Selenocysteine inserting tRNAs: an overview

One of the recent discoveries in protein biosynthesis was the finding that selenocysteine, the 21st amino acid, is cotranslationally inserted into polypeptides under the direction of a UGA codon assisted by a specific structural signal in the mRNA. The key to selenocysteine biosynthesis and insertion is a special tRNA species, tRNA(Sec). The formation of selenocysteine from serine represents an interesting tRNA-mediated amino acid transformation. tRNA(Sec) (or the gene encoding it) has been found over all three domains of life. It displays a number of unique features that designate it a selenocysteine-inserting tRNA and differentiate it from canonical elongator tRNAs. Although there are still some uncertainties concerning the precise secondary and tertiary structures of eukaryal tRNA(Sec), the major identity determinant for selenocysteine biosynthesis and insertion appears to be the 13 bp long extended acceptor arm. In addition the core of the 3D structure of these tRNAs is different from that of class II tRNAs like tRNA(Sec). The biological implications of these structural differences still remain to be fully understood.     

Coding from a distance: dissection of the mRNA determinants required for the incorporation of selenocysteine into protein.

Incorporation of selenocysteine into proteins is directed by specifically 'programmed' UGA codons. The determinants for recognition of the selenocysteine codon have been investigated by analysing the effect of mutations in fdhF, the gene for formate dehydrogenase H of Escherichia coli, on selenocysteine incorporation. It was found that selenocysteine was also encoded when the UGA codon was replaced by UAA and UAG, provided a proper codon-anticodon interaction was possible with tRNA(Sec). This indicates that none of the three termination codons can function as efficient translational stop signals in that particular mRNA position. The discrimination of the selenocysteine 'sense' codon from a regular stop codon has previously been shown to be dependent on an RNA secondary structure immediately 3' of the UGA codon in the fdhF mRNA. It is demonstrated here that the correct folding of this structure as well as the existence of primary sequence elements located within the loop portion at an appropriate distance to the UGA codon are absolutely required. A recognition sequence can be defined which mediates specific translation of a particular codon inside an mRNA with selenocysteine and a model is proposed in which translation factor SELB interacts with this recognition sequence, thus forming a quaternary complex at the mRNA together with GTP and selenocysteyl-tRNA(Sec).     

Interaction of the Escherichia coli fdhF mRNA hairpin promoting selenocysteine incorporation with the ribosome.

The codon UGA located 5' adjacent to an mRNA hairpin within fdhF mRNA promotes the incorporation of the amino acid selenocysteine into formate dehydrogenase H of Escherichia coli. The loop region of this mRNA hairpin has been shown to bind to the special elongation factor SELB, which also forms a complex with selenocysteinyl-tRNA(Sec) and GTP. We designed seven different mRNA constructs derived from the fdhF mRNA which contain a translation initiation region including an AUG initiation codon followed by no, one, two, three, four, five or six UUC phenylalanine codon(s) and the UGA selenocysteine codon 5' adjacent to the fdhF mRNA hairpin. By binding these different mRNA constructs to 30S ribosomal subunits in vitro we attempted to mimic intermediate steps of elongation of a structured mRNA approaching the ribosome by one codon at a time. Toeprint analysis of the mRNA-ribosome complexes showed that the presence of the fdhF mRNA hairpin strongly interferes with binding of the fdhF mRNA to 30S ribosomal subunits as soon as the hairpin is placed closer than 16 bases to the ribosomal P-site. Binding is reduced up to 25-fold compared with mRNA constructs where the hairpin is located outside the ribosomal mRNA track. Surprisingly, no toeprint signals were observed in any of our mRNA constructs when tRNA(Sec) was used instead of tRNA(fMet). Lack of binding of selenocysteinyl-tRNA(Sec) to the UGA codon was attributed to steric hindrance by the fdhF mRNA hairpin. By chemical probing of the shortest mRNA construct (AUG-UGA-fdhF hairpin) bound to 30S ribosomal subunits we demonstrate that the hairpin structure is not unfolded in the presence of ribosomes in vitro; also, this mRNA is not translated in vivo when fused in-frame 5' of the lacZ gene. Therefore, our data indicate that the fdhF mRNA hairpin has to be unfolded during elongation prior to entering the ribosomal mRNA track and we propose that the SELB binding domain within the fdhF mRNA is located outside the ribosomal mRNA track during decoding of the UGA selenocysteine codon by the SELB-selenocysteinyl-tRNA(Sec)-GTP complex.     

