79 Thermodynamic and kinetic studies of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) DNA

The expansion of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) DNA has been linked to several neurodegenerative diseases (McMurray, 2010). The number of repeats is usually a characteristic indication of the severity of TNR-related diseases, with longer repeats giving higher propensity to expand and earlier onset of symptoms (López, Cleary, & Pearson, 2010). It is generally accepted that formation of noncanonical secondary structures, such as stem-loop hairpins or slipouts, contributes to the expansion mechanisms during aberrant DNA replication or repair processes (Mirkin, 2007). The stability of these hairpins is considered an important factor (Paiva & Sheardy, 2005). In this work, we used differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and UV–Vis spectroscopy to study the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of a series of (CTG)_n and (CAG)_n TNR stem-loop hairpins and their corresponding (CTG)_n/(CAG)_n duplexes (n?=?6–14). We found that hairpins with n?=?even and n?=?even?+?1 (odd) repeats possess very similar thermodynamic stability. But, when converting to the canonical duplex form, odd-repeat hairpins are more stabilized compared to those of their even-repeat counterparts. Within both even- and odd-repeat series, hairpins with longer repeats are thermodynamically more stabilized compared to the shorter ones. Kinetic experiments of the stem-loop hairpin to duplex conversion revealed a longer lifetime for the even-repeat hairpins, while the odd-repeat hairpins convert to duplexes 10-fold faster. Also, hairpins with increased number of repeats are more resistant to the conversion when considered within the even- or odd-repeat series individually. Taken together, although it is thermodynamically more favored that hairpins containing longer repeats convert to canonical duplex form; On the contrary, these longer hairpins are kinetically trapped during the conversion and therefore can persist the noncanonical structures, which allows TNR expansion.     

A small unstructured nucleic acid disrupts a trinucleotide repeat hairpin

A variety of neurodegenerative disorders are associated with the expansion of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) sequences. These repetitive sequences are prone to adopting non-canonical structures, such as intrastrand stem-loop hairpins. Indeed, the formation and persistence of these hairpins during DNA replication and/or repair have been proposed as factors that facilitate TNR expansion. Given this proposed contribution of TNR hairpins to the expansion mechanism, disruption of such structures via strand invasion offers a potential means to negate the disease-initiating expansion. In this work, we investigated the strand invading abilities of a (CTG)₃ unstructured nucleic acid on a (CAG)₁₀ TNR hairpin. Using fluorescence, optical, and electrophoretic methods, instantaneous disruption of the (CAG)₁₀ hairpin by (CTG)₃ was observed at low temperatures. Additionally, we have identified three distinct duplex-like species that form between (CAG)₁₀ and (CTG)₃; these include 1, 2, or 3 (CTG)₃ sequences hybridized to (CAG)₁₀. The results presented here showcase (CTG)₃ as an invader of a TNR hairpin and suggest that unstructured nucleic acids could serve as a scaffold to design agents to prevent TNR expansion.     

In vitro repair of DNA hairpins containing various numbers of CAG/CTG trinucleotide repeats

Expansion of CAG/CTG trinucleotide repeats (TNRs) in humans is associated with a number of neurological and neurodegenerative disorders including Huntington's disease. Increasing evidence suggests that formation of a stable DNA hairpin within CAG/CTG repeats during DNA metabolism leads to TNR instability. However, the molecular mechanism by which cells recognize and repair CAG/CTG hairpins is largely unknown. Recent studies have identified a novel DNA repair pathway specifically removing (CAG)(n)/(CTG)(n) hairpins, which is considered a major mechanism responsible for TNR instability. The hairpin repair (HPR) system targets the repeat tracts for incisions in the nicked strand in an error-free manner. To determine the substrate spectrum of the HPR system and its ability to process smaller hairpins, which may be the intermediates for CAG/CTG expansions, we constructed a series of CAG/CTG hairpin heteroduplexes containing different numbers of repeats (from 5 to 25) and examined their repair in human nuclear extracts. We show here that although repair efficiencies differ slightly among these substrates, removal of the individual hairpin structures all involve endonucleolytic incisions within the repeat tracts in the nicked DNA strand. Analysis of the repair intermediates defined specific incision sites for each substrate, which were all located within the repeat regions. Mismatch repair proteins are not required for, nor do they inhibit, the processing of smaller hairpin structures. These results suggest that the HPR system ensures CAG/CTG stability primarily by removing various sizes of (CAG)(n)/(CTG)(n) hairpin structures during DNA metabolism.     

