Effect of thermal stability on protein adsorption to silica using homologous aldo-keto reductases

Gaining more insight into the mechanisms governing the behavior of proteins at solid/liquid interfaces is particularly relevant in the interaction of high-value biologics with storage and delivery device surfaces, where adsorption-induced conformational changes may dramatically affect biocompatibility. The impact of structural stability on interfacial behavior has been previously investigated by engineering nonwild-type stability mutants. Potential shortcomings of such approaches include only modest changes in thermostability, and the introduction of changes in the topology of the proteins when disulfide bonds are incorporated. Here we employ two members of the aldo-keto reductase superfamily (alcohol dehydrogenase, AdhD and human aldose reductase, hAR) to gain a new perspective on the role of naturally occurring thermostability on adsorbed protein arrangement and its subsequent impact on desorption. Unexpectedly, we find that during initial adsorption events, both proteins have similar affinity to the substrate and undergo nearly identical levels of structural perturbation. Interesting differences between AdhD and hAR occur during desorption and both proteins exhibit some level of activity loss and irreversible conformational change upon desorption. Although such surface-induced denaturation is expected for the less stable hAR, it is remarkable that the extremely thermostable AdhD is similarly affected by adsorption-induced events. These results question the role of thermal stability as a predictor of protein adsorption/desorption behavior.     

Investigation of Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) Attachment onto Self-Assembled Monolayers (SAMs) Using Combinatorial Quartz Crystal Microbalance with Dissipation (QCM-D) and Spectroscopic Ellipsometry (SE)

Understanding protein adsorption kinetics to surfaces is of importance for various environmental and biomedical applications. Adsorption of bovine serum albumin to various self-assembled monolayer surfaces including neutral and charged hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces was investigated using in-situ combinatorial quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation and spectroscopic ellipsometry. Adsorption of bovine serum albumin varied as a function of surface properties, bovine serum albumin concentration and pH value. Charged surfaces exhibited a greater quantity of bovine serum albumin adsorption, a larger bovine serum albumin layer thickness, and increased density of bovine serum albumin protein compared to neutral surfaces at neutral pH value. The quantity of adsorbed bovine serum albumin protein increased with increasing bovine serum albumin concentration. After equilibrium sorption was reached at pH 7.0, desorption of bovine serum albumin occurred when pH was lowered to 2.0, which is below the isoelectric point of bovine serum albumin. Our data provide further evidence that combinatorial quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation and spectroscopic ellipsometry is a sensitive analytical tool to evaluate attachment and detachment of adsorbed proteins in systems with environmental implications.     

Circular dichroism studies on conformational changes in protein molecules upon adsorption on ultrafine polystyrene particles

The conformational changes in well-characterized model proteins [bovine ribonuclease A (RNase A), horseradish peroxidase, sperm-whole myoglobin, human hemoglobin, and bovine serum albumin (BSA)] upon adsorption on ultrafine polystyrene (PS) particles have been studied using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. These proteins were chosen with special attention to molecular flexibility. The ultrafine PS particles were negatively charged and have average diameters of 20 or 30 nm. Utilization of these ultrafine PS particles makes it possible to apply the CD technique to determine the secondary structure of proteins adsorbed on the PS surface. Effects of protein properties and adsorption conditions on the extent of the changes in the secondary structure of protein molecules upon adsorption on ultrafine PS particles were studied. The CD spectrum changes upon adsorption were significant in the "soft" protein molecules (myoglobin, hemoglobin, and BSA), while they were insingnificant in the "rigid" proteins (RNase A and peroxidase). The soft proteins sustained a marked decrease in alpha-helix content upon adsorption. Moreover, the native alpha-helix content, which is given as the percentage of the alpha-helix content in the free proteins, of adsorbed BSA was found to decrease with decreasing pH and increase with increasing adsorbed amount. These observations confirm some well-known hypotheses for the confirmational chages in protein molecules upon adsorption. (c) 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Total internal reflection/fluorescence photobleaching recovery study of serum albumin adsorption dynamics.

