Cultivation of Marine Sponges

There is increasing interest in biotechnological production of marine sponge biomass owing to the discovery of many commercially important secondary metabolites in this group of animals. In this article, different approaches to producing sponge biomass are reviewed, and several factors that possibly influence culture success are evaluated. In situ sponge aquacultures, based on old methods for producing commercial bath sponges, are still the easiest and least expensive way to obtain sponge biomass in bulk. However, success of cultivation with this method strongly depends on the unpredictable and often suboptimal natural environment. Hence, a better-defined production system would be desirable. Some progress has been made with culturing sponges in semicontrolled systems, but these still use unfiltered natural seawater. Cultivation of sponges under completely controlled conditions has remained a problem. When designing an in vitro cultivation method, it is important to determine both qualitatively and quantitatively the nutritional demands of the species that is to be cultured. An adequate supply of food seems to be the key to successful sponge culture. Recently, some progress has been made with sponge cell cultures. The advantage of cell cultures is that they are completely controlled and can easily be manipulated for optimal production of the target metabolites. However, this technique is still in its infancy: a continuous cell line has yet to be established. Axenic cultures of sponge aggregates (primmorphs) may provide an alternative to cell culture. Some sponge metabolites are, in fact, produced by endosymbiotic bacteria or algae that live in the sponge tissue. Only a few of these endosymbionts have been cultivated so far. The biotechnology for the production of sponge metabolites needs further development. Research efforts should be continued to enable commercial exploitation of this valuable natural resource in the near future. Received November 5, 1998; accepted June 20, 1999.     

Seasonal production of primmorphs from the marine sponge Petrosia ficiformis (Poiret, 1789) and new culturing approaches

The need to produce bioactive compounds from marine sponges leads several groups of research to the culture of primmorphs from different species, which are generally maintained in aquaria for long time before processing. Here we present a study where the importance of several parameters on primmorphs production from the symbiotic sponge Petrosia ficiformis has been evaluated: (i) the sterility of sea water, (ii) the maintenance in aquarium before processing, (iii) the seasonal cycle. Sterility of sea water does not improve primmorphs production in this species. The maintenance of sponges in aquaria before processing negatively affects cell cultures. Regarding seasonality, it is evident that both the number and the size of primmorphs can deeply change depending on the period of the year the sponge is collected. April and July are the months that lead to the highest number of primmorphs, May and June are the months that lead to their biggest sizes. Possible relationships of these results with the life cycle of P. ficiformis are discussed.     

Long-Term Cultivation of Primmorphs from Freshwater Baikal Sponges <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lubomirskia baikalensis</Emphasis>

The work was aimed at performing long-term cultivation of primmorphs in vitro from freshwater sponge Lubomirskia baikalensis (Pallas 1776), collected from Lake Baikal, obtaining its long-term primmorph culture in both natural (NBW) and artificial (ABW) Baikal water and at identifying the impact of different environmental factors on formation and growth of primmorphs. The first fine aggregates of L. baikalensis are formed in vitro 10–15 min after dissociation of sponge cells. Epithelization of aggregates begins 4 h later after the dissociation. Young primmorphs are formed 1 or 2 days later. The surface of primmorphs is covered with a layer of exopinacocytes. The primmorphs remain viable for more than 10 months at 3–6°C. Over 50% of primmorphs in NBW and 25% in ABW are attached to the substrate and grow like adult sponges. Thus, the long-term primmorph cultivation in vitro allows the creation of a controlled live model system under experimental conditions. The results of this work will allow the creation of a cell culture collection of Baikal freshwater sponges for studying morphogenesis of primmorphs during cultivation at different stages and transdifferentiation of their cells, physiological functions of sponge cells, processes of spiculogenesis, identification of proteins involved in biomineralization process, decoding of their genes, as well as a spectrum of secondary metabolites.     

