Deep-etch visualization of 27S clathrin: a tetrahedral tetramer

It has recently been reported that 8S clathrin trimers or "triskelions" form larger 27S oligomers upon dialysis into low ionic strength buffers (Prasad, K., R. E. Lippoldt, H. Edelhoch, and M. S. Lewis, 1986, Biochemistry, 25:5214-5219). Here, deep-etch electron microscopy of the 27S species reveals that they are closed tetrahedra composed of four clathrin triskelions. This was determined by two approaches. First, standard quick-freezing and freeze-etching of unfixed 27S species suspended in 2 mM 2-(N-morpholino)ethane sulfonic acid (MES) buffer, pH 5.9, yielded unambiguous images of tetrahedra that measured 33 nm on each edge. Second, the technique of freeze-drying molecules on mica (Heuser, J. E., 1983, J. Mol. Biol., 169:155-195) was modified to overcome the low affinity of mica in 2 mM MES, by pretreating the mica with polylysine. Thereafter, 27S species adsorbed avidly to it and collapsed into characteristic configurations containing four globular domains, each linked to the others by three approximately 33-nm struts. The globular domains look like vertices of deep-etched clathrin triskelions and the links, numbering 12 in all, look like four sets of triskelion legs. New light scattering and equilibrium centrifugation data confirm that 27S polymer is four times as massive as one clathrin triskelion. We conclude that in conditions that do not favor the formation of standard clathrin cages, low affinity interactions lead to closed, symmetrical assemblies of four triskelions, each of which assumes a unique puckered, straight-legged configuration to create the edges of a tetrahedron. Tetrahedra are similar in construction to the cubic octomers of clathrin recently found in ammonium sulfate solutions (Sorger, P. K., R. A. Crowther, J. T. Finch, and B. M. F. Pearse, 1986, J. Cell Biol., 103:1213-1219) but are still smaller, involving only half as many clathrin triskelions.     

Human erythrocyte clathrin and clathrin-uncoating protein

Clathrin, a Mr = 72,000 clathrin-associated protein, and myosin were purified in milligram quantities from the same erythrocyte hemolysate fraction. Erythrocyte clathrin closely resembled brain clathrin in several respects: (a) both are triskelions as visualized by electron microscopy with arms 40 nm in length with globular ends and a flexible hinge region in the middle of each arm, and these triskelions assemble into polyhedral "cages" at appropriate pH and ionic strength; (b) both molecules contain heavy chains of Mr = 170,000 that are indistinguishable by two-dimensional maps of 125I-labeled peptides; and (c) both molecules contain light chains of Mr approximately 40,000 in a 1:1 molar ratio with the heavy chain. Erythrocyte clathrin is not identical to brain clathrin since antibody raised against the erythrocyte protein reacts better with erythrocyte clathrin than with brain clathrin and since brain clathrin contains two light chains resolved on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels while the light chain of erythrocyte clathrin migrates as a single band. The erythrocyte Mr = 72,000 clathrin-associated protein is closely related to a protein in brain that mediates ATP-dependent disassembly of clathrin from coated vesicles and binds tightly to clathrin triskelions (Schlossman, D. M., Schmid, S. L., Braell, W. A., and Rothman, J. E. (1984) J. Cell Biol. 99, 723-733). The erythrocyte and brain proteins have identical Mr on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels and identical maps of 125I-labeled peptides, share antigenic sites, and bind tightly to ATP immobilized on agarose. Clathrin and the uncoating protein are not restricted to reticulocytes since equivalent amounts of these proteins are present in whole erythrocyte populations and reticulocyte-depleted erythrocytes. Clathrin is present at 6,000 triskelions/cells, while the uncoating protein is in substantial excess at 250,000 copies/cell.     

