Characterization of salt-tolerance mechanisms in mycorrhizal (Claroideoglomus etunicatum) halophytic grass,Puccinellia distans

Responses of Puccinellia distans, a halophytic grass to low (50 mM) and high (200 mM) NaCl salinity, were studied in a sand culture experiment without or with inoculation by arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus (AMF), Claroideoglomus etunicatum isolated from its saline habitat. Plant biomass was not influenced by salinity levels, while a tendency to a higher biomass was observed in AMF plants under both control and saline conditions. Leaf photosynthesis increased by both salinity and AMF inoculation. Despite higher transpiration rate, AMF plants had higher water-use efficiency under sever saline conditions. AMF inoculation decreased proline concentration, but increased significantly leaf osmotic potential. Antioxidative enzymes responded differently to the salt and AMF treatments depending on the salt concentration and plant organ. Nonetheless, salt-induced malondialdehyde accumulation in the leaves diminished by AMF colonization. K and Ca contents were not affected by salt, while fungal colonization increased K in the roots and Ca in both leaves and roots. Our results indicated that enhancement of photosynthesis and ion homeostasis is involved in the tolerance of P. distans to both low and high salinity. AMF inoculation increased plants’ tolerance by augmentation of the above mechanisms accompanied by improvement of water relations and protection against oxidative damage in the leaves.     

植物盐胁迫应答蛋白质组学分析

土壤盐渍化是限制植物生长和分布的关键因素之一,揭示植物盐胁迫应答的分子机理是借助分子生物学手段提高植物耐盐性的基础.近年来,人们利用高通量蛋白质组学技术分析了拟南芥、水稻等19种植物的盐胁迫应答蛋白质表达图谱.从植物类群(盐生植物和甜土植物)、组织器官(根、地上部分/茎、胚根和胚轴、叶片、花序和配子体)、细胞(悬浮培养细胞、愈伤组织细胞和单细胞生物)和亚细胞结构(叶绿体、质膜和质外体)几方面整合分析了植物盐胁迫应答蛋白质组表达模式特征,主要特征包括:(1)盐生植物通过全面调节细胞骨架重塑、离子转运和区隔化、渗透平衡、活性氧(ROS)清除、信号转导、光合作用和能量代谢等信号与代谢网络体系,获得相对较高的抗/耐盐能力;(2)植物地上部分(叶片、茎、配子体)或光合组织细胞(悬浮培养细胞、愈伤组织细胞和单细胞盐藻)通过调节参与光合作用、碳和能量代谢、ROS清除过程蛋白质的表达模式应对盐胁迫环境;(3)植物地下部分(根、胚根)通过调控信号转导和离子转运相关蛋白质感知/传递盐胁迫信号并维持离子平衡;(4)花序中参与渗透调节、转录调控、蛋白质加工和ROS清除的蛋白质在盐胁迫条件下变化显著;(5)叶绿体通过调控参与光合作用、蛋白质加工和周转,以及氧化还原系统平衡等过程应对盐胁迫;(6)质外体中参与细胞壁代谢、胁迫防御和信号转导过程的蛋白质受盐胁迫影响明显;(7)细胞膜中参与维持膜结构稳定、物质/离子运输和信号转导过程的蛋白质对植物盐胁迫应答具有重要作用.这些分析为深入研究植物耐盐的分子机制提供了重要信息.     

Identification of proteins associated with ion homeostasis and salt tolerance in barley

Identification and characterization of proteins involved in salt tolerance are imperative for revealing its genetic mechanisms. In this study, ionic and proteomic responses of a Tibetan wild barley XZ16 and a well‐known salt‐tolerant barley cv. CM72 were analyzed using inductively coupled plasma‐optical emission spectrometer, 2DE, and MALDI‐TOF/TOF MS techniques to determine salt‐induced differences in element and protein profiles between the two genotypes. In total, 41 differentially expressed proteins were identified in roots and leaves, and they were associated with ion homeostasis, cell redox homeostasis, metabolic process, and photosynthesis. Under salinity stress, calmodulin, Na/K transporters, and H⁺‐ATPases were involved in establishment of ion homeostasis for barley plants. Moreover, ribulose‐1,5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase activase and oxygen‐evolving enhancer proteins were significantly upregulated under salinity stress, indicating the great impact of salinity on photosynthesis. In comparison with CM72, XZ16 had greater relative dry weight and lower Na accumulation in the shoots under salinity stress. A higher expression of HvNHX1 in the roots, and some specific proteins responsible for ion homeostasis and cell redox homeostasis, was also found in XZ16 exposed to salt stress. The current results showed that Tibetan wild barley XZ16 and cultivated barley cultivar CM72 differ in the mechanism of salt tolerance.     

