The inhibition of infection thread development in the cultivar-specific interaction ofRhizobium and subterranean clover is not caused by a hypersensitive response

Summary The cultivar specific interaction ofTrifolium subterranean cv. Woogenellup andRhizobium leguminosarum bv.trifolii strain ANU 794 was examined to establish the basis for nodulation failure on this cultivar. Infections were initiated by strain ANU 794 on cv. Woogenellup. Root hair curling, the initiation of infection threads, and cortical cell divisions were evident on the tap root and appeared normal after microscopic observation. However, in most cases, the infection threads stayed confined to the root hairs. No evidence was found for a hypersensitive response by the plant. The progress of infections on the tap roots was different from that on the lateral roots. This was confirmed by the differential tap and lateral root nodulation patterns of the mutants derived from strain ANU 794, which show enhanced nodulation on cv. Woogenellup. On the lateral roots, cortical cell divisions progressed further than those on the tap root and formed macroscopically visible swellings, which could be divided into two morphological classes. In some cases infection threads developed into these primordia but successful nodules were not established. The inhibition of infection appeared to be manifested at two levels: first, on the tap roots in the root hairs, where many of the infection threads are contained and secondly, in the primordia induced on the lateral roots, where the infection threads sometimes penetrate further than the root hair cell but stop in the primordial cells. It appears that an essential factor or trigger in the communication between plant and bacteria is missing or altered, resulting in an array of primordia-structures, which cease to develop.Abbreviations bv biovar - cv cultivar - Fix⁺ nitrogen fixing - GUS -glucuronidase - Nod⁺ nodulating - HR hypersensitive response - Km kanamycin - LOSs lipo-oligosaccharides - Sm streptomycin - Sp spectinomycin - X-Gluc 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indonyl--glucuronic acid     

Microscopic analysis of the effect ofRhizobium leguminosarum biovartrifolii host specific nodulation genes in the infection of white clovers

Summary A microscopic assessment is presented of the comparative infection capacity of wild-type and hybrid strains ofRhizobium leguminosarum bv.viciae withR. l. bv.trifolii strain ANU 843 on white clover seedlings. TheR. l. bv.viciae hybrid strains contained defined DNA segments coding for different combinations ofR. l. bv.trifolii host-specific nodulation genes. White clover plants were examined over a 72 h period to assessRhizobium infectivity, the morphological changes in root hair growth; colonisation ability of rhizobia; infection thread initiation and the ability to induce cortical cell division.R. l. bv.viciae strain 300 induced root hair curling more slowly than strain ANU 843 or any of the hybrid strain 300 bacteria, and when curling had taken place, there was poorer colonization by strain 300 within the folded hair cell, no evidence of infection thread formation and only limited cortical cell division 72 h after inoculation. The addition of the host-specific nodulation genes ofR. l. bv.trifolii to strain 300 was necessary to induce infection threads and establish a normal pattern of nodulation of the roots of white clovers.     

Construction of a Symbiotically Effective Strain of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii with Increased Nodulation Competitiveness

Genes involved in nodulation competitiveness (tfx) were inserted by marker exchange into the genome of the effective strain Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii TA1. Isogenic strains of TA1 were constructed which differed only in their ability to produce trifolitoxin, an antirhizobial peptide. Trifolitoxin production by the ineffective strain R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii T24 limited nodulation of clover roots by trifolitoxin-sensitive strains of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii. The trifolitoxin-producing exconjugant TA1::10-15 was very competitive for nodulation on clover roots when coinoculated with a trifolitoxin-sensitive reference strain. The nonproducing exconjugant TA1::12-10 was not competitive for nodule occupancy when coinoculated with the reference strain. Tetracycline sensitivity and Southern analysis confirmed the loss of vector DNA in the exconjugants. Trifolitoxin production by TA1::10-15 was stable in the absence of selection pressure. Transfer of tfx to TA1 did not affect nodule number or nitrogenase activity. These experiments represent the first stable genetic transfer of genes involved in nodulation competitiveness to a symbiotically effective Rhizobium strain.     

