Conservation of folding and stability within a protein family: the tyrosine corner as an evolutionary cul-de-sac

What are the selective pressures on protein sequences during evolution? Amino acid residues may be highly conserved for functional or structural (stability) reasons. Theoretical studies have proposed that residues involved in the folding nucleus may also be highly conserved. To test this we are using an experimental "fold approach" to the study of protein folding. This compares the folding and stability of a number of proteins that share the same fold, but have no common amino acid sequence or biological activity. The fold selected for this study is the immunoglobulin-like beta-sandwich fold, which is a fold that has no specifically conserved function. Four model proteins are used from two distinct superfamilies that share the immunoglobulin-like fold, the fibronectin type III and immunoglobulin superfamilies. Here, the fold approach and protein engineering are used to question the role of a highly conserved tyrosine in the "tyrosine corner" motif that is found ubiquitously and exclusively in Greek key proteins. In the four model beta-sandwich proteins characterised here, the tyrosine is the only residue that is absolutely conserved at equivalent sites. By mutating this position to phenylalanine, we show that the tyrosine hydroxyl is not required to nucleate folding in the immunoglobulin superfamily, whereas it is involved to some extent in early structure formation in the fibronectin type III superfamily. The tyrosine corner is important for stability, mutation to phenylalanine costs between 1.5 and 3 kcal mol(-1). We propose that the high level of conservation of the tyrosine is related to the structural restraints of the loop connecting the beta-sheets, representing an evolutionary "cul-de-sac".     

Electrophoretic mobility shift in native gels indicates calcium-dependent structural changes of neuronal calcium sensor proteins

In proteins of the neuronal calcium sensor (NCS) family, changes in structure as well as function are brought about by the binding of calcium. In this article, we demonstrate that these structural changes, solely due to calcium binding, can be assessed through electrophoresis in native gels. The results demonstrate that the NCS proteins undergo ligand-dependent conformational changes that are detectable in native gels as a gradual decrease in mobility with increasing calcium but not other tested divalent cations such as magnesium, strontium, and barium. Surprisingly, such a gradual change over the entire tested range is exhibited only by the NCS proteins but not by other tested calcium-binding proteins such as calmodulin and S100B, indicating that the change in mobility may be linked to a unique NCS family feature—the calcium–myristoyl switch. Even within the NCS family, the changes in mobility are characteristic of the protein, indicating that the technique is sensitive to the individual features of the protein. Thus, electrophoretic mobility on native gels provides a simple and elegant method to investigate calcium (small ligand)-induced structural changes at least in the superfamily of NCS proteins.     

Solution structure of choline binding protein A, the major adhesin of Streptococcus pneumoniae

Streptococcus pneumoniae (pneumococcus) remains a significant health threat worldwide, especially to the young and old. While some of the biomolecules involved in pneumococcal pathogenesis are known and understood in mechanistic terms, little is known about the molecular details of bacterium/host interactions. We report here the solution structure of the 'repeated' adhesion domains (domains R1 and R2) of the principal pneumococcal adhesin, choline binding protein A (CbpA). Further, we provide insights into the mechanism by which CbpA binds its human receptor, polymeric immunoglobulin receptor (pIgR). The R domains, comprised of 12 imperfect copies of the leucine zipper heptad motif, adopt a unique 3-alpha-helix, raft-like structure. Each pair of alpha-helices is antiparallel and conserved residues in the loop between Helices 1 and 2 exhibit a novel 'tyrosine fork' structure that is involved in binding pIgR. This and other structural features that we show are conserved in most pneumococcal strains appear to generally play an important role in bacterial adhesion to pIgR. Interestingly, pneumococcus is the only bacterium known to adhere to and invade human cells by binding to pIgR.     

Amino acid sequence of Sp23, a structural protein of the spermatophore of the mealworm beetle, Tenebrio molitor.

In this paper we present the amino acid sequence of Sp23, a structural protein of the spermatophore of the mealworm beetle (Tenebrio molitor). This is the first report of the primary structure of a spermatophorin. The protein is rich in proline (24%), relatively rich in tyrosine (9%) and glutamine (10%), and does not contain sulfur-containing amino acids. In the carboxyl-terminal half of the protein a peptide motif is repeated which is similar to a repetitive motif in a group of dipteran chorion proteins.     

