Nuclear stains with soluble metachrome metal mordant dye lakes

Summary Following our study on the effect of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) extraction on nuclear staining with soluble metal mordant dye lakes covering 29 dye lakes we chose a series of lakes representing the three groups: (1) readily prevented by DNA removal, (2) weakened by DNA extraction but not prevented, (3) unaffected by DNA removal, for application of other endgroup blockade reactions. The lakes selected were alum and iron hematoxylins, iron alum and ferrous sulfate galleins, Fe²⁺ gallo blue E, iron alum celestin blue B, iron alum fluorone black and the phenocyanin TC-FeSO₄ sequence. Azure A with and without an eosin B neutral stain, was used as a simple cationic (and anionic) dye control.Methylation was less effective than with simple cationic dyes, but did weaken celestin blue, gallo blue E and phenocyanin Fe²⁺ nuclear stains. These dyes also demonstrate other acid groups: acid mucins, cartilage matrix, mast cells, central nervous corpora amylacea and artificially introduced carboxyl, sulfuric and sulfonic acid groups. Alum hematoxylin stained cartilage weakly and demonstrated sulfation and sulfonation sites. The iron galleins, iron fluorone black and acid iron hematoxylin do not. A pH 4 iron alum hematoxylin gave no staining of these sites; an alum hematoxylin acidified with 1% 12 N HCl gave weaker results.Deamination prevented eosin and orange G counterstains but did not impair nuclear stains with any of the mordant dye lakes. The simple acetylations likewise did not alter mordant dye nuclear staining, the Skraup reagent gave its usual sulfation effect on other tissue elements, but did not alter nuclear stains by mordant dyes.The mordant dyes do not bind to periodic acid engendered aldehyde sites and p-toluidine/acetic acid and borohydride aldehyde blockades did not alter mordant dye lake nuclear staining. Nitration by tetranitromethane, which blocks azo coupling of tyrosine residues, did not alter nuclear staining by the mordant dye lakes¹. Benzil at pH 13, which prevents the -naphthoquinone-4-Na sulfonate (NQS) arginine reaction and the Fullmer reaction of basic nucleoprotein, did not affect iron gallein, iron or alum hematoxylin stains of nuclei or lingual keratohyalin.Assisted by Contract Nol-CB-43912 National Cancer Institute     

Hematoxylin substitutes: a survey of mordant dyes tested and consideration of the relation of their structure to performance as nuclear stains.

In the search for hematoxylin substitutes 26 dyes were more or less extensively tested for performance as nuclear stains, usually in combination with aluminum, chronic, ferrous and ferric salts. Reports from the literature on hematoxylin substitutes were also considered, and efforts were made to obtain samples of favorably reported dyes and test them. The reports on anthocyanins include isolated reports on several berry juices and a considerable number of studies on Sambucus niger and Vaccinium myrtillus. None of these have so far been tested by us. Otherwise favorable reports have appeared on eleven synthetic dyes and on carmine, brazilin, and hematin. Except for one of the synthetics, naphthazarin, which is no longer fractured, we had samples of all of these. In addition, more or less unsuccessful trials were made on twelve dyestuffs, some of which were new syntheses designed to combine chelating capacity with nucleophilia. Following Fyg's report of blue nuclear staining with chrome alum carmine, trial was made to change the red nuclear stain of kernechtrot by altering the metal mordant. The most successful dyes were phenocyanin TC, gallein, fluorone black, alizarin cyanin BB and alizarin blue S. Celestin blue B with an iron mordant is quite successful if properly handled to prevent gelling of solutions.     

Hematoxylin substitutes: fluorone black and methyl fluorone black (9-phenyl- and 9-methyl-2,3,7-trihydroxy-6-fluorone) as metachrome iron alum mordant dyes.

The phenyl and methyl trihydroxyfluorones, hitherto used histologically only in the rather difficult and unreliable Turchini technics for discriminating deoxyribonucleic from ribonucleic acid, find a new use as iron mordant metachrome dyes which act as nuclear stains. Nuclear staining is unaffected by acid extraction of nucleic acids, as with hematoxylin lakes. The two dyes, named by Liebermann and Lindenbaum 9-phenyl-2, 3, 7-trihydroxy-6-fluorone, have also acquired (illustrating with the phenyl homolog) longer chemical names of the form 2,6,7-trihydroxy-9-phenylisoxanthene-3-one (Eastman). Aldrich and Pfalz-Bauer adhere to the Liebermann-Lindenbaum nomenclature. The trivial name fluorone black is proposed for the phenyl homolog and methyl fluorone black for the methyl homolog. The iron lake of fluorone black appears to be a useful substitute for iron hematoxylin, methyl flurone black less useful. Neither dye has the diverse capability of hematoxylin.     