58 Packaging trinucleotide repeats: the effect of CAG/CTG repeats on nucleosome formation

In neurological diseases such as fragile X syndrome, spinal and bulbar muscular atrophy, myotonic dystrophy, and Huntington’s disease, the molecular basis of pathogenicity is the presence of an expanded trinucleotide repeat (TNR) tract (Ashley & Warren, 1995). TNRs implicated in many of these diseases are composed of CAG/CTG repeats. For example, in healthy individuals 5–35, CAG/CTG TNR repeats are present in the huntingtin gene. However, individuals with 40 or greater repeats will develop Huntington’s disease (Andrew et al., 1993). We are particularly interested in how these TNR sequences are packaged in chromatin. Recent evaluations of CAG/CTG TNR sequences in our laboratory have demonstrated that the repeats increase the propensity for the DNA sequences to incorporate into nucleosomes, where nucleosomes represent the minimal unit of packaging in chromatin (Volle & Delaney, 2012). In this work, we are interested in determining the minimum number of CAG/CTG repeats required to confer a significant increase in nucleosome incorporation relative to sequences that lack the TNR sequence. By defining the changes imposed on these fundamental interactions by the presence of a CAG/CTG repeat tract, we will gain insight into the possible interactions that allow for the expansion of these TNR tracts.     

Altered replication in human cells promotes DMPK (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) repeat instability

Myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1) is associated with expansion of (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) trinucleotide repeats (TNRs) in the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of the DMPK gene. Replication origins are cis-acting elements that potentiate TNR instability; therefore, we mapped replication initiation sites and prereplication complex protein binding within the ~10-kb DMPK/SIX5 locus in non-DM1 and DM1 cells. Two origins, IS(DMPK) and IS(SIX5), flanked the (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) TNRs in control cells and in DM1 cells. Orc2 and Mcm4 bound near each of the replication initiation sites, but a dramatic change in (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) replication polarity was not correlated with TNR expansion. To test whether (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) TNRs are cis-acting elements of instability in human cells, model cell lines were created by integration of cassettes containing the c-myc replication origin and (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) TNRs in HeLa cells. Replication forks were slowed by (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) TNRs in a length-dependent manner independent of replication polarity, implying that expanded (CTG)(n) · (CAG)(n) TNRs lead to replication stress. Consistent with this prediction, TNR instability increased in the HeLa model cells and DM1 cells upon small interfering RNA (siRNA) knockdown of the fork stabilization protein Claspin, Timeless, or Tipin. These results suggest that aberrant DNA replication and TNR instability are linked in DM1 cells.     

Involvement of the nucleotide excision repair protein UvrA in instability of CAG*CTG repeat sequences in Escherichia coli.

Several human genetic diseases have been associated with the genetic instability, specifically expansion, of trinucleotide repeat sequences such as (CTG)(n).(CAG)(n). Molecular models of repeat instability imply replication slippage and the formation of loops and imperfect hairpins in single strands. Subsequently, these loops or hairpins may be recognized and processed by DNA repair systems. To evaluate the potential role of nucleotide excision repair in repeat instability, we measured the rates of repeat deletion in wild type and excision repair-deficient Escherichia coli strains (using a genetic assay for deletions). The rate of triplet repeat deletion decreased in an E. coli strain deficient in the damage recognition protein UvrA. Moreover, loops containing 23 CTG repeats were less efficiently excised from heteroduplex plasmids after their transformation into the uvrA(-) strain. As a result, an increased proportion of plasmids containing the full-length repeat were recovered after the replication of heteroduplex plasmids containing unrepaired loops. In biochemical experiments, UvrA bound to heteroduplex substrates containing repeat loops of 1, 2, or 17 CAG repeats with a K(d) of about 10-20 nm, which is an affinity about 2 orders of magnitude higher than that of UvrA bound to the control substrates containing (CTG)(n).(CAG)(n) in the linear form. These results suggest that UvrA is involved in triplet repeat instability in cells. Specifically, UvrA may bind to loops formed during replication slippage or in slipped strand DNA and initiate DNA repair events that result in repeat deletion. These results imply a more comprehensive role for UvrA, in addition to the recognition of DNA damage, in maintaining the integrity of the genome.     

