Characterization of steroid-binding macromolecules in small biological samples by a rapid minigel filtration method

A gel filtration method using small Sephadex G-200 columns has been developed for study of steroid-binding macromolecules. Rapid (2 hr) characterization of high affinity steroid-binding proteins is possible with this technique. It allows the study of a specific serum steroid binder such as sex steroid-binding globulin and permits its separation from the target tissue cytosolic estradiol receptor which was eluted as a single molety, both at low and high ionic strength. The technique provides an approach to the steroid receptor characterization presenting some advantages over the widely used density gradient centrifugation procedure. Due to the small amounts of binding proteins required, the method appears particularly well suited for the microanalysis of pathological material such as cancer tissue from humans.     

Interaction of glucocorticoid · receptor complexes with rat liver nuclei

Some previous reports on acellular binding of glucocorticoid · receptor complexes to rat liver nuclei have pointed to the conclusion that there exists a small number of high affinity nuclear “receptor” sites. Various investigations lead us to the opposite conclusion and suggest that these results were actually due to the presence, in the cytosol, of one or several macromolecules which inhibited the binding to nuclei of steroid · receptor complexes. The mechanism of this inhibition was examined. It appeared to be due not to a competition between both molecules for the same nuclear acceptor site but to an interaction in the cytosol between teh inhibitor and the steroid · receptor complex which prevented the binding of the latter to the nuclei. The search for high affinity specific acceptor sites was also negative for physiological saline conditions and for the non-salt-extractable fraction of the nuclear receptor. When 940-fold purified receptor · steroid complexes were used, very high concentrations of complexes could be achieved and saturation of nuclei was then observed, but only under physiological ionic strength conditions. However, the interaction was of relatively low affinity (K_A = 3.8 · 10⁷ M^?1) and to a great number of acceptor sites (N = 26.2 pmol/mg DNA), largely exceeding the cellular concentration of receptor (5.8 pmol/mg DNA).These results suggested that saturation of nuclei by steroid · receptor complexes should not occur in the intact liver cell. They were confirmed by studies on the distribution of steroid · receptor complexes in liver slices incubated with various concentrations of [³H]dexamethasone. For all hormone concentrations a constant proportion (90%) of the complexes was found in the nuclei, thus showing no saturation of the nuclear acceptor sites.     

Two high-affinity ligand binding states of uterine estrogen receptor distinguished by modulation of hydrophobic environment

The steroid binding function of soluble (cytosolic) estrogen receptors from calf uteri was evaluated under conditions known to modify the extent of hydrophobic interaction with receptor-associated proteins. Receptor preparations were equilibrated into 6 M urea (+/- 0.4 M KCl) buffers and control buffers (+/- 0.4 M KCl) by chromatography through small columns of Sephadex G-25 or by dialysis at 0-6 degrees C. Equilibrium dissociation constants (Kd) and binding capacities (n) of experimental and control receptor preparations were determined by 13-point Scatchard analyses using concentrations of 17 beta-[3H]estradiol from 0.05 to 10 nM. Nonspecific binding was determined at each concentration by parallel incubations with a 200-fold molar excess of the receptor-specific competitor diethylstilbestrol. The control receptor population was consistently found to be a single class of binding sites with a high affinity for estradiol (Kd = 0.36 +/- 0.09 nM, n = 14) which was unaffected by G-25 chromatography, by dialysis, by dilution, or by the presence of 0.4 M KCl. However, equilibration into 6 M urea induced a discrete (10-fold) reduction in receptor affinity (Kd = 3.45 +/- 0.86 nM, n = 6) to reveal a second, thermodynamically stable, high-affinity binding state. The presence of 0.4 M KCl did not significantly influence the discrete change in receptor affinity induced by urea. However, KCl did help prevent the reduction in binding capacity induced by urea. The effects of urea on both receptor affinity and binding capacity were reversible, suggesting a lack of covalent modification.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Estradiol-17β receptors in the immature rat ovary

