Transition in the character of immunological memory in mice after immunization. II. Memory in T and B cell populations.

Teh immunological memory in antibody response of mice to bovine serum albumin (BSA) was investigated at the level of antibody-producing cells or their precursor B cells and thymus-dependent helper T cells. Spleen cells obtained from mice previously primed with alum-precipitated BSA at various times were transferred to irradiated syngeneic mice. Spleen cells from mice immunized 8 days or 64 days before presented a high degree of adoptive secondary response, whereas the adoptive response of cells from mice immunized 2 days previously was found to be inferior even to that of unprimed spleen cells. Primed spleen cells treated with anti-mouse thymocyte rabbit serum plus complement were supplemented with normal thymus cells and the restoration of the responsiveness was examined. It was suggested that the memory was carried mainly by T cells in the earlier phases of the immunological memory (2 days or 8 days after the primary immunization). On the other hand, the immunological memory in the B-cell population was shown to grow gradually toward the later phase (later than 40 days).     

In Vitro Studies on the Immunological Memory for Antibody Response to Bovine Serum Albumin

Immunological memory for T and B cells was studied in an in vitro culture system with spleen cells from mice primed with bovine serum albumin (BSA). Spleen cells taken from mice immunized at various times previously with a single intravenous injection of alum-precipitated (AP) BSA and bacterial endotoxin (ET) were cultured in Marbrook's system with dinitrophenylated (DNP) BSA as the in vitro antigen. In the cultures of spleen cells obtained from mice primed more than 14 days previously, an IgG-predominant anti-BSA response was generated. However, no anti-BSA response was observed in the culture of spleen cells taken from mice primed 7 days previously (day 7 spleen cells). The failure of day 7 spleen cells to generate an antibody response in vitro was shown to be attributable to both the lack of B memory cells and the effect of “suppressive” macrophages induced by ET. On the other hand, anti-BSA memory in the spleen of mice primed with AP-BSA plus ET and 2 months later challenged with AP-BSA matured within 7 days and declined rather quickly by 30 days after the challenge. The difference in the time course of the generation of memory between the spleen cells from primary and from secondary immunized mice might be attributable to the difference in the maturation of memory B cells, since the time course of the development of memory T cells after the secondary immunization was similar to that observed after primary immunization.     

Antigenic markers on mouse lymphoid cells: origin of cells mediating immunologic memory

Specific antisera were used for the purification of thymus dependent and thymus independent or bursa equivalent lymphoid cells in the mouse. Spleen cells from mice immune to sheep erythrocytes, a thymus dependent antigen, or to E. coli 055:B5 lipopolysaccharide, a thymus independent antigen, were treated with anti-θ (C3H) serum or anti-MBLA serum and complement prior to their adoptive transfer into lethally irradiated syngeneic recipients. Syngeneic thymocytes, bone marrow cells, or spleen cells from nonimmune donors were appropriately added to antiserum treated cells prior to transfer. The secondary response to these antigens was assayed in recipient spleens six days after cell transfer. The kinetics of the primary response to SRBC was investigated as to its effect on origin of specific hyper-reactive T or B lymphoid cells.The adoptive response to CPS originated in the B lymphoid cell population. Immunologic memory to CPS was demonstrated in recipients of immune cells, compared to recipients of normal cells, by a five fold increase in antibody forming cells.The IgM and IgG adoptive immune response to high doses of SRBC depended upon an increased number of specifically hyper-reactive T-lymphoid cells to facilitate cooperation between T and B lymphocytes. High doses of SRBC initially stimulated T cell memory but at 42 days after priming an increased number of specifically hyper-reactive B lymphoid cells were present.     

Induction and mechanism of tolerance to bovine serum albumin in mice given total lymphoid irradiation (TLI).

