RNA as an enzyme

The catalytic activity of ribonucleic acid is reviewed, with the intervening sequence (IVS) of the ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena serving as a major example. The IVS catalyzes its own excision from the precursor RNA and at the same time ligation of the flanking sequences, a reaction termed self-splicing. The excised IVS RNA can act as an enzyme to catalyze sequence-specific cleavage and ligation reactions on substrate RNA molecules. The RNA polymerization activity of the IVS supports the possibility that RNA catalysis could have been important in establishing a prebiotic self-replicating system. Other systems in which RNA catalysis has been found include related group I IVSs, group II IVSs, ribonuclease P, and certain plant infectious RNAs.     

Assessment of a model for intron RNA secondary structure relevant to RNA self-splicing--a review

A widespread class of introns is characterized by a particular RNA secondary structure, based upon four conserved nucleotide sequences. Among such "class I" introns are found the majority of introns in fungal mitochondrial genes and the self-splicing intron of the large ribosomal RNA of several species of Tetrahymena. A model of the RNA secondary structure, which must underlie the self-splicing activity, is here evaluated in the light of data on 16 further introns. The main body or "core structure" of the intron always consists of the base-paired regions P3 to P9 with the associated single-stranded loops, with P2 present also in most cases. Two minority sub-classes of core structure occur, one of which is typical of introns in fungal ribosomal RNA. Introns in which the core structure is close to the 5' splice site all have an internal guide sequence (IGS) which can pair with exon sequences adjacent to the 5' and 3' splice sites to align them precisely, as proposed by Davies et al. [Nature 300 (1982) 719-724]. In these cases, the internal guide model allows us to predict correctly the exact location of splice sites. All other introns probably use other mechanisms of alignment. This analysis provides strong support for the RNA splicing model which we have developed.     

Two group I ribozymes with different functions in a nuclear rDNA intron.

DiSSU1, a mobile intron in the nuclear rRNA gene of Didymium iridis, was previously reported to contain two independent catalytic RNA elements. We have found that both catalytic elements, renamed GIR1 and GIR2, are group I ribozymes, but with differing functionality. GIR2 carries out the several reactions associated with self-splicing. GIR1 carries out a hydrolysis reaction at an internal processing site (IPS-1). These conclusions are based on the catalytic properties of RNAs transcribed in vitro. Mutation of the P7 pairing segment of GIR2 abrogated self-splicing, while mutation of P7 in GIR1 abrogated hydrolysis at the IPS-1. Much of the P2 stem and all of the associated loop could be deleted without effect on self-splicing. These results are accounted for by a secondary structure model, in which a long P2 pairing segment brings the 5' splice site to the GIR2 catalytic core. GIR1 is the smallest natural group I ribozyme yet reported and is the first example of a group I ribozyme whose presumptive biological function is hydrolysis. We hypothesize that GIR1-mediated cleavage of the excised intron RNA functions in the generation and expression of the mRNA for the intron-encoded endonuclease I-DirI.     

RNA processing in prokaryotic cells

RNA processing in Escherichia coli and some of its phages is reviewed here, with primary emphasis on rRNA and tRNA processing. Three enzymes, RNase III, RNase E and RNase P are responsible for most of the primary endonucleolytic RNA processing events. The first two are proteins, while RNase P is a ribozyme. These three enzymes have unique functions and in their absence, the cleavage events they catalyze are not performed. On the other hand a relatively large number of exonucleases participate in the trimming of the 3′ ends of tRNA precursor molecules and they can substitute for each other. Primary processing is the first event that happens to the nascent RNA molecule, while in secondary RNA processing, the substrate is a product of a primary processing event. Although most RNA processing occurs in RNP particles, it seems that only in secondary RNA processing is the RNP particle required for the reaction. Bacteria and especially bacteriophages contain self-splicing introns which in cases were probably acquired from other species.     

Cancer therapy using a self-replicating RNA vaccine.

