Responses to ozone in 12 provenances of European beech (Fagus sylvatica): genotypic variation and chamber effects on photosynthesis and dry-matter partitioning

Seedlings of 12 provenances of European beech ( Fagus sylvatica ) were exposed to ambient, non-filtered air (NF) or NF+50 nl l⁻¹ ozone (NF50) for 8 h d⁻¹ in open-top chambers (OTCs), from 1 June to 4 October 1995. In 1996 exposure was continued from 31 May to 1 October at four levels: charcoal-filtered air (CF), NF, NF50 and NF+100 nl l⁻¹ ozone (NF100). Provenances were grown for both seasons in outside reference plots. All treatments were replicated. Ozone did not affect gas exchange in the provenances until late in the second season. NF100 reduced photosynthesis by 18% in August 1996 compared to CF. In September, photosynthesis was reduced by 22% in NF50 and by 29% in NF100. After two seasons, ozone reduced the root:shoot ratio by 24% when comparing CF and NF100; this was caused by reductions in the root biomass. Ozone did not affect height growth or stem diameter, and there were no ozone×provenance interactions for any growth parameter. There was, however, a significant ozone×provenance interaction for photosynthesis, showing northwest European provenances to be more sensitive to ozone than southeast European provenances when comparing dose–response estimates. This is interpreted in terms of genetic adaptation of the photosynthetic apparatus to regional growing conditions. Seedlings in the chambers grew 45% taller, and had 28% more shoot biomass and 29% smaller root biomass, resulting in a 44% reduction of root:shoot ratios compared to seedlings outside. Increased temperature and decreased PAR inside the chambers relative to the outside were probably the main causes for the differences. The magnitude of the chamber effects in OTCs raises doubts about conclusions drawn from ozone exposures in such chambers. This and previous ozone experiments with OTCs may have reached inaccurate conclusions concerning the size of ozone responses due to chamber effects.     

Survival and recovery of perennial forage grasses under prolonged Mediterranean drought: II. Water status, solute accumulation, abscisic acid concentration and accumulation of dehydrin transcripts in bases of immature leaves

Effects of ozone on spring wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Satu) were studied in an open-top chamber experiment during two growing seasons (1992–1993) at Jokioinen in south-west Finland. The wheat was exposed to filtered air (CF), non-filtered air (NF), non-filtered air+35 nl l⁻¹ ozone for 8 h d⁻¹ (NF⁺) and ambient air (AA). Each treatment was replicated five times. Two wk after anthesis, after 4 wk of ozone treatment (NF⁺, 45 nl l⁻¹ 1000–1800 hours, seasonal mean) the net CO₂ uptake of wheat flag leaves was decreased by c . 40% relative to CF and NF treatments, both initial and total activity of Rubisco and the quantity of protein-bound SH groups were decreased significantly. Added ozone also significantly accelerated flag leaf senescence recorded as a decrease in chloroplast size. The effect was significant 2 wk after anthesis, and senescence was complete after 4 wk. In the CF and NF treatments senescence was complete 5 wk after anthesis. The significant effect of ozone on the chloroplasts and net CO₂ uptake 2 wk after anthesis did not affect the grain filling rate. However, since the grain filling period was shorter for ozone fumigated plants, kernels were smaller. The decrease in 1000-grain weight explained most of the yield reduction in the plants under NF⁺ treatment. The results indicate that wheat plants are well buffered against substantial decrease in source activity, and that shortened flag leaf duration is the major factor causing ozone-induced yield loss.     

On the response of pigments and antioxidants of Pinus halepensis seedlings to Mediterranean climatic factors and long-term ozone exposure