Primmorphs Cryopreservation: A New Method for Long-Time Storage of Sponge Cells

The possibility to cryopreserve cells allows for wide opportunities of flexible handling of cell cultures from different sponge species. Primmorphs model, a multicellular 3D aggregate formed by dissociated sponge cells, is considered one of the best approaches to establish sponge cell culture but, in spite of the available protocols for freezing sponge cells, there is no information regarding the ability of the latter to form primmorphs after thawing. In the present work, we demonstrate that, after a freezing and thawing cycle using dissociated Petrosia ficiformis cells as a model, cells viability was high but it was not possible to obtain primmorphs. The same protocol for cryopreservation was then used to directly freeze primmorphs. In this second case, after thawing, viability and the cellular proliferative level were similar to unfrozen standard primmorphs. Spiculogenesis in thawed primmorphs was evaluated by quantifying the silicatein gene expression level and by assaying the silica amount in the newly formed spicules, then compared with the correspondent values obtained in standard unfrozen primmorphs. Results indicate that the freezing cycle does not affect the spiculogenesis rate. Finally, the expression level of heat shock protein 70, a well-known stress marker, was assayed and the results showed no differences between frozen and unfrozen samples. These findings are likely to promote relevant improvements in sponge cell culture technique, allowing for a worldwide exchange of living biological material, paving the way for cell banking of Porifera.     

Primmorphs from archaeocytes-dominant cell population of the sponge hymeniacidon perleve: improved cell proliferation and spiculogenesis

Marine sponges (Porifera) possess an extraordinary diversity of bioactive metabolites for new drug discovery and development. In vitro cultivation of sponge cells in a bioreactor system is very attractive for the sustainable production of sponge-derived bioactive metabolites; however, it is still a challenging task. The recent establishment of sponge primmorphs, multicellular aggregates from dissociated mixed-cell population (MCP), has been widely acknowledged to hold great promise for cultivation in vitro. Here we present a new method to establish an in vitro sponge primmorph culture from archaeocyte-dominant cell population (ADCP) enriched by a Ficoll gradient, rather than a mixed-cell population (MCP). Our rationale is based upon the totipotency (the ability of a cell to differentiate into other cell types) of archaeocyte cells and the different biological functions of various sponge cell types. A sponge, Hymeniacidon perleve collected from the China Yellow Sea was used as a model system for this investigation. Distinct dynamics of primmorph formation were observed while significant increases in DNA synthesis, cell proliferation (up to threefold), and cell growth (up to fourfold) were achieved. Furthermore, a time-dependent spiculogenesis was clearly demonstrated in our longterm culture, indicating high metabolic activity of primmorphs from the ADCP. This new method represents an important step forward to advance sponge cell culture in vitro that may lead to commercial exploitation of sponge-derived drugs.     

Antiangiogenic, Antimicrobial, and Cytotoxic Potential of Sponge-Associated Bacteria

The bacteria associated with marine invertebrates are a rich source of bioactive metabolites. In the present study bacteria associated with the sponge Suberites domuncula and its primmorphs (3-dimensional aggregates containing proliferating cells) were isolated and cultured. These bacteria were extracted, and the extracts were assayed for antiangiogenic, hemolytic, antimicrobial, and cytotoxic activities. Our studies revealed that extract obtained from the bacterium (PB2) isolated from sponge primmorphs is a potent angiogenesis inhibitor. In the chick chorio-allantoic membrane (CAM) assay, it showed 50% activity at 5 μg ml⁻¹ and 100% activity at 10 and 20 μg ml⁻¹ concentrations. Extracts obtained from 5 bacterial strains isolated from sponge and its primmorphs showed hemolytic activity. The sponge-associated bacteria belonging to the α subdivision of Proteobacteria and the primmorph-associated bacterium identified as a possible novel Pseudomonas sp. displayed remarkable antimicrobial activity. It is important to note that these bacterial extracts were strongly active against multidrug-resistant clinical strains such as Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus epidermidis, isolated from hospital patients. The bacterial extracts having antimicrobial activity also showed cytotoxicity against HeLa and PC12 cells. In summary, this investigation explores the importance of sponge-associated bacteria as a valuable resource for the discovery of novel bioactive molecules.     

