Different routes lead to apoptosis in unfertilized sea urchin eggs

Results obtained in various species, from mammals to invertebrates, show that arrest in the cell cycle of mature oocytes is due to a high ERK activity. Apoptosis is stimulated in these oocytes if fertilization does not occur. Our previous data suggest that apoptosis of unfertilized sea urchin eggs is the consequence of an aberrant short attempt of development that occurs if ERK is inactivated. They contradict those obtained in starfish, another echinoderm, where inactivation of ERK delays apoptosis of aging mature oocytes that are nevertheless arrested at G1 of the cell cycle as in the sea urchin. This suggests that the cell death pathway that can be activated in unfertilized eggs is not the same in sea urchin and in starfish. In the present study, we find that protein synthesis is necessary for the survival of unfertilized sea urchin eggs, contrary to starfish. We also compare the effects induced by Emetine, an inhibitor of protein synthesis, with those triggered by Staurosporine, a non specific inhibitor of protein kinase that is widely used to induce apoptosis in many types of cells. Our results indicate that the unfertilized sea urchin egg contain different mechanisms capable of leading to apoptosis and that rely or not on changes in ERK activity, acidity of intracellular organelles or intracellular Ca and pH. We discuss the validity of some methods to investigate cell death such as measurements of caspase activation with the fluorescent caspase indicator FITC-VAD-fmk or acidification of intracellular organelles, methods that may lead to erroneous conclusions at least in the sea urchin model.     

Unfertilized Xenopus eggs die by Bad-dependent apoptosis under the control of Cdk1 and JNK

Ovulated eggs possess maternal apoptotic execution machinery that is inhibited for a limited time. The fertilized eggs switch off this time bomb whereas aged unfertilized eggs and parthenogenetically activated eggs fail to stop the timer and die. To investigate the nature of the molecular clock that triggers the egg decision of committing suicide, we introduce here Xenopus eggs as an in vivo system for studying the death of unfertilized eggs. We report that after ovulation, a number of eggs remains in the female body where they die by apoptosis. Similarly, ovulated unfertilized eggs recovered in the external medium die within 72 h. We showed that the death process depends on both cytochrome c release and caspase activation. The apoptotic machinery is turned on during meiotic maturation, before fertilization. The death pathway is independent of ERK but relies on activating Bad phosphorylation through the control of both kinases Cdk1 and JNK. In conclusion, the default fate of an unfertilized Xenopus egg is to die by a mitochondrial dependent apoptosis activated during meiotic maturation.     

p90Rsk is required for G1 phase arrest in unfertilized starfish eggs

The cell cycle in oocytes generally arrests at a particular meiotic stage to await fertilization. This arrest occurs at metaphase of meiosis II (meta-II) in frog and mouse, and at G1 phase after completion of meiosis II in starfish. Despite this difference in the arrest phase, both arrests depend on the same Mos-MAPK (mitogen-activated protein kinase) pathway, indicating that the difference relies on particular downstream effectors. Immediately downstream of MAPK, Rsk (p90 ribosomal S6 kinase, p90(Rsk)) is required for the frog meta-II arrest. However, the mouse meta-II arrest challenges this requirement, and no downstream effector has been identified in the starfish G1 arrest. To investigate the downstream effector of MAPK in the starfish G1 arrest, we used a neutralizing antibody against Rsk and a constitutively active form of Rsk. Rsk was activated downstream of the Mos-MAPK pathway during meiosis. In G1 eggs, inhibition of Rsk activity released the arrest and initiated DNA replication without fertilization. Conversely, maintenance of Rsk activity prevented DNA replication following fertilization. In early embryos, injection of Mos activated the MAPK-Rsk pathway, resulting in G1 arrest. Moreover, inhibition of Rsk activity during meiosis I led to parthenogenetic activation without meiosis II. We conclude that immediately downstream of MAPK, Rsk is necessary and sufficient for the starfish G1 arrest. Although CSF (cytostatic factor) was originally defined for meta-II arrest in frog eggs, we propose to distinguish ;G1-CSF' for starfish from ;meta-II-CSF' for frog and mouse. The present study thus reveals a novel role of Rsk for G1-CSF.     

