Effect on transformation of mutations in the early region 1b-encoded 21- and 55-kilodalton proteins of adenovirus 5.

It is well established that the adenovirus 5 genes responsible for the initiation and maintenance of the transformed cell reside in the early region 1a and 1b genes, but it remains unclear how the polypeptides encoded in these genes mediate their functions. To probe the function of the early region 1b-encoded 55- and 21-kilodalton (kd) polypeptides during this process, a series of viral mutants was engineered so that they contained deletions or insertions at 5.4, 5.7, 7.9, or 9.6 map units. By means of either an overlap recombination procedure involving H5dl314 (delta 3.7 to 4.6 map units) cleaved with ClaI, or a marker rescue procedure involving H5dl312 (delta 1.2 to 3.8 map units), viral mutants were isolated by their ability to produce plaques on KB cell line 18 cells, which constitutively express only viral early region 1b functions. DNA sequence analysis confirmed that the series of mutants generated differed in their abilities to express the 21- or the 55-kd polypeptides, or both. Upon infection of cloned rat embryo fibroblast cells with viruses containing mutations affecting the 55-kd protein, the transformation frequency decreased as the size of the predicted truncated polypeptide decreased. Although all of the foci generated by the 55-kd protein mutants were indistinguishable from the foci induced by wild-type virus, they displayed an inefficient ability to grow in soft agar, again in relation to the size of the truncated polypeptide. In contrast, if cloned rat embryo fibroblast cells were transfected with viral DNA, the defectiveness in transformation observed after infection with virions was not as dramatic. However, all of the viruses containing 21-kd mutations were transformation defective, regardless of the mode by which the viral nucleic acid was introduced into the cell.     

Gene product of region E4 of adenovirus type 5 modulates accumulation of certain viral polypeptides.

An adenovirus type 5 mutant, designated H5ilE4I, was constructed in which region E4 was replaced by a cloned cDNA. The cDNA was a copy of an mRNA which exclusively contains open translational reading frames 6 and 7. The phenotype of the mutant was compared with that of the previously characterized E4 mutant H2dl808 and wild-type adenovirus 5. Although the H5ilE4I mutant lacked at least five E4 genes, it was nondefective for growth in HeLa cells. The defects in viral DNA replication, late protein synthesis, and shutoff of host cell protein synthesis associated with the phenotype of the H2dl808 mutant were not observed in HeLa cells infected with the H5ilE4I mutant. However, differences were observed regarding the time of onset of viral DNA replication and the accumulation of the hexon polypeptide as well as the 72-kilodalton adenovirus-specific DNA-binding protein. The results thus indicate that open reading frame 6 or 7 or both contain all genetic information required for viral replication in tissue culture cells, whereas another E4 gene modulates the accumulation of certain viral polypeptides. The early onset of viral DNA replication in H5ilE4I-infected cells may be an indirect effect of the enhanced expression of the 72-kilodalton DNA-binding protein.     

trans-dominant interference of type 5 adenovirus E1a mutants in cell transformation.

Two type 5 adenovirus (Ad5) early region 1a (E1a) mutants, H5in104 and H5dl105, were impaired in viral replication and cell transformation. In addition, these mutants trans dominantly inhibited the frequency with which H5sub309, a phenotypically wild-type mutant, and H5dl520, a high-frequency transformation mutant, transformed CREF cells. Inhibition of transformation varied in proportion to the input ratio of mutant to coinfecting virus. It was found that H5in104, but not H5dl105, could not complement Ad5 E1b mutants that failed to synthesize 19- or 55-kDa E1b product. H5dl105 yielded 10-fold less virus than the wild-type did in 293 cells, which constitutively express E1a and E1b products; similar low yields were also observed with H5in104 and H5dl105 in another E1a- and E1b-expressing transformed cell line, KB16. Marker rescue and DNA sequence analyses, however, indicated that the phenotypes of H5in104 and H5dl105 were the result of their respective E1a mutations. The data presented are the first to demonstrate that mutants of animal viruses can effect dominant interference with the viral function(s) that produce cell transformation.     

