Shifting meiotic to mitotic spindle assembly in oocytes disrupts chromosome alignment

Mitotic spindles assemble from two centrosomes, which are major microtubule‐organizing centers (MTOCs) that contain centrioles. Meiotic spindles in oocytes, however, lack centrioles. In mouse oocytes, spindle microtubules are nucleated from multiple acentriolar MTOCs that are sorted and clustered prior to completion of spindle assembly in an “inside‐out” mechanism, ending with establishment of the poles. We used HSET (kinesin‐14) as a tool to shift meiotic spindle assembly toward a mitotic “outside‐in” mode and analyzed the consequences on the fidelity of the division. We show that HSET levels must be tightly gated in meiosis I and that even slight overexpression of HSET forces spindle morphogenesis to become more mitotic‐like: rapid spindle bipolarization and pole assembly coupled with focused poles. The unusual length of meiosis I is not sufficient to correct these early spindle morphogenesis defects, resulting in severe chromosome alignment abnormalities. Thus, the unique “inside‐out” mechanism of meiotic spindle assembly is essential to prevent chromosomal misalignment and production of aneuploidy gametes.     

Perturbation of Spc25 expression affects meiotic spindle organization,chromosome alignment and spindle assembly checkpoint in mouse oocytes.

Spc25 is a component of the Ndc80 complex which consists of Ndc80, Nuf2, Spc24, and Spc25. Previous work has shown that Spc25 is involved in regulation of kinetochore microtubule attachment and the spindle assembly checkpoint in mitosis. The roles of Spc25 in meiosis remain unknown. Here, we report its expression, localization and functions in mouse oocyte meiosis. The Spc25 mRNA level gradually increased from the GV to MI stage, but decreased by MII during mouse oocyte meiotic maturation. Immunofluorescent staining showed that Spc25 was restricted to the germinal vesicle, and associated with chromosomes during all stages after GVBD. Overexpression of Spc25 by mRNA injection resulted in oocyte meiotic arrest, chromosome misalignment and spindle disruption. Conversely, Spc25 RNAi by siRNA injection resulted in precocious polar body extrusion and caused severe chromosome misalignment and aberrant spindle formation. Our data suggest that Spc25 is required for chromosome alignment, spindle formation, and proper spindle checkpoint signaling during meiosis.     

The spindle assembly checkpoint promotes chromosome bi-orientation: A novel Mad1 role in chromosome alignment

Faithful chromosome segregation relies on dynamic interactions between spindle microtubules and chromosomes. Especially, all chromosomes must be aligned at the equator of the spindle to establish bi-orientation before they start to segregate. The spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) monitors this process, inhibiting chromosome segregation until all chromosomes achieve bi-orientation. The original concept of ‘checkpoints’ was proposed as an external surveillance system that does not play an active role in the process it monitors. However, accumulating evidence from recent studies suggests that SAC components do play an active role in chromosome bi-orientation. In this review, we highlight a novel Mad1 role in chromosome alignment, which is the first conserved mechanism that links the SAC and kinesin-mediated chromosome gliding.     

APC and EB1 function together in mitosis to regulate spindle dynamics and chromosome alignment

Recently, we have shown that a cancer causing truncation in adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) (APC(1-1450)) dominantly interferes with mitotic spindle function, suggesting APC regulates microtubule dynamics during mitosis. Here, we examine the possibility that APC mutants interfere with the function of EB1, a plus-end microtubule-binding protein that interacts with APC and is required for normal microtubule dynamics. We show that siRNA-mediated inhibition of APC, EB1, or APC and EB1 together give rise to similar defects in mitotic spindles and chromosome alignment without arresting cells in mitosis; in contrast inhibition of CLIP170 or LIS1 cause distinct spindle defects and mitotic arrest. We show that APC(1-1450) acts as a dominant negative by forming a hetero-oligomer with the full-length APC and preventing it from interacting with EB1, which is consistent with a functional relationship between APC and EB1. Live-imaging of mitotic cells expressing EB1-GFP demonstrates that APC(1-1450) compromises the dynamics of EB1-comets, increasing the frequency of EB1-GFP pausing. Together these data provide novel insight into how APC may regulate mitotic spindle function and how errors in chromosome segregation are tolerated in tumor cells.     

