNA sequence polymorphisms. At least one of these DNA sequence polymorphisms was informative in each of three families with hereditary retinoblastoma that were not informative with any of the known RFLPs at this locus. We believe that direct sequencing is a reasonable alternative to other methods of screening for DNA sequence polymorphisms and that it represents a step forward for obtaining informative markers at well-characterized loci that have been minimally informative in the past.     

A simple method for non-radioactive PCR-SSCP using MDE gel solution and a midi gel format: application for the detection of variants in the GLUT1 and CTLA-4 genes

The need to identify disease-causing mutations and DNA polymorphisms has increased with the continuing identification of new candidate genes. PCR single-strand conformation polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) is one of the techniques most widely used to identify a mutant sequence or a polymorphism in a known gene. However, the original SSCP protocols using the incorporation of radioactive label and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis on sequencing gels for detection were labour intensive and time-consuming. Here we describe a simple SSCP protocol using MDE gel solution and a midi gel format to detect SSCP variations in the glucose transporter gene GLUT1, that we have previously analysed with the standard radioactive SSCP protocol, and we have also tested this method on the previously described point mutation (A/G transition in exon 1) of the CTLA-4 (cytotoxic T lymphocyte associated-4) gene. All known variants were detected. Based on the results, this technique appears to be simple, with no use of radioactive labels and with easy handling of the gel. Furthermore, it needs little optimisation, is relatively rapid and highly sensitive. We propose this method for the first screening for candidate gene variants.     

Mutation detection in the breast cancer gene BRCA1 using the protein truncation test

About 400 distinct mutations have been defined in the BRCA1 gene, and these are spread fairly evenly through the 5592 bp of coding DNA. This circumstance presents a formidable challenge for mutation screening. Apart from total direct sequencing, the preferred screening method has been single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) gels, with a smaller input from constant denaturant gradient electrophoresis (CDGE), heteroduplex (HD) analysis, and mismatch cleavage. The protein truncation test (PTT) was used early in BRCA1 mutation screening but has not been widely adopted, perhaps because a straightforward analysis of the whole BRCA1 gene requires working with RNA and all its perceived problems. The present work was undertaken to assess the practicality of using the PTT under routine conditions for the screening of long genes such as BRCA1 that are not highly expressed in lymphocytes. We conclude that, provided RNA preparation is carried out effectively and consistently, the PTT approach has significant advantages over other methodologies such as SSCP gels.     

Detection of eight BRCA1 mutations in 10 breast/ovarian cancer families, including 1 family with male breast cancer.

Genetic epidemiological evidence suggests that mutations in BRCA1 may be responsible for approximately one half of early onset familial breast cancer and the majority of familial breast/ovarian cancer. The recent cloning of BRCA1 allows for the direct detection of mutations, but the feasibility of presymptomatic screening for cancer susceptibility is unknown. We analyzed genomic DNA from one affected individual from each of 24 families with at least three cases of ovarian or breast cancer, using SSCP assays. Variant SSCP bands were subcloned and sequenced. Allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization was used to verify sequence changes and to screen DNA from control individuals. Six frameshift and two missense mutations were detected in 10 different families. A frameshift mutation was detected in a male proband affected with both breast and prostate cancer. A 40-bp deletion was detected in a patient who developed intra-abdominal carcinomatosis 1 year after prophylactic oophorectomy. Mutations were detected throughout the gene, and only one was detected in more than a single family. These results provide further evidence that inherited breast and ovarian cancer can occur as a consequence of a wide array of BRCA1 mutations. These results suggests that development of a screening test for BRCA1 mutations will be technically challenging. The finding of a mutation in a family with male breast cancer, not previously thought to be related to BRCA1, also illustrates the potential difficulties of genetic counseling for individuals known to carry mutations.     

