Morphological Aspects of Ciliary Motility

In Elliptio complanatus lateral cilia, two distinct patterns of filament termination can be discerned. In one case, all nine filaments are present and all are single; in the second, at least one filament is missing but doublets are still present. These probably represent different configurations within one cilium in different stroke positions; to get from one to the other, some peripheral filaments must move with respect to others. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that the filaments themselves do not change length, but rather slide past one another to accommodate increasing curvature. The bent regions of the cilium are in the form of circular arcs. In a few cases, apparent displacement of filaments at the tip (Δl) can be shown to be accounted for if we assume that all differences are generated within these arcs. The displacement per degree of bend is 35 A. Regions of bent arc are initially confined to the base of the cilium but move up the shaft as straight regions appear below them. From the relationship between arc length and radius of curvature, a shaft length that is the unit that initially bends and slides may be defined. Quantal displacements of the length of one 14S dynein may perhaps occur at sites between filaments at opposite sides of such a unit as sliding occurs.     

Adaptations of ciliary systems for the propulsion of water and mucus

1. The characteristics of ciliary systems are determined by the dominance of viscous effects over inertial effects. 2. The velocity of water propulsion depends on ciliary length, beat frequency, pattern of beating, the arrangement of the cilia and their co-ordination. Beating cilia influence a layer of water only two or three cilium lengths deep, with maximal velocity near the ciliary tip. 3. Mucus is propelled by the tips of short cilia that penetrate the mucus; these cilia are closely spaced on epithelia, and achieve slow propulsion that is relatively independent of load and does not require strong ciliary co-ordination.     

Distinctive features of cilia in metazoans and their significance for systematics.

A comparative study of epidermal cilia in the Turbellaria and Nemertea has revealed features in these organelles that are specific to certain taxonomic groups. Turbellarians of the order Acoela, in particular, have a characteristic pattern of axonemal filament termination in the distal tips of their cilia and a characteristic ciliary rootlet system that is not seen in other turbellarian orders nor in other metazoans. Each epidermal cilium in acoels has a typical 9 + 2 axonemal pattern through the main part of its length, but near its distal tip there is an abrupt shelf-life narrowing at which filaments 4-7 terminate; filaments 1, 2, 8 and 9 continue into the thinner distal-most part of the shaft along with singlet microtubules from the axonemal center. The rootlet system in acoel cilia involves an interconnecting pattern with lateral connectives. The unique structure of these cilia has systematic and phylogenetic significance for the Acoela, and it is argued that ultrastructural characters in general, including characters of organelles, can be validly applied to the phylogeny and systematics of the Metazoa.     

THE FINE STRUCTURE OF THE CILIA FROM CTENOPHORE SWIMMING-PLATES

The ctenophore swimming-plate has been examined with the electron microscope. It has been recognized as an association of long cilia in tight hexagonal packing. One of the directions of the hexagonal packing is parallel to the long edge of the swimming-plate and is perpendicular to the direction of the ciliary beat. All the cilia in the swimming-plate are identically oriented. The effective beat in the movement of the swimming-plate is directed towards the aboral pole of the animal, and this is also the side of the unpaired peripheral filament in all the cilia. The direction of the ciliary beat is fixed in relation to the position of the filaments of the cilia. The swimming-plate cilium differs from other types of cilia and flagella in having a filament arrangement that can be described as 9 + 3 as opposed to the conventional 9 + 2 pattern. The central filaments appear in a group of two "tubular" filaments and an associated compact filament. The compact filament might have a supporting function. It has been called "midfilament." Two of the peripheral nine filaments (Fig. 1, Nos. 3 and 8) are joined to the ciliary membrane by means of slender lamellae, which divide the cilium into two unequal compartments. These lamellae have been called "compartmenting lamellae." Some observations of the arrangement of the compartmenting lamelae indicate that they function by cementing the cilia together in lateral rows. The cilia of the rows meet at a short distance from each other, leaving a gap of 30 A only. The meeting points are close to the termini of the compartmenting ridges. An electron-dense substance is sometimes seen bridging the gap. Some irregularities are noted with regard to the arrangement of the compartmenting lamellae particularly at the peripheral rows of cilia. In many cilia in these rows there are small vesicles beneath the ciliary membrane.     

