In situ field measurement of leaf water potential using thermocouple psychrometers

Thermocouple psychrometers are the only instruments which can measure the in situ water potential of intact leaves, and which can possibly be used to monitor leaf water potential. Unfortunately, their usefulness is limited by a number of difficulties, among them fluctuating temperatures and temperature gradients within the psychrometer, sealing of the psychrometer chamber to the leaf, shading of the leaf by the psychrometer, and resistance to water vapor diffusion by the cuticle when the stomates are closed. Using Citrus jambhiri, we have tested several psychrometer design and operational modifications and showed that in situ psychrometric measurements compared favorably with simultaneous Scholander pressure chamber measurements on neighboring leaves when the latter were corrected for the osmotic potential.     

Errors in measuring water potentials of small samples resulting from water adsorption by thermocouple psychrometer chambers

The adsorption of water by thermocouple psychrometer assemblies is known to cause errors in the determination of water potential. Experiments were conducted to evaluate the effect of sample size and psychrometer chamber volume on measured water potentials of leaf discs, leaf segments, and sodium chloride solutions. Reasonable agreement was found between soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) leaf water potentials measured on 5-millimeter radius leaf discs and large leaf segments. Results indicated that while errors due to adsorption may be significant when using small volumes of tissue, if sufficient tissue is used the errors are negligible. Because of the relationship between water potential and volume in plant tissue, the errors due to adsorption were larger with turgid tissue. Large psychrometers which were sealed into the sample chamber with latex tubing appeared to adsorb more water than those sealed with flexible plastic tubing. Estimates are provided of the amounts of water adsorbed by two different psychrometer assemblies and the amount of tissue sufficient for accurate measurements of leaf water potential with these assemblies. It is also demonstrated that water adsorption problems may have generated low water potential values which in prior studies have been attributed to large cut surface area to volume ratios.     

A rapid leaf-disc sampler for psychrometric water potential measurements

An instrument was designed which facilitates faster and more accurate sampling of leaf discs for psychrometric water potential measurements. The instrument consists of an aluminum housing, a spring-loaded plunger, and a modified brass-plated cork borer. The leaf-disc sampler was compared with the conventional method of sampling discs for measurement of leaf water potential with thermocouple psychrometers on a range of plant material including Gossypium hirsutum L., Zea mays L., and Begonia rex-cultorum L. The new sampler permitted a leaf disc to be excised and inserted into the psychrometer sample chamber in less than 7 seconds, which was more than twice as fast as the conventional method. This resulted in more accurate determinations of leaf water potential due to reduced evaporative water losses. The leaf-disc sampler also significantly reduced sample variability between individual measurements. This instrument can be used for many other laboratory and field measurements that necessitate leaf disc sampling.     

Psychrometric Field Measurement of Water Potential Changes following Leaf Excision

In situ measurement of sudden leaf water potential changes has not been performed under field conditions. A laboratory investigation involving the measurement of leaf water potential prior to and 2 to 200 minutes after excision of citrus leaves (Citrus jambhiri) showed good linear correlation (r = 0.99) between in situ leaf psychrometer and Scholander pressure chamber measurements. Following this, a field investigation was conducted which involved psychrometric measurement prior to petiole excision and 1 minute after excision. Simultaneous pressure chamber measurements were performed on neighboring leaves prior to the time of excision and then on the psychrometer leaf about 2 minutes after excision. These data indicate that within the first 2 minutes after excision, psychrometer and pressure chamber measurements were linearly correlated (r = 0.97). Under high evaporative demand conditions, the rate of water potential decrease was between 250 and 700 kilopascals in the first minute after excision. These results show that the thermocouple psychrometer can be used as a dynamic and nondestructive field technique for monitoring leaf water potential.     