Rhizobium leguminosarum genes required for expression and transfer of host specific nodulation

The contributions of various nod genes from Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viceae to host-specific nodulation have been assessed by transferring specific genes and groups of genes to R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii and testing the levels of nodulation on Pisum sativum (peas) and Vicia hirsuta. Many of the nod genes are important in determination of host-specificity; the nodE gene plays a key (but not essential) role and the efficiency of transfer of host specific nodulation increased with additional genes such that nodFE < nodFEL < nodFELMN. In addition the nodD gene was shown to play an important role in host-specific nodulation of peas and Vicia whilst other genes in the nodABCIJ gene region also appeared to be important. In a reciprocal series of experiments involving nod genes cloned from R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii it was found that the nodD gene enabled bv. viciae to nodulate Trifolium pratense (red clover) but the nodFEL gene region did not. The bv. trifolii nodD or nodFEL genes did significantly increase nodulation of Trifolium subterraneum (sub-clover) by R. leguminosarum bv. viciae. It is concluded that host specificity determinants are encoded by several different nod genes.     

Genome sequence of the clover-nodulating Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain TA1

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain TA1 is an aerobic, motile, Gram-negative, non-spore-forming rod that is an effective nitrogen fixing microsymbiont on the perennial clovers originating from Europe and the Mediterranean basin. TA1 however is ineffective with many annual and perennial clovers originating from Africa and America. Here we describe the features of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain TA1, together with genome sequence information and annotation. The 8,618,824 bp high-quality-draft genome is arranged in a 6 scaffold of 32 contigs, contains 8,493 protein-coding genes and 83 RNA-only encoding genes, and is one of 20 rhizobial genomes sequenced as part of the DOE Joint Genome Institute 2010 Community Sequencing Program.     

A cultivar-specific interaction between Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii and subterranean clover is controlled by nodM, other bacterial cultivar specificity genes, and a single recessive host gene.

Insertion mutagenesis identified two negatively acting gene loci which restrict the ability of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii TA1 to infect the homologous host Trifolium subterraneum cv. Woogenellup. One locus was confirmed by DNA sequence analysis as the nodM gene, while the other locus, designated csn-1 (cultivar-specific nodulation), is not located on the symbiosis plasmid. The presence of these cultivar specificity loci could be suppressed by the introduction of the nodT gene from ANU843, a related R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain. Other nod genes, present in R. leguminosarum bv. viciae (including nodX) and R. meliloti, were capable of complementing R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii TA1 for nodulation on cultivar Woogenellup. Nodulation studies conducted with F2 seedlings from a cross between cultivar Geraldton and cultivar Woogenellup indicated that a single recessive gene, designated rwt1, is responsible for the Nod- association between strain TA1 and cultivar Woogenellup. Parallels can be drawn between this association and gene-for-gene systems common in interactions between plants and biotrophic pathogens.     

Influence ofRhizobium leguminosarum biovartrifolii host specific nodulation genes on the ontogeny of clover nodulation

Summary The infection of white clover seedlings byRhizobium strains with different host range properties was assessed using various microscopic techniques. Several wild-type andRhizobium leguminosarum biovarvicias hybrid strains containing definedR. l. bv.trifolii host range genes were used. The morphological changes in the root tissue of uninoculated and rhizobia inoculated white clovers were identified and compared. In particular, changes were observed in the induction of inner cortical cell division, alterations to nodule development and lateral root formation. The responses of the infected roots and the types of structures formed support the hypothesis that lateral roots and nodules may be physiologically homologous structures. To establish a normal pattern of nodulation on white clover roots, both sets of known host specific nodulation genes (operonsnod FERL andnod MNX) ofR. l. bv.trifolii were required. However, some nodule development occurred when only thenod FERL genes were present in the hybrid strain.     

Number of Rhizobia and delayed inoculation influence nodulation of clovers

The relationship between numbers of rhizobia and nodulation response of legumes is of considerable practical importance. Experiments were done under controlled conditions to determine the influence of numbers of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar. trifolii on nodulation of arrowleaf clover (Trifolium vesiculosum Savi.) and crimson clover (T. incarnatum L.). Numbers of rhizobia in excess of 1000 per seed did not substantially increase earliness of nodulation or total number of nodules formed on the taproot. Nodules, however, were formed nearer the top of the taproot as numbers of rhizobia increased to 100,000 per seed. Delayed inoculation experiments indicated that nodulation sites for these clovers only remained susceptible to infection for less than 1 day. Delaying inoculation for 4 days resulted in only a 1 to 2 day delay in nodulation for arrowleaf and crimson clovers respectively and no delay for subterranean clover (T. subterraneum L.). Apparently, larger seedlings nodulated faster.     

