Nonheterochronic developmental changes underlie morphological heterochrony in the evolution of the Ardeidae

Evolutionary changes in developmental timing and rates (heterochrony) are a source of morphological variation. Here we explore a central issue in heterochronic analysis: are the alterations in developmental timing and rates the only factor underlying morphological heterochrony? Tarsometatarsal growth through endochondral ossification in Ardeidae evolution has been taken as a case study. Evolutionary changes in bone growth rate (morphological heterochrony) might be either (a) the result of alterations in the mitotic frequency of epiphyseal chondrocytes (process‐heterochrony hypothesis), or (b) the outcome of alterations in the number of proliferating cells or in the size of hypertrophic chondrocytes (structural hypothesis). No correlation was found between tarsometatarsal growth rates and the frequency of cell division. However, bone growth rates were significantly correlated with the number of proliferating cells. These results support the structural hypothesis: morphological acceleration and deceleration are the outcome of evolutionary changes in one structural variable, the number of proliferating cells.     

Early evolution of the bilateria

The phylogeny of the Bilateria and especially the early steps in the evolution of the bilaterian bauplan are still a controversial topic. In this context the relationships of the platyhelminths and the nematodes play a crucial role. Previous molecular studies of the relationships of these groups, which were based on 18S ribosomal DNA sequences, yielded conflicting results. In the present study a new framework is developed for the phylogenetic analysis of bilaterian relationships, using concatenated amino acid sequences of several nuclear genes. In this analysis, the rhabditophoran platyhelminths are probably the sister group of all other analyzed Bilateria, the Eubilateria, which are characterized by a one-way intestine with an anus. The Eubilateria are split into the nematode lineage and the coelomates. The phylogenetic results of the present study indicate that genetic features found in the model organisms Caenorhabditis and Drosophila might be found in all Eubilateria. Estimations of the divergence times show that the major bilaterian phyla did not originate in an explosive radiation during the Cambrian but rather that the Bilateria have a several hundred million years long Precambrian history.     

Butterfly wing pattern mutants: developmental heterochrony and co-ordinately regulated phenotypes

Butterfly wings are colored late in development, when pigments are synthesized in specialized wing scale cells in a fixed developmental succession. In this succession, colored pigments are deposited first and the remaining areas are later melanized black or brown. Here we studied the developmental changes underlying two wing pattern mutants, firstly melanic mutants of the swallowtail Papilio glaucus, in which the yellow background is turned black, and secondly a Spotty mutant of the satyrid Bicyclus anynana, which carries two additional eyespots. Despite the very different pattern changes in these two mutants, they are both associated with changes in rates of scale development and correspondingly, the final color pattern. In the melanic swallowtail, background scales originally destined to become yellow (normally developing early and synthesizing papiliochrome) show delayed development, fail to make papiliochrome, and subsequently melanize at the same time as scales in the wild-type black pattern. In the B. anynana eyespot, scale maturation begins with the central white focus, then progresses to the surrounding gold ring and later finishes with melanization of the black center. Mutants showing additional eyespots display accelerated rates of scale development (corresponding to new eyespots) in wing cells not normally occupied by eyespots. Thus by either delaying or accelerating rates of scale development, the final color, or position, of a wing pattern element can be changed. We propose that this heterochrony of scale development is a basic mechanism of color pattern formation on which developmental mutants act to change lepidopteran color patterns. Received: 20 April 2000 / Accepted: 19 July 2000     

Larval ontogenetic stages of Chaetopterus: developmental heterochrony in the evolution of chaetopterid polychaetes

Seven post-gastrulation larval stages are described for the sedentary polychaete Chaetopterus. Analysis of larval anatomy and morphology through ontogeny reveals significant differences in the temporal sequence of segmentation, and in the character of segments formed, from the typical embryological pattern described for other polychaete families, such as nereidids or spionids. When compared in alternative phylogenetic schemes, these differences represent significant developmental heterochrony, among other evolutionary transitions, which has arisen in the chaetopterid lineage. The heterochrony is correlated with the extreme morphological regionalization along the anterior-posterior body axis, a feature that is also characteristic of chaetopterids.     