CILIARY MEMBRANE DIFFERENTIATIONS IN TETRAHYMENA PYRIFORMIS : Tetrahymena Has Four Types of Cilia

We have examined thin sections and replicas of freeze-fractured cilia of Tetrahymena pyriformis. The ciliary necklace located at the base of all freeze-fractured oral and somatic cilia has been studied in thin sections. Since electron-dense linkers have been found to connect both microtubule doublets and triplets to the ciliary membrane at the level of the necklace, the linkers and the associated necklace seem to be related to the transition region between the doublets and triplets of a cilium. Plaque structures, consisting of small rectangular patches of particles located distal to the ciliary necklace, are found in strain GL, but are absent in other strains examined in this study. In freeze-cleaved material, additional structural differentiations are observed in the distal region of the ciliary membranes of somatic and oral cilia. Somatic cilia contain many randomly distributed particles within their membrane. Oral cilia can be divided into three categories on the basis of the morphology of their freeze-fractured membranes: (a) undifferentiated cilia with very few randomly distributed particles: (b) cilia with particles arranged in parallel longitudinal rows spaced at intervals of 810–1080 Å that are located on one side of the cilium; and (c) cilia with patches of particles arranged in short rows oriented obliquely to the main axis of the cilium. The latter particles, found on one side of the cilium, seem to serve as attachment sites for bristles 375–750 Å long and 100 Å wide which extend into the surrounding medium. The particles with bristles are located at the tips of cilia in the outermost membranelle and may be used to detect food particles and/or to modify currents in the oral region so that food particles are propelled more efficiently into the buccal cavity. Examination of thin-sectioned material indicates that the particles in oral cilia which form the longitudinal rows could be linked to microtubule doublets. Linkage between microtubule doublets and adjacent membrane areas on one side of the cilium could modify the form of ciliary beat by restricting the sliding of the microtubules. It is suggested that membrane-microtubule interactions may form the basis for the various forms of ciliary beat observed in different organisms.     

Splayed Tetrahymena cilia. A system for analyzing sliding and axonemal spoke arrangements

This study makes use of a procedure designed to illustrate, without serial section analysis, the three-dimensional changes in the ciliary axoneme produced by microtubule sliding, and to confirm essential features of the sliding microtubule hypothesis of ciliary movement. Cilia, isolated from Tetrahymena pyriformis by the dibucaine procedure, are attached to polylysine substratum, and treated with Triton X-100. Critical point drying maintains three-dimensional structure without embedding. The detergent removes the membrane and many axonemes unroll, always in an organized fashion so that doublets follow one another in sequence, according to the enantiomorphic form of the cilium. The central pair of microtubules fall to the side as a unit. The parallel doublet microtubules retain relative longitudinal positions in part by interdoublet or nexin links. Spoke organization and tip patterns are preserved in the opened axonemes. We generalize the work of Warner and Satir (Warner, F. D., and P. Satir, 1976. J. Cell Biol. 63:35-63) to show that spoke group arrangements are maintained for all doublets in straight regions, while systematic displacements occur in bent regions. The conclusion that local contraction of microtubles is absent in the axoneme is strengthened, and direct graphic demonstrations of sliding at the ciliary tip are shown. A morphogenetic numbering scheme is presented which results in a quantitative fit of the tip images to the images predicated by the equation for doublet sliding, and which makes possible new comparisons of structural parameters between axonemes and with cilia of other organisms.     

Discocilia—A new type of kinocilia in the larvae of Lanice conchilega (Polychaeta,Terebellomorpha)

A modified type of kinocilia has been found in the Aulophora-Iarva of the sedentarian polychaete Lanice conchilega. For this newly described cilium type the term "discocilium" is proposed. The only structural difference from usual locomotory cilia is the tip, which possesses a discoidal head. The head is formed from the terminal part of the cilium shaft, which is bent to give rise to a loop-like ring covered by the ciliary membrane. Three types of discocilia can be distinguished: a) discocilia having swollen, bulblike heads with a central straight axoneme; b) discocilia having heads with a curved lateral axoneme and c) discocilia in which the axoneme forms a loop. The internal structure shows the usual 9 + 2 arrangement of the filaments. The head shows no sign of secretion; it appears structureless in electron microscopical examination. There are two kinds of discocilia arrangements: 1) isolated bunches of cilia especially at the tentacles and in the frontal region, and 2) segmental dorsal rows of cilia. The possible formation of discocilia is described.     