Leaf water potentials measured with a pressure chamber

Leaf water potentials were estimated from the sum of the balancing pressure measured with a pressure chamber and the osmotic potential of the xylem sap in leafy shoots or leaves. When leaf water potentials in yew, rhododendron, and sunflower were compared with those measured with a thermocouple psychrometer known to indicate accurate values of leaf water potential, determinations were within ± 2 bars of the psychrometer measurements with sunflower and yew. In rhododendron. water potentials measured with the pressure chamber plus xylem sap were 2.5 bars less negative to 4 bars more negative than psychrometer measurements.

The discrepancies in the rhododendron measurements could be attributed, at least in part, to the filling of tissues other than xylem with xylem sap during measurements with the pressure chamber. It was concluded that, although stem characteristics may affect the measurements, pressure chamber determinations were sufficiently close to psychrometer measurements that the pressure chamber may be used for relative measurements of leaf water potentials, especially in sunflower and yew. For accurate determinations of leaf water potential, however, pressure chamber measurements must be calibrated with a thermocouple psychrometer.

     

Improved Thermocouple Psychrometer for the Measurement of Plant and Soil Water Potential: I. THERMOCOUPLE PSYCHROMETRY AND AN IMPROVED INSTRUMENT DESIGN

This paper is the first of a series which describes: (a) thedesign and operation of a thermocouple psychrometer which providesimproved range of measurement, accuracy, and equilibration rateof water potential determinations of plant and soil samples,and which avoids or minimizes six sources of large error, oneor more of which occur with previous psychrometers and (b) studiesthat provide a better understanding of the thermocouple psychrometricmethod. The present paper describes the main difficulties encounteredwith the method, examines those due to absorption phenomena,and describes an improved thermocouple psychrometer which overcomesor reduces some of these difficulties. Improvements include: (i) chamber walls of stainless steel type316 and samples arranged in shielding geometries to reduce delaysin equilibration due to adsorption, (ii) sample holders of geometriesthat avoid or reduce errors of leaf resistance, adsorption andtissue damage when appropriate cooling periods and tissue segmentsof adequate size are used, (iii) shielding arrangement of respiringtissue samples to permit thermal equilibration in the regionsensed by the ‘active’ thermojunction, a new thermocoupleassembly for increased range of measurement of water potential,(v) sample holders that permit plant or soil samples to be accommodatedin the one chamber.     

Theoretical and experimental errors for in situ measurements of plant water potential

Errors in psychrometrically determined values of leaf water potential caused by tissue resistance to water vapor exchange and by lack of thermal equilibrium were evaluated using commercial in situ psychrometers (Wescor Inc., Logan, UT) on leaves of Tradescantia virginiana (L.). Theoretical errors in the dewpoint method of operation for these sensors were demonstrated. After correction for these errors, in situ measurements of leaf water potential indicated substantial errors caused by tissue resistance to water vapor exchange (4 to 6% reduction in apparent water potential per second of cooling time used) resulting from humidity depletions in the psychrometer chamber during the Peltier condensation process. These errors were avoided by use of a modified procedure for dewpoint measurement. Large changes in apparent water potential were caused by leaf and psychrometer exposure to moderate levels of irradiance. These changes were correlated with relatively small shifts in psychrometer zero offsets (−0.6 to −1.0 megapascals per microvolt), indicating substantial errors caused by nonisothermal conditions between the leaf and the psychrometer. Explicit correction for these errors is not possible with the current psychrometer design.     

Field measurement of leaf water potential with a temperature-corrected in situ thermocouple psychrometer

Abstract. The construction and evaluation of a temperature-corrected in situ thermocouple psychrometer for measurement of leaf water potential (Ψ) is described. The instrument utilized two chromel-constantan thermocouples which allowed for detection of both the psychrometric zero offset and the temperature differential between the sample and the Peltier measuring junction. The psychrometer was subjected to stable temperature gradients while in contact with reference solutions of sodium chloride, and the effects of thermal gradients were quantified. Regression analysis indicated that temperature differentials were responsible for errors in water potential determinations of approximately –7.73 MPa°C⁻¹. When installed on leaves of field-grown cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.), corn ( Zea mays L.) and soybean ( Glycine max L. Merr) the instrument detected temperature differentials up to 0.1°C (–6.0 μV) which were associated with relatively small shifts in psychrometric zero offsets (–0.05––0.75 μV). Results indicated that substantial errors in apparent Ψ were caused by non-isothermal conditions between the leaf and the psychrometer measuring junction. The relative magnitude of these errors could be quantified and the corrected results showed good agreement with conventional psychrometric determination of Ψ on excised samples during a diurnal cycle.     