Crystal structure of human selenocysteine tRNA

Selenocysteine (Sec) is the 21st amino acid in translation. Sec tRNA (tRNA^Sec) has an anticodon complementary to the UGA codon. We solved the crystal structure of human tRNA^Sec. tRNA^Sec has a 9-bp acceptor stem and a 4-bp T stem, in contrast with the 7-bp acceptor stem and the 5-bp T stem in the canonical tRNAs. The acceptor stem is kinked between the U6:U67 and G7:C66 base pairs, leading to a bent acceptor-T stem helix. tRNA^Sec has a 6-bp D stem and a 4-nt D loop. The long D stem includes unique A14:U21 and G15:C20a pairs. The D-loop:T-loop interactions include the base pairs G18:U55 and U16:U59, and a unique base triple, U20:G19:C56. The extra arm comprises of a 6-bp stem and a 4-nt loop. Remarkably, the D stem and the extra arm do not form tertiary interactions in tRNA^Sec. Instead, tRNA^Sec has an open cavity, in place of the tertiary core of a canonical tRNA. The linker residues, A8 and U9, connecting the acceptor and D stems, are not involved in tertiary base pairing. Instead, U9 is stacked on the first base pair of the extra arm. These features might allow tRNA^Sec to be the target of the Sec synthesis/incorporation machineries.     

Selenocysteine, a highly specific component of certain enzymes, is incorporated by a UGA-directed co-translational mechanism

The opal termination codon UGA is used in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic species to direct the specific insertion of selenocysteine into certain selenium-dependent enzymes. So far a formate dehydrogenase (hydrogenase-linked) of Escherichia coli and glutathione peroxidases of murine, human and rat origin have been identified as enzymes containing selenocysteine residues encoded by UGA. A novel seryl-tRNA, anticodon UCA, that specifically recognizes the UGA codon is required for selenocysteine incorporation into formate dehydrogenase. A eukaryotic UGA suppressor tRNA with UCA anticodon that accepts serine and is phosphorylated to O-phosphoseryl-tRNA may have a corresponding function in glutathione peroxidase synthesis. Other factors required for the unusual usage of the in-frame UGA codons to specify selenocysteine incorporation and the biochemical mechanism involved in distinguishing these from normal UGA termination codons are discussed.     

A dynamic competition between release factor 2 and the tRNA(Sec) decoding UGA at the recoding site of Escherichia coli formate dehydrogenase H.

Factors affecting competition between termination and elongation in vivo during translation of the fdhF selenocysteine recoding site (UGA) were studied with wild-type and modified fdhF sequences. Altering sequences surrounding the recoding site UGA without affecting RNA secondary structure indicated that the kinetics of stop signal decoding have a significant influence on selenocysteine incorporation efficiency. The UGA in the wild-type fdhF sequence remains 'visible' to the factor and forms a site-directed cross-link when mRNA stem-loop secondary structure is absent, but not when it is present. The timing of the secondary structure unfolding during translation may be a critical feature of competition between release factor 2 and tRNA(Sec) for decoding UGA. Increasing the cellular concentration of either of these decoding molecules for termination or selenocysteine incorporation showed that they were able to compete for UGA by a kinetic competition that is dynamic and dependent on the Escherichia coli growth rate. The tRNA(Sec)-mediated decoding can compete more effectively for the UGA recoding site at lower growth rates, consistent with anaerobic induction of fdhF expression.     

Barriers to heterologous expression of a selenoprotein gene in bacteria.

The specificity parameters counteracting the heterologous expression in Escherichia coli of the Desulfomicrobium baculatum gene (hydV) coding for the large subunit of the periplasmic hydrogenase which is a selenoprotein have been studied. hydV'-'lacZ fusions were constructed, and it was shown that they do not direct the incorporation of selenocysteine in E. coli. Rather, the UGA codon is efficiently suppressed by some other aminoacyl-tRNA in an E. coli strain possessing a ribosomal ambiguity mutation. The suppression is decreased by the strA1 allele, indicating that the hydV selenocysteine UGA codon has the properties of a "normal" and suppressible nonsense codon. The SelB protein from D. baculatum was purified; in gel shift experiments, D. baculatum SelB displayed a lower affinity for the E. coli fdhF selenoprotein mRNA than E. coli SelB did and vice versa. Coexpression of the hydV'-'lacZ fusion and of the selB and tRNA(Sec) genes from D. baculatum, however, did not lead to selenocysteine insertion into the protein, although the formation of the quaternary complex between SelB, selenocysteyl-tRNA(Sec), and the hydV mRNA recognition sequence took place. The results demonstrate (i) that the selenocysteine-specific UGA codon is readily suppressed under conditions where the homologous SelB protein is absent and (ii) that apart from the specificity of the SelB-mRNA interaction, a structural compatibility of the quaternary complex with the ribosome is required.     