The Effects of Trinucleotide Repeats Found in Human Inherited Disorders on Palindrome Inviability in Escherichia Coli Suggest Hairpin Folding Preferences in Vivo

Unusual DNA secondary structures have been implicated in the expansion of trinucleotide repeat tracts that are associated with several human inherited disorders. We present evidence consistent with the folding of these trinucleotide repeats into hairpin loops at the center of a long DNA palindrome in vivo. Our assay utilizes a palindrome in bacteriophage λ, the center of which determines its ability to inhibit plaque formation in a manner that is consistent with folding into a hairpin or cruciform structure. We show that central inserts of even numbers of d(CAG)·d(CTG) repeats inhibit plaque formation more than do odd numbers. Both d(CAG)(2)·d(CTG)(2) and d(CGG)(2)·d(CCG)(2) central sequences behave like DNA sequences known to form two-base loops in vitro, suggesting that they may also form compact and stable loops. By contrast, repeats of d(GAC)·d(GTC) do not show any evidence consistent with unusual loop stability. These results agree with in vitro evidence that the unstable repeats can form hairpin secondary structures and suggest a favored position of folding. We discuss the potential roles of secondary structures, DNA replication and recombination in models of repeat tract expansion.     

Structural roles of CTG repeats in slippage expansion during DNA replication

CTG triplet repeat sequences have been found to form slipped-strand structures leading to self-expansion during DNA replication. The lengthening of these repeats causes the onset of neurodegenerative diseases, such as myotonic dystrophy. In this study, electrophoretic and NMR spectroscopic studies have been carried out to investigate the length and the structural roles of CTG repeats in affecting the hairpin formation propensity. Direct NMR evidence has been successfully obtained the first time to support the presence of three types of hairpin structures in sequences containing 1–10 CTG repeats. The first type contains no intra-loop hydrogen bond and occurs when the number of repeats is less than four. The second type has a 4 nt TGCT-loop and occurs in sequences with even number of repeats. The third type contains a 3 nt CTG-loop and occurs in sequences with odd number of repeats. Although stabilizing interactions have been identified between CTG repeats in both the second and third types of hairpins, the structural differences observed account for the higher hairpin formation propensity in sequences containing even number of CTG repeats. The results of this study confirm the hairpin loop structures and explain how slippage occurs during DNA replication.     

Replication and expansion of trinucleotide repeats in yeast

The mechanisms of trinucleotide repeat expansions, underlying more than a dozen hereditary neurological disorders, are yet to be understood. Here we looked at the replication of (CGG)(n) x (CCG)(n) and (CAG)(n) x (CTG)(n) repeats and their propensity to expand in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Using electrophoretic analysis of replication intermediates, we found that (CGG)(n) x (CCG)(n) repeats significantly attenuate replication fork progression. Replication inhibition for this sequence becomes evident at as few as approximately 10 repeats and reaches a maximal level at 30 to 40 repeats. This is the first direct demonstration of replication attenuation by a triplet repeat in a eukaryotic system in vivo. For (CAG)(n) x (CTG)(n) repeats, on the contrary, there is only a marginal replication inhibition even at 80 repeats. The propensity of trinucleotide repeats to expand was evaluated in a parallel genetic study. In wild-type cells, expansions of (CGG)(25) x (CCG)(25) and (CAG)(25) x (CTG)(25) repeat tracts occurred with similar low rates. A mutation in the large subunit of the replicative replication factor C complex (rfc1-1) increased the expansion rate for the (CGG)(25) repeat approximately 50-fold but had a much smaller effect on the expansion of the (CTG)(25) repeat. These data show dramatic sequence-specific expansion effects due to a mutation in the lagging strand DNA synthesis machinery. Together, the results of this study suggest that expansions are likely to result when the replication fork attempts to escape from the stall site.     