The total internal reflection/fluorescence photobleaching recovery (TIR/FPR) technique (Thompson et al. 1981. Biophys. J. 33:435) is used to study adsorbed bovine serum albumin dynamics at a quartz glass/aqueous buffer interface. Adsorbed fluorescent labeled protein is bleached by a brief flash of the evanescent wave of a focused totally internally reflected laser beam. The rates of adsorption/desorption and surface diffusion determine the subsequent fluorescence recovery. The protein surface concentration is low enough to be proportional to the observed fluorescence and high enough to insure that the observed recovery rates arise mainly from adsorbed rather than bulk protein dynamics. The photobleaching recovery curves for rhodamine-labeled bovine serum albumin reveal both an irreversibly bound state and a multiplicity of reversibly bound states. The relative amount of reversible to irreversible adsorption increases with increasing bulk protein concentration. Since the adsorbed protein concentration appears to be too high to pack into a homogeneous surface monolayer, the wide range of desorption rates possibly results from multiple layers of protein on the surface. Comparison of the fluorescence recovery curves obtained with various focused laser beam widths suggests that some of the reversibly bound bovine serum albumin molecules can surface diffuse. Aside from their relevance to the surface chemistry of blood, these results demonstrate the feasibility of the TIR/FPR technique for measuring molecular dynamics on solid surfaces.     

Human serum albumin adsorption onto a-SiC:H and a-C:H thin films deposited by plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition

In the present paper, we report the study of the adsorption behavior of a model protein such as human serum albumin (HSA) onto surfaces of a-SiC:H and a-C:H thin films deposited by using the plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD) technique. The surface composition and surface energy of the various substrates as well as the evaluation of the adsorbed amount of protein has been carried out by means of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and contact angle measurements. It has been found that HSA tends to preferentially adsorb on Si-rich surfaces, as far as the relative amount of adsorbed HSA decreases with increasing S-C concentration. Preliminary elements of mechanistic models are proposed for the correlation between chemical factors and the observed protein adsorption behavior.     

Evaluation of desorption of proteins adsorbed to hydrophilic surfaces by two-dimensional electrophoresis

The evaluation of the plasma protein adsorption patterns of superparamagnetic iron oxide (SPIO) particles is of high interest concerning their in vivo fate and is carried out by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). The sample preparation is of great importance, especially the removal of the adsorbed proteins (desorption) from the particle surface for subsequent analysis by 2-DE. The removal is carried out by a desorption solution. In this study, negatively and positively charged SPIO model particles were under investigation concerning the desorption of proteins adsorbed on their surfaces. Firstly, the desorption process was determined quantitatively using the Bradford protein assay. Secondly, the removable or nonremovable protein species, from particles surface were under investigation by 2-DE. Looking at the desorption in a quantitative manner with the Bradford assay, the desorption efficacy from negatively charged particles was about 90%. In the case of the positively charged particles, the desorption efficacy seemed to be reduced, approximately 34% of the proteins remained on the surface. Comparing the protein patterns of the particles evaluated by 2-DE in the desorption solution and the proteins remaining on the particles, they confirmed the results from the protein quantification. After desorption, the IgG gamma-chains were found to be the dominant protein fraction remaining on the negatively charged particles. On the positively charged particles, many more protein species were found after desorption. The more basic the protein fragments, the more ineffective was the desorption from the positively charged model particle, and vice versa. Nevertheless, all protein spots were found qualitatively in the desorption solution, especially when the desorption solutions still containing the particles were used for the 2-DE analysis. In conclusion, 2-DE could be confirmed as the "gold standard" for determining the plasma protein adsorption patterns of nanoparticulate systems.     

Interactions of thrombin with fibrinogen adsorbed on methyl-, hydroxyl-, amine-, and carboxyl-terminated self-assembled monolayers

We have examined the initial phase of fibrin formation, thrombin-catalyzed fibrinopeptide cleavage, from adsorbed fibrinogen using surface plasmon resonance and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Fibrinogen adsorption impaired thrombin-fibrinogen interactions compared to the interactions of thrombin with fibrinogen in solution. The properties of the underlying substrate significantly affected the extent and kinetics of fibrinopeptide cleavage, and the conversion of adsorbed fibrinogen to fibrin. Fibrinogen adsorbed on negatively charged surfaces (carboxyl-terminated self-assembled monolayers) released a smaller amount of fibrinopeptides, at a reduced rate relative to those of hydrophobic, hydrophilic, and positively charged surfaces (methyl-, hydroxyl-, and amine-terminated self-assembled monolayers, respectively). Additionally, the conversion of adsorbed fibrinogen to fibrin was comparatively inefficient at the negatively charged surface. These data correlated well with trends previously reported for fibrin proliferation as a function of surface properties. We conclude that thrombin interactions with adsorbed fibrinogen determine the extent of subsequent fibrin proliferation on surfaces.     

Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry: a new tool for probing interactions between proteins and metal surfaces. Use in dental implantology.

The fixation in the bone of an artificial titanium tooth root is believed to be initiated by the rapid adsorption of the proteins present in the surgical cavity on the titanium surface. The study of this adsorption should make it possible to predict the osseointegration capacities of new implant surface treatments. We describe here a new method, based on matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS), for quantifying proteins adsorbed on titanium surfaces fully identical to these designed for implantology. The key step of this method is a new MALDI-MS sample preparation allowing the adsorbed proteins to be removed from the surface and to be homogeneously dispersed in the matrix crystals. The adsorption of a model protein (lysozyme) on two titanium surfaces (polished and sandblasted) was studied in order to evaluate the method. The absolute MALDI-MS intensity was shown to vary linearly with the amount of adsorbed lysozyme. After dipping the titanium surfaces for different times in lysozyme solutions at different concentrations, the maximum amount of adsorbed lysozyme was measured by MALDI-MS and was shown to correspond to a lysozyme monolayer, which is consistent with results described in the literature.     

The investigation of protein adsorption behaviors on different functionalized polymers films

The adsorption of BSA and fibrinogen onto plasma-polymerized di-(ethylene glycol) vinyl ether, allylamine, and maleic anhydride films were investigated in detail by surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy (SPR). The chemical properties of the plasma polymers were initially determined by the plasma deposition conditions during the generation procedure. The analysis of the chemical structure of the films and the refractive index of plasma polymers in aqueous solution was carried out using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and waveguide mode spectroscopy, respectively. Using water contact angle measurement, the surface wettability of plasma polymers was also characterized. These properties have a critical influence on the behavior of protein adsorption on the surface of the plasma polymers. Protein adsorption was found to depend not only on the types of functionalized groups, but also on the plasma polymer thickness since the protein molecules penetrate into the plasma polymer network bulk. According to the size of protein molecules in aqueous solution and the amount of adsorbed proteins observed by SPR, the conformational changes of proteins could be deduced.     

Comparison of the adsorbed conformation of barley lipid transfer protein at the decane-water and vacuum-water interface: a molecular dynamics simulation

Molecular dynamics simulation is used to model the adsorption of the barley lipid transfer protein (LTP) at the decane-water and vacuum-water interfaces. Adsorption at both surfaces is driven by displacement of water molecules from the interfacial region. LTP adsorbed at the decane surface exhibits significant changes in its tertiary structure, and penetrates a considerable distance into the decane phase. At the vacuum-water interface LTP shows small conformational changes away from its native structure and does not penetrate into the vacuum space. Modification of the conformational stability of LTP by reduction of its four disulphide bonds leads to an increase in conformational entropy of the molecules, which reduces the driving force for adsorption. Evidence for changes in the secondary structure are also observed for native LTP at the decane-water interface and reduced LTP at the vacuum-water interface. In particular, intermittent formation of short (six-residue) regions of beta-sheet is found in these two systems. Formation of interfacial beta-sheet in adsorbed proteins has been observed experimentally, notably in the globular milk protein beta-lactoglobulin and lysozyme.     