Ultrastructural studies of epidermis, sense receptors and sperm of Craspedella sp. and Didymorchis sp. (Platyhelminthes, Rhabdocoela)

Craspedella has a non-ciliated epidermis with nuclei located in the epidermis and with short microvilli. There is a thin basal lamina and thick underlying fibrous matrix. Rhabdites are secreted through ducts lined by microtubules. Multiciliate sense receptors consist of bundles of dendrites in a depression of the epidermis. Each dendrite has a cilium with a cross-striated rootlet; there are no electron-dense collars. Spermatozoa have peripheral microtubules which in cross-section are arranged in a ring-like or spiral fashion, numerous electron-dense granules, mitochondria and a nucleus; axonemes of the 9 +'1'type are free for most of their length. Centrioles occur in some nerve fibres. In Didymorchis parts of the epidermis are ciliated and epidermal perikarya are 'insunk', connected to the surface part of the epidermis by a single cytoplasmic process. Epidermal cilia have cross-striated vertical and horizontal rootlets. In the ciliary tips a short electron-dense rod along the central pair of tubules extends to the tip, where it widens to become a terminal plate; peripheral doublets gradually disappear by losing their microtubules. Receptors observed are uniciliate. Spermatozoa are as in Craspedella . Ultrastructural evidence indicates that Craspedella and Didymorchis arc closely related and belong to the Rhabdocoela.     

Ciliary activity in the mouse oviduct as studied by transmission and scanning electron microscopy

The mouse oviduct is covered by dense tracts of ciliated cells interspersed at random with occasional non-ciliated cells. Correlation between scanning electron microscopy and thin section images indicates that in the isolated fimbria most cilia are short (5 µm) and inactive, resting at the end of a uterad-directed effective stroke. These cilia terminate in a 9S−2 tip, the microtubules ending in an electron-dense plaque underneath the cell membrane. At the tip of the cilium a crown of fine extracellular hairs is attached to the ciliary membrane. In the ampulla and isthmus the ciliated cells decrease progressively in number and appear to lie in crypts.     

The Contractile Mechanism in Cilia

A detailed analysis is made of the motion and the forces in the cilium of Sabellaria over the complete cycle. The results indicate that the stiffness of the cilium is directly related to the moments produced by the internal contractile elements. A sliding filament model is developed to generate the complete cycle of motion. The activation of the force-producing elements, the peripheral fibers, occurs over their entire length at once during the effective stroke. In the recovery stroke the sliding of peripheral fibers relative to each other produces activation. The peripheral fibers contribute to the stiffness of the cilium in the sliding filament model only when they are not free to slide because of cross-linkage. The model describes successfully the motion of a variety of types of cilia.     

The termination of the central microtubules from the cilia of Tetrahymena pyriformis.

In frayed axonemes of cilia isolated from Tetrahymena pyriformis, observed in negative stain, the central apparatus remains intact, stabilized in part by the sheath projections that encircle the two singlet central microtubules. The projections terminate ca. 1.5 +/- 0.5 micron before the microtubules themselves end. The microtubules are capped together at their tips by a distinct structure, the central pair cap. The cap, ca. 50 nm across and 90 nm long, consists of a stack of two disks and a ball, similar in shape to a finial. The cap is the only part of the axoneme that extends to the distalmost point of the ciliary membrane and, therefore, it may be of significance in length determination or in shaping the ciliary tip.     

Kinesin-13 regulates the quantity and quality of tubulin inside cilia

Kinesin-13, an end depolymerizer of cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules, also affects the length of cilia. However, in different models, depletion of kinesin-13 either lengthens or shortens cilia, and therefore the exact function of kinesin-13 in cilia remains unclear. We generated null mutations of all kinesin-13 paralogues in the ciliate Tetrahymena. One of the paralogues, Kin13Ap, localizes to the nuclei and is essential for nuclear divisions. The remaining two paralogues, Kin13Bp and Kin13Cp, localize to the cell body and inside assembling cilia. Loss of both Kin13Bp and Kin13Cp resulted in slow cell multiplication and motility, overgrowth of cell body microtubules, shortening of cilia, and synthetic lethality with either paclitaxel or a deletion of MEC-17/ATAT1, the α-tubulin acetyltransferase. The mutant cilia assembled slowly and contained abnormal tubulin, characterized by altered posttranslational modifications and hypersensitivity to paclitaxel. The mutant cilia beat slowly and axonemes showed reduced velocity of microtubule sliding. Thus kinesin-13 positively regulates the axoneme length, influences the properties of ciliary tubulin, and likely indirectly, through its effects on the axonemal microtubules, affects the ciliary dynein-dependent motility.     