Nondisjunction, disturbances in spindle structure, and characteristics of chromosome alignment in maturing oocytes of mice heterozygous for Robertsonian translocations

To correlate the chromosomal constitution of meiotic cells with possible disturbances in spindle function and the etiology of nondisjunction, we examined the spindle apparatus and chromosome behavior in maturing oocytes and analyzed the chromosomal constitution of metaphase II-arrested oocytes of CD/Cremona mice, which are heterozygous for a large number of Robertsonian translocation chromosomes (18 heterobrachial metacentrics in addition to two acrocentric chromosomes 19 and two X chromosomes). Spreading of oocytes during prometaphase 1 revealed that nearly all oocytes of the heterozygotes contained one large ring multivalent, apart from the bivalents of the two acrocentric chromosomes 19 and the X chromosomes, indicating that proper pairing and crossing-over between the homologous chromosome arms of all heterobrachial chromosomes took place during prophase. A large proportion of in vitro-matured oocytes arrested in metaphase II exhibited numerical chromosome aberrations (26.5% hyperploids, 40.8% hypoploids, and 6.1% diploids). In addition, some of the oocytes with euploid chromosome numbers (26.5% of the total examined) appeared to be nullisomic for one chromosome and disomic for another chromosome, so that aneuploidy levels may even be higher than expected on the basis of chromosome counts alone. Although oocytes of the complex heterozygous mice seemed able initially to form a bipolar spindle during first prometaphase, metaphase I spindles were frequently asymmetrical. Chromosomes in the multivalent did not align properly at the equator, centromeres of neighboring chromosomes in the multivalent remained maloriented, and pronounced lagging of chromosomes was observed at telophase I in oocytes obtained from the Robertsonian translocation heterozygotes. Therefore, disturbance in spindle structure and chromosome behavior appear to correlate with the chromosomal constitution in these oocytes and, ultimately, with failures in proper chromosome separation. In particular, reorientation appears to be a rare event, and malorientation of chromosomes may remain uncorrected throughout prometaphase, as we could not find many typical metaphase I stages in heterozygotes. This, in turn, could be the basis for malsegregation at anaphase and may ultimately induce a high rate of nondisjunction and aneuploidy in the oocytes of CD/Cremona mice, leading to total sterility in heterozygous females.     

Heat shock reduces developmental competence and alters spindle configuration of bovine oocytes

Heat shock may enhance the thermotolerance of, or cause detrimental effects on, a variety of cell types or organisms, depending on the duration and intensity of the thermal challenge. Experiments were designed to investigate the effect of heat shock on the developmental competence and cytoskeletal structures of bovine oocytes following IVF. In Experiment 1, bovine cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were subjected to standard IVM culture conditions for 20 h and were then randomly allocated to groups for heat shock at 42 degrees C for 0 (control), 1, 2, or 4h. The oocytes were fertilized after heat shock and followed by culture in KSOM for 8d. There were no significant differences in cleavage rates, but blastocyst formation (27% versus 44%) and total cell number per blastocyst (82+/-21 versus 108+/-36; mean+/-S.D.) were lower in the 4-h heat shock group compared to the control (P<0.05). Trophectoderm, but not ICM, cell numbers were decreased (P<0.05) in the 4-h heat shock group compared to the control. Alterations in the meiotic spindle of IVM oocytes (n=120-126) were examined after 1 to 4-h of heat shock in Experiments 2 and 3. The metaphase spindle became elongated or aberrant and smaller following heat shock, compared to the non-heat shock oocytes (P<0.05). The basis for changes in spindle configuration and the differential decrease in trophectoderm cell numbers after heat shock are not clear, but may lead to reduced embryonic development and perhaps the low pregnancy rate of domestic animals during hot seasons.     

