Intrinsic Interference: a New Type of Viral Interference

The hemadsorption-negative plaque test has revealed a new type of viral interference, termed intrinsic interference. Several unrelated types of noncytopathic viruses were shown to induce in infected host cells a state of interference unique in being directed solely against superinfection by Newcastle disease virus (NDV). The NDV-refractory state arises only in those individual cells of a population actually infected by the inducing virus, and presumably results from the action of a protein(s) coded for by the viral genome. Thus, intrinsic interference differs fundamentally from that mediated by an extrinsic protein detectable under conditions favoring resistance to a broad spectrum of viruses and characteristic of interference induced by interferon, the latter being coded for by the cell genome. Intrinsic interference is defined as a viral genome-induced cellular state of resistance to challenge by high multiplicities of NDV, coexistent with a state of susceptibility to a broad spectrum of other viruses, similarly tested at high multiplicities. The capacity to induce intrinsic interference was demonstrated with rubella virus, Sindbis virus (arbovirus, group A), West Nile virus (arbovirus, group B), poliovirus (MEF, type 2), the lactic dehydrogenase virus (Riley's agent), and an unidentified nonhemadsorbing, noncytopathic adventitious virus. A state of intrinsic interference was also observed in the V5 line of mouse cells carrying a murine leukemia virus, probably resulting from some heretofore unsuspected contaminating virus. The molecular basis for intrinsic interference is not known, but it appears to involve a step in the NDV growth cycle beyond that of viral attachment, entry, and eclipse.     

Viral determinants of the variable sensitivity of herpes simplex virus strains to gD-mediated interference.

Cells that express glycoprotein D (gD) of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) resist infection by HSV-1 and HSV-2 because of interference with viral penetration. The results presented here show that both HSV-1 and HSV-2 gD can mediate interference and that various HSV-1 and HSV-2 strains differ in sensitivity to this interference. The relative degree of sensitivity was not necessarily dependent on whether the cell expressed the heterologous or homologous form of gD but rather on the properties of the virus. Marker transfer experiments revealed that the allele of gD expressed by the virus was a major determinant of sensitivity to interference. Amino acid substitutions in the most distal part of the gD ectodomain had a major effect, but substitutions solely in the cytoplasmic domain also influenced sensitivity to interference. In addition, evidence was obtained that another viral gene(s) in addition to the one encoding gD can influence sensitivity to interference. The results indicate that HSV-1 and HSV-2 gD share determinants required to mediate interference with infection by HSV of either serotype and that the pathway of HSV entry that is blocked by expression of cell-associated gD can be cleared or bypassed through subtle alterations in virion-associated proteins, particularly gD.     

Distinct superinfection interference properties yet similar receptor utilization by cytopathic and noncytopathic feline leukemia viruses.

Cell killing by cytopathic retroviruses is often associated with a delay or failure in the establishment of superinfection interference. Superinfection has been observed during T-cell killing and fatal immunodeficiency disease induction by the feline leukemia virus (FeLV) chimera FeLV-FAIDS-EECC, containing the surface envelope glycoprotein (SU) of FeLV-FAIDS clone 61C. We demonstrate here that 61C SU has a defect that results in a nearly complete failure to establish superinfection interference against homologous virus challenge. This failure was evident only in feline T (FeT) cell clones expressing envelope protein, not in the rare cells that have survived cytopathic infection to become chronically infected. The regions of SU responsible for this defect were the same as those previously identified as responsible for T-cell killing. The superinfection interference properties of a noncytophatic molecular clone, FeLV-FAIDS-61E, were different in that 61E established interference to homologous virus challenge, both in SU-expressing cell clones and in chronically infected cells. Neither 61E nor EECC established interference against heterologous virus challenge. Viruses expressing chimeric SU proteins displayed varied and intermediate interference properties. Purified 61E and 61C SU competed for binding sites on FeT cell surfaces, and purified 61E SU blocked infection of virus bearing 61E or 61C SU. In addition, purified 61E and 61C SU each coprecipitated 70-kDa FeT cell surface proteins. Our data are consistent with the hypothesis that there are multiple cellular components necessary for 61E and 61C attachment to and penetration of FeT cells, a primary receptor that is utilized by both 61E and 61C, and secondary receptors that are likely to be virus specific.     

Exclusion of superinfecting homologous virus by Sindbis virus-infected Aedes albopictus (mosquito) cells.