MAP kinase links the fertilization signal transduction pathway to the G1/S-phase transition in starfish eggs.

The mechanism by which fertilization initiates S-phase in the zygote is examined by manipulating the activity of MAP kinase in mature starfish eggs. These unfertilized eggs, which are arrested at G1-phase after the completion of meiosis, have high MAP kinase activity but undetectable cdc2 kinase activity. Either fertilization or inhibition of protein synthesis causes a decrease in MAP kinase activity, which is followed by DNA synthesis. Inactivation of MAP kinase with its specific phosphatase, CL100, initiates DNA synthesis in the absence of fertilization, while constitutive activation of MAP kinase with MEK represses the initiation of DNA synthesis following fertilization. Thus, in unfertilized mature starfish eggs, a capacity for DNA replication is already acquired, but entry into S-phase is negatively regulated by MAP kinase activity that is supported by a continuously synthesized protein(s) but not by cdc2 kinase. Upon fertilization, downregulation of MAP kinase activity is necessary and sufficient for triggering the G1/S-phase transition.     

Fertilization initiates the transition from anaphase I to metaphase II during female meiosis in C. elegans

Oocytes from most animals arrest twice during the meiotic cell cycle. The universally conserved prophase I arrest is released by a maturation hormone that allows progression to a second arrest point, typically metaphase I or II. This second arrest allows for short-term storage of fertilization-competent eggs and is released by signaling that occurs during fertilization. Nematodes are unique in that the maturation hormone is secreted by sperm rather than by the mother's somatic tissues. We have investigated the nature of the second arrest in matured but unfertilized Caenorhabditis elegans embryos using time-lapse imaging of GFP-tubulin or GFP-histone. Unfertilized embryos completed anaphase I but did not form polar bodies or assemble meiosis II spindles. Nevertheless, unfertilized embryos assembled female pronuclei at the same time as fertilized embryos. Analysis of embryos fertilized by sperm lacking the SPE-11 protein indicated that fertilization promotes meiotic cytokinesis through the SPE-11 protein but assembly of the meiosis II spindle is initiated through an SPE-11-independent pathway.     

Autophagy is used as a survival program in unfertilized sea urchin eggs that are destined to die by apoptosis after inactivation of MAPK1/3 (ERK2/1)

A high MAPK1/3 (also known as ERK2/1, respectively) activity, preventing spontaneous activation, is essential to maintain cell cycle arrest of mature oocytes of mammals, frogs or invertebrates such as starfish. Mature oocytes would undergo a “suicide”-like cell death if not fertilized. We previously have reported that downregulation of MAPK1/3 in unfertilized sea urchin eggs induces a calcium-dependent entry into mitosis. We show here that this event is followed by a series of pseudo-mitotic cell cycles associated with transient Ca_i increases, preceding CASP3/caspase-3 activation and apoptosis. However, cell death was delayed after inhibition of the Ca_i transients or of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDK), with roscovitine. In these conditions, eggs enter an autophagy program as suggested by detection of processed LC3B by western blot, immunofluorescence and immunogold staining, visualization of autophagy vesicles by electron microscopy, and an increase in acidic vesicular organelles (AVOs). We found that bafilomycin A₁ or an association of leupeptin and pepstatin, which are widely used to study autophagy, may act upon calcium signaling or cell cycle events, respectively, and not only on autophagy events. Finally, inhibition of PtdIns 3-kinase with wortmannin or LY294002 powerfully stimulated cell death of unfertilized eggs, which suggests that this activity does not negatively regulate autophagy as is often reported, but rather stimulates survival in unfertilized eggs. We suggest that apoptosis of unfertilized eggs is the consequence of an aberrant short attempt of development that occurs if MAPK1/3 is inactivated, but these eggs can use autophagy as a survival program when the cell cycle is blocked.     