Analysis of gyrA mutations in quinolone-resistant and -susceptible Campylobacter jejuni isolates from retail poultry and human clinical isolates by non-radioactive single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis and DNA sequencing

AIMS: The aims of this study were to characterize the molecular variations in the quinolone resistance-determining region (QRDR) of gyrA among quinolone-resistant and -susceptible Campylobacter jejuni isolates originating from foods of animal origin and human infections and to evaluate the suitability of the single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) method as a screening method for molecular characterization of fluoroquinolone resistance. METHODS AND RESULTS: Alterations in QRDR of gyrA from 182 C. jejuni isolates were determined by nonradioisotopic SSCP analysis and direct sequencing. A total of 13 types of nucleic acid sequence combinations within the QRDR of the gyrA gene resulted in 11 different SSCP patterns. All nalidixic acid resistant strains possessed nucleotide substitution at either codon Thr-86 or Asp-90. Silent mutations were detected additionally. Thr-86 to Ile mutation was detected in all 139 ciprofloxacin resistant strains, which showed cross-resistance to nalidixic acid. CONCLUSIONS: The SSCP method is suitable for a molecular screening of quinolone resistant C. jejuni isolates and in combination with DNA sequencing suitable to detect genetic variations of the QRDR of gyrA. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY: This study provides data of the genetic variations of the QRDR of gyrA from C. jejuni isolates of foods and human beings.     

SSCP is not so difficult: the application and utility of single-stranded conformation polymorphism in evolutionary biology and molecular ecology

All genetic markers are estimators of DNA nucleotide sequence variation. Rather than obtaining DNA sequence data, it is cheaper and faster to use techniques that estimate sequence variation, although this usually results in the loss of some information. SSCP (single-stranded conformation polymorphism) offers a sensitive but inexpensive, rapid, and convenient method for determining which DNA samples in a set differ in sequence, so that only an informative subset need be sequenced. In short, most DNA sequence variation can be detected with relatively little sequencing. SSCP has been widely applied in medical diagnosis, yet few studies have been published in population genetics. The utility and convenience of SSCP is far from fully appreciated by molecular population biologists. We hope to help redress this by illustrating the application of a single simple SSCP protocol to mitochondrial genes, nuclear introns, microsatellites, and anonymous nuclear sequences, in a range of vertebrates and invertebrates.     

Optimized sample preparation for tandem capillary electrophoresis single-stranded conformational polymorphism/ heteroduplex analysis

Here we describe DNA sample preparation methods that allow the rapid, simultaneous generation of both single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP) and heteroduplex DNA elements from a single sample in a single tube, which are suitable for direct injection into a capillary electrophoresis (CE) instrument with excellent sensitivity of genetic mutation detection. The p53 gene was used as a model DNA region for this study, which was performed on a high-throughput MegaBACE 96-capillary array electrophoresis instrument. We found that, contrary to the practice common in slab-gel SSCP analysis, denaturants such as formamide are incompatible with this novel technique because they result in homo- and heteroduplex peak broadening in CE (possibly as a result of incomplete dsDNA re-hybridization) that reduces the peak resolution and hence the sensitivity of mutation detection. We also have found that PCR buffers, which are typically used to suspend samples for slab-gel heteroduplex analysis (HA), but which are less suitable for CE because of the presence of extra salt that reduces the efficiency of electrokinetic injection, may be substituted with a 10 mM Tris-HCI buffer (pH 8.5). The use of this Tris-HCl buffer for sample preparation provides both a high sensitivity of mutation detection by tandem SSCP/HA and high efficiency ofelectrokinetic injection by CE. In a related study (published elsewhere), we have applied this optimized protocol to the screening of a set of 32 mutant DNA samples from p53 exons 7 and 8 and recorded 100% sensitivity of mutation detection for tandem CE-SSCP/HA, whereas each individual method yielded lower sensitivity on its own (93% for SSCP and 75% for HA).     

Combined SSCP/duplex analysis by capillary electrophoresis for more efficient mutation detection

SSCP and heteroduplex analysis (HA) continue to be the most popular methods of mutation detection due to their simplicity, high sensitivity and low cost. The advantages of these methods are most clearly visible when large genes, such as BRCA1 and BRCA2, are scanned for scattered unknown mutations and/or when a large number of DNA samples is screened for specific mutations. Here we describe a novel combined SSCP/duplex analysis adapted to the modern capillary electrophoresis (CE) system, which takes advantage of multicolor labeling of DNA fragments and laser-induced fluorescence detection. In developing this method, we first established the optimum conditions for homoduplex and heteroduplex analysis by CE. These were determined based on comprehensive analysis of representative Tamra-500 markers and BRCA1 fragments at different concentrations of sieving polymer and temperatures in the presence or absence of glycerol. The intrinsic features of DNA duplex structures are discussed in detail to explain differences in the migration rates between various types of duplexes. When combined SSCP/duplex analysis was carried out in single conditions, those found to be optimal for analysis of duplexes, all 31 BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations, polymorphisms and variants tested were detected. It is worth noting that the panel of analyzed sequence variants was enriched in base substitutions, which are usually more difficult to detect. The sensitivity of mutation detection in the SSCP portion alone was 90%, and that in the duplex portion was 81% in the single conditions of electrophoresis. As is also shown here, the proposed combined SSCP/duplex analysis by CE has the potential of being applied to the analysis of pooled genomic DNA samples, and to multiplex analysis of amplicons from different gene fragments. These modifications may further reduce the costs of analysis, making the method attractive for large scale application in SNP scanning and screening.     

