Ribonucleotide sequence homology among avian oncornaviruses.

RNA sequence relatedness among avian RNA tumor virus genomes was analyzed by inhibition of DNA-RNA hybrid formation between 3H-labeled 35S viral RNA and an excess of leukemic or normal chicken cell DNA with increasing concentrations of unlabeled 35S viral RNA. The avian viruses tested were Rous associated virus (RAV)-3, avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV), RAV-60, RAV-61, and B-77 sarcoma virus. Hybridization of 3H-labeled 35S AMV RNA with DNA from normal chicken cells was inhibited by unlabeled 35S RAV-0 RNA as effeciently (100%) as by unlabeled AMV RNA. Hybridization between 3H-labeled 35S AMV RNA and DNA from leukemic chicken myeloblasts induced by AMV was suppressed 100 and 68% by unlabeled 35S RNA from AMV and RAV-0, respectively. Hybridization between 3H-labeled RAV-0 and leukemic chicken myeloblast DNA was inhibited 100 and 67% by unlabeled 35S RNA from RAV-0 and AMV, respectively. It appears therefore that the AMV and RAV-0 genomes are 67 to 70% homologous and that AMV hybridizes to RAV-0 like sequences in normal chicken DNA. Hybridization between AMV RNA and leukemic chicken DNA was inhibited 40% by RNA from RAV-60 or RAV-61 and 50% by B-77 RNA. Hybridization between RAV-0 RNA and leukemic chicken DNA was inhibited 80% by RAV-60 or RAV-61 and 70% by B-77 RNA. Hybridization between 3H-labeled 35S RNA from RAV-60 or RAV-61 and leukemic chicken myeloblast DNA was reduced equally by RNA from RAV-60, RAV-61, AMV or RAV-0; this suggests that RNA from RAV-60 and RAV-61 hybridizes with virus-specific sequences in leukemic DNA which are shared by AMV, RAV-0, RAV-60, and RAV-61 RNA'S. Hybridization between 3H-labeled 35S RNA from RAV-61 and normal pheasant DNA was inhibited 100% by homologous viral RNA, 22 TO 26% BY RNA from AMV or RAV-0, and 30 to 33% by RNA from RAV-60 or B-77. Nearly complete inhibition of hybricization between RAV-0 RNA and leukemic chicken DNA by a mixture of AMV and B-77 35S RNAs indicates that the RNA sequences shared by B-77 virus and RAV-0. It appears that different avian RNA tumor virus genomes have from 50 to 80% homology in nucleotide sequences and that the degree of hybridization between normal chicken cell DNA and a given viral RNA can be predicted from the homology that exists between the viral RNA tested and RAV-0 RNA.     

Homology between avian oncornavirus RNAs and DNA from several avian species.

3H-labeled 35S RNA from avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV), Rous associated virus (RAV)-0, RAV-60, RAV-61, RAV-2, or B-77(w) was hybridized with an excess of cellular DNA from different avian species, i.e., normal or leukemic chickens, normal pheasants, turkeys, Japanese quails, or ducks. Approximately two to three copies of endogenous viral DNA were estimated to be present per diploid of normal chicken cell genome. In leukemic chicken myeloblasts induced by AMV, the number of viral sequences appeared to have doubled. The hybrids formed between viral RNA and DNA from leukemic chicken cells melted with a Tm 1 to 6 C higher than that of hybrids formed between viral RNA and normal chicken cell DNA. All of the viral RNAs tested, except RAV-61, hybridized the most with DNA from AMV-infected chicken cells, followed by DNA from normal chicken cells, and then pheasant DNA. RAV-61 RNA hybridized maximally (39%) with pheasant DNA, followed by DNA from leukemic (34%), and then normal (29%) chicken cells. All viral RNAs tested hybridized little with Japanese quail DNA (2 to 5%), turkey DNA (2 to 4%), or duck DNA (1%). DNA from normal chicken cells contained only 60 to 70% of the RAV-60 genetic information, and normal pheasant cells lacked some RAV-61 DNA sequences. RAV-60 and RAV-61 genomes were more homologous to the RAV-0 genome than to the genome of RAV-2, AMV, or B-77(s). RAV-60 and RAV-61 appear to be recombinants between endogenous and exogenous viruses.     