Bar to normal UGA translation by the selenocysteine tRNA.

The selC gene product, tRNA(Sec), inserts selenocysteine at UGA (opal) codons in a specialized mRNA context. We have investigated the action of the tRNA at ordinary UGA codons, normally not translated, by changing the unusual structural features of tRNA(Sec). Sequences in the D arm, CCA arm and variable arm of the tRNA all contribute to the prohibition against translation of ordinary UGA codons. One multiple mutant is a moderately efficient serine-inserting UGA suppressor tRNA.     

Dynamics and efficiency in vivo of UGA-directed selenocysteine insertion at the ribosome

The kinetics and efficiency of decoding of the UGA of a bacterial selenoprotein mRNA with selenocysteine has been studied in vivo. A gst-lacZ fusion, with the fdhF SECIS element ligated between the two fusion partners, gave an efficiency of read-through of 4-5%; overproduction of the selenocysteine insertion machinery increased it to 7-10%. This low efficiency is caused by termination at the UGA and not by translational barriers at the SECIS. When the selenocysteine UGA codon was replaced by UCA, and tRNASec with anticodon UGA was allowed to compete with seryl-tRNASer1 for this codon, selenocysteine was found in 7% of the protein produced. When a non-cognate SelB-tRNASec complex competed with EF-Tu for a sense codon, no effects were seen, whereas a non-cognate SelB-tRNASec competing with EF-Tu-mediated Su7-tRNA nonsense suppression of UGA interfered strongly with suppression. The induction kinetics of beta-galactosidase synthesis from fdhF'-'lacZ gene fusions in the absence or presence of SelB and/or the SECIS element, showed that there was a translational pause in the fusion containing the SECIS when SelB was present. The results show that decoding of UGA is an inefficient process and that using the third dimension of the mRNA to accommodate an additional amino acid is accompanied by considerable quantitative and kinetic costs.     

The length of the aminoacyl-acceptor stem of the selenocysteine-specific tRNA(Sec) of Escherichia coli is the determinant for binding to elongation factors SELB or Tu

Mutations in selC, which reduce the 8-base pair aminoacyl-acceptor helix to the canonical 7-base pair length (tRNA(Sec)(delAc] or which replace the extra arm of tRNA(Sec) by that of a serine acceptor tRNA species (tRNA(Sec)(ExS), block the function in selenoprotein synthesis in vivo (Baron, C., Heider, J., and B?ck, A. (1990) Nucleic Acids Res. 18, 6761-6766). tRNA(Sec), tRNA(Sec)(delAc), and tRNA(Sec)(ExS) were purified and analyzed for their interaction with purified seryl-tRNA synthetase, selenocysteine synthase and translation factors SELB and EF-Tu. It was found that seryl-tRNA synthetase displays 10-fold impaired Km and Kcat values for tRNA(Sec) in comparison to tRNA(Ser), decreasing the overall charging efficiency (Kcat/Km) of tRNA(Sec) to 1% of that characteristic for tRNA(Ser). tRNA(Sec)(ExS) was a less efficient substrate for the enzyme (Kcat/Km 0.2% of the tRNA(Ser) value) whereas the tRNA(Ser)(delAc) variant was charged with an approximately 2-3-fold improved rate compared to wild-type tRNA(Sec). Both mutant tRNA variants, when charged with L-serine, were able to interact with selenocysteine synthase to give rise to selenocysteyl-tRNA with tRNA(Sec)(ExS) being as efficient as wild-type tRNA(Sec). Seryl-tRNA(Sec)(delAc), on the other hand, was selenylated very slowly. Reduction of the length of the aminoacyl-acceptor stem to 7 base pairs prevented the interaction with translation factor SELB but allowed binding to EF-Tu, irrespective of whether tRNA(Sec)(delAc) was charged with serine or selenocysteine. The aminoacyl-acceptor helix of tRNA(Sec), therefore, is a major determinant directing binding to SELB and precluding interaction with EF-Tu.     

Interplay between termination and translation machinery in eukaryotic selenoprotein synthesis.