'Naked' nucleic acid vaccines are potentially useful candidates for the treatment of patients with cancer, but their clinical efficacy has yet to be demonstrated. We sought to enhance the immunogenicity of a nucleic acid vaccine by making it 'self-replicating'. We accomplished this by using a gene encoding an RNA replicase polyprotein derived from the Semliki forest virus, in combination with a model antigen. A single intramuscular injection of a self-replicating RNA immunogen elicited antigen-specific antibody and CD8+ T-cell responses at doses as low as 0.1 microg. Pre-immunization with a self-replicating RNA vector protected mice from tumor challenge, and therapeutic immunization prolonged the survival of mice with established tumors. The self-replicating RNA vectors did not mediate the production of substantially more model antigen than a conventional DNA vaccine did in vitro. However, the enhanced efficacy in vivo correlated with a caspase-dependent apoptotic death in transfected cells. This death facilitated the uptake of apoptotic cells by dendritic cells, providing a potential mechanism for enhanced immunogenicity. Naked, non-infectious, self-replicating RNA may be an excellent candidate for the development of new cancer vaccines.     

Novel RNA polymerization reaction catalyzed by a group I ribozyme.

We have converted a bacterial tRNA precursor containing a 205 nt self-splicing group I intron into a RNA enzyme that catalyzes polymerization of an external RNA substrate. The reaction involves transesterification steps analogous to both the forward and reverse exon ligation steps of group I splicing; as such it depends entirely on 3' splice site reactions. The RNA substrate is a 20 nt analogue of the ligated exons (E1.E2), whose 3' end resembles the 3' terminus of the intron RNA enzyme (IVS). The splice junction of the substrate is attacked by the 3' end of the intron, then the molecule displaces the original 3' terminal guanosine so that the new 3' terminus is brought into the active site and used as the attacking nucleophile in the next reaction. Polymerization occurs via a series of covalent enzyme-linked intermediates of the structure IVS.(E2)n, where n = 1 to > or = 18. The 5' exon accumulates during the course of the reaction and can attack the covalent intermediates to produce elongation products of structure E1.(E2)n, regenerating the intron RNA enzyme in unchanged form. In this manner, the enzyme converts 20 nt oligoribonucleotides into polyribonucleotides up to at least 180 nt by 10 nt increments. These results have significant implications for the evolution of RNA-based self-replicating systems.     

The search for missing links between self-replicating nucleic ACIDs and the RNA world

The notion that modern metabolism was derived from a complex RNA world in which most reactions were catalyzed by ribozymes has received wide acceptance. However, the evolutionary links between the first self-replicating systems and ribozymes as complex as, say, the Group I self-splicing intron or the HDV ribozyme, have remained elusive. While prebiotic chemists have succeeded in synthesizing short oligonucleotides, it is not immediately obvious how these could have replicated and evolved to the point where they could assume complex shapes and catalytic functions. Nonetheless, recent experiments from a variety of disciplines suggest a plausible pathway from prebiotic chemistry to complex metabolism, and this review is intended as a hypothetical roadmap for the origin and subsequent evolution of life.     

Product analysis of RNA generated de novo by Qβ replicase

Q_β replicase synthesizes self-replicating RNA in the absence of exogenous template after a certain lag time (“template-free synthesis”). The products of the template-free RNA synthesis have been investigated by gel electrophoresis and fingerprinting techniques. It has been found that a multitude of self-replicating RNA species appears in the early phases of reaction with variable lengths and sequences. Template-free synthesis in different samples under completely identical conditions yields RNA products with very different and unrelated fingerprints. The early products rapidly undergo an evolution process that alters the phenotypic properties of the self-replicating RNA, and leads to a concomitant increase of replication efficiency. Fingerprints and electrophoretic mobilities of the self-replicating RNA species are altered discontinuously during the evolution process. The evolution process ends with the selection of optimized self-replicating RNA species, whose phenotypes are conserved even after many serial transfers. Some optimized RNA species and midivariant RNA apparently have related sequences, since they contain many identical spots in their fingerprints. The properties of the RNA species produced by template-free synthesis match those of 6 S RNA found in Q_β-infected Escherichia coli cells. The results are in full agreement with the finding of Sumper & Luce (1975), who have presented evidence that Q_β replicase synthesized RNA de novo in the absence of exogenous template.     