SNP frequency and allelic haplotype structure of Beta vulgaris expressed genes

Based on EST sequences, fragments of 37 genes have been amplified and sequenced in two inbred lines of sugar beet. The rate of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) corresponded to 1 every 130 bp, with an average (nucleotide diversity) value of 7.6×10^–3. When extrapolated to the whole sugar beet genome, randomly compared lines differ at 5.4×10⁶ SNPs in the genetic pool considered. In a wider search for SNP-related polymorphisms, 96 fragments of expressed genes were scanned with SSCP (single-strand conformation polymorphism) and heteroduplex (HA) analyses in 8 inbred lines. One SSCP or HA polymorphism was found every 1,470 bp of amplified DNA, corresponding to 5×10⁵ SSCP or HA loci in the whole genome. This frequency, 11 times lower than the SNP rate, was attributed to the high frequency of base pair substitution along the amplified fragment analysed electrophoretically. Therefore nucleotide variability was further studied by sequencing fragments of 10 genes in the same 8 lines. The results indicate that sugar beet alleles of expressed genes are very frequently organized as robust intragene haplotypes. In the 8 lines analysed, two haplotypes were identified for each of three gene fragments, three haplotypes for six gene fragments and four haplotypes for one gene fragment which is in good correspondence with the number of alleles detected by SSCP and HA analysis. In a cross between two lines, SSCP or HA alleles of expressed genes have 54% probability to be different.     

Autosomal dominant retinal dystrophy (Rdy) in Abyssinian cats: exclusion of PDE6G and ROM1 and likely exclusion of Rhodopsin as candidate genes

Retinal dystrophy (Rdy) is an autosomal dominant photoreceptor dysplasia of Abyssinian cats and a model for autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa (ADRP) in man. We have pursued a candidate gene approach in the search for the causal mutation in Rdy. The genes RHO (encoding rhodopsin), ROM1 (encoding the structural retinal outer-membrane protein-1) and PDE6G (encoding the gamma subunit of the visual transduction protein cyclic guanosine monophosphate-phosphodiesterase) were polymerase chain reaction-amplified from normal feline genomic DNA. Leader, coding and 3' untranslated regions of each gene, and parts of introns were sequenced. Single-stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis of Rdy-affected and normal cats was used to identify intragenic polymorphisms within ROM1 and PDE6G. DNA sequencing of all three genes in Rdy-affected cats was used to confirm results from SSCP. For both ROM1 and PDE6G polymorphisms identified by SSCP and sequencing showed disconcordance between the polymorphism and the disease phenotype within an Rdy disease pedigree. SSCP analysis of RHO performed across the 5' untranslated region, the entire coding sequence and the intron/exon boundaries in Rdy-affected and control cats failed to identify any intragenic polymorphisms that could be used for linkage analysis. DNA sequencing of these regions showed no differences between Rdy-affected and control cats. Mutations in ROM1 or in PDE6G are not causative of feline Rdy. The absence of potentially pathogenic polymorphisms in sequenced portions of the RHO gene makes it unlikely that a mutation in this gene is the cause of Rdy.     

Four new nucleotide sequence polymorphisms in the LDL receptor gene detected by SSCP analysis

Seven nucleotide sequence polymorphisms were detected within exons of the low-density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor gene using single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis followed by direct sequence analysis on amplified DNA. Four nucleotide changes at nucleotide positions 1617, 1725, 2232, and 2635 were new nucleotide sequence polymorphisms not previously described. The remaining three nucleotide changes were identical with restriction fragment length polymorphisms and a previously reported nucleotide sequence polymorphism. These nucleotide sequence polymorphisms, detectable by SSCP analysis, are useful genetic markers for linkage analysis of the LDL receptor gene and familial hypercholesterolemia.     