Termination of translation in eukaryotes is catalyzed by eRF1, the stop codon recognition factor, and eRF3, an eRF1 and ribosome-dependent GTPase. In selenoprotein mRNAs, UGA codons, which typically specify termination, serve an alternate function as sense codons. Selenocysteine incorporation involves a unique tRNA with an anticodon complementary to UGA, a unique elongation factor specific for this tRNA, and cis-acting secondary structures in selenoprotein mRNAs, termed SECIS elements. To gain insight into the interplay between the selenocysteine insertion and termination machinery, we investigated the effects of overexpressing eRF1 and eRF3, and of altering UGA codon context, on the efficiency of selenoprotein synthesis in a transient transfection system. Overexpression of eRF1 does not increase termination at naturally occurring selenocysteine codons. Surprisingly, selenocysteine incorporation is enhanced. Overexpression of eRF3 did not affect incorporation efficiency. Coexpression of both factors reproduced the effects with eRF1 alone. Finally, we show that the nucleotide context immediately upstream and downstream of the UGA codon significantly affects termination to incorporation ratios and the response to eRF overexpression. Implications for the mechanisms of selenocysteine incorporation and termination are discussed.     

The long extra arms of human tRNA((Ser)Sec) and tRNA(Ser) function as major identify elements for serylation in an orientation-dependent, but not sequence-specific manner.

Selenocysteine tRNA [tRNA((Ser)Sec)] is charged with serine by the same seryl-tRNA synthetase (SerRS) as the canonical serine tRNAs. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we have introduced a series of mutations into human tRNA((Ser)Sec) and tRNA(Ser) in order to study the identity elements of tRNA((Ser)Sec) for serylation and the effect of the orientation of the extra arm. Our results show that the long extra arm is one of the major identity elements for both tRNA(Ser) and tRNA((Ser)Sec) and gel retardation assays reveal that it appears to be a prerequisite for binding to the cognate synthetase. The long extra arm functions in an orientation-dependent, but not in a sequence-specific manner. The discriminator base G73 is another important identity element of tRNA((Ser)Sec), whereas the T- and D-arms play a minor role for the serylation efficiency.     

The nature of the minimal 'selenocysteine insertion sequence' (SECIS) in Escherichia coli.

The UGA codon, usually a stop codon, can also direct the incorporation into a protein of the modified amino acid selenocysteine. This UGA decoding process requires a cis -acting mRNA element called 'selenocysteine insertion sequence' (SECIS) that can form a stem-loop structure. In Escherichia coli the SECIS of the selenoprotein formate dehydrogenase (FdhH) mRNA has been previously described to consist of at least 40 nucleotides following the UGA codon. Here we determined the nature of the minimal SECIS required for the in vivo UGA-directed selenocysteine incorporation in E.coli . Our study is based on extensive mutational analysis of the fdhF SECIS DNA located in a lac' Z fusion. We found that the whole stem-loop RNA structure of the E.coli fdhF SECIS previously described is not required for the UGA-directed selenocysteine incorporation in vivo . Rather, only its upper stem-loop structure of 17 nucleotides is necessary on the condition that it is located in a proper distance (11 nucleotides) from the UGA codon. Based on these observations, we present a new model for the minimal E.coli SECIS.     

Selenocysteine insertion directed by the 3'-UTR SECIS element in Escherichia coli

Co-translational insertion of selenocysteine (Sec) into proteins in response to UGA codons is directed by selenocysteine insertion sequence (SECIS) elements. In known bacterial selenoprotein genes, SECIS elements are located in the coding regions immediately downstream of UGA codons. Here, we report that a distant SECIS element can also function in Sec insertion in bacteria provided that it is spatially close to the UGA codon. We expressed a mammalian phospholipid hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase in Escherichia coli from a construct in which a natural E.coli SECIS element was located in the 3′-untranslated region (3′-UTR) and adjacent to a sequence complementary to the region downstream of the Sec UGA codon. Although the major readthrough event at the UGA codon was insertion of tryptophan, Sec was also incorporated and its insertion was dependent on the functional SECIS element in the UTR, base-pairing potential of the SECIS flanking region and the Sec UGA codon. These data provide important implications into evolution of SECIS elements and development of a system for heterologous expression of selenoproteins and show that in addition to the primary sequence arrangement between UGA codons and SECIS elements, their proximity within the tertiary structure can support Sec insertion in bacteria.     