Premutation huntingtin allele adopts a non-B conformation and contains a hot spot for DNA damage

The expansion of a CAG trinucleotide repeat (TNR) sequence has been linked to several neurological disorders, for example, Huntington's disease (HD). In HD, healthy individuals have 5-35 CAG repeats. Those with 36-39 repeats have the premutation allele, which is known to be prone to expansion. In the disease state, greater than 40 repeats are present. Interestingly, the formation of non-B DNA conformations by the TNR sequence is proposed to contribute to the expansion. Here we provide the first structural and thermodynamic analysis of a premutation length TNR sequence. Using chemical probes of nucleobase accessibility, we found that similar to (CAG)(10), the premutation length sequence (CAG)(36) forms a stem-loop hairpin and contains a hot spot for DNA damage. Additionally, calorimetric analysis of a series of (CAG)(n) sequences, that includes repeat tracts in both the healthy and premutation ranges, reveal that thermodynamic stability increases linearly with the number of repeats. Based on these data, we propose that while non-B conformations can be formed by TNR tracts found in both the healthy and premutation allele, only sequences containing at least 36 repeats have sufficient thermodynamic stability to contribute to expansion.     

Frustration Between Preferred States of Complementary Trinucleotide Repeat DNA Hairpins Anticorrelates with Expansion Disease Propensity

DNA trinucleotide repeat (TRs) expansion beyond a threshold often results in human neurodegenerative diseases. The mechanisms causing expansions remain unknown, although the tendency of TR ssDNA to self-associate into hairpins that slip along their length is widely presumed related. Here we apply single molecule FRET (smFRET) experiments and molecular dynamics simulations to determine conformational stabilities and slipping dynamics for CAG, CTG, GAC and GTC hairpins. Tetraloops are favored in CAG (89%), CTG (89%) and GTC (69%) while GAC favors triloops. We also determined that TTG interrupts near the loop in the CTG hairpin stabilize the hairpin against slipping. The different loop stabilities have implications for intermediate structures that may form when TR-containing duplex DNA opens. Opposing hairpins in the (CAG) ∙ (CTG) duplex would have matched stability whereas opposing hairpins in a (GAC) ∙ (GTC) duplex would have unmatched stability, introducing frustration in the (GAC) ∙ (GTC) opposing hairpins that could encourage their resolution to duplex DNA more rapidly than in (CAG) ∙ (CTG) structures. Given that the CAG and CTG TR can undergo large, disease-related expansion whereas the GAC and GTC sequences do not, these stability differences can inform and constrain models of expansion mechanisms of TR regions.     

The Werner Syndrome Protein Promotes CAG/CTG Repeat Stability by Resolving Large (CAG)n/(CTG)n Hairpins

Expansion of CAG/CTG repeats causes certain neurological and neurodegenerative disorders, and the formation and subsequent persistence of stable DNA hairpins within these repeats are believed to contribute to CAG/CTG repeat instability. Human cells possess a DNA hairpin repair (HPR) pathway, which removes various (CAG)(n) and (CTG)(n) hairpins in a nick-directed and strand-specific manner. Interestingly, this HPR system processes a (CTG)(n) hairpin on the template DNA strand much less efficiently than a (CAG)(n) hairpin on the same strand (Hou, C., Chan, N. L., Gu, L., and Li, G. M. (2009) Incision-dependent and error-free repair of (CAG)(n)/(CTG)(n) hairpins in human cell extracts. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 16, 869-875), suggesting the involvement of an additional component for (CTG)(n) HPR. To identify this activity, a functional in vitro HPR assay was used to screen partially purified HeLa nuclear fractions for their ability to stimulate (CTG)(n) HPR. We demonstrate here that the stimulating activity is the Werner syndrome protein (WRN). Although WRN contains both a 3'→5' helicase activity and a 3'→5' exonuclease activity, the stimulating activity was found to be the helicase activity, as a WRN helicase mutant failed to enhance (CTG)(n) HPR. Consistently, WRN efficiently unwound large (CTG)(n) hairpins and promoted DNA polymerase δ-catalyzed DNA synthesis using a (CTG)(n) hairpin as a template. We, therefore, conclude that WRN stimulates (CTG)(n) HPR on the template DNA strand by resolving the hairpin so that it can be efficiently used as a template for repair or replicative synthesis.     