BALB/c mice given total lymphoid irradiations (TLI) were injected i.p. with bovine serum albumin (BSA) in saline, and challenged with DNP-BSA in complete Freund's adjuvant 6 weeks later. The latter animals made no anti-DNP antibody response as measured by a modified Farr assay, but made a normal anti-DNP response after challenge with DNP-BGG in adjuvant. Normal mice or mice given whole body irradiation were not tolerized by the i.p. injection of BSA in saline. Spleen cells from unresponsive mice (TLI + BSA in saline) suppressed the adoptive secondary anti-DNP response of sublethally irradiated syngeneic hosts given BSA-primed T cells, DNP-BSA-primed B cells, and DNP-BSA in saline. The suppressor cells were antigen specific, and were inactivated by in vitro treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 antiserum and complement. The findings suggest that soluble antigens administered to mice after TLI evoke a state of tolerance that is maintained by antigen-specific suppressor T cells. A similar mechanism may be involved in the maintenance of tolerance to allografts. These findings may have important clinical implications for patients treated with TLI for lymphoid malignancies.     

Specific suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. I. Parameters affecting the level of suppression.

After adoptive transfer, the spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells. However, this suppressive activity in the spleen cells of tolerant mice is only present for a brief period after treatment with tolerogen. Spleen cells from animals injected 10 days earlier with tolerogen reduce the immune response of an equal number of normal spleen cells by 75%. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant 40 days previously are, however, no longer suppressive, even though they remain completely unresponsive. These data suggest that active suppression of antigen-reactive cells is not the mechanism responsible for maintaining tolerance to HGG, but rather is only transiently associated with the tolerant state. Further evidence in favor of the separation of the tolerant state from suppressive activity is that complete suppression of the normal spleen cell response requires either a high ratio of tolerant to immune competent cells or a delay in the antigenic challenge of the reconstituted recipients. By contrast, such manipulations are not required to demonstrate the complete unresponsiveness of the tolerant cells after adoptive transfer.     

Trypanosoma cruzi: the T-cell dependence of the primary immune response and the effects of depletion of T cells and Ig-bearing cells on immunological memory

The effects of T-cell depletion on primary infection with Trypanosoma cruzi and on immunological memory to this parasite were studied in a syngeneic mouse system. Exacerbation of T. cruzi infections occurred in thymectomized, irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted (TX) C57BL/6J mice compared to sham thymectomized, irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted (STX) mice. Reconstitution of TX mice with thymocytes restored the resistance to a level equivalent to that of STX mice. Immunological memory against T. cruzi present in spleen cells in mice recovered from T. cruzi infections could be ablated by treatment with rabbit anti-brain-associated theta serum but not with rabbit anti-mouse immunoglobulin serum prior to adoptive transfer of immune spleen cells into TX mice. These experiments suggest that modulation of the primary immune response and memory against T. cruzi depends largely on the thymus-derived lymphocyte. The possible implications of this T-cell regulation on previously reported effector mechanisms againt this parasite are discussed.     

Immunological memory and lymphoblast-migration in mice infected with Hymenolepis nana

The presence of small cells carrying memory and lymphoblast migration in C57 Bl/6N inbred mice with the intestinal parasite Hymenolepis nana were investigated. Hymenolepis nana egg-infection stimulated an enhanced accumulation of mesenteric lymphoblasts at days 3, 6 and 9 after infection; lymphoblasts accumulated selectively in the mesenteric nodes (MLN) of mice suggesting a cell-trapping effect. The migration was studied using lymphoblasts from non-infected donors. Spleen cells and MLNC collected from donor mice 30 days after a primary infection and enriched for T cells were able to transfer an adoptive immunity, by contrast unseparated cells were uneffective. This result provides preliminary evidence for the existence of T memory cells in the spleen and in the mesenteric nodes.     