Analyses of single-amino-acid substitution mutants of adenovirus type 5 E1B-55K protein

The E1B-55K protein plays an important role during human adenovirus type 5 productive infection. In the early phase of the viral infection, E1B-55K binds to and inactivates the tumor suppressor protein p53, allowing efficient replication of the virus. During the late phase of infection, E1B-55K is required for efficient nucleocytoplasmic transport and translation of late viral mRNAs, as well as for host cell shutoff. In an effort to separate the p53 binding and inactivation function and the late functions of the E1B-55K protein, we have generated 26 single-amino-acid mutations in the E1B-55K protein. These mutants were characterized for their ability to modulate the p53 level, interact with the E4orf6 protein, mediate viral late-gene expression, and support virus replication in human cancer cells. Of the 26 mutants, 24 can mediate p53 degradation as efficiently as the wild-type protein. Two mutants, R240A (ONYX-051) and H260A (ONYX-053), failed to degrade p53 in the infected cells. In vitro binding assays indicated that R240A and H260A bound p53 poorly compared to the wild-type protein. When interaction with another viral protein, E4orf6, was examined, H260A significantly lost its ability to bind E4orf6, while R240A was fully functional in this interaction. Another mutant, T255A, lost the ability to bind E4orf6, but unexpectedly, viral late-gene expression was not affected. This raised the possibility that the interaction between E1B-55K and E4orf6 was not required for efficient viral mRNA transport. Both R240A and H260A have retained, at least partially, the late functions of wild-type E1B-55K, as determined by the expression of viral late proteins, host cell shutoff, and lack of a cold-sensitive phenotype. Virus expressing R240A (ONYX-051) replicated very efficiently in human cancer cells, while virus expressing H260A (ONYX-053) was attenuated compared to wild-type virus dl309 but was more active than ONYX-015. The ability to separate the p53-inactivation activity and the late functions of E1B-55K raises the possibility of generating adenovirus variants that retain the tumor selectivity of ONYX-015 but can replicate more efficiently than ONYX-015 in a broad spectrum of cell types.     

Mapping of an adenovirus function involved in the inhibition of DNA degradation.

A function involved in the inhibition of DNA degradation has been assigned through complementation tests to a product of region E1b of the adenovirus genome (between 4.5 and 10.5 map units). DNA degradation induced by the adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) cyt mutant H12cyt70 and the Ad5 early deletion mutant dl313 (with the deletion between 3.5 and 10.7 map units) was inhibited by coinfection with Ad5 region E1a (between 0 and 4.5 map units) mutants dl312 and hr1 and region E1b mutant hr6. The defect of inhibition of DNA degradation in Ad5 dl313 was also complemented in 293 cells. This DNase-inhibitory function does not appear to involve polypeptide IX or the 58,000-dalton polypeptide. Wild-type Ad12 induced DNA degradation in hamster embryo cells, suggesting that the DNase-inhibitory function is not expressed in these nonpermissive cells. Additional evidence suggests the involvement of a second viral product which positively influences the DNase activity and which appears to be an early function.     

Expression of adenovirus E1a and E1b gene products and the Escherichia coli XGPRT gene in KB cells

The recombinant plasmid pSV2-gpt, which contains the Escherichia coli XGPRT gene under the control of a simian virus 40 early promoter, was modified to contain the type 2 adenovirus (Ad2) XhoI-C (0 to 15.5 map units) restriction endonuclease fragment. Plasmid (pLB206) DNA was introduced into human KB cells by Ca2+-mediated DNA transfection, and transformants were selected in medium containing xanthine, aminopterin, and mycophenolic acid, as a consequence of expression of the dominant, selectable XGPRT gene. A series of 13 gpt+ cell lines were isolated and tested for their ability to complement Ad5 deletion mutants in E1a (H5dl312) and E1b (H5dl315). Four classes of gpt+ KB cell lines were identified, including clones constitutively expressing both E1a and E1b, only E1a, or only E1b or not expressing either E1a or E1b. DNA and RNA filter transfer hybridization analysis substantiated the conclusions that those cell lines capable of complementing viral host range mutants contained the appropriate viral DNA sequences and cytoplasmic polyadenylated RNA species. DNA filter transfer hybridization studies also revealed that the transfected vector DNA was stably integrated into chromosomal DNA in the KB transformants and the number of integrated sites ranged from 1 to 3. The gpt+ KB cell line that only expressed E1b gene functions only contained viral E1b gene sequences; those cell lines that expressed neither E1a nor E1b gene function contained only small or no regions of Ad2 DNA. When weaned off the selective medium, transformed KB cell lines stably maintained their inserted DNA in the absence of selective pressure and could easily be adapted to growth in suspension culture.     