Plant water potential measured continuously in the field

Summary A simple system is described which allowed the use of a stem attached psychrometer in the field. Water was circulated between a tank buried in the soil and the psychrometer and this sytem reduced temperature gradients sufficiently to enable continuous measurements of plant water potential to be made in the field. Measurements agreed with those taken independently with a destructive pressure chamber method.     

Simple techniques for microclimate measurement

This paper describes simple ways of measuring the very local climate near the ground, and explains what these measurements mean. The equipment described includes a solar radiometer and a dew point instrument, both with mercury-in-glass thermometers, and a thermocouple psychrometer. The psychrometer may be used with standard metering equipment and a suitable metering device is described. Examples are given of field measurements taken with some of the equipment described and the presentation of results and their interpretation are discussed.     

Effect of Cuticular Abrasion on Thermocouple Psychrometric In Situ Measurement of Leaf Water Potential

Cuticular resistance to water vapour diffusion between the substomatalcavity and the sensing psychrometer junction is a problem uniqueto leaf hygrometry. This resistance is not encountered in soilor solution hygrometry. The cuticular resistance may introduceerror in the measurement of leaf water potential. Using in situleaf hygrometers, we studied the effect of abrading the cuticleof Citrus jambhiri Lushington leaves, to reduce the diffusiveresistance. Field measurements of psychrometer water potentialwere compared with Scholander pressure chamber values for adjacentleaves. Different treatments were compared by sealing pairsof psychrometers on either side of the midrib. The time forwater vapour equilibration between the leaf and the psychrometerchamber was greater than 5 h for no abrasion. For abraded leaves,the true water potential value was obtained within an hour.After equilibration, psychrometer values compared favourablywith pressure chamber values for adjacent leaves (r > 0.97).Measured water potential for unabraded leaves did not correlatewell with corresponding pressure chamber measurements. Scanning electron micrographs indicated that the damage causedby abrading leaves for 60 s using carborundum powder (60 µmdiameter) was surface localized, with numerous scratchings ofthe leaf cuticle. The coarse abrasion treatment (aluminium oxide,75 µm diameter) resulted in fewer but larger cavitiesin the epidermis, which may explain the observed variabilityin the corresponding psychrometric measurements. Key words: Leaf water potential, Cuticular resistance, Leaf abrasion, Thermocouple psychrometer     

Effects of salt secretion on psychrometric determinations of water potential of cotton leaves

Thermocouple psychrometers gave lower estimates of water potential of cotton leaves than did a pressure chamber. This difference was considerable for turgid leaves, but progressively decreased for leaves with lower water potentials and fell to zero at water potentials below about −10 bars. The conductivity of washings from cotton leaves removed from the psychrometric equilibration chambers was related to the magnitude of this discrepancy in water potential, indicating that the discrepancy is due to salts on the leaf surface which make the psychrometric estimates too low. This error, which may be as great as 400 to 500%, cannot be eliminated by washing the leaves because salts may be secreted during the equilibration period. Therefore, a thermocouple psychrometer is not suitable for measuring the water potential of cotton leaves when it is above about −10 bars.     

