E2F factors rate controls the dual role of CDE/E2F composite element: a model of E2F-regulated gene expression in plant development

The promoters of several E2F-regulated genes identified in plants contain a variety of E2F motifs, notably a composite element consisting of a "CDE-like element" C/GGCGG on one strand, described as repressor in animals, associated with an E2F element on the complementary strand. This detailed study throughout plant development using ribonucleotide reductase promoters, allows us to propose a model, where E2F and composite elements play a dual role. Such regulation is mainly conditioned by the availability of E2F factors in tissues and during the cell cycle in tobacco.     

A mutant allele of BARA/LIN-9 rescues the cdk4-/- phenotype by releasing the repression on E2F-regulated genes

It has been proposed that C. elegans LIN-9 functions downstream of CDK4 in a pathway that regulates cell proliferation. Here, we report that mammalian BARA/LIN-9 is a predominantly nuclear protein that inhibits cell proliferation. More importantly, we demonstrate that BARA/LIN-9 also acts downstream of cyclin D/CDK4 in mammalian cells since (i) its antiproliferative effect is partially blocked by coexpression of cyclin D1, and (ii) a mutant form that lacks the first 84 amino acids rescues several phenotypic alterations observed in mice null for cdk4. Interestingly, mutation of BARA/LIN-9 restores the expression of E2F target genes in CDK4 null MEFs, indicating that the wild-type protein plays a role in the expression of genes required for the G1/S transition.     

E2F7 and E2F8 keep the E2F family in balance

An article by Li and colleagues (in this issue of Developmental Cell) shows that the atypical E2Fs, E2F7 and E2F8, are critical for mouse development. One of the important functions of these family members stems from a negative feedback loop in which E2F7 and E2F8 limit the expression of E2F1 and prevent E2F1-dependent apoptosis.     

DNA-damage response control of E2F7 and E2F8

Here, we report that the two recently identified E2F subunits, E2F7 and E2F8, are induced in cells treated with DNA-damaging agents where they have an important role in dictating the outcome of the DNA-damage response. The DNA-damage-dependent induction coincides with the binding of E2F7 and E2F8 to the promoters of certain E2F-responsive genes, most notably that of the E2F1 gene, in which E2F7 and E2F8 coexist in a DNA-binding complex. As a consequence, E2F7 and E2F8 repress E2F target genes, such as E2F1, and reducing the level of each subunit results in an increase in E2F1 expression and activity. Importantly, depletion of either E2F7 or E2F8 prevents the cell-cycle effects that occur in response to DNA damage. Thus, E2F7 and E2F8 act upstream of E2F1, and influence the ability of cells to undergo a DNA-damage response. E2F7 and E2F8, therefore, underpin the DNA-damage response.     

Binding of the retinoblastoma protein is not the determinant for stable repression of some E2F-regulated promoters in muscle cells

Permanent silencing of E2F-dependent genes is a hallmark of the irreversible cell cycle exit that characterizes terminally differentiated and senescent cells. The determinant of this silencing during senescence has been proposed to be the binding of the retinoblastoma protein Rb and the consequent methylation of H3K9. During ex vivo skeletal muscle differentiation, while most cells terminally differentiate and form myotubes, a subset of myoblasts remains quiescent and can be reinduced by growth factor stimulation to enter the cell cycle. Thus, differentiating cells are composed of two different populations: one in which E2F-dependent genes are permanently repressed and the other not. We observed that, in a manner reminiscent to senescent cells, permanent silencing of the E2F-dependent cdc6, dhfr, and p107 promoters in myotubes was associated with a specific increase in H3K9 trimethylation. To investigate the role of Rb in this process, we developed a reliable method to detect Rb recruitment by chromatin immunoprecipitation. Surprisingly, we observed that Rb was recruited to these promoters more efficiently in quiescent cells than in myotubes. Thus, our data indicate that during muscle differentiation, permanent silencing and H3K9 trimethylation of some E2F-dependent genes are not directly specified by Rb binding, in contrast to what is proposed for senescence.