Cloning and characterisation of a family of disease resistance gene analogs from wheat and barley

 The most common class of plant disease resistance (R) genes cloned so far belong to the NBS-LRR group which contain nucleotide-binding sites (NBS) and a leucine-rich repeat (LRR). Specific primer sequences derived from a previously isolated NBS-LRR sequence at the Cre3 locus, which confers resistance to cereal cyst nematode (CCN) in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) were used in isolating a family of resistance gene analogs (RGA) through a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) cloning approach. The cloning, analysis and genetic mapping of a family of RGAs from wheat (cv ‘Chinese Spring’) and barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cvs ‘Chebec’ and ‘Harrington’) are presented. The wheat and barley RGAs contain other conserved motifs present in known R genes from other plants and share between 55–99% amino acid sequence identity to the NBS-LRR sequence at the Cre3 locus. Phylogenetic analysis of the RGAs with other cloned R genes and RGAs from various plant species indicate that they belong to a superfamily of NBS-containing genes. Two of the barley derived RGAs were mapped onto loci on chromosomes 2H (2), 5H (7) and 7H (1) using barley doubled haploid (DH) mapping populations. Some of these loci identified are associated with regions carrying resistance to CCN and corn leaf aphid. Received: 6 January 1998 / Accepted: 1 April 1998     

Genome-wide identification of NBS genes in<Emphasis Type="Italic"> japonica</Emphasis> rice reveals significant expansion of divergent non-TIR NBS-LRR genes

A complete set of candidate disease resistance ( R) genes encoding nucleotide-binding sites (NBSs) was identified in the genome sequence of japonica rice ( Oryza sativa L. var. Nipponbare). These putative R genes were characterized with respect to structural diversity, phylogenetic relationships and chromosomal distribution, and compared with those in Arabidopsis thaliana. We found 535 NBS-coding sequences, including 480 non-TIR (Toll/IL-1 receptor) NBS-LRR (Leucine Rich Repeat) genes. TIR NBS-LRR genes, which are common in A. thaliana, have not been identified in the rice genome. The number of non-TIR NBS-LRR genes in rice is 8.7 times higher than that in A. thaliana, and they account for about 1% of all of predicted ORFs in the rice genome. Some 76% of the NBS genes were located in 44 gene clusters or in 57 tandem arrays, and 16 apparent gene duplications were detected in these regions. Phylogenetic analyses based both NBS and N-terminal regions classified the genes into about 200 groups, but no deep clades were detected, in contrast to the two distinct clusters found in A. thaliana. The structural and genetic diversity that exists among NBS-LRR proteins in rice is remarkable, and suggests that diversifying selection has played an important role in the evolution of R genes in this agronomically important species. (Supplemental material is available online at .)Communicated by R. HagemannThe first three authors contributed equally to this work     

The maize rp1 rust resistance gene identifies homologues in barley that have been subjected to diversifying selection

A number of agronomically important grasses (sorghum, wheat, panicum, sugar cane, oats, rice and barley) are shown to contain sequences homologous to rp1, a maize gene that confers race-specific resistance to the rust fungus Puccinia sorghi. Mapping of rp1-related sequences in barley identified three unlinked loci on chromosomes 1HL, 3HL and 7HS. The locus located on chromosome 7HS comprises a small gene family of at least four members, two of which were isolated and are predicted to encode nucleotide binding site-leucine-rich repeat (NBS-LRR) proteins that are respectively 58% and 60% identical to the maize rp1 protein. Evidence of positive selection for sequence diversification acting upon these two barley genes was observed; however, diversifying selection was restricted to the carboxy terminal half of the LRR domain. One of these rp1 homologous genes cosegregated with the barley Rpg1 stem rust resistance gene amongst 148 members of the Steptoe × Morex double haploid mapping family. Three other unrelated resistance gene-like sequences, potentially encoding NBS-LRR proteins, are also shown to be linked to the Rpg1 locus but not cosegregating with the gene. Received: 2 August 1999 / Accepted: 28 September 1999     

High-resolution mapping of the barley leaf rust resistance gene Rph5 using barley expressed sequence tags (ESTs) and synteny with rice

