Quaternary Structure of Pathological Prion Protein as a Determining Factor of Strain-Specific Prion Replication Dynamics

Prions are proteinaceous infectious agents responsible for fatal neurodegenerative diseases in animals and humans. They are essentially composed of PrP^Sc, an aggregated, misfolded conformer of the ubiquitously expressed host-encoded prion protein (PrP^C). Stable variations in PrP^Sc conformation are assumed to encode the phenotypically tangible prion strains diversity. However the direct contribution of PrP^Sc quaternary structure to the strain biological information remains mostly unknown. Applying a sedimentation velocity fractionation technique to a panel of ovine prion strains, classified as fast and slow according to their incubation time in ovine PrP transgenic mice, has previously led to the observation that the relationship between prion infectivity and PrP^Sc quaternary structure was not univocal. For the fast strains specifically, infectivity sedimented slowly and segregated from the bulk of proteinase-K resistant PrP^Sc. To carefully separate the respective contributions of size and density to this hydrodynamic behavior, we performed sedimentation at the equilibrium and varied the solubilization conditions. The density profile of prion infectivity and proteinase-K resistant PrP^Sc tended to overlap whatever the strain, fast or slow, leaving only size as the main responsible factor for the specific velocity properties of the fast strain most infectious component. We further show that this velocity-isolable population of discrete assemblies perfectly resists limited proteolysis and that its templating activity, as assessed by protein misfolding cyclic amplification outcompetes by several orders of magnitude that of the bulk of larger size PrP^Sc aggregates. Together, the tight correlation between small size, conversion efficiency and duration of disease establishes PrP^Sc quaternary structure as a determining factor of prion replication dynamics. For certain strains, a subset of PrP assemblies appears to be the best template for prion replication. This has important implications for fundamental studies on prions.     

A Structural and Functional Comparison Between Infectious and Non-Infectious Autocatalytic Recombinant PrP Conformers

Infectious prions contain a self-propagating, misfolded conformer of the prion protein termed PrP^Sc. A critical prediction of the protein-only hypothesis is that autocatalytic PrP^Sc molecules should be infectious. However, some autocatalytic recombinant PrP^Sc molecules have low or undetectable levels of specific infectivity in bioassays, and the essential determinants of recombinant prion infectivity remain obscure. To identify structural and functional features specifically associated with infectivity, we compared the properties of two autocatalytic recombinant PrP conformers derived from the same original template, which differ by >10⁵-fold in specific infectivity for wild-type mice. Structurally, hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (DXMS) studies revealed that solvent accessibility profiles of infectious and non-infectious autocatalytic recombinant PrP conformers are remarkably similar throughout their protease-resistant cores, except for two domains encompassing residues 91-115 and 144-163. Raman spectroscopy and immunoprecipitation studies confirm that these domains adopt distinct conformations within infectious versus non-infectious autocatalytic recombinant PrP conformers. Functionally, in vitro prion propagation experiments show that the non-infectious conformer is unable to seed mouse PrP^C substrates containing a glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor, including native PrP^C. Taken together, these results indicate that having a conformation that can be specifically adopted by post-translationally modified PrP^C molecules is an essential determinant of biological infectivity for recombinant prions, and suggest that this ability is associated with discrete features of PrP^Sc structure.     

Immunopurification of Pathological Prion Protein Aggregates

Background

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders that can arise sporadically, be genetically inherited or acquired through infection. The key event in these diseases is misfolding of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into a pathogenic isoform that is rich in β-sheet structure. This conformational change may result in the formation of PrP^Sc, the prion isoform of PrP, which propagates itself by imprinting its aberrant conformation onto PrP^C molecules. A great deal of effort has been devoted to developing protocols for purifying PrP^Sc for structural studies, and testing its biological properties. Most procedures rely on protease digestion, allowing efficient purification of PrP27-30, the protease-resistant core of PrP^Sc. However, protease treatment cannot be used to isolate abnormal forms of PrP lacking conventional protease resistance, such as those found in several genetic and atypical sporadic cases.

