Selective production of autoantibodies in graft-vs-host-induced and spontaneous murine lupus. Predominant reactivity with histone regions accessible in chromatin

The injection of (C57BL/6 X DBA/2)F1 mice with parental DBA/2 lymphoid cells leads to a lupus-like disease in which IgG autoantibodies are targeted to certain nuclear and cell surface antigens. To investigate further the extent of antibody diversity in this graft-vs-host (GVH) model, we studied the specificity of antihistone antibodies induced by the GVH reaction. High levels of IgG antibodies to histones H1 and H2B were detected whereas responses to H2A, H3, and H4 were only marginally elevated above pre-GVH levels. Immunoblotting analysis further revealed that the response to H2B was focused on epitopes that most likely reside in the N-terminal region. In contrast, F1 mice immunized with H2B/RNA complexes in adjuvant produced antibodies to the N terminus as well as to other regions of the H2B molecule. Thus, the antihistone response stimulated by the GVH reaction is only a fraction of the potentially activatable B cell repertoire. We also determined whether antibodies that arise spontaneously in genetically predisposed lupus strains were restricted in their histone reactivity. The response to core histones was highly variable among individual animals of the NZB/NZW and MRL-lpr/lpr strains despite their inbred nature. However, nearly all mice exhibited a preferential reactivity for epitopes in histone regions that are lost after partial trypsin digestion of chromatin. These data demonstrating autoantibody responses that are limited to particular histone regions support a mechanism by which B cells are selectively activated in murine lupus. The predominant production of antibodies to histone regions that are exposed in nucleosomes raises the possibility that chromatin is an antigenic stimulus for histone-specific B cells in this disease.     

The Lyb-3+5+ subset of B cells is not required for lupus-like autoantibody formation caused by graft-vs-host reaction

We asked the question whether or not the Lyb-3+5+ B cell subset, which is lacking in CBA/N immune defective mice, is required for the lupus-like autoantibody formation caused by graft-vs-host reaction (GVHR). (CBA/N X DBA/2)F1 male defective mice injected with DBA/2 T cells produced IgG autoantibodies to the same extent as did nondefective F1 mice suffering from GVHR. Although a very small number of DBA/2 B cells might have contaminated the T cell inocula, it was shown that these were B cells of the defective F1 mice that produced autoantibodies during the GVHR. This was demonstrated by detecting autoantibodies carrying an immunoglobulin allotype of the F1 recipient. Furthermore, the defective F1 male mice injected with CBA/N lymphoid cells, which were lacking Lyb-3+5+ B cells, also produced autoantibodies. Isotype analysis of antinuclear antibodies revealed that some of them belonged to IgG3 isotype. It was concluded that the ontogenically late-appearing B cell subset is not required for GVH autoimmunity.     

Role of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in the prevention of lupus-like disease occurring in a murine model of graft-vs-host disease

The inoculation of B6D2F1 mice with T lymphocytes from the C57BL/6 parental strain induces an "immunosuppressive" graft-vs-host reaction (B6 GVH), whereas inoculation of T cells from the other, DBA/2 parental strain induces an "immunostimulatory" GVH reaction and a lupus-like disease (DBA GVH). The present study compares cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) function in the spleens of these GVH mice as well as differences in the donor inoculum that could account for these different types of GVH. We observed that the B6 GVH induces an immunodeficiency that encompasses CTL precursors (and possibly T helper cells) and results in suppressor cells that abrogate responses to both trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified self and third party alloantigens. In contrast, the DBA GVH induces only a T helper cell immunodeficiency and results in suppressor cells selective for class II restricted L3T4+ T helper cells. Chimeric T cells were detected in both types of GVH. In the B6 GVH both L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ donor cells were observed, although Lyt-2+ cells predominated. In the DBA GVH, donor T cells were almost exclusively of the L3T4+ phenotype. The lack of appreciable donor Lyt-2+ cells in the DBA GVH can be explained by a defect in the DBA donor inoculum manifested by a naturally occurring two-fold reduction in Lyt-2+ cell numbers as well as a nine-fold reduction in CTL precursors with anti-F1 specificity. T cells in the DBA inoculum, therefore, are predominantly L3T4+. A similar defect induced in B6 donor cells by anti-Lyt2 antibody and complement not only converted the suppressive GVH to a stimulatory GVH, as measured by anti-DNA antibodies, but also resulted in a T cell immune deficiency characteristic of the DBA GVH, i.e., a selective loss of the TNP-self CTL response. Thus the presence or absence of adequate numbers of functioning Lyt-2+ cells in the donor inoculum is correlated with the development of either a suppressive or stimulatory GVH, respectively. That donor Lyt-2+ cells mediate a suppressive GVH through cytolytic mechanisms is evidenced by greater than 70% reduction in B6 GVH spleen cell numbers and readily demonstrable anti-F1 CTL activity by these spleen cells despite an inability to generate anti-allogeneic or anti-TNP self CTL activity even in the presence of added T helper factors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Allosuppressor- and allohelper-T cells in acute and chronic graft-vs-host disease. IV. Activation of donor allosuppressor cells is confined to acute GVHD