The infection of tissue-cultured Aedes albopictus (mosquito) cells by an alphavirus ultimately results in a persistently infected cell population which can be maintained in the laboratory for years. One characteristic of this culture is that it will not support the replication of superinfecting homologous virus. We have previously shown that mosquito cells persistently infected with Sindbis virus produce an antiviral agent which when applied to uninfected mosquito cells suppresses Sindbis virus replication. The exclusion of virus replication in the antiviral-agent-treated cells is similar to the phenomenon of homologous interference described in alphavirus-infected vertebrate cells. In this study we examined the expression of homologous interference in three lines of mosquito cells and compared the expression of homologous interference to the effects of the antiviral activity. The cell lines were found to differ in their ability to express homologous interference, and evidence suggests that the mosquito cells may suppress replication by homologous interference or by the action of the antiviral agent.     

Interference Among Group A Arboviruses

Interference among group A arboviruses is described which does not involve the mediation of interferon. Interference was observed only if the interfering virus had an advantage over the challenge virus, either in time or in multiplicity of infection. Adsorption, penetration, and uncoating of challenge virus did not appear to be inhibited, but the synthesis of infectious viral ribonucleic acid of the challenge virus was significantly retarded. It was shown with temperature-sensitive viruses or mutants that the replication of viral ribonucleic acid by the interfering virus was required to establish interference. A mechanism of interference based on a competition for replication sites or substrates is compared with other possible explanations.     

Defective Influenza Viral Ribonucleoproteins Cause Interference

Ribonucleoproteins (RNPs) isolated from infectious and defective interfering (DI) influenza virus (WSN) contained three major RNP peaks when analyzed in a glycerol gradient. Peak I RNP was predominant in infectious virus but was greatly reduced in DI virus preparations. Conversely, peak III RNP was elevated in DI virus, suggesting a large increase in DI RNA in this fraction. Labeled [(32)P]RNA was isolated from each RNP region and analyzed by electrophoresis on polyacrylamide gels. Peak I RNP contained primarily the polymerase and some HA genes, peak II contained some HA gene but mostly the NP and NA genes, and peak III contained the M and NS genes. In addition, peak III RNP from DI virus also contained the characteristic DI RNA segments. Interference activity of RNP fractions isolated from infectious and DI virus was tested using infectious center reduction assay. RNP peaks (I, II, and III) from infectious virus did not show any interference activity, whereas the peak III DI RNP caused a reduction in the number of infectious centers as compared to controls. Similar interference was not demonstrable with peak I RNP of DI virus nor with any RNP fractions from infectious virus alone. The interference activity of RNP fractions was RNase sensitive, suggesting that the DI RNA contained in DI RNPs was the interfering agent, and dilution experiments supported the conclusion that a single DI RNP could cause interference. The interfering RNPs were heterogeneous, and the majority migrated slower than viral RNPs containing M and NS genes. These results suggest that DI RNP (or DI RNA) is also responsible for interference in segmented, negative-stranded viruses.     

BHK cells expressing Sindbis virus-induced homologous interference allow the translation of nonstructural genes of superinfecting virus.

The process by which Sindbis virus excludes superinfecting homologous virus was investigated with the use of temperature-sensitive mutants. Mutants in two RNA-negative complementation groups were found to be defective in their ability to establish interference at the nonpermissive temperature. These mutants were unable to establish interference in a mixed infection (complementation), suggesting that both were defective in a common gene product. Homologous interference was found to block the replication of superinfecting virus after attachment, penetration, and translation of the nonstructural genes encoded in the virus RNA. The production of nonstructural gene products of superinfecting wild-type virus was found to enhance the replication of certain RNA- temperature-sensitive interfering viruses at the permissive and the nonpermissive temperature. The ability of certain RNA- mutants to establish homologous interference and to demonstrate enhanced growth after superinfection with wild-type virus was interpreted to produce a model implicating both virus and host components in the establishment of homologous interference and in the replication of Sindbis virus RNA.     

Interaction Between Cytomegalovirus and Newcastle Disease Virus as Mediated by Intrinsic Interference

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) was demonstrated to induce intrinsic interference to Newcastle disease virus (NDV) in human fibroblast cells under noncytopathic conditions. This interference is unique in that (i) cytomegalovirus is the first DNA virus demonstrated to have this property and (ii) the state of interference was transient and progressively lost as the condition of the cells changed with the development of cytopathic effect. These observations are consistent with the view that the newly formed protein responsible for interference with NDV has a limited half-life and is no longer made when cytopathic conditions are produced by CMV.     