Identification of the PXW sequence as a structural gatekeeper of the headpiece C-terminal subdomain fold

The HeadPiece (HP) domain, present in several F-actin-binding multi-domain proteins, features a well-conserved, solvent-exposed PXWK motif in its C-terminal subdomain. The latter is an autonomously folding subunit comprised of three alpha-helices organised around a hydrophobic core, with the sequence motif preceding the last helix. We report the contributions of each conserved residue in the PXWK motif to human villin HP function and structure, as well as the structural implications of the naturally occurring Pro to Ala mutation in dematin HP. NMR shift perturbation mapping reveals that substitution of each residue by Ala induces only minor, local perturbations in the full villin HP structure. CD spectroscopic thermal analysis, however, shows that the Pro and Trp residues in the PXWK motif afford stabilising interactions. This indicates that, in addition to the residues in the hydrophobic core, the Trp-Pro stacking within the motif contributes to HP stability. This is reinforced by our data on isolated C-terminal HP subdomains where the Pro is also essential for structure formation, since the villin, but not the dematin, C-terminal subdomain is structured. Proper folding can be induced in the dematin C-terminal subdomain by exchanging the Ala for Pro. Conversely, the reverse substitution in the villin C-terminal subdomain leads to loss of structure. Thus, we demonstrate a crucial role for this proline residue in structural stability and folding potential of HP (sub)domains consistent with Pro-Trp stacking as a more general determinant of protein stability.     

Identification of residues that determine the absence of a Ca(2+)/myristoyl switch in neuronal calcium sensor-1

The neuronal calcium sensor (NCS) family of Ca(2+)-binding proteins regulates a number of different processes in neurons and photoreceptor cells. The first of these proteins to be characterized, recoverin, was shown to exhibit a Ca(2+)/myristoyl switch whereby its N-terminal myristoyl group is sequestered in the Ca(2+)-free form and is exposed on Ca(2+) binding to allow the protein to become membrane-associated. It has subsequently been shown that certain other family members also exhibit this mechanism in living cells. In contrast, NCS-1 does not show the Ca(2+)/myristoyl switch and is membrane-associated even at low Ca(2+) concentrations. We have used sequence comparison combined with information from structural analyses to attempt to identify candidate residues within the NCS proteins that determine whether or not the Ca(2+)/myristoyl switch operates in cells and have tested their functional significance by mutagenesis. The results show that NCS-1 possesses residues within its N terminus that lock the myristoyl group in an exposed conformation. In addition, other structural aspects within the C-terminal domains are required to allow the switch to operate. We have determined a key role for residues within the motif EELTRK in NCS-1 in keeping the myristoyl group exposed and allowing the protein to be constitutively membrane-associated.     

Analysis of the FLVR motif of SHIP1 and its importance for the protein stability of SH2 containing signaling proteins

Binding of proteins with SH2 domains to tyrosine-phosphorylated signaling proteins is a key mechanism for transmission of biological signals within the cell. Characterization of dysregulated proteins in cell signaling pathways is important for the development of therapeutic approaches. The AKT pathway is a frequently upregulated pathway in most cancer cells and the SH2-containing inositol 5-phosphatase SHIP1 is a negative regulator of the AKT pathway. In this study we investigated different mutations of the conserved FLVR motif of the SH2 domain and putative phosphorylation sites of SHIP1 which are located in close proximity to its FLVR motif. We demonstrate that patient-derived SHIP1-FLVR motif mutations e.g. F28L, and L29F possess reduced protein expression and increased phospho-AKT-S473 levels in comparison to SHIP1 wildtype. The estimated half-life of SHIP1-F28L protein was reduced from 23.2 h to 0.89 h in TF-1 cells and from 4.7 h to 0.6 h in Jurkat cells. These data indicate that the phenylalanine residue at position 28 of SHIP1 is important for its stability. Replacement of F28 with other aromatic residues like tyrosine and tryptophan preserves protein stability while replacement with non-aromatic amino acids like leucine, isoleucine, valine or alanine severely affects the stability of SHIP1. In consequence, a SHIP1-mutant with an aromatic amino acid at position 28 i.e. F28W can rescue the inhibitory function of wild type SHIP1, whereas SHIP1-mutants with non-aromatic amino acids i.e. F28V do not inhibit cell growth anymore. A detailed structural analysis revealed that F28 forms hydrophobic surface contacts in particular with W5, I83, L97 and P100 which can be maintained by tyrosine and tryptophan residues, but not by non-aromatic residues at position 28. In line with this model of mutation-induced instability of SHIP1-F28L, treatment of cells with proteasomal inhibitor MG132 was able to rescue expression of SHIP1-F28L. In addition, mutation of putative phosphorylation sites S27 and S33 adjacent to the FLVR motif of SHIP1 have an influence on its protein stability. These results further support a functional role of SHIP1 as tumor suppressor protein and indicate a regulation of protein expression of SH2 domain containing proteins via the FLVR motif.     