Interstrain Competition between Representatives of Indigenous Serotypes of Rhizobium trifolii

The symbiotic characteristics of Rhizobium trifolii strains 1-01 and 2-01 were evaluated both individually and in various combinations on two cultivars (Mt. Barker and Woogenellup) of subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum L.). Nodules were observed on day 8 independent of cultivar or strain. Cultivar differences were measured in nodulating efficiency by 1-01 since 54% of the primary nodules were formed on cv. Mt. Barker and only 15% were formed on cv. Woogenellup in the zone above, or 1 cm below, the root tip location at the time of inoculation. The percentage of nodules formed in this zone by 2-01 was similar on both cultivars (31 to 32%). When mixtures of strains 1-01 and 2-01 (230:1 and 1:20) were used to inoculate plants, >90% of the nodules on both cultivars were occupied by the more abundant strain in the inoculum regardless of sampling date (4 or 8 weeks). In contrast, large percentages of nodules on 4-week-old plants of both cultivars exposed to a 5:1 inoculum mixture were doubly occupied (64 and 74%). By week 8 these values had decreased significantly (P ≤ 0.01) and were accompanied by large increases in the percentage of nodules occupied by either strain 1-01 alone (1 to 65%) on cv. Mt. Barker or 2-01 alone (4 to 49%) on cv. Woogenellup. The superior (cv. Mt. Barker) and inferior (cv. Woogenellup) symbiotic performance of plants inoculated with the 5:1 mixture correlated more closely with the 8-week than the 4-week nodule occupancy data. Primary nodule occupancy by 1-01 and 2-01 was significantly influenced by changes in the inoculum ratios of 1-01/2-01 from 5.7:1 to 0.67:1 on cv. Mt. Barker and from 1.9:1 to 0.67:1 on cv. Woogenellup. Despite evidence for extensive proliferation of the inoculant strains on the rhizoplanes, no evidence was obtained for either interstrain antagonism or selective proliferation as a valid reason to explain the outcome of primary nodulation.     

Trifolitoxin Production and Nodulation Are Necessary for the Expression of Superior Nodulation Competitiveness by Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii Strain T24 on Clover

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii T24 is ineffective in symbiotic nitrogen fixation, produces a potent antibiotic (referred to here as trifolitoxin) that is bacteriostatic to certain Rhizobium strains, and is very competitive for clover root nodulation (EA Schwinghamer, RP Belkengren 1968 Arch Mikrobiol 64: 130-145). The primary objective of this work was to demonstrate the roles of nodulation and trifolitoxin production in the expression of nodulation competitiveness by T24. Unlike wildtype T24, transposon mutants of T24 lacking trifolitoxin production were unable to decrease clover nodulation by an effective, trifolitoxin-sensitive strain of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii. A non-nodulating transposon mutant of T24 prevented clover nodulation by a trifolitoxin-sensitive R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii when co-inoculated with a T24 mutant lacking trifolitoxin production. Neither mutant alone prevented nodulation by the trifolitoxin-sensitive strain. These results demonstrate that trifolitoxin production and nodulation are required for the expression of nodulation competitiveness by strain T24. A trifolitoxin-sensitive strain of R. meliloti did not nodulate alfalfa when co-inoculated with T24 and a trifolitoxin-resistant strain of R. meliloti. Thus, a trifolitoxin-producing strain was useful in regulating nodule occupancy on a legume host other than clover. Trifolitoxin production was constitutive in both minimal and enriched media. Trifolitoxin was found to inhibit the growth of 95% of all strains of R. leguminosarum bvs. trifolii, viceae, and phaseoli tested. Strains of all 13 biotypes of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii were inhibited by trifolitoxin. Three strains of R. fredii were also inhibited. Strain T24 ineffectively nodulated 46 clover species, did not nodulate Trifolium ambiguum, and induced partially effective nodules on Trifolium micranthum. Since T24 produced partially effective nodules on T. micranthum and since a trifolitoxin-minus mutant of T24 induced ineffective nodules, trifolitoxin production is not the cause of the symbiotic ineffectiveness of T24.     