Two classes of binding sites for uncoating protein in clathrin triskelions

Clathrin released from coated vesicles or empty cages by the ATP-dependent action of uncoating protein exists as a complex with the uncoating protein. Despite its apparent consumption during a round of uncoating, we have found that uncoating protein functions as an enzyme in that it rapidly and spontaneously recycles from its product (triskelions) to its substrate (cages). The binding of uncoating protein to clathrin triskelions is a complex equilibrium that involves the interaction of uncoating protein with at least two distinct sites on the clathrin molecule. Limited proteolysis dissected clathrin into two domains, each of which contained distinct binding sites. Binding to one of these sites, located on the proximal leg of a triskelion, was dependent upon the presence of light chains and was unstable to gel filtration. Binding to the second kind of site, located on the distal portion of a triskelion leg, was stable to gel filtration and was independent of the presence of light chains.     

Purification of Clathrin Heavy and Light Chain fromDictyostelium discoideum

Clathrin, a protein important for endocytosis, is a hexamer composed of three heavy chains and three light chains. We report here the purification scheme used to isolate the clathrin protein from the simple eukaryote,Dictyostelium discoideum.Using a combination of differential centrifugation and column chromatography, we isolated ∼2 mg of clathrin triskelions from 150–200 g ofDictyosteliumcells. One additional step purified the 30-kDa clathrin light chain to homogeneity. Glycerol gradient centrifugation was used to determine anSvalue of 7.9 for purified clathrin. Rotary shadowed images ofDictyosteliumclathrin revealed trimeric molecules with extended legs measuring 48 ± 5 nm, similar in length to the legs of mammalian and yeast clathrin triskelions. The single clathrin light chain proved resistant to heat treatment, a property also similar to light chains from other species. The conservation of these physical properties inDictyosteliumclathrin demonstrates the potential of this model organism for the study of clathrin structure and function.     

Enzymatic dissociation of clathrin cages in a two-stage process

Uncoating ATPase catalyzes the ATP-dependent dissociation of clathrin from coated vesicles and empty cages. Following an uncoating reaction, clathrin triskelions are released intact, in a stoichiometric complex with bound uncoating protein. This overall uncoating process was dissected into two partial reactions. In the first, ATP hydrolysis drives the transient displacement of a portion of a triskelion from a cage. Uncoating protein then captures the displaced triskelion, in the second stage, by binding to a newly exposed site on clathrin that had previously been buried in the cage lattice. Triskelion-uncoating protein complexes are released when all points of attachment of the triskelion to the cage have been severed. The uncoating protein interacts with a distinct site on clathrin for each of these reactions.     

The association of clathrin fragments with coated vesicle membranes

The association between clathrin triskelions and the clathrin-stripped membranes of coated vesicles has been investigated using a filter assay to separate bound from unbound clathrin. The filter assay is more sensitive and less cumbersome than a sedimentation assay used previously (1). While confirming the high affinity interaction between clathrin and the vesicle membrane, our results yield Scatchard plots that are curvilinear and consistent with a positively cooperative interaction between clathrin and the vesicle membranes. Controlled digestion with trypsin removes the distal portions of the triskelion legs leaving the proximal 31 nm portions that form the hub of the triskelions. These hubs are trimers of large 112,000- and 124,000-dalton fragments of clathrin heavy chains. They competitively inhibit the binding of 125I-labeled intact triskelions to stripped vesicles with a KI identical to the KD for the association of 125I-labeled intact triskelions to stripped vesicles. Furthermore, these large fragment trimers bind to stripped vesicles with approximately the same high affinity as do intact triskelions and also show evidence of a positively cooperative interaction. It is concluded that clathrin binds to coated vesicles by an interaction that is mediated by the proximal 112,000-dalton fragment of the clathrin heavy chains.     

An enzyme that removes clathrin coats: purification of an uncoating ATPase

Uncoating ATPase, an abundant 70,000-mol-wt polypeptide mediating the ATP-dependent dissociation of clathrin from coated vesicles and empty clathrin cages, has been purified to virtual homogeneity from calf brain cytosol. Uncoating protein is present in cells in amounts roughly stoichiometric with clathrin. This enzyme is isolated as a mixture of monomers and dimers, both forms being active. ATP can support protein-facilitated dissociation of clathrin at micromolar levels; all other ribotriphosphates as well as deoxy-ATP are inactive. The clathrin that is released from cages consists of trimers (triskelions) in a stoichiometric complex with uncoating ATPase. These complexes with clathrin have little tendency to self-associate at neutral pH, and at acidic pH they interfere with the assembly of free clathrin. The possible existence and function of these complexes as clathrin carriers in cells would explain why uncoating protein is made in quantities equivalent to clathrin.     