Groups of nonirradiated BDF1 mice were injected with unseparated spleen cells from B10, B10.D2, or DBA/2 donors. The diverse clinical and pathologic symptoms that developed during the course of the ensuing graft-vs-host reaction (GVHR) were related to the functional subsets of donor-T cells activated in the host. The activation of F1-specific donor T suppressor (TS) cells was confined to those GVH F1 mice that developed acute GVH disease (GVHD) (donor B10 or B10.D2). Moreover, activation in these GVH F1 mice of the Lyt-1-2+ donor TS cells sharply preceded the onset of and coincided with (week 2 to 6) the suppressive pathologic symptoms characteristic of acute GVHD, such as pancytopenia and suppression of splenic IgG production. The activation of these alloreactive TS effector cells was briefly preceded by the activation of F1-specific Lyt-1+-2- donor T helper (TH) cells and stimulation of the host's lymphoid tissue. Thus, in acute GVHD, a sequential alloactivation first of donor TH and then of TS cells was found. Those F1 mice that recovered from acute GVHD and developed stimulatory pathologic symptoms showed a concomitant loss of donor TS cell activity. An initial activation of F1-specific Lyt-1 +2- donor TH cells was also found in that parent----F1 combination (donor DBA/2), which failed to develop acute GVHD. Significantly in that combination, the alloactivation of donor TH cells was not followed by activation of significant numbers of donor TS cells. Instead, the DBA/2-injected BDF1 mice directly developed a persistent increase in splenic Ig formation and lupus-like GVHD.     

Allogeneic MHC antigen requirements for lupus-like autoantibody production and nephritis in murine graft-vs-host disease

A graft-vs-host (GVH) reaction of parental T cells in allogeneic F1 mice can lead to an autoimmune disease resembling human SLE. We analyzed the contribution of MHC genes to the development of IgG antinuclear antibody production and immune complex glomerulonephritis in MHC-congenic F1 recipients. DBA/2 T cells elicited IgG antibodies to histone, ssDNA, and dsDNA in all histoincompatible F1 recipients that were studied. The anti-DNA antibody responses were quantitatively similar among the F1 combinations and displayed comparable IgG2a subclass and cationic charge characteristics. In contrast, severe renal disease was manifested only in F1 mice that expressed H-2b encoded class II gene products. Disease susceptibility was associated with a decrease in circulating anti-DNA antibodies and a characteristic localization of immune complexes in the glomeruli. The data suggest that the production of potentially pathogenic IgG anti-nuclear antibodies is not sufficient for the development of renal disease in GVH-induced lupus. Thus, another event separate from autoantibody production is MHC dependent and appears to be critical for the formation and/or deposition of pathologic immune complexes.     

Donor CD8 T cells and IFN-gamma are critical for sex-based differences in donor CD4 T cell engraftment and lupus-like phenotype in short-term chronic graft-versus-host disease mice