An experiment was carried out in open-top chambers located in eastern Spain. One-yr-old Pinus halepensis Mill. seedlings were exposed during three consecutive summers to the following ozone (O₃) treatments: charcoal-filtered air (CFA), non-filtered air (NFA) or non-filtered air plus 40 nl l⁻¹ O₃, 9 h d⁻¹, 5 d wk⁻¹ (NFA+40). Seasonal variations in Aleppo pine performance were observed since reductions in chlorophyll and cellular peroxidase levels associated with increases in superoxide dismutase activity, were recorded during the summer. Similarly, a reduction in epoxidation state was found at midday during the summer, derived from an activation of the xanthophyll cycle associated to an increment in radiation and temperature levels.
The first O₃-induced effects were recorded in previous-year needles (1991) during the first summer exposure as an increase in extracellular and total peroxidase activities and in zeaxanthin levels in the NFA+40 treatment along with a trend to a higher SOD activity in this treatment. A carry-over effect was detected since a lower winter recovery of chlorophyll levels was found in the NFA+40 seedlings along with a reduction of xanthophyll levels. A reduction in chlorophyll levels was observed in the previous-year needles (1992) from the NFA+40 treatment at the end of the second fumigation period. Realistic ozone exposures induced alterations in plant antioxidative systems and plant pigments as shown in this paper. These observations together with the reductions in stomatal conductance and net photosynthesis recorded in the same experiment, indicate that Aleppo pine is a species sensitive to ozone.     

Rate and duration of grain filling in relation to flag leaf senescence and grain yield in spring wheat (Triticum aestivum) exposed to different concentrations of ozone

Effects of different concentrations of ozone on grain filling, flag leaf senescence and final grain yield in field‐grown spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv. Dragon) were studied using open‐top chambers. The hypothesis tested was that an ozone‐induced reduction in grain yield is mainly related to an enhanced senescence and a shortening of the grain‐filling period. The plants were exposed to filtered air (F), non‐filtered air without extra ozone (NF) or non‐filtered air with 3 different levels of ozone added (NF1+, NF2+ and NF3+). The mean daytime (08.00–20.00 h) ozone concentrations during the exposure period (31 days) were 7, 20, 34, 48 and 62 nmol mol?1 in F, NF, NF1+, NF2+ and NF3+, respectively. The corresponding ozone doses, expressed as the accumulated exposure over a concentration threshold of 40 nmol mol?1 (AOT40), were 0, 12, 1 989, 5 881 and 10 375 nmol mol?1 h, respectively, and 884, 2 594, 4 557, 6 188 and 7 900 μmol m?2, respectively, expressed as the calculated cumulative flag leaf ozone flux (CFO30). The flag leaves senesced earlier and the grain‐filling duration was significantly shorter at higher ozone exposure compared to F (?5, ?13 and ?18% in NF1+, NF2+ and NF3+, respectively). The relative grain‐filling rate did not differ between the treatments. The 1000‐grain weights were 10, 28 and 37% lower, and the grain yields were 15, 29 and 46% lower than F in NF1+, NF2+ and NF3+, respectively. Ozone exposure had no significant effect on the number of grains per unit ground area or on straw yield, but significantly reduced the harvest index and increased the grain protein concentration in NF2+ and NF3+ compared to F. The grain yield was negatively correlated with the ozone dose, expressed either as AOT40 or as CFO3 with or without an ozone flux threshold. The 1000‐grain weight was positively correlated with the grain‐filling duration (R2=0.998), which in turn was positively correlated with the leaf area duration (R2=0.989).     

Four years of ozone exposure at high or low phosphorus reduced biomass in Norway spruce

Saplings of one clone of Norway spruce (Picea abies) were planted in pots and exposed to charcoal filtered (CF) air, non-filtered (NF) air or NF air plus extra ozone (NF+; ambient × 1.4) in open-top chambers (OTCs). The lowest and highest ozone concentrations were combined with low phosphorus (LP) supply. Ambient air plots without OTCs, and with and without pots, were also included. A long-term study was conducted with 756 trees (3–7 years old) harvested successively over four growing seasons. Ozone had a negative impact on tree growth, both in the high phosphorus (HP) supply and in the LP treatments. The ozone-induced decrease in biomass of the whole tree (NF+ relative to CF) was approximately 5% after four seasons, irrespective of phosphorus status. The corresponding decrease in biomass caused by LP, relative to HP, was 20% whatever the ozone treatment. LP also caused a shift in the shoot to root ratio, where root growth was favoured at the expense of the shoot. A weak effect of ozone treatment on the shoot to root ratio, favouring shoot growth, was found after three seasons, but was totally surpassed by the opposite effect of LP in the fourth season. The effect of OTCs and pots is also discussed.     