Mutations in yeast replication proteins that increase CAG/CTG expansions also increase repeat fragility

Expansion of trinucleotide repeats (TNRs) is the causative mutation in several human genetic diseases. Expanded TNR tracts are both unstable (changing in length) and fragile (displaying an increased propensity to break). We have investigated the relationship between fidelity of lagging-strand replication and both stability and fragility of TNRs. We devised a new yeast artificial chromomosme (YAC)-based assay for chromosome breakage to analyze fragility of CAG/CTG tracts in mutants deficient for proteins involved in lagging-strand replication: Fen1/Rad27, an endo/exonuclease involved in Okazaki fragment maturation, the nuclease/helicase Dna2, RNase HI, DNA ligase, polymerase delta, and primase. We found that deletion of RAD27 caused a large increase in breakage of short and long CAG/CTG tracts, and defects in DNA ligase and primase increased breakage of long tracts. We also found a correlation between mutations that increase CAG/CTG tract breakage and those that increase repeat expansion. These results suggest that processes that generate strand breaks, such as faulty Okazaki fragment processing or DNA repair, are an important source of TNR expansions.     

Trinucleotide repeat DNA alters structure to minimize the thermodynamic impact of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine

In the phenomenon of trinucleotide repeat (TNR) expansion, an important interplay exists between DNA damage repair of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoG) and noncanonical structure formation. We show that TNR DNA adapts its structure to accommodate 8-oxoG. Using chemical probe analysis, we find that CAG repeats composing the stem-loop arm of a three-way junction alter the population of structures in response to 8-oxoG by positioning the lesion at or near the loop. Furthermore, we find that oligonucleotides composed of odd-numbered repeat sequences, which form populations of two structures, will also alter their structure to place 8-oxoG in the loop. However, sequences with an even number of repeats do not display this behavior. Analysis by differential scanning calorimetry indicates that when the lesion is located within the loop, there are no significant changes to the thermodynamic parameters as compared to the DNA lacking 8-oxoG. This contrasts with the enthalpic destabilization observed when 8-oxoG is base-paired to C and indicates that positioning 8-oxoG in the loop avoids the thermodynamic penalty associated with 8-oxoG base-pairing. Since formation of stem-loop hairpins is proposed to facilitate TNR expansion, these results highlight the importance of defining the structural consequences of DNA damage.     

Incidence and persistence of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine within a hairpin intermediate exacerbates a toxic oxidation cycle associated with trinucleotide repeat expansion

The repair protein 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine glycosylase (OGG1) initiates base excision repair (BER) in mammalian cells by removing the oxidized base 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoG) from DNA. Interestingly, OGG1 has been implicated in somatic expansion of the trinucleotide repeat (TNR) sequence CAG/CTG. Furthermore, a 'toxic oxidation cycle' has been proposed for age-dependent expansion in somatic cells. In this cycle, duplex TNR DNA is (1) oxidized by endogenous species; (2) BER is initiated by OGG1 and the DNA is further processed by AP endonuclease 1 (APE1); (3) a stem-loop hairpin forms during strand-displacement synthesis by polymerase β (pol β); (4) the hairpin is ligated and (5) incorporated into duplex DNA to generate an expanded CAG/CTG region. This expanded region is again subject to oxidation and the cycle continues. We reported previously that the hairpin adopted by TNR repeats contains a hot spot for oxidation. This finding prompted us to examine the possibility that the generation of a hairpin during a BER event exacerbates the toxic oxidation cycle due to accumulation of damage. Therefore, in this work we used mixed-sequence and TNR substrates containing a site-specific 8-oxoG lesion to define the kinetic parameters of human OGG1 (hOGG1) activity on duplex and hairpin substrates. We report that hOGG1 activity on TNR duplexes is indistinguishable from a mixed-sequence control. Thus, BER is initiated on TNR sequences as readily as non-repetitive DNA in order to start the toxic oxidation cycle. However, we find that for hairpin substrates hOGG1 has reduced affinity and excises 8-oxoG at a significantly slower rate as compared to duplexes. Therefore, 8-oxoG is expected to accumulate in the hairpin intermediate. This damage-containing hairpin can then be incorporated into duplex, resulting in an expanded TNR tract that now contains an oxidative lesion. Thus, the cycle restarts and the DNA can incrementally expand.     