Mos is not required for the initiation of meiotic maturation in Xenopus oocytes

In Xenopus oocytes, the c-mos proto-oncogene product has been proposed to act downstream of progesterone to control the entry into meiosis I, the transition from meiosis I to meiosis II, which is characterized by the absence of S phase, and the metaphase II arrest seen prior to fertilization. Here, we report that inhibition of Mos synthesis by morpholino antisense oligonucleotides does not prevent the progesterone-induced initiation of Xenopus oocyte meiotic maturation, as previously thought. Mos-depleted oocytes complete meiosis I but fail to arrest at metaphase II, entering a series of embryonic-like cell cycles accompanied by oscillations of Cdc2 activity and DNA replication. We propose that the unique and conserved role of Mos is to prevent mitotic cell cycles of the female gamete until the fertilization in Xenopus, starfish and mouse oocytes.     

MAP kinases regulate unfertilized egg apoptosis and fertilization suppresses death via Ca2+ signaling

The default fate for eggs from many species is death by apoptosis and thus, successful fertilization depends upon suppression of the maternal death program. Little is known about the molecular triggers which activate this process or how the fertilization signal suppresses the default maternal apoptotic pathway. The MAP kinase (MAPK) family member, ERK, plays a universal and critical role in several stages of oocyte meiotic maturation, and fertilization results in ERK inactivation. In somatic cells, ERK and other MAPK family members, p38 and JNK, provide opposing signals to regulate apoptosis, however, it is not known whether MAPKs play a regulatory role in egg apoptosis, nor whether suppression of apoptosis by fertilization is mediated by MAPK activity. Here we demonstrate that MAPKs are involved in starfish egg apoptosis and we investigate the relationship between the fertilization induced signaling pathway and MAPK activation. ERK is active in post-meiotic eggs just until apoptosis onset and then p38, JNK and a third kinase are activated, and remain active through execution. Sequential activation of ERK and p38 is necessary for apoptosis, and newly synthesized proteins are required both upstream of ERK and downstream of p38 for activation of the full apoptotic program. Fertilization causes a dramatic rise in intracellular Ca2+, and we report that Ca2+ provides a necessary and sufficient pro-survival signal. The Ca2+ pathway following fertilization of both young and aged eggs causes ERK to be rapidly inactivated, but fertilization cannot rescue aged eggs from death, indicating that ERK inactivation is not sufficient to suppress apoptosis.     

A metaphase pause: Hormone-induced maturation progresses through a long pause at the first meiotic metaphase in oocytes of the starfish, Pisaster ochraceus

In several species of starfish, it has been reported that the meiotic divisions in fertilized oocytes occur precociously compared to those in unfertilized oocytes. The nature of the 'acceleration' of meiosis was studied using Pisaster ochraceus oocytes. The extent of the acceleration of first polar body formation was found to be completely dependent on the time of fertilization (or artificial activation); fertilization at about 100 min after 1–methyladenine application accelerated meiosis I the most, while earlier or later fertilization resulted in a smaller extent of accelerations of meiosis I. Observation of isolated meiotic spindles and fluorescent visualization of meiotic spindles in whole oocytes showed that progression of meiosis I in Pisaster oocytes pauses transiently at metaphase I for more than 40min unless they are activated. The activation shortened the duration of metaphase I, which resulted in the acceleration of first polar body formation. A new term 'metaphase pause' is proposed to define this long duration of metaphase I in starfish oocytes.     

More than G1 or G2 arrest: useful starfish oocyte system for investigating skillful MAP kinase

During the meiotic cycles in starfish oocytes, MAP kinase (MAPK) is involved in the meta-I arrest, the meiosis I to II transition, and the arrest at pronucleus stage (G1 and/or G2 phase). The eventual fate, either development or death, of mature eggs is also under the control of MAPK. Starfish oocytes are thus a useful model system to study multiple functions of skillful MAPK.     