Effect of ambient ozone at the somma of Lake Mashu on growth and leaf gas exchange in Betula ermanii and Betula platyphylla var. japonica

We examined the effects of ambient ozone, at the somma of Lake Mashu in northern Japan, on the growth and photosynthetic traits of two common birch species in Japan (mountain birch and white birch). Seedlings of the two birch species were grown in open-top chambers and were exposed to charcoal-filtered ambient air (CF) or non-filtered ambient air (NF) at the somma of Lake Mashu during the growing season in 2009. For the mountain birch, ambient ozone significantly increased the ratio of aboveground dry mass to belowground dry mass (T/R ratio), although no difference in the whole-plant biomass was observed between the treatments. For the white birch, in contrast, ozone exposure at ambient level did not decrease in growth and photosynthesis. These results suggest that ambient O₃ at the somma of Lake Mashu may shift the allocation of biomass to above-ground rather than below-ground in the mountain birch.     

Ozone exposure results in various carry-over effects and prolonged reduction in biomass in birch (Betula pendula Roth)

In the first experiment, saplings of ozone-sensitive and a more tolerant clone of Betula pendula Roth were exposed to ambient ozone (control treatment, accumulated exposure over a threshold 40 nmol mol ^{? 1} (AOT40) exposure of 1·0 μmol mol ^{? 1} h) and 1·5 × ambient ozone (elevated-ozone treatment, AOT40 of 17·3 μmol mol ^{? 1} h) over one growing season, 1996. After over-wintering, the dormant elevated-ozone saplings were transferred to the control blocks and assessed for short-term carry-over effects during the following growing season. In the second experiment, three sensitive, four intermediate and three tolerant clones were grown under ambient ozone (control treatment, AOT40 of 0·5–0·8 μmol mol ^{? 1} h per growing season) and 1·6–1·7 × ambient ozone (elevated-ozone treatment, AOT40 of 18·3–18·6 μmol mol ^{? 1} h per growing season) from May 1994 until May 1996, and were assessed for long-term carry-over effects during growing season 1997, after a 12–16 months recovery period. Deleterious short-term carry-over effects of ozone exposure included reduced contents of Rubisco, chlorophyll, carotenoids, starch and nutrients in leaves, lower stomatal conductance, and decreased new shoot growth and net assimilation rate, followed by a 7·5% (shoot dry weight (DW)), 15·2% (root DW) and 23·2% (foliage area) decreased biomass accumulation and yield over the long term, including a reduced root : shoot ratio. However, a slow recovery of relative growth rates during the following two seasons without elevated ozone was apparent. Several long-lasting structural, biochemical and stomatal acclimation, stress-defence and compensation reactions were observed in the ozone-tolerant clone, whereas in the sensitive clone allocation shifted from growth towards defensive phenolics such as chlorogenic acid. The results provide evidence of persistent deleterious effects of ozone which remain long after the ozone episode.     

The impact of ozone on juvenile maize (Zea mays L.) plant photosynthesis: effects on vegetative biomass, pigmentation, and carboxylases (PEPc and Rubisco)

The impact of ozone on crops was more studied in C (3) than in C (4) species. In C (3) plants, ozone is known to induce a photosynthesis impairment that can result in significant depressions in biomass and crop yields. To investigate the impact of O (3) on C (4) plant species, maize seedlings ( ZEA MAYS L. cv. Chambord) were exposed to 5 atmospheres in open-top chambers: non-filtered air (NF, 48 nL L (-1) O (3)) and NF supplied with 20 (+ 20), 40 (+ 40), 60 (+ 60), and 80 (+ 80) nL L (-1) ozone. An unchambered plot was also available. Leaf area, vegetative biomass, and leaf dry mass per unit leaf area (LMA) were evaluated 33 days after seedling emergence in OTCs. At the same time, photosynthetic pigments as well as carboxylase (PEPc and Rubisco) activities and amounts were also examined in the 5th leaf. Ozone enhanced visible symptoms characterizing foliar senescence. Across NF, + 20, + 40, and + 60 atmospheres, both chlorophylls and carotenoids were found to be linearly decreased against increasing AOT40 ( CA. - 50 % in + 60). No supplementary decrease was observed between + 60 and + 80. Total above-ground biomass was reduced by 26 % in + 80 atmosphere; leaf dry matter being more depressed by ozone than leaf area. In some cases, LMA index was consistent to reflect low negative effects caused by a moderate increase in ozone concentration. PEPc and Rubisco were less sensitive to ozone than pigments: only the two highest external ozone doses reduced their activities by about 20 - 30 %. These changes might be connected to losses in PEPc and Rubisco proteins that were decreased by about one-third. The underlying mechanisms for these results were discussed with special reference to C (3) species. To conclude, we showed that both light and dark reactions of C (4) photosynthesis can be impaired by realistic ozone doses.     