Chloroplast response to low leaf water potentials: I. Role of turgor

The effect of decreases in turgor on chloroplast activity was studied by measuring the photochemical activity of intact sunflower (Helianthus annuus L. cv. Russian Mammoth) leaves having low water potentials. Leaf turgor, calculated from leaf water potential and osmotic potential, was found to be affected by the dilution of cell contents by water in the cell walls, when osmotic potentials were measured with a thermocouple psychrometer. After the correction of measurements of leaf osmotic potential, both the thermocouple psychrometer and a pressure chamber indicated that turgor became zero in sunflower leaves at leaf water potentials of −10 bars. Since most of the loss in photochemical activity occurred at water potentials below −10 bars, it was concluded that turgor had little effect on the photochemical activity of the leaves.     

The origin and theoretical correction of thermal gradients in thermocouple psychrometers

Temperature-compensated psychrometers are explained and a theoretical correction for temperature gradients, with its boundaries, is given. The correction was elaborated for in situ determination of water potential on soybean and tomato stems where it was indispensable. The origin of the thermal gradients in the psychrometric chamber is then discussed. Cooling of the conducting tissue by the circulation of xylem sap seemed to be the major cause for these gradients, while the heating of the psychrometer (thermally insulated) by the surroundings through radiative or conductive transfer was negligible.     

XYLEM WATER HOLDING CAPACITY AS A SOURCE OF ERROR IN WATER POTENTIAL ESTIMATES MADE WITH THE PRESSURE CHAMBER AND THERMOCOUPLE PSYCHROMETER

The pressure chamber and the thermocouple psychrometer often provide different values when used to estimate plant water potential. One hypothesis to explain the discrepancy between instruments is that water movement between the xylem and symplast occurs during pressurization in the pressure chamber. Pressure chamber and thermocouple psychrometer measurements of Pinus ponderosa (Laws.) seedling shoots and mature Quercus agrifolia (Nee) shoots showed that the discrepancy is greater for Quercus. It was hypothesized that the xylem water content-water potential relationship of these species would explain the magnitude of the discrepancy between instruments. The xylem water holding capacity alone, however, does not explain the difference between species. The larger discrepancy in Quercus is likely due to a greater volume of water held in the xylem relative to the volume held in the symplast.     

Comparison of the dye method with the thermocouple psychrometer for measuring leaf water potentials

The dye method for measuring water potential was examined and compared with the thermocouple psychrometer method in order to evaluate its usefulness for measuring leaf water potentials of forest trees and common laboratory plants. Psychrometer measurements are assumed to represent the true leaf water potentials. Because of the contamination of test solutions by cell sap and leaf surface residues, dye method values of most species varied about 1 to 5 bars from psychrometer values over the leaf water potential range of 0 to −30 bars. The dye method is useful for measuring changes and relative values in leaf potential. Because of species differences in the relationships of dye method values to true leaf water potentials, dye method values should be interpreted with caution when comparing different species or the same species growing in widely different environments. Despite its limitations the dye method has a usefulness to many workers because it is simple, requires no elaborate equipment, and can be used in both the laboratory and field.     

The Evaporative Function of Cockroach Hygroreceptors

Insect hygroreceptors associate as antagonistic pairs of a moist cell and a dry cell together with a cold cell in small cuticular sensilla on the antennae. The mechanisms by which the atmospheric humidity stimulates the hygroreceptive cells remain elusive. Three models for humidity transduction have been proposed in which hygroreceptors operate either as mechanical hygrometers, evaporation detectors or psychrometers. Mechanical hygrometers are assumed to respond to the relative humidity, evaporation detectors to the saturation deficit and psychrometers to the temperature depression (the difference between wet-bulb and dry-bulb temperatures). The models refer to different ways of expressing humidity. This also means, however, that at different temperatures these different types of hygroreceptors indicate very different humidity conditions. The present study tested the adequacy of the three models on the cockroach’s moist and dry cells by determining whether the specific predictions about the temperature-dependence of the humidity responses are indeed observed. While in previous studies stimulation consisted of rapid step-like humidity changes, here we changed humidity slowly and continuously up and down in a sinusoidal fashion. The low rates of change made it possible to measure instantaneous humidity values based on UV-absorption and to assign these values to the hygroreceptive sensillum. The moist cell fitted neither the mechanical hygrometer nor the evaporation detector model: the temperature dependence of its humidity responses could not be attributed to relative humidity or to saturation deficit, respectively. The psychrometer model, however, was verified by the close relationships of the moist cell’s response with the wet-bulb temperature and the dry cell’s response with the dry-bulb temperature. Thus, the hygroreceptors respond to evaporation and the resulting cooling due to the wetness or dryness of the air. The drier the ambient air (absolutely) and the higher the temperature, the greater the evaporative temperature depression and the power to desiccate.     