Bioactives from microalgal dinoflagellates

Dinoflagellate microalgae are an important source of marine biotoxins. Bioactives from dinoflagellates are attracting increasing attention because of their impact on the safety of seafood and potential uses in biomedical, toxicological and pharmacological research. Here we review the potential applications of dinoflagellate toxins and the methods for producing them. Only sparing quantities of dinoflagellate toxins are generally available and this hinders bioactivity characterization and evaluation in possible applications. Approaches to production of increased quantities of dinoflagellate bioactives are discussed. Although many dinoflagellates are fragile and grow slowly, controlled culture in bioreactors appears to be generally suitable for producing many of the metabolites of interest.     

繁茂膜海绵原细胞富集细胞团培养过程中的细胞迁移规律

海绵是重要的生物活性物质来源, 近10年来, 从海绵中发现的具有生物活性的新化合物占海洋生物来源的30%以上, 并且大多具有显著的抗肿瘤, 抗艾滋病病毒的活性。但是, 由于海绵生物量不能满足这些活性物质进一步研究和商业化的需求, 目前仅有一种活性物质被成功的商业化, 这不仅是商业开发的损失, 也是提高人类生活质量活动的一种损失。为了解决海绵供给不足的问题, 人们进行了包括化学合成、海绵养殖以及海绵细胞培养在内的多种尝试,目前的研究结果表明, 海绵细胞离体培养技术是最有可能彻底解决海绵供给不足的途径之一。但是由于海绵自身的特殊性, 还没有人成功的建立起海绵细胞系以满足生产需要。人们发现, 海绵细胞的相互接触对于离体海绵细胞长期培养至关重要。经过多年的探索, 大连化物所海洋生物产品工程组建立了开发出了海绵原细胞富集细胞团培养技术, 通过对海绵组织内的原细胞进行富集来获得可长期培养的海绵细胞。海绵原细胞是海绵组织内的“干细胞”, 具有很强的分化、增殖潜力, 同时也是海绵组织内负责消化的主要细胞类型。为了探索海绵原细胞的增殖、分化规律, 本研究基于海绵原细胞富集细胞团培养体系, 构建了海绵细胞培养实时观测平台, 对繁茂膜海绵原细胞、领细胞、上皮细胞3类主要海绵细胞类型在海绵细胞团形成及生长的全过程进行观察, 了解不同类型细胞迁移规律的变化。通过对视频记录进行分析,发现离散的海绵细胞与细胞团内的海绵细胞具有截然相反的运动规律, 海绵细胞的运动具有很强的协同性。伴随原细胞在细胞团内不停息的迁移, 还观察到海绵细胞团内新生骨针的迁移以及细胞间进行颗粒物质的传递。这些信息的获得, 将有助于进一步了解不同细胞的功能与作用, 也有助于在此基础上探索海绵细胞的增殖、分化控制规律。     

Origin of metazoan stem cell system in sponges: first approach to establish the model (Suberites domuncula)

It is established that Porifera (sponges) represent the earliest phylum which branched off from the common ancestor of all multicellular animals, the Urmetazoa. In the present study, the hypothesis is tested if, during this transition, pluripotent stem cells were formed which are provided-similar to the totipotent cells (archaeocytes/germ cells)-with a self-renewal capacity. As a model system, primmorphs from the sponge Suberites domuncula were used. These 3D-cell aggregates were cultivated in medium (RPMI 1640/seawater) either lacking silicate and ferric iron or in medium which was supplemented with these 'morphogenetic' factors. As molecular markers for the potential existence of stem cells in primmorphs, two genes which encode proteins found in stem cells of higher metazoan species, were cloned from S. domuncula. First, the noggin gene, which is present in the Spemann organizer of amphibians and whose translation product acts during the formation of dorsal mesoderm derivatives. The second gene encodes the mesenchymal stem cell-like protein. Both cDNAs were used to study their expression in primmorphs in dependence on the incubation conditions. It was found that noggin expression is strongly upregulated in primmorphs kept in the presence of silicate and ferric iron, while the expression of the mesenchymal stem cell-like protein was downregulated. These data are discussed with respect to the existence of stem cells in sponges.     