Suppressor cells as an agent of immune facilitation. II. Adoptive transfer of passively induced enhancement of allografted tumors

CBA mice injected intravenously with CBA anti-A/J spleen cell antiserum, and challenged subcutaneously 24 hr later with A/J-derived sarcoma 1 (Sa 1) develop progressive tumors. “Normal” CBA mice (i.e., injected with normal CBA serum or noninjected) reject the allograft within 20 days. Spleen cells taken from mice 20–35 days after the injection of antiserum and Sa 1 challenge can specifically transfer the ability to enhance tumor growth when injected into 200 rad irradiated recipients. Spleen cells taken 8 days after antiserum and Sa 1 challenge cannot transfer suppression. The induction of suppressor cells requires both antiserum treatment and Sa 1 challenge. Serum from suppressed mice, and from control mice that are rejecting their tumors, can also transfer suppression but only when taken 20–35 days after treatment. The suppressor cells function most effectively when transferred at the time of tumor challenge, however, they also inhibit the rejection of Sa 1 when mixed with nylon-wool purified sensitized T cells. Suppressor cells are both nylon-wool nonadherent and adherent. Further purification of the column-enriched cells using antiimmunoglobulin or anti-Thy 1.2, plus complement, suggests that both T and B cells can suppress. The mixed lymphocyte response (MLR) of spleen cells from mice challenged only with Sa 1 is inhibited 8 days after challenge. A secondary response is obtained at 20–27 days. In contrast, the MLR from antiserum and Sa 1-treated mice 8 days after challenge resembles a secondary response. By 20–27 days mice with progressive tumors have only a primary-like response. In the present experimental situation, mitomycin-treated spleen cells from antiserum and Sa 1-treated mice cannot significantly inhibit the MLR of normal cells.     

The cytolytic T lymphocyte response to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic cells. I. Evidence for antigen-specific helper T cells.

Mice were primed subcutaneously with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified syngeneic spleen cells. Seven days later, spleen cells from these in vivo primed mice, or spleen cells from naive mice, were co-cultured with TNP-modified syngeneic cells. Spleen cells from the in vivo primed mice demonstrated augmented cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity. The spleens of these in vivo primed mice contained a population of radioresistant, antigen-specific, helper T cells. Specifically, spleen cells from these mice, after x-irradiation, were able to augment the in vitro CTL response of normal spleen cells to TNP-modified syngeneic cells.     

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) in BCG-sensitized mice I. Lack of suppressor T cell activity on DTH to sheep red blood cells.

Mice pretreated with an intravenous (i.v.) injection of BCG (BCG-sensitized mice) and then immunized intravenously with a high dose (10(8)--10(9)) of sheep red blood cells (SRBC) 2 weeks later developed strong delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) to SRBC, as in mice pretreated with cyclophosphamide (CY) (CY-treated mice) and then immunized with SRBC 2 days later; normal mice given the same dose of SRBC did not show such DTH. The mechanism of this strong DTH to SRBC which developed in BCG-sensitized mice was studied, by comparing it with that in CY-treated mice. The transfer of either whole spleen cells or thymus cells, but not serum, obtained from mice immunized with i.v. injections of 10(9) SRBC 4 days previously (hyperimmune mice) did not suppress either the induction or the expression of DTH to SRBC in BCG-sensitized mice, but suppressed those in CY-treated mice. The suppressor cells were SRBC-specific T cells. Adoptive transfer of DTH to SRBC by spleen cells from either BCG-sensitized mice of CY-treated mice to hyperimmune recipients failed. The adoptive transfer of DTH from BCG-sensitized mice to normal recipients also failed if the spleen cells from hyperimmune mice were cotransferred. Whole body irradiation (600 rad) of mice 2 hr before or after the time of immunization with SRBC reduced significantly DTH to SRBC in both BCG-sensitized and CY-treated mice. It was noticed that the total number of spleen cells in BCG-sensitized mice was 3--4 times larger than that in CY-treated mice. From these results, we conclude that the entity of effector T cells of DTH to SRBC induced in BCG-sensitized mice and in CY-treated mice was not different in terms of susceptibility to suppressor T cells and irradiation, but that the total numbers of effector T cells generated in these mice differed remarkably, resulting in the above-described different responsiveness to suppressor T cells transferred passively.     