ATP catalyzes the sequestration of clathrin during enzymatic uncoating

ATP facilitates the sequestration of displaced triskelions by uncoating protein. In so doing, ATP is not hydrolyzed; nor does the concentration of ATP affect the equilibrium of this binding. However, the rates of both the binding of uncoating protein to clathrin and of their dissociation are greatly accelerated by ATP. These properties suggest that ATP acts catalytically to speed the capture of displaced triskelions by uncoating protein, as well as stoichiometrically in its hydrolysis to drive the displacement of triskelions from cages. The nucleotide specificity of this "catalytic" site for ATP on the uncoating protein is much less strict than that of the distinct "hydrolytic" site that drives the ATP-dependent displacement of triskelions from cages.     

Image averaging of flexible fibrous macromolecules: the clathrin triskelion has an elastic proximal segment.

We have developed computational techniques that allow image averaging to be applied to electron micrographs of filamentous molecules that exhibit tight and variable curvature. These techniques, which involve straightening by cubic-spline interpolation, image classification, and statistical analysis of the molecules' curvature properties, have been applied to purified brain clathrin. This trimeric filamentous protein polymerizes, both in vivo and in vitro, into a wide range of polyhedral structures. Contrasted by low-angle rotary shadowing, dissociated clathrin molecules appear as distinctive three-legged structures, called "triskelions" (E. Ungewickell and D. Branton (1981) Nature 289, 420). We find triskelion legs to vary from 35 to 62 nm in total length, according to an approximately bell-shaped distribution (mu = 51.6 nm). Peaks in averaged curvature profiles mark hinges or sites of enhanced flexibility. Such profiles, calculated for each length class, show that triskelion legs are flexible over their entire lengths. However, three curvature peaks are observed in every case: their locations define a proximal segment of systematically increasing length (14.0-19.0 nm), a mid-segment of fixed length (approximately 12 nm), and a rather variable end-segment (11.6-19.5 nm), terminating in a hinge just before the globular terminal domain (approximately 7.3 nm diameter). Thus, two major factors contribute to the overall variability in leg length: (1) stretching of the proximal segment and (2) stretching of the end-segment and/or scrolling of the terminal domain. The observed elasticity of the proximal segment may reflect phosphorylation of the clathrin light chains.     

Clathrin coats at 21 A resolution: a cellular assembly designed to recycle multiple membrane receptors.

We present a map at 21 A resolution of clathrin assembled into cages with the endocytic adaptor complex, AP-2. The map was obtained by cryo-electron microscopy and single-particle reconstruction. It reveals details of the packing of entire clathrin molecules as they interact to form a cage with two nested polyhedral layers. The proximal domains of each triskelion leg depart from a cage vertex in a skewed orientation, forming a slightly twisted bundle with three other leg domains. Thus, each triskelion contributes to two connecting edges of the polyhedral cage. The clathrin heavy chains continue inwards under the vertices with local 3-fold symmetry, the terminal domains contributing to 'hook-like' features which form an intermediate network making possible contacts with the surface presented by the inner adaptor shell. A node of density projecting inwards from the vertex may correspond to the C-termini of clathrin heavy chains which form a protrusion on free triskelions at the vertex. The inter-subunit interactions visible in this map provide a structural basis for considering the assembly of clathrin coats on a membrane and show the contacts which will need to be disrupted during disassembly.     