Effect of a chronic and moderate ozone pollution on the phenolic pattern of bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Nerina): relations with visible injury and biomass production

From sowing, bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Nerina) plants were exposed to three chronic doses of ozone for 7h.day(-1): non-filtered air (NF), non-filtered air supplied with 40nl.l(-1) ozone (NF+40) and non-filtered air supplied with 60nll(-1) ozone (NF+60). Four harvests were carried out 6, 13, 20 and 27 days after emergence. Either primary leaves, or first trifoliate leaves, or both were sampled as far as possible. For each sampled leaf, visible ozone injuries were registered, the free polyphenolic pool was analysed using HPLC and the dry matter was weighed. Visible damage on leaves was related to both exposure time and ozone concentration added. There were no adverse effects of added ozone on the biomass of primary leaves while a significant reduction of first trifoliates dry matter could be observed (NF+60 atmosphere, third and fourth harvest). Among the normally occurring phenolics, we detected a significant decrease in the accumulation of a hydroxycinnamic acid derivative as the ozone concentration increased. Nevertheless, we demonstrated that this ozone-induced modification could be sometimes distinguishable with difficulties from changes expected to be of development relevance. Beside this phenolic disbalance, we detected a de novo biosynthesis of compounds that closely depended on the level of visible ozone injury. Since their accumulation increased with leaf damage, these ozone-induced phenolics could be used to detect phytotoxic ambient levels of tropospheric ozone.     

In vivo occurrence of carbonyl residues in Phaseolus vulgaris proteins as a direct consequence of a chronic ozone stress

We aimed to show that a chronic and realistic ozone stress could induce in vivo formation of carbonyl groups in leaf proteins of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Bergamo). Plants were grown in three open-top chambers with increasing ozone concentrations: non-filtered air (NF), NF+40 nL·L^–1, NF+80 nL·L^–1 ozone 7 h·d^–1 for 22 d. Carbonyl contents in proteins, evaluation of Rubisco (EC 4.1.1.39) amounts and visible damages were systematically investigated in primary and first trifoliate leaves. Visible ozone injuries clearly reflected the total external ozone dose (expressed as AOT40) that the leaf had suffered. Ozone was effective at inducing aldehydes and ketones formation in bean proteins. This production of carbonyl groups increased with ozone concentration, the most relevant difference being observed on the Rubisco small subunit (Rubisco SSU). Contrary to young first trifoliate leaves, older primary leaves from O₃-enriched atmospheres exhibited a two-fold decrease in Rubisco level. Carbonyl group formation in Rubisco SSU and decrease in Rubisco level were not necessarily linked. Depending on ozone concentration, exposure time and leaf age, these two effects were observed either together or separately for an almost similar external dose of ozone. To conclude, leaf symptoms, loss of Rubisco and oxidized Rubisco SSU could participate in the assessment of the impact of a chronic ozone stress.     