Ribonucleotide Sequence Homology Among Avian Oncornaviruses

RNA sequence relatedness among avian RNA tumor virus genomes was analyzed by inhibition of DNA-RNA hybrid formation between ³H-labeled 35S viral RNA and an excess of leukemic or normal chicken cell DNA with increasing concentrations of unlabeled 35S viral RNA. The avian viruses tested were Rous associated virus (RAV)-0, avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV), RAV-60, RAV-61, and B-77 sarcoma virus. Hybridization of ³H-labeled 35S AMV RNA with DNA from normal chicken cells was inhibited by unlabeled 35S RAV-0 RNA as efficiently (100%) as by unlabeled AMV RNA. Hybridization between ³H-labeled 35S AMV RNA and DNA from leukemic chicken myeloblasts induced by AMV was suppressed 100 and 68% by unlabeled 35S RNA from AMV and RAV-0, respectively. Hybridization between ³H-labeled RAV-0 and leukemic chicken myeloblast DNA was inhibited 100 and 67% by unlabeled 35S RNA from RAV-0 and AMV, respectively. It appears therefore that the AMV and RAV-0 genomes are 67 to 70% homologous and that AMV hybridizes to RAV-0 like sequences in normal chicken DNA. Hybridization between AMV RNA and leukemic chicken DNA was inhibited 40% by RNA from RAV-60 or RAV-61 and 50% by B-77 RNA. Hybridization between RAV-0 RNA and leukemic chicken DNA was inhibited 80% by RAV-60 or RAV-61 and 70% by B-77 RNA. Hybridization between ³H-labeled 35S RNA from RAV-60 or RAV-61 and leukemic chicken myeloblast DNA was reduced equally by RNA from RAV-60, RAV-61, AMV or RAV-0; this suggests that RNA from RAV-60 and RAV-61 hybridizes with virus-specific sequences in leukemic DNA which are shared by AMV, RAV-0, RAV-60, and RAV-61 RNAs. Hybridization between ³H-labeled 35S RNA from RAV-61 and normal pheasant DNA was inhibited 100% by homologous viral RNA, 22 to 26% by RNA from AMV or RAV-0, and 30 to 33% by RNA from RAV-60 or B-77. Nearly complete inhibition of hybridization between RAV-0 RNA and leukemic chicken DNA by a mixture of AMV and B-77 35S RNAs indicates that the RNA sequences shared by B-77 virus and RAV-0 are different from the sequences shared by AMV and RAV-0. It appears that different avian RNA tumor virus genomes have from 50 to 80% homology in nucleotide sequences and that the degree of hybridization between normal chicken cell DNA and a given viral RNA can be predicted from the homology that exists between the viral RNA tested and RAV-0 RNA.     

Nucleotide Sequence Relationships of Avian RNA Tumor Viruses: Measurement of the Deletion in a Transformation-Defective Mutant of Rous Sarcoma Virus

Stocks of cloned helper-independent Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) spontaneously segregate transformation-defective (td) mutants that appear to have an RNA genome composed of smaller subunits than those of the patent virus. Differential hybridization and competitive hybridization techniques involving reactions between viral RNA and proviral sequences in host cell DNA (under conditions of initial DNA excess) were used to measure the extent of the deletion in a td mutant of Prague strain (Pr) of RSV (Pr RSV-C). Viral 60 to 70S RNA sequences labeled to 1 to 5 x 10(7) counts per min per mug with (125)I were characterized with respect to their properties in hybridization reactions and used to reinforce data obtained with [(3)H]RNA of lower specific activity. By these techniques, about 13% +/- 3% of the sequences Pr RSV-C that formed hybrids with DNA from virus-induced sarcomas appeared to be deleted from the genome of td Pr RSV-C. Studies comparing hybridization of RNA from Pr RSV-C and td Pr RSV-C with RSV-related sequences in normal cells, and competition experiments with RNA from the endogenous chicken oncornavirus Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0) provided evidence that the majority, if not all, of the RNA sequences of Pr RSV-C deleted from its transformation-defective mutant are not represented in normal chicken DNA. Competition studies with a leukosis virus, RAV-7, indicated this virus also lacks a genome segment of about the same size as the deletion in the td mutant. Finally, the genome of all three "exogenous" viruses was found to lack a small segment (about 12%) of sequences present in the endogenous provirus of RAV-O.     