Tyrosine phosphorylation of the well packed ephrinB cytoplasmic beta-hairpin for reverse signaling. Structural consequences and binding properties

Tyrosine phosphorylation of the 22-residue cytoplasmic region of ephrinB induces its binding to the SH2 domain of Grb4, thus initiating reverse signaling pathways controlling cytoskeleton assembly and remodeling. Recently, the region corresponding to this 22-residue motif was demonstrated to adopt a well packed beta-hairpin structure with a high conformational stability in the unphosphorylated cytoplasmic subdomain. However, because the binding to Grb4 is phosphorylation-dependent and the hairpin contains three conserved tyrosine residues that may be phosphorylated, the key events remain unknown as to how tyrosine phosphorylation affects the structure of this well packed beta-hairpin and which phosphorylation site is relevant to SH2 domain binding. By characterizing the structural and binding properties of six 22-residue SH2 domain-binding motifs with different phosphorylated sites, the present study reveals that, as shown by circular dichroism and NMR, the unphosphorylated 22-residue motif adopts a well formed beta-hairpin structure in isolation from the ephrinB cytoplasmic subdomain. However, this beta-hairpin is radically abolished by tyrosine phosphorylation, regardless of the relative location and number of Tyr residues. Unexpectedly, the peptides with either Tyr304 or Tyr316 phosphorylated show high affinity binding to SH2 domain, whereas the peptide with Tyr311 phosphorylated has no detectable binding. This implies that ephrinB with Tyr311 phosphorylated might have a currently unidentified binding partner distinct from the Grb4 protein, because Tyr311 is known to be phosphorylated in vivo. Based on the results above, it is thus proposed that the disruption of the tight side-chain packing by tyrosine phosphorylation in the well structured region of a signaling protein may represent a general activation mechanism by which a cryptic binding site is disclosed for new protein-protein interactions.     

Protein-DNA interactions: the story so far and a new method for prediction

This review describes methods for the prediction of DNA binding function, and specifically summarizes a new method using 3D structural templates. The new method features the HTH motif that is found in approximately one-third of DNAbinding protein families. A library of 3D structural templates of HTH motifs was derived from proteins in the PDB. Templates were scanned against complete protein structures and the optimal superposition of a template on a structure calculated. Significance thresholds in terms of a minimum root mean squared deviation (rmsd) of an optimal superposition, and a minimum motif accessible surface area (ASA), have been calculated. In this way, it is possible to scan the template library against proteins of unknown function to make predictions about DNA-binding functionality.     

Structural and biochemical characterization of CIB1 delineates a new family of EF-hand-containing proteins

CIB1 (CIB) is an EF-hand-containing protein that binds multiple effector proteins, including the platelet alphaIIbbeta3 integrin and several serine/threonine kinases and potentially modulates their function. The crystal structure for Ca(2+)-bound CIB1 has been determined at 2.0 A resolution and reveals a compact alpha-helical protein containing four EF-hands, the last two of which bind calcium ions in the standard fashion seen in many other EF-hand proteins. CIB1 shares high structural similarity with calcineurin B and the neuronal calcium sensor (NCS) family of EF-hand-containing proteins. Most importantly, like calcineurin B and NCS proteins, which possess a large hydrophobic pocket necessary for ligand binding, CIB1 contains a hydrophobic pocket that has been implicated in ligand binding by previous mutational analysis. However, unlike several NCS proteins, Ca(2+)-bound CIB1 is largely monomeric whether bound to a relevant peptide ligand or ligand-free. Differences in structure, oligomeric state, and phylogeny define a new family of CIB1-related proteins that extends from arthropods to humans.     