Intraflagellar transport delivers tubulin isotypes to sensory cilium middle and distal segments

Sensory cilia are assembled and maintained by kinesin-2-dependent intraflagellar transport (IFT). We investigated whether two Caenorhabditis elegans α- and β-tubulin isotypes, identified through mutants that lack their cilium distal segments, are delivered to their assembly sites by IFT. Mutations in conserved residues in both tubulins destabilize distal singlet microtubules. One isotype, TBB-4, assembles into microtubules at the tips of the axoneme core and distal segments, where the microtubule tip tracker EB1 is found, and localizes all along the cilium, whereas the other, TBA-5, concentrates in distal singlets. IFT assays, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching analysis and modelling indicate that the continual transport of sub-stoichiometric numbers of these tubulin subunits by the IFT machinery can maintain sensory cilia at their steady-state length.     

Ultrastructural evidence for the occurrence of three types of mechanosensitive cells in the tentacles of the cubozoan polypCarybdea marsupialis

Summary The ectodermal cell layer in the tentacles of the cubozoan polypCarybdea marsupialis contains four types of cells (types 1–4) bearing specialized cilia. Epitheliomuscular cells (type 1) are characterized by motile cilia with dynein-decorated axonemes. 200 nm long extramembranous filaments of unknown function are restricted to a belt-like region distal to the transition zone. Up to 40 rn long rigid cilia formed by a slender epithelial cell type (type 2) are surrounded by rings of short microvilli. The axonemes of these cilia are composed of incomplete microtubules and lack dynein. Microvilli and cilia are linked by intermembrane connectors. Microtubuledoublets and ciliary membrane are interconnected by microtubule-associated cross-bridges only within this contact region. At the tip of each tentacle a single nematocyte (type 3) is surrounded by 7–10 accessory cells (type 4). These both cell types are equipped with similar cilium-stereovilli-complexes consisting of a cone-like arrangement of stereovilli and a modified cilium. The axonemal modifications of the cilium, its interconnections with the surrounding stereovilli and the linkages between ciliary axoneme and ciliary membrane are similar to those known from the cnidocil-complexes of hydrozoons and other epithelial mechanosensitive cells of the collar-receptor type. Our data indicate that besides the nematocyte two other types of mechanosensory cells (types 2 and 4) are integrated in the ectodermal cell layer ofCarybdea which possibly affect the triggering mechanism of nematocyst discharge.     

The structure of the tips of mammalian respiratory cilia

Summary The ciliary crown and the relationship of the ciliary crown to the underlying axoneme were studied by electron microscopy in cilia from hamster and rat trachea and bronchioles, and rabbit trachea. The ciliary crown is a cluster of 4 to 6 fibrils 35 nm long protruding beyond the plasma membrane at the tips of the cilia. The fibrils are well preserved after tannic acidglutaraldehyde-osmium tetroxide fixation and have high contrast with a periodic density of 4.5 nm. They stain relatively weakly with phosphotungstic acid. The surface of the fibrils stains with ruthenium red.The microtubules of the axoneme end in a plate of electron dense amorphous material. A five layered disc occupies the space between the membrane and the amorphous plate at the tip of the axoneme. The plasma membrane can be dissolved with the detergent triton X-100 without loss of the ciliary crown. This indicates that the ciliary crown is composed of transmembranous filaments which are bound to the disc at the tip of the axoneme.Supported by U.S.P.H.S. Research Grant number HL-12650     

Ciliary function of the frog oro-pharyngeal epithelium

Summary The palate epithelium of the frog was examined by scanning electron microscopy, light microscopy and high speed cine micrography. The cilia remain stationary for much of the time in the end-of-effective stroke position. Each beat cycle begins with a forwardly-directed recovery stroke lasting about 60 ms, followed by an effective stroke towards the oesophagus lasting about 12 ms. Activity can often be correlated with the presence of mucus, which is carried as strands on the tips of the ciliary effective strokes whilst the recovery strokes move beneath the mucus. Coordination of ciliary activity was very variable; local antiplectic metachrony of the recovery strokes could almost always be seen, and on very active epithelia effective strokes were associated with approximately diaplectic waves (either to left or right), but any particular pattern of coordinated activity was transient and quickly transformed to another pattern. Beating and coordination of these short cilia were compared with those of cilia propelling water.     