Impacts of urban levels of ozone on Pinus halepensis foliage

Between May and September, 1996, seedlings of Pinus halepensis were placed at a site adjacent to an automated air pollution monitoring station within the urban area of Florence. Additional 'control' plants were placed in chambers ventilated with charcoal/Purafil(R)-filtered air. All trees were well watered throughout the whole experimental period. During the exposure period, ambient levels of sulphur dioxide were very low, whilst the accumulated hourly exposure to ozone above 40 ppb (i.e. AOT40) exceeded 20000 ppb h(-1) - peak hourly ozone concentrations rising to levels above 100 ppb. Trees exposed to ambient levels of air pollution exhibited typical symptoms of ozone damage (chlorotic mottle) on previous year needles toward the end of the summer. Similar symptoms were not observed on equivalent trees exposed to filtered-air, nor were visible symptoms accompanied by insect or pest infestation. Anatomical and ultrastructural observations made on symptomatic needles revealed degeneration in mesophyll cells bordering sub-stomatal cavities and alterations in chloroplast ultrastructure (fat accumulation, starch and tannin pattern modifications). These observations are consistent with the known effects of air pollutants (namely ozone) recorded in the literature. Findings are discussed in relation to the impacts of ozone on P. halepensis in the Mediterranean region.     

冬小麦气孔臭氧通量拟合及通量产量关系的比较分析

基于田间原位开顶箱(Open-Top Chambers,OTCs)实验,研究了不同浓度臭氧(O3)处理下(自然大气处理,AA;箱内大气处理,NF;箱内低浓度O3处理,NF+40 nL/L;箱内中等浓度O3处理,NF+80 nL/L;箱内高浓度O3处理,NF+120 nL/L),冬小麦(Triticum aestivum L.)旗叶气孔运动对不同环境因子的响应,并通过剂量反应分析,比较了冬小麦产量损失与累积气孔O3吸收通量(AFstX)和累积O3暴露浓度(AOT40和SUM06)的相关性差异。结果表明:冬小麦旗叶气孔运动的光饱和点和最适温度分别约为400μmol.m-.2s-1和27℃,水汽压差、土壤含水量和O3剂量的气孔限制临界值分别约为1.4 kPa、-100 kPa和20μL.L-.1h-1,超过此临界值时,气孔导度会明显下降。利用Jarvis气孔导度模型对冬小麦旗叶气孔导度和气孔O3吸收通量进行了预测,结果表明Jarvis模型解释了冬小麦实测气孔导度60%的变异性。由于不同时期植物体气孔导度的差异,冬小麦旗叶生长期内累积气孔O3吸收通量(AFstX)呈非线性增加趋势。O3吸收速率临界值(X)为4 nmol.m-.2s-1时,累积O3吸收通量(AFst4)与冬小麦产量的相关性最高(R2=0.76),该数值介于O3暴露指标AOT40和SUM06的剂量反应决定系数(0.74和0.81)之间。与O3浓度指标(AOT40和SUM06)相比,O3通量指标(AFstX)在本试验冬小麦产量损失评价中未表现出明显优势。     

Ozone effects on visible foliar injury and growth of Fagus sylvatica and Viburnum lantana seedlings grown in monoculture or in mixture

Seedlings of Fagus sylvatica (beech) and Viburnum lantana (Viburnum) grown in monoculture and mixture were exposed to ambient and sub-ambient (charcoal-filtered) ozone concentrations in open-top chambers over the course of the 2003 and 2004 growing seasons at the WSL Lattecaldo open-top chamber facility in southern Switzerland. The aim of the study was to determine how the sensitivity to ozone in ambient air of these two species would differ between monocultures and mixtures in terms of growth and visible foliar injury development. Ambient ozone concentrations were consistently higher from the end of April to the middle of October in 2003 than in 2004 with seasonal peaks and means reaching 147 and 50 parts-per-billion (ppb) in 2003 compared to 124 and 40 ppb in 2004. Ambient AOT40 (ozone concentration accumulated over a threshold of 40 ppb during daylight hours with global radiation >50 W m^?2) values from the end of April to the middle of October reached 48.3 and 26.8 parts-per-billon hours (ppm h) in 2003 and 2004, respectively. In general, Viburnum was a stronger competitor than beech over the course of this 2-year study. Seedlings of Viburnum benefited from interspecific competition in terms of both height growth and above-ground biomass accumulation at the expense of beech seedlings, which showed significantly reduced growth in the mixture as compared to the monoculture. However, as this was only the case for Viburnum growing in the charcoal-filtered treatment, ozone seemed to counteract the beneficial effect of interspecific competition on above-ground biomass accumulation in Viburnum, while at the same time decreasing relative biomass allocation to roots. Foliar sensitivity of the two species was also altered under interspecific competition suggesting that results based on seedlings of single species grown in monocultures may significantly over- or under-estimate foliar sensitivity to ozone. These results demonstrate that competition is an important factor affecting plant responses to ozone stress, but the direction and severity of these effects depend on the interacting species.     

