Biophysical investigations of the structure and function of the tear fluid lipid layers and the effect of ectoine. Part B: Artificial lipid films

The tear fluid lipid layer is present at the outermost part of the tear film which lines the ocular surface and functions to maintain the corneal surface moist by retarding evaporation. Instability in the structure of the tear fluid lipid layer can cause an increased rate of evaporation and thus dry eye syndrome. Ectoine has been previously shown to fluidize lipid monolayers and alter the phase behavior. In the current study we have investigated the effect of ectoine on the artificial tear fluid lipid layer composed of binary and ternary lipid mixtures of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC), cholesteryl esters and tri-acyl-glycerols. The focus of our study was mainly the structural and the biophysical aspects of the artificial tear fluid lipid layer using surface activity studies and topology analysis. The presence of ectoine consistently causes an expansion of the pressure–area isotherm indicating increased intermolecular spacing. The topology studies showed the formation of droplet-like structures due to the addition of ectoine only when tri-acyl-glycerol is present in the mixture of DPPC and chol-palmitate, similar to the natural meibomian lipids. Consequently, the hypothesis of an exclusion of tri/di-acyl-glycerol from the meibomian lipid film in the presence of ectoine in the subphase is confirmed. A model describing the effect of ectoine on meibomian lipid films is further presented which may have an application for the use of ectoines in eye drops as a treatment for the dry eye syndrome.     

Biophysical properties of tear film lipid layer I. Surface tension and surface rheology

Tear film lipid layer (TFLL) is the outmost layer of the tear film. It plays a crucial role in stabilizing the tear film by reducing surface tension and retarding evaporation of the aqueous layer. Dysfunction of the TFLL leads to dysfunctional tear syndrome, with dry eye disease (DED) being the most prevalent eye disease, affecting 10%–30% of the world population. To date, except for treatments alleviating dry eye symptoms, effective therapeutic interventions in treating DED are still lacking. Therefore, there is an urgent need to understand the biophysical properties of the TFLL with the long-term goal to develop translational solutions in effectively managing DED. Here, we studied the composition-function correlations of an artificial TFLL, under physiologically relevant conditions, using a novel experimental methodology called constrained drop surfactometry. This artificial TFLL was composed of 40% behenyl oleate and 40% cholesteryl oleate, representing the most abundant wax ester and cholesteryl ester in the natural TFLL, respectively, and 15% phosphatidylcholine and 5% palmitic-acid-9-hydroxy-stearic-acid (PAHSA), which represent the two predominant polar lipid classes in the natural TFLL. Our study suggests that the major biophysical function of phospholipids in the TFLL is to reduce the surface tension, whereas the primary function of PAHSA is to optimize the rheological properties of the TFLL. These findings have novel implications in better understanding the physiological and biophysical functions of the TFLL and may offer new translational insight to the treatment of DED.     

Coupling Fluid and Solute Dynamics Within the Ocular Surface Tear Film: A Modelling Study of Black Line Osmolarity

We present a mathematical model describing the spatial distribution of tear film osmolarity across the ocular surface of a human eye during one blink cycle, incorporating detailed fluid and solute dynamics. Based on the lubrication approximation, our model comprises three coupled equations tracking the depth of the aqueous layer of the tear film, the concentration of the polar lipid, and the concentration of physiological salts contained in the aqueous layer. Diffusive boundary layers in the salt concentration occur at the thinnest regions of the tear film, the black lines. Thus, despite large Peclet numbers, diffusion ameliorates osmolarity around the black lines, but nonetheless is insufficient to eliminate the build-up of solute in these regions. More generally, a heterogeneous distribution of solute concentration is predicted across the ocular surface, indicating that measurements of lower meniscus osmolarity are not globally representative, especially in the presence of dry eye.Vertical saccadic eyelid motion can reduce osmolarity at the lower black line, raising the prospect that select eyeball motions more generally can assist in alleviating tear film hyperosmolarity. Finally, our results indicate that measured evaporative rates will induce excessive hyperosmolarity at the black lines, even for the healthy eye. This suggests that further evaporative retardation at the black lines, for instance due to the cellular glycocalyx at the ocular surface or increasing concentrations of mucus, will be important for controlling hyperosmolarity as the black line thins.     