盐生植物星星草叶表皮具有泌盐功能的蜡质层

利用扫描电镜和 X射线电子探针研究了星星草 (Puccinellia tenuiflora)的叶表皮及其与生境高盐的关系。结果表明 ,叶表皮由表皮细胞和气孔器组成 ,下表皮气孔器多于上表皮 ,且常下陷 ,表皮具表皮毛。表皮细胞外存在丰富的蜡质纹饰和蜡质颗粒 ,这些蜡质包含盐离子 ,具有泌盐的功能。这些特征表明星星草受外界生态因素的影响 ,而演化出具有泌盐功能的蜡质层来适应所生长的高盐生境     

Salt tolerance of Beta macrocarpa is associated with efficient osmotic adjustment and increased apoplastic water content

The chenopod Beta macrocarpa Guss (wild Swiss chard) is known for its salt tolerance, but the mechanisms involved are still debated. In order to elucidate the processes involved, we grew wild Swiss chard exposed to three salinity levels (0, 100 and 200 mm NaCl) for 45 days, and determined several physiological parameters at the end of this time. All plants survived despite reductions in growth, photosynthesis and stomatal conductance in plants exposed to salinity (100 and 200 mm NaCl). As expected, the negative effects of salinity were more pronounced at 200 mm than at 100 mm NaCl: (i) leaf apoplastic water content was maintained or increased despite a significant reduction in leaf water potential, revealing the halophytic character of B. macrocarpa; (ii) osmotic adjustment occurred, which presumably enhanced the driving force for water extraction from soil, and avoided toxic build up of Na⁺ and Cl^– in the mesophyll apoplast of leaves. Osmotic adjustment mainly occurred through accumulation of inorganic ions and to a lesser extent soluble sugars; proline was not implicated in osmotic adjustment. Overall, two important mechanisms of salt tolerance in B. macrocarpa were identified: osmotic and apoplastic water adjustment.     

The role of mitochondrial respiration in salinity tolerance

NaCl is the most abundant salt in salinity-affected land. The ability of plants to sift the water table, limit NaCl uptake, compartmentalise Na?/Cl? ions and prevent negative ionic and osmotic effects on cell function, are the foundations of salinity tolerance mechanisms. In this review, we show that although the quantitative response of respiratory rate to changes in salt concentration is complex, the properties of respiratory processes are crucial for tolerance during ion exclusion and tissue tolerance. We consider whole-plant gas exchange and carbon balance analysis alongside the salt responses of mitochondrial properties and genetic studies manipulating respiratory processes. We showcase the importance of efficient ATP generation, dampened reactive oxygen species and mitochondrial osmolytes for salinity tolerance in plants.     

Carbohydrate metabolism and phosphorus/salinity interactions in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

Foliar inorganic ion and carbohydrate concentrations were determined in wheat plants treated with factorial combinations of phosphorus fertilizer and NaCl in a glasshouse experiment. Growth reductions and visual symptoms of salt toxicity were minimized when phosphorus nutrition was adequate, and were intensified by phosphorus deficiency. Foliar sodium and chloride accumulated up to 4.0–5.5% d.w. with salinity treatment. However, ionic concentrations within corresponding leaves or distributions between leaves of plants with different phosphorus treatments were not influenced by phosphorus treatment and had no relationship to the severity of salt toxicity symptoms. This suggests that phosphorus deficiency reduced the cellular tolerance for ion accumulation. A combination of phosphorus deficiency and salinity induced an accumulation of foliar starch and sucrose despite substantial reductions in net CO₂ assimilation rates. This accumulation did not occur if phosphorus nutrition was adequate, which is consistent with the roles of phosphorus in carbohydrate metabolism. It is proposed that adequate phosphorus nutrition is essential for effective ion compartmentation by contributing to efficient carbohydrate utilization in salt-stressed wheat.     