Homologous Interference by Incomplete Sendai Virus Particles: Changes in Virus-Specific Ribonucleic Acid Synthesis

Incomplete Sendai virus particles (I particles) interfered with the replication of several strains of infectious Sendai virions (standard virus) but not with the replication of Newcastle disease virus, mumps virus, or Sindbis virus. I particles did not induce interferon, and ultraviolet irradiation of I particles abolished their ability to interfere. Protein synthesis was not necessary to establish interference. The degree of interference depended on the interval between exposure of cells to the I particles and challenge by standard virus, and this was reflected in the degree of inhibition of virus-specific ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis in infected cells. The most dramatic change was decreased accumulation of 50S virus-specific RNA in infected cells. RNA species sedimenting slower than 50S were not as markedly reduced in total amount, but hybridization experiments showed that a substantial portion of these slowly sedimenting RNA species were plus strands, presumably representing replicas of the RNA species in I particles. When I particles in insufficient numbers to interfere were added to cells as late as 8 hr after standard virus, there were no obvious changes in virus-specific RNA species in the cells; however, significant amounts of 19 and 25S RNA species, representing progeny of the I particles, appeared in the culture medium. It was concluded that interference was an intracellular event affecting an early step in virus replication. Competition by I particles for cell sites or substrates needed by standard virus seemed a less likely mechanism of interference than competition for enzymes specified by standard virus.     

Interference is controlled by segment 2 and possibly by segment 8 of the nondefective interfering influenza virus variant A/FM/1/47-MA.

On mouse adaption of A/FM/1/47, a variant, A/FM/1/47-MA (FM-MA), that had acquired the properties of increased virulence and interference was produced. Coinfection of cells with FM-MA and prototype strains of influenza virus yielded > 100-fold more FM-MA virus than prototype virus, whereas coinfection with the same prototype strains and the parental A/FM/1/47 virus produced equivalent yields, indicating that FM-MA had acquired mutations that confer the property of interference during mouse adaption. FM-MA is a nondefective interfering virus that grows to a high titer in vivo and in vitro. It has previously been shown that segments 4, 7, and 8 and possibly segment 5 account for the increased virulence. In this study we show by genetic analysis of FM-MA x A/HK/1/68 reassortants that segment 2, coding for the polymerase-associated protein PB1, and possibly segment 8, encoding the NS1 and NS2 proteins, control the ability of FM-MA to interfere. Interference could not be overcome by increasing the titer of the coinfecting strain, but delaying FM-MA infection by 4 to 6 h did avoid interference. During interference of A/HK/1/68, protein synthesis was inhibited by less than 65% throughout coinfection. Given the kinetics of interference and the small perturbation in protein synthesis, interference appeared to occur at the level of late genome replication or virus assembly. Virulence and interference in FM-MA were not linked. An interfering avirulent FM-MA x A/HK/1/68 reassortant, E07, was capable of protecting mice against lethal pneumonia due to a virulent noninterfering reassortant, H04.     

Autophagy is involved in influenza A virus replication

Autophagy is involved in the replication of viruses, especially those that perform RNA assembly on the surface of cytoplasmic membrane in host cells. However, little is known about the regulatory role of autophagy in influenza A virus replication. Using fluorescence and electron microscopy, we observed that autophagosomes can be induced and identified upon influenza A virus infection. The virus increased the amount of the autophagosome marker protein microtubule-associated protein light chain 3-II (LC3-II) and enhanced autophagic flux. When autophagy was pharmacologically inhibited by either 3-methylademine or wortmannin, the titers of influenza A virus were remarkably decreased. Viral reduction via autophagy inhibition was further confirmed by RNA interference, through which two different proteins required for autophagy were depleted. Noticeably, the compounds utilized had no marked effect on virus entry or cell viability, either of which might limit viral replication. Furthermore, alteration of cellular autophagy via pharmacological reagents or RNA interference impaired viral protein accumulation. Taken together, these findings indicate that autophagy is actively involved in influenza A virus replication.     

Murine retroviruses use at least six different receptors for entry into Mus dunni cells.

Murine retroviruses have been divided into six interference groups that use different receptors for cell entry: the ecotropic, xenotropic, polytropic, amphotropic, 10A1, and Mus dunni endogenous virus groups. Some interference is observed between xenotropic and polytropic viruses and between amphotropic and 10A1 viruses, indicating some overlap in receptor specificity between these groups, but otherwise these interference groups appear completely independent. In contrast, one study found interference among many of these groups when Mus dunni wild mouse cells were examined with an immunofluorescence assay to detect infection by the challenge virus. Here we have used a more direct assay for cell entry by using pseudotyped retroviral vectors to measure interference in M. dunni cells, and we find no evidence for extensive interference between members of different murine retrovirus groups. Indeed, our results in M. dunni cells are consistent with interference results observed in other cell types and indicate that the anomalous interference results previously observed in M. dunni cells with the immunofluorescence assay were most likely due to factors other than those that affect receptor-mediated virus entry. In summary, our results show that murine retroviruses use at least six different receptors for entry into M. dunni cells.     