The Effect of Polar Lipids on Tear Film Dynamics

In this paper, we present a mathematical model describing the effect of polar lipids, excreted by glands in the eyelid and present on the surface of the tear film, on the evolution of a pre-corneal tear film. We aim to explain the interesting experimentally observed phenomenon that the tear film continues to move upward even after the upper eyelid has become stationary. The polar lipid is an insoluble surface species that locally alters the surface tension of the tear film. In the lubrication limit, the model reduces to two coupled non-linear partial differential equations for the film thickness and the concentration of lipid. We solve the system numerically and observe that increasing the concentration of the lipid increases the flow of liquid up the eye. We further exploit the size of the parameters in the problem to explain the initial evolution of the system.     

Longitudinal changes in tear fluid lipidome brought about by eyelid-warming treatment in a cohort of meibomian gland dysfunction

Meibomian gland dysfunction (MGD) is a leading cause of evaporative dry eye and ocular discomfort characterized by an unstable tear film principally attributed to afflicted delivery of lipids to the ocular surface. Herein, we elucidated longitudinal tear lipid alterations associated with disease alleviation and symptom improvement in a cohort of MGD patients undergoing eyelid-warming treatment for 12 weeks. Remarkably, eyelid-warming resulted in stark reductions in lysophospholipids (P < 0.001 for lyso-plasmalogen phosphatidylethanolamine, lysophosphatidylcholine, and lysophosphatidylinositol), as well as numerous PUFA-containing diacylglyceride species in tears, accompanied by significant increases in several PUFA-containing phospholipids. These changes in tear lipidomes suggest that eyelid-warming leads to diminished activity of tear phospholipases that preferentially target PUFA-containing phospholipids. In addition, treatment led to appreciable increases (P < 0.001) in O-acyl-ω-hydroxy-FAs (OAHFAs), which are lipid amphiphiles critical to the maintenance of tear film stability. Longitudinal changes in the tear lipids aforementioned also significantly (P < 0.05) correlated with reduced rate of ocular evaporation and improvement in ocular symptoms. The foregoing data thus indicate that excess ocular surface phospholipase activity detrimental to tear film stability could be alleviated by eyelid warming alone without application of steroids and identify tear OAHFAs as suitable markers to monitor treatment response in MGD.     

Molecular organization of the tear fluid lipid layer

The tear fluid protects the corneal epithelium from drying out as well as from invasion by pathogens. It also provides cell nutrients. Similarly to lung surfactant, it is composed of an aqueous phase covered by a lipid layer. Here we describe the molecular organization of the anterior lipid layer of the tear film. Artificial tear fluid lipid layers (ATFLLs) composed of egg yolk phosphatidylcholine (60 mol %), free fatty acids (20 mol %), cholesteryl oleate (10 mol %), and triglycerides (10 mol %) were deposited on the air-water interface and their physico-chemical behavior was compared to egg-yolk phosphatidylcholine monolayers by using Langmuir-film balance techniques, x-ray diffraction, and imaging techniques as well as in silico molecular level simulations. At low surface pressures, ATFLLs were organized at the air-water interface as heterogeneous monomolecular films. Upon compression the ATFLLs collapsed toward the air phase and formed hemispherelike lipid aggregates. This transition was reversible upon relaxation. These results were confirmed by molecular-level simulations of ATFLL, which further provided molecular-scale insight into the molecular distributions inside and dynamics of the tear film. Similar type of behavior is observed in lung surfactant but the folding takes place toward the aqueous phase. The results provide novel information of the function of lipids in the tear fluid.     