Protein design for non-aqueous solvents

Improving protein stability in unnatural and suboptimal environments is a promising application of protein engineering technology. Carefully designed amino acid alterations may lead to dramatic positive effects on the stability of proteins under highly perturbing conditions, such as in non-aqueous solvents. Applications of biocatalysts and proteins with specific binding capabilities in the chemical industry have been severely limited by constraints placed on the solvent environment. With the advent of convenient methods for altering the amino acid composition and even synthesizing entirely new protein molecules, it is worthwhile to consider engineering proteins for stability in non-aqueous solvents. In order to identify the features that a protein would need for stability in organic media, we have been studying the structure and properties of the hydrophobic protein crambin. Crambin is unique in that it is soluble and stable in very high concentrations of polar organic solvents. Crambin and its water-soluble homologs offer a powerful demonstration of protein engineering for non-aqueous solvents. This paper describes the structural features that contribute to crambin's special properties. Based on these observations and consideration of how non-aqueous solvents affect the interactions important in protein folding, a set of rules for designing non-aqueous solvent-stable proteins is proposed.     

The coiled coil motif in polymer drug delivery systems

The coiled coil is a superhelical structural protein motif that has been thoroughly investigated in recent years. Because of the relatively well-understood principles that determine the properties of coiled coil peptides and proteins, macromolecular systems containing the coiled coil motif have been suggested for various applications. This short review focuses on hybrid polymer coiled coil systems designed for drug delivery purposes. After a short introduction, the most important features of the coiled coils (stability, association number, oligomerization selectivity and orientation of helices) are described, and the factors influencing these characteristics are discussed. Several examples of the most interesting biomedical applications of the polymer-coiled coil systems (according to the authors' opinion) are presented.     

A novel motif identified in dependence receptors

Programmed cell death signaling is a critical feature of development, cellular turnover, oncogenesis, and neurodegeneration, among other processes. Such signaling may be transduced via specific receptors, either following ligand binding-to death receptors-or following the withdrawal of trophic ligands-from dependence receptors. Although dependence receptors display functional similarities, no common structural domains have been identified. Therefore, we employed the Multiple Expectation Maximization for Motif Elicitation and the Motif Alignment and Search Tool software programs to identify a novel transmembrane motif, dubbed dependence-associated receptor transmembrane (DART) motif, that is common to all described dependence receptors. Of 3,465 human transmembrane proteins, 25 (0.7%) display the DART motif. The predicted secondary structure features an alpha helical structure, with an unusually high percentage of valine residues. At least four of the proteins undergo regulated intramembrane proteolysis. To date, we have not identified a function for this putative domain. We speculate that the DART motif may be involved in protein processing, interaction with other proteins or lipids, or homomultimerization.     

Modulating repeat protein stability: the effect of individual helix stability on the collective behavior of the ensemble

Repeat proteins are tandem arrays of a small structural motif, in which tertiary structure is stabilized by interactions within a repeat and between neighboring repeats. Several studies have shown that this modular structure is manifest in modular thermodynamic properties. Specifically, the global stability of a repeat protein can be described by simple linear models, considering only two parameters: the stability of the individual repeated units (H) and the coupling interaction between the units (J). If the repeat units are identical, single values of H and J, together with the number of repeated units, is sufficient to completely describe the thermodynamic behavior of any protein within a series. In this work, we demonstrate how the global stability of a repeat protein can be changed, in a predictable fashion, by modifying only the H parameter. Taking a previously characterized series of consensus tetratricopeptide repeats (TPR) (CTPRa) proteins, we introduced mutations into the basic repeating unit, such that the stability of the individual repeat unit was increased, but its interaction with neighboring units was unchanged. In other words, we increased H but kept J constant. We demonstrated that the denaturation curves for a series of such repeat proteins can be fit and additional curves can be predicted by the one-dimensional Ising model in which only H has changed from the original fit for the CTPRa series. Our results show that we can significantly increase the stability of a repeat protein by rationally increasing the stability of the units (H), whereas the interaction between repeats (J) remains unchanged.     