Chemiluminescence-based detection and comparison of protein amounts adsorbed on differently modified silica surfaces

The biological consequences of protein adsorption on biomaterial surfaces are considered to be of utmost importance for their biocompatibility. A new method based on amino group-labeling coupled to a chemiluminescence reaction for direct determination of proteins adsorbed on material surfaces was employed. This method was used to explore the effects of surface chemistry and surface roughness on protein adsorption in a silicon oxide model system. Corundum sandblasting was applied to silicon wafers to create roughened surfaces while immobilization of fluorocarbon-, hydrocarbon-, and poly(ethylene glycol)-containing silanes produced surfaces of varying wettability. The adsorption behavior of two complex body fluids, human serum and saliva, and of two purified components, human serum albumin and fibronectin, was strongly influenced by the surface parameters. A general tendency to higher amounts of adsorbed protein was found on roughened surfaces and modification with poly(ethylene glycol) or with fluorocarbon moieties reduced protein adsorption. The values obtained with the new method could be confirmed by a colorimetric determination of protein amounts adsorbed on identically modified silica beads and were in accordance with those previously reported utilizing established methods for protein quantification. The presented method, which was methodically simple to perform and allowed the simultaneous measurement of a large number of samples, may be of future value for high-throughput surveying of the protein adsorption characteristics of biomaterials.     

Protein instability during HIC: Evidence of unfolding reversibility,and apparent adsorption strength of disulfide bond‐reduced α‐lactalbumin variants

A two‐conformation, four‐state model has been proposed to describe protein adsorption and unfolding behavior on hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) resins. In this work, we build upon previous study and application of a four‐state model to the effect of salt concentration on the adsorption and unfolding of the model protein α‐lactalbumin in HIC. Contributions to the apparent adsorption strength of the wild‐type protein from native and unfolded conformations, obtained using a deuterium labeling technique, reveal the free energy change and kinetics of unfolding on the resin, and demonstrate that surface unfolding is reversible. Additionally, variants of α‐lactalbumin in which one of the disulfide bonds is reduced were synthesized to examine the effects of conformational stability on apparent retention. Below the melting temperatures of the wild‐type protein and variants, reduction of a single disulfide bond significantly increases the apparent adsorption strength (～6–8 kJ/mol) due to increased instability of the protein. Finally, the four‐state model is used to accurately predict the apparent adsorption strength of a disulfide bond‐reduced variant. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009;102: 1416–1427. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The leucine rich amelogenin protein (LRAP) adsorbs as monomers or dimers onto surfaces

Amelogenin is believed to be involved in controlling the formation of the highly anisotropic and ordered hydroxyapatite crystallites that form enamel. The adsorption behavior of amelogenin proteins onto substrates is very important because protein–surface interactions are critical to its function. We have previously used LRAP, a splice variant of amelogenin, as a model protein for the full-length amelogenin in solid-state NMR and neutron reflectivity studies at interfaces. In this work, we examined the adsorption behavior of LRAP in greater detail using model self-assembled monolayers containing COOH, CH₃, and NH₂ end groups as substrates. Dynamic light scattering (DLS) experiments indicated that LRAP in phosphate buffered saline and solutions containing low concentrations of calcium and phosphate consisted of aggregates of nanospheres. Null ellipsometry and atomic force microscopy (AFM) were used to study protein adsorption amounts and quaternary structures on the surfaces. Relatively high amounts of adsorption occurred onto the CH₃ and NH₂ surfaces from both buffer solutions. Adsorption was also promoted onto COOH surfaces only when calcium was present in the solutions suggesting an interaction that involves calcium bridging with the negatively charged C-terminus. The ellipsometry and AFM studies revealed that LRAP adsorbed onto the surfaces as small subnanosphere-sized structures such as monomers or dimers. We propose that the monomers/dimers were present in solution even though they were not detected by DLS or that they adsorbed onto the surfaces by disassembling or “shedding” from the nanospheres that are present in solution. This work reveals the importance of small subnanosphere-sized structures of LRAP at interfaces.     

Chemisorption of proteins and their thiol derivatives onto gold surfaces: characterization based on electrochemical nonlinearity

This study was conducted to monitor the electrochemical responses of two proteins (bovine serum albumin (BSA) and gelatin) and their thiol derivatives adsorbed onto gold (Au) electrodes, which were analyzed by a "nonlinear" impedance method. A sinusoidal voltage is applied to a protein-containing aqueous solution and the waveform of the output current is analyzed by fast Fourier transformation (FFT). The intensities of the higher harmonics in the FFT varied with the species of protein and their thiol derivatives, and with time. From the higher harmonics, voltage-dependent capacitance and conductance were quantitatively evaluated to differentiate the state of adsorbed protein. Adsorption and desorption characteristics of BSA and its thiol derivative on the Au surface were continuously measured by a quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) in situ. The microscopic state of thiol-derivatized BSA adsorbed onto the Au surface was imaged by atomic force microscopy (AFM). In general, thiol-derivatized proteins were tightly adsorbed on the Au surface and showed no desorption. The present electrochemical measurements clearly differentiated adsorption characteristics of physically adsorbed (physisorbed) and chemically adsorbed (chemisorbed) proteins on Au surfaces.     