Ran is required before metaphase for spindle assembly and chromosome alignment and after metaphase for chromosome segregation and spindle midbody organization

The Ran pathway has been shown to have a role in spindle assembly. However, the extent of the role of the Ran pathway in mitosis in vivo is unclear. We report that perturbation of the Ran pathway disrupted multiple steps of mitosis in syncytial Drosophila embryos and uncovered new mitotic processes that are regulated by Ran. During the onset of mitosis, the Ran pathway is required for the production, organization, and targeting of centrosomally nucleated microtubules to chromosomes. However, the role of Ran is not restricted to microtubule organization, because Ran is also required for the alignment of chromosomes at the metaphase plate. In addition, the Ran pathway is required for postmetaphase events, including chromosome segregation and the assembly of the microtubule midbody. The Ran pathway mediates these mitotic events, in part, by facilitating the correct targeting of the kinase Aurora A and the kinesins KLP61F and KLP3A to spindles.     

Sirt3 controls chromosome alignment by regulating spindle dynamics during mitosis

Sirt3, one of mammalian sirtuins is a prominent mitochondrial deacetylase that controls mitochondrial oxidative pathways and the rate of reactive oxygen species. Sirt3 also regulates energy metabolism by deacetylating enzymes involved in the metabolic pathway related with lifespan. We report here a novel function of Sirt3 which was found to be involved in mitosis. Depletion of the Sirt3 protein generated unaligned chromosomes in metaphase which caused mitotic arrest by activating spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC). Furthermore, the shape and the amount of the spindles in Sirt3 depleted cells were abnormal. Microtubule (MT) polymerization also increased in Sirt3 depleted cells, suggesting that Sirt3 is involved in spindle dynamics. However, the level of acetylated tubulin was not increased significantly in Sirt3 depleted cells. The findings collectively suggest that Sirt3 is not a tubulin deacetylase but regulates the attachment of spindle MTs to the kinetochore and the subsequent chromosome alignment by increasing spindle dynamics.     

Inhibition of Aurora kinases perturbs chromosome alignment and spindle checkpoint signaling in rat spermatocytes

In somatic cells, integrity of cell division is safeguarded by the spindle checkpoint, a signaling cascade that delays the separation of sister chromatids in the presence of misaligned chromosomes. Aurora kinases play important roles in this process by promoting centrosome maturation, chromosome bi-orientation, spindle checkpoint signaling, and cytokinesis. To investigate the functions of Aurora kinases in male meiosis, we applied a small molecule Aurora inhibitor, ZM447439, to seminiferous tubules in vitro. Primary and secondary spermatocytes exposed to ZM447439 exhibit defects in the spindle morphology and fail to align their chromosomes at the metaphase plate. Moreover, the treated spermatocytes undergo a forced exit from the meiotic M-phase without cytokinesis. These results suggest that the activities of Aurora kinases are required for normal spindle assembly as well as for establishment and maintenance of proper microtubule-kinetochore attachments and spindle checkpoint signaling in male mammalian meiosis.     

In vitro parthenogenetic development of mouse oocytes following reciprocal transfer of the chromosome spindle between in vivo-matured oocytes and in vitro-matured oocytes

Mouse follicles grown in vitro from preantral to mature stages yield oocytes that can be fertilized in vitro, but embryonic development is poor. To investigate whether this poor development is due to a nuclear or a cytoplasmatic factor, we designed an experiment in which the MII chromosome spindle was exchanged between in vitro-matured oocytes and in vivo-matured oocytes by electrofusion. Subsequent embryo development was evaluated by blastocyst formation rate and blastocyst cell number after parthenogenetic activation. Electrofusion was successful in 62-78% of the oocytes. Transfer of the spindle apparatus from in vitro-matured oocytes to the in vivo MII cytoplasmic environment resulted in a high rate of blastocyst development, whereas in the reverse situation (transfer of the nucleus from in vivo-matured oocytes into in vitro-matured MII cytoplasm) poor quality embryos and a low rate of blastocyst formation was observed. These results indicate that the low developmental competence of in vitro-matured oocytes from mouse preantral follicles after activation is caused by the cytoplasmic component rather than the nuclear component.     