Biochemical and immunological studies on clathrin light chains and their binding sites on clathrin triskelions

Clathrin light chains from bovine brain tissue (LC alpha and LC beta) are monomeric proteins with an average mol. wt. of approximately 33,000, as determined by sedimentation equilibrium. Solution studies on purified light chains indicate a large Stokes radius (Re = 3.3 nm) and little defined secondary structure. Both light chains bind specifically and with high affinity (KA approximately 5 x 10(7)/M) to overlapping sites on clathrin heavy chains. These binding sites are contained within a 125,000 dalton heavy chain fragment that forms truncated triskelions with legs, 15 nm shorter than those of intact triskelions. As judged by immuno-electron microscopy, light chain-specific IgG molecules bind mostly to the center of triskelions, but there are also sites that are scattered some 16 nm along the proximal part of triskelion legs. From heterologous binding experiments using human placenta light chains and heavy chain fragments from bovine brain clathrin, it is concluded that the domains of light and heavy chains that are involved in the interaction are conserved across tissue and species boundaries.     

Assembly and packing of clathrin into coats

We present a model for the packing of clathrin molecules into the characteristic hexagons and pentagons covering coated pits and vesicles. The assembly unit is a symmetrical trimer with three extended legs. Polymerization of these units occurs in seconds under suitable conditions, giving empty polyhedral cages resembling the structures around coated vesicles. Images of small, negatively stained fragments of cages, assembled directly on electron microscope grids, reveal details of the structure, which correlate well with the predicted features of the model. There is one clathrin trimer at each polyhedral vertex, and each leg of the trimer extends along two neighboring polyhedral edges. Quasi-equivalent packing in pentagons and hexagons in polyhedra of different sizes requires a variable joint at the vertex of the molecule and a hinge in each leg. The construction of clathrin coats is remarkable for the extended fibrous contacts that each molecule makes with many others. Such contacts may confer mechanical strength combined with flexibility needed when a vesicle is pinched off from the membrane.     

Conformation of a clathrin triskelion in solution

A principal component in the protein coats of certain post-golgi and endocytic vesicles is clathrin, which appears as a three-legged heteropolymer (known as a triskelion) that assembles into polyhedral cages principally made up of pentagonal and hexagonal faces. In vitro, this assembly depends upon the pH, with cages forming more readily at low pH and less readily at high pH. We have developed procedures, on the basis of static and dynamic light scattering, to determine the radius of gyration, R(g), and hydrodynamic radius, R(H), of isolated triskelia, under conditions where cage assembly occurs. Calculations based on rigid molecular bead models of a triskelion show that the measured values can be accounted for by bending the legs and a puckering at the vertex. We also show that the values of R(g) and R(H) measured for clathrin triskelia in solution are qualitatively consistent with the conformation of a triskelion in a "D6 barrel" cage assembly measured by cryoelectron microscopy.     

Purification and characterization of two distinct complexes of assembly polypeptides from calf brain coated vesicles that differ in their polypeptide composition and kinase activities

The binding and assembly of clathrin triskelions on vesicle membranes seem to be mediated by certain assembly polypeptides (Keen, J.H., Willingham, M.C., and Pastau, I.H. (1979) Cell 16, 303-312). These assembly polypeptides were further purified into two distinct complexes using hydroxylapatite chromatography. Peak 1 consists of two major bands of 98 and 112 kDa, two minor bands of 103 and 118 kDa, and a polypeptide of 46 kDa. Peak 2 consists of one major band of 100 kDa, two minor bands of 103 and 115 kDa, and a polypeptide of 50 kDa. Both complexes have a native molecular mass of 290 kDa as determined by gel filtration. Each 290-kDa complex contains two polypeptides of 98-118/100-115 kDa and two polypeptides of 46/50 kDa. The 46-kDa polypeptide is not phosphorylated, whereas the 50-kDa polypeptide is. Both peaks contain 50-kDa kinase-like activity. Time courses of the 50-kDa phosphorylation show that the activity in peak 1 saturates much faster than the activity in peak 2; there may be two 50-kDa kinase activities in coated vesicles. A kinase that phosphorylates the polypeptides in 98-118-kDa group is present in peak 1 but not in peak 2. Both peaks assemble clathrin triskelions into cages under conditions in which the clathrin alone would not assemble. Both rotary shadowed and negatively stained preparations of these reassembled cages as well as the purified complexes were examined by electron microscopy. Thus, two complexes have been identified that differ in their polypeptide composition and kinase activities, but are similar in their ability to assemble clathrin triskelions into cages.     