Analyses of soil fungal communities in adjacent natural forest and hoop pine plantation ecosystems of subtropical Australia using molecular approaches based on 18S rRNA genes

Soil fungal communities were studied using 18S rDNA-based molecular techniques. Soil DNA was analyzed using temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE), single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP), cloning and sequencing methods, following community DNA extraction and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The extracted community DNA was successfully amplified using the primer pair of EF4f-Fung5r which produced ca. 550bp 18S rDNA fragments. TGGE screening of the PCR products showed some differences in band position and intensity between two soil samples in adjacent natural forest (YNF) and hoop pine plantation (YHP) ecosystems at Yarraman in subtropical Australia. TGGE and SSCP could be used for screening PCR products. However, care must be exercised when interpreting the TGGE and SSCP results with respect to microbial diversity, because one band may not necessarily represent one species. It is recommended that the PCR products should be purified before TGGE or SSCP screening. SSCP screening of the clone sequences revealed differences among the clones. Sequence and phylogenetic analyses revealed that all obtained clones were affiliated to the kingdom Fungi, including three phyla, i.e., Zygomycota, Ascomycota and Basidiomycota. Our results suggested that community DNA extraction, PCR, cloning, SSCP screening of clones, sequencing of selected clones and phylogentic analyses could be a good strategy in investigation of soil fungal community and diversity.     

Single nucleotide polymorphisms in clinical genetic testing: the characterization of the clinical significance of genetic variants and their application in clinical research for BRCA1

Clinical genetic testing is increasingly employed in the medical management of cancer patients. These tests support a variety of clinical decisions by providing results that indicate risk for future disease, confirmation of diagnoses, and more recently, therapeutic selection and prognosis. Most genetic variation detected during clinical testing involves single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Continued advances in the technologies of genetic analyses make these tests increasingly sensitive, cost-effective and timely, which contribute to their increased utilization. Conversely, it has proven difficult to characterize the clinical significance of genetic variants that do not obviously truncate the open reading frames of genes. These genetic variants of uncertain clinical significance diminish the value of genetic test results. This article highlights a variety of approaches that have emerged from research in diverse disciplines to solve the problem, including the application of information about common SNPs in multiple methods to better characterize clinically uncertain variants. Hereditary breast/ovarian cancer, and in particular BRCA1, provides a framework for this discussion. BRCA1 is particularly interesting in this respect since clinical genetic testing by direct DNA sequencing for over 50,000 patients in North America has revealed approximately 1500 genetic variants to date. This large data set combined with the clinical significance of BRCA1 have resulted in research groups selecting BRCA1 as a preferred gene to evaluate novel methods in this field. Finally, the lessons learned through work with BRCA1 are highly applicable to many other genes associated with cancer risk.     

A novel mutant (transthyretin Ile-50) related to amyloid polyneuropathy. Single-strand conformation polymorphism as a new genetic marker.

DNA sequence polymorphisms in transthyretin (TTR) genes were investigated by single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis of polymerase chain reaction products. The amplified DNA fragments that encode each exon of the normal TTR gene showed two bands, representing the two complementary single strands of DNA. In one patient with amyloid polyneuropathy, the exon 3 DNA showed a unique, aberrant migration pattern. Direct sequencing analysis of the amplified exon 3 revealed a single base change (G-to-T), resulting in a novel amino acid substitution (Ser-50----Ile). We also present the SSCP patterns for five known Japanese TTR variants.     

Nucleotide sequence polymorphism within exon 4 of the bovine prolactin gene and its associations with milk performance traits

Prolactin plays an important regulatory function in mammary gland development, milk secretion, and expression of milk protein genes. Hence the PRL gene is a potential quantitative trait locus and genetic marker of production traits in dairy cattle. We analysed the sequence of the PRL gene to investigate whether mutations in this sequence might be responsible for quantitative variations in milk yield and composition. Using SSCP and direct sequencing, we detected six single-nucleotide polymorphisms within a 294-bp prolactin gene fragment involving exon 4. All detected mutations were silent with respect to the amino acid sequence of the protein. PCR-RFLP genotyping of SNP 8398 R (RsaI) was used to assess allele frequencies in 186 Black-and-White cows (0.113 and 0.887 for A and G, respectively) and in 138 Jersey cows (0.706 and 0.294 for A and G, respectively). Black-and-White cows with genotype AG showed the highest milk yield, while cows with genotype GG showed the highest fat content.     