Memory T cells are uniquely resistant to melanoma-induced suppression

We have previously observed that in vivo exposure to growing melanoma tumors fundamentally alters activated T cell homeostasis by suppressing the ability of naïve T cells to undergo antigen-driven proliferative expansion. We hypothesized that exposure of T cells in later stages of differentiation to melanoma would have similar suppressive consequences. C57BL/6 mice were inoculated with media or syngeneic B16F10 melanoma tumors 8 or 60 days after infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV), and splenic populations of LCMV-specific T cells were quantified using flow cytometry 18 days after tumor inoculation. Inoculation with melanoma on post-infection day 8 potentiated the contraction of previously activated T cells. This enhanced contraction was associated with increased apoptotic susceptibility among T cells from tumor-bearing mice. In contrast, inoculation with melanoma on post-infection day 60 did not affect the ability of previously established memory T cells to maintain themselves in stable numbers. In addition, the ability of previously established memory T cells to respond to LCMV challenge was unaffected by melanoma. Following adoptive transfer into melanoma-bearing mice, tumor-specific memory T cells were significantly more effective at controlling melanoma growth than equivalent numbers of tumor-specific effector T cells. These observations suggest that memory T cells are uniquely resistant to suppressive influences exerted by melanoma on activated T cell homeostasis; these findings may have implications for T cell–based cancer immunotherapy.     

Defective production of interleukin 1 and interleukin 2 in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)

The effects of local antigenic exposure on the responsiveness of systemic T cells were evaluated after C3H mice were given drinking water containing 6% bovine serum albumin (BSA) for 10 days and challenged sc with 1.0 mg BSA in adjuvant 28 days after the initiation of antigen feeding. During the first 28 days, no evidence of in vitro antigen-induced proliferation [( 3H]thymidine incorporation) was detected in whole lymphocyte populations from the peripheral lymph nodes (PLN), spleen, or mesenteric nodes. In contrast, PLN cells treated with anti-Lyt-1 plus complement (C) had a significant proliferative response only if the cells were obtained during the first 6 days of antigen ingestion. Lymphoid cells from the same animals, treated with anti-Lyt-2 and C, did not respond to antigen. Two or 4 days after the injection, given on day 28, whole PLN cell populations from antigen-fed mice showed proliferation. No response was observed with PLN cells obtained 8 days after injection. Shortening the interval between the initiation of feeding and parenteral challenge partially restored proliferative responses detected 8 days after injection. Cultures prepared 4 days after simultaneous oral and parenteral antigenic exposure showed proliferation equal to or greater than cultures from mice that received only the injection. These data show that systemic T cell responsiveness is not eliminated by ingestion of soluble antigen, but rather is modulated in a manner previously detected in the humoral immune system.     

Regulation of the primary in vitro response to TNP-polymerized ovalbumin by T suppressor cells induced by ovalbumin feeding

Spleen cells from DBA/2 mice that received a single feeding of 20 mg of ovalbumin (OVA) 7 days previously were specifically hyporesponsive to primary in vitro challenge with the thymic-dependent antigen TNP-polymerized ovalbumin (TNP-POL-OVA). The tolerance observed in spleen cells from OVA-fed animals was dependent upon OVA-specific T suppressor cells, because splenic T cells from OVA-fed mice suppressed the primary response to TNP-POL-OVA of cultures containing normal T and B cells. The tolerance and suppression was OVA specific, because spleen cells from OVA-fed animals responded well to other antigens (including TNP on another carrier), and splenic T cells from OVA-fed mice did not affect the response of normal T and B cells to sheep erythrocytes. These data confirm the existence of T suppressor cells after OVA feeding and provide a direct means of assaying their activity in a primary in vitro response.     