Adenovirus ubiquitin-protein ligase stimulates viral late mRNA nuclear export

Theadenovirus type 5 (Ad5) E1B-55K and E4orf6 proteins are required together to stimulate viral late nuclear mRNA export to the cytoplasm and to restrict host cell nuclear mRNA export during the late phase of infection. Previous studies have shown that these two viral proteins interact with the cellular proteins elongins B and C, cullin 5, RBX1, and additional cellular proteins to form an E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase that polyubiquitinates p53 and probably one or more subunits of the MRE11-RAD50-NBS1 (MRN) complex, directing their proteasomal degradation. The MRN complex is required for cellular DNA double-strand break repair and induction of the DNA damage response by adenovirus infection. To determine if the ability of E1B-55K and E4orf6 to stimulate viral late mRNA nuclear export requires the ubiquitin-protein ligase activity of this viral ubiquitin-protein ligase complex, we designed and expressed a dominant-negative mutant form of cullin 5 in HeLa cells before infection with wild-type Ad5 or the E1B-55K null mutant dl1520. The dominant-negative cullin 5 protein stabilized p53 and the MRN complex, indicating that it inhibited the viral ubiquitin-protein ligase but had no effect on viral early mRNA synthesis, early protein synthesis, or viral DNA replication. However, expression of the dominant-negative cullin 5 protein caused a decrease in viral late protein synthesis and viral nuclear mRNA export similar to the phenotype produced by mutations in E1B-55K. We conclude that the stimulation of adenovirus late mRNA nuclear export by E1B-55K and E4orf6 results from the ubiquitin-protein ligase activity of the adenovirus ubiquitin-protein ligase complex.     

Effect of deletions in adenovirus early region 1 genes upon replication of adeno-associated virus.

The growth of adeno-associated virus (AAV) is dependent upon helper functions provided by adenovirus. We investigated the role of adenovirus early gene region 1 in the AAV helper function by using six adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) host range mutants having deletions in early region 1. These mutants do not grow in human KB cells but are complemented by and grow in a line of adenovirus-transformed human embryonic kidney cells (293 cells); 293 cells contain and express the Ad5 early region 1 genes. Mutants having extensive deletions of adenovirus early region 1a (dl312) or regions 1a and 1b (dl313) helped AAV as efficiently as wild-type adenovirus in 293 cells, but neither mutant helped in KB cells. No AAV DNA, RNA, or protein synthesis was detected in KB cells in the presence of the mutant adenoviruses. Quantitative blotting experiments showed that at 20 h after infection with AAV and either dl312 or dl313 there was less than one AAV genome per cell. In KB cells infected with AAV alone, the unreplicated AAV genomes were detected readily. Apparently, infection with adenovirus mutant dl312 or dl313 results in degradation of most of the infecting AAV genomes. We suggest that at least an adenovirus region 1b product (and perhaps a region 1a product also) is required for AAV DNA replication. This putative region 1b function appears to protect AAV DNA from degradation by an adenovirus-induced DNase. We also tested additional Ad5 mutants (dl311, dl314, sub315, and sub316). All of these mutants were inefficient helpers, and they showed varying degrees of multiplicity leakiness. dl312 and dl313 complemented each other for the AAV helper function, and each was complemented by Ad5ts125 at the nonpermissive temperature. The defect in region 1 mutants for AAV helper function acts at a different stage of the AAV growth cycle than the defect in the region 2 mutant ts125.     

Deletion of the gene encoding the adenovirus 5 early region 1b 21,000-molecular-weight polypeptide leads to degradation of viral and host cell DNA.