Hematoxylin Substitutes: A Survey of Mordant Dyes Tested and Consideration of the Relation of Their Structure to Performance as Nuclear Stains

In the search for hematoxylin substitutes 26 dyes were more or less extensively tested for performance as nuclear stains, usually in combination with aluminum, chromic, ferrous and ferric salts. Reports from the literature on hematoxylin substitutes were also considered, and efforts were made to obtain samples of favorably reported dyes and test them. The reports on anthocyanins include isolated reports on several berry juices and a considerable number of studies on Sambucus niger and Vaccinium mytillus. None of these have so far been tested by us. Otherwise favorable reports have appeared on eleven synthetic dyes and on carmine, brazilin, and hematein. Except for one of the synthetics, naphthazarin, which is no longer manufactured, we had samples of all of these. In addition, more or less unsuccessful trials were made on twelve dyestuffs, some of which were new syntheses designed to combine chelating capacity with nucleophilia. Following Fyg's report of blue nuclear staining with chrome alum carmine, trial was made to change the red nuclear stain of kernechtrot by altering the metal mordant.

The most successful dyes were phenocyanin TC, gallein, fluorone black, alizarin cyanin BB and alizarin blue S. Celestin blue B with an iron mordant is quite successful if properly handled to prevent gelling of solutions.     

Hematoxylin Substitutes: Fluorone Black and Methyl Fluorone Black (9-Phenyl- and 9-Methyl-2, 3, 7-Trihydroxy-6-Fluorone) as Metachrome Iron Alum Mordant Dyes

The phenyl and methyl trihydroxyfluorones, hitherto used histologically only in the rather difficult and unreliable Turchini tecbnics for discriminating deoxyribonucleic from ribonucleic acid, find a new use as iron mordant metachrome dyes which act as nuclear stains. Nuclear staining is unaffected by acid extraction of nudeic acids, as with hematoxylin lakes.

The two dyes, named by Liebermann and Lindenbanm 9-phenyl-2, 3, 7-trihydroxy-6-fluorone and 9-methyl-2, 3, 7-trihydroxy-6-Ruorone, have also acquired (illustrating with the phenyl homolog) longer chemical names of the form 2, 6, 7-trihydroxy-9-phenylisoxanthene-3-one (Eastman). Aldrich and Pfalz-Bauer adhere to the Liebermann-Lindenbaum nomenclature. The trivial name fluorone black is proposed for the phenyl homolog and methyl fluorone black for the methyl homolog.

The iron lake of fluorone black appears to be a useful substitute for iron hematoxylin, methyl fluorone black less useful. Neither dye has the diverse capability of hematoxylin.

Aided by a contract from the National Cancer Institute NO-1-CB-43912     

Improved nuclear staining with mordant blue 3 as a hematoxylin substitute.

For progressive staining 1 g mordant blue 3, 0.5 g iron a alum and 10 ml hydrochloric acid are combined to make 1 liter with distlled water. Paraffin sections are stained 5 minutes blued in 0.5% sodium acetate for 30 seconds and counterstained with eosin. For regressive staining, 1 g dye, 9 g iron alum and 50 ml acetic acid are combined to make 1 liter with distilled water. Staining time is 5 minutes followed by differentiation in 1% acid alcohol and blueing in 0.5% sodium acetate. Counterstain with eosin. In both cases results very closely results very resemble a good hematoxylin and eosin.     

Improved Nuclear Staining with Mordant Blue 3 as A Hematoxylin Substitute

For progressive staining 1 g mordant blue 3, 0.5 g iron alum and 10 ml hydrochloric acid are combined to make 1 liter with distilled water. Paraffin sections are stained 5 minutes, blued in 03% sodium acetate for 30 seconds and counterstained with eosin. For regressive staining, 1 g dye, 9 g iron alum and 50 ml acetic acid are combined to make 1 liter with distilled water. Staining time is 5 minutes followed by differentiation in 1% acid alcohol and blueing in 0.5% sodium acetate. Counterstain with eosin. In both cases results very closely resemble a good hematoxylin and eosin.     