臭氧对水稻根系活力、可溶性蛋白含量与抗氧化系统的影响

采用旋转布气法开顶式气室 (Open top chambers, OTCs) 装置, 研究4种臭氧 (O3) 浓度水平 (过滤大气, O3浓度20nl·L-1;环境大气, O3浓度40nl·L-1;中等O3浓度处理, O3浓度为75nl·L-1;高浓度处理, O3浓度为150nl·L-1) 下水稻 (Oryzasativa) 根系中根系活力、可溶性蛋白含量、膜脂过氧化程度与抗氧化系统的变化差异。主要结果表明与过滤大气处理相比, O3浓度升高 (75和150nl·L-1) 使植株根系活力显著降低, 根系大幅度、过早地衰退;根系可溶性蛋白质含量显著下降;根系MDA含量显著升高, 膜脂过氧化程度加剧;SOD活性呈先升高后下降的变化趋势根系中H2O2含量大幅度显著上升, 并随着O3处理浓度升高和暴露时间延长变化幅度增大;CAT与POD活性则表现出升高趋势, 但处理后期升高幅度略微降低;整个处理期间根系ASA含量无显著变化。环境大气处理与过滤大气处理植株各个指标变化趋势基本一致并略微下降, 随着处理时间延长根系活力与蛋白质含量出现显著下降, 其他指标无显著差异。试验结果表明O3浓度升高会对植物地下部分根系产生影响;随着O3胁迫时间的延长, 植物将面临着缺乏强有力的根系生理代谢活力支持。     

Interactive effects of elevated [CO2] and drought on cherry (Prunus avium) seedlings I. Growth, whole-plant water use efficiency and water loss

Seeds of cherry ( Prunus avium ) were germinated and grown for two growing seasons in ambient (∼350 μmol mol⁻¹) or elevated (ambient+∼350 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ mole fractions in six open-top chambers. The seedlings were fertilized once a week, following Ingestad principles in order to supply mineral nutrients at free-access rates. In the first growing season gradual drought was imposed on rapidly growing cherry seedlings by withholding water for a 6-wk drying cycle. In the second growing season, the rapid onset of drought was imposed at the height of the growing season on the seedlings which had already experienced drought in the first growing season. Elevated [CO₂] significantly increased total dry-mass production in both water regimes, but did not ameliorate the growth response to drought of the cherry seedlings subjected to two sequential drying cycles. Water loss did not differ in either well watered or droughted seedlings between elevated and ambient [CO₂]; consequently whole-plant water- use efficiency (the ratio of total dry mass produced to total water consumption) was significantly increased. Similar patterns of carbon allocation between shoot and root were found in elevated and ambient [CO₂] when the seedlings were the same size. Thus, elevated [CO₂] did not improve drought tolerance, but it accelerated ontogenetic development irrespective of water status.     

Physiological indicators of nitrogen response in a short rotation sycamore plantation. I. CO2 assimilation, photosynthetic pigments and soluble carbohydrates

American sycamore ( Platanus occidentalis L.) seedlings were grown in the field under different urea-nitrogen fertilization regimes to identify physiological variables that characterize the growth response. Treatments included fertilization at the beginning of the growing season with 50, 150, 450 kg N ha⁻¹, fertilization 3 times each at 37.5 kg N ha⁻¹ and unfertilized control. The greatest aboveground biomass accumulation (3× that of control) occurred in plots fertilized with 450 kg N ha⁻¹, but nearly as much growth occurred when 37.5 kg N ha⁻¹ was added periodically. Photosynthesis, chlorophyll concentrations and growth increased rapidly after the midseason application of 37.5 kg N ha⁻¹ but not after the late-season application. Although nitrogen fertilization increased leaf area per plant, leaf nitrogen concentration did not differ between treatments. There was no evidence to indicate that fertilization extended the physiologically active season or increased susceptibility to drought or cold. Sycamore leaves accumulated sucrose and mannose in response to water stress in all treatments. Photosynthetic pigment concentrations and net photosynthetic rate were the most sensitive indicators of growth response to nitrogen fertilization in the first growing season. Careful timing (based on physiological indicators) of low level applications of nitrogen fertilizer can optimize growth.     

