Immobilized-biomembrane affinity chromatography for binding studies of membrane proteins

Analyses of specific interactions between solutes and a membrane protein can serve to characterize the protein. Frontal affinity chromatography of an interactant on a column containing the membrane protein immobilized in a lipid environment is a simple and robust approach for series of experiments with particular protein molecules. Regression analysis of the retention volumes at a series of interactant concentrations shows the affinity of the protein for the interactant and the amount of active binding sites. The higher the affinity, the fewer sites are required to give sufficient retention. Competition experiments provide the affinities of even weakly binding solutes and the non-specific retention of the primary interactant. Hummel and Dreyer size-exclusion chromatography allows complementary analyses of non-immobilized membrane materials. Analyses of the human facilitative glucose transporter GLUT1 by use of the inhibitor cytochalasin B (radioactively labeled) and the competitive substrate D-glucose (non-labeled) showed that GLUT1 interconverted between two states, exhibiting one or two cytochalasin B-binding sites per two GLUTI monomers, dependent on the membrane composition and environment. Similar analyses of a nucleoside transporter, a photosynthetic reaction center, nicotinic acetylcholine receptors and a P-glycoprotein, alternative techniques, and immobilized-liposome chromatographic approaches are presented briefly.     

Protein interactions with immobilized transition metal ions: quantitative evaluations of variations in affinity and binding capacity

The interaction of proteins with immobilized transition-metal ions proceeds via mechanisms influenced by metal type and degree of coordination, variations in mobile phase constituents, and protein surface architecture at or near the metal binding site(s). The contributions each of these variables make toward the affinity of protein surfaces for immobilized metal ions remain empirical. We have used equilibrium binding analyses to evaluate the influence of pH and competitive binding reagents on the apparent equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) and binding capacity of immobilized Cu(II) and Ni(II) ions for several model proteins of known three-dimensional structure. Linear Scatchard plots suggested that 8/13 of the proteins evaluated interacted with immobilized metal ions via a single class of operational (Kd = 10-700 microM) binding sites. Those proteins with the highest affinities for the immobilized Cu(II) ions (5/13) showed evidence of multiple, non-identical or nonindependent binding sites. The effects of altered metal type, pH, and concentration of competitive affinity reagents (e.g., imidazole, free metal ions) on the apparent Kd and binding capacity varied in magnitude for individual proteins. The presence of free Cu(II) ions did not detectably alter either the affinity or binding capacity of the proteins for immobilized Cu(II) ions. The expected relationship between the relative chromatographic elution sequence and calculated affinity constants was not entirely evident by evaluation under only one set of conditions. Our results demonstrate the utility of nonchromatographic equilibrium binding analyses for the quantitative evaluation of experimental variables affecting the relative affinity and capacity of immobilized metal ions for proteins. This approach affords the opportunity to improve understanding and to vary the contribution of interaction mechanisms involved.     

Quantitative affinity chromatographic studies of mitochondrial cytochrome c binding to bacterial photosynthetic reaction center, reconstituted in liposome membranes and immobilized by detergent dialysis and avidin--biotin binding

In order to study the affinity binding of c-type cytochromes to the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) by quantitative affinity chromatography (QAC), RC from Rhodobacter sphaeroides was reconstituted into liposomes composed of egg phosphatidylcholine (EPC) and 2 mol% of biotinyl phosphatidylethanolamine simultaneously as the liposomes were formed and immobilized in (strept)avidin-coupled gel beads by rotary detergent dialysis. The immobilized amount was up to 80 nmol of RC and 33 micromol of lipid/g of moist gel in streptavidin-coupled Sephacryl S-1000 gel. By QAC frontal runs, retardation of mitochondrial cyt c on immobilized RC liposome columns was demonstrated. The dissociation constant for the RC-cyt c interaction was determined to be 0.20-0.57 microM. QAC studies also allowed evaluation of the orientation of reconstituted RC in immobilized liposomes by comparison of the total amount of cyt c binding sites with the amount of available binding sites obtained by QAC. It seems that the RC proteoliposomes immobilized in Sephacryl S-1000 gel exposed the cyt c binding sites on the outer surface of the liposomes due to effects of the gel network pore size and the resulting liposomal size.     