The adenovirus 5 mutant H5dl337 lacks 146 base pairs within early region 1B. The deletion removes a portion of the region encoding the E1B 21,000-molecular-weight (21K) polypeptide, but does not disturb the E1B-55K/17K coding region. The virus is slightly defective for growth in cultured HeLa cells, in which its final yield is reduced ca. 10-fold compared with wild-type virus. The mutant displays a striking phenotype in HeLa cells. The onset of cytopathic effect is dramatically accelerated, and both host cell and viral DNAs are extensively degraded late after infection. This defect has been described previously for a variety of adenovirus mutants and has been termed a cytocidal (cyt) phenotype. H5dl337 serves to map this defect to the loss of E1B-21K polypeptide function. In addition to its defect in the productive growth cycle, H5dl337 is unable to transform rat cells at normal efficiency.     

Deletion and insertion mutations in early region 1a of type 5 adenovirus that produce cold-sensitive or defective phenotypes for transformation

On the basis of earlier findings showing that H5hr1 (hr1) is cold sensitive for transformation, a series of mutants were constructed so that they contained deletions or insertions in different sites of early region 1a (E1a) to ascertain: (i) whether the cold-sensitive phenotype of hr1 was the result of the identified single-base pair deletion of nucleotide 1,055 or due to a missense mutation at another site and (ii) what region and how much of the E1a 51-kilodalton protein is actually required to produce cell transformation. A mutant, H5dl101 (dl101), was constructed to contain a 5-base pair deletion of nucleotides 1,008 to 1,012, which produced a frameshift and a subsequent stop codon at nucleotide 1,241. This mutant, which should encode a truncated 33-kilodalton protein in place of the wild-type 51-kilodalton protein, had a cold-sensitive phenotype for transformation essentially identical to hr1. Consonant with this finding, a mutant (H5in106) engineered to contain a 16-base pair insertion initiated after nucleotide 1,009, with a stop codon beginning at the newly inserted nucleotide 1,013, also had a cold-sensitive phenotype like hr1 and dl101. It is striking, however, that a mutant (H5dl105) with a 69-base pair deletion beginning at nucleotide 1,003, and having a stop codon at nucleotide 1,544, was totally defective for transformation at any temperature. Transfection studies with plasmids containing the E1a or E1a and E1b genes of sub309, hr1, and dl101 further revealed that the cold-sensitive transformation phenotype observed could be exhibited in the absence of viral E1b gene expression.     

Cloning of a DNA fragment from the left-hand terminus of the adenovirus type 2 genome and its use in site-directed mutagenesis.

The HpaI E fragment (0-4.5 map units) of adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) DNA was cloned in the plasmid vector pBR322. Excision of the viral insert with PstI and XbaI generated a fragment which comigrated with Ad2 XbaI-E (0-3.8 map units), and this fragment was ligated to the 3.8-100 fragment generated by XbaI cleavage of the DNA of the Ad5 mutant, dl309 (N. Jones and T. Shenk, Cell 17:683-689, 1979). Transfection with the ligation products resulted in the production of progeny virus which was able to replicate on both HeLa and line 293 cells, demonstrating the biological activity of the sequences rescued from the plasmid. Small deletions were introduced around the SmaI site (map position 2.8) within the cloned viral insert, and the altered DNA sequences were reintroduced into progeny virus as described above. The mutant viruses grew well on line 293 cells but plaqued with greatly reduced efficiency on HeLa cells, exhibiting a host range phenotype similar to previously described mutants with lesions located within this region of the genome. When plasmid-derived left-end fragments containing pBR322 DNA sequences to the left of map position 0 were ligated to the 3.8-100 fragment of dl309 DNA, the infectivity of the ligation products was not reduced. However, all progeny viruses examined yielded normal-size restriction enzyme fragments from their left-hand ends, indicating that the bulk of the pBR322 DNA sequences are removed either prior to or as a consequence of the replication of the transfecting DNA molecules.     

p53-Independent and -Dependent Requirements for E1B-55K in Adenovirus Type 5 Replication