The transfer of unfractionated DBA/2J (DBA) splenocytes into B6D2F(1) (DBA → F(1)) mice results in greater donor CD4 T cell engraftment in females at day 14 that persists long-term and mediates greater female lupus-like renal disease. Although donor CD8 T cells have no demonstrated role in lupus pathogenesis in this model, we recently observed that depletion of donor CD8 T cells prior to transfer eliminates sex-based differences in renal disease long-term. In this study, we demonstrate that greater day 14 female donor CD4 engraftment is also critically dependent on donor CD8 T cells. Male DBA → F(1) mice exhibit stronger CD8-dependent day 8-10 graft-versus-host (GVH) and counter-regulatory host-versus-graft (HVG) responses, followed by stronger homeostatic contraction (days 10-12). The weaker day 10-12 GVH and HVG in females are followed by persistent donor T cell activation and increasing proliferation, expansion, and cytokine production from days 12 to 14. Lastly, greater female day 14 donor T cell engraftment, activation, and cytokine production were lost with in vivo IFN-γ neutralization from days 6 to 14. We conclude the following: 1) donor CD8 T cells enhance day 10 proliferation of donor CD4 T cells in both sexes; and 2) a weaker GVH/HVG in females allows prolonged survival of donor CD4 and CD8 T cells, allowing persistent activation. These results support the novel conclusion that sex-based differences in suboptimal donor CD8 CTL activation are critical for shaping sex-based differences in donor CD4 T cell engraftment at 2 wk and lupus-like disease long-term.     

The existence of antibody-like activities against the weakly immunogenic minor histocompatibility antigens

BALB/c mice develop cytotoxic lymphocytes as well as produce specific antibodies against the minor histocompatibility antigens when injected with DBA/2 P815 cells. P815 cells grown in BALB/c mice have IgG antibodies on their surface as demonstrated by the binding of ¹²⁵I-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG and by complement-dependent cytotoxicity. Serum from BALB/c mice hyperimmunized with P815 cells blocked lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity by BALB/c immune peritoneal exudate cells. This blocking activity was removed by absorbing hyperimmune serum with DBA/2 spleen cells or P815 cells. This result suggests that specific antibodies were generated against the minor histocompatibility differences between BALB/c and DBA/2 mice. The experimental procedures described may be very useful in demonstrating minute quantities of antibody against minor histocompatibility antigens on tumor cells.     

Histone autoantigens in murine lupus. Definition of a major epitope within an accessible region of chromatin.

In SLE and in the (NZB x NZW)F1 murine model of this disease, IgG autoantibodies are frequently produced to DNA and histones. In the present study, we define a linear epitope on histone H2B that is recognized by (NZB x NZW)F1 mice. IgG antibodies from anti-H2B positive (but not anti-H2B negative) mice bound strongly to a peptide containing the first 15 N-terminal amino acids, a region that is exposed in chromatin. Competitive inhibition studies showed that the binding of autoantibodies to H2B in ELISA as well as the binding to soluble H2B was substantially blocked by this peptide. Studies with smaller peptides mapped the epitope to residues 3-12. Individual mice recognized different residues within this region, and a sequence search did not reveal proteins other than H2B that could elicit this spectrum of antibodies. Interestingly, these autoantibody specificities were not a component of those induced in preautoimmune mice by immunization with H2B/RNA complexes or with H2B peptide 1-30 containing the autoantigenic sequence. These findings argue that recognition of a specific N-terminal region of self histone contributes to the anti-H2B autoantibody response in lupus. Autoreactive B cells with specificity for this sequence seem to develop only after the autoimmune process has been initiated.     

Treatment of NZB/NZW mice with total lymphoid irradiation: long-lasting suppression of disease without generalized immune suppression

We used total lymphoid irradiation (TLI; total dose = 3400 rad) to treat the lupus-like renal disease of 6-mo-old female NZB/NZW mice. Similar to our past studies, this treatment resulted in a marked prolongation of survival, decrease in proteinuria, and decrease in serum anti-DNA antibodies compared with untreated littermate controls. Although there was no evidence of disease recurrence in TLI-treated mice until after 12 mo of age, the in vitro proliferative response to phytohemagglutinin by NZB/NZW spleen cells recovered within 6 wk such that responses were greater than control NZB/NZW animals. A similar recovery and overshoot after TLI were evident in the primary antibody response to the T cell-dependent antigen sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Both the total and IgG anti-SRBC antibody responses after TLI were greater than those of untreated NZB/NZW controls, and were comparable with those of untreated non-autoimmune mice. Despite this increased response to mitogens and antigens after TLI, we noted a decrease in spontaneous splenic IgG-secreting cells and a decrease in IgG but not IgM antinuclear antibody production. Nonspecific suppressor cells of the mixed leukocyte response were detectable in the spleens of NZB/NZW mice early after TLI. However, the disappearance of suppressor cells was not associated with recrudescence of disease activity. Furthermore, transfer of large numbers of spleen cells from TLI-treated NZB/NZW mice did not result in disease suppression in untreated age-matched recipients. In summary, treatment of NZB/NZW mice with TLI results in a prolonged remission in autoimmune disease, which is achieved in the absence of generalized immunosuppression.     