The rapidly growing expressed sequence tag (EST) resources of species representing the Poacea family and availability of comprehensive sequence information for the rice (Oryza sativa) genome create an excellent opportunity for comparative genome analysis. Extensive synteny between rice chromosome 1 and barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) chromosome 3 has proven extremely useful for saturation mapping of chromosomal regions containing target genes of large-genome barley with conserved orthologous genes from the syntenic regions of the rice genome. Rph5 is a gene conferring resistance to the barley leaf rust pathogen Puccinia hordei. It was mapped to chromosome 3HS, which is syntenic with rice chromosome 1S. The objective of this study was to increase marker density within the sub-centimorgan region around Rph5, using sequence-tagged site (STS) markers that were developed based on barley ESTs syntenic to the phage (P1)-derived artificial chromosome (PAC) clones comprising the distal region of rice chromosome 1S. Five rice PAC clones were used as queries in a blastn search to screen 375,187 barley ESTs. Ninety-four non-redundant EST sequences were identified from the EST database and used as templates to design 174 pairs of primer combinations. As a result, 9 barley EST-based STS markers were incorporated into the ‘Bowman’ × ‘Magnif 102’ high-resolution map of the Rph5 region. More importantly, six markers, including five EST-derived STS sequences, were found to co-segregate with Rph5. The results of this study demonstrate the usefulness of rice genomic resources for efficient deployment of barley ESTs for marker saturation of targeted barley genomic regions.     

Downy mildew (Pl ( 8 ) and Pl ( 14 )) and rust (R ( Adv )) resistance genes reside in close proximity to tandemly duplicated clusters of non-TIR-like NBS-LRR-encoding genes on sunflower chromosomes 1 and 13

Nucleotide binding site-leucine rich repeat (NBS-LRR) proteins are encoded by a ubiquitous gene family in sunflower and frequently harbor disease resistance genes. We investigated NBS-LRR-encoding resistance gene candidates (RGCs) flanking the downy mildew resistance genes Pl ₈ and Pl ₁₄ and the rust resistance gene R _Adv , which map on the NBS-LRR clusters of linkage groups 1 and 13 in sunflower genome. We shotgun sequenced bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones proximal to Pl ₈ , Pl ₁₄ , and R _Adv and identified seven novel non-Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR)-like NBS-LRR RGCs, which clustered with previously identified RGCs of linkage group 13 but were phylogenetically distant from the TIR- and non-TIR-NBS-LRR-encoding superfamilies of sunflower. Six of the seven predicted RGCs have intact open reading frames and reside in genomic segments with abundant transposable elements. The genomic localization and sequence similarity of the novel non-TIR-like predicted RGCs suggests that they originated from tandem duplications. RGCs in the proximity of Pl ₈ and R _Adv were likely introgressed from silverleaf sunflower genome, where the RGC cluster of linkage group 13 is duplicated in two independent chromosomes that have different architecture and level of recombination from the respective common sunflower chromosomes.     

Identification and mapping of the leaf stripe resistance gene Rdg1a in Hordeum spontaneum