Mordant Blue 3: a Readily Availablx Substitute for Hematoxylin in the Routine Hematoxylin and Eosin Stain

Mordant blue 3 may be used as a suhstitute for hematoxylin in hematoxylin and eosin stains. The staining solution consists of 0.25 g dye, 40 ml of 10% iron dam, 5 ml of cone H₂SO₄, and 955 ml of dirtilled H₂O. Staining the is 5 minutes, followed by differentiation in acid water or acid alcohol. After blueing, the seaions are counterstained with emin. Results closely resemble the hematoxylin and eosin stain.     

Metallic Lakes of the oxazines (Gallamin Blue, Gallocyanin and Coelestin Blue) as Nuclear Stain Substitutes for Hematoxylin

Becher's investigations upon the soluble metallic lakes of the oxazines have been re-investigated, extended and results described. Gallamin blue, gallocyanin and coelestin blue in combination with ferric ammonium sulfate gave the best results. The dyes are dissolved in a five per cent aqueous solution of ferric ammonium sulfate. The solution is boiled for 2-3 minutes, cooled, filtered and ready for immediate use. The iron lakes of these dyes stain nuclei excellently giving a deep blue or blue black in 3-5 minutes. No differentiation with acid is required. Coelestin blue gives the most stable solution and is recommended as a routine nuclear stain. The protoplasm remains practically colorless and counter-staining with acid dyes such as ethyl-eosin, orange G, or fuchsin gives pictures which cannot be distinguished from a good hematoxylin stain.

Counter-staining with van Gieson solution is also possible. Benda's modification of the van Gieson solution is recommended. Staining of fat with Sudan, scarlet red, etc., does not interfere with nuclear staining by these dyes.

As applied to the central nervous system these dyes are far superior to hematoxylin. Ganglion and glia cells are as excellently stained as with thionin.

The most widely used fixatives, namely formaldehyde, Mueller-formaldehyde, Zenker's and alcohol, give equally as good results. The nature of the staining process is briefly discussed and a prospectus offered.     

Standardization of the Papanicolaou stain. I. A comparison of five nuclear stains.

The staining characteristics of five nuclear stains used in a Papanicolaou staining procedure were investigated. Alcohol-fixed cervical smears were stained with a modified Papanicolaou procedure using hematoxylin, alcoholic thionin bromide, alcoholic Victoria blue B, gallocyanin or the thionin Feulgen reagent (thionin-SO2) as the nuclear stain. The same anionic counterstain was used for all slides, and the optical densities of cell nuclei and cytoplasm were measured with the IBAS 2000 image analyzer. Alcoholic thionin gave the most intense nuclear stain, with a very high reproducibility of the staining pattern. Hematoxylin showed the highest coefficient of variation of the staining intensity. Both hematoxylin and gallocyanin gave some nonspecific cytoplasmic staining. Thionin-SO2 allowed a quantitative assessment of DNA, but gave a low staining intensity. Staining with the metal complex dyes interfered with subsequent staining with the pararosaniline Feulgen reagent. Alcoholic thioinin is thus recommended as a nuclear stain for cervical cytology in the Papanicolaou procedure, both for image analysis and for visual microscopy.     

News from the Biological Stain Commission

Abstract

The origins of repeated hematoxylin shortages are outlined. Lack of integration in the hematoxylin trade exacerbates the problems inherent in using a natural product. Separate corporations are engaged in tree growth and harvesting, dye extraction, processing of extracts to yield hematoxylin, and formulation and sale of hematoxylin staining solutions to the end users in biomedical laboratories. Hematoxylin has many uses in biological staining and no single dye can replace it for all applications. Probably, the most satisfactory substitutes for aluminum-hematoxylin (hemalum) are the ferric complexes of celestine blue (CI 51050; mordant blue 14) and eriochrome cyanine R (CI 43820; mordant blue 3, also known as chromoxane cyanine R and solochrome cyanine R). The iron-celestine blue complex is a cationic dye that binds to nucleic acids and other polyanions, such as those of cartilage matrix and mast cell granules. Complexes of iron with eriochrome cyanine R are anionic and give selective nuclear staining similar to that obtained with acidic hemalum solutions. Iron complexes of gallein (CI 45445; mordant violet 25), a hydroxyxanthene dye, can replace iron-hematoxylin in formulations for staining nuclei, myelin, and protozoa.     