Chromatography on cells and biomolecular assemblies

Red cells, biomembrane vesicles, proteoliposomes and liposomes non-covalently immobilized in gel particles or beads have been used as stationary phases for biomembrane affinity analyses and ion-exchange chromatographic separation. Lipid monolayers coupled to silica beads have been utilized for membrane protein purification in detergent solution and plant cell walls for group separation of macromolecules according to size and charge. Further methodological studies are essential to implement general practical application.     

A ligand-receptor binding assay by receptor immobilization

Using transferrin-transferrin receptor binding as a model of ligand-receptor binding, we have developed a new and simple binding assay for the solubilized receptor. Solubilized membrane proteins containing transferrin receptor were immobilized by covalent binding to beads having chemical reactive epoxide groups, and then 125I-labeled transferrin was added to the beads. Dose-dependent, ligand-specific, and saturable binding of 125I-labeled transferrin to the immobilized membrane proteins were demonstrated and a Scatchard analysis derived affinity of Kd = 1.8 X 10(-9) M was obtained. These results indicate that the immobilization of receptors onto beads may be useful in a simple binding assay of the solubilized receptor.     

Phosphatidylserine binding sites in erythroid spectrin: location and implications for membrane stability

The erythrocyte membrane is a composite structure consisting of a lipid bilayer tethered to the spectrin-based membrane skeleton. Two complexes of spectrin with other proteins are known to participate in the attachment. Spectrin has also been shown to interact with phosphatidylserine (PS), a component of the lipid bilayer, which is confined to its inner leaflet. That there may be multiple sites of interaction with PS in the spectrin sequence has been inferred, but they have not hitherto been identified. Here we have explored the interaction of PS-containing liposomes with native alpha- and beta-spectrin chains and with recombinant spectrin fragments encompassing the entire sequences of both chains. We show that both alpha-spectrin and beta-spectrin bind PS and that sites of high affinity are located within 8 of the 38 triple-helical structural repeats which make up the bulk of both chains; these are alpha8, alpha9-10, beta2, beta3, beta4, beta12, beta13, and beta14, and PS affinity was also found in the nonhomologous N-terminal domain of the beta-chain. No other fragments of either chain showed appreciable binding. Binding of spectrin and its constituent chains to mixed liposomes of PS and phosphatidylcholine (PC) depended on the proportion of PS. Binding of spectrin dimers to PS liposomes was inhibited by single repeats containing PS binding sites. It is noteworthy that the PS binding sites in beta-spectrin are grouped in close proximity to the sites of attachment both of ankyrin and of 4.1R, the proteins engaged in attachment of spectrin to the membrane. We conjecture that direct interaction of spectrin with PS in the membrane may modulate its interactions with the proteins and that (considering also the known affinity of 4.1R for PS) the formation of PS-rich lipid domains, which have been observed in the red cell membrane, may be a result.     

Enrichment of multiphosphorylated peptides by immobilized metal affinity chromatography using Ga(III)- and Fe(III)-complexes

The detection and identification of O-phosphorylation sites in proteins with mass spectrometry remains a challenge. A common approach to analyse these modifications is to enrich phosphopeptides by immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) prior to mass spectrometric analysis. In this study two commercially available IMAC kits based on Fe(III)-ions immobilized on magnetic beads and Ga(III)-ions immobilized on a chelate-resin, have been investigated and the binding efficiency of peptide mixtures containing non-phosphorylated, singly, doubly and triply phosphorylated peptides have been tested.     

Freeze-thaw immobilization of liposomes in chromatographic gel beads: evaluation by confocal microscopy and effects of freezing rate

Biological membranes immobilized in chromatographic gel beads constitute a multifunctional affinity matrix. Membrane protein-solute interactions and drug partitioning into the lipid bilayers can conveniently be studied. By the use of confocal laser-scanning microscopy (CLSM) the distribution of immobilized model membranes in the beads has been visualized for the first time. Freeze-thaw-immobilized liposomes in Superdex 200 gel beads were situated in a thick shell surrounding a liposome-free core. The amount of phospholipids immobilized by freeze-thawing was dependent on the temperature in the cooling bath and the type of test tube used. A bath temperature of -25 degrees C gave higher immobilization yield than freezing at -75 or -8 degrees C did. Freeze-thawing in the presence of liposomes did not affect the gel bead shape or the refractive index homogeneity of the agarose network of the beads, as shown by confocal microscopy.     