Leaf stripe of barley, caused by Pyrenophora graminea, is an important seed-borne disease in organically grown as well as in conventionally grown Nordic and Mediterranean barley districts. Two barley segregating populations represented by 103 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) of the cross L94 (susceptible) × Vada (resistant) and 194 RILs of the cross Arta (susceptible) × Hordeum spontaneum 41-1 (resistant) were analysed with two highly virulent leaf stripe isolates, Dg2 and Dg5, to identify loci for P. graminea resistance. A major gene with its positive allele contributed by Vada and H. spontaneum 41-1 was detected in both populations and for both pathogen isolates on chromosome 2HL explaining 44.1 and 91.8% R ², respectively for Dg2 and Dg5 in L94 × Vada and 97.8 and 96.1% R ², respectively for Dg2 and Dg5 in Arta × H. spontaneum 41-1. Common markers in the gene region of the two populations enabled map comparison and highlighted an overlapping for the region of the resistance locus. Since the map position of the resistance locus identified in this report is the same as that for the leaf stripe resistance gene Rdg1a, mapped earlier in Alf and derived from the ‘botanical’ barley line H. laevigatum, we propose that leaf stripe resistance in Vada and H. spontaneum 41-1 is governed by the same gene, namely by Rdg1a, and that Rdg1a resistance could be traced back to H. spontaneum, the progenitor of cultivated barley. PCR-based molecular markers that can be used for marker-assisted selection (MAS) of Rdg1a were identified. An Rdg1a syntenic interval with the rice chromosome arm 4L was identified on the basis of rice orthologs of EST-based barley markers. Analysis of the rice genes annotated into the syntenic interval did not reveal sequences strictly belonging to the major class (nucleotide-binding site plus leucine-rich repeat) of the resistance genes. Nonetheless, four genes coding for domains that are present in the major disease-resistance genes, namely receptor-like protein kinase and ATP/GTP-binding proteins, were identified together with a homolog of the barley powdery mildew resistance gene mlo. Three (out of five) homologs of these genes were mapped in the Rdg1a region in barley and the mlo homolog map position was tightly associated with the LOD score peak in both populations.     

Pyramiding of bacterial blight resistance genes in rice: marker-assisted selection using RFLP and PCR

 DNA marker-assisted selection was used to pyramid four bacterial blight resistance genes, Xa-4, xa-5, xa-13 and Xa-21. Breeding lines with two, three and four resistance genes were developed and tested for resistance to the bacterial blight pathogen (Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae). The pyramid lines showed a wider spectrum and a higher level of resistance than lines with only a single gene. To speed up the gene pyramiding process and to facilitate future marker-aided selection, we developed PCR markers for the two recessive genes, xa-5 and xa-13, and used these to survey a range of rice germplasm. The results of the germplasm survey will be useful for the selection of parents in breeding programs aimed at transferring these bacterial blight resistance genes from one varietal background to another. Received: 6 December 1996/Accepted: 20 December 1996     

Gene organization of the quail major histocompatibility complex (MhcCoja) class I gene region

 Class I genomic clones of the quail (Coturnix japonica) major histocompatibility complex (MhcCoja) were isolated and characterized. Two clusters spanning the 90.8 kilobase (kb) and 78.2 kb class I gene regions were defined by overlapping cosmid clones and found to contain at least twelve class I loci. However, unlike in the chicken Mhc, no evidence for the existence of any Coja class II gene was obtained in these two clusters. Based on comparative analysis of the genomic sequences with those of the cDNA clones, Coja-A, Coja-B, Coja-C, and Coja-D (Shiina et al. 1999), these twelve loci were assigned to represent one Coja-A gene, two Coja-B genes (Coja-B1 and -B2), four Coja-C genes (Coja-C1-C4), four Coja-D genes (Coja-D1-D4), and one new Coja-E gene. A class I gene-rich segment of 24.6 kb in which five of these genes (Coja-B1, -B2, -D1, -D2 and -E) are densely packed were sequenced by the shotgun strategy. All of these five class I genes are very compact in size [2089 base pairs (bp)–2732 bp] and contain no apparent genetic defect for functional expression. A transporter associated with the antigen processing (TAP) gene was identified in this class I gene-rich segment. These results suggest that the quail class I region is physically separated from the class II region and characterized by a large number of the expressible class I loci (at least seven) in contrast to the chicken Mhc, where the class I and class II regions are not clearly differentiated and only at most three expressed class I loci so far have been recognized. Received: 9 March 1998 / Revised: 12 October 1998     

Comparative mapping of a gibberellic acid-insensitive dwarfing gene (Dwf2) on chromosome 4HS in barley