Estradiol binding components in the cytosol and nuclear fractions of the ovary from immature rats (22–28 days old) were characterized by $\text{in vitro}$ methods. Several of the biochemical characteristics of the estradiol binding components in the ovarian tissue were compared with the estradiol receptor from the uterus. The results suggest that the ovarian estradiol binding components are similar to the specific high affinity estradiol receptors in the uterus. In the cytosol of intact rat ovary a significant fraction of the total binding sites was found to be occupied, presumably by the endogenous estrogen. Following hypophysectomy there was a significant increase in the available cytosol binding sites. Evidence for translocation of cytosol receptor-estrogen (RE) complex to the nucleus was obtained for the ovary. The sedimentation properties of the RE complex of the ovary and the uterus are similar. The ovarian cytosol RE complex sediments at 7-8S in glycerol gradients at low ionic strength and at 4S in sucrose gradients at high ionic strength. Following extraction with 0.4 M KCl the ovarain nuclear RE complex sediments at 5S in sucrose gradients which is identical to that of the uterine nuclear receptor.     

Characterization of estrogen receptors in the hamster brain

Although the hamster is frequently used as an experimental animal for studying reproductive neuroendocrinology and sex behavior, estrogen receptors (ER) in the central nervous system have not been fully characterized. Using Sephadex LH-20 gel filtration and DNA-cellulose affinity chromatography, estrogen binding macromolecules having the physicochemical properties of classical ER were identified in cytosolic and nuclear extracts of brain tissues. These receptors exhibited high affinity for estradiol (Kd = 10(-9) M), limited capacity (30-50 fmol/g tissue), and estrogen specificity; however, competition studies indicate that brain and uterine ER have different binding kinetics. The neuroanatomic distribution of ER was similar in males and females with highest levels in the limbic brain and consistently low levels in remaining forebrain and mid/hindbrain. No sex differences in receptor number or other binding parameters were evident. Sucrose gradient centrifugation showed that cytosolic ER sedimented in the 7-8S region of a 5-20% linear gradient (no salt), whereas nuclear ER had a sedimentation coefficient of 5S under high ionic strength. On DNA-cellulose affinity columns, these receptors had an elution maximum of 0.18 M NaCl. After a single injection of estradiol, nuclear ER increased and cytosolic ER were depleted. The lower estradiol binding affinity and receptor levels in hamster brain as compared to the rat are consistent with observed species differences in neural sensitivity to estrogen. We expect these data in hamsters, a markedly photosensitive species, to provide a basis for future studies examining the role of receptors in mediating the effects of day-length on steroid dependent feedback and behavioral responses.     

DNA and protein components of nuclear acceptor sites for androgen receptors in the rat prostate

Androgen receptor-acceptor complexes in nuclei from rat ventral prostates were cross-linked in situ with formaldehyde and partially purified using affinity chromatography. To isolate acceptor DNA, the cross-linked receptor-acceptor complexes in formaldehyde-treated chromatin samples were adsorbed to dihydrotestosterone-17 beta-succinyl agarose, eluted with 75 microM dihydrotestosterone-1% SDS, digested with proteinase K and extracted with phenol-chloroform. After 32P end-labelling and PAGE, this DNA contained two distinct bands of DNA (about 300 and 400 base pairs respectively) which were unique relative to the total prostatic DNA. As an alternative approach for characterizing acceptor DNA, the DNA in prostatic nuclei and cross-linked chromatin was labelled with 32P by nick translation and analysed in glycerol density gradients for associations with cross-linked androgen receptors. A symmetrical 7s peak of 32P-DNA with a small amount of coincident receptor was observed in the gradients after mild trypsin treatment. In the absence of trypsin treatment, both the cross-linked receptors and the labelled DNA sedimented to the bottom of the gradients. Isolation of acceptor proteins involved iodination of cross-linked chromatin with 125I and androgen affinity chromatography. A comparison of the relative efficiency of retention and elution of 125I-proteins from different affinity columns revealed that testosterone-17 beta-succinyl agarose was potentially most suitable for purification of acceptor proteins. After electrophoresis on SDS-polyacrylamide gels, the eluates from this type of affinity matrix were found to contain two major peaks of 125I-labelled proteins--one corresponding to a protein with a similar molecular weight as the nuclear androgen receptor (33,000 Da); the other having a molecular weight of 20,000 Da. While the precise identity of this latter entity is unknown, its enrichment and retention by the affinity gel implies that it is closely associated with the androgen receptor and may be a component of the acceptor sites.     

Characteristics of the corticosterone-receptor complex in rat liver cytosol.