Remodeling of chloroplast proteome under salinity affects salt tolerance of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Festuca arundinacea</Emphasis>

Acclimation of photosynthetic apparatus to variable environmental conditions is an important component of tolerance to dehydration stresses, including salinity. The present study deals with the research on alterations in chloroplast proteome of the forage grasses. Based on chlorophyll fluorescence parameters, two genotypes of a model grass species—Festuca arundinacea with distinct levels of salinity tolerance: low salt tolerant (LST) and high salt tolerant (HST), were selected. Next, two-dimensional electrophoresis and mass spectrometry were applied under both control and salt stress conditions to identify proteins accumulated differentially between these two genotypes. The physiological analysis revealed that under NaCl treatment the studied plants differed in photosystem II activity, water content, and ion accumulation. The differentially accumulated proteins included ATPase B, ATP synthase, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase large and small subunits, cytochrome b6-f complex iron-sulfur subunit, oxygen-evolving enhancer proteins (OEE), OEE1 and OEE2, plastidic fructose-bisphosphate aldolase (pFBA), and lipocalin. A higher level of lipocalin, potentially involved in prevention of lipid peroxidation under stress, was also observed in the HST genotype. Our physiological and proteomic results performed for the first time on the species of forage grasses clearly showed that chloroplast metabolism adjustment could be a crucial factor in developing salinity tolerance.     

Seasonal changes in the levels of compatible osmolytes in three halophytic species of inland saline vegetation in Hungary

Seasonal changes in the leaf concentration of compatible osmolytes were investigated in three halophytic species (Lepidium crassifolium, Camphorosma annua and Limonium gmelini subsp. hungaricum) native to a salty-sodic grassland. The investigated species were shown to accumulate both carbohydrate- and amino acid-derived osmolytes. The leaf tissues of C. annua (Chenopodiaceae) preferentially stored glycine betaine and pinitol, while in L. gmelini (Plumbaginaceae) beta-alanine betaine, choline-O-sulphate, and pinitol were accumulated. In the leaves of L. crassifolium (Brassicaceae) a very high amount of proline, associated with a high level of soluble carbohydrates was found. Not only the biochemical nature of the osmolyte, but also the seasonal pattern of osmolyte accumulation showed significant species-specific fluctuations. In addition, the cellular levels of the observed osmolytes changed with the growth period and according to the environmental parameters. The highest concentrations of osmolytes were found in March, when low temperatures, hypoxic conditions and high salt concentrations were the main constraints to plant growth. The high structural diversity of osmolytes combined with their multifunctionality and the seasonal flexibility of the metabolism in plants facing multiple stresses is discussed.     

植物耐盐性机理研究进展

在盐胁迫下环境中某些植物会在发生一些变化。从生理学、生物化学、盐胁迫分子学机制的角度对植物对盐胁迫的反应研究进行了回顾,并提供了一些目前知识水平上能增加植物盐耐性的方法。解释了在盐胁迫下植物的离子吸收、相溶性物质、抗氧化酶、植物激素、光合作用等方面的变化规律,其中也有耐盐植物功能调节的研究,这有助于从多学科研究的角度评估盐胁迫的生态重要性。     

Oxidative stress protection and stomatal patterning as components of salinity tolerance mechanism in quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa)

Two components of salinity stress are a reduction in water availability to plants and the formation of reactive oxygen species. In this work, we have used quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa), a dicotyledonous C3 halophyte species displaying optimal growth at approximately 150 mM NaCl, to study mechanisms by which halophytes cope with the afore-mentioned components of salt stress. The relative contribution of organic and inorganic osmolytes in leaves of different physiological ages (e.g. positions on the stem) was quantified and linked with the osmoprotective function of organic osmolytes. We show that the extent of the oxidative stress (UV-B irradiation) damage to photosynthetic machinery in young leaves is much less when compared with old leaves, and attribute this difference to the difference in the size of the organic osmolyte pool (1.5-fold difference under control conditions; sixfold difference in plants grown at 400 mM NaCl). Consistent with this, salt-grown plants showed higher Fv/Fm values compared with control plants after UV-B exposure. Exogenous application of physiologically relevant concentrations of glycine betaine substantially mitigated oxidative stress damage to PSII, in a dose-dependent manner. We also show that salt-grown plants showed a significant (approximately 30%) reduction in stomatal density observed in all leaves. It is concluded that accumulation of organic osmolytes plays a dual role providing, in addition to osmotic adjustment, protection of photosynthetic machinery against oxidative stress in developing leaves. It is also suggested that salinity-induced reduction in stomatal density represents a fundamental mechanism by which plants optimize water use efficiency under saline conditions.     