Direct amplification of length polymorphisms (DALP), or how to get and characterize new genetic markers in many species.

Direct amplification of length polymorphisms (DALP) uses an arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) to produce genomic fingerprints and to enable sequencing of DNA polymorphisms in virtually any species. Oligonucleotide pairs were designed to each produce a specific multi-banded pattern and all the fragments thus generated can be directly sequenced with the same two universal M13 sequencing primers. This strategy combines the advantages of a high resolution fingerprint technique and the possibility of characterizing the polymorphisms. The use of family members as templates in the multi-locus detection step allows a direct test of allele transmission, as well as early mapping of the markers or selection of loci associated with some traits or diseases. We used this method to detect micro-deletions/insertions and microsatellite DNA loci useful in population genetics studies, but it could be applied in many other fields of biology, such as genome mapping for definition of polymorphic sequence tagged sites, directly localized on a genetic map.     

TILLING,high-resolution melting (HRM), and next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques in plant mutation breeding

Induced mutations have been used effectively for plant improvement. Physical and chemical mutagens induce a high frequency of genome variation. Recently, developed screening methods have allowed the detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and the identification of traits that are difficult to identify at the molecular level by conventional breeding. With the assistance of reverse genetic techniques, sequence variation information can be linked to traits to investigate gene function. Targeting induced local lesions in genomes (TILLING) is a high-throughput technique to identify single nucleotide mutations in a specific region of a gene of interest with a powerful detection method resulted from chemical-induced mutagenesis. The main advantage of TILLING as a reverse genetics strategy is that it can be applied to any species, regardless of genome size and ploidy level. However, TILLING requires laborious and time-consuming steps, and a lack of complete genome sequence information for many crop species has slowed the development of suitable TILLING targets. Another method, high-resolution melting (HRM), which has assisted TILLING in mutation detection, is faster, simpler and less expensive with non-enzymatic screening system. Currently, the sequencing of crop genomes has completely changed our vision and interpretation of genome organization and evolution. Impressive progress in next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies has paved the way for the detection and exploitation of genetic variation in a given DNA or RNA molecule. This review discusses the applications of TILLING in combination with HRM and NGS technologies for screening of induced mutations and discovering SNPs in mutation breeding programs.     

Single strand conformation polymorphism is a sensitive method for screening nucleotide variations in Mycosphaerella graminicola

Single Strand Conformation Polymorphism (SSCP) and sequencing were performed in order to assess molecular polymorphism of mating type sequences in the heterothallic ascomycete Mycosphaerella graminicola, the causal agent of Septoria tritici blotch of wheat. The screening was undertaken on mat1-1 and mat1-2 partial sequences of 341 and 657 bp, respectively, amplified with multiplex PCR from 510 French single-conidial strains plus the two reference isolates IPO323 and IPO94269 from The Netherlands. After restriction with Taq1 in order to reduce the fragment sizes, all digested amplicons were subjected to SSCP. Sequencing was then performed when a SSCP pattern deviates from the most frequently occurring profile. Among the assessed strains, 228 ones plus IPO323 were MAT1-1 and 282 ones plus IPO94269 were MAT1-2. Among the MAT1-1 strains, only a single one exhibited a SSCP profile distinct to the other MAT1-1 strains, whereas 10 MAT1-2 strains (among which 2 and 4 with same profiles, respectively) showed a SSCP profile differing to the other MAT1-2 strains. Sequencing revealed that all polymorphisms observed on SSCP gels were single nucleotide variations and all strains displaying the same SSCP profiles showed identical nucleotide sequences. Among the seven disclosed nucleotide variations, only two were non-synonymous and both were non-conservative. This study reports a high sensitivity of SSCP allowing detection of single point mutations in M. graminicola, shows a conservation of mating type idiomorphs in the fungus at both sequence and population scales, but also suggests a difference in polymorphism level between the two mating type sequences.