Optimizing the formation of in vitro sponge primmorphs from the Chinese sponge Stylotella agminata (Ridley)

The establishment and optimization of in vitro primmorph formation from a Chinese sponge, Stylotella agminata (Ridley), collected from the South China Sea, were investigated. Our aims were to identify the key factors affecting primmorph formation in this species and to optimize the technique for developing an in vitro primmorph culture system. The size of dissociated cells from S. agminata is relatively small, in the range between 5 and 10 microm. Round-shaped primmorphs of less than 100 microm were formed 3 days after transferring the dissociated cells into seawater containing Ca(2+) and Mg(2+). The effect of various cell dissociation conditions, inoculum cell density, concentration of antibiotics, pH, and temperature was further investigated upon the formation of primmorphs. The time required for primmorph formation, primmorph size distribution, and the proliferating capability were microscopically documented. Healthy sponge S. agminata, inoculum cell density and culture temperature play a critical role for the successful formation of primmorphs and that the microbial contamination will have to be controlled.     

Farming Sponges to Supply Bioactive Metabolites and Bath Sponges: A Review

Sponges have been experimentally farmed for over 100 years, with early attempts done in the sea to supply “bath sponges”. During the last 20 years, sponges have also been experimentally cultured both in the sea and in tanks on land for their biologically active metabolites, some of which have pharmaceutical potential. Sea-based farming studies have focused on developing good farming structures and identifying the optimal environmental conditions that promote production of bath sponges or bioactive metabolites. The ideal farming structure will vary between species and regions, but will generally involve threading sponges on rope or placing them inside mesh. For land-based sponge culture, most research has focused on determining the feeding requirements that promote growth. Many sea- and land-based studies have shown that sponges grow quickly, often doubling in size every few months. Other favorable results and interesting developments include partially harvesting farmed sponges to increase biomass yields, seeding sexually reproduced larvae on farming structures, using sponge farms as large biofilters to control microbial populations, and manipulating culture conditions to promote metabolite biosynthesis. Even though some results are promising, land-based culture needs further research and is not likely to be commercially feasible in the near future. Sea-based culture still holds great promise, with several small-scale farming operations producing bath sponges or metabolites. The greatest potential for commercial bath sponge culture is probably for underdeveloped coastal communities, where it can provide an alternative and environmentally friendly source of income.     

Expression of one sponge Iroquois homeobox gene in primmorphs from Suberites domuncula during canal formation

Sponges (Porifera) represent the evolutionary oldest multicellular animals. They are provided with the basic molecules involved in cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions. We report here the isolation and characterization of a complementary DNA from the sponge Suberites domuncula coding for the sponge homeobox gene, SUBDOIRX-a. The deduced polypeptide with a predicted Mr of 44,375 possesses the highly conserved Iroquois-homeodomain. We applied in situ hybridization to localize Iroquois in the sponge. The expression of this gene is highest in cells adjacent to the canals of the sponge in the medulla region. To study the expression of Iroquois during development, the in vitro primmorph system from S. domuncula was used. During the formation of these three-dimensional aggregates composed of proliferating cells, the expression of Iroquois depends on ferric iron and water current. An increased expression in response to water current is paralleled with the formation of canal-like pores in the primmorphs. It is suggested that Iroquois expression is involved in the formation of the aquiferous system, the canals in sponges and the canal-like structures in primmorphs.     