Principal Findings

We developed a method for purifying pathological PrP molecules based on sequential centrifugation and immunoprecipitation with a monoclonal antibody selective for aggregated PrP. With this procedure we purified full-length PrP^Sc and mutant PrP aggregates at electrophoretic homogeneity. PrP^Sc purified from prion-infected mice was able to seed misfolding of PrP^C in a protein misfolding cyclic amplification reaction, and mutant PrP aggregates from transgenic mice were toxic to cultured neurons.

Significance

The immunopurification protocol described here isolates biologically active forms of aggregated PrP. These preparations may be useful for investigating the structural and chemico-physical properties of infectious and neurotoxic PrP aggregates.     

Isolation of Soluble and Insoluble PrP Oligomers in the Normal Human Brain

The central event in the pathogenesis of prion diseases involves a conversion of the host-encoded cellular prion protein PrP^C into its pathogenic isoform PrP^{Sc 1}. PrP^C is detergent-soluble and sensitive to proteinase K (PK)-digestion, whereas PrP^Sc forms detergent-insoluble aggregates and is partially resistant to PK^2-6. The conversion of PrP^C to PrP^Sc is known to involve a conformational transition of α-helical to β-sheet structures of the protein. However, the in vivo pathway is still poorly understood. A tentative endogenous PrP^Sc, intermediate PrP* or "silent prion", has yet to be identified in the uninfected brain⁷.Using a combination of biophysical and biochemical approaches, we identified insoluble PrP^C aggregates (designated iPrP^C) from uninfected mammalian brains and cultured neuronal cells^{8, 9}. Here, we describe detailed procedures of these methods, including ultracentrifugation in detergent buffer, sucrose step gradient sedimentation, size exclusion chromatography, iPrP enrichment by gene 5 protein (g5p) that specifically bind to structurally altered PrP forms¹⁰, and PK-treatment. The combination of these approaches isolates not only insoluble PrP^Sc and PrP^C aggregates but also soluble PrP^C oligomers from the normal human brain. Since the protocols described here have been used to isolate both PrP^Sc from infected brains and iPrP^C from uninfected brains, they provide us with an opportunity to compare differences in physicochemical features, neurotoxicity, and infectivity between the two isoforms. Such a study will greatly improve our understanding of the infectious proteinaceous pathogens. The physiology and pathophysiology of iPrP^C are unclear at present. Notably, in a newly-identified human prion disease termed variably protease-sensitive prionopathy, we found a new PrP^Sc that shares the immunoreactive behavior and fragmentation with iPrP^{C 11, 12}. Moreover, we recently demonstrated that iPrP^C is the main species that interacts with amyloid-β protein in Alzheimer disease¹³. In the same study, these methods were used to isolate Abeta aggregates and oligomers in Alzheimer''s disease¹³, suggesting their application to non-prion protein aggregates involved in other neurodegenerative disorders.     

Recombinant Prion Protein Refolded with Lipid and RNA Has the Biochemical Hallmarks of a Prion but Lacks In Vivo Infectivity

During prion infection, the normal, protease-sensitive conformation of prion protein (PrP^C) is converted via seeded polymerization to an abnormal, infectious conformation with greatly increased protease-resistance (PrP^Sc). In vitro, protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) uses PrP^Sc in prion-infected brain homogenates as an initiating seed to convert PrP^C and trigger the self-propagation of PrP^Sc over many cycles of amplification. While PMCA reactions produce high levels of protease-resistant PrP, the infectious titer is often lower than that of brain-derived PrP^Sc. More recently, PMCA techniques using bacterially derived recombinant PrP (rPrP) in the presence of lipid and RNA but in the absence of any starting PrP^Sc seed have been used to generate infectious prions that cause disease in wild-type mice with relatively short incubation times. These data suggest that lipid and/or RNA act as cofactors to facilitate the de novo formation of high levels of prion infectivity. Using rPrP purified by two different techniques, we generated a self-propagating protease-resistant rPrP molecule that, regardless of the amount of RNA and lipid used, had a molecular mass, protease resistance and insolubility similar to that of PrP^Sc. However, we were unable to detect prion infectivity in any of our reactions using either cell-culture or animal bioassays. These results demonstrate that the ability to self-propagate into a protease-resistant insoluble conformer is not unique to infectious PrP molecules. They suggest that the presence of RNA and lipid cofactors may facilitate the spontaneous refolding of PrP into an infectious form while also allowing the de novo formation of self-propagating, but non-infectious, rPrP-res.     

