The Switch that Does Not Flip: The Blue-Light Receptor YtvA from Bacillus subtilis Adopts an Elongated Dimer Conformation Independent of the Activation State as Revealed by a Combined AUC and SAXS Study

Photoreceptors play an important role in plants and bacteria by converting extracellular stimuli into intracellular signals. One distinct class are the blue-light-sensitive phototropins harboring a light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domain coupled to various effector domains. Photon absorption by the chromophore within the LOV domain results in an activation of the output domain via mechanisms that are hitherto not well understood. The photoreceptor YtvA from Bacillus subtilis is a bacterial analog of phototropins, consists of an LOV and a sulfate transporter/anti-sigma factor antagonist domain, and is involved in the response of the bacterium to environmental stress. We present here analytical ultracentrifugation studies and small-angle X-ray scattering experiments, showing that YtvA is a dimer. On the basis of these results, we present a low-resolution model of the dimer in the dark and the lit state of the protein. In addition, we show that YtvA does not change its oligomerization state or its overall shape upon light activation.     

Enhancement of a sigma(B)-dependent stress response in Bacillus subtilis by light via YtvA photoreceptor

YtvA of Bacillus subtilis consists of light, oxygen or voltage (LOV) domain and sulfate transporter and anti-sigma antagonist (STAS) domain, and was reported to act as a photoreceptor, sensing light signals through the LOV domain, like a plant blue light receptor, phototropin. At the same time, YtvA was reported to act as a positive regulator for stress responsive-gene expression regulated by sigma(B) factor. Here we indicate that, like phototropins, the conserved Cys residue among the LOV domains is required for light-sensing in YtvA in vitro, possibly by the photoadduct formation, and YtvA forms a homodimer via its LOV domain, independently to light signal. We also indicate that, when ytvA expression is in normal level, light itself does not trigger sigma(B) activation, but a photo-enhancement of sigma(B) activity, activated by salt stress, occurs only in the presence of ytvA. The conserved Cys residue in the LOV domain and the STAS domain seem to be responsible for light-sensing and signal-transmission to the sigma(B) regulatory network, respectively.     

Conformational analysis of the blue-light sensing protein YtvA reveals a competitive interface for LOV-LOV dimerization and interdomain interactions.

The Bacillus subtilis protein YtvA is related to plant phototropins in that it senses UVA-blue-light by means of the flavin binding LOV domain, linked to a nucleotide-binding STAS domain. The structural basis for interdomain interactions and functional regulation are not known. Here we report the conformational analysis of three YtvA constructs, by means of size exclusion chromatography, circular dichroism (CD) and molecular docking simulations. The isolated YtvA-LOV domain (YLOV, aa 25-126) has a strong tendency to dimerize, prevented in full-length YtvA, but still observed in YLOV carrying the N-terminal extension (N-YLOV, aa 1-126). The analysis of CD data shows that both the N-terminal cap and the linker region (aa 127-147) between the LOV and the STAS domain are helical and that the central beta-scaffold is distorted in the LOV domains dimers. The involvement of the central beta-scaffold in dimerization is supported by docking simulation of the YLOV dimer and the importance of this region is highlighted by light-induced conformational changes, emerging from the CD data analysis. In YtvA, the beta-strand fraction is notably less distorted and distinct light-driven changes in the loops/turn fraction are detected. The data uncover a common surface for LOV-LOV and intraprotein interaction, involving the central beta-scaffold, and offer hints to investigate the molecular basis of light-activation and regulation in LOV proteins.     

The photocycle of a flavin-binding domain of the blue light photoreceptor phototropin.