Chicken leukosis virus genome sequences in DNA from normal chick cells and virus-induced bursal lymphomas.

Genome sequences of two recent field isolates of avian leukosis viruses in the DNA of normal and neoplastic chicken cells were studied by DNA-RNA hybridization under conditions of DNA excess. Comparisons were made between 60-70S RNA from these viruses and that of a chicken endogenous type C virus (RAV-0), and of a series of "laboratory" leukosis and sarcoma viruses, by competitive hybridization analysis. A minimum of 18% of the genome sequences of both ALV isolates detected in DNA from lymphomas they induced were not detected in normal chicken DNA. The vast majority of the fraction of RNA sequences from ALV which do form hybrids with normal chick DNA appear to be reacting with the endogenous provirus of RAV-0. The genomic representation of a variety of avian leukosis and sarcoma viruses in normal chicken cells could not be distinguished by these methods (except that 13% of the RAV-0 genome was not shared with any of the other viruses). In contrast, the portion of the ALV genome exogenous to the normal chicken geome showed significant divergence from that of two sarcoma viruses (Pr RSV-C and B-77). The increased hybridization of ALV RNA with lymphoma DNA was used to detect the appearance of ALV specific sequences in the bursa of Fabricius following infection.increased hybridization was correlated with both the time after infection and the extent of replacement of the bursa by lymphoma. About one half of the increase in hybridization preceded histologic evidence of transformation.     

Reticuloendotheliosis Virus Nucleic Acid Sequences in Cellular DNA

Reticuloendotheliosis virus 60S RNA labeled with (125)I, or reticuloendotheliosis virus complementary DNA labeled with (3)H, were hybridized to DNAs from infected chicken and pheasant cells. Most of the sequences of the viral RNA were found in the infected cell DNAs. The reticuloendotheliosis viruses, therefore, replicate through a DNA intermediate. The same labeled nucleic acids were hybridized to DNA of uninfected chicken, pheasant, quail, turkey, and duck. About 10% of the sequences of reticuloendotheliosis virus RNA were present in the DNA of uninfected chicken, pheasant, quail, and turkey. None were detected in DNA of duck. The specificity of the hybridization was shown by competition between unlabeled and (125)I-labeled viral RNAs and by determination of melting temperatures. In contrast, (125)I-labeled RNA of Rous-associated virus-O, an avian leukosis-sarcoma virus, hybridized 55% to DNA of uninfected chicken, 20% to DNA of uninfected pheasant, 15% to DNA of uninfected quail, 10% to DNA of uninfected turkey, and less than 1% to DNA of uninfected duck.     

Structural protein markers in the avian oncoviruses.

The proteins of purified avian oncoviruses were analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and isoelectric focusing. Certain members of the avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses (ALSV) had group-specific antigens with altered electrophoretic properties. (i) The p27 protein of Rous-associated virus 0 (RAV-0) had a lower electrophoretic mobility in SDS gels and a lower isoelectric point than the p27 of other ALSV. (ii) The p19 proteins of RAV-1, RAV-2, and the Bryan high-titer strain of Rous sarcoma virus had higher mobilities in SDS gels than did the corresponding protein of other viruses. This altered electrophoretic mobility was correlated with specific differences in the tryptic peptides of radioiodinated p19s. (iii) The p15 protein of RAV-7 had a lower mobility in SDS gels than did the p15 of other ALSV. These markers were used in a study of the structural proteins of subgroup E RAV-60 produced after infection of chicken embryo cells by exogenous ALSV. Although exogenous group-specific protein markers could often be identified in the subgroup E isolates, one RAV-60 had a p27 that comigrated with the p27 of RAV-0. The p19s of two other RAV-60 isolates had electrophoretic properties that were different than those of p19s from either RAV-0 or the exogenous viruses. These results support the hypothesis that RAV-60 is generated by recombination between endogenous and exogenous oncoviruses and indicate that at least the p27 encoded by RAV-0 is closely related to a protein specified by endogenous viral information in chicken cells.     