QCM-D sensitivity to protein adsorption reversibility

Using a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipative monitoring (QCM-D) we have determined the adsorption reversibility and viscoelastic properties of ribonuclease A adsorbed to hydrophobic self-assembled monolayers. Consistent with previous work with proteins unfolding on hydrophobic surfaces, high protein solution concentrations, reduced adsorption times, and low ammonium sulfate concentrations lead to increased adsorption reversibility. Measured rigidity of the protein layers normalized for adsorbed protein amounts, a quantity we term specific dissipation, correlated with adsorption reversibility of ribonuclease A. These results suggest that specific dissipation may be correlated with changes in structure of adsorbed proteins.     

Kinetics of protein adsorption and desorption on surfaces with grafted polymers

The kinetics of protein adsorption are studied using a generalized diffusion approach which shows that the time-determining step in the adsorption is the crossing of the kinetic barrier presented by the polymers and already adsorbed proteins. The potential of mean-force between the adsorbing protein and the polymer-protein surface changes as a function of time due to the deformation of the polymer layers as the proteins adsorb. Furthermore, the range and strength of the repulsive interaction felt by the approaching proteins increases with grafted polymer molecular weight and surface coverage. The effect of molecular weight on the kinetics is very complex and different than its role on the equilibrium adsorption isotherms. The very large kinetic barriers make the timescale for the adsorption process very long and the computational effort increases with time, thus, an approximate kinetic approach is developed. The kinetic theory is based on the knowledge that the time-determining step is crossing the potential-of-mean-force barrier. Kinetic equations for two states (adsorbed and bulk) are written where the kinetic coefficients are the product of the Boltzmann factor for the free energy of adsorption (desorption) multiplied by a preexponential factor determined from a Kramers-like theory. The predictions from the kinetic approach are in excellent quantitative agreement with the full diffusion equation solutions demonstrating that the two most important physical processes are the crossing of the barrier and the changes in the barrier with time due to the deformation of the polymer layer as the proteins adsorb/desorb. The kinetic coefficients can be calculated a priori allowing for systematic calculations over very long timescales. It is found that, in many cases where the equilibrium adsorption shows a finite value, the kinetics of the process is so slow that the experimental system will show no adsorption. This effect is particularly important at high grafted polymer surface coverage. The construction of guidelines for molecular weight/surface coverage necessary for kinetic prevention of protein adsorption in a desired timescale is shown. The time-dependent desorption is also studied by modeling how adsorbed proteins leave the surface when in contact with a pure water solution. It is found that the kinetics of desorption are very slow and depend in a nonmonotonic way in the polymer chain length. When the polymer layer thickness is shorter than the size of the protein, increasing polymer chain length, at fixed surface coverage, makes the desorption process faster. For polymer layers with thickness larger than the protein size, increases in molecular weight results in a longer time for desorption. This is due to the grafted polymers trapping the adsorbed proteins and slowing down the desorption process. These results offer a possible explanation to some experimental data on adsorption. Limitations and extension of the developed approaches for practical applications are discussed.     

Adsorption of viral matrix protein M1 in acidic medium

Adsorption of viral matrix protein M1 on the self-assembled monolayer of carboxyhexadecanthiol molecules simulating the surface of the cell membrane was studied by surface plasmon resonance refractometry technique. It was shown that in the acidic medium (pH 4.0) the fraction of irreversibly adsorbed protein increases with time. The protein formed a monolayer on the surface in concentration range from 50 to 500 nM. It was found that the amount of the adsorbed protein increased more than 3 times in this range. An important observation is that even at the lowest concentrations of the protein its molecules totally occupied the entire surface of the substrate, and a further protein addition did not lead to its further adsorption. To explain this phenomena, it was suggested that the number of M1 bonds with the surface increases during the adsorption, which leads to spreading of the protein molecules. Apparently, this effect is caused by the intrinsic disorder of the C-domain of the protein. It is hypothesized that the disassembly of the protein-lipid envelope of the influenza virus in the acidic medium does not result from desorption of the M1, but it is caused by the weakening of protein-protein bonds.     