The plant blue light receptor, phot1, a member of the phototropin family, is a plasma membrane-associated flavoprotein that contains two ( approximately 110 amino acids) flavin-binding domains, LOV1 and LOV2, within its N terminus and a typical serine-threonine protein kinase domain at its C terminus. The LOV (light, oxygen, and voltage) domains belong to the PAS domain superfamily of sensor proteins. In response to blue light, phototropins undergo autophosphorylation. E. coli-expressed LOV domains bind riboflavin-5'-monophosphate, are photochemically active, and have major absorption peaks at 360 and 450 nm, with the 450 nm peak having vibronic structure at 425 and 475 nm. These spectral features correspond to the action spectrum for phototropism in higher plants. Blue light excitation of the LOV2 domain generates, in less than 30 ns, a transient approximately 660 nm-absorbing species that spectroscopically resembles a flavin triplet state. This putative triplet state subsequently decays with a 4-micros time constant into a 390 nm-absorbing metastable form. The LOV2 domain (450 nm) recovers spontaneously with half-times of approximately 50 s. It has been shown that the metastable species is likely a flavin-cysteine (Cys(39) thiol) adduct at the flavin C(4a) position. A LOV2C39A mutant generates the early photoproduct but not the adduct. Titrations of LOV2 using chromophore fluorescence as an indicator suggest that Cys(39) exists as a thiolate.     

A critical element of the light‐induced quaternary structural changes in YtvA‐LOV

YtvA, a photosensory LOV (light‐oxygen‐voltage) protein from Bacillus subtilis, exists as a dimer that previously appeared to undergo surprisingly small structural changes after light illumination compared with other light‐sensing proteins. However, we now report that light induces significant structural perturbations in a series of YtvA‐LOV domain derivatives in which the Jα helix has been truncated or replaced. Results from native gel analysis showed significant mobility changes in these derivatives after light illumination; YtvA‐LOV without the Jα helix dimerized in the dark state but existed as a monomer in the light state. The absence of the Jα helix also affected the dark regeneration kinetics and the stability of the flavin mononucleotide (FMN) binding to its binding site. Our results demonstrate an alternative way of photo‐induced signal propagation that leads to a bigger functional response through dimer/monomer conversions of the YtvA‐LOV than the local disruption of Jα helix in the As‐LOV domain.     

The β-scaffold of the LOV domain of the Brucella light-activated histidine kinase is a key element for signal transduction

Light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domains are blue-light-activated signaling modules present in a wide range of sensory proteins. Among them, the histidine kinases are the largest group in prokaryotes (LOV-HK). Light modulates the virulence of the pathogenic bacteria Brucella abortus through LOV-HK. One of the striking characteristic of Brucella LOV-HK is the fact that the protein remains activated upon light sensing, without recovering the basal state in the darkness. In contrast, the light state of the isolated LOV domain slowly returns to the dark state. To gain insight into the light activation mechanism, we have characterized by X-ray crystallography and solution NMR spectroscopy the structure of the LOV domain of LOV-HK in the dark state and explored its light-induced conformational changes. The LOV domain adopts the α/β PAS (PER-ARNT-SIM) domain fold and binds the FMN cofactor within a conserved pocket. The domain dimerizes through the hydrophobic β-scaffold in an antiparallel way. Our results point to the β-scaffold as a key element in the light activation, validating a conserved structural basis for light-to-signal propagation in LOV proteins.     

NTP-binding properties of the blue-light receptor YtvA and effects of the E105L mutation

YtvA is a blue-light-sensing protein from Bacillus subtilis related to plant phototropins. It carries a LOV (light, oxygen and voltage) domain, binding FMN (flavin mononucleotide) as chromophore, and a STAS (sulphate transporters and antisigma-factor antagonists) domain with poorly characterized function. We have recently shown that YtvA binds triphosphate nucleotides (NTP) and highlighted a structural similarity between the STAS domain and small GTP-binding proteins. In this work we further investigated the NTP-binding properties of YtvA, employing a fluorescent derivative of GTP (GTP_TR) and mutagenesis experiments. The main results are as follows: (a) competition experiments indicate that the affinity of YtvA for GTP is much higher than that for GDP and GMP. (b) Blue-light-induced structural changes are transmitted from the LOV core to the NTP-binding cavity, establishing a possible intraprotein signal-transduction pathway. (c) A mutation in the central β-scaffold of the LOV core, E105L, impairs the light-driven spectroscopic changes of bound GTP_TR. This result is supported by circular dichroism data, in that YtvA-E105L does not show the light-induced conformational change in the turn fraction that characterizes YtvA, implying that E105 is functionally important. (d) In the structural model of the LOV-STAS complex, based on docking algorithms, the interface includes the Iβ–Hβ loop on the LOV core, as well as parts of the central β-scaffold. E105 is predicted to interact with the LOV-STAS linker region, suggested to play a role in phototropin signaling. Proceedings of the XVIII Congress of the Italian Society of Pure and Applied Biophysics (SIBPA), Palermo, Sicily, September 2006.     