Involvement of mitogen-activating protein kinase and intracellular pH in the duration of the metaphase I (MI) pause of starfish oocytes after spawning

The metaphase I (MI) arrest of starfish oocytes is released after spawning. In this study using starfish Asterina pectinifera , the duration of MI after spawning was ~20 min and ~30 min in fertilized and unfertilized oocytes, respectively. This prolongation of MI in unfertilized oocytes, referred to as the MI pause, was maintained by mitogen-activating protein kinase (MAPK) as well as low intracellular pH (~7.0). Contrary to previous reports, MI arrest was not maintained by MAPK, since it was inactive in the oocytes arrested at MI in the ovary and activated immediately after spawning. Also, cyclin B was not degraded at pH 6.7 in the cell-free preparation without MAPK activity, whereas it was degraded at pH 7.0, suggesting that MI arrest was solely maintained by lower pH (< 7.0). Normal development occurred when the spawned oocytes were fertilized before the first polar body formation, whereas fertilization after the first polar body formation increased the rate of abnormal development. Thus, due to MI pause and MI arrest, the probability for fertilization before the polar body formation might be increased, leading to normal development.     

The Role of "Cytostatic Factor (CSF)" in the Control of Oocyte Cell Cycles: A Summary of 20 Years of Study

Cytostatic Factor (CSF) is a cytoplasmic factor found in unfertilized eggs of the frog that causes metaphase arrest of cell cycles in the oocyte and zygote. CSF appears in maturing oocyte cytoplasm, but disappears during egg activation. CSF-injected zygotes are arrested at metaphase and show morphology and cellular activities strikingly similar to those of unfertilized eggs. Fresh cytosols extracted from unfertilized eggs contain unstable CSF, called "primary" CSF, which is highly sensitive to Ca ions. Cytosols incubated with Ca ions develop stable CSF, called "secondary" CSF, which is resistant to Ca ions. It has been hypothesized that primary CSF is responsible for the metaphase arrest of meiosis in the unfertilized egg, and its inactivation by a surge of Ca ions during fertilization releases the egg from metaphase arrest. Studies of molecular characteristics of partially purified primary and secondary CSFs suggest that they are both proteins. Recent studies in other laboratories indicate that primary CSF is the c-mos proto-oncogene product. The effect of CSF appears to be primarily stabilization of maturation-promoting factor (MPF), another oocyte cytoplasmic factor, that causes transition of the cell from interphase to metaphase. This paper will summarize the studies on CSF in the author's laboratory over the past 20 years, describe the development of the concept of CSF as a cell cycle regulator, and speculate on the mechanism of its action based on current knowledge.     

Metaphase I arrest of starfish oocytes induced via the MAP kinase pathway is released by an increase of intracellular pH

Reinitiation of meiosis in oocytes usually occurs as a two-step process during which release from the prophase block is followed by an arrest in metaphase of the first or second meiotic division [metaphase I (MI) or metaphase II (MII)]. The mechanism of MI arrest in meiosis is poorly understood, although it is a widely observed phenomenon in invertebrates. The blockage of fully grown starfish oocytes in prophase of meiosis I is released by the hormone 1-methyladenine. It has been believed that meiosis of starfish oocytes proceeds completely without MI or MII arrest, even when fertilization does not occur. Here we show that MI arrest of starfish oocytes occurs in the ovary after germinal vesicle breakdown. This arrest is maintained both by the Mos/MEK/MAP kinase pathway and the blockage of an increase of intracellular pH in the ovary before spawning. Immediately after spawning into seawater, activation of Na+/H+ antiporters via a heterotrimeric G protein coupling to a 1-methyladenine receptor in the oocyte leads to an intracellular pH increase that can overcome the MI arrest even in the presence of active MAP kinase.     