Specific cell-surface alteration by enteroviruses as reflected by viral-attachment interference

Crowell, Richard L. (Hahnemann Medical College, Philadelphia, Pa.). Specific cell-surface alteration by enteroviruses as reflected by viral-attachment interference. J. Bacteriol. 91:198-204. 1966.-Exposure of HeLa cells to high levels of coxsackievirus B3 produced cells which were refractory to attachment of coxsackievirus B1, whereas poliovirus T2 attached normally. Under similar conditions, poliovirus T2 was found to interfere with the attachment of poliovirus T1 to HeLa cells without affecting the attachment rate of coxsackievirus B3. The data confirm earlier findings that the receptor sites on HeLa cells, which bind members of group B coxsackieviruses, are distinct from those for polioviruses. Quantitatively, coxsackieviruses B1 and B3 were found to be mutually exclusive in the attachment interference assay to suggest that they compete for the same receptors on the HeLa cell surface. The finding that input multiplicities of B3 virus which exceeded 500 saturated the homologous viral receptors of HeLa cells was unexpected, but was consistent with the results of interference assays. Excessive amounts of input virus did not, however, inhibit eclipse of homologous cell-associated virus. Attachment interference between enteroviruses occurred even though the interfering virus was eclipsed prior to addition of challenge virus. The finding that enterovirus attachment interference was reversible with acid pH suggested that attachment and eclipse of enterovirus does not result in a permanent alteration of the cell membrane and that these events occur at the cell surface.     

Homologous Viral Interference in Aedes albopictus Cultures Chronically Infected with Sindbis Virus

Complete homologous interference is demonstrated in cultures of Aedes albopictus cells chronically infected with Sindbis virus. The interference occurred before there was any detectable RNA synthesis by the superinfecting virus.     

From interference to interferon: a brief historical introduction

The idea that a substance mediating interference was released from cells upon contact with inactivated influenza A virus emerged from an abortive attempt at showing that interference was initiated by passage of only part of the virus into the cell, from previous knowledge about interference, and from the use of a simple technique allowing easy separation of fluid and tissue.     

Insights into RNA virus mutant spectrum and lethal mutagenesis events: replicative interference and complementation by multiple point mutants

RNA virus behavior can be influenced by interactions among viral genomes and their expression products within the mutant spectra of replicating viral quasispecies. Here, we report the extent of interference of specific capsid and polymerase mutants of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) on replication of wild-type (wt) RNA. The capsid and polymerase mutants chosen for this analysis had been characterized biochemically and structurally. Upon co-electroporation of BHK-21 cells with wt RNA and a tenfold excess of mutant RNA, some mutants displayed strong interference (<10% of progeny production by wt RNA alone), while other mutants did not show detectable interference. The capacity to interfere required an excess of mutant RNA and was associated with intracellular replication, irrespective of the formation of infectious particles by the mutant virus. The extent of interference did not correlate with the known types and number of interactions involving the amino acid residue affected in each mutant. Synergistic interference was observed upon co-electroporation of wt RNA and mixtures of capsid and polymerase mutants. Interference was specific, in that the mutants did not affect expression of encephalomyocarditis virus RNA, and that a two nucleotide insertion mutant of FMDV expressing a truncated polymerase did not exert any detectable interference. The results support the lethal defection model for viral extinction by enhanced mutagenesis, and provide further evidence that the population behavior of highly variable viruses can be influenced strongly by the composition of the quasispecies mutant spectrum as a whole.     

Transient Inhibition of Polyoma Virus Synthesis by Sendai Virus (Parainfluenza I) I. Demonstration and Nature of the Inhibition by Inactivated Virus

Superinfection of polyoma virus-infected mouse embryo cells by beta-propiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus resulted in a 90% inhibition of the synthesis of infectious polyoma progeny. The interference is dependent upon the time of superinfection and the concentration of the inactivated virus. The inhibition of polyoma virus synthesis is transient in nature since normal synthesis of polyoma progeny virus is seen upon prolonged incubation. Interferon does not appear to be implicated in the interference. Various aspects of the biological and synthetic capabilities of beta-propiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus are also described.     

Homologous interference of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus involves a ribavirin-susceptible block in virus replication.

Depending on the multiplicity of infection (MOI), infection of L929 cells results in either productive lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus replication or homologous interference M. Bruns, A. Gessner, H. Lother, and F. Lehmann-Grube, Virology 166:133-139, 1988). As shown in this communication, productive lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus replication as observed at a low MOI was effectively inhibited by ribavirin. In contrast, virus yields increased if cells were infected with a high MOI and in the presence of 5 microM of the antiviral compound. This drug-dependent release of infectious virus was preceded by enhanced nucleoprotein (NP) synthesis, a change in intracellular NP distribution, and by an onset of glycoprotein synthesis. It is therefore proposed that this block in viral replication is brought about by a posttranslational effect on a viral gene product, probably the NP, present in reasonably large quantities both during homologous interference as well as persistent infection.