The equilibrium partition function and base pair binding probabilities for RNA secondary structure.

A novel application of dynamic programming to the folding problem for RNA enables one to calculate the full equilibrium partition function for secondary structure and the probabilities of various substructures. In particular, both the partition function and the probabilities of all base pairs are computed by a recursive scheme of polynomial order N3 in the sequence length N. The temperature dependence of the partition function gives information about melting behavior for the secondary structure. The pair binding probabilities, the computation of which depends on the partition function, are visually summarized in a "box matrix" display and this provides a useful tool for examining the full ensemble of probable alternative equilibrium structures. The calculation of this ensemble representation allows a proper application and assessment of the predictive power of the secondary structure method, and yields important information on alternatives and intermediates in addition to local information about base pair opening and slippage. The results are illustrated for representative tRNA, 5S RNA, and self-replicating and self-splicing RNA molecules, and allow a direct comparison with enzymatic structure probes. The effect of changes in the thermodynamic parameters on the equilibrium ensemble provides a further sensitivity check to the predictions.     

Probing the role of a secondary structure element at the 5'- and 3'-splice sites in group I intron self-splicing: the tetrahymena L-16 ScaI ribozyme reveals a new role of the G.U pair in self-splicing

Several ribozyme constructs have been used to dissect aspects of the group I self-splicing reaction. The Tetrahymena L-21 ScaI ribozyme, the best studied of these intron analogues, catalyzes a reaction analogous to the first step of self-splicing, in which a 5'-splice site analogue (S) and guanosine (G) are converted into a 5'-exon analogue (P) and GA. This ribozyme preserves the active site but lacks a short 5'-terminal segment (called the IGS extension herein) that forms dynamic helices, called the P1 extension and P10 helix. The P1 extension forms at the 5'-splice site in the first step of self-splicing, and P10 forms at the 3'-splice site in the second step of self-splicing. To dissect the contributions from the IGS extension and the helices it forms, we have investigated the effects of each of these elements at each reaction step. These experiments were performed with the L-16 ScaI ribozyme, which retains the IGS extension, and with 5'- and 3'-splice site analogues that differ in their ability to form the helices. The presence of the IGS extension strengthens binding of P by 40-fold, even when no new base pairs are formed. This large effect was especially surprising, as binding of S is essentially unaffected for S analogues that do not form additional base pairs with the IGS extension. Analysis of a U.U pair immediately 3' to the cleavage site suggests that a previously identified deleterious effect from a dangling U residue on the L-21 ScaI ribozyme arises from a fortuitous active site interaction and has implications for RNA tertiary structure specificity. Comparisons of the affinities of 5'-splice site analogues that form only a subset of base pairs reveal that inclusion of the conserved G.U base pair at the cleavage site of group I introns destabilizes the P1 extension >100-fold relative to the stability of a helix with all Watson-Crick base pairs. Previous structural data with model duplexes and the recent intron structures suggest that this effect can be attributed to partial unstacking of the P1 extension at the G.U step. These results suggest a previously unrecognized role of the G.U wobble pair in self-splicing: breaking cooperativity in base pair formation between P1 and the P1 extensions. This effect may facilitate replacement of the P1 extension with P10 after the first chemical step of self-splicing and release of the ligated exons after the second step of self-splicing.     

