The general protein secretory pathway: phylogenetic analyses leading to evolutionary conclusions

We have identified all homologues in the current databases of the ubiquitous protein constituents of the general secretory (Sec) pathway. These prokaryotic/eukaryotic proteins include (1) SecY/Sec61α, (2) SecE/Sec61γ, (3) SecG/Sec61β, (4) Ffh/SRP54 and (5) FtsY/SRP receptor subunit-α. Phylogenetic and sequence analyses lead to major conclusions concerning (1) the ubiquity of these proteins in living organisms, (2) the topological uniformity of some but not other Sec constituents, (3) the orthologous nature of almost all of them, (4) a total lack of paralogues in almost all organisms for which complete genome sequences are available, (5) the occurrence of two or even three paralogues in a few bacteria, plants, and yeast, depending on the Sec constituent, and (6) a tremendous degree of sequence divergence in bacteria compared with that in archaea or eukaryotes. The phylogenetic analyses lead to the conclusion that with a few possible exceptions, the five families of Sec constituents analyzed generally underwent sequence divergence in parallel but at different characteristic rates. The results provide evolutionary insights as well as guides for future functional studies. Because every organism with a fully sequenced genome exhibits at least one orthologue of each of these Sec proteins, we conclude that all living organisms have relied on the Sec system as their primary protein secretory/membrane insertion system. Because most prokaryotes and many eukaryotes encode within their genomes only one of each constituent, we also conclude that strong evolutionary pressure has minimized gene duplication events leading to the establishment of Sec paralogues. Finally, the sequence diversity of bacterial proteins as compared with their archaeal and eukaryotic counterparts is in agreement with the suggestion that bacteria were the evolutionary predecessors of archaea and eukaryotes.     

The general protein secretory pathway: phylogenetic analyses leading to evolutionary conclusions

We have identified all homologues in the current databases of the ubiquitous protein constituents of the general secretory (Sec) pathway. These prokaryotic/eukaryotic proteins include (1) SecY/Sec61alpha, (2) SecE/Sec61gamma, (3) SecG/Sec61beta, (4) Ffh/SRP54 and (5) FtsY/SRP receptor subunit-alpha. Phylogenetic and sequence analyses lead to major conclusions concerning (1) the ubiquity of these proteins in living organisms, (2) the topological uniformity of some but not other Sec constituents, (3) the orthologous nature of almost all of them, (4) a total lack of paralogues in almost all organisms for which complete genome sequences are available, (5) the occurrence of two or even three paralogues in a few bacteria, plants, and yeast, depending on the Sec constituent, and (6) a tremendous degree of sequence divergence in bacteria compared with that in archaea or eukaryotes. The phylogenetic analyses lead to the conclusion that with a few possible exceptions, the five families of Sec constituents analyzed generally underwent sequence divergence in parallel but at different characteristic rates. The results provide evolutionary insights as well as guides for future functional studies. Because every organism with a fully sequenced genome exhibits at least one orthologue of each of these Sec proteins, we conclude that all living organisms have relied on the Sec system as their primary protein secretory/membrane insertion system. Because most prokaryotes and many eukaryotes encode within their genomes only one of each constituent, we also conclude that strong evolutionary pressure has minimized gene duplication events leading to the establishment of Sec paralogues. Finally, the sequence diversity of bacterial proteins as compared with their archaeal and eukaryotic counterparts is in agreement with the suggestion that bacteria were the evolutionary predecessors of archaea and eukaryotes.     

Pullulanase: Model protein substrate for the general secretory pathway of gram-negative bacteria

Pullulanase ofKlebsiella oxytoca is one of a wide variety of extracellular proteins that are secreted by Gram-negative bacteria by the complex main terminal branch (MTB) of the general secretory pathway. The roles of some of the 14 components of the MTB are now becoming clear. In this review it is proposed that most of these proteins form a complex, the secreton, that spans the cell envelope to control the opening and closing of channel in the outer membrane. Progress toward the goal of testing this model is reviewed. Presented at the SymposiumRegulatory Aspects of Bacterial Cell Biology, Prague, October 16–17, 1996.     

The chaperone/usher pathway: a major terminal branch of the general secretory pathway

Gram-negative bacteria assemble a variety of adhesive organelles on their surface, including the thread-like structures known as pili. Recent studies on pilus assembly by the chaperone/usher pathway have revealed new insights into the mechanisms of pilus subunit export into the periplasm and targeting to the outer membrane. Signaling events controlling pilus biogenesis have begun to emerge and investigations of the usher have yielded insights into pilus translocation across the outer membrane.     