Nodulation of specific legumes is controlled by several distinct loci in Rhizobium trifolii

Summary Three distinct loci (designated regions III, IV and V) were identified in the 14 kb Nod region of Rhizobium trifolii strain ANU843 and were found to determine the host range characteristics of this strain. Deletion of region III or region V only from the 14 kb Nod region affected clover nodulation capacity. The introduction to R. Leguminosarum of DNA fragments on multicopy vectors carrying regions III, IV and V (but not smaller fragments) extended the host range of R. leguminosarum so that infection threads and nodules occurred on white clover plants. The same DNA fragments were introduced to the Sym plasmid-cured strain (ANU845) carrying the R. meliloti recombinant nodulation plasmid pRmSL26. Plasmid pRmSL26 alone does not confer root hair curling or nodulation on clover plants. However, the introduction to ANU845 (pRmSL26) of a 1.4 kb fragment carrying R. trifolii region IV only, resulted in the phenotypic activation of marked root hair curling ability to this strain on clovers but no infection events or nodules resulted. Only the transfer of regions III, IV and V to strain ANU845 (pRmSL26) conferred normal nodulation and host range ability of the original wild type R. trifolii strain. These results indicate that the host range genes determine the outcome of early plant-bacterial interactions primarily at the stage of root hair curling and infection.     

Siderophore and organic acid production in root nodule bacteria

Nineteen strains of root nodule bacteria were grown under various iron regimes (0.1, 1.0 and 20 M added iron) and tested for catechol and hydroxamate siderophore production and the excretion of malate and citrate. The growth response of the strains to iron differed markedly. For 12 strains (Bradyrhizobium strains NC92B and 32H1, B. japonicum USDA110 and CB1809, B. lupini WU8, cowpea Rhizobium NGR234, Rhizobium meliloti strains U45 and CC169, Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae WU235 and Rhizobium leguminosarum bv trifolii strains TA1, T1 and WU95) the mean generation time showed no variation with the 200-fold increase in iron concentration. In contrast, in Bradyrhizobium strains NC921, CB756 and TAL1000, B. japonicum strain 61A76 and R. leguminosarum bv viciae MNF300 there was a 2–5 fold decrease in growth rate at low iron. R. meliloti strains WSM419 and WSM540 showed decreased growth at high iron.All strains of root nodule bacteria tested gave a positive CAS (chrome azurol S) assay for siderophore production. No catechol-type siderophores were found in any strain, and only R. leguminosarum bv trifolii T1 and bv viciae WU235 produced hydroxamate under low iron (0.1 and 1.0 M added iron).Malate was excreted by all strains grown under all iron regimes. Citrate was excreted by B. japonicum USDA110 and B. lupini WU8 in all iron concentrations, while Bradyrhizobium TAL1000, R. leguminosarum bv viciae MNF300 and B. japonicum 61A76 only produced citrate under low iron (0.1 and/or 1.0 M added iron) during the stationary phase of growth.Abbreviations CAS chrome azurol S - HDTMA hexadecyltrime-thylammonium bromide     

Cloning and mutagenesis of nodulation genes from Rhizobium leguminosarum TOM, a strain with extended host range

Summary Some primitive pea lines, e.g. cultivar Afghanistan, are resistant to nodulation by most strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum. However the Turkish strain TOM can nodulate cv. Afghanistan in addition to commercial pea varieties, and this extended host range is a property of its symbiotic plasmid, pRL5JI. A gene bank was constructed using DNA from a strain of R. leguminosarum containing pRL5JI. Following transfer to a strain of R. leguminosarum that had been cured of its symbiotic plasmid, two derivatives were isolated that contained cloned nodulation determinants, and were able to nodulate both cv. Afghanistan and a commercial pea variety. In addition, these clones conferred the ability to nodulate peas to a strain of R. phaseoli that had been previously cured of its symbiotic plasmid. One of these clones was subjected to mutagenesis with transposon Tn5, and 11 mutants were identified that were affected in nodulation ability. The sites of Tn5 insertions were mapped using restriction endonucleases and all were found to be within a region of 5 kb. The mutants fell into three classes on the basis of their map positions and their phenotypes on the two different pea lines tested. One class of mutants was affected in gene functions that were common to the nodulation of both pea hosts; a second class was impaired specifically in the nodulation of the commercial pea variety; a third class of mutant failed to confer on a normal strain of R. leguminosarum the supplementary ability to nodulate cv. Afghanistan.     