A New Principle in Polychrome Staining: A System of Automated Staining, Complementary to Hematoxylin and Eosin, and Usable as a Research Tool

A staining system is described in which each stage forms a separate module or unit. All reagents, concentrations of dye, ratios of phosphotungstic acid to dye, pH values, temperature and staining times are standardized and only aqueous solutions used. The technic uses equal strength solutions of orange G, acid fuchsin and methyl (or aniline) blue, in ascending order of molecular size, at pH 2.5 (range: 2.3 to 2.7). Phosphotungstic acid is incorporated in the dyebaths, not used separately, and the combination of this with ferric alum hematoxylin (Lillie's by preference) and either naphthol yellow S or picric acid as a primer, enables fibrin and cytoplasmic components to be demonstrated vividly, with other tissues shown in clear contrasting colors. Erythrocytes are yellow, fibrin red and collagen blue. The system permits substitution of dyes, lending itself to both manual and computer recording and analysis, helped by a notation system for identifying variants. Many of the factors are variable at will. The system aids research into the mechanism of polychrome staining, and, by extrapolation, into the mechanism of action of other stains. Two manually or machine usable progressive polychrome technics intended for routine use are described. They identify tissue components consistently, complementing the standard hematoxylin and eosin stain, and deserve equal attention during reporting. Variants may be used for one-minute one-stage staining of frozen sections, or to give strong colors with 2 mμ acrylic sections.     

A new principle in polychrome staining: a system of automated staining, complementary to hematoxylin and eosin, and usable as a research tool

A staining system is described in which each stage forms a separate module or unit. All reagents, concentrations of dye, ratios of phosphotungstic acid to dye, pH values, temperature and staining times are standardized and only aqueous solutions used. The technic uses equal strength solutions of orange G, acid fuchsin and methyl (or aniline) blue, in ascending order of molecular size, at pH 2.5 (range: 2.3 to 2.7). Phosphotungstic acid is incorporated in the dyebaths, not used separately, and the combination of this with ferric alum hematoxylin (Lillie's by preference) and either naphthol yellow S or picric acid as a primer, enables fibrin and cytoplasmic components to be demonstrated vividly, with other tissues shown in clear contrasting colors. Erythrocytes are yellow, fibrin red and collagen blue. The system permits substitution of dyes, lending itself to both manual and computer recording and analysis, helped by a notation system for identifying variants. Many of the factors are variable at will. The system aids research into the mechanism of polychrome staining, and, by extrapolation, into the mechanism of action of other stains. Two manually or machine usable progressive polychrome technics intended for routine use are described. They identify tissue components consistently, complementing the standard hematoxylin and eosin stain, and deserve equal attention during reporting. Variants may be used for one-minute one-stage staining of frozen sections, or to give strong colors with 2 millimicrons acrylic sections.     

Metallic Lakes of the oxazines (Gallamin Blue,Gallocyanin and Coelestin Blue) as Nuclear Stain Substitutes for Hematoxylin

Becher's investigations upon the soluble metallic lakes of the oxazines have been re-investigated, extended and results described. Gallamin blue, gallocyanin and coelestin blue in combination with ferric ammonium sulfate gave the best results. The dyes are dissolved in a five per cent aqueous solution of ferric ammonium sulfate. The solution is boiled for 2–3 minutes, cooled, filtered and ready for immediate use. The iron lakes of these dyes stain nuclei excellently giving a deep blue or blue black in 3–5 minutes. No differentiation with acid is required. Coelestin blue gives the most stable solution and is recommended as a routine nuclear stain. The protoplasm remains practically colorless and counter-staining with acid dyes such as ethyl-eosin, orange G, or fuchsin gives pictures which cannot be distinguished from a good hematoxylin stain.

Counter-staining with van Gieson solution is also possible. Benda's modification of the van Gieson solution is recommended. Staining of fat with Sudan, scarlet red, etc., does not interfere with nuclear staining by these dyes.

As applied to the central nervous system these dyes are far superior to hematoxylin. Ganglion and glia cells are as excellently stained as with thionin.

The most widely used fixatives, namely formaldehyde, Mueller-formaldehyde, Zenker's and alcohol, give equally as good results. The nature of the staining process is briefly discussed and a prospectus offered.     

Romanowsky Staining with Buffered Solutions, III. Extension of the Method to Romanowsky Stains in General

Solutions at 0.3 g. per 100 cc. of equal parts of glycerin and methyl alcohol of various Wright, Giemsa, Leishman and Balch stains and similar eosinates of thiazene dyes give satisfactory wholesale staining of sections without differentiation when buffered with citric-acid and sodium-phosphate. Prestaining with alum hematoxylin adds to depth, density and permanence of nuclear staining, but decreases clarity. A satisfactory modification of Mayer's acid hemalum is described. The reaction should be pH 4.2 for neutral formalin or Orth fixation, pH 4.6 for acid formalin, pH 5.0 for Zenker formalin and pH 6.5 for ethyl or methyl alcohol or Carney fixation. Toluidine blue phloxhiate is found to be a quite desirable stain and its preparation is described. Clarite and clarite are definitely superior to neutral Canada balsam, and somewhat inferior in regard to fading compared with liquid petrolatum as mounting media for these Romanowsky stains.     