Protein interaction with immobilized ligands: quantitative analyses of equilibrium partition data and comparison with analytical chromatographic approaches using immobilized metal affinity adsorbents

Quantitative or analytical affinity chromatography has been successful primarily for the analysis of biologically determined macromolecular affinity relationships. Quantitative approaches are also needed to better characterize simpler, chemically defined immobilized ligands with potential for selective interaction with specific, predetermined protein surface groups. Protein interaction with immobilized metal is a rather selective and versatile, high-affinity adsorption technique for which there is little quantitative information. Using model protein interactions with immobilized Cu2+ ions, we have compared analytical frontal affinity chromatographic methods to a simple, nonchromatographic protocol for the rapid determination of quantitative affinity relationships. Values obtained for the equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) and binding capacity (Lt) characterizing the interaction of lysozyme with immobilized Cu2+ were quite similar by frontal analysis (Kd = 37-42 X 10(-6) M; Lt = 6.8-7.4 X 10(-6) mol protein/ml gel) and by equilibrium binding analyses (Kd = 33 +/- 4.7 X 10(-6) M; Lt = 5.8-6.1 X 10(-6) mol protein/ml gel; 14 determinations). The interaction of ovalbumin with immobilized Cu2+ was characterized by an affinity (Kd = 4.2-4.8 X 10(-6) M) and capacity (Lt = 1.5-2.1 X 10(-6) mol protein/ml gel) which were also the same regardless of the method for affinity analysis. These values indicate that the total protein bound at saturation corresponds to as much as 17% of the total immobilized Cu2+ ions (approximately 40 X 10(-6) mol/ml gel). Thus, depending on the fraction of total immobilized Cu2+ available for interaction with a given protein (e.g., lysozyme), the number of individual immobilized ligands actively participating as well as those rendered unavailable upon individual protein binding events may be greater than 1. Linear Scatchard plots obtained for both lysozyme and ovalbumin (purified) suggest the presence of only a single type of immobilized Cu2+-protein interaction operative under the experimental conditions employed. However, Scatchard analyses of data obtained by the nonchromatographic equilibrium binding method also demonstrated the ability to simultaneously resolve the contribution of two components whose presence was predicted by frontal chromatography. Our results support the validity and utility of equilibrium binding data analyzed according to the equations outlined by Scatchard and others as an alternative to analytical chromatographic methods.     

Analytical high-performance affinity chromatography: evaluation by studies of neurophysin self-association and neurophysin-peptide hormone interaction using glass matrices

Bovine neurophysin II (BNP II) was covalently immobilized on both nonporous and porous (200-nm pore diameter) glass beads and incorporated in a high-performance liquid chromatograph to evaluate analytical high-performance affinity chromatography as a microscale method for characterizing biomolecular interactions. By extension of the theoretical treatment of analytical affinity chromatography, both the self-association of neurophysin and its binding of the peptide hormone vasopressin were characterized by using a single chromatographic column containing immobilized neurophysin predominantly in the monomer form. Both [3H] [Arg8]vasopressin (AVP) and 125I-BNP II were rapidly eluted (less than 25 min). The relatively symmetrical elution peaks obtained allowed calculation of both equilibrium dissociation constants and kinetic dissociation rate constants. The dissociation constant measured chromatographically for the AVP-immobilized neurophysin complex, KM/L = 11 microM with porous glass beads and 75 microM with nonporous glass (NPG) beads, was in reasonable agreement with those previously obtained by curve fitting of Scatchard plots (16-20 microM) and from binding to [BNP II]Sepharose (50 microM). The values obtained are larger than that for dissociation of AVP from BNP II dimer, by a factor consistent with the intended nature of immobilized BNP II as monomers. Chromatography of BNP II on the [BNP II]NPG gave a dimer dissociation constant of 166 microM, a value in excellent agreement with that derived from equilibrium sedimentation studies (172 microM). In contrast to the agreement of chromatographic equilibrium binding constants with those measured in solution, the dissociation rate, k-3, determined from the variance of the affinity chromatographic elution profile with nonporous beads, was several orders of magnitude smaller than the solution counterpart.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Drug affinity to immobilized target bio-polymers by high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrophoresis

This review addresses the use of high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and capillary electrophoresis (CE) as affinity separation methods to characterise drugs or potential drugs-bio-polymer interactions. Targets for the development of new drugs such as enzymes (IMERs), receptors, and membrane proteins were immobilized on solid supports. After the insertion in the HPLC system, these immobilized bio-polymers were used for the determination of binding constants of specific ligands, substrates and inhibitors of pharmaceutical interest, by frontal analyses and zonal elution methods. The most used bio-polymer immobilization techniques and methods for assessing the amount of active immobilized protein are reported. Examples of increased stability of immobilized enzymes with reduced amount of used protein were shown and the advantages in terms of recovery for reuse, reproducibility and on-line high-throughput screening for potential ligands are evidenced. Dealing with the acquisition of relevant pharmacokinetic data, examples concerning human serum albumin binding studies are reviewed. In particular, papers are reported in which the serum carrier has been studied to monitor the enantioselective binding of chiral drugs and the mutual interaction between co-administered drugs by CE and HPLC. Finally CE, as merging techniques with very promising and interesting application of microscale analysis of drugs' binding parameters to immobilized bio-polymers is examined.     

A Quantitative Approach to Membrane Binding of Human Ubiquitous Mitochondrial Creatine Kinase Using Surface Plasmon Resonance

We have evaluated surface plasmon resonance with avidin-biotin immobilized liposomes tocharacterize membrane binding of ubiquitous mitochondrial creatine kinase (uMtCK). Whilethe sarcomeric sMtCK isoform is well known to bind to negatively charged phospholipids,especially cardiolipin, this report provides the first experimental evidence on the membraneinteraction of an uMtCK isoform. Qualitative measurements showed that liposomes containing16% (w/w) cardiolipin bind octameric as well as dimeric human uMtCK and also cytochromec, but not bovine serum albumin. Quantitative parameters could be derived only for themembrane interaction of octameric human uMtCK using an improved analytical approach.Association and dissociation kinetics of octameric uMtCK fit well to a model for heterogeneousinteraction suggesting two independent binding sites. Rate constants of the two sites differedby one order of magnitude, while their affinity constants were both about 80–100 nM. Thedata obtained demonstrate that surface plasmon resonance with immobilized liposomes is asuitable approach to characterize the binding of peripheral proteins to a lipid bilayer and thatthis method yields consistent quantitative binding parameters.     

Insights into the complex association of bovine factor Va with acidic-lipid-containing synthetic membranes.

The mechanism of binding of blood coagulation cofactor factor Va to acidic-lipid-containing membranes has been addressed. Binding isotherms were generated at room temperature using the change in fluorescence anisotropy of pyrene-labeled bovine factor Va to detect binding to sonicated membrane vesicles containing either bovine brain phosphatidylserine (PS) or 1,2-dioleoyl-3-sn-phosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) in combination with 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-3-sn-phosphatidylcholine (POPC). The composition of the membranes was varied from 0 to 40 mol% for PS/POPC and from 0 to 65 mol % for DOPG/POPC membranes. Fitting the data to a classical Langmuir adsorption model yielded estimates of the dissociation constant (Kd) and the stoichiometry of binding. The values of Kd defined in this way displayed a maximum at low acidic lipid content but were nearly constant at intermediate to high fractions of acidic lipid. Fitting the binding isotherms to a two-process binding model (nonspecific adsorption in addition to binding of acidic lipids to sites on the protein) suggested a significant acidic-lipid-independent binding affinity in addition to occupancy of three protein sites that bind PS in preference to DOPG. Both analyses indicated that interaction of factor Va with an acidic-lipid-containing membrane is much more complex than those of factor Xa or prothrombin. Furthermore, a change in the conformation of bound pyrene-labeled factor Va with surface concentration of acidic lipid was implied by variation of both the saturating fluorescence anisotropy and the binding parameters with the acidic lipid content of the membrane. Finally, the results cannot support the contention that binding occurs through nonspecific adsorption to a patch or domain of acidic lipids in the membrane. Factor Va is suggested to associate with membranes by a complex process that includes both acidic-lipid-specific and acidic-lipid-independent sites and a protein structure change induced by occupancy of acidic-lipid-specific sites on the factor Va molecule.     