A biophysical study of tear film lipid layer model membranes

The tear film lipid layer (TFLL), the final layer of the human tear film is responsible for surface tension reduction while blinking, water evaporation retardation and maintaining the stability of the tear film. The study of the composition-structure-function relationship of TFLL is paramount, as a compromised structure of TFLL leads to the emergence of dry eye disease (DED) which is one the most prevalent ophthalmic surface diseases of the modern world, associated with chronic pain and reduced visual capability. In this model membrane study, a systematic approach is used to study the biophysical properties of TFLL model membranes as a function of composition. Three mixed-lipid model membranes are studied along with their individual components comprising cholesteryl oleate (CO), glyceryl trioleate (GT), L-α-phosphatidylcholine (egg PC) and a free fatty acid mixture. The models become progressively more complex from binary to quaternary mixtures, allowing the role of each individual lipid to be derived. Langmuir balance, Brewster Angle Microscopy (BAM) and Profile Analysis Tensiometer (PAT) are used to study the surface activity and compression-expansion cycles, morphology, and rheological behaviour of the model membranes, respectively. Evidence of multilayering is observed with inclusion of CO and a reversible collapse is associated with the GT phase transition. An initially more coherent film is observed due to the addition of polar PC. Notably, these individual behaviours are retained in the mixed films and suggest a possible role for each physiological component of TFLL.     

Phospholipid transfer protein is present in human tear fluid

The human tear fluid film consists of a superficial lipid layer, an aqueous middle layer, and a hydrated mucin layer located next to the corneal epithelium. The superficial lipid layer protects the eye from drying and is composed of polar and neutral lipids provided by the meibomian glands. Excess accumulation of lipids in the tear film may lead to drying of the corneal epithelium. In the circulation, phospholipid transfer protein (PLTP) and cholesteryl ester transfer protein (CETP) mediate lipid transfers. To gain insight into the formation of tear film, we investigated whether PLTP and CETP are present in human tear fluid. Tear fluid samples were collected with microcapillaries. The presence of PLTP and CETP was studied in tear fluid by Western blotting, and the PLTP concentration was determined by ELISA. The activities of the enzymes were determined by specific lipid transfer assays. Size-exclusion and heparin-affinity chromatography assessed the molecular form of PLTP. PLTP is present in tear fluid, whereas CETP is not. Quantitative assessment of PLTP by ELISA indicated that the PLTP concentration in tear fluid, 10.9 +/- 2.4 microg/mL, is about 2-fold higher than that in human plasma. PLTP-facilitated phospholipid transfer activity in tears, 15.1 +/- 1.8 micromol mL(-)(1) h(-)(1), was also significantly higher than that measured in plasma. Inactivation of PLTP by heat treatment (+58 degrees C, 60 min) or immunoinhibition abolished the phospholipid transfer activity in tear fluid. Size-exclusion chromatography of tear fluid indicated that PLTP eluted in a position corresponding to a size of 160-170 kDa. Tear fluid PLTP was quantitatively bound to Heparin-Sepharose and could be eluted as a single peak by 0.5 M NaCl. These data indicate that human tear fluid contains catalytically active PLTP protein, which resembles the active form of PLTP present in plasma. The results suggest that PLTP may play a role in the formation of the tear film by supporting phospholipid transfer.     

Extensive characterization of human tear fluid collected using different techniques unravels the presence of novel lipid amphiphiles

The tear film covers the anterior eye and the precise balance of its various constituting components is critical for maintaining ocular health. The composition of the tear film amphiphilic lipid sublayer, in particular, has largely remained a matter of contention due to the limiting concentrations of these lipid amphiphiles in tears that render their detection and accurate quantitation tedious. Using systematic and sensitive lipidomic approaches, we validated different tear collection techniques and report the most comprehensive human tear lipidome to date; comprising more than 600 lipid species from 17 major lipid classes. Our study confers novel insights to the compositional details of the existent tear film model, in particular the disputable amphiphilic lipid sublayer constituents, by demonstrating the presence of cholesteryl sulfate, O-acyl-ω-hydroxyfatty acids, and various sphingolipids and phospholipids in tears. The discovery and quantitation of the relative abundance of various tear lipid amphiphiles reported herein are expected to have a profound impact on the current understanding of the existent human tear film model.     