Monoclonal autoantibodies to subnucleosomes from a MRL/Mp(-)+/+ mouse. Oligoclonality of the antibody response and recognition of a determinant composed of histones H2A, H2B, and DNA.

MRL/Mp(-)+/+ mice produce antinuclear antibodies and develop a spontaneous autoimmune syndrome with lupus-like nephritis. We obtained a panel of seven histone-reactive IgG mAb from a single MRL/Mp(-)+/+ mouse. These antibodies do not react significantly with DNA or individual histones, but bind strongly to the histone H2A-H2B dimer and even more strongly to the H2A-H2B-DNA complex. These antibodies also bind to whole nuclei when tested by immunofluorescence, indicating that they recognize an epitope accessible in chromatin. The V region sequences of these antibodies have been determined. The H chain third complementarity-determining regions of these antibodies are similar to those found in anti-DNA antibodies even though the antibodies in our panel do not react with DNA in the absence of histones, suggesting that DNA is part of the subnucleosome epitope. Several of these antibodies are clonally related, supporting the hypothesis that the activation of these clones is Ag-driven. Analysis of the sequences of these antibodies indicates that they derive from autoreactive B cells that were clonally expanded and whose V region genes have undergone numerous somatic mutations.     

Therapeutic effect of CpG motifs on the development of chronic graft-versus-host disease in mice

Transferring DBA/2 spleen cells into (C57BL/10xDBA/2) F1 (referred to as BDF1) mice induces a chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), characterized by the production of Th(2) cytokines, hypergammaglobulinemia, and immune complex-mediated glomerulonephritis that resembles systemic lupus erythematosus. DNA motif consisting of an unmethylated CpG dinucleotide flanked by two 5' purines and two 3' pyrimidines (CpG ODN) induces Th(1) cytokine production in mice. This study examines the effect of administering CpG ODN to mice undergoing chronic GVHD, based on the premise that altering Th(1)/Th(2) activity might beneficially impact on disease progression.GVHD BDF1 mice injected with DBA/2 spleen cells were treated with weekly intraperitoneal injection of 50 microg CpG ODN. This treatment significantly suppressed the production of IgG anti-DNA autoantibody and reduced the development of glomerulonephritis. Serum IgG2a titers were higher in the CpG ODN than in non-CpG control group, whereas IgG1 titers were unchanged. As predicted, IFN-gamma levels were significantly higher in the CpG ODN-treated group, while IL-4 levels were lower, resulting in a shift in the Th(1)/Th(2) cytokine ratio. Results suggest that CpG ODN administration may be of therapeutic benefit in chronic GVHD.     

In vivo allogeneic effects: shift in the isotype profile of primary TI-2 responses in mice undergoing graft-vs-host reaction

We showed previously that primary responses to T-dependent (TD) and T-independent type 2 (TI-2) antigens were differentially affected by allogeneic effects induced in vivo during a graft-vs-host reaction (GVH). TD responses were greater than or equal to 80% suppressed, whereas the TI-2 responses were greatly enhanced, particularly the IgG component, which normally is very low. We have analyzed the IgG subclass distribution in primary responses of normal and GVH F1 mice in order to determine whether the strong T cell signals that occur during GVH reactions also induce shifts in the isotype profile. The effect of GVH on responses to TI-2 antigens was of particular interest because they are usually dominated by IgM and IgG3 classes in normal mice. We found a threefold to 10-fold increase in the PFC numbers of all four IgG subclasses in the response to TI-2 antigens, with an apparent shift from the usual IgG3 dominance to IgG1 in GVH mice. This IgG1 dominance was not found in serum antibodies where IgG3, IgG1, and IgG2b were equally expressed, although total IgG was increased greater than 20-fold. No isotype shift was found in either the TNP-KLH response, which was greater than or equal to 75% suppressed (IgG1 dominance was retained), or in the TI-1 response to TNP-Ba. The latter response was reduced (25 to 50%) in GVH mice and continued to be dominated by IgG2b/2a and IgG3. Unlike the unique isotype patterns found in primary responses, TNP-KLH primed mice challenged with TD, TI-1, or TI-2 antigens gave memory responses with identical isotype profiles that were dominated by IgG1 PFC. The role of T cells in B cell differentiation and isotype expression is discussed.     