Generation of antisera to purified prions in lipid rafts

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders caused by prion proteins (PrP). Infectious prions accumulate in the brain through a template-mediated conformational conversion of endogenous PrP^C into alternately folded PrP^Sc. Immunoassays toward pre-clinical detection of infectious PrP^Sc have been confounded by low-level prion accumulation in non-neuronal tissue and the lack of PrP^Sc selective antibodies. We report a method to purify infectious PrP^Sc from biological tissues for use as an immunogen and sample enrichment for increased immunoassay sensitivity. Significant prion enrichment is accomplished by sucrose gradient centrifugation of infected tissue and isolation with detergent resistant membranes from lipid rafts (DRMs). At equivalent protein concentration a 50-fold increase in detectable PrP^Sc was observed in DRM fractions relative to crude brain by direct ELISA. Sequential purification steps result in increased specific infectivity (DRM >20-fold and purified DRM immunogen >40-fold) relative to 1% crude brain homogenate. Purification of PrP^Sc from DRM was accomplished using phosphotungstic acid protein precipitation after proteinase-K (PK) digestion followed by size exclusion chromatography to separate PK and residual protein fragments from larger prion aggregates. Immunization with purified PrP^Sc antigen was performed using wild-type (wt) and Prnp^0/0 mice, both on Balb/cJ background. A robust immune response against PrP^Sc was observed in all inoculated Prnp^0/0 mice resulting in antisera containing high-titer antibodies against prion protein. Antisera from these mice recognized both PrP^C and PrP^Sc, while binding to other brain-derived protein was not observed. In contrast, the PrP^Sc inoculum was non-immunogenic in wt mice and antisera showed no reactivity with PrP or any other protein.Key words: prion, scrapie, Prnp0/0 mice, purification methodology, antibody, antisera, lipid-rafts, detergent resistant membranes, neuroscience, immunization, diagnostic     

Prion Seeding Activities of Mouse Scrapie Strains with Divergent PrPSc Protease Sensitivities and Amyloid Plaque Content Using RT-QuIC and eQuIC

Different transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE)-associated forms of prion protein (e.g. PrP^Sc) can vary markedly in ultrastructure and biochemical characteristics, but each is propagated in the host. PrP^Sc propagation involves conversion from its normal isoform, PrP^C, by a seeded or templated polymerization mechanism. Such a mechanism is also the basis of the RT-QuIC and eQuIC prion assays which use recombinant PrP (rPrP^Sen) as a substrate. These ultrasensitive detection assays have been developed for TSE prions of several host species and sample tissues, but not for murine models which are central to TSE pathogenesis research. Here we have adapted RT-QuIC and eQuIC to various murine prions and evaluated how seeding activity depends on glycophosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchoring and the abundance of amyloid plaques and protease-resistant PrP^Sc (PrP^Res). Scrapie brain dilutions up to 10⁻⁸ and 10⁻¹³ were detected by RT-QuIC and eQuIC, respectively. Comparisons of scrapie-affected wild-type mice and transgenic mice expressing GPI anchorless PrP showed that, although similar concentrations of seeding activity accumulated in brain, the heavily amyloid-laden anchorless mouse tissue seeded more rapid reactions. Next we compared seeding activities in the brains of mice with similar infectivity titers, but widely divergent PrP^Res levels. For this purpose we compared the 263K and 139A scrapie strains in transgenic mice expressing P101L PrP^C. Although the brains of 263K-affected mice had little immunoblot-detectable PrP^Res, RT-QuIC indicated that seeding activity was comparable to that associated with a high-PrP^Res strain, 139A. Thus, in this comparison, RT-QuIC seeding activity correlated more closely with infectivity than with PrP^Res levels. We also found that eQuIC, which incorporates a PrP^Sc immunoprecipitation step, detected seeding activity in plasma from wild-type and anchorless PrP transgenic mice inoculated with 22L, 79A and/or RML scrapie strains. Overall, we conclude that these new mouse-adapted prion seeding assays detect diverse types of PrP^Sc.     