The value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation

The authors published their article on the value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation in 1989. The purpose of this update is to expand the original article in light of refinements and experiences in subsequent years. It was concluded in the 1989 article that the abnormal tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests were not good predictors of possible postblepharoplasty dry eye complications. It was concluded in the review that the anatomy and the history including scleral show, lagophtholmus, negative vector, snap test, previous surgery, increased blinking, dryness, grittiness and pain were more important predictors of postoperative dry eye problems than the ocular tests. The authors' opinion remains so, and they do less preoperative tear film testing and place more emphasis on the history and the anatomy as predictors of potential problems. In this follow-up to the 1989 article, the authors include a survey from several surgeons as to how they evaluate their patients for elective aesthetic blepharoplasty, which in large measure confirms the authors' practice.     

The Effect of Tear Supplementation on Ocular Surface Sensations during the Interblink Interval in Patients with Dry Eye

Purpose

To investigate the characteristics of ocular surface sensations and corneal sensitivity during the interblink interval before and after tear supplementation in dry eye patients.

Methods

Twenty subjects (41.88±14.37 years) with dry eye symptoms were included in the dry eye group. Fourteen subjects (39.13±11.27 years) without any clinical signs and/or symptoms of dry eye were included in the control group. Tear film dynamics was assessed by non-invasive tear film breakup time (NI-BUT) in parallel with continuous recordings of ocular sensations during forced blinking. Corneal sensitivity to selective stimulation of corneal mechano-, cold and chemical receptors was assessed using a gas esthesiometer. All the measurements were made before and 5 min after saline and hydroxypropyl-guar (HP-guar) drops.

Results

In dry eye patients the intensity of irritation increased rapidly after the last blink during forced blinking, while in controls there was no alteration in the intensity during the first 10 sec followed by an exponential increase. Irritation scores were significantly higher in dry eye patients throughout the entire interblink interval compared to controls (p<0.004). NI-BUT significantly increased after HP-guar (p = 0.003) but not after saline drops (p = 0.14). In both groups, either after saline or HP-guar the shape of symptom intensity curves remained the same with significantly lower irritation scores (p<0.004), however after HP-guar the decrease was significantly more pronounced (p<0.004). Corneal sensitivity to selective mechanical, cold and chemical stimulation decreased significantly in both groups after HP-guar (p<0.05), but not after saline drops (p>0.05).

Conclusion

Ocular surface irritation responses due to tear film drying are considerably increased in dry eye patients compared to normal subjects. Although tear supplementation improves the protective tear film layer, and thus reduce unpleasant sensory responses, the rapid rise in discomfort is still maintained and might be responsible for the remaining complaints of dry eye patients despite the treatment.     

Lacrimal Hypofunction as a New Mechanism of Dry Eye in Visual Display Terminal Users

Background

Dry eye has shown a marked increase due to visual display terminal (VDT) use. It remains unclear whether reduced blinking while focusing can have a direct deleterious impact on the lacrimal gland function. To address this issue that potentially affects the life quality, we conducted a large-scale epidemiological study of VDT users and an animal study.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Cross sectional survey carried out in Japan. A total of 1025 office workers who use VDT were enrolled. The association between VDT work duration and changes in tear film status, precorneal tear stability, lipid layer status and tear secretion were analyzed. For the animal model study, the rat VDT user model, placing rats onto a balance swing in combination with exposure to an evaporative environment was used to analyze lacrimal gland function. There was no positive relationship between VDT working duration and change in tear film stability and lipid layer status. The odds ratio for decrease in Schirmer score, index of tear secretion, were significantly increased with VDT working year (P = 0.012) and time (P = 0.005). The rat VDT user model, showed chronic reduction of tear secretion and was accompanied by an impairment of the lacrimal gland function and morphology. This dysfunction was recovered when rats were moved to resting conditions without the swing.

Conclusions/Significance

These data suggest that lacrimal gland hypofunction is associated with VDT use and may be a critical mechanism for VDT-associated dry eye. We believe this to be the first mechanistic link to the pathogenesis of dry eye in office workers.     