In vitro production of anti-histone antibodies by spleen cells from young autoantibody negative NZB/NZW mice

Anti-histone antibodies (AHA) are spontaneously produced in NZB/NZW mice as part of their autoimmune disease. IgM AHA are usually not detected until after 4 mo of age, and older female mice switch to the production of IgG AHA. We studied the in vitro production of AHA by spleen cells from young (less than or equal to 12-wk-old) NZB/NZW mice. Despite the absence of elevated serum AHA activity, spleen cells from these mice demonstrated marked spontaneous autoantibody production in culture. In kinetic studies, little in vitro production was detectable after 1 day of culture, and maximal accumulation occurred on day 5. Elevated AHA production was apparent by cells from 2-wk-old NZB/NZW mice, and an age-dependent increase in autoantibody production was also noted. Only AHA of the IgM class were detected in cultures of young spleen cells. The in vitro production of IgM AHA in culture was T cell dependent, depletion of T cells resulting in a 70 to 90% reduction in production, which was corrected by the readdition of T cells. In cultures where both IgM AHA and total IgM secretion were measured, a much greater T cell dependence for AHA production was apparent. The requirement for T cells could also be partially replaced by factors present in concanavalin A supernatant. AHA secretion was induced by lipopolysaccharide by using cells from both NZB/NZW and non-autoimmune mice. Although production was greater with NZB/NZW cells, the difference was much less than that for spontaneous production. Thus, AHA-secreting cells that are dependent on in vitro T cell help are present in young NZB/NZW mice. These studies may help define the mechanisms responsible for selective autoantibody secretion in lupus-like disease.     

Fate of H2-activated T lymphocytes in syngeneic hosts. III. Differentiation into long-lived recirculating memory cells.

Memory to H2 determinants was studied with an adoptive transfer system using a population of H2-activated blast T cells (T.TDL) obtained from thoracic duct lymph of irradiated F₁ hybrid mice injected with parental strain T cells. CBA T.TDL activated either to DBA/2 or C57BL determinants were transferred to syngeneic “B” mice. Thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) were obtained from the recipients 4–6 weeks later and tested for their capacity to produce (a) a graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction, (b) a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) (measured by an in vivo technique) and (c) allograft rejection (suppression of the growth of allogeneic tumour cells in vivo). Control experiments involved testing the function of TDL obtained from “B” mice preinjected with TDL or no cells.TDL from “B” mice injected with TDL (passaged TDL) gave strong MLR and GVH reactions to both DBA/2 and C57BL determinants. Passaged T.TDL activated to C57BL antigens gave intermediate MLR and GVH reactions to the specific (C57BL) determinants but only very low responses to third-party (DBA/2) determinants; reciprocal results were obtained with passaged T.TDL activated to DBA/2 determinants. TDL from “B” mice given no cells failed to respond to either set of determinants.Since the responses by the passaged T.TDL did not exceed those by passaged TDL there was no evidence that adoptive transfer of T.TDL had conferred to the recipients a state of memory to either MLR or GVH determinants. Adoptive transfer did, however, lead to qualitative changes in the properties of T.TDL since, before transfer, they were unable to evoke GVH reactions or produce an MLR of normal kinetics.Passaged T.TDL were far superior to passaged TDL at suppressing the growth of allogeneic tumour cells. The protection was specific since protection against DBA/2 tumour cells was, cell for cell, 5–10 fold more effective with passaged T.TDL activated to DBA/2 determinants than with cells activated to C57BL determinants. No protection was observed with cells treated with anti-θ serum. The protective cells appeared to be precursors of effector cells rather than effector cells per se since they failed to lyse the tumour cells in vitro. These data suggest therefore that the descendants of T.TDL which survived after transfer to “B” mice were highly enriched in long-lived recirculating T lymphocytes reactive to determinants expressed by specific tumour allografts.     

Increased spontaneous polyclonal activation of B lymphocytes in mice with spontaneous autoimmune disease.