A non-directed, hydroxylamine-generated suppressor mutation in the P3 pairing region of the bacteriophage T4 td intron partially restores self-splicing capability

Hydroxylamine (HA) mutagenesis of an HA-induced splicing-defective bacteriophage T4 td intron mutant with a mutation in the intron P3 RNA pairing region was used to generate pseudorevertants. Because HA can only cause GC to AT transitions, the original mutant (H104A) could not undergo true reversion, yet the compensatory mutation on the opposite side of the P3 helix, which was complementary to the original H104A mutation, could occur. A pseudorevertant was isolated that contained both the original H104A mutation and the compensatory mutation HS9. By phenotypic and molecular genetic criteria, this double mutant (H104A-HS9) was shown to be able to undergo significant RNA splicing, thus confirming the existence and functional importance of the long-range P3 pairing region in this phage intron. The second-site suppressor mutation (HS9) was isolated by phage cross and also exhibited some self-splicing ability. A correlation exists between the strength of P3 helix Watson-Crick base pairing and the apparent level of splicing when wild-type, H104A, HS9, and H104A-HS9 are compared. This suggests that the primary role of the P3 RNA pairing region in the T4 td intron is structural in contributing to the critical RNA secondary structure.     

Function of P11, a tertiary base pairing in self-splicing introns of subgroup IA

There is phylogenetic evidence for the existence of a new pairing in subgroup IA1 self-splicing introns. This tertiary interaction, called P11, which is extraneous to the catalytic centre of these ribozymes was modelled after a "pseudoknot" and grafted by computer modelling on the common core structure of group I introns that was recently proposed by Michel & Westhof. In order to probe the function of the P11 pairing, we mutated the P11 helix in the intron of the large ribosomal precursor of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondria (Sc.LSU). Our experimental data show that the P11 pairing plays a role in stabilizing the overall fold of the RNA molecule. While P11 is not essential for self-splicing activity in vitro, mutants with disrupted P11 require higher concentration of MgCl2 for self-splicing. By contrast, mutants with a reinforced P11 pairing (via introduction of several G.C base-pairs) self-splice more efficiently than the wild-type at 55 degrees C. Based on this work, the possible engineering of new stable versions of the ribozyme is discussed.     

Kinetic characterization of the first step of the ribozyme-catalyzed trans excision-splicing reaction

Group I introns catalyze the self-splicing reaction, and their derived ribozymes are frequently used as model systems for the study of RNA folding and catalysis, as well as for the development of non-native catalytic reactions. Utilizing a group I intron-derived ribozyme from Pneumocystis carinii, we previously reported a non-native reaction termed trans excision-splicing (TES). In this reaction, an internal segment of RNA is excised from an RNA substrate, resulting in the covalent reattachment of the flanking regions. TES proceeds through two consecutive phosphotransesterification reactions, which are similar to the reaction steps of self-splicing. One key difference is that TES utilizes the 3'-terminal guanosine of the ribozyme as the first-step nucleophile, whereas self-splicing utilizes an exogenous guanosine. To further aid in our understanding of ribozyme reactions, a kinetic framework for the first reaction step (substrate cleavage) was established. The results demonstrate that the substrate binds to the ribozyme at a rate expected for simple helix formation. In addition, the rate constant for the first step of the TES reaction is more than one order of magnitude lower than the analogous step in self-splicing. Results also suggest that a conformational change, likely similar to that in self-splicing, exists between the two reaction steps of TES. Finally, multiple turnover is curtailed because dissociation of the cleavage product is slower than the rate of chemistry.     

Two guanosine binding sites exist in group I self-splicing IVS RNAs.

A shortened form of the self-splicing rRNA intervening sequence (IVS) of Tetrahymena thermophila can catalyze a transesterification reaction, termed G-exchange, between a monomeric guanosine derivative such as GTP and the substrate GpN (where N is A, C, G or U). The reaction is specific to the two guanosines involved, providing evidence that two guanosine binding sites exist in this group I IVS RNA. One binding site accommodates a guanosine which initiates self-splicing and the other recognizes the guanosine preceding the 3' splice site. Previously, only one guanosine binding site was thought to be involved in the mechanism of self-splicing. Based on the two functionally distinguishable guanosine binding sites, a new model is proposed to explain how the two independent transesterification reactions required for self-splicing might proceed in a concerted manner.     