Early Appearance but Lagged Accumulation of Detergent-Insoluble Prion Protein in the Brains of Mice Inoculated with a Mouse-Adapted Creutzfeldt–Jakob Disease Agent

SUMMARY 1. To elucidate mechanisms for the generation of the detergent-insoluble, proteinase K-resistant prion protein (PrP^Sc) from the detergent-soluble, proteinase K-sensitive PrP (PrP^C) and the replication of the infectious agent in prion diseases, we followed the kinetics of detergent-insoluble PrP and PrP^Sc levels, infectious titers, and associated pathological changes in the brains of mice inoculated with a mouse-adapted Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease agent.2. PrP^Sc in brain homogenate and detergent-insoluble PrP enriched by two-cycle ultracentrifugation were detected by immunoblotting and their relative amounts were estimated according to a standard curve plotted between the amount of PrP and signal intensity on immunoblotting. The titer of infectivity was determined by the incubation periods of mice inoculated with the unfractionated homogenate on the basis of a standard curve plotted between the titer and incubation period.3. Detergent-insoluble PrP became detectable 4 weeks postinoculation (p.i.) well before the detection of PrP^Sc. The low level of detergent-insoluble PrP continued until dramatic accumulation occurred at 14 weeks p.i., correlating well with the accumulation of PrP^Sc and development of pathological changes. The infectious titer was undetectable at 4 weeks p.i. and its logarithmic increase occurred 10 weeks p.i. preceding the logarithmic accumulation of PrPs.4. The lag time of detergent-insoluble PrP accumulation and the discrepancy between infectious titers and PrPs observed during the early period after inoculation suggest a slow and rate-limiting step for the detergent-insoluble PrP to become the infectious agent-associated PrP^Sc.     

The ultrastructure of infectious L-type bovine spongiform encephalopathy prions constrains molecular models

Bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) is a prion disease of cattle that is caused by the misfolding of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into an infectious conformation (PrP^Sc). PrP^C is a predominantly α-helical membrane protein that misfolds into a β-sheet rich, infectious state, which has a high propensity to self-assemble into amyloid fibrils. Three strains of BSE prions can cause prion disease in cattle, including classical BSE (C-type) and two atypical strains, named L-type and H-type BSE. To date, there is no detailed information available about the structure of any of the infectious BSE prion strains. In this study, we purified L-type BSE prions from transgenic mouse brains and investigated their biochemical and ultrastructural characteristics using electron microscopy, image processing, and immunogold labeling techniques. By using phosphotungstate anions (PTA) to precipitate PrP^Sc combined with sucrose gradient centrifugation, a high yield of proteinase K-resistant BSE amyloid fibrils was obtained. A morphological examination using electron microscopy, two-dimensional class averages, and three-dimensional reconstructions revealed two structural classes of L-type BSE amyloid fibrils; fibrils that consisted of two protofilaments with a central gap and an average width of 22.5 nm and one-protofilament fibrils that were 10.6 nm wide. The one-protofilament fibrils were found to be more abundant compared to the thicker two-protofilament fibrils. Both fibrillar assemblies were successfully decorated with monoclonal antibodies against N- and C-terminal epitopes of PrP using immunogold-labeling techniques, confirming the presence of polypeptides that span residues 100–110 to 227–237. The fact that the one-protofilament fibrils contain both N- and C-terminal PrP epitopes constrains molecular models for the structure of the infectious conformer in favour of a compact four-rung β-solenoid fold.     