The ankyrin repeat as molecular architecture for protein recognition

The ankyrin repeat is one of the most frequently observed amino acid motifs in protein databases. This protein-protein interaction module is involved in a diverse set of cellular functions, and consequently, defects in ankyrin repeat proteins have been found in a number of human diseases. Recent biophysical, crystallographic, and NMR studies have been used to measure the stability and define the various topological features of this motif in an effort to understand the structural basis of ankyrin repeat-mediated protein-protein interactions. Characterization of the folding and assembly pathways suggests that ankyrin repeat domains generally undergo a two-state folding transition despite their modular structure. Also, the large number of available sequences has allowed the ankyrin repeat to be used as a template for consensus-based protein design. Such projects have been successful in revealing positions responsible for structure and function in the ankyrin repeat as well as creating a potential universal scaffold for molecular recognition.     

Partially folded states of staphylococcal nuclease highlight the conserved structural hierarchy of OB-fold proteins

We have been interested in whether three proteins that share a five-stranded beta-barrel "OB-fold" structural motif but no detectable sequence homology fold by similar mechanisms. Here we describe native-state hydrogen exchange experiments as a function of urea for SN (staphylococcal nuclease), a protein with an OB-fold motif and additional nonconserved elements of structure. The regions of structure with the largest stability and unfolding cooperativity are contained within the conserved OB-fold portion of SN, consistent with previous results for CspA (cold shock protein A) and LysN (anticodon binding domain of lysyl tRNA synthetase). The OB-fold also has the subset of residues with the slowest unfolding rates in the three proteins, as determined by hydrogen exchange experiments in the EX1 limit. Although the protein folding hierarchy is maintained at the level of supersecondary structure, it is not evident for individual residues as might be expected if folding depended on obligatory nucleation sites. Rather, the site-specific stability profiles appear to be linked to sequence hydrophobicity and to the density of long-range contacts at each site in the three-dimensional structures of the proteins. We discuss the implications of the correlation between stability to unfolding and conservation of structure for mechanisms of protein structure evolution.     

Crystal structure of the C-terminal SH3 domain of the adaptor protein GADS in complex with SLP-76 motif peptide reveals a unique SH3-SH3 interaction

The Grb2-like adaptor protein GADS is essential for tyrosine kinase-dependent signaling in T lymphocytes. Following T cell receptor ligation, GADS interacts through its C-terminal SH3 domain with the adaptors SLP-76 and LAT, to form a multiprotein signaling complex that is crucial for T cell activation. To understand the structural basis for the selective recognition of GADS by SLP-76, herein is reported the crystal structure at 1.54 Angstrom of the C-terminal SH3 domain of GADS bound to the SLP-76 motif 233-PSIDRSTKP-241, which represents the minimal binding site. In addition to the unique structural features adopted by the bound SLP-76 peptide, the complex structure reveals a unique SH3-SH3 interaction. This homophilic interaction, which is observed in presence of the SLP-76 peptide and is present in solution, extends our understanding of the molecular mechanisms that could be employed by modular proteins to increase their signaling transduction specificity.     

A test of proposed rules for helix capping: implications for protein design

alpha-helices within proteins are often terminated (capped) by distinctive configurations of the polypeptide chain. Two common arrangements are the Schellman motif and the alternative alpha(L) motif. Rose and coworkers developed stereochemical rules to identify the locations of such motifs in proteins of unknown structure based only on their amino acid sequences. To check the effectiveness of these rules, they made specific predictions regarding the structural and thermodynamic consequences of certain mutations in T4 lysozyme. We have constructed these mutants and show here that they have neither the structure nor the stability that was predicted. The results show the complexity of the protein-folding problem. Comparison of known protein structures may show that a characteristic sequence of amino acids (a sequence motif) corresponds to a conserved structural motif. In any particular protein, however, changes in other parts of the sequence may result in a different conformation. The structure is determined by sequence as a whole, not by parts considered in isolation.