The value of tear film breakup and Schirmer's tests in preoperative blepharoplasty evaluation

The results of tear film breakup (BUT) and Schirmer's I and II tests were retrospectively analyzed on 146 patients undergoing elective blepharoplasty over a 41-month period. These tests were evaluated in conjunction with ocular history, orbital and periorbital anatomy, and Bell's phenomenon in order to determine their value, if any, in identifying patients at risk of developing a post-blepharoplasty dry eye complication. One-hundred and six patients (73 percent) had test results that were within normal limits, and two of these patients (1.9 percent) complained postoperatively of a transient gritty or burning sensation. Forty patients (27 percent) had abnormal results to one, two, or all three tests, and two of these patients (5 percent) also complained postoperatively of a transient gritty or burning sensation. These four symptomatic patients all had preoperative dry eye histories and abnormal orbital and periorbital anatomy. When analyzed alone, an abnormal tear film breakup (BUT) or Schirmer's test was not a good predictor of possible postblepharoplasty dry eye complications. An abnormal preoperative ocular history or abnormal orbital and periorbital anatomy proved to be the best predictor for the possible development of a postblepharoplasty dry eye complication.     

Lipidomic analysis of human tear fluid reveals structure-specific lipid alterations in dry eye syndrome

As current diagnostic markers for dry eye syndrome (DES) are lacking in both sensitivity and specificity, a pressing concern exists to develop activity markers that closely align with the principal axes of disease progression. In this study, a comprehensive lipidomic platform designated for analysis of the human tear lipidome was employed to characterize changes in tear lipid compositions from a cohort of 93 subjects of different clinical subgroups classified based on the presence of dry eye symptoms and signs. Positive correlations were observed between the tear levels of cholesteryl sulfates and glycosphingolipids with physiological secretion of tears, which indicated the possible lacrimal (instead of meibomian) origin of these lipids. Notably, we found wax esters of low molecular masses and those containing saturated fatty acyl moieties were specifically reduced with disease and significantly correlated with various DES clinical parameters such as ocular surface disease index, tear breakup time, and Schirmer''s I test (i.e., both symptoms and signs). These structure-specific changes in tear components with DES could potentially serve as unifying indicators of disease symptoms and signs. In addition, the structurally-specific aberrations in tear lipids reported here were found in patients with or without aqueous deficiency, suggesting a common pathology for both DES subtypes.     

The Effect of the Lipid Layer on Tear Film Behaviour

This paper investigates the effect of surfactants during tear film deposition and subsequent thinning. The surfactants occur naturally on the surface of the tear film in the form of a lipid layer. A lubrication model is developed that describes lipid spreading and film height evolution. It is shown that lipids may play an important role in drawing the tear film up the cornea during the opening phase of the blink. Further, nonuniform distributions of lipids may lead to a rapid thinning of the tear film behind the advancing lipid front (shock). Experiments using a fluorescein dye technique and using a tearscope were undertaken in order to visualise the motion of the lipid layer and any associated shocks immediately after a blink. It is found that the lipid layer continues to spread upwards on the cornea after the opening phase of the blink, in agreement with the model. Using the experimental data, lipid particles were tracked in order to determine the surface velocity and these results are compared to the model predictions.     

Biophysical investigations of the structure and function of the tear fluid lipid layer and the effect of ectoine. Part A: Natural meibomian lipid films

The tear fluid lipid layer is the outermost part of the tear film on the ocular surface which protects the eye from inflammations and injuries. We investigated the influence of ectoine on the structural organization of natural meibomian lipid films using surface activity analysis and topographical studies. These films exhibit a continuous pressure–area isotherm without any phase transition. With the addition of ectoine, the isotherm is expanded towards higher area per molecule values suggesting an increased area occupied by the interfacial lipid molecules. The AFM topology scans of natural meibomian lipid films reveal a presence of fiber-like structures. The addition of ectoine causes an appearance of droplet-like structures which are hypothesized to be tri-acyl-glycerols and other hydrophobic components excluded from the lipid film. Further the material properties of the droplet-like structure with respect to the surrounding were determined by using the quantitative imaging mode of the AFM technique. The droplet-like structures were found to be comparatively softer than the surrounding. Based on the observations a preliminary hypothesis is proposed explaining the mechanism of action of ectoine leading to the fluidization of meibomian lipid films. This suggests the possibility of ectoine as a treatment for the dry eye syndrome.     