Early in life, mice of four kinds [NZB, (NZB X NZW)F1, MRL/1, and male BXSB] with autoimmune disease spontaneously produced far more (greater than 3 S.D.) anti-hapten antibody-forming cells in spleens and greater concentrations of anti-hapten antibodies in sera than immunologically normal strains of mice (AKR, BALB/c, C57BL/6, DBA/1-J, DBA/2J, LG/J, 129, NZW, and female BXSB). This increased nonspecific antibody production by the abnormal animals' B cells correlated well with the spontaneous development of anti-single-stranded DNA antibodies, but not with serum levels of the viral envelope glycoprotein, gp70. These results suggest that the spontaneous formation of autoantibodies in mice whose immunologic disorder is manifested by a lupus-like disease may result from polyclonal activation of B cells by endogenous or exogenous B cell activators.     

Autoantibody to the nucleosome subunit (H2A-H2B)-DNA is an early and ubiquitous feature of lupus-like conditions

Chromatin, a huge polymer of nucleosomes, has been implicated as an important target of autoantibodies in idiopathic and drug-induced lupus for decades, but the antigenicity of chromatin has only recently been dissected. IgG reactivity with the (H2A-H2B)-DNA complex, a subunit of the nucleosome, is present in the majority of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus, in >90% of patients with lupus induced by procainamide and in individual patients with lupus induced by a variety of other drugs, but is not seen in people taking these medications who are clinically asymptomatic. Anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA] accounted for the bulk of the anti-chromatin activity in drug-induced lupus. The earliest detectable autoantibody in lupus-prone mice recognized similar epitopes in the (H2A-H2B)-DNA subnucleosome complex; as the immune response progressed, native DNA and other constituents of chromatin became antigenic. The importance of chromatin-reactive T cells in the anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA] response is suggested by the presence of somatic mutations in antibody V_H and V_L regions, their perdominant IgG isotype and the similarity in kinetics of their production to that of conventional T cell dependent antigens. Together with the serologic data from human lupus-like disease, these results are consistent with chromatin being a common stimulant for both B and T cells. While chromatin-reactive antibodies are closely associated with systemic disease and have recently been implicated in glomerulonephritis in SLE, the absence of renal disease in drug-induced lupus indicates that additional abnormalities are required to manifest the serious pathogenic potential of anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA] antibodies.Abbreviations APC antigen present cells - DIL drug-induced lupus - ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay - GBM glomerular basement membrane - [(H2A-H2B)-DNA] an intermolecular complex consisting of DNA and a dimer of histones H2A and H2B - nDNA native (double-stranded) DNA - SLE systemic lupus erythematosus     

Studies on the influence of the internal environment on autoantibody production by B cells

Purified splenic B cells from autoimmune NZB and nonautoimmune DBA/2 mice were transferred to unmanipulated H-2 compatible xid recipients. The number of autoantibody-secreting clones present in recipient mice was quantitated at varying times after transfer using a splenic fragment assay. We found that NZB and DBA/2 B cells expanded equally well in equivalent xid environments. Cells from either donor expanded significantly better in autoimmune-prone NZB.xid as compared with DBA/2.xid recipients. Moreover, clones producing antibodies reactive with T cell surface antigens, bromelain-treated mouse red cells, or DNA expanded more rapidly than did cells producing antibodies to the nonautoantigen TNP-KLH. Serum autoantibody levels rose in concert with the increased numbers of autoantibody-producing lymphocytes. We conclude that factors present in the internal milieu of autoimmune-prone NZB.xid mice, rather than an intrinsic B cell defect, facilitate the expansion of (auto)antibody-secreting B cells.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VII. Suppressive effect of irradiated MLC cells on CTL response.

