Comparison of culturable fecal coliforms and Escherichia coli enumeration in freshwaters

Fecal coliforms (FC) counts were compared with Escherichia coli counts in differently contaminated freshwater samples (n = 166). FC were enumerated by plate count on triphenyl 2,3,5-tetrazolium chloride Tergitol medium. Escherichia coli were enumerated by the most probable number microplate method based on the detection of glucuronidase activity. FC and E. coli counts were highly correlated; an average E. coli/FC ratio equal to 0.77 was found, meaning that on average, 77% of FC were E. coli. Knowing the E. coli/FC ratio allows us to convert the historical microbiological quality data expressed in FC counts into E. coli abundance and thus to compare with present and future monitoring data that are (or will be) based on E. coli enumeration.     

Comparison of methods for enumeration of selected coliforms exposed to ozone

mT7 medium performed no better than m-Endo medium in enumerating cells of Escherichia coli and Citrobacter freundii exposed to ozone. Also, there was no difference in the plate count of heterotrophic bacteria in ozonated raw water determined on modified Henrici agar or R2A agar. Statistically significant differences were seen between bacteria and the type of water in which they were suspended during ozonation.     

Comparison of methods for enumeration of selected coliforms exposed to ozone.

mT7 medium performed no better than m-Endo medium in enumerating cells of Escherichia coli and Citrobacter freundii exposed to ozone. Also, there was no difference in the plate count of heterotrophic bacteria in ozonated raw water determined on modified Henrici agar or R2A agar. Statistically significant differences were seen between bacteria and the type of water in which they were suspended during ozonation.     

A rapid method for the enumeration of coliforms in processed foods by ion mobility spectrometry

The number of coliforms in processed food was enumerated rapidly by the use of ion mobility spectrometry. This method measured the time to observe o -nitrophenol liberated from the substrate o -nitrophenylgalactoside and was inversely proportional to the logarithm of the initial coliform count. The presence or absence of coliforms was determined within 12 h. This assay was unsuitable for non-processed foods due to the presence of an endogenous β-galactosidase enzyme.     

Automated electrical impedance technique for rapid enumeration of fecal coliforms in effluents from sewage treatment plants.

Fecal coliforms growing in a selective lactose-based broth medium at 44.5 degrees C generate a change in the electrical impedance of the culture relative to a sterile control when populations reach 10(6) to 10(7) per ml. The ratio of these changes was measured automatically, and the data were processed by computer. A linear relation was found between the log10 of the number of fecal coliforms in an inoculum and the time required for an electrical impedance ratio signal to be detected. Pure culture inocula consisting of 100 fecal coliforms in log phase or stationary phase were detected in 6.5 and 7.7 h, respectively. Standard curves of log10 fecal coliforms in wastewater inocula versus detection time, based on samples collected at a sewage treatment plant over a 4-month period, were found to vary from one another with time. Nevertheless, detection times were rapid and ranged from 5.8 to 7.9 h for 200 fecal coliforms to 8.7 to 11.4 h for 1 fecal coliform. Variations in detection times for a given number of fecal coliforms were also found among sewage treatment plants. A strategy is proposed which takes these variations into account and allows for rapid, automated enumeration of fecal coliforms in wastewater by the electrical impedance ratio technique.     

Comparison of selected methods for the enumeration of fecal coliforms and Escherichia coli in shellfish.

In a comparison of five selected methods for the enumeration of fecal coliforms and Escherichia coli in naturally contaminated and sewage-seeded mussels (Choromytilus spp.) and oysters (Ostrea spp.), a spread-plate procedure with mFC agar without rosolic acid and preincubation proved the method of choice for routine quality assessment.     

Automated electrical impedance technique for rapid enumeration of fecal coliforms in effluents from sewage treatment plants.

Fecal coliforms growing in a selective lactose-based broth medium at 44.5 degrees C generate a change in the electrical impedance of the culture relative to a sterile control when populations reach 10(6) to 10(7) per ml. The ratio of these changes was measured automatically, and the data were processed by computer. A linear relation was found between the log10 of the number of fecal coliforms in an inoculum and the time required for an electrical impedance ratio signal to be detected. Pure culture inocula consisting of 100 fecal coliforms in log phase or stationary phase were detected in 6.5 and 7.7 h, respectively. Standard curves of log10 fecal coliforms in wastewater inocula versus detection time, based on samples collected at a sewage treatment plant over a 4-month period, were found to vary from one another with time. Nevertheless, detection times were rapid and ranged from 5.8 to 7.9 h for 200 fecal coliforms to 8.7 to 11.4 h for 1 fecal coliform. Variations in detection times for a given number of fecal coliforms were also found among sewage treatment plants. A strategy is proposed which takes these variations into account and allows for rapid, automated enumeration of fecal coliforms in wastewater by the electrical impedance ratio technique.     

Comparison of Colilert with Dutch standard enumeration methods for Escherichia coli and total coliforms in water

The average recovery of Escherichia coli with Colilert was 26% (range 12–42%) and that for coliforms was 35% (range 4–140%, when compared with Dutch standard methods. In samples with low numbers of target organisms, Colilert gave false-negative results and was therefore regarded as an unsuitable alternative for Dutch standard methods.     