The adenovirus type 5 mutant dl1520 was engineered previously to be completely defective for E1B-55K functions. Recently, this mutant (also known as ONYX-015) has been suggested to replicate preferentially in p53(-) and some p53(+) tumor cell lines but to be attenuated in primary cultured cells (C. Heise, A. Sampson-Johannes, A. Williams, F. McCormick, D. D. F. Hoff, and D. H. Kirn, Nat. Med. 3:639-645, 1997). It has been suggested that dl1520 might be used as a "magic bullet" that could selectively lyse tumor cells without harm to normal tissues. However, we report here that dl1520 replication is independent of p53 genotype and occurs efficiently in some primary cultured human cells, indicating that the mutant virus does not possess a tumor selectivity. Although it was not the sole host range determinant, p53 function did reduce dl1520 replication when analyzed in a cell line expressing temperature-sensitive p53 (H1299-tsp53) (K. L. Fries, W. E. Miller, and N. Raab-Traub, J. Virol. 70:8653-8659, 1996). As found earlier for other E1B-55K mutants in HeLa cells (Y. Ho, R. Galos, and J. Williams, Virology 122:109-124, 1982), dl1520 replication was temperature dependent in H1299 cells. When p53 function was restored at low temperature in H1299-tsp53 cells, it imposed a modest defect in viral DNA replication and accumulation of late viral cytoplasmic mRNA. However, in both H1299 and H1299-tsp53 cells, the defect in late viral protein synthesis appeared to be much greater than could be accounted for by the modest defects in late viral mRNA levels. We therefore propose that in addition to countering p53 function and modulating viral and cellular mRNA nuclear transport, E1B-55K also stimulates late viral mRNA translation.     

Restricted changes in the adenovirus DNA-binding protein that lead to extended host range or temperature-sensitive phenotypes

Human adenovirus fails to multiply efficiently in monkey cells owing to a block to late viral gene expression. Ad2hr400 through Ad2hr403 are a set of host range (hr) mutants which were selected for their ability to readily grow in these cells at 37 degrees C. The mutations responsible for this extended host range have previously been mapped to the 5' portion of the gene encoding the 72-kilodalton DNA-binding protein (DBP). DNA sequence analyses indicate that all four hr mutants contain the same alteration at coding triplet 130, which changes a histidine codon to a tyrosine codon. These results extend those of Anderson et al. (J. Virol. 48:31-39, 1983), which suggested that only this change in the DBP amino acid sequence can expand adenovirus host range to monkey cells. The hr phenotype does not appear to require phosphorylation of this tyrosine residue, since no phosphotyrosine was detected in DBP isolated from Ad2hr400-infected monkey cells. The hr mutants Ad2hr400 through Ad2hr403, however, are cold sensitive for growth in monkey cells. The mutant Ad2ts400, which was derived from Ad2hr400, represents a second class of hr mutants which can grow efficiently in monkey cells at 32.5 degrees C. The cold-resistant hr mutation of Ad2ts400 has previously been mapped to the 5' region of the DBP gene (map units 63.6 through 66). DNA sequence analysis of this region shows that this mutant contains the original hr alteration at coding triplet 130 as well as a second alteration at coding triplet 148, which changes an alanine codon to a valine codon. We suspect that the alterations at amino acids 130 and 148 change the structure of the amino-terminal domain of the DBP, allowing it to better interact with monkey cell components required for late viral gene expression. Ad2ts400 also contains a temperature-sensitive mutation which has previously been mapped to the 3' portion of the DBP gene (map units 61.3 through 63.6). Sequence analysis of this region indicates that the DBP coding triplet 413 has been altered. This change from a serine codon to a proline codon is the same alteration reported in the previously sequenced DBP mutants Ad5ts125 (W. Kruijer et al., Nucleic Acids Res. 9:4439-4457, 1981) and Ad5ts107 (W. Kruijer et al., Virology 124:425-433, 1983). Thus it appears that only a very limited number of changes in either the 5' or the 3' portion of the DBP gene can give rise to the hr or temperature-sensitive phenotypes, respectively.     

Pre-early adenovirus 5 gene product regulates synthesis of early viral messenger RNAs.