Regulatory Mechanism of Delayed-Type Hypersensitivity in Mice: III. In Vitro Analysis of Memory T Cells Involved in Augmentation of DTH Responses

The memory of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), manifested by the augmented responsiveness upon challenge with alum-absorbed ovalbumin (OA), was induced in mice primed 7 days, 21 days, or 90 days previously with 1 μg of reduced and alkylated OA. The memory cells involved in the augmentation of DTH responses were analyzed in the in vitro induction system of T cells which mediate DTH against OA. Spleen cells from the primed mice generated DTH-effector T cells (DTH-Te) in a significantly accelerated fashion, compared with unprimed spleen cells, when cultured with OA. The accelerated generation of DTH-Te in vitro was induced antigen specifically and was dependent on a certain T cell population in the primed spleen. The T cell population was found in the spleen of primed mice for at least 3 months after priming, corresponding to the persistence of DTH-memory in vivo. Moreover, it was fractionated in the high-density layer by discontinuous bovine serum albumin gradient centrifugation. The high-density cell population decreased in density with increase in the time of culture and developed into DTH-Te, which were separated in the low-density layer on day 4 of culture. These results indicate that the T cells involved in the accelerated generation of DTH-Te in vitro are long-lived DTH-memory T cells, which are probably precursor cells, capable of differentiating into DTH-Te upon challenge with the antigen.     

Splenic suppressor macrophages induced in mice by injection of Corynebacterium parvum.

Spleen cells from C57BL/6N mice injected with killed Corynebacterium parvum (CP) had a marked growth inhibitory effect on the in vitro proliferation of RBL-5 murine lymphoma cells. It was most marked 12 to 14 days after injection and was usually no longer detectable later than 21 days. It could be demonstrated at effector cell to target ratios between 20:1 and 5:1 at which normal spleen cells had a growth-promoting effect. Addition of CP to an in vitro mixture of spleen cells and tumor cells augmented the inhibitory effect of spleen cells from CP-injected mice although it conferred no inhibitory potential on normal spleen cells. Growth inhibiton by CP spleen cells was not mediated by T cells and various depletion experiments suggested that the effector cells of the phenomenon were macrophages. Spleen cells of CP-injected mice also showed strongly depressed responses to the T cell mitogens PHA and Con A and suppressed the mitogen responses of syngeneic normal spleen cells. The characteristics of the suppressor cells mediating this effect appeared to be very similar to those inhibiting lymphoma cell growth. The responses to LPS were also strongly suppressed in mice injected with 2.1 mg of CP. However, after injection of one-tenth of the dose a relative sparing of the LPS response was noted, whereas the PHA response was still suppressed.     

A reactivity to polyclonal stimulation of immunogenesis with salmozan after its repeated administration

The injection of 100 micrograms of salmozan (polysaccharide isolated from Salmonella typhi somatic O-antigen) or 50 micrograms of Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide into mice induced a considerable increase in the number of antibody-forming cells in the spleen in response to the injection of sheep red blood cells (SRBC) 2-3 days later. This polyclonal effect was essentially weaker if the animals previously received 500 micrograms of salmozan (9-10 days prior to the injection of SRBC). The absence of reactivity was not linked with antibodies to salmozan or with some other serum factor. The lymphocytes of nonreactive mice proved to be capable of polyclonal response in the adoptive system, and at the same time the polyclonal response of intact lymphocytes to salmozan in the body of nonreactive irradiated mice was essentially weakened. The features making the above phenomenon similar to, as well as different from, the so-called "endotoxin tolerance" are analyzed.     

Role of T- and B-cells in immunologic memory and the prolonged production of antibodies in the body]

The role of T and B cells in the immunological memory and prolonged antibody production in mice was studied; for this purpose CBA mice were immunized with SRBC in doses of 1 X 10(6) or 1 X 10(9) cells, decapitated 21--25 days later, and their spleen cells were treated with T or B antiserum and transferred in a dose 7 x 10(7) cells to syngeneic recipients treated with cyclophosphamide for suppressing their immunity. The treatment of the donor spleen cells with T or B antiserum resulted in a considerable decrease in the hemagglutinin level, as well as in the number of IgM- and IgG-forming cells. The transfer of T and B cells, mixed in equal amounts, to syngeneic recipients restored the immunological memory of the animals; in those cases when the mixture had the prevalence of T cells the restoration of the immunological memory was even more pronounced. The donor spleen cells treated with T or B antiserum, when tested for their ability to produce IgM- and IgG-forming cells in vitro (prior to their transfer to the recipient), showed a decrease in the production of IgM-forming cells (68%) and IgG-forming cells (74%) only under the action of B antiserum, whereas T antiserum had no influence on the production of IgM- and IgG-forming cells in vitro.     