Functional organization of clathrin in coats: combining electron cryomicroscopy and X-ray crystallography.

The sorting of specific proteins into clathrin-coated pits and the mechanics of membrane invagination are determined by assembly of the clathrin lattice. Recent structures of a six-fold barrel clathrin coat at 21 A resolution by electron cryomicroscopy and of the clathrin terminal domain and linker at 2.6 A by X-ray crystallography together show how domains of clathrin interact and orient within the coat and reveal the strongly puckered shape and conformational variability of individual triskelions. The beta propeller of the terminal domain faces the membrane so that recognition segments from adaptor proteins can extend along its lateral grooves. Clathrin legs adapt to different coat environments in the barrel by flexing along a segment at the knee that is free of contacts with other molecules.     

THE CONFORMATION OF CLATHRIN LIGHT-CHAINS ON TRISKELIONS PROBED BY ANTIBODY INHIBITION

The conformation of clathrin light-chains along the proximal arm of the clathrin triskelion was studied by using rabbit anti-(light-chain peptides) to inhibit the binding of a mouse monoclonal antibody against an epitope in the amino-terminal region. Prior incubation of triskelions with rabbit antisera raised against the extreme carboxyl-terminal of the light-chains partially inhibited binding. The inhibition was largely removed when tested on light-chains that had been freed from triskelions. This suggests that when the light-chains bind the heavy-chain, they adopt a conformation in which the amino and carboxyl-terminal domains are not fully extended, but fold such that these two domains face each other.     

Clathrin exchange during clathrin-mediated endocytosis

During clathrin-mediated endocytosis, clathrin-coated pits invaginate to form clathrin-coated vesicles (CVs). Since clathrin-coated pits are planar structures, whereas CVs are spherical, there must be a structural rearrangement of clathrin as invagination occurs. This could occur through simple addition of clathrin triskelions to the edges of growing clathrin-coated pits with very little exchange occurring between clathrin in the pits and free clathrin in the cytosol, or it could occur through large scale exchange of free and bound clathrin. In the present study, we investigated this question by studying clathrin exchange both in vitro and in vivo. We found that in vitro clathrin in CVs and clathrin baskets do not exchange with free clathrin even in the presence of Hsc70 and ATP where partial uncoating occurs. However, surprisingly FRAP studies on clathrin-coated pits labeled with green fluorescent protein-clathrin light chains in HeLa cells show that even when endocytosis is blocked by expression of a dynamin mutant or depletion of cholesterol from the membrane, replacement of photobleached clathrin in coated pits on the membrane occurs at almost the same rate and magnitude as when endocytosis is occurring. Furthermore, very little of this replacement is due to dissolution of old pits and reformation of new ones; rather, it is caused by a rapid ATP-dependent exchange of clathrin in the pits with free clathrin in the cytosol. On the other hand, consistent with the in vitro data both potassium depletion and hypertonic sucrose, which have been reported to transform clathrin-coated pits into clathrin cages just below the surface of the plasma membrane, not only block endocytosis but also block exchange of clathrin. Taken together, these data show that ATP-dependent exchange of free and bound clathrin is a fundamental property of clathrin-coated pits, but not clathrin baskets, and may be involved in a structural rearrangement of clathrin as clathrin-coated pits invaginate.     