Embryonic infection with the endogenous avian leukosis virus Rous-associated virus-0 alters responses to exogenous avian leukosis virus infection.

We inoculated susceptible chicken embryos with the endogenous avian leukosis virus Rous-associated virus-0 (RAV-0) on day 6 of incubation. At 1 week after hatching, RAV-0-infected and control chickens were inoculated with either RAV-1 or RAV-2, exogenous viruses belonging to subgroups A and B, respectively. The chickens injected with RAV-0 as embryos remained viremic with exogenous virus longer and either failed to develop type-specific humoral immunity to exogenous virus or developed it later than the control chickens not inoculated with RAV-0. The RAV-0-injected chickens also developed neoplasms at a much higher frequency than did the control chickens. We suggest that the lower immune responses of the RAV-0-injected chickens were due to an immunological tolerance to envelope group-specific glycoproteins shared among endogenous and exogenous viruses.     

Recombinants between endogenous and exogenous avian tumor viruses: role of the C region and other portions of the genome in the control of replication and transformation.

Endogenous retroviruses of chickens are closely related to exogenous viruses isolated from spontaneous tumors in the same species, yet differ in a number of important characteristics, including the ability to transform cells in culture, ability to cause sarcomas or leukemias, host range, and growth rate in cell culture. To correlate these differences with specific sequence differences between the two viral genomes, the genome RNA of transforming subgroup E recombinants between the Prague strain of Rous sarcoma virus, subgroup B (Pr-RSV-B), and the endogenous Rous-associated virus-0 (RAV-0), Subgroup E, and seven nontransforming subgroup E recombinants between the transformation-defective mutant of Pr-RSV-B and RAV-0 was examined by oligonucleotide fingerprinting. The pattern of inheritance among the recombinant viruses of regions of the genome in which Pr-RSV-B and RAV-0 differ allowed us to draw the following conclusions. (i) Nonselected parts of the genome were, with a few exceptions, inherited by the recombinant virus progeny randomly from either parent, with no obvious linkage between neighboring sequences. (ii) A small region in the Pr-RSV-B genome which maps in the 5' region was found in all transforming but only some of the nontransforming recombinants, suggesting that it plays a role in the control of the expression of transformation. (iii) A region of the Pr-RSV-B genome which maps between env and src was similarly linked to the src gene and may be either part of the structural gene for src or a control sequence regulating the expression of src. (iv) The C region at the extreme 3' end of the virus genome which is closely related in all the exogenous avian retroviruses but distinctly different in the endogenous viruses is the major determinant responsible for the differences in growth rate between RAV-0 and Pr-RSV-B. This latter observation allowed us to redefine the C region as a genetic locus, c, with two alleles cn (in RAV-0) and cx (in exogenous viruses).     

Induction of neoplasms by subgroup E recombinants of exogenous and endogenous avian retroviruses (Rous-associated virus type 60).

Chickens susceptible to infection with subgroup E viruses were inoculated with four independent isolates of Rous-associated virus type 60 (RAV-60) that are subgroup e recombinants of endogenous and exogenous virus. Neoplasms developed in each inoculated group. Therefore, nontransforming viruses of subgroup E can induce lymphoid leukosis at a moderate rate compared with RAV-0, a subgroup E endogenous virus, suggesting that oncogenicity is not a viral envelope (env)-related characteristic. Since the common (c) regions of the RAV-60s examined were of exogenous origin, we suggest that the c region rather than env is important for a high rate of induction of lymphoid leukosis and related neoplasms.     