The efficiency of protein compartmentalization into the secretory pathway

Numerous proteins targeted for the secretory pathway are increasingly implicated in functional or pathological roles at alternative cellular destinations. The parameters that allow secretory or membrane proteins to reside in intracellular locales outside the secretory pathway remain largely unexplored. In this study, we have used an extremely sensitive and quantitative assay to measure the in vivo efficiency of signal sequence-mediated protein segregation into the secretory pathway. Our findings reveal that segregation efficiency varies tremendously among signals, ranging from >95 to <60%. The nonsegregated fraction is generated by a combination of mechanisms that includes inefficient signal-mediated translocation into the endoplasmic reticulum and leaky ribosomal scanning. The segregation efficiency of some, but not other signal sequences, could be influenced in cis by residues in the mature domain or in trans by yet unidentified cellular factors. These findings imply that protein compartmentalization can be modulated in a substrate-specific manner to generate biologically significant quantities of cytosolically available secretory and membrane proteins.     

Avl9p, a member of a novel protein superfamily, functions in the late secretory pathway

The branching of exocytic transport routes in both yeast and mammalian cells has complicated studies of the late secretory pathway, and the mechanisms involved in exocytic cargo sorting and exit from the Golgi and endosomes are not well understood. Because cargo can be sorted away from a blocked route and secreted by an alternate route, mutants defective in only one route do not exhibit a strong secretory phenotype and are therefore difficult to isolate. In a genetic screen designed to isolate such mutants, we identified a novel conserved protein, Avl9p, the absence of which conferred lethality in a vps1Delta apl2Delta strain background (lacking a dynamin and an adaptor-protein complex 1 subunit). Depletion of Avl9p in this strain resulted in secretory defects as well as accumulation of Golgi-like membranes. The triple mutant also had a depolarized actin cytoskeleton and defects in polarized secretion. Overexpression of Avl9p in wild-type cells resulted in vesicle accumulation and a post-Golgi defect in secretion. Phylogenetic analysis indicated evolutionary relationships between Avl9p and regulators of membrane traffic and actin function.     

Mutagenesis of cellulase EGZ for studying the general protein secretory pathway in Erwinia chrysanthemi

Extracellular secretion of endoglucanase Z (EGZ) from Erwinia chrysanthemi is mediated by the so-called Out general secretion pathway and, presumably, involves recognition of EGZ-carried structural information by one or more of the Out proteins. Investigating the relationships between structure and secretability of EGZ was the purpose of the present work. EGZ is made of two independent domains, located at the N-and C-proximal sides, separated by a Ser/Thr-rich region, which are responsible for catalysis and cellulose-binding, respectively. The existence of a secretion region (‘targeting signal’) was investigated by studying the secretability of modified EGZ derivatives. These resulted from deletion or peptide insertion and were designed by using the domain organization cited above as a guide. Catalytic and/or cellulose-binding tests showed that all proteins exhibited at least a functional EGZ domain while immunoblot analyses confirmed that neither the insertions nor the deletions led to grossly misfolded proteins. In contrast, all of the proteins lost their secretability in E. chrysanthemi. This suggested that at least two secretion motifs existed, one lying within each functional domain. The role of the Ser/Thr-rich linker region was subsequently tested. Accordingly, two proteins containing a linker region whose length was increased by the addition of 8 and 18 additional residues and one protein lacking the linker region were studied. All three exhibited endoglucanase activity and cellulose-binding ability, confirming the independence of the domains within the context of EGZ/polysaccharide interaction. In contrast, none was secreted by E. chrysanthemi. Collectively, our results with EGZ (i) suggest the occurrence of multiple secretion-related sites either acting sequentially or forming a single three-dimensional secretion signal, (ii) show that secretability is not determined by either one of the two functional domains alone, and (iii) reveal that the linker region plays a role in secretion. We propose that all EGZ derivatives were impaired in the recognition step, the nature of which is discussed.     

Specific interaction between OutD, an Erwinia chrysanthemi outer membrane protein of the general secretory pathway, and secreted proteins.

OutD is an outer membrane component of the main terminal branch of the general secretory pathway (GSP) in Erwinia chrysanthemi. We analyzed the interactions of OutD with other components of the GSP (Out proteins) and with secreted proteins (PelB, EGZ and PemA). OutD is stabilized by its interaction with another GSP component, OutS. The 62 C-terminal amino acids of OutD are necessary for this interaction. In vivo formation of OutD multimers, up to tetramers, was proved after the dissociation in mild conditions of the OutD aggregates formed in the outer membrane. Thus, OutD could form a channel-like structure in the outer membrane. We showed that OutD is stabilized in vivo when co-expressed with Out-secreted proteins. This stabilization results from the formation of complexes that were detected in experiments of co-immunoprecipitation and co-sedimentation in sucrose density gradients. The presence of the N-terminal part of OutD is required for this interaction. The interaction between OutD and the secreted protein PelB was confirmed in vitro, suggesting that no other component of the GSP is required for this recognition. No interaction was observed between the E. carotovora PelC and the E. chrysanthemi OutD. Thus, the interaction between GspD and the secreted proteins present in the periplasm could be the key to the specificity of the secretion machinery and a trigger for that process.     