Photochemical and mutational analysis of the FMN-binding domains of the plant blue light receptor, phototropin

The plant photoreceptor phototropin is an autophosphorylating serine-threonine protein kinase activated by UV-A/blue light. Two domains, LOV1 and LOV2, members of the PAS domain superfamily, mediate light sensing by phototropin. Heterologous expression studies have shown that both domains function as FMN-binding sites. Although three plant blue light photoreceptors, cry1, cry2, and phototropin, have been identified to date, the photochemical reactions underlying photoactivation of these light sensors have not been described so far. Herein, we demonstrate that the LOV domains of Avena sativa phototropin undergo a self-contained photocycle characterized by a loss of blue light absorbance in response to light and a spontaneous recovery of the blue light-absorbing form in the dark. Rate constants and quantum efficiencies for the photoreactions indicate that LOV1 exhibits a lower photosensitivity than LOV2. The spectral properties of the photoproduct produced for both LOV domains are unrelated to those found for photoreduced flavins and flavoproteins, but are consistent with those of a flavin-cysteinyl adduct. Flavin-thiol adducts are generally short-lifetime reaction intermediates formed during the flavoprotein-catalyzed reduction of protein disulfides. By site-directed mutagenesis, we have identified several amino acid residues within the putative chromophore binding site of LOV1 and LOV2 that appear to be important for FMN binding and/or the photochemical reactivity. Among those is Cys39, which plays an important role in the photochemical reaction of the LOV domains. Replacement of Cys39 with Ala abolished the photochemical reactions of both LOV domains. We therefore propose that light sensing by the phototropin LOV domains occurs via the formation of a stable adduct between the FMN chromophore and Cys39.     

Phototropins and Their LOV Domains：Versatile Plant Blue-Light Receptors

The phototropins phot1 and phot2 are plant blue-light receptors that mediate phototropism, chloroplast movements, stomatal opening, leaf expansion, the rapid Inhibition of hypocotyl growth in etiolated seedlings, and possibly solar tracking by leaves in those species in which It occurs. The phototroplns are plasma membrane-associated hydrophilic proteins with two chromophore domains （designated LOV1 and LOV2 for their resemblance to domains In other signaling proteins that detect light, oxygen, or voltage） in their Nterminal half and a classic serine/threonlne kinase domain in their C-terminal half. Both chromophore domains bind flavin mononucleotide （FMN） and both undergo light-activated formation of a covalent bond between a nearby cystelne and the C（4a） carbon of the FMN to form the signaling state. LOV2-cystelnyl adduct formation leads to the release downstream of a tightly bound amphlpathlc α-helix, a step required for activation of the klnase function. This cysteinyl adduct then slowly decays over a matter of seconds or minutes to return the photoreceptor chromophore modules to their ground state. Functional LOV2 is required for light-activated phosphorylation and for various blue-light responses mediated by the phototroplns. The function of LOV1 is still unknown, although It may serve to modulate the signal generated by LOV2. The LOV domain Is an ancient chromophore module found In a wide range of otherwise unrelated proteins In fungi and prokaryotes, the latter Including cyanobacterla, eubacterla, and archaea. Further general reviews on the phototropins are those by Celaya and Liscum （2005） and Christie and Briggs （2005）.     

PAS/LOV proteins: A proposed new class of plant blue light receptor

The light, oxygen or voltage (LOV) domain belongs to the Per-ARNT-Sim (PAS) superfamily of domains, and functions with the flavin chromophore as a module for sensing blue light in plants and fungi. The Arabidopsis thaliana PAS/LOV proteins (PLPs), of unknown function, possess an N-terminal PAS domain and a C-terminal LOV domain. Our recent analysis using yeast two-hybrid and Escherichia coli protein production systems reveals that the interactions of Arabidopsis PLPs with several proteins diminish under blue light illumination and that the PLP LOV domain may bind to a flavin chromophore. These results suggest that PLP functions as a blue light receptor. Homologs of PLP exist in rice, tomato and moss. The LOV domains of these PLP homologs form a distinct group in phylogenetic analysis. These facts suggest that PLP belongs to a new class of plant blue light receptor.Key words: PAS, LOV, blue light, protein-protein interaction, photoreceptor     