Integration of Rous-associated virus type O provirus in susceptible chicken cells.

The number of viral genome equivalents per haploid cell genome was determined in normal chicken embryos from three selected chicken lines and in cultured fibroblasts (CEF) from these embryos. The cellular concentration of endogenous proviral DNA is similar in embryos from chickens of lines SPAFAS, 7, 15, 7 x 15, and 100. The concentration of proviral DNA is not affected by in vitro cultivation in CEF from lines that do not spontaneously produce virus, nor in CEF from line 7, which lacks receptors for Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0). There is, however, a restricted increase in the number of integrated proviral genome equivalents in CEF from line 7 x 15, which produces RAV-0 and can support replication of this virus, and in CEF from line 15 experimentally infected with RAV-0.     

Organization of shared and unshared sequences in the genomes of chicken endogenous and sarcoma viruses.

The genome of the genetically transmitted endogenous C type virus of chickens, RAV-O, is closely related to that of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV). Nevertheless, these viruses differ widely in oncogenicity and regulation by the host cell. Competitive hybridization analysis of ¹²⁵I-labeled genomic RNA demonstrated that the genome of RAV-O lacks about 35% of the sequences of nondefective RSV which formed hybrids with proviral DNA from RSV-infected cells, and that the genome of transformation-defective deletion mutants of RSV (td RSV) lacks about 15% of these sequences. Conversely, about 12% of the RAV-O sequences forming hybrids with normal chicken cell DNA were not detected in the sarcoma virus. A technique was developed to map the location of these unshared sequences by competitive hybridization. The deletion in the genome of td RSV was seen to begin at about 0.2 and to end at about 0.05 of the genome length from the 3′ end of sarcoma virus RNA, confirming the results of other laboratories using the method of mapping RNAase TI resistance of oligonucleotides. The 35% of RSV sequences missing and/or diverged in the genome of RAV-O were concentrated within 40% of the sarcoma virus genome from the 3′ end, and most of this large section did not appear to form hybrids with chicken DNA under the conditions of these experiments. A low level of hybrid formation was, however, detected between uninfected chicken cellular DNA and a small fraction of the nucleotides in the region of the td deletion. Analysis of RAV-O 3′ end fragments demonstrated that the genomic sequences of RAV-O missing in RSV were concentrated at the 3′ end of the endogenous viral genome. We conclude that the sequence differences between endogenous and sarcoma viruses are largely concentrated in specific regions of the viral genome.     

Nucleotide Sequences Derived from Pheasant DNA in the Genome of Recombinant Avian Leukosis Viruses with Subgroup F Specificity

Recombination between viral and cellular genes can give rise to new strains of retroviruses. For example, Rous-associated virus 61 (RAV-61) is a recombinant between the Bryan high-titer strain of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and normal pheasant DNA. Nucleic acid hybridization techniques were used to study the genome of RAV-61 and another RAV with subgroup F specificity (RAV-F) obtained by passage of RSV-RAV-0 in cells from a ring-necked pheasant embryo. The nucleotide sequences acquired by these two independent isolates of RAV-F that were not shared with the parental virus comprised 20 to 25% of the RAV-F genomes and were indistinguishable by nucleic acid hybridization. (In addition, RAV-F genomes had another set of nucleotide sequences that were homologous to some pheasant nucleotide sequences and also were present in the parental viruses.) A specific complementary DNA, containing only nucleotide sequences complementary to those acquired by RAV-61 through recombination, was prepared. These nucleotide sequences were pheasant derived and were not present in the genomes of reticuloendotheliosis viruses, pheasant viruses, and avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses of subgroups A, B, C, D, and E. They were partially endogenous, however, to avian DNA other than pheasant. The fraction of these nucleotide sequences present in other avian DNAs generally paralleled the genetic relatedness of these avian species to pheasants. However, there was a high degree of homology between these pheasant nucleotide sequences and related nucleotide sequences in the DNA of normal chickens as indicated by the identical melting profiles of the respective hybrids.     