The Structural Architecture of an Infectious Mammalian Prion Using Electron Cryomicroscopy

The structure of the infectious prion protein (PrP^Sc), which is responsible for Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in humans and bovine spongiform encephalopathy, has escaped all attempts at elucidation due to its insolubility and propensity to aggregate. PrP^Sc replicates by converting the non-infectious, cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into the misfolded, infectious conformer through an unknown mechanism. PrP^Sc and its N-terminally truncated variant, PrP 27–30, aggregate into amorphous aggregates, 2D crystals, and amyloid fibrils. The structure of these infectious conformers is essential to understanding prion replication and the development of structure-based therapeutic interventions. Here we used the repetitive organization inherent to GPI-anchorless PrP 27–30 amyloid fibrils to analyze their structure via electron cryomicroscopy. Fourier-transform analyses of averaged fibril segments indicate a repeating unit of 19.1 Å. 3D reconstructions of these fibrils revealed two distinct protofilaments, and, together with a molecular volume of 18,990 ų, predicted the height of each PrP 27–30 molecule as ~17.7 Å. Together, the data indicate a four-rung β-solenoid structure as a key feature for the architecture of infectious mammalian prions. Furthermore, they allow to formulate a molecular mechanism for the replication of prions. Knowledge of the prion structure will provide important insights into the self-propagation mechanisms of protein misfolding.     

PrPST,a Soluble,Protease Resistant and Truncated PrP Form Features in the Pathogenesis of a Genetic Prion Disease

While the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc in the transmissible form of prion disease requires a preexisting PrP^Sc seed, in genetic prion disease accumulation of disease related PrP could be associated with biochemical and metabolic modifications resulting from the designated PrP mutation. To investigate this possibility, we looked into the time related changes of PrP proteins in the brains of TgMHu2ME199K/wt mice, a line modeling for heterozygous genetic prion disease linked to the E200K PrP mutation. We found that while oligomeric entities of mutant E199KPrP exist at all ages, aggregates of wt PrP in the same brains presented only in advanced disease, indicating a late onset conversion process. We also show that most PK resistant PrP in TgMHu2ME199K mice is soluble and truncated (PrP^ST), a pathogenic form never before associated with prion disease. We next looked into brain samples from E200K patients and found that both PK resistant PrPs, PrP^ST as in TgMHu2ME199K mice, and “classical” PrP^Sc as in infectious prion diseases, coincide in the patient''s post mortem brains. We hypothesize that aberrant metabolism of mutant PrPs may result in the formation of previously unknown forms of the prion protein and that these may be central for the fatal outcome of the genetic prion condition.     

Trans-Dominant Inhibition of Prion Propagation In Vitro Is Not Mediated by an Accessory Cofactor

Previous studies identified prion protein (PrP) mutants which act as dominant negative inhibitors of prion formation through a mechanism hypothesized to require an unidentified species-specific cofactor termed protein X. To study the mechanism of dominant negative inhibition in vitro, we used recombinant PrP^C molecules expressed in Chinese hamster ovary cells as substrates in serial protein misfolding cyclic amplification (sPMCA) reactions. Bioassays confirmed that the products of these reactions are infectious. Using this system, we find that: (1) trans-dominant inhibition can be dissociated from conversion activity, (2) dominant-negative inhibition of prion formation can be reconstituted in vitro using only purified substrates, even when wild type (WT) PrP^C is pre-incubated with poly(A) RNA and PrP^Sc template, and (3) Q172R is the only hamster PrP mutant tested that fails to convert into PrP^Sc and that can dominantly inhibit conversion of WT PrP at sub-stoichiometric levels. These results refute the hypothesis that protein X is required to mediate dominant inhibition of prion propagation, and suggest that PrP molecules compete for binding to a nascent seeding site on newly formed PrP^Sc molecules, most likely through an epitope containing residue 172.     