Blue light activates the sigmaB-dependent stress response of Bacillus subtilis via YtvA

Here we present evidence for a physiologically relevant light response mediated by the LOV domain-containing protein YtvA in the soil bacterium Bacillus subtilis. The loss and overproduction of YtvA abolish and enhance, respectively, the increase in sigma(B)-controlled ctc promoter activity at moderate light intensities. These effects were absent in the dark and in red light but present under blue-light illumination. Thus, activation of the general stress response in B. subtilis is modulated by blue light.     

Blue-light- and phosphorylation-dependent binding of a 14-3-3 protein to phototropins in stomatal guard cells of broad bean

Phototropins are blue-light (BL) receptor serine (Ser)/threonine kinases, and contain two light, oxygen, and voltage (LOV) domains, and are members of the PAS domain superfamily. They mediate phototropism, chloroplast movement, leaf expansion, and stomatal opening of higher plants in response to BL. In stomatal guard cells, genetic analysis has revealed that phototropins mediate activation of the plasma membrane H+-ATPase by phosphorylation and drive stomatal opening. However, biochemical evidence for the involvement of phototropins in the BL response of stomata is lacking. Using guard cell protoplasts, we showed that broad bean (Vicia faba) phototropins (Vfphots) were phosphorylated by BL, and that this phosphorylation of Vfphots reached to the maximum level earlier than that of the H+-ATPase. Phosphorylation of both Vfphots and H+-ATPase showed similar sensitivity to BL and were similarly suppressed by protein kinase and flavoprotein inhibitors. We found that a 14-3-3 protein was bound to Vfphots upon phosphorylation, and this binding occurred earlier than the H+-ATPase phosphorylation. Vfphots (Vfphot1a and Vfphot1b) were expressed in Escherichia coli, and phosphorylation sites were determined to be Ser-358 for Vfphot1a and Ser-344 for Vfphot1b, which are localized between LOV1 and LOV2. We conclude that Vfphots act as BL receptors in guard cells and that phosphorylation of a Ser residue between LOV1 and LOV2 and subsequent 14-3-3 protein binding are likely to be key steps of BL response in stomata. The binding of a 14-3-3 protein to Vfphot was found in etiolated seedlings and leaves in response to BL, suggesting that this event was common to phototropin-mediated responses.     

Effect of computational methodology on the conformational dynamics of the protein photosensor LOV1 from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

LOV domains are the light-sensitive protein domains of plant phototropins and bacteria. They photochemically form a covalent bond between a flavin mononucleotide (FMN) chromophore and a cysteine, attached to the apo-protein, upon irradiation with blue light, which triggers a signal in the adjacent kinase. Although their signaling state has been well characterized through experimental means, their signal transduction pathway as well as dark-state activity are generally only poorly understood. Here we show results from molecular dynamics simulations where we investigated the effect of thermostating and long-range electrostatics on the solution structure and dynamical behavior of the wild-type LOV1 domain from the green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii in the dark. We demonstrate that these computational issues can dramatically affect the conformational fluctuations of such protein domains by suppressing configurations far from equilibrium or destabilizing local configurations, leading to artificial changes of the protein secondary structure as well as the H-bond network formed by the amino acids and the FMN. By comparing our calculation results with recent experimental data, we show that the non-invasive thermostating strategy, where the protein solute is only indirectly coupled to the thermostat via the solvent, in conjunction with the particle-mesh Ewald technique, provides dark-state conformers, which are in consistency with experimental observations. Moreover, our calculations indicate that the LOV1 domains can alter the intersystem crossing rate and rate of adduct formation by adjusting the population distribution of these dark-state conformers. This might permit them to function as a modulator of the signal intensity under low light conditions.     