Architecture of Clathrin Fullerene Cages Reflects a Geometric Constraint—the Head-to-Tail Exclusion Rule—and a Preference for Asymmetry

Fullerene cages have n trivalent vertices, 12 pentagonal faces, and (n - 20)/2 hexagonal faces. The smallest cage in which all of the pentagons are surrounded by hexagons and thus isolated from each other has 60 vertices and is shaped like a soccer ball. The protein clathrin self-assembles into fullerene cages of a variety of sizes and shapes, including smaller ones with adjacent pentagons as well as larger ones, but the variety is limited. To explain the range of clathrin architecture and how these fullerene cages self-assemble, we proposed a hypothesis, the “head-to-tail exclusion rule” (the “Rule”). Of the 5769 small clathrin cage isomers with n ≤ 60 vertices and adjacent pentagons, the Rule permits just 15, three identified in 1976 and 12 others. A “weak version” of the Rule permits another 99. Based on cryo-electron tomography, Cheng et al. reported six raw clathrin fullerene cages. One was among the three identified in 1976. Here, (1) we identify the remaining five. (2) Four are new and are among the 12 others permitted by the Rule. (3) One, also new, is among the 99 weak version cages. (4) Of particular note, none of the remaining 5565 excluded cages has been identified. These findings provide powerful experimental confirmation of the Rule and the principle on which it is based. (5) Surprisingly, the newly identified clathrin cages are among the least symmetric of those permitted. (6) By devising a method for counting assembly paths, (7) we show that asymmetric cages can be assembled by larger numbers of paths, thus providing a kinetic explanation for the prevalence of asymmetric cages. (8) Finally, we show that operation during cage growth of the Rule greatly increases the likelihood of producing a closed fullerene cage, specifically one of those permitted, but efficient assembly still appears to require internal remodeling.     

A motif in the clathrin heavy chain required for the Hsc70/auxilin uncoating reaction

The 70-kDa heat-shock cognate protein (Hsc70) chaperone is an ATP-dependent "disassembly enzyme" for many subcellular structures, including clathrin-coated vesicles where it functions as an uncoating ATPase. Hsc70, and its cochaperone auxilin together catalyze coat disassembly. Like other members of the Hsp70 chaperone family, it is thought that ATP-bound Hsc70 recognizes the clathrin triskelion through an unfolded exposed hydrophobic segment. The best candidate is the unstructured C terminus (residues 1631-1675) of the heavy chain at the foot of the tripod below the hub, containing the sequence motif QLMLT, closely related to the sequence bound preferentially by the substrate groove of Hsc70 (Fotin et al., 2004b). To test this hypothesis, we generated in insect cells recombinant mammalian triskelions that in vitro form clathrin cages and clathrin/AP-2 coats exactly like those assembled from native clathrin. We show that coats assembled from recombinant clathrin are good substrates for ATP- and auxilin-dependent, Hsc70-catalyzed uncoating. Finally, we show that this uncoating reaction proceeds normally when the coats contain recombinant heavy chains truncated C-terminal to the QLMLT motif, but very inefficiently when the motif is absent. Thus, the QLMLT motif is required for Hsc-70-facilitated uncoating, consistent with the proposal that this sequence is a specific target of the chaperone.     

Model for transformations of the clathrin lattice in the coated vesicle pathway

Transport of receptors by the coated vesicle pathway entails assembly of clathrin triskelions into a lattice in conjunction with receptors in a membrane. The processes by which the receptors are concentrated, the lattice is assembled, transformed into a cage during vesiculation, and subsequently removed from pinched off vesicles are not understood in regard to mechanism, energetics or control. Tubulin and actin assembly are looked to for analogies applicable to clathrin. The present model supposes that clathrin assembly is energy linked and can be described by kinetic equations of the same general form as those for treadmilling in linear polymers. The coat lattice assembles in a steady state involving the degradation of a high energy form of the clathrin triskelions. Diffuse endocytosis receptors are assumed to be associated with individual triskelions and to be able to trigger clustering and coated pit formation by influencing the assembly kinetics of the bound triskelions. A generalization of the treadmilling scheme is proposed by which the kinetic parameters associated with clathrin polymerization can shift simultaneously for an entire lattice to favor alternatively net assembly or disassembly. This shift is effected by a coordinated conversion of the lattice bound receptors. The conversion of the receptors in turn depends on some global property of the membrane compartments (arguably pH, calcium concentration or transmembrane voltage) which is likely to change as a consequence of vesiculation. Thereby, lattice disassembly can be coordinated with the topological conversion from coated pit to coated vesicle.