The ubiquitin-mediated proteolytic pathway and mechanisms of energy-dependent intracellular protein degradation

In this review we briefly describe the lysosomal system, consider the evidence for multiplicity of protein degradation pathways in vivo, discuss in detail the ubiquitin-mediated pathway of intracellular ATP-dependent protein degradation, and also the possible significance of ubiquitin-histone conjugates in chromatin. For detailed discussions of the various characteristics and physiological roles of intracellular protein breakdown, the reader is referred to earlier reviews [1-7] and reports of recent symposia [8-10]. Information on the ubiquitin system prior to 1981 was described in an earlier review [11]. Hershko has briefly reviewed more recent information [12].     

The ubiquitin-mediated proteolytic pathway: enzymology and mechanisms of recognition of the proteolytic substrates

Degradation of proteins by the ubiquitin system involves two discrete steps. Initially, ubiquitin is covalently linked in an ATP-dependent mode to the protein substrate. The protein moiety of the conjugate is subsequently degraded by a specific protease into peptides and free amino acids with the release of free and reutilizable ubiquitin. The degradation process also requires energy. In this review we shall discuss the mechanisms involved in ubiquitin activation, selection of substrates for conjugation, and subsequent degradation of ubiquitin-conjugated proteins. In addition, we shall briefly summarize what is currently known of the role of the ubiquitin system in protein degradation in vitro and in vivo.     

Lumenal protein multimerization in the distal secretory pathway/secretory granules

Differences in protein solubility appear to play an important role in lumenal protein trafficking through Golgi/post-Golgi compartments. Recent advances indicate that multimeric protein assembly is one of the factors regulating the efficiency of protein storage within secretory granules, by mechanisms that, with slight modification, might be considered to represent the culmination of a process of Golgi cisternal maturation.     

Lectins and protein traffic early in the secretory pathway

Lectins of the early secretory pathway are involved in selective transport of newly synthesized glycoproteins from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the ER-Golgi intermediate compartment (ERGIC). The most prominent cycling lectin is the mannose-binding type I membrane protein ERGIC-53 (ERGIC protein of 53 kDa), a marker for the ERGIC, which functions as a cargo receptor to facilitate export of an increasing number of glycoproteins with different characteristics from the ER. Two ERGIC-53-related proteins, VIP36 (vesicular integral membrane protein 36) and a novel ERGIC-53-like protein, ERGL, are also found in the early secretory pathway. ERGL may act as a regulator of ERGIC-53. Studies of ERGIC-53 continue to provide new insights into the organization and dynamics of the early secretory pathway. Analysis of the cycling of ERGIC-53 uncovered a complex interplay of trafficking signals and revealed novel cytoplasmic ER-export motifs that interact with COP-II coat proteins. These motifs are common to type I and polytopic membrane proteins including presenilin 1 and presenilin 2. The results support the notion that protein export from the ER is selective.     

Biosynthetic protein transport through the early secretory pathway

 Newly synthesized proteins destined for delivery to the cell surface are inserted cotranslationally into the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and, after their correct folding, are transported out of the ER. During their transport to the cell surface, cargo proteins pass through the various cisternae of the Golgi apparatus and, in the trans-most cisternae of the stack, are sorted into constitutive secretory vesicles that fuse with the plasma membrane. Simultaneously with anterograde protein transport, retrograde protein transport occurs within the Golgi complex as well as from the Golgi back to the ER. Vesicular transport within the early secretory pathway is mediated by two types of non-clathrin coated vesicles: COPI- and COPII-coated vesicles. The formation of these carrier vesicles depends on the recruitment of cytosolic coat proteins that are thought to act as a mechanical device to shape a flattened donor membrane into a spherical vesicle. A general molecular machinery that mediates targeting and fusion of carrier vesicles has been identified as well. Beside a general overview of the various coat structures known today, we will discuss issues specifically related to the biogenesis of COPI-coated vesicles: (1) a possible role of phospholipase D in the formation of COPI-coated vesicles; (2) a functional role of a novel family of transmembrane proteins, the p24 family, in the initiation of COPI assembly; and (3) the direction COPI-coated vesicles may take within the early secretory pathway. Moreover, we will consider two alternative mechanisms of protein transport through the Golgi stack: vesicular transport versus cisternal maturation. Accepted: 24 October 1997     

Receptor-mediated protein transport in the early secretory pathway

Many secretory proteins are thought to rely upon transmembrane cargo receptors for efficient endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-to-Golgi transport. These receptors recognize specific cargo-encoded sorting signals. Only a few such cargo receptors have been characterized in detail, most of them in yeast. The only well-defined cargo receptor from mammalian cells, the LMAN1-MCFD2 complex, is required for the efficient secretion of coagulation factors V and VIII. Studies of this complex, coupled with recent advances in elucidating the basic machinery that mediates ER-to-Golgi transport, have provided a more-detailed picture of the mechanisms underlying receptor-mediated transport in the early secretory pathway. In addition to yeast studies, insights have also come from investigations into several inherited disorders that have recently been attributed to defects in the secretory pathway.     