Iron and Aluminum Lakes of Gallo Blue E As Nuclear and Metachromatic Mucin Stains

Gallo blue E, C. I. No. 51040, Mordant Violet 54, furnishes a blue black nuclear stain when applied to tissue sections in the form of its moderately stable iron lakes. This adoring combined well with such counterstains as orange G and eosin B. The Van Gieson stain tends to decolorize mucins, cartilage, and mast ells previously stained with this dye. Its aluminum lake solutions tend to gel in a few minutes to 24 hours depending on the solvent wed and the amount of Al²⁺ present. Aluminum lake solutions give a moderately good blue to dark blue nuclear stain and a brilliant purplish red to dark purple stain to a variety of epithelial and connective tissue mucins. Acid dye counterstains are poorly tolerated. With either lake, nuclear staining is abolished by deoxyribonuclease digestion or relatively short mineral acid extraction of DNA.     

Milling Red SWB: A Textile Dye for Staining Epithelial Intercellular Bridges

Fourteen textile dyes were evaluated as histological stains for benign and malignant tissues. An acid dye, Milling red SWB (Acid Red 114, C.I. 23635) was found to possess great affinity for epithelial intercellular bridges. The intercellular bridges were demonstrated clearly when the Milling red SWB was used as a 1% solution in 1% potassium alum after hematoxylin and, also, when methylene blue ZX (Basic Blue 9, C.I. 52015) was used as a counter-stain, without hematoxylin. The intercellular bridges could not be demonstrated in pleomorphic cells which invaded the subepithelial connective tissue.     

Gallocyanin-Chrome Alum: I. Technique and Specificity

Certain technical aspects of gallocyanin-chrome alum were examined relative to its supposed specificity for nucleic acids. Five different lake formulae were prepared using four different batches of gallocyanin. Spectrophotometric curves were made of each lake and of each dye in a simple water solution. Paraffin sections 6-8 μ thick of spinal cords from albino rats and from cats fixed in CaCl₂-formalin or plain formalin were stained 10 min to 48 hr with gallocyanin lakes made with chrome alum, ferric alum, strontium chloride and copper nitrate. Similar sections were treated with ribonuclease or perochloric acid and stained in the same manner. The spectrophotometric data indicates considerable variation in dye content between different batches and different lakes. Chrome alum was the best of the 4 mordants and a 12-15 hr staining time with Einarson's 1932 preparation was optimal. Neither perchloric acid nor ribonuclease destroyed cytoplasmic basophilia as revealed by gallocyaninchrome alum. Staining was more intense after CaCl₂-formalin fixation than after plain formalin. Variation of the dye content in the different batches of dyes, the poorly understood role of boiling in preparing the lakes, and the inability of ribonuclease or perchloric acid to destroy cytoplasmic basophilia indicates that we are not dealing with a histochemically specific reagent for nucleic acid, but only a desirable nuclear stain.     

Difficulties in Ferrous Iron Mordant Hematoxylin Staining and Some Hematoxylin Substitutes

A gradual deterioration of intensity of sequence ferrous sulfate hematoxylin staining was traced, after elimination of hematoxylin quality as a cause, to a deterioration of the metal salt, associated with caking of the crystals. Fresh samples were also partly caked and ineffective. Ferrous ammonium sulfate was found also subject to the same deterioration. Ferrous chloride freshly prepared as a 1 M solution from iron wire under anaerobic conditions at biweekly intervals proved to be satisfactory as a mordant source. Of several other mordant dyes tested: gallein, brazilin and chromoxane pure blue B were the best, but none was equal to good hematoxylin.     

A Stable, High-Contrast Mordant for Hematoxylin Staining

Small, quantities of sulfuric acid will stabilize iron mordants, used in hematoxylin staining, by preserving these solutions against oxidation. The presence of acetic acid in the mordant improves the specificity of the stain. A stable, high-contrast mordant is obtained when both acids are combined with ferric-ammonium sulfate. This mordant, used in combination with fresh alkaline solutions of hematoxylin, has been found especially effective in the staining of certain nuclear and cytoplasmic components of plant cells.