Ciliary microtubule capping structures contain a mammalian kinetochore antigen

Structures that cap the plus ends of microtubules may be involved in the regulation of their assembly and disassembly. Growing and disassembling microtubules in the mitotic apparatus are capped by kinetochores and ciliary and flagellar microtubules are capped by the central microtubule cap and distal filaments. To compare the ciliary caps with kinetochores, isolated Tetrahymena cilia were stained with CREST (Calcinosis/phenomenon esophageal dysmotility, sclerodactyly, telangiectasia) antisera known to stain kinetochores. Immunofluorescence microscopy revealed that a CREST antiserum stained the distal tips of cilia that contained capping structures but did not stain axonemes that lacked capping structures. Both Coomassie blue-stained gels and Western blots probed with CREST antiserum revealed that a 97-kD antigen copurifies with the capping structures. Affinity-purified antibodies to the 97-kD ciliary protein stained the tips of cap-containing Tetrahymena cilia and the kinetochores in HeLa, Chinese hamster ovary, and Indian muntjak cells. These results suggest that at least one polypeptide found in the kinetochore is present in ciliary microtubule capping structures and that there may be a structural and/or functional homology between these structures that cap the plus ends of microtubules.     

Primary cilium mechanotransduction of tensile strain in 3D culture: Finite element analyses of strain amplification caused by tensile strain applied to a primary cilium embedded in a collagen matrix

Human adipose-derived stem cells (hASC) exhibit multilineage differentiation potential with lineage specification that is dictated by both the chemical and mechanical stimuli to which they are exposed. We have previously shown that 10% cyclic tensile strain increases hASC osteogenesis and cell-mediated calcium accretion. We have also recently shown that primary cilia are present on hASC and that chemically-induced lineage specification of hASC concurrently results in length and conformation changes of the primary cilia. Further, we have observed cilia length changes in hASC cultured within a collagen I gel in response to 10% cyclic tensile strain. We therefore hypothesize that primary cilia may play a key mechanotransduction role for hASC exposed to tensile strain. The goal of this study was to use finite element analysis (FEA) to determine strains occurring within the ciliary membrane in response to 10% tensile strain applied parallel, or perpendicular, to cilia orientation. To elucidate the mechanical environment experienced by the cilium, several lengths were modeled and evaluated based on cilia lengths measured on hASC grown under varied culture conditions. Principal tensile strains in both hASC and ciliary membranes were calculated using FEA, and the magnitude and location of maximum principal tensile strain determined. We found that maximum principal tensile strain was concentrated at the base of the cilium. In the linear elastic model, applying strain perpendicular to the cilium resulted in maximum strains within the ciliary membrane from 150% to 200%, while applying strain parallel to the cilium resulted in much higher strains, approximately 400%. In the hyperelastic model, applying strain perpendicular to the cilium resulted in maximum strains within the ciliary membrane around 30%, while applying strain parallel to the cilium resulted in much higher strains ranging from 50% to 70%. Interestingly, FEA results indicated that primary cilium length was not directly related to ciliary membrane strain. Rather, it appears that cilium orientation may be more important than cilium length in determining sensitivity of hASC to tensile strain. This is the first study to model the effects of tensile strain on the primary cilium and provides newfound insight into the potential role of the primary cilium as a mechanosensor, particularly in tensile strain and potentially a multitude of other mechanical stimuli beyond fluid shear.     

Ciliary specializations in branchial stigmatal cells of protochordates

Tissues from the pharynx of five representative species of the protochordates (subphylum Tunicata, the three classes Ascidiacea, Thaliacea and Appendicularia, and subphylum Cephalochordata) were examined in both thin sections and freeze-fracture replicas. In all species, the stigmatal cilia of the branchial chamber are neatly arranged and move continuously to propel sea-water in a fixed direction for respiration and feeding of the organism. A number of specializations are found in the basal region of these cilia and are represented by: a) bridges connecting axonemal doublets numbers 5 and 6; b) dense fibrous material linking the doublet microtubules of the axoneme to the ciliary membrane, sometimes in the shape of longitudinal strands or as clusters of filaments; c) intramembrane particles (IMPs) associated with the P-face of the membrane, often arranged in clusters evenly aligned along the ciliary shaft in relation to the underlying axonemal doublets. Ciliary specializations are distributed along the plane of the effective stroke of the beat in both the ascidian Botryllus schlosseri and in the thaliacean Pyrosoma atlanticum and the amphioxus Branchiostoma lanceolatum, whereas in the thaliacean Doliolum nationalis and the appendicularian Oikopleura dioica a more uniform distribution of these specializations all around the basal portion of the cilia is observed. Whatever the disposition of the ciliary specializations in all the examined species, they are always present at the base of the water-propelling cilia. Some morphological evidence suggests that these specializations play a mechanical function in tethering the ciliary membrane to the axoneme. We propose that they help maintain the orientation of the cilia during beating, enhance their stiffness and improve their efficiency.