Biomembrane affinity chromatographic analysis of nitrobenzylthioinosine binding to the reconstituted human red cell nucleoside transporter

Solute interactions with membrane proteins can be analyzed by biomembrane affinity chromatography (BAC), previously applied to the human red cell glucose transporter. As a novel example, frontal BAC analysis of interactions between the nucleoside transport inhibitor nitrobenzylthioinosine (NBTI) and immobilized reconstituted nucleoside and glucose transporters from human red cells revealed two binding sites, presumably corresponding to the two transporters. The affinities and amounts of sites were determined by use of a double rectangular hyperbolic equation. The Kd value for NBTI binding to the nucleoside transporter in egg phospholipid proteoliposomes was 0.38 +/- 0.08 nM (22 degrees C, I = 0.16, pH 7.4), lower than previously reported for reconstituted systems. The molar ratio between the amounts of nucleoside transporter sites for NBTI and glucose transporter sites for cytochalasin B was 4.5 +/- 0.6%.     

Selective ligand purification using high-performance affinity beads

Since the development of affinity chromatography, affinity purification technology has been applied to many aspects of biological research, becoming an indispensable tool. Efficient strategies for the identification of biologically active compounds based on biochemical specificity have not yet been established, despite widespread interest in identifying chemicals that directly alter biomolecular functions. Here, we report a novel method for purifying chemicals that specifically interact with a target biomolecule using reverse affinity beads, a receptor-immobilized high-performance solid-phase matrix. When FK506-binding protein 12 (FKBP12) immobilized beads were used in this process, FK506 was efficiently purified in one step either from a mixture of chemical compounds or from fermented broth extract. The reverse affinity beads facilitated identification of drug/receptor complex binding proteins by reconstitution of immobilized ligand/receptor complexes on the beads. When FKBP12/FK506 and FKBP12/rapamycin complexes were immobilized, calcineurin and FKBP/rapamycin-associated protein were purified from a crude cell extract, respectively. These data indicate that reverse affinity beads are powerful tools for identification of both specific ligands and proteins that interact with receptor/ligand complexes.     

The membrane lipid environment modulates drug interactions with the P-glycoprotein multidrug transporter.

The P-glycoprotein multidrug transporter functions as an ATP-driven efflux pump for a large number of structurally unrelated hydrophobic compounds. Substrates are believed to gain access to the transporter after partitioning into the membrane, rather than from the extracellular aqueous phase. The binding of drug substrates to P-glycoprotein may thus be modulated by the properties of the lipid bilayer. The interactions with P-glycoprotein of two drugs (vinblastine and daunorubicin) and a chemosensitizer (verapamil) were characterized by quenching of purified fluorescently labeled protein in the presence of various phospholipids. Biphasic quench curves were observed for vinblastine and verapamil, suggesting that more than one molecule of these compounds may bind to the transporter simultaneously. All three drugs bound to P-glycoprotein with substantially higher affinity in egg phosphatidylcholine (PC), compared to brain phosphatidylserine (PS) and egg phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). The nature of the lipid acyl chains also modulated binding, with affinity decreasing in the order egg PC > dimyristoyl-PC (DMPC) > dipalmitoyl-PC (DPPC). Following reconstitution of the transporter into DMPC, all three compounds bound to P-glycoprotein with 2-4-fold higher affinity in gel phase lipid relative to liquid-crystalline phase lipid. The P-glycoprotein ATPase stimulation/inhibition profiles for the drugs were also altered in different lipids, in a manner consistent with the observed changes in binding affinity. The ability of the drugs to partition into bilayers of phosphatidylcholines was determined. All of the drugs partitioned much better into egg PC relative to DMPC and DPPC. The binding affinity increased (i.e., the value of Kd decreased) as the drug-lipid partition coefficient increased, supporting the proposal that the effective concentration of the drug substrate in the membrane is important for interaction with the transporter. These results provide support for the vacuum cleaner model of P-glycoprotein action.     