The interaction of peripheral proteins and membranes studied with alpha-lactalbumin and phospholipid bilayers of various compositions

To characterize the interaction of peripheral proteins and membranes at the molecular level, we studied the reversible association of bovine alpha-lactalbumin (BLA) with lipid bilayers composed of different molecular forms of phosphatidylserine or equimolar mixtures of these phosphatidylserine forms and egg yolk phosphatidylcholine. At pH 4.5, almost all BLA (>90%) associates to negatively charged small unilamellar vesicles. The conformational changes that binding to these bilayers induced on the protein were characterized by circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy. Because binding of BLA to negatively charged vesicles is reverted by adjusting the pH back to >6.0, we also investigated the conformation of the membrane-bound protein by NMR-monitored H-D exchange of the backbone amide protons. The conformation adopted by BLA bound to these bilayers resembles a molten globule-like state but the negative ellipticity at 222 nm and the apparent alpha-helix content of the bound protein senses the changes in the physical properties of the membrane. Binding to bilayers in the gel state appears to correlate with an increased amount of alpha-helical structure and with a lower extent of integration into the membrane, corresponding to the adsorbed protein, while the opposite is found for BLA bound to vesicles in the liquid-crystalline phase, corresponding to the embedded conformation. A common feature for the membrane-bound conformations of BLA is that the amphipathic helix C (residues 86 to 99) is an important determinant for the adsorption and further integration of the protein into the membrane.     

Thermal and Structural Stability of Adsorbed Proteins

Experimental evidence suggests that proteins adsorbed to hydrophobic surfaces at low coverages are stabilized relative to the bulk. For larger coverages, proteins unfold and form β-sheets. We performed computer simulations on model proteins and found that: 1), For weakly adsorbing surfaces, unfolded conformations lose more entropy upon adsorption than folded ones. 2), The melting temperature, both in the bulk and at surfaces, decreases with increasing protein concentration because of favorable interprotein interactions. 3), Proteins in the bulk show large unfolding free energy barriers; this barrier decreases at stronger adsorbing surfaces. We conjecture that typical experimental temperatures appear to be below the bulk melting temperature for a single protein, but above the melting temperature for concentrated protein solutions. Purely thermodynamic factors then explain protein stabilization on adsorption at low concentrations. However, both thermodynamic and kinetic factors are important at higher concentrations. Thus, proteins in the bulk do not denature with increasing concentration due to large kinetic barriers, even though the aggregated state is thermodynamically preferred. However, they readily unfold upon adsorption, with the surface acting as a heterogeneous catalyst. The thermal behavior of proteins adsorbed to hydrophobic surfaces thus appears to follow behavior independent of their chemical specificity.     

Adsorption of a strong polyelectrolyte to model lignin surfaces

The adsorption of a strong, highly charged cationic polyelectrolyte to a kraft lignin thin film was investigated as a function of the adsorbing solution conditions using the quartz crystal microbalance. The polyelectrolyte, PDADMAC, with a molecular weight of 100 kDa and one cationic charge group per monomer, was adsorbed to the anionically charged lignin film in the pH range 3.5-9.5 in electrolyte solution of 0.1 to 100 mM NaCl. At low pH, the adsorbed amount of PDADMAC was minimal, however, this increased as a function of increasing pH. Indeed, the surface excess increased significantly at about pH 8.5, where ionization of the phenolic groups on the lignin macromolecule may be expected. Furthermore, at this elevated pH, the adsorbed amount of PDADMAC decreased as the ionic strength of the solution increased above 1 mM. This is due to the competitive adsorption of counterions to the lignin surface and indicates that the adsorption of PDADMAC to lignin is of a pure electrosorption nature.