Perturbation of survivin expression affects chromosome alignment and spindle checkpoint in mouse oocyte meiotic maturation

Survivin is a member of inhibitors of apoptosis proteins (IAPs), which have multiple regulatory functions in mitosis, but its roles in meiosis remain unknown. Here, we report its expression, localization and functions in mouse oocyte meiosis. Survivin displayed maximal expression levels in GV stages, and then gradually decreased from Pro-MI to MII stages. Immunofluorescent staining showed that survivin was restricted to the germinal vesicle, associated with centromeres from pro-metaphase I to metaphase I stages, distributed at the midzone and midbody of anaphase and telophase spindles, and located to centromeres at metaphase II stages. Depletion of survivin by antibody injection and morpholino injection resulted in severe chromosome misalignment, precocious polar body extrusion, and larger-than-normal polar bodies. Overexpression of survivin resulted in severe chromosome misalignment and prometaphase I or metaphase I arrest in a large proportion of oocytes. Our data suggest that survivin is required for chromosome alignment and that it may regulate spindle checkpoint activity during mouse oocyte meiosis.     

Induction and inhibition of meiotic maturation of follicle-enclosed porcine oocytes in vitro

Isolated porcine Graafian follicles which were explanted in vitro and maintained in organ culture were used as a test-system for the meiosis-inducing action of PMSG and hCG. The addition of either PMSG or hCG alone (10 or 20 IU/ml, respectively) to the culture medium was not effective, whereas the simultaneous administration of these hormones ($\text{15}\text{15}\text{IU/ml}$) induced resumption of meiosis in 90.3% ($\text{37}\text{41}$). The same hormone concentrations were used in a second series of experiments in which the inhibition and induction of meiosis of isolated oocytes were tested by transferring them into host follicles. In host follicles containing up to 12 foreign eggs, which were cultured in control media, meiosis was prevented in 86.0% of all oocytes ($\text{104}\text{121}$). By adding PMSG (15 IU/ml) simultaneously with hCG (15 IU/ml) to the medium, meiosis was induced in 95.0% of all oocytes ($\text{133}\text{140}$).The assumption is made that the signal initiating resumption of meiosis of the isolated and transferred oocytes is mediated by the follicular fluid, since intimate contact with the membrana granulosa of the host follicle was prevented by using a roller technique.     

2-methoxyestradiol induces spindle aberrations, chromosome congression failure, and nondisjunction in mouse oocytes

2-Methoxyestradiol (2-ME) is a metabolite of 17beta-estradiol and a natural component of follicular fluid. Local concentrations of 2-ME may be increased by exposure to environmental pollutants that activate the expression of enzymes in the metabolic pathway from 17beta-estradiol to 2-ME. It has been suspected that this may have adverse effects on spindle formation in maturing oocytes, which would affect embryo quality. To study the dose-response patterns, we exposed denuded mouse oocytes to 2-ME during in vitro maturation. Meiotic progression, spindle morphology, centrosome integrity, and chromosome congression were examined by immunofluorescence and noninvasive polarizing microscopy (PolScope). Chromosomal constituents were assessed after spreading and C-banding. 2-ME sustained MAD2L1 expression at the centromeres and increased the number of meiosis I-blocked oocytes in a dose-dependent manner. 2-ME also caused dramatic dose-dependent increases in the hyperploidy of metaphase II oocytes. Some of these meiosis II oocytes contained anaphase I-like chromosomes, which suggests that high concentrations of the catecholestradiol interfere with the physical separation of chromosomes. Noninvasive PolScope analysis and tubulin immunofluorescence revealed that perturbations in spindle organization, which resulted in severe disturbances of the chromosome alignment at the spindle equator (congression failure), were caused by 2-ME at meiosis I and II. Pericentrin-positive centrosomes failed to align at the spindle poles, and multipolar spindles and prominent arrays of cytoplasmic microtubule asters were induced in 2-ME-exposed metaphase II oocytes. In conclusion, a micromolar level of 2-ME is aneugenic for mammalian oocytes. Therefore, exposure to 2-ME and conditions that increase the intrinsic local concentration of 2-ME in the ovary may affect fertility and increase risks for chromosomal aberrations in the oocyte and embryo.     