Detergents as intrinsic P-glycoprotein substrates and inhibitors

We assessed the interaction of three electrically neutral detergents (Triton X-100, C₁₂EO₈, and Tween 80) with P-glycoprotein (ABCB1, MDR1) and identified the molecular elements responsible for this interaction. To this purpose we titrated P-glycoprotein in inside-out plasma membrane vesicles of MDR1-transfected mouse embryo fibroblasts (NIH-MDR1-G185) with the detergents below their critical micelle concentration, CMC. The P-glycoprotein ATPase measured as a function of the detergent concentration yielded bell-shaped activity curves which were evaluated with a two-site binding model. The lipid-water partition coefficient and the transporter-water binding constant of the detergents were measured independently. Knowledge of these two parameters allowed assessment of the free energy of detergent binding to P-glycoprotein in the lipid membrane, ΔG_tl⁰, that reflects the direct detergent-transporter affinity. It increased as the number of ethoxyl groups increased, suggesting that these hydrogen bond acceptor groups are the key elements for the detergent-transporter interaction in the lipid membrane. The free energy of binding to P-glycoprotein per ethoxyl group (EO) was determined as approximately ΔG_EO⁰ = − 1.6 kJ/mol. The present findings moreover document that, depending on the concentration applied, detergents are intrinsic substrates for, or inhibitors of P-glycoprotein.     

Membrane solubilization by a hydrophobic polyelectrolyte: surface activity and membrane binding.

We have previously observed that the hydrophobic polyelectrolyte poly(2-ethylacrylic acid) solubilizes lipid membranes in a pH-dependent manner, and we have exploited this phenomenon to prepare lipid vesicles that release their contents in response to pH, light, or glucose (Thomas, J. L., and D. A. Tirrell. Acc. Chem. Res. 25:336-342, 1992). The physical basis for the interaction between poly(2-ethylacrylic acid) and lipid membranes has been explored using surface tensiometry and fluorimetry. Varying the polymer concentration results in changes in surface activity and membrane binding that correlate with shifts in the critical pH for membrane solubilization. Furthermore, the binding affinity is reduced as the amount of bound polymer increases. These results are consistent with a hydrophobically driven micellization process, similar to those observed with apolipoproteins, melittin, and other amphiphilic alpha-helix-based polypeptides. The absence of specific secondary structure in the synthetic polymer suggests that amphiphilicity, rather than structure, is the most important factor in membrane micellization by macromolecules.     

Lipid Vesicle-mediated Affinity Chromatography using Magnetic Activated Cell Sorting (LIMACS): a Novel Method to Analyze Protein-lipid Interaction

The analysis of lipid protein interaction is difficult because lipids are embedded in cell membranes and therefore, inaccessible to most purification procedures. As an alternative, lipids can be coated on flat surfaces as used for lipid ELISA and Plasmon resonance spectroscopy. However, surface coating lipids do not form microdomain structures, which may be important for the lipid binding properties. Further, these methods do not allow for the purification of larger amounts of proteins binding to their target lipids. To overcome these limitations of testing lipid protein interaction and to purify lipid binding proteins we developed a novel method termed lipid vesicle-mediated affinity chromatography using magnetic-activated cell sorting (LIMACS). In this method, lipid vesicles are prepared with the target lipid and phosphatidylserine as the anchor lipid for Annexin V MACS. Phosphatidylserine is a ubiquitous cell membrane phospholipid that shows high affinity to the protein Annexin V. Using magnetic beads conjugated to Annexin V the phosphatidylserine-containing lipid vesicles will bind to the magnetic beads. When the lipid vesicles are incubated with a cell lysate the protein binding to the target lipid will also be bound to the beads and can be co-purified using MACS. This method can also be used to test if recombinant proteins reconstitute a protein complex binding to the target lipid. We have used this method to show the interaction of atypical PKC (aPKC) with the sphingolipid ceramide and to co-purify prostate apoptosis response 4 (PAR-4), a protein binding to ceramide-associated aPKC. We have also used this method for the reconstitution of a ceramide-associated complex of recombinant aPKC with the cell polarity-related proteins Par6 and Cdc42. Since lipid vesicles can be prepared with a variety of sphingo- or phospholipids, LIMACS offers a versatile test for lipid-protein interaction in a lipid environment that resembles closely that of the cell membrane. Additional lipid protein complexes can be identified using proteomics analysis of lipid binding protein co-purified with the lipid vesicles.Download video file.^{(48M, mov)}