 We report the genetic mapping of Dwf2, a dominant gibberellic acid (GA₃)-insensitive dwarfing gene which has been previously described to cause a very short growth habit in barley (Hordeum vulgare) mutant ‘93/B694’. Using RFLP and microsatellite markers we performed segregation analysis in an F₂ population comprising 86 individuals developed from a cross of ‘93/B694’ (Dwf2) with ‘Bonus M2’ (dwf2). Dwf2 was mapped on the short arm of barley chromosome 4H proximal to microsatellite marker XhvOle (5.7 cM) and distal to RFLP marker Xmwg2299 (18.3 cM). The genetic localization of the Dwf2 gene at a homoeologous position to the multiallelic Rht-B1 and Rht-D1 loci in wheat suggests synteny of GA-insensitive dwarfing genes within the Triticeae. Moreover, the extremely prostrate growth habit exhibited in barley ‘93/B694’ (Dwf2) resembles that of wheat plants carrying the genes Rht-B1c (Rht3) or Rht-D1c (Rht10). Received: 1 July 1998 / Accepted: 17 September 1998     

Enhancing disease resistances of Super Hybrid Rice with four antifungal genes

A plant expression vector harboring four antifungal genes was delivered into the embryogenic calli of ‘9311’, an indica restorer line of Super Hybrid Rice, via modified biolistic particle bombardment. Southern blot analysis indicated that in the regenerated hygromycin-resistant plants, all the four antifungal genes, including RCH10, RAC22, β-Glu and B-RIP, were integrated into the genome of ‘9311’, co-transmitted altogether with the marker gene hpt in a Mendelian pattern. Some transgenic R₁ and R₂ progenies, with all transgenes displaying a normal expression level in the Northern blot analysis, showed high resistance to Magnaporthe grisea when tested in the typical blast nurseries located in Yanxi and Sanya respectively. Furthermore, transgenic F₁ plants, resulting from a cross of R₂ homozygous lines with high resistance to rice blast with the non-transgenic male sterile line Peiai 64S, showed not only high resistance to M. grisea but also enhanced resistance to rice false smut (a disease caused by Ustilaginoidea virens) and rice kernel smut (another disease caused by Tilletia barclayana).     

Isolation of an Rx homolog from C. annuum and the evolution of Rx genes in the Solanaceae family

The well-conserved NBS domain of resistance (R) genes cloned from many plants allows the use of a PCR-based approach to isolate resistance gene analogs (RGAs). In this study, we isolated an RGA (CapRGC) from Capsicum annuum “CM334” using a PCR-based approach. This sequence encodes a protein with very high similarity to Rx genes, the Potato Virus X (PVX) R genes from potato. An evolutionary analysis of the CapRGC gene and its homologs retrieved by an extensive search of a Solanaceae database provided evidence that Rx-like genes (eight ESTs or genes that show very high similarity to Rx) appear to have diverged from R1 [an NBS-LRR R gene against late blight (Phytophthora infestans) from potato]-like genes. Structural comparison of the NBS domains of all the homologs in Solanaceae revealed that one novel motif, 14, is specific to the Rx-like genes, and also indicated that several other novel motifs are characteristic of the R1-like genes. Our results suggest that Rx-like genes are ancient but conserved. Furthermore, the novel conserved motifs can provide a basis for biochemical structural–function analysis and be used for degenerate primer design for the isolation of Rx-like sequences in other plant species. Comparative mapping study revealed that the position of CapRGC is syntenic to the locations of Rx and its homolog genes in the potato and tomato, but cosegregation analysis showed that CapRGC may not be the R gene against PVX in pepper. Our results confirm previous observations that the specificity of R genes is not conserved, while the structure and function of R genes are conserved. It appears that CapRGC may function as a resistance gene to another pathogen, such as the nematode to which the structure of CapRGC is most similar.     

Resistance gene analogues from rice: cloning, sequencing and mapping

 Degenerate oligonucleotide primers were designed on the basis of nucleotide-binding-site (NBS) motifs conserved between resistance genes of Arabidopsis, flax and tobacco and subsequently used as PCR primers to amplify resistance gene analogues (RGA) in rice. Primers amplified a major band of approximately 500 bp. Restriction analysis of the amplified product revealed that the band was made up of several different fragments. Many of these fragments were cloned. Sixty different cloned fragments were analysed and assigned to 14 categories based on Southern blot analysis. Fourteen clones, each representing one of the 14 categories of RGAs were mapped onto the rice genetic map using a Nipponbare ( japonica)בKasalath’ (indica) mapping population consisting of 186 F₂ lines. Of the 14 clones representing each class 12 could be mapped onto five different chromosomes of rice with a major cluster of 8 RGAs on chromosome 11. Our results indicate that it is possible to use sequence homology from conserved motifs of known resistance genes to amplify candidate resistance genes from diverse plant taxa. Received: 23 September 1998 / Accepted: 28 November 1998     