Cultivation of primmorphs from the marine sponge Suberites domuncula: morphogenetic potential of silicon and iron

Marine demosponges (phylum Porifera) are rich sources for potent bioactive compounds. With the establishment of the primmorph system from sponges, especially from Suberites domuncula, the technology to cultivate sponge cells in vitro improved considerably. This progress was possible after the elucidation that sponges are provided with characteristic metazoan cell adhesion receptors and extracellular matrix molecules which allow their cells a positioning in a complex organization pattern. This review summarizes recent data on the cultivation of sponges in aquaria and--with main emphasis--of primmorphs in vitro. It is outlined that silicon and Fe(+++) contribute substantially to the formation of larger primmorphs (size of 10 mm) as well as of a canal system in primmorphs; canals are probably required for an improved oxygen and food supply. We conclude that the primmorph system will facilitate a sustainable use of sponges in the production of bioactive compounds; it may furthermore allow new and hitherto not feasible insights into basic questions on the origin of Metazoa.     

Sustained growth of explants from Mediterranean sponge Crambe crambe cultured in vitro with enriched RPMI 1640

Marine sponges are potential sources of many unique metabolites, including cytotoxic and anticancer compounds. Natural sponge populations are insufficient or inaccessible for producing commercial quantities of metabolites of interest. It is commonly accepted that tissue (fragments, explants, and primmorphs) and in vitro cell cultivation show great potential. However, there is little knowledge of the nutritional requirements of marine sponges to carry out efficient and sustained in vitro culture and progress has been slow. In marine invertebrate fila many unsuccessful attempts have been made with in vitro cultures using typical commercial animal cell media based on sources of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) (e.g., DMEM, RPMI, M199, L-15, etc.). One of the reasons for this failure is the use of hardly identifiable growth promoters, based on terrestrial animal sera. An alternative is the use of extracts from marine animals, since they may contain nutrients necessary for growth. In this work we have cultivated in vitro explants of the encrusting marine sponge Crambe crambe. It is one of the most abundant sponges on the Mediterranean coastline and also possesses an array of potentially active metabolites (crambines and crambescidins). Initially a new approach was developed in order to show consumption of DOC by explants. Thus, different initial DOC concentrations (300, 400, 700 and 1200 mg DOC L(-1)) were assayed. Consumption was evident in all four assays and was more marked in the first 6 h. The DOC assimilation data were adjusted to an empirical model widely used for uptake kinetics of organic dissolved compounds in marine invertebrates. Second, a protocol was established to cultivate explants in vitro. Different medium formulations based on RPMI 1640 commercial medium enriched with amino acids and inorganic salts to emulate seawater salinity were assayed. The enrichment of this medium with an Octopus aqueous extract in the proportions of 10% and 20% (v/v) resulted in an evident sustained long-term growth of C. crambe explants. This growth enhancement produced high metabolic activity in the explants, as is confirmed by the high ammonium and lactate content in the medium a few days after its renewal and by the consumption of glucose. The lactate accumulation increased with the size and age of explants. Prior to these experiments, we successfully developed a robust new alternative method, based on digital image treatment, for accurate determination of the explant apparent volume as growth measure.     

Sulfated polysaccharides from marine sponges: conspicuous distribution among different cell types and involvement on formation of in vitro cell aggregates

Marine sponges (Porifera) display an ancestral type of cell-cell adhesion, based on carbohydrate-carbohydrate interaction. The aim of the present work was to investigate further details of this adhesion by using, as a model, the in vitro aggregation of dissociated sponge cells. Our results showed the participation of sulfated polysaccharides in this cell-cell interaction, as based on the following observations: (1) a variety of sponge cells contained similar sulfated polysaccharides as surface-associated molecules and as intracellular inclusions; (2) ³⁵S-sulfate metabolic labeling of dissociated sponge cells revealed that the majority (two thirds) of the total sulfated polysaccharide occurred as a cell-surface-associated molecule; (3) the aggregation process of dissociated sponge cells demanded the active de novo synthesis of sulfated polysaccharides, which ceased as cell aggregation reached a plateau; (4) the typical well-organized aggregates of sponge cells, known as primmorphs, contained three cell types showing sulfated polysaccharides on their cell surface; (5) collagen fibrils were also produced by the primmorphs in order to fill the extracellular spaces of their inner portion and the external layer surrounding their entire surface. Our data have thus clarified the relevance of sulfated polysaccharides in this system of in vitro sponge cell aggregation. The molecular basis of this system has practical relevance, since the culture of sponge cells is necessary for the production of molecules with biotechnological applications.     