Using a gel filtration on Sephadex G-150 in low ionic strength, it was possible to separate a corticosterone-binding protein in rat liver cytosol from corticosteroid-binding globulin after incubation of cytosol with [3H]corticosterone. The corticosterone-protein complex ("alpha-Complex") had a sedimentation coefficient of 8-9 S in low ionic strength. In high ionic strength, the alpha-Complex rapidly dissociated with a half-life of 15 h, compared to a half-life of 31 h for the hepatic dexamethasone-receptor complex under identical conditions (0 degrees C). The alpha-Compelx was saturable with an excess of unlabelled corticosterone of dexamethasone and was sensitive to heat and protease digestion. It is stressed that quantitation of the corticosterone-receptor complex must include separation of the receptor from corticosteroid-binding globulin as this protein binds corticosterone with high affinity and with a saturable amount of binding sites.     

Modulation of the estrogen receptor's affinity for DNA by estradiol

The binding constant for estrogen receptor-DNA interaction when measured in the presence and absence of estradiol revealed a distinct difference dependent upon whether the receptor was hormone-bound or hormone-free. The binding constant of estrogen receptor-DNA interaction was determined by analysis of the exponential elution profile of the estrogen receptor from DNA-Sepharose columns using Tris buffer at a constant salt concentration. The binding constant of the hormone-bound estrogen receptor for DNA in Tris buffer, pH 7.4, containing 0.2 M KCl was 10.1 +/- 0.8 X 10(6) M-1, 5-fold higher than the value for the hormone-free estrogen receptor. Analysis of the number of ionic bonds between the estrogen receptor and DNA indicates that the hormone-free receptor establishes eight salt bridges, while the hormone-bound estrogen receptor establishes 10-13. The affinity of the hormone-bound estrogen receptor for DNA in Tris buffer at pH 7.4 in 0.2 M KCl is 10-fold greater than at pH 8.0, suggesting that ionic bonding between the receptor and DNA may involve histidine residues of the receptor. The concentration-dependence of the hormone-bound receptor's affinity for DNA emphasizes the receptor's associative state as an influence on the receptor's DNA binding characteristics. Our results demonstrate that estradiol modifies the conformation of the estrogen receptor to a state having an increased affinity for DNA.     

Glucocorticoid receptors in lung. Comparison between nonactivated and activated forms of the cytoplasmic glucocorticoid binding protein and their relationship to the nuclear binding protein of fetal rabbit lung.

In the absence of salt the cytoplasmic glucocorticoid receptor of fetal rabbit lung sediments at 7 S while the nuclear receptor sediments at 4 S. However, if nuclear extracts are mixed with receptor-depleted cytosol preparations in dilute buffer solutions without added salt, the nuclear 4 S receptor sediments as a 7 S species similar to that observed for the cytoplasmic form under the same conditions suggesting an interaction of the nuclear receptor with other cytosol proteins rather than with itself. In addition, both cytoplasmic and nuclear receptors sediment at 4 S in 0.4 M KCl and a major fraction of the nuclear receptor has an agarose elution profile identical to that of the cytoplasmic receptor. Thus a major fraction of the nuclear receptors is indistinguishable from the cytoplasmic receptors by the methods used. Since the cytoplasmic receptor sediments at 4 S in 0.15 M KCl, it is suggested that in vivo the glucocorticoid receptor may exist as a 4 S species and that the 7 S form described previously may result from an interaction of the 4 S component with other cytosol proteins in hypotonic media. About 25% of the receptor present in nuclear extracts has an agarose elution profile different from that of the cytoplasmic receptor in 0.4 M KCl. This suggests that either the nuclear receptor associates with itself or other nuclear proteins or that more than one form of nuclear receptor exists. Earlier observations suggested that in the absence of hormone the glucocorticoid receptor is localized exclusively in the cytoplasm of lung cells and that the nuclear receptor is formed by a transfer of the cytoplasmic steroid-receptor complex into the nucleus. A prerequisite for this transfer seems to be a modification of the receptor to an active form which can bind to nuclei. This receptor transfomration, referred to in this paper as activation of the receptor, can occur in the absence of nuclei and is highly dependent on temperature and ionic strength. Cytoplasmic receptors activated either by heating or by exposure to high ionic strength are indistinguishable from nonactivated receptors by sucrose density gradient analysis or by agarose gel filtration in solutions containing 0.4 M KCl. Simiarly, no significant difference in the absence of salt is observed after activation by heating. These results suggest that activation of the cytoplasmic glucocorticoid receptor involves conformational changes which favor its transfer and/or binding to nuclear sites rather than conversion of a 4 S species to a faster-sedimenting form by dimerization or by addition of another protein unit as has been proposed for the activation of the estrogen receptor of the rat uterus.     