Fine mapping and syntenic integration of the semi-dwarfing gene sdw3 of barley

The barley mutant allele sdw3 confers a gibberellin-insensitive, semi-dwarf phenotype with potential for breeding of new semi-dwarfed barley cultivars. Towards map-based cloning, sdw3 was delimited by high-resolution genetic mapping to a 0.04 cM interval in a “cold spot” of recombination of the proximal region of the short arm of barley chromosome 2H. Extensive synteny between the barley Sdw3 locus (Hvu_sdw3) and the orthologous regions (Osa_sdw3, Sbi_sdw3, Bsy_sdw3) of three other grass species (Oryza sativa, Sorghum bicolor, Brachypodium sylvaticum) allowed for efficient synteny-based marker saturation in the target interval. Comparative sequence analysis revealed colinearity for 23 out of the 38, 35, and 29 genes identified in Brachypodium, rice, and Sorghum, respectively. Markers co-segregating with Hvu_sdw3 were generated from two of these genes. Initial attempts at chromosome walking in barley were performed with seven orthologous gene probes which were delimiting physical distances of 223, 123, and 127 kb in Brachypodium, rice, and Sorghum, respectively. Six non-overlapping small bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clone contigs (cumulative length of 670 kb) were obtained, which indicated a considerably larger physical size of Hvu_sdw3. Low-pass sequencing of selected BAC clones from these barley contigs exhibited a substantially lower gene frequency per physical distance and the presence of additional non-colinear genes. Four candidate genes for sdw3 were identified within barley BAC sequences that either co-segregated with the gene sdw3 or were located adjacent to these co-segregating genes. Identification of genic sequences in the sdw3 context provides tools for marker-assisted selection. Eventual identification of the actual gene will contribute new information for a basic understanding of the mechanisms underlying growth regulation in barley.     

Rice has two distinct classes of protein kinase genes related to SNF1 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae , which are differently regulated in early seed development

We have isolated five cDNA clones (osk1–5) for protein kinases from rice which are related to SNF1 protein kinase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Based on the sequence homology, these cDNAs can be classified into two groups, group 1 (osk1) and group 2 (osk2–5). The products of these genes were demonstrated to be functional SNF1-related protein kinases by in vitro and in vivo experiments. Recombinant proteins expressed from both groups of genes were fully active as protein kinases and could phosphorylate SAMS peptide, a substrate specific for the SNF1/AMPK family, as well as themselves (autophosphorylation). Moreover, expression of osk3 cDNA in yeast snf1 mutants restored SNF1 function. Northern blot analyses showed differential expression of these two gene groups; group 1 is expressed uniformly in growing tissues (young roots, young shoots, flowers, and immature seeds), whereas group 2 is strongly expressed in immature seeds. SNF1-related protein kinases have been reported from different plant species, such as rye, barley, Arabidopsis, tobacco, and potato, while the type of gene strongly expressed in immature seeds is known only in cereals such as rye, barley, and, from our findings, in rice. Expression levels of the group 2 genes were further analyzed in seeds during seed maturation. Expression is transiently increased in the early stages of seed maturation and then decreases. The expression peak precedes those of the sbe1 and waxy genes, which are involved in starch synthesis in rice. Taken together, these findings suggest that group 2 OSK genes play important roles in the early stages of endosperm development in rice seeds. Received: 30 April 1998 / Accepted: 20 August 1998     