Regulation of Intracellular pH by p90Rsk-dependent Activation of an Na+/H+ Exchanger in Starfish Oocytes

Starfish oocytes arrest at metaphase of the first meiotic division (MI arrest) in the ovary and resume meiosis after spawning into seawater. MI arrest is maintained by lower intracellular pH (pH_i) and release from arrest by cellular alkalization. To elucidate pH_i regulation in oocytes, we cloned the starfish (Asterina pectinifera) Na⁺/H⁺ exchanger 3 (ApNHE3) expressed in the plasma membrane of oocytes. The cytoplasmic domain of ApNHE3 contains p90 ribosomal S6 kinase (p90Rsk) phosphorylation sites, and injection of a constitutively active p90Rsk and the upstream regulator Mos to immature oocytes, stimulated an increase in pH_i. This increase was blocked by 5-(N-ethyl-N-isopropyl)-amiloride, a NHE inhibitor, and SL0101, a specific Rsk inhibitor. The MAPK kinase (MEK) inhibitor U0126 blocked the Mos-induced, but not the p90Rsk-induced, pH_i increase, suggesting that the Mos-MEK-MAPK-p90Rsk pathway promotes ApNHE3 activation. In a cell-free extract, the Mos-MEK-MAPK-p90Rsk pathway phosphorylates ApNHE3 at Ser-590, -606, and -673. When p90Rsk-dependent ApNHE3 phosphorylation was blocked by a dominant-negative C-terminal fragment, or neutralizing antibody, the p90Rsk-induced pH_i increase was suppressed in immature oocytes. However, ApNHE3 is up-regulated via the upstream phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase pathway before MAPK activation and the active state is maintained until spawning, suggesting that the p90Rsk-dependent ApNHE3 phosphorylation is unlikely to be the primary regulatory mechanism involved in MI arrest exit. After meiosis is completed, unfertilized eggs maintain their elevated pH_i (∼7.4) until the onset of apoptosis. We suggest that the p90Rsk/ApNHE3-dependent elevation of pH_i increases fertilization success by delaying apoptosis initiation.     

Induction of apoptosis in starfish eggs requires spontaneous inactivation of MAPK (extracellular signal-regulated kinase) followed by activation of p38MAPK

Mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) (extracellular signal-regulated kinase) prevents DNA replication and parthenogenesis in maturing oocytes. After the meiotic cell cycle in starfish eggs, MAPK activity is maintained until fertilization. When eggs are fertilized, inactivation of MAPK occurs, allowing development to proceed. Without fertilization, highly synchronous apoptosis of starfish eggs starts 10 h after germinal vesicle breakdown, which varies according to season and individual animals. For induction of the apoptosis, MAPK should be activated for a definite period, called the MAPK-dependent period, during which eggs develop competence to die, although the exact duration of the period was unclear. In this study, we show that the duration of the MAPK-dependent period was approximately 8 h. Membrane blebbing occurred approximately 2 h after the MAPK-dependent period. Surprisingly, when MAPK was inhibited by U0126 after the MAPK-dependent period, activation of caspase-3 occurred earlier than in the control eggs. Thus, inactivation of MAPK is a prerequisite for apoptosis. Also, even in the absence of the inhibitor, MAPK was inactivated spontaneously when eggs began to bleb, indicating that inactivation of MAPK after the MAPK-dependent period acts upstream of caspase-3. Inactivation of MAPK also resulted in the activation of p38MAPK, which may contribute to apoptotic body formation.     

Changes in calpain during meiosis in the rat egg

Resumption of meiosis at fertilization is mediated by increased levels of calcium which activate several calcium-dependent enzymes. Calpain, a neutral calcium-activated thiol protease, is present in the cytoplasm of many cells. Its activation is associated with limited autolysis and relocalization in the cell. Calpain is thought to participate in the regulation of mitosis and resumption of meiosis in Xenopus oocytes. In this study we followed the activation and localization of calpain during maturation and fertilization in rat eggs using a polyclonal antibody raised against chicken muscle calpain. A band of 80 kDa was detected in GV oocytes and its level increased in unfertilized MII eggs. At the early stages of fertilization, we observed a transient decrease in the level of calpain which was regained at the pronuclear stage. Adding Ca²⁺ to lysate of MII eggs resulted in an additional band, representing the degraded fragment of the activated protein. In eggs activated by ionomycin, calpain level decreased, followed by an increase in a dynamic similar to that observed in fertilized eggs. Egg activation also led to changes in calpain localization. A homogenous distribution was observed in GV and in MII eggs, while in activated eggs it was localized predominantly overlying the metaphase plate. In the current study we demonstrate the presence of calpain in the rat egg. During maturation, calpain level increases; however, during egg activation, in response to [Ca²⁺]_i changes, calpain undergoes autolysis, translocation, and fluctuation in its level. We therefore suggest a correlation between calpain activation and fertilization. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 48:119–126, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Spermatogonial stem cells