Epigenetic developmental programs and adipogenesis

Psychotropic agents are notorious for their ability to increase fat mass in psychiatric patients. The two determinants of fat mass are the production of newly differentiated adipocytes (adipogenesis), and the volume of lipid accumulation. Epigenetic programs have a prominent role in cell fate commitments and differentiation required for adipogenesis. In parallel, epigenetic effects on energy metabolism are well supported by several genetic models. Consequently, a variety of psychotropics, often prescribed in combinations and for long periods, may utilize a common epigenetic effector path causing an increase in adipogenesis or reduction in energy metabolism. In particular, the recent discovery that G protein coupled signaling cascades can directly modify epigenetic regulatory enzymes implicates surface receptor activity by psychotropic medications. The potential therapeutic implications are also suggested by the effects of the clinically approved antidepressant tranylcypromine, also a histone demethylase inhibitor, which has impressive therapeutic effects on metabolism in the obese phenotype.     

Amphetamine recapitulates developmental programs in the zebrafish

Addictive drugs hijack the human brain's 'reward' systems. A zebrafish model of addiction has recently been used to query changes in gene expression during this process.     

The genetic control of heterochrony: Evidence from developmental mutants of Pisum sativum L.

Heterochrony, as a means of evolution in which the rate or timing of developmental events of the descendant is altered compared with that of the ancestor, is of significance because it suggests that rapid and dramatic morphological changes are possible with few genetic changes. The putative origin of plant taxa by this means of evolution is becoming increasingly frequent in the literature but there is little evidence of the extent of the genetic change necessary to alter the timing of developmental events to produce such changes. This study shows that the onset of flowering can be altered independently from the vegetative transition in leaf form in at least one genotype of Pisum in response to different environments. Further, it identifies 9 mutations that act in a heterochronic manner to produce dramatic morphological changes that can be described as progenesis, neoteny, hypermorphosis or acceleration. In addition, it is demonstrated that the same heterochronic process (e.g. progenesis) may be caused by genes controlling distinctly different physiological processes. It is suggested that Pisum is an ideal model species for studies of heterochrony and that few genetic changes are necessary to bring about dramatic heterochronic changes.     

Stem cells: cross-talk and developmental programs

The thesis advanced in this essay is that stem cells-particularly those in the nervous system-are components in a series of inborn 'programs' that not only ensure normal development, but persist throughout life so as to maintain homeostasis in the face of perturbations-both small and great. These programs encode what has come to be called 'plasticity'. The stem cell is one of the repositories of this plasticity. This review examines the evidence that interaction between the neural stem cell (as a prototypical somatic stem cell) and the developing or injured brain is a dynamic, complex, ongoing reciprocal set of interactions where both entities are constantly in flux. We suggest that this interaction can be viewed almost from a 'systems biology' vantage point. We further advance the notion that clones of exogenous stem cells in transplantation paradigms may not only be viewed for their therapeutic potential, but also as biological tools for 'interrogating' the normal or abnormal central nervous system environment, indicating what salient cues (among the many present) are actually guiding the expression of these 'programs'; in other words, using the stem cell as a 'reporter cell'. Based on this type of analysis, we suggest some of the relevant molecular pathways responsible for this 'cross-talk' which, in turn, lead to proliferation, migration, cell genesis, trophic support, protection, guidance, detoxification, rescue, etc. This type of developmental insight, we propose, is required for the development of therapeutic strategies for neurodegenerative disease and other nervous system afflictions in humans. Understanding the relevant molecular pathways of stem cell repair phenotype should be a priority, in our view, for the entire stem cell field.     

Patterns of heterochrony in the fossil record

Recent analyses of the fossil record have revealed that heterochrony has played a significant role in the evolution of most marine invertebrate groups. Recognition of several different heterochronic processes has allowed their influence under different ecological regimes to be assessed. Furthermore, recent research has demonstrated significant differences in frequencies of these processes between groups and at their different stages of phylogenetic development. The fossil record shows that heterochron y has been an important component in the generation of evolutionary trends. Heterochrony is an important factor in macroevolution because it can result in relatively abrupt morphological change with only minimum alteration of the genome.     