Solubilized nuclear "receptors" for thyroid hormones. Physical characteristics and binding properties, evidence for multiple forms.

Tissues regulated by thyroid hormones contain chromatin-localized "receptors" that may be involved in the actions of these hormones. In this report, we describe some properties of these receptors after their solubilization from rat liver nuclei and their separation from nucleic acids and basic proteins. The nuclear extract and partially purified preparations contain a dominant class of binding sites which have a high affinity for triiodothyronine (3,5,3'-triiodo-L-thyronine, Kd approximately 1 nM) and for the biologically potent isopropyl diiodothyronine (3,5-diiodo-3'-isopropyl-L-thyronine, Kd congruent to 1 nM) and also bind thyroxine (3,5,3',5'-tetraiodo-L-thyronine, Kd approximately 5 nM) and reverse triiodothyronine (3,3',5'-triiodo-L-thyronine, Kd approximately nM). This binding activity elutes on Sephadex G-100 in an included peak which has a Stokes radius of 35 A and sediments on glycerol gradients at 3.5 S. From these data a molecular weight ratio of 50,500 and a frictional ratio of 1.4 were calculated, suggesting that the receptor is somewhat asymmetrical. There was a sharp decline in triiodothyronine binding by this component above pH 8.7 (optimum around pH 7.6) where there is marked dissociation of the 4' phenolic hydroxyl of triiodothyronine (pKalpha approximately 8.5). A similar decrease in thyroxine (pKalpha approximately 6.7) binding with pH increases in this range was not observed. Thus, ionization of the phenolic hydroxyl may influence binding. The solubilized preparations can also contain a minor specific-binding component that can be identified by binding analyses, and by G-100 or quaternary aminoethyl Sephadex chromatography. this component has a much lower affinity for triiodothyronine and isopropyl diiodothyronine than for thyroxine as compared to the major component. It probably has a pH optima around 6.0 and demonstrates and apparent tendency to aggregate. The minor component was not always identified by direct Scatchard analysis and may be generated in part from the major component as it was more commonly observed after storage or purification of the nuclear extract. Thus, at least two thyroid hormone-binding components can be present in extracts of purified rat liver nuclei; the minor component may be an altered form or subunit of the major component. The relative binding activities of triiodothyronine, isopropyl diiodothyronine, and thyroxine by the major component, similar to those in intact nuclei, parallel the biological potencies of these compounds, and suggest that the dominant binding is by biologically relevant receptors. Since ionization of the phenolic hydroxyl may influence binding, the lower activity of thyroxine relative to triiodothyronine may in part be due to the fact that at physiological pH, the phenolic hydroxyl of thyroxine is more dissociated than is that of triiodothyronine. The finding that this receptor is somewhat asymmetrical provides an indication of the shape of an intrinsic chromatin protein implicated in specific gene regulation...     

Binding of glucocorticoid receptors to DNA.

DNA has been implicated as the nuclear acceptor for receptor-glucocorticoid complexes. The present study concerns the interaction of these complexes, isolated from cultured rat hepatoma cells, with purified DNA. This association is rapid, reaching a maximum within a few minutes at 0 degrees, whereas dissociation requires several hours. DNA binds neither free glucocorticoids nor those complexed with transcortin or cytosol proteins different from the receptor. Receptors which are not complexed by steroid have little or no affinity for DNA. "Activation," necessary for the binding of receptor-steroid complexes to isolated nuclei, also enhances DNA binding. The capacity of DNA for binding receptor-steroid complexes is large; saturation was not observed at the complex concentrations studied, using either crude or partially purified receptor preparations. The association of complexes with DNA is inhibited by divalent cations, at increasing ionic strengths, and by mercurial reagents. Complexes bind equally well to bacterial, bacteriophage, or rat DNA; however, there was either no or substantially reduced binding by bacterial 23 S rRNA. The binding of complexes to native DNA is roughly 3-fold greater than to denatured DNA. These characteristics are consistent with the possibility that DNA is the nuclear acceptor for receptor-glucocorticoid complexes; however, the actual composition of the acceptor sites remains unknown.     