Mapping the Prion Protein Using Recombinant Antibodies

The fundamental event in prion disease is thought to be the posttranslational conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into a pathogenic isoform (PrP^Sc). The occurrence of PrP^C on the cell surface and PrP^Sc in amyloid plaques in situ or in aggregates following purification complicates the study of the molecular events that underlie the disease process. Monoclonal antibodies are highly sensitive probes of protein conformation which can be used under these conditions. Here, we report the rescue of a diverse panel of 19 PrP-specific recombinant monoclonal antibodies from phage display libraries prepared from PrP deficient (Prnp^0/0) mice immunized with infectious prions either in the form of rods or PrP 27-30 dispersed into liposomes. The antibodies recognize a number of distinct linear and discontinuous epitopes that are presented to a varying degree on different PrP preparations. The epitope reactivity of the recombinant PrP(90-231) molecule was almost indistinguishable from that of PrP^C on the cell surface, validating the importance of detailed structural studies on the recombinant molecule. Only one epitope region at the C terminus of PrP was well presented on both PrP^C and PrP^Sc, while epitopes associated with most of the antibodies in the panel were present on PrP^C but absent from PrP^Sc.     

Inherited Prion Disease A117V Is Not Simply a Proteinopathy but Produces Prions Transmissible to Transgenic Mice Expressing Homologous Prion Protein

Prions are infectious agents causing fatal neurodegenerative diseases of humans and animals. In humans, these have sporadic, acquired and inherited aetiologies. The inherited prion diseases are caused by one of over 30 coding mutations in the human prion protein (PrP) gene (PRNP) and many of these generate infectious prions as evidenced by their experimental transmissibility by inoculation to laboratory animals. However, some, and in particular an extensively studied type of Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker syndrome (GSS) caused by a PRNP A117V mutation, are thought not to generate infectious prions and instead constitute prion proteinopathies with a quite distinct pathogenetic mechanism. Multiple attempts to transmit A117V GSS have been unsuccessful and typical protease-resistant PrP (PrP^Sc), pathognomonic of prion disease, is not detected in brain. Pathogenesis is instead attributed to production of an aberrant topological form of PrP, C-terminal transmembrane PrP (^CtmPrP). Barriers to transmission of prion strains from one species to another appear to relate to structural compatibility of PrP in host and inoculum and we have therefore produced transgenic mice expressing human 117V PrP. We found that brain tissue from GSS A117V patients did transmit disease to these mice and both the neuropathological features of prion disease and presence of PrP^Sc was demonstrated in the brains of recipient transgenic mice. This PrP^Sc rapidly degraded during laboratory analysis, suggesting that the difficulty in its detection in patients with GSS A117V could relate to post-mortem proteolysis. We conclude that GSS A117V is indeed a prion disease although the relative contributions of ^CtmPrP and prion propagation in neurodegeneration and their pathogenetic interaction remains to be established.     