Electron Microscope Study of Cuticular Abrasion on Cotton Leaves in Relation to Water Potential Measurements

Wullschleger, S. D. and Oosterhuis, D. M. 1987. Electron microscopestudy of cuticular abrasion on cotton leaves in relation towater potential measurements.—J. exp. Bot 38: 660–667. Accurate determination of plant water potential using thermocouplepsychrometers requires vapour equilibrium between the tissuesample and the sensing psychrometer junction. Failure to achievethis equilibrium due to cuticular resistances to vapour movementmay introduce significant errors into psychrometrically measured. The effect of cuticular abrasion on W equilibration timesfor cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) was studied with three typesof thermocouple psychrometers, and the extent of surface andcuticular damage was determined with electron microscopy. Water vapour equilibration between the leaf and psychrometerchamber was achieved in approximately 4 h for unabraded controls,whereas abrasion of the leaf with carborundum powder consistentlyreduced equilibration times to below 2?5 h for all three typesof psychrometers. Microscopic observation of abraded leaf tissueindicated that substantial damage to surface structures occurredduring the cuticular abrasion process. Scanning electron micrographsrevealed localized cellular damage to anastomosing leaf veinsand physical disruption of both the stomatal complex and glandulartrichomes. Transverse sections viewed with a transmission electronmicroscope indicated substantial direct damage to the cuticlewith large sections of cell wall devoid of a cuticular layer.Although the exposed cell walls were intact, the lateral cellwalls were physically compressed and distorted during abrasion.In addition, the cytoplasmic and vacuolar membranes of the epidermalcells were also frequently ruptured. Evaluation of the damagefollowing abrasion indicated that the release of turgor by theaffected cells may contribute to increased sample variabilityand possibly to errors in measurements. Key words: Leaf water potential, cuticular resistance, thermocouple psychrometer     

Pressure probe and isopiestic psychrometer measure similar turgor

Turgor measured with a miniature pressure probe was compared to that measured with an isopiestic thermocouple psychrometer in mature regions of soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) stems. The probe measured turgor directly in cells of intact stems whereas the psychrometer measured the water potential and osmotic potential of excised stem segments and turgor was calculated by difference. When care was taken to prevent dehydration when working with the pressure probe, and diffusive resistance and dilution errors with the psychrometer, both methods gave similar values of turgor whether the plants were dehydrating or rehydrating. This finding, together with the previously demonstrated similarity in turgor measured with the isopiestic psychrometer and a pressure chamber, indicates that the pressure probe provides accurate measurements of turgor despite the need to penetrate the cell. On the other hand, it suggests that as long as precautions are taken to obtain accurate values for the water potential and osmotic potential, turgor can be determined by isopiestic psychrometry in tissues not accessible to the pressure probe for physical reasons.     

A technique to measure the components of root water potential using screen-caged thermocouple psychrometers

This paper describes a simple method which uses screen-caged thermocouple psychrometers to measure the water potential components of the roots of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) grown in pots of sand or nutrient solution. Water stress was imposed by withholding irrigation from the sand-grown plants. Sampling was conducted inside a humidified chamber to prevent evaporative losses. The results obtained were within the range expected and comparable to the few published values for other plants. The technique enabled the demonstration of osmotic adjustment in cotton leaves and roots. Published with the approval of the Director of the Arkansas Agricultural Experiment Station.