三种红树植物对盐胁迫的生理适应

无瓣海桑（Sa）、海桑（Sc）、红海榄（Rs）都属于乔木红树植物。这3种红树植物对盐度的敏感程度存在着差异,因此对不同标准的盐度的适应性也大不相同。通过对这3种红树植物用不同的盐度的水3个月的处理,发现Sa和Sc叶片的净光合作用速率、气孔导度、蒸腾速率都随着盐度的增加而降低。Sa,Sc,Rs叶片中的可溶性总糖含量随着盐度的升高整体上有上升趋势。Sa和Sc茎、叶中丙二醛（MDA）含量在低盐度时（〈10）略有降低,随着盐度升高,MDA含量急速升高,而Rs茎、叶中MDA只是在盐度超过40时才会有明显增长,3种红树植物根部的MDA含量变化都不明显。Rs可以依靠超氧化物歧化酶（SOD）来消除活性氧自由基,而红树植物Sa和Sc的耐盐性稍差,SOD对膜的保护能力不强。根据实验结果,可以得出对3种红树植物对盐度的适应范围,这将为指导中国南海海岸线上的红树造林计划提供依据。     

Proteome Dynamics and Physiological Responses to Short-Term Salt Stress in Brassica napus Leaves

Salt stress limits plant growth and crop productivity and is an increasing threat to agriculture worldwide. In this study, proteomic and physiological responses of Brassica napus leaves under salt stress were investigated. Seedlings under salt treatment showed growth inhibition and photosynthesis reduction. A comparative proteomic analysis of seedling leaves exposed to 200 mM NaCl for 24 h, 48 h and 72 h was conducted. Forty-four protein spots were differentially accumulated upon NaCl treatment and 42 of them were identified, including several novel salt-responsive proteins. To determine the functional roles of these proteins in salt adaptation, their dynamic changes in abundance were analyzed. The results suggested that the up-accumulated proteins, which were associated with protein metabolism, damage repair and defense response, might contribute to the alleviation of the deleterious effect of salt stress on chlorophyll biosynthesis, photosynthesis, energy synthesis and respiration in Brassica napus leaves. This study will lead to a better understanding of the molecular basis of salt stress adaptation in Brassica napus and provides a basis for genetic engineering of plants with improved salt tolerance in the future.     

Insight into the salt tolerance factors of a wild halophytic rice, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Porteresia coarctata</Emphasis>: a physiological and proteomic approach

Salinity poses a serious threat to yield performance of cultivated rice in South Asian countries. To understand the mechanism of salt-tolerance of the wild halophytic rice, Porteresia coarctata in contrast to the salt-sensitive domesticated rice Oryza sativa, we have compared P. coarctata with the domesticated O. sativa rice varieties under salinity stress with respect to several physiological parameters and changes in leaf protein expression. P. coarctata showed a better growth performance and biomass under salinity stress. Relative water content was conserved in Porteresia during stress and sodium ion accumulation in leaves was comparatively lesser. Scanning electron microscopy revealed presence of two types of salt hairs on two leaf surfaces, each showing a different behaviour under stress. High salt stress for prolonged period also revealed accumulation of extruded NaCl crystals on leaf surface. Changes induced in leaf proteins were studied by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and subsequent quantitative image analysis. Out of more than 700 protein spots reproducibly detected and analyzed, 60% spots showed significant changes under salinity. Many proteins showed steady patterns of up- or downregulation in response to salinity stress. Twenty protein spots were analyzed by MALDI-TOF, leading to identification of 16 proteins involved in osmolyte synthesis, photosystem functioning, RubisCO activation, cell wall synthesis and chaperone functions. We hypothesize that some of these proteins confer a physiological advantage on Porteresia under salinity, and suggest a pattern of salt tolerance strategies operative in salt-marsh grasses. In addition, such proteins may turn out to be potential targets for recombinant cloning and introgression in salt-sensitive plants. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Comparative proteomic analysis of early salt stress responsive proteins in roots and leaves of rice