Structural basis for dynamic interdomain movement and RNA recognition of the selenocysteine-specific elongation factor SelB

Selenocysteine (Sec) is the "21st" amino acid and is genetically encoded by an unusual incorporation system. The stop codon UGA becomes a Sec codon when the selenocysteine insertion sequence (SECIS) exists downstream of UGA. Sec incorporation requires a specific elongation factor, SelB, which recognizes tRNA(Sec) via use of an EF-Tu-like domain and the SECIS mRNA hairpin via use of a C-terminal domain (SelB-C). SelB functions in multiple translational steps: binding to SECIS mRNA and tRNA(Sec), delivery of tRNA(Sec) onto an A site, GTP hydrolysis, and release from tRNA and mRNA. However, this dynamic mechanism remains to be revealed. Here, we report a large domain rearrangement in the structure of SelB-C complexed with RNA. Surprisingly, the interdomain region forms new interactions with the phosphate backbone of a neighboring RNA, distinct from SECIS RNA binding. This SelB-RNA interaction is sequence independent, possibly reflecting SelB-tRNA/-rRNA recognitions. Based on these data, the dynamic SelB-ribosome-mRNA-tRNA interactions will be discussed.     

Structure and properties of a bovine liver UGA suppressor serine tRNA with a tryptophan anticodon

A bovine liver serine tRNA with a variety of unusual features has been sequenced and characterized. This tRNA is aminoacylated with serine, although it has a tryptophan anticodon CmCA. In ribosome binding assays, this tRNA (tRNA_CmCA^Ser) binds to the termination codon UGA and shows little or no binding in response to a variety of other codons including those for tryptophan and serine. The unusual codon recognition properties of this molecule were confirmed in an in vitro assay where this tRNA suppressed UGA termination. This is the first naturally occurring eucaryotic suppressor tRNA to be so characterized. Other unusual features, possibly related to the ability of this tRNA to read UGA, are the presence of two extra nucleotides, compared to all other tRNAs, between the universal residues U at position 8 and A at position 14 and the presence of an extra unpaired nucleotide within the double-stranded loop IV stem. This tRNA is also the largest eucaryotic tRNA sequenced to date (90 nucleotides). Despite its size, however, it contains only six modified residues. tRNA_CmCA^Ser shows extremely low homology to other mammalian serine (47–52% homology) or tryptophan (49% homology) tRNAs.     

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii selenocysteine tRNA[Ser]Sec

Eukaryotic selenocysteine (Sec) protein insertion machinery was thought to be restricted to animals, but the occurrence of both Sec-containing proteins and the Sec insertion system was recently found in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, a member of the plant kingdom. Herein, we used RT-PCR to determine the sequence of C. reinhardtii Sec tRNA[Ser]Sec, the first non-animal eukaryotic Sec tRNA[Ser]Sec sequence. Like its animal counterpart, it is 90 nucleotides in length, is aminoacylated with serine by seryl-tRNA synthetase, and decodes specifically UGA. Evolutionary analyses of known Sec tRNAs identify the C. reinhardtii form as the most diverged eukaryotic Sec tRNA[Ser]Sec and reveal a common origin for this tRNA in bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes.     

The Nature of the Nucleotide at the 5' Side of the tRNA Su9 Anticodon Affects UGA Suppression in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli a UGA codon can be efficiently suppressedby a suppressor tRNA^Trp called Su9. Here, we show that the levelof UGA suppression is determined by the nature of the nucleotideat the 5' side of the anticodon of the suppressor (position33). UGA suppression occurs when a pyrimidine residue is locatedin position 33 of the tRNA, and suppression is more efficientwith a U than with a C in this position. On the other hand,when a purine residue is located at this position UGA suppressionis extremely low. These results show that in the case of tRNASu9, the UGA codon context effect does not require base pairingbetween the nucleotide at the 3' side of the codon and the 5'side of the anticodon.     

Modeling the tertiary interactions in the eukaryotic selenocysteine tRNA.

A novel three-dimensional model of tertiary interactions in the core region of the eukaryotic selenocysteine tRNA is proposed based on the analysis of available nucleotide sequences. The model features the 7/5 tRNA(Sec) secondary structure characterized by seven and five base pairs in the acceptor and T-stems, respectively, and four nucleotides in the connector region between the acceptor and D-stems. The model suggests a unique system of tertiary interactions in the area between the major groove of the D-stem and the first base pair of the extra arm that provides a rigid orientation of the extra arm and contributes to the overall stability of the molecule. The model is consistent with available experimental data on serylation, selenylation, and phosphorylation of different tRNA(Sec) mutants. The important similarity between the proposed model and the structure of the tRNA(Ser) is shown. Based on this similarity, the ability of some tRNA(Ser) mutants to be serylated, selenylated, and phosphorylated was evaluated and found to be in a good agreement with experimental data.