Interaction of the hepatic glucocorticoid-receptor complex with Affigel blue

Summary Unlike the unactivated glucocorticoid-receptor complex, the thermally activated glucocorticoid-receptor complex was able to bind to Affigel blue (a matrix previously shown to bind proteins containing a dinucleotide fold region) under low ionic conditions (0.05 M KCl). Glucocorticoid-receptor complex binding capacity to Affigel blue was enhanced by increasing salt concentration. Optimal binding was obtained at 0.15 M KCl and remained at a plateau level up to 0.4 M KCl. In contrast to Affigel blue binding, glucocorticoid-receptor complex binding to nuclei was optimum at low ionic strength buffer, declined at 0.15 M KCl and became negligible at 0.4 M KCl. Interestingly, at physiological ionic strength (0.15 M KCl) both nuclei and Affigel blue bound to the glucocorticoid-receptor complex with almost identical capacity. Glucocorticoid-receptor complexes incubated 45 min at 25 °C (activation conditions) in the presence of 10 mM molybdate were unable to bind to Affigel blue (or isolated nuclei) as expected. The results obtained suggest that Affigel blue mimics isolated nuclei in the binding of activated glucocorticoid-receptor complexes under physiological (0.15 M KCl) conditions. In addition, Affigel blue may provide a rapid and easy method to study glucocorticoid-receptor complex activation and interaction with nuclear acceptor sites.     

Characterization of estrogen binding proteins in mouse liver cytosol: absence of sexual dimorphism

Estrogen binding proteins in mouse liver cytosol were characterized by separation on Sephadex G-75 columns, by Scatchard plot analysis, and by hormonal competition studies. A high affinity receptor (56-70 fmol/mg cytosolic protein) with a mol. wt greater than 75,000, Kd of 5.7-8.4 X 10(-10) M was identified in male and female C3H liver. A second high capacity low affinity (HCLA) binder (200-300 fmol/mg cytosolic protein) with a mol. wt of about 50,000, Kd of 1.7-7.2 X 10(-8) was also identified. Following partial purification of the estrogen binders by ammonium sulfate precipitation, Scatchard plot analysis revealed selective removal of HCLA. On Sephadex G-75 filtration, the purification also resulted in selective removal of the 17 beta-estradiol binding component with a mol. wt of 50,000. Comparison with rat cytosol separations show that the sexual dimorphism in HCLA binding proteins (5 times higher in male than female rat liver) was absent in the mouse liver. These studies document the presence of a specific high affinity estrogen binding protein in mouse liver and indicate that the sexual dimorphism in HCLA proteins is not a universal feature of all rodent species.     

Purification of rat renal renin from crude kidney extracts by diaminohexamethylene-Sepharose chromatography

Renin from rat kidney extracts was adsorbed to diaminohexamethylene-sepharose columns at extremely low ionic strength and neutral pH. Renin was retarded while the column was developed in 1 mM sodiumpyrophosphate and extraneous proteins were removed. Elution of renin was performed using a linear gradient of sodiumpyrophosphate, 1 – 17 mM at pH 6.8. Renin was purified in a yield up to approx. 60 per cent of the applied activity and a purification factor between 5 – 122 depending on the specific activity of the applied sample. The specific activity after this single chromatography of crude rat kidney homogenate on diaminohexamethylene-sepharose showed a median of 11.3 Goldblatt units per mg protein in a range of 5.3 – 42.0 Goldblatt units per mg protein. The renin binding capacity of the column was 1 Goldblatt unit per ml wet gel. The purified renin was subjected to G-100 Sephadex chromatography demonstrating two molecular weight forms of 44000 and 50000 dalton. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis demonstrated three separate fractions of renin.     