Growth and productivity of rice (Oryza sativa L.) are severely affected by salinity. Understanding the mechanisms that protect rice and other important cereal crops from salt stress will help in the development of salt‐stress‐tolerant strains. In this study, rice seedlings of the same genetic species with various salt tolerances were studied. We first used 2DE to resolve the expressed proteome in rice roots and leaves and then used nanospray liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry to identify the differentially expressed proteins in rice seedlings after salt treatment. The 2DE assays revealed that there were 104 differentially expressed protein spots in rice roots and 59 in leaves. Then, we identified 83 proteins in rice roots and 61 proteins in rice leaves by MS analysis. Functional classification analysis revealed that the differentially expressed proteins from roots could be classified into 18 functional categories while those from leaves could be classified into 11 functional categories. The proteins from rice seedlings that most significantly contributed to a protective effect against increased salinity were cysteine synthase, adenosine triphosphate synthase, quercetin 3‐O‐methyltransferase 1, and lipoxygenase 2. Further analysis demonstrated that the primary mechanisms underlying the ability of rice seedlings to tolerate salt stress were glycolysis, purine metabolism, and photosynthesis. Thus, we suggest that differentially expressed proteins may serve as marker group for the salt tolerance of rice.     

Salt tolerance is unrelated to carbohydrate metabolism in cowpea cultivars

Under salinity stress, plants commonly accumulate carbohydrates for osmotic adjustment to balance the excess accumulated ions and to protect biomolecules. We selected two cowpea cultivars with contrasting response to salinity, Pitiúba (salt-tolerant) and TVu (salt-sensitive), to investigate whether the salt tolerance could be associated with changes in carbohydrate accumulation and metabolism in leaves and roots during a long-term experiment. Two salt treatments (0 and 75 mM NaCl) were applied to 10-day-old plants grown in nutrient solution for 24 days. Despite some changes in carbohydrate accumulation and carbohydrate metabolism enzymes induced by salt stress, no consistent alterations in carbohydrates could be found in leaves or roots in this study. Therefore, we suggest that tolerance to salt stress is largely unrelated to carbohydrate accumulation in cowpea.     

Enhanced photosynthesis and redox energy production contribute to salinity tolerance in Dunaliella as revealed by homology-based proteomics

Salinity is a major limiting factor for the proliferation of plants and inhibits central metabolic activities such as photosynthesis. The halotolerant green alga Dunaliella can adapt to hypersaline environments and is considered a model photosynthetic organism for salinity tolerance. To clarify the molecular basis for salinity tolerance, a proteomic approach has been applied for identification of salt-induced proteins in Dunaliella. Seventy-six salt-induced proteins were selected from two-dimensional gel separations of different subcellular fractions and analyzed by mass spectrometry (MS). Application of nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry, combined with sequence-similarity database-searching algorithms, MS BLAST and MultiTag, enabled identification of 80% of the salt-induced proteins. Salinity stress up-regulated key enzymes in the Calvin cycle, starch mobilization, and redox energy production; regulatory factors in protein biosynthesis and degradation; and a homolog of a bacterial Na(+)-redox transporters. The results indicate that Dunaliella responds to high salinity by enhancement of photosynthetic CO(2) assimilation and by diversion of carbon and energy resources for synthesis of glycerol, the osmotic element in Dunaliella. The ability of Dunaliella to enhance photosynthetic activity at high salinity is remarkable because, in most plants and cyanobacteria, salt stress inhibits photosynthesis. The results demonstrated the power of MS BLAST searches for the identification of proteins in organisms whose genomes are not known and paved the way for dissecting molecular mechanisms of salinity tolerance in algae and higher plants.     

Effect of salinity on osmotic adjustment characteristics of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Kandelia candel</Emphasis>

To elucidate the osmotic adjustment characteristics of mangrove plants, inorganic ion and organic solute contents of intermediate leaves were investigated in 3-month-old Kandelia candel (L.) Druce seedlings during 45 days of NaCl treatments (0, 200, and 500 mM NaCl). The contents of Na⁺, Cl⁻, total free amino acids, proline, total soluble sugars, pinitol and mannitol increased to different degree by salinity, whereas, K⁺ content decreased by salinity compared with control. NaCl treatment induced an increase of inorganic ion contribution while a decrease of organic solute contribution. It was concluded that accumulating a large amount of inorganic ions was used as the main osmotic adjustment mechanism under salinity treatment. However, accumulation of organic osmolytes might be considered to play much more important role in osmoregulation under severe salinity (500 mM NaCl) than under moderate salinity (200 mM NaCl), thus the damage caused by high toxic ions (Na⁺ and Cl⁻) concentration in K. candel leaves could be avoided.