Suppressors of the graft vs graft reaction in tolerance to alloantigens

Immune response and suppressor cell activity of CBA (H-2k) mice made tolerant to allogeneic C57B1/6 (H-2b) heart graft were studied in graft-versus-graft reaction (GvGR). Intact CBA spleen cells inhibited response of (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 cells to antigenic stimulus (sheep red blood cells--SRBC), when injected together into lethally irradiated (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 mice. Spleen cells of tolerant mice were unable to decrease immune response of (CBA X C57B1/6F1 lymphocytes to SRBC and suppressed specifically the inhibition induced by intact CBA spleen cells. Spleen cells from tolerant mice were also capable of suppressing GvGR induced by CBA lymphocytes immune to C57B1/6 cells. Pretreatment of tolerant spleen cells with rabbit antithymocyte globulin and complement before adoptive transfer diminished markedly the suppression. The results obtained in the study suggest that suppression of transplantation immunity in this model is mostly due to T suppressor cells.     

Transfer of immunity to Babesia microti of human origin using T lymphocytes in mice

Lymph node and spleen cells from mice infected with Babesia microti of human origin developed the ability to transfer adoptive immunity to naive mice within 25 days after infection. This protective activity was greater in cells obtained at 32 days than in cells obtained at 25 days postinfection and remained stable up to 52 days postinfection. Recipients of lymph node cells and spleen cells displayed similar peak parasitemias although 2 days after peak parasitemia, immune spleen cell recipients had significantly lower parasitemias than immune lymph node cell recipients. Strong protective activity was demonstrated when cells were transferred 1 day postinfection, while equal numbers of cells, transferred 3 days postinfection did not confer significant protection over nonimmune cells. There was also a suggestion that the number of immune spleen cells necessary for significant protection was directly related to the number of parasites inoculated. The subpopulation of lymphocytes responsible for the transfer of adoptive immunity to B. microti of human origin was then studied in BALB/c mice depleted of T lymphocytes by thymectomy and lethal irradiation. One day after infection with B. microti, T-cell-depleted mice were given complement-treated immune spleen cells, anti-θ serum-treated immune spleen cells, nonimmune spleen cells, or no cells. Similar experiments were performed comparing the effects of anti-immunoglobulin serum-treated and unfractionated immune spleen cells on B. microti parasitemia. Treatment with anti-θ serum abrogated the protective activity of immune spleen cells while anti-immunoglobulin serum treatment had no effect. These results suggest that immunologic memory of B. microti in BALB/c mice is modulated by T rather than B lymphocytes.     

Regulation of antigen induced changes in cyclic nucleotide levels in NZB/wf1 mice.

Normal C57BL/6J mice respond to the iv injection of antigen with an increase in splenic cAMP at 2 min. NZB/WF₁ mice are predisposed to autoimmune and immunological disorders upon aging. The ability of NZB/WF₁ mice to respond to antigen with an increase in their splenic cAMP level was found to diminish with age. This loss of responsiveness is antigen specific and not due to a loss of adenylate cyclase activity in spleen cells of old NZB/WF₁ mice. The adoptive transfer of spleen cells from unresponsive old mice into responder young mice inhibited the cAMP response to antigen by the recipients. Spleen cells from young responsive mice, on transfer into old nonresponsive NZB/WF₁ recipients, resulted in restoration of the cAMP response to antigen. In both cases, the activity of donor cells was dependent on the transfer of T cells. These results indicate that populations of T cells participate in the regulation of the cAMP response to antigen by NZB/WF₁ mice. The response of old mice could also be restored by treatment with indomethacin, and also the spleen cells of such treated donors failed to suppress the cAMP response of young recipients. Together, the results suggest a role for prostaglandins in regulating the cAMP response to antigen.