The mammalian seminiferous epithelium consists of a highly complex yet well-organized cell population, with germ cells in mitosis and meiosis and postmeiotic cells undergoing transformation to become spermatozoa. To study the factors which control renewal and differentiation of spermatogonial stem cells, animal models are now available which allow for arrest and restart of spermatogonial differentiation. In addition, marked progress has been made in understanding the control of apoptosis and its role in spermatogonia. For the future, spermatogonial stem cell transplantation may have important practical applications.     

Fertilization regulates apoptosis of Ciona intestinalis extra-embryonic cells through thyroxine (T4)-dependent NF-kappaB pathway activation during early embryonic development

In Ciona intestinalis, the elimination of extra-embryonic test cells during early stage of development is delayed by a fertilization signal. Test cells undergo a caspase-dependent apoptosis event repressed by thyroxine (T4)-activated NF-kappaB. When apoptosis was experimentally blocked, the hatching stage was delayed. The incubation of unfertilized eggs with a 1-h-fertilized egg extract or purified T4 restored apoptosis in test cells at a similar timing than found in fertilized eggs. Ciona expresses specific genes forming a functional IkappaB/NF-kappaB pathway. One, Ci-p65, was transiently induced upon fertilization via T4 and found to exert its anti-apoptotic role in test cells nuclei as well as in a reconstituted cell system. Blocking NF-kappaB activity by dexamethasone-induced overexpression of Ci-IkappaB abrogated the repression of apoptosis in test cells. Overall, the data are consistent for defining a central coupling role of both T4 and NF-kappaB during early embryo development.     

A member of the Ste20/PAK family of protein kinases is involved in both arrest of Xenopus oocytes at G2/prophase of the first meiotic cell cycle and in prevention of apoptosis.

We have identified new members (X-PAKs) of the Ste20/PAK family of protein kinases in Xenopus, and investigated their role in the process that maintains oocytes arrested in the cell cycle. Microinjection of a catalytically inactive mutant of X-PAK1 with a K/R substitution in the ATP binding site, also deleted of its Nter-half that contains the conserved domains responsible for binding of both Cdc42/Rac GTPases and SH3-containing proteins, greatly facilitates oocyte release from G2/prophase arrest by progesterone and insulin. Addition of the same X-PAK1 mutant to cell cycle extracts from unfertilized eggs induced apoptosis, as shown by activation of caspases and cytological changes in in vitro-assembled nuclei. This was suppressed by adding Bcl-2 or the DEVD peptide inhibitor of caspases, and rescued by competing the dominant-negative mutant with its constitutively active X-PAK1 counterpart. Such results indicate that X-PAK1 (or another member of the Xenopus Ste20/PAK family of protein kinases) is involved in arrest of oocytes at G2/prophase and prevention of apoptosis; thus death by apoptosis and release of healthy oocytes from cell cycle arrest may be linked. That cell cycle arrest protects oocytes from apoptosis is consistent with the finding that extracts from metaphase II-arrested oocytes are less sensitive to apoptotic signals than those from activated eggs.     

Melittin, a Component of Bee Venom, Activates Unfertilized Sea Urchin Eggs

Melittin, which is known to stimulate phospholipase A , in many cells, caused as much elevation of fertilization membranes and increase in respiration of unfertilized eggs of the sea urchins Anthocidaris crassispina and Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus as normal fertilization.
In melittin-activated eggs, amino acid transport was decreased to less than that of unfertilized eggs, nucleoside transport was only slightly, activated, protein synthesis was rather inhibited and neither DNA synthesis nor cleavage was observed. It is concluded that although melittin induces the cortical reaction and activation of respiration in unfertilized eggs, its cytotoxicity prevents any "late changes".