Mapping of low- and high-fluence autophosphorylation sites in phototropin 1

Phototropins, originally detected by their blue light-dependent autophosphorylation, are plant photoreceptors involved in several blue light responses such as phototropism, chloroplast relocation, leaf expansion, rapid inhibition of hypocotyl growth, and stomatal opening. Three domains have been identified in phototropin sequences, two chromophore binding domains (LOV1 and LOV2) and a kinase domain. We describe here two additional domains, the N-terminus upstream of LOV1 and the hinge region between LOV1 and LOV2, as the regions for autophosphorylation; the phosphorylation sites were identified by site-directed mutagenesis as S27, S30, S274, S300, S317, S325, S332, and S349 of the PHOT1a sequence of Avena sativa. Investigation of the autophosphorylation in vivo revealed that serines close to the LOV1 domain are phosphorylated at lower fluence of blue light than the serines close to the LOV2 domain. Recovery of phosphorylation in vivo during a dark period after saturating irradiation is caused by dephosphorylation rather than by degradation of the phosphorylated form and new synthesis of nonphosphorylated phototropin. The results were obtained by a combination of autophosphorylation of phototropin with phosphorylation of recombinant domains by protein kinase A, which turned out to have the same site specificity as the phototropin kinase, followed by proteolysis and separation of phosphopeptides. With the knowledge of the phosphorylation sites, the physiological and biochemical consequences of autophosphorylation can now be approached by site-directed mutagenesis of phototropins.     

Isolation and characterization of a Chlamydomonas gene that encodes a putative blue-light photoreceptor of the phototropin family

In the search for a Chlamydomonas reinhardtii photoreceptor that may mediate blue-light-induced responses we identified a gene that encodes a protein with a structure typical for that of members of the phototropin family, i.e. two LOV domains that may function in flavin mononucleotide binding and a ser/thr kinase domain. The amino acid sequences of these domains are closely related to those of higher plant phototropins. This single-copy gene ( Phot ) encodes a protein with a calculated molecular mass of 81.4 kDa which is distinctly smaller than the homologous proteins of higher plants that exhibit molecular masses around 120 kDa. Expression analyses revealed rather constant levels of Phot mRNA and Phot protein in vegetative cells incubated in the dark and in cells undergoing gametogenesis. Only vegetative cells in the light showed a reduced expression of the Phot gene. Cell fractionation studies revealed that the protein is membrane-associated. In higher plants, phototropins were shown to be bound to the plasma membrane. However, the expression of a Phot-GFP gene fusion in tobacco protoplasts revealed an association of the fusion protein with the endogenous membrane network of the cell.     

Chromophore exchange in the LOV2 domain of the plant photoreceptor phototropin1 from oat

Phototropins are a family of plant photoreceptors mediating blue light responses such as phototropism, leaf expansion, chloroplast relocation, and stomatal opening. Characteristic for phototropins are two LOV domains which, when expressed in heterologous systems, each carry a single flavin mononucleotide (FMN) chromophore. Here we describe removal of FMN from the LOV2 domain of Avena sativa using a hydrophobic matrix and successful incorporation of flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), riboflavin, and 5'-malonyl-riboflavin into the resulting apoprotein; 5-deaza-FMN was not incorporated under the applied conditions. The chromoproteins reconstituted with the various flavins showed absorption spectra and photocycle almost identical to those of the native LOV2 domain and that reconstituted with FMN except for the kinetics: LOV2-riboflavin and LOV2-5'-malonyl-riboflavin showed more rapid regeneration in the dark. LOV2-FAD can be hydrolyzed to LOV2-FMN with phosphodiesterase, indicating that the adenosine part extrudes from the protein. Together with the data from the X-ray structure (Crosson, S., and Moffat, K. (2001) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 98, 2995-3000), the results allow us to decide which of the chromophore-protein interactions are essential for the reconstitution process.     