The studies described here demonstrate that the expression of many early adenovirus mRNAs is dependent upon the activity of a pre-early viral product. This viral gene product is defective in adenovirus 5 host range (Ad hr) group I mutants. Adenovirus 5 host range mutants were previously isolated by their ability to replicate in the adenovirus 5-transformed human embryonic cell line 293 and by their inability to replicate efficiently in HeLa cells (Harrison, Graham and Williams, 1977). The group I complementation class of host range mutants has been mapped by marker rescue between 0 and 4.4 units (Frost and Williams, 1978). We have used the S1 nuclease gel technique to examine the expression of early mRNA after infection of HeLa cells with Ad5 hr group I and II mutants. The Ad5 hr group II mutants stimulate the synthesis of a wild-type pattern of early mRNAs. In contrast, infection of HeLa cells with Ad5 hr group I mutants gives rise to only two early mRNAs. These mRNAs map from 1.5–4.4 units, or in the same region as the Ad5 hr group I mutations. Since infection of HeLa cells with Ad5 hr group I mutants was defective for synthesis of cytoplasmic mRNAs complementary to three early regions in the right half of the genome and to the early region 4.5–11.0 units, we also analyzed nuclear RNA from these cells by the S1 nuclease gel technique for the presence of precursor RNA chains. Nuclear precursors were not detected in Ad5 hr group I-infected HeLa cells, suggesting that the gene product defective in these mutants is required for synthesis of stable nuclear RNA from the three early regions in the right half of the genome and from the early region 4.5–11.0 units.     

Genetic identification of adenovirus type 5 genes that influence viral spread

The mechanisms that control cell-to-cell spread of human adenoviruses (Ad) are not well understood. Two early viral proteins, E1B-19K and E3-ADP, appear to have opposing effects since viral mutants that are individually deficient in E1B-19K produce large plaques (G. Chinnadurai, Cell 33:759-766, 1983), while mutants deficient in E3-ADP produce small plaques (A. E. Tollefson et al., J. Virol. 70:2296-2306, 1996) on infected cell monolayers. We have used a genetic strategy to identify different viral genes that influence adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) spread in an epithelial cancer cell line. An Ad5 mutant (dl327; lacking most of the E3 region) with the restricted-spread (small-plaque) phenotype was randomly mutagenized with UV, and 27 large-plaque (lp) mutants were isolated. A combination of analyses of viral proteins and genomic DNA sequences have indicated that 23 mutants contained lesions in the E1B region affecting either 19K or both 19K and 55K proteins. Four other lp mutants contained lesions in early regions E1A and E4, in the early L1 region that codes for the i-leader protein, and in late regions that code for the viral structural proteins, penton base, and fiber. Our results suggest that the requirement of E3-ADP for Ad spread could be readily compensated for by abrogation of the functions of E1B-19K and provide genetic evidence that these two viral proteins influence viral spread in opposing manners. In addition to E1B and E3 proteins, other early and late proteins that regulate viral replication and infectivity also influence lateral viral spread. Our studies have identified novel mutations that could be exploited in designing efficient oncolytic Ad vectors.     

Temperature-sensitive initiation and elongation of adenovirus DNA replication in vitro with nuclear extracts from H5ts36-, H5ts149-, and H5ts125-infected HeLa cells.

Adenovirus DNA replication was studied in vitro in nuclear extracts prepared from HeLa cells infected at the permissive temperature with H5ts125, H5ts36, or H5ts149, three DNA-negative mutants belonging to two different complementation groups. At the restrictive temperature, H5ts125 extracts, containing a thermolabile 72-kilodalton DNA-binding protein, enable the formation of an initiation complex between the 82-kilodalton terminal protein precursor (pTP) and dCTP, but further elongation of this complex is inhibited. Wild-type DNA-binding protein or a 47-kilodalton chymotryptic DNA-binding fragment can complement the mutant protein in the elongation reaction. No difference in heat inactivation was observed between wild-type extracts and H5ts36 or H5ts149 extracts when the replication of terminal XbaI fragments of adenovirus type 5 DNA-terminal protein complex was studied. In contrast, the formation of a pTP-dCMP initiation complex, as well as the partial elongation reaction up to nucleotide 26, were consistently more temperature sensitive in mutant extracts. The results suggest that the H5ts36/H5ts149 gene product is required for initiation of adenovirus type 5 DNA replication and that the 72-kilodalton DNA-binding protein functions early in elongation.