Irradiated cells obtained from MLC at the peak of the CTL response caused profound suppression of generation of CTL when added in small numbers at the initiation of primary MLC prepared with normal spleen cells. The inhibitory activity of the MLC cells was not affected by irradiation (1000 rads) but was abolished by treatment with anti-theta serum and complement. The suppression was immunologically specific. The response of A (H-2a) spleen cells toward C3H (H-2k) alloantigens was suppressed by irradiated MLC cells obtained from MLC prepared with A spleen cells and irradiated C3H-stimulating cells, whereas the response of A spleen cells toward DBA/2 (H-2d) alloantigens was affected relatively little. However, if irradiated C3H X DBA/2 F1 hybrid spleen cells were used to stimulate A spleen cells in MLC, addition of irradiated MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward C3H antigens abolished the response to both C3H and DBA/2 antigens. The response to DBA/2 antigens was much less affected when a mixture of irradiated C3H and DBA/2 spleen cells was used as stimulating cells. Thus, the presence of MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward one alloantigen abolished the response to another non-cross reacting antigen only when both antigens were present on the same F1 hybrid-stimulating cells. This suppression of generation of CTL by irradiated MLC cells apparently involves inactivation of alloantigen-bearing stimulating cells as a result of residual cytotoxic activity of the irradiated MLC cells. This mechanism may be active during the decline in CTL activity noted in the normal immune response in vivo and in vitro.     

Further evidence against random polyclonal antibody formation in mice with lupus-like graft-vs-host disease

The pathologic symptoms in F1 mice with chronic graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) (GVH F1) strongly resemble those of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Mice with SLE-like GVHD do not produce antibodies to a number of non-self and self antigens. This finding is inconsistent with the widely accepted view that the (auto)-antibody formation in SLE is polyclonal in the sense that B cells are triggered at random, i.e., irrespective of their specificity. In the present study, therefore, we performed a systematic study of the kinetics of total IgM- and IgG-secreting splenic B cells and tested their specificities. The total IgM-secreting B cell population was increased only in the first week after the initiation of SLE-like GVHD; it seemed to reflect a random, but self-limited, polyclonal B cell stimulation. In contrast, the total number of IgG-secreting cells in the GVH F1 mice was increased to a much higher extent than that of the IgM-secreting cells and remained increased. At no time during GVHD was there an increase in the number of plaque-forming cells (PFC) spontaneously secreting IgG antibodies to non-self antigens. The GVH reaction (GVHR) did, however, lead to the appearance of PFC that secreted IgG antibodies to DNA. Similarly, the GVH F1 mice showed high serum titers of antibodies to self antigens characteristic of SLE and to endogenous viruses, but during the entire observation period they failed to develop serum antibodies to non-self antigens and insulin. Hence, the enhanced production of Ig, especially that of IgG, that occurs in SLE-like GVHD is not a random process, because it requires the presence of antigen, or signal 1. The data support our hypothesis that only certain kinds of self antigen, such as DNA and cell membrane epitopes, can cross-link the Ig receptors on the corresponding B cells and thus provide an adequate signal 1. Given the increase in help, or signal 2, in chronic GVHD, only the B cell clones that simultaneously receive an adequate signal 1 seem to be driven into clonal proliferation and IgG secretion.     

Defective primary and secondary IgG responses to thymic-dependent antigens in autoimmune PN mice

Palmerston North (PN) mice spontaneously develop autoimmune disease resembling SLE. Because immune responsiveness has not been defined in this strain, a study was designed to assay primary splenic plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses to thymus-dependent (TD) and thymus-independent (TI) Ag. Initial surveys of PN mice inoculated with the TD Ag SRBC showed adequate production of IgM PFC, but small numbers of IgG PFC were developed with polyspecific antiserum. In contrast, H-2-compatible DBA/1 control mice gave the expected responses to SRBC (IgG plaques elevated twofold compared with IgM plaques). PN mice had the usual responses to Ag that are largely TI; both PN and DBA/1 mice had active IgM and modest IgG responses to TNP-LPS and TNP-Ficoll. Additional experiments determined that PN mice had similar patterns of defective IgG responses to several different TD Ag (SRBC, horse RBC, and DNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin). In each instance, the usual predominance of IgG1 plaques was absent, and total numbers of plaques developed with antisera specific for IgG isotypes were suppressed. Defective PN IgG production was evident as early as 3 wk of age, was not influenced by aging to 43 wk, and was not corrected by increasing the antigenic challenge 10-fold. PN spleen cells treated with monoclonal anti-Thy-1.2 and C were injected with pools of DBA/1 T cells into 850-rad irradiated (DBA/1 x PN)F1 hybrids. These recipients expressed low IgG1 responses to SRBC, suggesting that the B cell-containing fraction that was not lysed by anti-Thy-1.2 transferred the PN defect. PN mice, which do not respond to TD Ag with active IgG production, contradict the proposal that autoimmunity is associated with hyper-responsiveness to TD and TI Ag.