EU Drinking Water Directive reference methods for enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli compared with alternative methods

AIMS: The reference methods for enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli as stated in the European Drinking Water Directive were compared with alternative methods. METHODS AND RESULTS: Laboratories used the reference method on Lactose TTC agar (LTTC), the Colilert/18 system, Laurysulphate Agar (LSA), Chromocult Coliform Agar and the E. coli Direct Plating (DP) method. They enumerated more total coliforms on LTTC than on LSA. CONCLUSIONS: LTTC is suitable for analysis of very clean water samples only, due to heavy background growth. Colilert/18 is a good alternative but it enumerates a broader group of total coliforms, resulting in higher counts. The DP method appeared to be the best choice for enumeration of E. coli because Colilert/18 produces lower counts and false-negative results. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study shows the limitations of the EU reference method on LTTC due to lack of selectivity and suggests alternative methods for the enumeration of total coliforms and E. coli.     

Detection and enumeration of coliforms in drinking water: current methods and emerging approaches.

The coliform group has been used extensively as an indicator of water quality and has historically led to the public health protection concept. The aim of this review is to examine methods currently in use or which can be proposed for the monitoring of coliforms in drinking water. Actually, the need for more rapid, sensitive and specific tests is essential in the water industry. Routine and widely accepted techniques are discussed, as are methods which have emerged from recent research developments.Approved traditional methods for coliform detection include the multiple-tube fermentation (MTF) technique and the membrane filter (MF) technique using different specific media and incubation conditions. These methods have limitations, however, such as duration of incubation, antagonistic organism interference, lack of specificity and poor detection of slow-growing or viable but non-culturable (VBNC) microorganisms. Nowadays, the simple and inexpensive membrane filter technique is the most widely used method for routine enumeration of coliforms in drinking water.The detection of coliforms based on specific enzymatic activity has improved the sensitivity of these methods. The enzymes beta-D galactosidase and beta-D glucuronidase are widely used for the detection and enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli, respectively. Many chromogenic and fluorogenic substrates exist for the specific detection of these enzymatic activities, and various commercial tests based on these substrates are available. Numerous comparisons have shown these tests may be a suitable alternative to the classical techniques. They are, however, more expensive, and the incubation time, even though reduced, remains too long for same-day results. More sophisticated analytical tools such as solid phase cytometry can be employed to decrease the time needed for the detection of bacterial enzymatic activities, with a low detection threshold.Detection of coliforms by molecular methods is also proposed, as these methods allow for very specific and rapid detection without the need for a cultivation step. Three molecular-based methods are evaluated here: the immunological, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and in-situ hybridization (ISH) techniques. In the immunological approach, various antibodies against coliform bacteria have been produced, but the application of this technique often showed low antibody specificity. PCR can be used to detect coliform bacteria by means of signal amplification: DNA sequence coding for the lacZ gene (beta-galactosidase gene) and the uidA gene (beta-D glucuronidase gene) has been used to detect total coliforms and E. coli, respectively. However, quantification with PCR is still lacking in precision and necessitates extensive laboratory work. The FISH technique involves the use of oligonucleotide probes to detect complementary sequences inside specific cells. Oligonucleotide probes designed specifically for regions of the 16S RNA molecules of Enterobacteriaceae can be used for microbiological quality control of drinking water samples. FISH should be an interesting viable alternative to the conventional culture methods for the detection of coliforms in drinking water, as it provides quantitative data in a fairly short period of time (6 to 8 h), but still requires research effort.This review shows that even though many innovative bacterial detection methods have been developed, few have the potential for becoming a standardized method for the detection of coliforms in drinking water samples.     

Use of a microbial fuel cell for the rapid enumeration of bacteria

Summary The detection of bacteria using a thionine mediated microbial fuel cell was examined. On addition of bacteria to the anode compartment of a fuel cell, a rapid increase in the current output was observed. Both the total change in the steady state current (mA) and the initial rate of change of current were proportional to the numbers of bacteria added. Regression analysis of plots of log₁₀ mA against log₁₀ bacteria ml^-1 (final concentration) upon the addition of E. coli K12, Lactococcus lactis, coliform sp. A1, Micrococcus sp. M3 but not Pseudomonas sp. P5 gave reasonable correlation coefficients. Determination of the rates of respiration and thionine reduction by E. coli indicated that the transfer of metabolic electrons from the bacteria to the mediator was reasonably efficient (approx. 50%). These results are discussed with respect to the potential application of this technique for the rapid estimation of the bacterial contamination of foods.     

Comparison of different media for the enumeration of Aeromonas sp. in freshwaters

I. KERSTERS, N. SMEYERS AND W. VERSTRAETE. 1996. Ampicillin-dextrin agar (ADA), m-Aeromonas agar (mA), starch glutamate ampicillin penicillin C-glucose agar (SGAP-10C), trehalose agar (TRE) and ampicillin bile salts inositol xylose agar (MIX) were evaluated for the isolation of Aeromonas sp. from aquatic environments. Recovery of pure cultures was excellent on all media, except for Aer. sobria on SGAP-10C and MIX agars. Recovery of Aeromonas sp. from freshwaters was comparable on ADA, mA, SGAP-10C and TRE. The most selective media were SGAP-10C and ADA, which yielded an average reduction factor of more than 2.9 log. The ability to differentiate Aeromonas sp. from the background microbiota present in freshwaters was best on ADA. The present findings indicate that ADA is the most adequate medium for the selective isolation of Aeromonas sp. from freshwaters.     