Photodegradation illuminates the role of polyanions in prion infectivity

Understanding the mechanism by which prion infectivity is encoded by the misfolded protein PrP^Sc remains a high priority within the prion field. Work from several groups has indicated cellular cofactors may be necessary to form infectious prions in vitro. The identity of endogenous prion conversion cofactors is currently unknown, but may include polyanions and/or lipid molecules. In a recent study, we manufactured infectious hamster prions containing purified PrP^Sc, co-purified lipid and a synthetic photocleavable polyanion. The polyanion was incorporated into infectious PrP^Sc complexes and then specifically degraded by exposure to ultraviolet light. Light-induced in situ degradation of the incorporated polyanion had no effect on the specific infectivity of the samples as determined by end-point dilution sPMCA and scrapie incubation time assays. Furthermore, prion strain properties were not changed by polyanion degradation, suggesting that intact polyanions are not required to maintain the infectious properties of hamster prions. Here, we review these results and discuss the potential roles cofactors might play in encoding prion infectivity and/or strain properties.Key words: prion, polyanion, photodegradation, incorporation, PrPThe prion diseases are infectious diseases that are believed to be caused by the conformational change of a host-encoded protein, PrP^C, to a pathogenic conformer PrP^Sc. The controversial “protein-only” hypothesis posits that the infectious agent is composed solely of the misfolded conformer PrP^Sc. There have been many attempts to create infectious prions from purified recombinant PrP protein. However, all of the samples generated in these experiments display relatively low levels of specific infectivity when inoculated intracerebrally into wild-type animals.^1–4 Several lines of evidence suggest that cellular cofactors, such as polyanionic molecules, facilitate the formation of the infectious conformation.^5–14The first in vitro PrP conversion assay used radiolabeled PrP^C substrate purified from mammalian cells mixed with a stoichiometric excess of unlabeled PrP^Sc. This cell free assay produced a protease-resistant, radioactive product termed PrP-res.¹⁵ These pioneering studies showed for the first time that PrP could be specifically transformed in vitro, but the yield using purified substrates was low. Using a modification of the cell free assay in which crude brain homogenate replaced purified PrP^C as the substrate, our laboratory was able to amplify PrP^Sc 6-fold over input prion seed, suggesting that non-PrP constituents of crude brain homogenate might be required for efficient PrP^Sc formation in vitro.¹⁶ Using this system, we discovered that nuclease treatment of hamster brain homogenates abolished PrP^Sc amplification in vitro, and that reconstituting the nuclease-treated reactions with purified mammalian RNA rescued the amplification process.⁵ PrP^Sc amplification could also be obtained by adding certain synthetic homopolymeric nucleic acids to immunopurified PrP^C.⁶ Taken together, these surprising results argue that non-proteinaceous, host-encoded cofactors such as RNA molecules might facilitate prion conversion through a structural (as opposed to encoding) mechanism.⁸ The high efficiency of the serial protein misfolding amplification (sPMCA) technique developed by Soto and colleagues has allowed researchers to amplify prion infectivity as well as PrP^Sc molecules.^17,18 Using sPMCA, we showed that infectious PrP^Sc molecules could be formed from immunopurified PrP^C, co-purified lipid and synthetic RNA molecules. Moreover, even unseeded reactions containing these defined components were capable of generating prions with high specific infectivity in a prion-free environment, showing for the first time that wild type infectious prions could be produced de novo.⁷Additional studies in this purified system showed that PrP^C molecules undergo a time-dependent conformational change upon interaction with RNA. When this change occurs, PrP^C adopts an intermediate conformation that mimics some of the characteristics of PrP^Sc, such as detergent insolubility and reactivity to PrP^Sc-specific antibodies, but remains sensitive to proteinase K digestion.⁸ When incubated with a heterogeneous size mixture of homopolymeric [³²P] poly(A) molecules during PMCA, hamster PrP^C molecules incorporated a specific size subset (1–2.5 kb) of the RNA molecules into nuclease-resistant complexes. The physical interaction between RNA and PrP^Sc was confirmed by fluorescence microscopy experiments showing that fluorescein-labeled RNA molecules became integrated into nuclease-resistant complexes with PrP^Sc molecules. Interestingly, neuropathologic analysis of scrapie-infected hamsters revealed that endogenous RNA molecules stained with acridine orange co-localized with large extracellular PrP aggregates.⁸ Taken together, these studies suggest that PrP interacts specifically with polyanionic molecules in vitro and in situ, and raised the possibility that polyanions might be a necessary component of infectious prions.Jeong et al. investigated whether endogenous RNA molecules might be required for prion infectivity by treating scrapie brain homogenates with LiAlH4 (lithium aluminum hydride), a strong reducing agent that can cleave the phosphodiester bond in RNA molecules.