Nonlinear theory of tear film rupture

Nonlinear thin film rupture has been analyzed by investigating the stability of tear films to finite amplitude disturbances. The dynamics of the liquid film is formulated using the Navier-Stokes equations, including a body force term due to van der Waals attractions. The governing equation was solved by the finite difference method as part of an initial value problem for spatial periodic boundary conditions. The rupture of the tear film covering the cornea and the formation of dry spots is an important phenomenon in various pathological states associated with a dry eye.     

Spectroscopic evaluation of human tear lipids

Infrared and fluorescence spectroscopies were applied to characterize the molecular conformational/structure and dynamics of human meibum (ML) and tear lipids (SSL). ML lipids contained more CC and CH3 moieties than SSL. SSL contained OH groups that were not apparent in the spectra of ML. The CO stretching band observed in the infrared spectra of SSL and ML revealed that the CO groups are not involved in hydrogen bonds. Bands due to the polar moieties CO and PO2- did not change significantly with increasing temperature, suggesting that they may not play an appreciable thermodynamic role in the lipid hydrocarbon chain phase transition. Components in tears bind to SSL and exclude water at the water-lipid boundary where the polar headgroups of phospholipids are located. If similar interactions occur in vivo at the tear film lipid-aqueous interface, they would reduce the rate of evaporation. The results provide a foundation for future studies to assess possible differences with age and sex in tears from normal and dry eye subjects.     

Tear cytokine and ocular surface alterations following brief passive cigarette smoke exposure

Purpose: To prospectively investigate the effects of acute passive cigarette smoke exposure on the ocular surface and tear film in healthy non-smokers. Methods: Twelve right eyes of 12 subjects without any ocular diseases were examined before, 5 min, and 24 h after 5 min of passive cigarette smoke exposure in a controlled smoke chamber. Tear samples were obtained before, 5 min and 24 h after smoke exposure to detect tear hexanoyl-lysine (HEL), acrolein and inflammatory cytokine concentrations. Tear evaporation rate, DR-1 tear film lipid layer interferometry, tear film break-up time (TBUT), ocular surface fluorescein staining (FS) and Rose Bengal staining (RB), Schirmer I test were performed before, 5 min, and 24 h after smoke exposure. Conjunctival impression cytology (IC) and brush cytology (BC) were carried out before and 24 h after smoke exposure. Results: Tear evaporation rate, tear lipid spread time, tear film break-up time, and vital staining scores showed significant worsening with passive smoke exposure. Tear HEL and IL-6 concentrations increased significantly 24 h after smoke exposure. Tear acrolein level showed an insignificant increase at 5 min. IC and RT-PCR revealed a significant reduction in goblet cell density, a shift toward higher squamous metaplasia grades and a significant downregulation of MUC5AC mRNA expression at 24 h. Conclusion: Even brief passive exposure to cigarette smoke in healthy non-smoker subjects was associated with adverse effects on the ocular surface health as evidenced by an increase of tear inflammatory cytokines, tear lipid peroxidation products and decrease of mucosal defense resulting in tear instability and damage to the ocular surface epithelia.     

Improved antigen retrieval in freeze-fracture cytochemistry by evaporation of carbon as first replication layer

The recently developed freeze-fracture replica immunolabeling technique uses sodium dodecyl sulfate to clean replicas obtained from chemically unfixed, rapidly frozen cells by evaporation of platinum as first and carbon as second replication layer. The detergent dissolves remains of cellular material with the exception of components which are in direct contact to the replica film. Membrane lipids and membrane protein complexes of the protoplasmic and the exoplasmic membrane halves remain attached to the replica film and are accessible for cytochemical localization. We immunolabeled the membrane proteins caveolin-1 and connexin 43 in mouse cell lines as well as the membrane attached protein tetrachloroethene reductive dehalogenase (PceA) in bacterial cells at freeze-fracture replicas generated by different evaporation parameters. The labeling experiments for caveolin-1 and the PceA showed that freeze-fracture replication of cellular membranes accomplished with thin platinum layers as well as replication with carbon as first evaporation layer lead in these cases to an improved antigen retrieval, whereas the labeling efficiency of connexin 43 was not affected by different evaporation conditions.