Cranial modularity and sequence heterochrony in mammals

Heterochrony, the temporal shifting of developmental events relative to each other, requires a degree of autonomy among those processes or structures. Modularity, the division of larger structures or processes into autonomous sets of internally integrated units, is often discussed in relation to the concept of heterochrony. However, the relationship between the developmental modules derived from studies of heterochrony and evolutionary modules, which should be of adaptive importance and relate to the genotype-phenotype map, has not been explicitly studied. I analyzed a series of sectioned and whole cleared-and-stained embryological and neonatal specimens, supplemented with published ontogenetic data, to test the hypothesis that bones within the same phenotypic modules, as determined by morphometric analysis, are developmentally integrated and will display coordinated heterochronic shifts across taxa. Modularity was analyzed in cranial bone ossification sequences of 12 therian mammals. A dataset of 12-18 developmental events was used to assess if modularity in developmental sequences corresponds to six phenotypic modules, derived from a recent morphometric analysis of cranial modularity in mammals. Kendall's tau was used to measure rank correlations, with randomization tests for significance. If modularity in developmental sequences corresponds to observed phenotypic modules, bones within a single phenotypic module should show integration of developmental timing, maintaining the same timing of ossification relative to each other, despite differences in overall ossification sequences across taxa. Analyses did not find any significant conservation of developmental timing within the six phenotypic modules, meaning that bones that are highly integrated in adult morphology are not significantly integrated in developmental timing.     

Estimating evolution of temporal sequence changes: a practical approach to inferring ancestral developmental sequences and sequence heterochrony

Developmental biology often yields data in a temporal context. Temporal data in phylogenetic systematics has important uses in the field of evolutionary developmental biology and, in general, comparative biology. The evolution of temporal sequences, specifically developmental sequences, has proven difficult to examine due to the highly variable temporal progression of development. Issues concerning the analysis of temporal sequences and problems with current methods of analysis are discussed. We present here an algorithm to infer ancestral temporal sequences, quantify sequence heterochronies, and estimate pseudoreplicate consensus support for sequence changes using Parsimov-based genetic inference [PGi]. Real temporal developmental sequence data sets are used to compare PGi with currently used approaches, and PGi is shown to be the most efficient, accurate, and practical method to examine biological data and infer ancestral states on a phylogeny. The method is also expandable to address further issues in developmental evolution, namely modularity.     

Amphibian regeneration and cellular heterochrony

It is posited that the initiating event of amphibian regeneration of a limb, is retrodifferentiation* of what are to become the developing cells of the blastema. These cells reiterate a larval or premetamorphic ontogenic repertoire, induced by elevated levels of prolactin with adequate innervation. Subsequent redifferentiation of the blastema cells occurs, controlled by thyroxine and innervation.This temporal displacement of cellular morphologic characters in regeneration should be looked upon as a function of the ability to reiterate larval characters and subsequently metamorphose. If correct, this would explain why amphibians which metamorphose only once, lose the ability to postmetamorphically regenerate. An exception to this,Xenopus laevis, an anuran which can epimorphically regenerate, to some extent, will be discussed.[/p]     

The significance of muscle cells for the origin of mesoderm in bilateria

Muscle tissue may have played a central role in the early evolutionof mesoderm. The first function of myocytes could have beento control swimming and gliding motion in ciliated vermiformorganisms, as it still is in such present-day basal Bilateriaas the Nemertodermatida. The only mesodermal cells between epidermisand gastrodermis in Nemertodermatida are myocytes, and conceivablythe myocyte was, in fact, the original mesodermal cell type.In Nemertodermatida as well as the Acoela, myocytes are subepithelialfiber-type muscle cells and appear to originate from the gastrodermalepithelium by emigration of single cells. Other mesodermal cellsin the acoels are the peripheral parenchyma (connective tissue)and tunica cells of the gonads, and these also arise from thegastrodermis. Musculature in many of the coelomate protostomesand deuterostomes, on the other hand, is in the form of epitheliomuscular(myoepithelial) cells, and this cell type may also have beenan early form of the mesodermal myocyte. The mesodermal bandsin the small annelid Polygordius and in juvenile enteropneustshave cells intermediate between mesenchymal and epithelial intheir histological organization as they develop into myoepithelia.If acoelomates were derived from coelomates by progenesis, thenthe fiber-type muscles of acoelomates could be products of foreshorteneddifferentiation of such tissue. The precise serial patterningof circular muscle cells along the anterior-posterior axis duringembryonic development in the acoel Convoluta pulchra providesa model for early steps in the gradual evolution of segmentationfrom iterated organ systems.     