Comparative studies on two potential methods for the biotechnological production of sponge biomass.

The production of marine sponge biomass is one of the main outstanding goals of marine biotechnology. Due to the increased number of sponge secondary metabolites of economical value the interest in sponge cultivation increased over the last years, too. Therefore, we examined cultivation properties of 11 Mediterranean sponge species. Two methodologies were tested: functional fragment culture and multicell reaggregate culture. The in vitro cultivation of sponge fragments without further dissociation and reaggregation is a method formerly not reported. Reaggregates and functional fragments are promising attempts for culture system development. A broad spectrum of reaggregation properties was found among the species tested. In three species multicell aggregate cultures could be maintained for several months: Petrosia ficiformis, Suberites domuncula and Acanthella acuta. Our results indicate that cellular aggregates or fragments of sponges can be valuable tools in the development of methods for biotechnological production of sponge biomass. Further focus on nutritional demands and the biochemical status of the cells in these kind of cellular associations are needed in order to obtain functional aggregates and fragments.     

Ethylene modulates gene expression in cells of the marine sponge Suberites domuncula and reduces the degree of apoptosis.

Sponges (phylum Porifera) live in an aqueous milieu that contains dissolved organic carbon. This is degraded photochemically by ultraviolet radiation to alkenes, particularly to ethylene. This study demonstrates that sponge cells (here the demosponge Suberites domuncula has been used), which have assembled to primmorphs, react to 5 microM ethylene with a significant up-regulation of intracellular Ca(2+) concentration and with a reduction of starvation-induced apoptosis. In primmorphs from S. domuncula the expression of two genes is up-regulated after exposure to ethylene. The cDNA of the first gene (SDERR) isolated from S. domuncula encodes a potential ethylene-responsive protein, termed ERR_SUBDO; its putative M(r) is 32,704. Data bank search revealed that the sponge polypeptide shares high similarity (82% on amino acid level) with the corresponding plant molecule, the ethylene-inducible protein from Hevea brasiliensis. Until now no other metazoan ethylene-responsive proteins have been identified. The second gene, whose expression is up-regulated in response to ethylene is a Ca(2+)/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II. Its cDNA, SDCCdPK, encodes a M(r) 54,863 putative kinase that shares 69% similarity with the corresponding enzyme from Drosophila melanogaster. The expression of both genes in primmorphs from S. domuncula is increased by approximately 5-fold after a 3-day incubation period with ethylene. It is concluded that also metazoan cells, with sponge cells as a model, may react to ethylene with an activation of cell metabolism including gene induction.     

Influence of rocky substrata on three-dimensional sponge cells model development

Many marine and freshwater organisms are rocky bottom dwellers, and the mineralogical composition of the substratum is known to potentially condition their biology and ecology. In this work, we propose the use of 3D sponge cellular aggregates, called primmorphs, as suitable models for a multidisciplinary study of the mechanisms which regulate the biological responses triggered by the contact with different inorganic substrata. In our experiments, primmorphs obtained from the marine sponge Petrosia ficiformis (Poiret, 1789) were reared on calcium carbonate or on quartzitic substrata, respectively, and their morphological development was described. In parallel, the quantitative expression levels of two genes, silicatein and heat shock protein 70 (HSP70), were evaluated. The first gene is strictly correlated to spiculogenesis and sponge growth, while the second is an important indicator of stress. The results achieved with this in vitro model clearly demonstrate that quartzitic substrata determine the increase of silicatein gene expression, a lower expression of HSP70 gene, and a remarkable difference in primmorphs morphology compared to the analogous samples grown on marble.