Post-Golgi protein traffic in the plant secretory pathway

The Golgi apparatus in plants is organized as a multitude of individual stacks that are motile in the cytoplasm and in close association with the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) (Boevink et al. in Plant J 15:441–447, 1998). These stacks operate as a sorting centre for cargo molecules, providing modification and redirection to other organelles as appropriate. In the post-Golgi direction, these include vacuole and plasma membrane, and specialized transport routes to each are required to prevent mislocalization. Recent evidence in plant cells points to the existence of post-Golgi organelles that function as intermediate stations for efficient protein traffic, as well as to the influence of small GTPases such as Rabs and ARFs on post-Golgi trafficking. This review focuses on the latest findings on post-Golgi trafficking routes and on the involvement of GTPases and their effectors on the trafficking of proteins in the plant secretory pathway. Sally L. Hanton and Loren A. Matheson have contributed equally to this work.     

Machine learning-based investigation of the cancer protein secretory pathway

Deregulation of the protein secretory pathway (PSP) is linked to many hallmarks of cancer, such as promoting tissue invasion and modulating cell-cell signaling. The collection of secreted proteins processed by the PSP, known as the secretome, is often studied due to its potential as a reservoir of tumor biomarkers. However, there has been less focus on the protein components of the secretory machinery itself. We therefore investigated the expression changes in secretory pathway components across many different cancer types. Specifically, we implemented a dual approach involving differential expression analysis and machine learning to identify PSP genes whose expression was associated with key tumor characteristics: mutation of p53, cancer status, and tumor stage. Eight different machine learning algorithms were included in the analysis to enable comparison between methods and to focus on signals that were robust to algorithm type. The machine learning approach was validated by identifying PSP genes known to be regulated by p53, and even outperformed the differential expression analysis approach. Among the different analysis methods and cancer types, the kinesin family members KIF20A and KIF23 were consistently among the top genes associated with malignant transformation or tumor stage. However, unlike most cancer types which exhibited elevated KIF20A expression that remained relatively constant across tumor stages, renal carcinomas displayed a more gradual increase that continued with increasing disease severity. Collectively, our study demonstrates the complementary nature of a combined differential expression and machine learning approach for analyzing gene expression data, and highlights key PSP components relevant to features of tumor pathophysiology that may constitute potential therapeutic targets.     

Genetic analysis of the indices of gastric acid secretory and proteolytic functions in duodenal ulcer patients

The phenotypic correlations between pepsinogen, proteases and the debit of acid secretion in patients with the peptic ulcer of duodenum and their parents were studied. It was found that the genetic factors have great influence on the level of pepsinogen and proteases in the basal conditions and under stimulation. In comparison with the general population, we obtained highly reliable increase of the level of pepsinogen and proteases in the groups of patients and their parents.     

Biosynthesis of the secretory core protein of duck hepatitis B virus: intracellular transport, proteolytic processing, and membrane expression of the precore protein.

The biosynthesis of the secretory core gene product of the duck hepatitis B virus (DHBe protein) was examined. Recombinant vaccinia viruses were constructed encoding either the full-length or C-terminally truncated forms of the DHBe precursor protein (precore protein) and used to express these proteins in the human hepatoma cell line HepG2. Western immunoblot analysis of core gene products isolated from cells producing the full-length precore protein revealed the presence of DHBe precursor proteins containing the strongly basic C-terminal sequence which is lacking in the mature DHBe protein. These proteins were not secreted, suggesting that C-terminal proteolytic processing of the precore protein represents an obligatory step for DHBe biosynthesis. Pulse-chase experiments showed that this cleavage reaction occurs late during DHBe synthesis. Interestingly, when mutated precore proteins were expressed which lacked the basic C-terminal domain, proteins were produced which were glycosylated but not secreted. This shows that the transient presence of this region is essential for intracellular transport of the precore protein. Cell sorter analyses revealed that production of a cell surface-expressed variant of the secretory core protein is a feature conserved between the duck and the human hepatitis B viruses. Surprisingly, the C terminus of the membrane-expressed DHBe protein was accessible from the outside, showing that the topology of this interesting protein is more complicated than expected.