Interactions of the nuclear thyroid hormone receptor with core histones

These studies concern the interactions of the rat liver thyroid hormone nuclear receptor with histones and factors influencing the receptor's assay and stability. Heating certain crude receptor preparations at 50 degrees C produces a selective loss of triiodothyronine (T3) but not thyroxine (T4) binding activity, whereas, with more purified preparations, such heating decreases both T3 and T4 binding. The selective T3-binding loss in crude preparations was found to be due to the simultaneous denaturation of the receptor's high-affinity hormone-binding activity for both T3 and T4 and generation of new low-affinity T4-binding sites. The fraction in which T4 binding can be activated could be separated from the receptors by Sephadex G-100 chromatography. Core histones stimulated both T3- and T4-binding activity of 6-fold-purified receptor preparations, and data from several different experimental approaches suggest that this stimulation is due to the capability of the core histones to prevent the receptor from binding to or being denatured by Sephadex G-25 assay columns. The core histones were also found to stabilize 500-fold-purified but not 6-fold-purified or crude receptor preparations. A number of other acidic or basic proteins had little or none of these stimulatory effects, whereas a few proteins (such as the insulin B chain and histone H1) did have activity, although it was less than that of the core histones. There were no significant differences between the purified core histone subfractions (H2A, H2B, H3, and H4). That core histones can interact with the thyroid hormone receptors was demonstrated more directly by the finding that the receptors bind to histone-Sepharose but not Sepharose or insulin- or ovalbumin-Sepharose columns and that this binding was blocked by core histones at concentrations suggestive of an affinity for the receptor-core histone interaction of around 3 microM at 0.15 M salt concentration. The results demonstrate the utility of the histones in the assay and stabilization of purified thyroid hormone receptors, but they fail to support our previous hypothesis of a receptor subunit where T3- but not T4-binding activity is regulated selectively by histones. However, the results indicate that histones may interact with the receptors with some degree of specificity, and they raise the possibility that the histones participate in the nuclear localization of the receptors.     

A low molecular weight inhibitor of steroid receptor activation.

Dilution at 0 degrees of rat liver cytosol incubated with [3H]triamcinolone acetonide provoked an enhanced binding of steroid-receptor complexes to nuclei. The explanation of this phenomenon was found to be an "activation" of the complexes. Dilution acted by decreasing the concentration of a cytosol inhibitor. This reaction was irreversible at 0 degrees: once activated the complexes could not be reversed to the nonactivated state by the addition of inhibitor. The presence of hormone was necessary, since hormone-free receptor molecules could not be activated by dilution. Removal of the inhibitor did not lead to activation of all complexes: after 24 h a "plateau" was attained where 55 to 70% of the complexes were activated. The inhibitor was shown to be a low molecular weight molecule by dialysis, Sephadex G-25 chromatography, ammonium sulfate precipitation, and ultrafiltration. Thus [3H]triamcinolone acetonide-receptor complexes present in a cytosol from which the inhibitor had been removed by Sephadex G-25 chromatography became spontaneously activated at low ionic strength and at 0 degrees. The inhibitor is not a steroid (at least of usual polarity) since it cannot be extracted by methylene chloride or adsorbed by activated charcoal. It is thermostable (resists to 30 min at 100 degrees). Its removal by incubation with a cation exchange resin suggests that it may be positively charged, however it is not complexed by EDTA. This inhibitor must be distinguished from a previously described inhibitor of steroid-receptor complexes binding to nuclei. The latter compound has been shown in various systems to be responsible for an artifactual saturation of nuclear acceptor by steroid-receptor complexes. It inhibits the binding to nuclear acceptors of already activated complexes and is probably a macromolecule. It is thus different from the low molecular weight activation inhibitor described in the present paper.     

Calcium binding to troponin C. II. A Ca2+ ion titration study with a Ca2+ ion sensitive electrode

The effects of pH,Mg2+, and ionic strength on Ca2+ binding to rabbit skeletal troponin C were studied by using a Ca2+ sensitive electrode. Troponin C has two high affinity and two low affinity sites and the Ca2+ affinity of both sites was increased by increasing pH in a pH range from pH 5.6 to 10.4. The affinity was decreased by increasing ionic strength. The change of the Ca2+ affinity can be explained by the electrostatic interaction between Ca2+ and the protein. At alkaline pH, the four Ca2+ binding sites bind Ca2+ with the same affinity and the distinction between the high and the low affinity sites vanished. This result shows that the difference of the Ca2+ affinity is owing to differences of the secondary or the tertiary structure of the Ca2+ binding sites, not owing to a difference of the primary structures of the Ca2+ binding sites. The two high affinity sites bound two Ca2+ ions cooperatively in neutral pH. The cooperativity was diminished at both acidic and alkaline pH. Mg2+ ion decreased the affinity of the low affinity sites.