Growth responses to ozone in plant species from wetlands

Ten wet grassland species were fumigated with four concentrations of ozone (charcoal-filtered air, non-filtered air and non-filtered air plus 25 or 50 nl l(-1) ozone) in open-top chambers during one growing season to investigate the long-term effect of this air pollutant on various growth variables. Only Eupatorium cannabinum showed ozone-related foliar injury, while five species reacted with significantly ozone-enhanced senescence. Premature senescence was paralleled by a significant ozone-induced reduction of green leaf area in Achillea ptarmica, E. cannabinum and Plantago lanceolata. At the intermediate harvest performed after 28 days shoot weights were significantly decreased by ozone in A. ptarmica and increased in Molinia caerulea. At the final harvest performed at the end of the growing season two other species, Cirsium dissectum and E. cannabinum had a significantly reduced shoot weight due to ozone. Root biomass was determined only at the intermediate harvest. The root:shoot ratio (RSR) was significantly reduced in C. dissectum, while it increased in M. caerulea. Seven of the species developed flowers during the experiment. While no significant ozone effects on flowering date and flower numbers were detected, flower weights were significantly reduced in E. cannabinum and P. lanceolata.     

Biomass, reproductive output, and physiological responses of rapid-cycling Brassica (Brassica rapa) to ozone and modified root temperature

Brassica rapa L. (rapid-cycling Brassica), was grown in environmentally controlled chambers to determine the interactive effects of ozone (O₃) and increased root temperature (RT) on biomass, reproductive output, and photosynthesis. Plants were grown with or without an average treatment of 63 ppb O₃. RT treatments were 13°C (LRT) and 18°C (HRT). Air temperatures were 25°C/15°C day/night for all RT treatments.
Ozone affected plant biomass more than did root temperature. Plants in O₃ had significantly smaller total plant d. wt, shoot weight, leaf weight, leaf area and leaf number than plants grown without O₃. LRT plants tended to have slightly smaller total plant d. wt, shoot weight, root weight, leaf weight, leaf area, and leaf number than HRT plants. For all variables, LRT plants grown in O₃ had the smallest biomass, and plants grown in HRT without O₃ had the largest biomass.
Ozone reduced both fruit weight and fruit number; LRT also reduced fruit weight but had no effect on fruit number. Ozone reduced photosynthesis but RT had no effect. Conductance and internal CO₂ were unaffected by O₃ or RT.
These studies indicate that plant growth with LRT might be more reduced in the presence of O₃ than growth in plants with HRT, which might be able to compensate for O₃-caused reductions in photosynthesis to avoid decreased biomass and reproductive output.     

Growth, photosynthesis and ozone uptake of young beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) in response to different ozone exposures

Beech seedlings (Fagus sylvatica L.) were exposed to episodes of O₃ in environmentally controlled growth chambers during one growing season. Three treatments were applied: charcoal-filtered air, charcoal-filtered air with the addition of 40 ppb O₃ for seven episodes of 5 days' duration (9000-1700 hours), and charcoal-filtered air with the addition of 100 ppb O₃ for seven episodes of 5 days' duration (9000-1700 hours). The accumulated exposure over a threshold of 40 ppb in the last treatment reached 13,911 ppb h. Throughout the growing season we measured growth as well as photosynthetic properties and related effects to external and calculated internal doses of O₃, using stomatal conductance (g_s) data. Growth, measured as diameter increment and biomass, was not significantly affected by the O₃ treatments. In the 100-ppb treatment, light-saturated CO₂ assimilation rates and chlorophyll content were significantly reduced, and the chlorophyll fluorescence parameter F_v/F_m was significantly reduced at times of high uptake rates and coincided with strong reductions of assimilation rates. O₃ uptake was lowered in the 100-ppb treatment due to reduced g_s. There was serious visible damage by the end of the exposure period in the 100-ppb treatment, while the treatment with 40 ppb O₃ did not seem to cause any significant changes.