Lack of Sequence Homology Among RNAs of Avian Leukosis-Sarcoma Viruses, Reticuloendotheliosis Viruses, and Chicken Endogenous RNA-Directed DNA Polymerase Activity

The relatedness of the RNAs of the three avian systems, including six avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses, four reticuloendotheliosis viruses, and the microsome fraction of normal uninfected chicken embryo cells, containing RNA and a DNA polymerase have been studied by nucleic acid hybridization. All six avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses have closely related nucleotide sequences; and all four reticuloendotheliosis viruses have closely related nucleotide sequences. But, almost no similarities were detected between the RNAs of avian leukosis-sarcoma viruses and reticuloendotheliosis viruses. The RNA template of the endogenous RNA-directed DNA polymerase activity of normal uninfected chicken cells had no detectable relationship to RNAs of avian leukosis-sarcoma and reticuloendotheliosis viruses.     

Comparison of an avian osteopetrosis virus with an avian lymphomatosis virus by RNA-DNA hybridization.

Myeloblastosis-associated virus (MAV)-2(0), a virus which was derived from avian myeloblastosis virus and induced a high incidence of osteopetrosis, was compared with avian lymphomatosis virus 5938, a recent field isolate which induced a high incidence of lymphomatosis. The following information was obtained. (i) MAV-2(0) induced osteopetrosis, nephroblastoma, and a very low incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma. No difference was seen in the oncogenic spectrum of end point and plaque-purified MAV-2(0). (ii) 125I-labeled RNA sequences from MAV-2(0) formed hybrids with DNA extracted from osteopetrotic bone at a rate suggesting five proviral copies per haploid cell genome. The extent of hybridization of MAV-2(0) RNA with DNA from osteopetrotic tissue was more extensive (87%) than was observed in reactions with DNA from uninfected chicken embryos (52%). (iii) Competition of unlabeled viral RNA in hybridization reactions between the radioactive RNA from the two viruses and their respective proviral sequences present in tumor tissues showed that 15 to 20% of the viral sequences detected in these reactions were unshared. In contrast, no differences were detected in competition analyses of RNA sequences from the two viruses detected in DNA of normal chicken cells. (iv) MAV-2(0) 35S RNA was indistinguishable in size from avian lymphomatosis virus 5938 35S RNA by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.     

Synethesis and integration of viral DNA in chicken cells at different time after infection with various multiplicities of avian oncornavirus.

To see if integration of the provirus resulting from RNA tumor virus infection is limited to specific sites in the cell DNA, the variation in the number of copies of virus-specific DNA produced and integrated in chicken embryo fibroblasts after RAV-2 infection with different multiplicities has been determined at short times, long times, and several transfers after infection. The number of copies of viral DNA in cells was determined by initial hybridization kinetics of single-stranded viral complementary DNA with a moderate excess of cell DNA. The approach took into account the different sizes of cell DNA and complementary DNA in the hybridization mixture. It was found that uninfected chicken embryo fibroblasts have approximately seven copies, part haploid genome of DNA sequences homologous to part of the Rous-association virus 2 (RAV-2) genome. Infection with RAV-2 adds additional copies, and different sequences, of RAV -2- specific DNA. By 13 h postinfection, there are 3 to 10 additional copies per haploid genome. This number can not be increased by increasing the multiplicity of infection, and stays relatively constant up to 20 h postinfection, when some of the additional viral DNA is integrated. Between 20 and 40 h postinfection, the cells accumulated up to 100 copies per haploid genome of viral DNA. Most of these are unintegrated. This number decreases with cell transfer, until cells are left with one to three copies of additional viral DNA sequences per haploid genome, of which most are integrated. The finding that viral infection causes the permanent addition of one to three copies of integrated viral DNA, despite the cells being confronted with up to 100 copies per haploid genome after infection, is consistent with a hypothesis that chicken cells contain a limited number of specific integration sites for the oncornavirus genome.