Plating procedure for the enumeration of coliforms from dairy products.

A "repair-detection" procedure consisting of pour plating of food samples with Trypticase soy agar, followed by 1-h repair incubation at room temperature and subsequent overlay with violet red bile agar, was found to be an effective method for the detection of injuried and uninjuried coliforms from dairy products. This method was relatively less effective for the detection of coliforms in many semipreserved foods as compared with dairy products, but more effective than the most-probable-number method.     

Plating procedure for the enumeration of coliforms from dairy products.

A "repair-detection" procedure consisting of pour plating of food samples with Trypticase soy agar, followed by 1-h repair incubation at room temperature and subsequent overlay with violet red bile agar, was found to be an effective method for the detection of injuried and uninjuried coliforms from dairy products. This method was relatively less effective for the detection of coliforms in many semipreserved foods as compared with dairy products, but more effective than the most-probable-number method.     

Evaluation of a rapid, defined substrate technology method for enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in chlorinated drinking water

A rapid, defined substrate technology method, commercially available as Colilert, simultaneously enumerates total coliforms and Escherichia coli in drinking water samples in 24 h without the need for confirmatory tests. The ability of this method to enumerate both total coliforms and E. coli in simulated chlorine-treated drinking water samples was compared with the standard UK method (minerals-modified glutamate most probable number) which requires up to 96 h to complete including confirmation. Statistical analysis by a nonparametric matched-pair test showed the Colilert method to be less efficient at detecting down to one E. coli in these samples compared to the standard UK method. No statistically significant difference between the two methods of enumeration for total coliforms was detected.     

Comparative study of methods for the enumeration of total and fecal coliforms in the eastern oyster, Crassostrea virginica.

Violet red bile agar and Coli-Count Sampler (Millipore Corp.) procedures were shown to be acceptable alternatives to the standard most-probable-number method for monitoring relative coliform levels in oysters.     

Comparative study of methods for the enumeration of total and fecal coliforms in the eastern oyster, Crassostrea virginica.

Violet red bile agar and Coli-Count Sampler (Millipore Corp.) procedures were shown to be acceptable alternatives to the standard most-probable-number method for monitoring relative coliform levels in oysters.     

Evaluation of PetrifilmTM methods for enumeration of aerobic flora and coliforms in a wide range of foods

C. DE W. BLACKBURN, C.L. BAYLIS AND S.B. PETITT. 1996. Petrifilm^TM is a ready-to-use alternative to traditional microbial enumeration methods. The Petrifilm^TM Aerobic Count Plate (ACP) and Coliform Count Plate (CCP) were compared with standard methods for the enumeration of the aerobic mesophilic flora and coliform bacteria in 91 foods covering a wide range of different food commodities. There was good correlation between the Petrifilm^TM ACP and the standard aerobic colony count method ( r = 0.989) and between the Petrifilm^TM CCP and the standard Violet Red Bile Agar plating method ( r = 0.872). In both cases, the Petrifilm^TM methods had a better repeatability than the standard methods. The Petrifilm^TM ACP and CCP were shown to be practical and accurate alternatives to standard enumeration methods in a wide range of foods, with benefits of saving time, labour and incubator space.     

Evaluation of the Autoanalysis Colilert test for detection and enumeration of total coliforms

The Autoanalysis Colilert (AC) test was compared with the membrane filter (MF), 10-tube multiple-tube fermentation (MTF) technique, and the presence-absence test as described in Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater for the detection and enumeration of total coliforms in water. The methods were evaluated with 31 samples from seven different sources. Each sample was analyzed by each of the techniques, using replicate 100-ml sample volumes. A total of 582 confirmed tubes were positive by the MTF test, and 533 tubes were positive by the AC test. Statistical analysis of the most-probable-number comparability data showed a statistically significant difference in the number of positive tubes, with the MTF test resulting in more positive tubes. There were no statistically significant differences in precision between the two methods. All the methods were comparable in detection of total coliforms. Levels of heterotrophic bacteria generally encountered in drinking water did not interfere with detection or enumeration of coliforms by the AC test.     

Impedance as an alternative to MPN enumeration of coliforms in pasteurized milks

R.H. MADDEN AND A. GILMOUR. 1995. Samples (900) of pasteurized whole, semi-skimmed and skimmed milk were subjected to conventional enumeration of coliforms by a nine-tube most probable number (MPN) technique, and impedance enumeration, in parallel. Regression analysis of the positive samples (98) showed that impedance enumeration was at least as accurate as the MPN method but results were obtained faster, with all testing being completed in 20 h, rather than 48 h. Consumable requirements, and staffing levels, were also much less with the impedance system. The impedance method could therefore beneficially replace the conventional method.