Enhancing disease resistances of Super Hybrid Rice with four antifungal genes

A plant expression vector harboring four antifungal genes was delivered into the embryogenic calli of ‘9311’, an indica restorer line of Super Hybrid Rice, via modified biolistic particle bombardment. Southern blot analysis indicated that in the regenerated hygromycin-resistant plants, all the four anti-fungal genes, including RCH10, RAC22, β-Glu and B-RIP, were integrated into the genome of ‘9311’, co-transmitted altogether with the marker gene hpt in a Mendelian pattern. Some transgenic R1 and R2 progenies, with all transgenes displaying a normal expression level in the Northern blot analysis, showed high resistance to Magnaporthe grisea when tested in the typical blast nurseries located in Yanxi and Sanya respectively. Furthermore, transgenic F₁ plants, resulting from a cross of R₂ homozygous lines with high resistance to rice blast with the non-transgenic male sterile line Peiai 64S, showed not only high resistance to M. grisea but also enhanced resistance to rice false smut (a disease caused by Ustilaginoidea virens) and rice kernel smut (another disease caused by Tilletia barclayana).     

Identification and mapping of a gene conferring resistance to the spot form of net blotch (Pyrenophora teres f maculata) in barley

 Spot form of net blotch (SFNB) (Pyrenophora teres f maculata) is an economically damaging foliar disease of barley in many of the world’s cereal growing areas. The development of SFNB-resistant cultivars may be accelerated through the use of molecular markers. A screen for SFNB resistance in 96 lines identified four new sources of resistance, including a feed variety, ‘Galleon’, for which a fully mapped doubled haploid population was available. Segregation data indicated SFNB resistance was conferred by a single gene in the ‘Galleon’בHaruna Nijo’ cross, positioned on the long arm of chromosome 7H. This gene is designated Rpt4 and is flanked by the RFLP loci Xpsr117(D) and Xcdo673 at distances of 6.9 cM and 25.9 cM, respectively. The marker Xpsr117(D) was validated using another population segregating for Rpt4, correctly predicting SFNB resistance with more than 90% accuracy. Received: 24 September 1998 / Accepted: 19 December 1998     

Identification of a YAC clone carrying the Xa-1 allele, a bacterial blight resistance gene in rice

Map-based cloning methods have been applied for isolation of Xa-1, one of the bacterial blight resistance genes in rice.Xa-1 was previously mapped on chromosome 4 using molecular markers. For positional cloning of Xa-1, a high-resolution genetic map was made for theXa-1 region using an F₂ population of 402 plants and additional molecular markers. Three restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers, XNpb235, XNpb264 and C600 were found to be linked tightly to Xa-1, with no recombinants, and U08 ₇₅₀ was mapped 1.5 cM from Xa-1. The screening of a yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) library using theseXa-1-linked RFLP markers resulted in the identification of ten contiguous YAC clones. Among these, one YAC clone, designated Y5212, with an insert of 340 kb, hybridized with all three tightly linked markers. This YAC was confirmed to possess the Xa-1 allele by mapping the Xa-1 gene between both end clones of this YAC (Y5212R and Y5212L).     

Homoeologous set of NBS-LRR genes located at leaf and stripe rust resistance loci on short arms of chromosome 1 of wheat

Homoeologous group 1 chromosomes of wheat contain important genes that confer resistance to leaf, stem and stripe rusts, powdery mildew and Russian wheat aphid. A disease resistance gene analog encoding nucleotide binding site-leucine rich repeat (NBS-LRR), designated RgaYr10, was previously identified at the stripe rust resistant locus, Yr10, located on chromosome 1BS distal to the storage protein, Gli-B1 locus. RgaYr10 identified gene members in the homoeologous region of chromosome 1DS cosegregating with the leaf rust resistance gene, Lr21, which originally was transferred from a diploid D genome progenitor. Four RgaYr10 gene members were isolated from chromosome 1DS and compared to two gene members previously isolated from the chromosome 1BS homeologue. NBS-LRR genes tightly linked to stripe rust resistance gene Yr10 on chromosome 1BS were closely related in sequence and structure to NBS-LRR genes tightly linked to leaf rust resistance gene Lr21 located within the homoeologous region on chromosome 1DS. The level of sequence homology was similar between NBS-LRR genes that were isolated from different genomes as compared to genes from the same genome. Electronic Publication