First evidence for phototropin-related blue-light receptors in prokaryotes

A prokaryotic protein, YtvA from Bacillus subtilis, was found to possess a light, oxygen, voltage (LOV) domain sharing high homology with the photoactive, flavin mononucleotide (FMN)-binding LOV domains of phototropins (phot), blue-light photoreceptors for phototropism in higher plants. Computer-based three-dimensional modeling suggests that YtvA-LOV binds FMN in a similar pocket as phot-LOVs. Recombinant YtvA indeed exhibits the same spectroscopical features and blue-light-induced photochemistry as phot-LOVs, with the reversible formation of a blue-shifted photoproduct, assigned to an FMN-cysteine thiol adduct (Thio383). By means of laser-flash photolysis and time-resolved optoacoustic experiments, we measured the quantum yield of formation for Thio383, Phi(Thio) = 0.49, and the enthalpy change, DeltaH(Thio) = 135 kJ/mol, with respect to the parent state. The formation of Thio383 is accompanied by a considerable volume contraction, DeltaV(Thio) = -13.5 ml/mol. Similar to phot-LOVs, Thio383 is formed from the decay of a red-shifted transient species, T650, within 2 micros. In both YtvA and free FMN, this transient has an enthalpy content of approximately 200 kJ/mol, and its formation is accompanied by a small contraction, DeltaV(T) approximately -1.5 ml/mol, supporting the assignment of T650 to the FMN triplet state, as suggested by spectroscopical evidences. These are the first studies indicating that phototropin-related, blue-light receptors may exist also in prokaryotes, besides constituting a steadily growing family in plants.     

Photochemical properties of the flavin mononucleotide-binding domains of the phototropins from Arabidopsis,rice, and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Phototropins (phot1 and phot2, formerly designated nph1 and npl1) are blue-light receptors that mediate phototropism, blue light-induced chloroplast relocation, and blue light-induced stomatal opening in Arabidopsis. Phototropins contain two light, oxygen, or voltage (LOV) domains at their N termini (LOV1 and LOV2), each a binding site for the chromophore flavin mononucleotide (FMN). Their C termini contain a serine/threonine protein kinase domain. Here, we examine the kinetic properties of the LOV domains of Arabidopsis phot1 and phot2, rice (Oryza sativa) phot1 and phot2, and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii phot. When expressed in Escherichia coli, purified LOV domains from all phototropins examined bind FMN tightly and undergo a self-contained photocycle, characterized by fluorescence and absorption changes induced by blue light (T. Sakai, T. Kagawa, M. Kasahara, T.E. Swartz, J.M. Christie, W.R. Briggs, M. Wada, K. Okada [2001] Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 6969-6974; M. Salomon, J.M. Christie, E. Knieb, U. Lempert, W.R. Briggs [2000] Biochemistry 39: 9401-9410). The photocycle involves the light-induced formation of a cysteinyl adduct to the C(4a) carbon of the FMN chromophore, which subsequently breaks down in darkness. In each case, the relative quantum efficiencies for the photoreaction and the rate constants for dark recovery of LOV1, LOV2, and peptides containing both LOV domains are presented. Moreover, the data obtained from full-length Arabidopsis phot1 and phot2 expressed in insect cells closely resemble those obtained for the tandem LOV-domain fusion proteins expressed in E. coli. For both Arabidopsis and rice phototropins, the LOV domains of phot1 differ from those of phot2 in their reaction kinetic properties and relative quantum efficiencies. Thus, in addition to differing in amino acid sequence, the phototropins can be distinguished on the basis of the photochemical cycles of their LOV domains. The LOV domains of C. reinhardtii phot also undergo light-activated spectral changes consistent with cysteinyl adduct formation. Thus, the phototropin family extends over a wide evolutionary range from unicellular algae to higher plants.     

Blue news: NTP binding properties of the blue-light sensitive YtvA protein from Bacillus subtilis

The blue-light sensitive protein YtvA from Bacillus subtilis is built of a photoactive, flavin-binding LOV (Light, Oxygen and Voltage) domain and a STAS domain with unknown function. Here we show that YtvA binds a fluorescent derivative of guanosine triphosphate (GTPTR) that can be displaced by both GTP or ATP. Unspecific NTP (N=G or A) binding is supported by the molecular model of YtvA-STAS. Blue-light activation of YtvA results in small and dark-reversible spectroscopic changes for GTPTR, suggesting that light-driven conformational changes are transmitted from the LOV core to the GTPTR binding site. These results support the idea that STAS domains may have a general NTP binding role and open a way to investigate the molecular functionality of YtvA-STAS.