Characterization of products derived from self-splicing of intron aI5 alpha which is located in the mitochondrial COX I gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

We have characterized the in vitro self-splicing of intron aI5 alpha containing precursor RNA from the yeast mitochondrial gene coding for cytochrome oxidase subunit I. This intron follows the rules for group I self-splicing introns and all the characteristic products have been identified. In addition we have detected abnormal RNA products with features that indicate that the self-splicing behaviour of this intron is more complex. Two intron circles are formed by use of a major and minor intron-internal site for circle closure. A cryptic 5'-splice site located in the 3' exon results in guanosine nucleotide mediated opening at a position 30 nt downstream of the normal 3' splice site. The reactions can all be explained on the basis of the "splice guide" model proposed by Davies et al (1982 Nature 300 719-724). Although the sequence motifs at cyclization and splice sites occur more often in this intron, only some of them are allowed to interact with the internal guide sequence, suggesting that both primary structure and spatial folding of the RNA are involved in formation of productive reaction sites.     

Toward predicting self-splicing and protein-facilitated splicing of group I introns

In the current era of massive discoveries of noncoding RNAs within genomes, being able to infer a function from a nucleotide sequence is of paramount interest. Although studies of individual group I introns have identified self-splicing and nonself-splicing examples, there is no overall understanding of the prevalence of self-splicing or the factors that determine it among the >2300 group I introns sequenced to date. Here, the self-splicing activities of 12 group I introns from various organisms were assayed under six reaction conditions that had been shown previously to promote RNA catalysis for different RNAs. Besides revealing that assessing self-splicing under only one condition can be misleading, this survey emphasizes that in vitro self-splicing efficiency is correlated with the GC content of the intron (>35% GC was generally conductive to self-splicing), and with the ability of the introns to form particular tertiary interactions. Addition of the Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein activated splicing of two nonself-splicing introns, but inhibited the second step of self-splicing for two others. Together, correlations between sequence, predicted structure and splicing begin to establish rules that should facilitate our ability to predict the self-splicing activity of any group I intron from its sequence.     

Catalysis by RNA

Until the discovery of catalytic RNA, the notion that all enzymes are proteins had seemed incontrovertible. Now the existence of RNA enzymes has been confirmed in a variety of contexts. What is known about the chemistry of RNA-catalyzed reactions is reviewed below, with particular attention to the self-splicing rRNA intron of Tetrahymena thermophila and the processing of pre-tRNA molecules by RNase P.     

Glyoxylate as a Backbone Linkage for a Prebiotic Ancestor of RNA

The origin of the first RNA polymers is central to most current theories for the origin of life. Difficulties associated with the prebiotic formation of RNA have lead to the general consensus that a simpler polymer preceded RNA. However, polymers proposed as possible ancestors to RNA are not much easier to synthesize than RNA itself. One particular problem with the prebiotic synthesis of RNA is the formation of phosphoester bonds in the absence of chemical activation. Here we demonstrate that glyoxylate (the ionized form of glyoxylic acid), a plausible prebiotic molecule, represents a possible ancestor of the phosphate group in modern RNA. Although in low yields (∼ 1%), acetals are formed from glyoxylate and nucleosides under neutral conditions, provided that metal ions are present (e.g., Mg²⁺), and provided that water is removed by evaporation at moderate temperatures (e.g., 65 ^∘C), i.e. under “drying conditions”. Such acetals are termed ga-dinucleotides and possess a linkage that is analogous to the backbone in RNA in both structure and electrostatic charge. Additionally, an energy-minimized model of a gaRNA duplex predicts a helical structure similar to that of A-form RNA. We propose that glyoxylate-acetal linkages would have had certain advantages over phosphate linkages for early self-replicating polymers, but that the distinct functional properties of phosphoester and phosphodiester bonds would have eventually lead to the replacement of glyoxylate by phosphate.