Presence of an extra chromosome alters meiotic double-stranded break repair dynamics and MLH1 foci distribution in human oocytes

Studies performed on human trisomic 21 oocytes have revealed that during meiosis, the three homologues 21 synapse and, in some cases, achieve what looks like a trivalent. This implies that meiotic recombination takes place among the three homologous chromosomes 21, and to some extent, crossovers form between them. To see how meiotic recombination is in the presence of an extra chromosome 21, we analyzed the distribution of three recombination markers (γH2AX, RPA, and MLH1) on trisomic 21 oocytes at pachynema and, in particular, on chromosomes 21. Results clearly show how the presence of an extra chromosome 21 alters meiotic recombination progression, leading to the presence of a higher number of early recombination markers at pachynema. Moreover, the distribution on these chromosomes 21 of some of these markers is different in aneuploid oocytes. Finally, there is a substantial increase in the number of MLH1 foci, a marker of most crossovers in mammals, which is related to the number of synapsed chromosomes in pachynema. Thus, bivalents 21 had fewer MLH1 foci than partial or total trivalents, suggesting a close relationship between synapsis and crossover designation. All of the data presented suggest that the presence of an extra chromosome alters meiotic recombination globally in aneuploid human oocytes.     

BRCA1 is required for meiotic spindle assembly and spindle assembly checkpoint activation in mouse oocytes

BRCA1 as a tumor suppressor has been widely investigated in mitosis, but its functions in meiosis are unclear. In the present study, we examined the expression, localization, and function of BRCA1 during mouse oocyte meiotic maturation. We found that expression level of BRCA1 was increased progressively from germinal vesicle to metaphase I stage, and then remained stable until metaphase II stage. Immunofluorescent analysis showed that BRCA1 was localized to the spindle poles at metaphase I and metaphase II stages, colocalizing with centrosomal protein gamma-tubulin. Taxol treatment resulted in the presence of BRCA1 onto the spindle microtubule fibers, whereas nocodazole treatment induced the localization of BRCA1 onto the chromosomes. Depletion of BRCA1 by both antibody injection and siRNA injection caused severely impaired spindles and misaligned chromosomes. Furthermore, BRCA1-depleted oocytes could not arrest at the metaphase I in the presence of low-dose nocodazole, suggesting that the spindle checkpoint is defective. Also, in BRCA1-depleted oocytes, gamma-tubulin dissociated from spindle poles and MAD2L1 failed to rebind to the kinetochores when exposed to nocodazole at metaphase I stage. Collectively, these data indicate that BRCA1 regulates not only meiotic spindle assembly, but also spindle assembly checkpoint, implying a link between BRCA1 deficiency and aneuploid embryos.     

Butyrolactone I reversibly alters nuclear configuration, periooplasmic microtubules and development of porcine oocytes