Long CTG.CAG repeats from myotonic dystrophy are preferred sites for intermolecular recombination

Homologous recombination was shown to enable the expansion of CTG.CAG repeat sequences. Other prior investigations revealed the involvement of replication and DNA repair in these genetic instabilities. Here we used a genetic assay to measure the frequency of homologous intermolecular recombination between two CTG.CAG tracts. When compared with non-repeating sequences of similar lengths, long (CTG.CAG)(n) repeats apparently recombine with an approximately 60-fold higher frequency. Sequence polymorphisms that interrupt the homogeneity of the CTG.CAG repeat tracts reduce the apparent recombination frequency as compared with the pure uninterrupted repeats. The orientation of the repeats relative to the origin of replication strongly influenced the apparent frequency of recombination. This suggests the involvement of DNA replication in the recombination process of triplet repeats. We propose that DNA polymerases stall within the CTG.CAG repeat tracts causing nicks or double-strand breaks that stimulate homologous recombination. The recombination process is RecA-dependent.     

Trinucleotide repeats associated with human disease.

Triplet repeat expansion diseases (TREDs) are characterized by the coincidence of disease manifestation with amplification of d(CAG. CTG), d(CGG.CCG) or d(GAA.TTC) repeats contained within specific genes. Amplification of triplet repeats continues in offspring of affected individuals, which generally results in progressive severity of the disease and/or an earlier age of onset, phenomena clinically referred to as 'anticipation'. Recent biophysical and biochemical studies reveal that five of the six [d(CGG)n, d(CCG)n, (CAG)n, d(CTG)n and d(GAA)n] complementary sequences that are associated with human disease form stable hairpin structures. Although the triplet repeat sequences d(GAC)n and d(GTC)n also form hairpins, repeats of the double-stranded forms of these sequences are conspicuously absent from DNA sequence databases and are not anticipated to be associated with human disease. With the exception of d(GAG)n and d(GTG)n, the remaining triplet repeat sequences are unlikely to form hairpin structures at physiological salt and temperature. The details of hairpin structures containing trinucleotide repeats are summarized and discussed with respect to potential mechanisms of triplet repeat expansion and d(CGG.CCG) n methylation/demethylation.     

Long CTG.CAG repeat sequences markedly stimulate intramolecular recombination

Previous studies have shown that homologous recombination is a powerful mechanism for generation of massive instabilities of the myotonic dystrophy CTG.CAG sequences. However, the frequency of recombination between the CTG.CAG tracts has not been studied. Here we performed a systematic study on the frequency of recombination between these sequences using a genetic assay based on an intramolecular plasmid system in Escherichia coli. The rate of intramolecular recombination between long CTG.CAG tracts oriented as direct repeats was extraordinarily high; recombinants were found with a frequency exceeding 12%. Recombination occurred in both RecA(+) and RecA(-) cells but was approximately 2-11 times higher in the recombination proficient strain. Long CTG.CAG tracts recombined approximately 10 times more efficiently than non-repeating control sequences of similar length. The recombination frequency was 60-fold higher for a pair of (CTG.CAG)(165) tracts compared with a pair of (CTG.CAG)(17) sequences. The CTG.CAG sequences in orientation II (CTG repeats present on a lagging strand template) recombine approximately 2-4 times more efficiently than tracts of identical length in the opposite orientation relative to the origin of replication. This orientation effect implies the involvement of DNA replication in the intramolecular recombination between CTG.CAG sequences. Thus, long CTG.CAG tracts are hot spots for genetic recombination.