Identification of a nodD-like gene in Frankia by direct complementation of a Rhizobium nodD-mutant.

Summary Clones from aFrankia At4 gene bank were pooled into groups and mass conjugated into anodD mutant ofRhizobium leguminosarum bv.viciae by triparental matings. When peas were inoculated with the pooled transconjugants, nodulation was observed. A plasmid, pAt2GX containingFrankia DNA, was isolated from bacteria recovered from these nodules. This plasmid was shown to complement anodD mutant ofR. leguminosarum bv.viciae. Thus pAt2GX contains aFrankia gene that is functionally equivalent tonodD ofR. leguminosarum bv.viciae.     

Characterization of Sym plasmids of Rhizobium leguminosarum strains able to nodulate Pisum sativum cv Afghanistan

Rhizobium leguminosarum strains that can form nodules on Pisum sativum cv. Afghanistan have been reported as uncommon in Europe, North America and Africa [11, 12]. The organization of the nodulation regions of the symbiotic plasmids of five strains of R. leguminosarum originating from Denmark [9], which can nodulate P. sativum cv. Afghanistan, was compared with that of a Turkish strain (TOM [18]) by DNA hybridizations. Four of the five Danish strains were found to be very similar to the Turkish strain with respect to the overall organizations of their respective nodulation regions.     

repABC-based replication systems of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii TA1 plasmids: incompatibility and evolutionary analyses

Soil bacteria of the genus Rhizobium possess complex genomes consisting of a chromosome and in addition, often, multiple extrachromosomal replicons, which are usually equipped with repABC genes that control their replication and partition. The replication regions of four plasmids of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii TA1 (RtTA1) were identified and characterized. They all contained a complete set of repABC genes. The structural diversity of the rep regions of RtTA1 plasmids was demonstrated for parS and incα elements, and this was especially apparent in the case of symbiotic plasmid (pSym). Incompatibility assays with recombinant constructs containing parS or incα demonstrated that RtTA1 plasmids belong to different incompatibility groups. Horizontal acquisition was plausibly the main contributor to the origin of RtTA1 plasmids and pSym is probably the newest plasmid of this strain. Phylogenetic and incompatibility analyses of repABC regions of three closely related strains: RtTA1, R. leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841 and Rhizobium etli CFN42, provided data on coexistence of their replicons in a common genomic framework.     

Nodulation ofTrifolium subterraneum byRhizobium leguminosarum

Summary Four cultivars ofTrifolium subterraneum were nodulated by five strains ofRhizobium leguminosarum; all combinations except one gave 100% nodulation. Rates of nodule formation and total nodule numbers were similar to those with an effectiveR. trifolii strain. The nodules were more commonly associated with lateral roots and were ineffective in nitrogen fixation.     

sym 18. A novel gene conditioning altered strain specificity in Pisum sativum cv. ‘Sparkle’

An induced mutant of pea Pisum sativum cv. Sparkle forms few nodules with R. leguminosarum bv. viciea from temperate regions, exemplified by strain PRE, but nodulates normally with some rhizobia from Middle East soils, exemplified by strain TOM. The mutant gene is not an allele of sym2, found in the primitive cultivar Afghanistan. Mutant line E54 has a specificity similar to Afghanistan but forms more nodules with temperate strains, especially PF₂ which nodulates Afghanistan only poorly. The new phenotype is conditioned by gene sym18, which can act as recessive or semi-dominant depending on the rhizobial strain. Also sym18 is distinguished from sym 2 by its location on a different linkage group. Sym18 was mapped 9cM from k on linkage group II.