In the present study, we investigated the effects of specific cdc2 kinase inhibitor, butyrolactone I (BL I) on the prevention of germinal vesicle breakdown, changes of microtubular structures, and development of porcine oocytes after removal of the drug. In Experiment 1, cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were cultured (44 h) in NCSU-23 medium containing different concentrations of BL I. The percentages of oocytes remaining at GV stage were 0, 0, 32, 80, and 84% (P<0.05), and the maturation rates were 86, 63, 30, 0, and 0% (P<0.05) for oocytes treated with 0, 10, 20, 40, and 80 microM of BL I, respectively. When oocytes were released from BL I incubation (Experiment 2) and cultured for an additional 44 h, 79, 84, and 83% of oocytes resumed meiosis, but only 52, 38 and 17% of oocytes reached normal metaphase II (MII) stage in the groups treated with 20, 40 and 80 microM BL I, respectively. In Experiments 3-5, reversibility and development of oocytes and embryos were evaluated after removal of the inhibitor. A reduced duration of BL I incubation (22 h) at 20 microM increased the percentage of oocytes remaining at the GV stage compared to the control group (85% versus 9%, P<0.05). Blastocyst rates were lower in treatment groups than in the control (44 h) group (0-14% versus 24%; P<0.05). However, all developing blastocysts possessed similar cell numbers, regardless of the drug-treated or non-treated controls. Taken together, treatment with 20-80 microM of BL I effectively prevented the resumption of meiosis and polymerization of periooplasmic microtubules. Furthermore, reversibility of the oocytes after reduced duration of BL I treatment was satisfactory.     

Follicle-stimulating hormone affects metaphase I chromosome alignment and increases aneuploidy in mouse oocytes matured in vitro

Follicle-Stimulating Hormone (FSH) at a wide range of doses is routinely added to culture media during in vitro maturation (IVM) of oocytes, but the effects on oocyte health are unclear. The suggestion that superovulation may cause aneuploidy and fetal abnormalities prompted us to study the potential role of FSH in the genesis of chromosomal abnormalities during meiosis I. Mouse cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) isolated from the antral follicles of unprimed, sexually immature B6CBF1 mice were cultured in increasing concentrations of FSH. Following culture, matured oocytes were isolated, spread, stained with DAPI, and the numbers of chromosomes counted. Significantly increased aneuploidy, arising during the first meiotic division, was observed in metaphase II oocytes matured in higher concentrations of FSH (> or =20 ng/ml). The effect of FSH on spindle morphology and chromosome alignment during metaphase I was then explored using immunocytochemistry and three-dimensional reconstruction of confocal sections. High FSH had no effect on gross spindle morphology but did alter chromosome congression during prometaphase and metaphase, with the spread of chromosomes across the spindle at this time being significantly greater in oocytes cultured in 2000 ng/ml compared with 2 ng/ml FSH. Analysis of three-dimensional reconstructions of spindles in oocytes matured in 2000 ng/ml FSH shows that chromosomes are more scattered and farther apart than they are following maturation in 2 ng/ml FSH. These results demonstrate that exposure to high levels of FSH during IVM can accelerate nuclear maturation and induce chromosomal abnormalities and highlights the importance of the judicious use of FSH during IVM.     

A functional relationship between NuMA and kid is involved in both spindle organization and chromosome alignment in vertebrate cells

We examined spindle morphology and chromosome alignment in vertebrate cells after simultaneous perturbation of the chromokinesin Kid and either NuMA, CENP-E, or HSET. Spindle morphology and chromosome alignment after simultaneous perturbation of Kid and either HSET or CENP-E were no different from when either HSET or CENP-E was perturbed alone. However, short bipolar spindles with organized poles formed after perturbation of both Kid and NuMA in stark contrast to splayed spindle poles observed after perturbation of NuMA alone. Spindles were disorganized if Kid, NuMA, and HSET were perturbed, indicating that HSET is sufficient for spindle organization in the absence of Kid and NuMA function. In addition, chromosomes failed to align efficiently at the spindle equator after simultaneous perturbation of Kid and NuMA despite appropriate kinetochore-microtubule interactions that generated chromosome movement at normal velocities. These data indicate that a functional relationship between the chromokinesin Kid and the spindle pole organizing protein NuMA influences spindle morphology, and we propose that this occurs because NuMA forms functional linkages between kinetochore and nonkinetochore microtubules at spindle poles. In addition, these data show that both Kid and NuMA contribute to chromosome alignment in mammalian cells.