Paedomorphosis and heterochrony in the origin and evolution of the class holothuroidea

The role of paedomorphosis as a particular case of heterochrony in the origin and evolution of the class Holothuroidea is analyzed. It is shown that holothurians are characterized by the presence of some paedomorphic characters (reduced skeleton, absence of an axial complex in the shape of a morphologically integrated structure, single gonad with one gonopore). In many members of the subclass Holothuriacea, sclerites of the body wall are arranged in two layers. Sclerites of the deeper layer develop as a perforated plate and correspond to the skeletal elements forming in other echinoderms the body skeleton, for example, the test of sea urchins. Sclerites of the superficial layer frequently look like various tables, develop like spines of other echinoderm classes, in particular, juvenile tetraradiate spines of sea urchins, and correspond to spines of other classes of Echinodermata. Ontogenetic changes at the stage of five first tentacles resulted in interruption at an early stage of the development with the catastrophic metamorphosis, which is typical for other Eleutherozoa. The ontogeny of holothurians acquired the evolutive (gradual) character; the adult body began to develop on the basis of the larval body and larval tissues were partially included in the body of adult holothurians. As a result, the place and developmental pattern of the radial complex of organs changed and heterochrony in the development of characters concerned with different coordination chains intensified; therefore, the modern body plan of holothurians was formed. The processes of paedomorphosis and heterochrony played an important role not only in the origin and formation of the class Holothuroidea, but also during its evolution. Paedomorphic processes became rather important in the evolution of the order Synaptida. Paedomorphic features are particularly prominent in the structure of small interstitial forms. In some holothurians, the paedomorphosis resulted in the change in relationships between symmetry planes. The bilateral plane of symmetry of these holothurians coincide with the plane of symmetry 2–1–2, which is positioned in the majority of holothurians at about 72° to the bilateral plane. Independently, but frequently in parallel, the intestinal loop disappeared, so that the gut became straight and suspended on mediodorsal mesentery almost throughout its extent. The combination of these processes in holothurians of the order Synaptida resulted in the formation of almost complete pentaradially bilateral symmetry.     

The embryonic moult in diplogastrids (Nematoda) - homology of developmental stages and heterochrony as a prerequisite for morphological diversity

Video analysis of developing eggs showed that diplogastrids, in contrast to the majority of nematodes, moult from J1 to J2 before they hatch from the egg. This embryonic moult leads to a conflict between the terminology for the J1-J4 postembryonic stages and the definition for the embryonic period that ranges from fertilization to hatching. The nature of developmental stages is discussed on the occasion of this terminological problem. Stages as “embryo”, J1, J2,… are defined as periods of time between certain developmental events and are called instars, whereas other stages as “tadpole stage” refer to characters. Character-defined stages refer to the temporal aspect of developmental characters. Only character-defined stages can be homologized between species. It is proposed to ignore the conflict of the J1-J4 terminology with the embryonic-postembryonic dichotomy as an embryonic stage cannot be satisfyingly defined. The biological relevance of the heterochronic shift of the first moult into the egg period is the possibility to omit secretion of the J1 stoma and pharynx cuticle as the diplogastrid J1 does not feed. Thereby the time slot for stoma morphogenesis that must be finished before cuticle deposition is prolonged. Within Diplogastridae this time slot facilitated the evolution of a tremendous diversity of complex stoma morphologies that is unique within “Rhabditida”.