¹⁹ Interestingly, treatment of hamster scrapie brain homogenates with LiAlH₄ caused an ∼3-fold increase in scrapie incubation period measured by bioassay, suggesting that RNA may be an important component of infectious prions and therefore may play a role in stabilizing PrP^Sc structure. However, LiAlH₄ is not a specific reagent, and can damage a variety of other macromolecules, including proteins. Therefore, the decrease in infectivity measured in this study cannot be specifically ascribed to degradation of the polyanion.¹⁹We recently reinvestigated the potential role of polyanion in maintaining prion infectivity by using a more targeted approach.²⁰ Specifically, we utilized a synthetic oligonucleotide that could be selectively hydrolyzed by treatment with ultraviolet (UV) light. The photocleavable oligonucleotide was synthesized by inserting a photocleavable linker in between every fives bases of a poly(dT) 100-mer. Exposure to UV light quantitatively converted the oligonucleotide into five base fragments. During incubation with excess recombinant PrP, the photocleavable oligonucleotide became incorporated into a nuclease-resistant nucleoprotein complex, but remained sensitive to photocleavage. This novel system allowed us to study the role of a polyanion molecule incorporated into infectious prions in situ (Fig. 1).Open in a separate windowFigure 1Selective photodegradation of an incorporated polyanion in situ.We used PMCA to create PrP^Sc molecules that contained either the photocleavable oligonucleotide or a non-photocleavable control analog. After treatment with UV light, the infectivity of each sample was measured using a combination of end-point dilution sPMCA and animal bioassays. The end-point dilution PMCA assay showed a ∼1 log decrease in the seeding ability of PrP^Sc samples treated with UV light, but this effect was not specific since a similar decrease was measured in samples containing the control nucleic acid. In the bioassay, there was no change in the incubation periods of animals inoculated with PrP^Sc samples treated either in the presence or absence of UV light. Neuropathological analysis of inoculated animals also showed no differences in neurotropism between the two groups. Degradation of the nucleic acid had no effect on the molecular migration or structural stability of PrP^Sc samples as determined by SDS-PAGE and urea denaturation assays, respectively. There were also no differences in the molecular migration or glycosylation profile of the PrP^Sc molecules produced in the brains of animals inoculated with light- versus mock-treated inocula, and urea denaturation assays showed no differences in PrP^Sc stability. These results collectively demonstrate that the presence of intact polyanion molecules is not required to maintain the infectious, biochemical or strain properties prions generated in vitro.These results are consistent with the stringent “protein-only” hypothesis, but do not yet provide definitive proof. The purified PrP^C molecules used as substrate in these experiments contain a stoichiometric amount of co-purified lipid⁷ that may play a role in the generation of prion infectivity.⁹ Also, although the efficacy of photocleavage conditions was carefully confirmed in control reactions, it is possible that some intact oligonucleotide survived UV treatment at a level below detection. Alternatively, the remnant five base nucleic acid fragments may remain incorporated within the PrP^Sc molecule and play a role in maintaining the infectious conformation. Even in this scenario, our results would place a significant geometric constraint on the role of incorporated polyanion. While polyanions ≥40 bases facilitate the formation infectious prions in vitro,⁸ our results suggest that polyanions >5 bases are not necessary to maintain the infectious properties the prion. The exact role polyanions play in prion formation is still unclear, but it is tempting to speculate that they may serve as scaffolds that facilitate prion conversion by (a) bringing PrP^C and PrP^Sc seed together for templating to occur or (b) acting as a catalyst which is necessary to reduce the activation energy of refolding to the PrP^Sc form. Future studies will need to be performed to differentiate between these two hypotheses. It is also possible that polyanions are completely dispensable for maintaining PrP^Sc structure, and it is the co-purified lipid molecules that serve this role instead. Consistent with this possibility, we recently discovered that mouse PrP^Sc can be serially propagated in vitro in the absence of nucleic acids.²¹ Finally, it is possible that either polyanions or lipids can function equally well as stabilizers of the infectious PrP^Sc conformation. More work is required to distinguish between these possibilities.Generating high levels of specific infectivity solely using purified recombinant PrP remains the ultimate proof of the “protein-only” hypothesis. To date, evidence suggests that cellular cofactors are necessary to create infectious prions but may or may not be required to maintain infectivity once formed. Significantly, Wang et al. showed that bona fide prions could be formed from recombinant PrP, synthetic lipid and RNA molecules.⁹ Although no completely pure preparations of misfolded PrP possessing significant levels of specific infectivity have yet been produced, it should eventually be possible to produce such a preparation if the “protein-only” hypothesis is correct. On the other hand, a rigorous refutation of the hypothesis would require demonstrating that PrP^Sc and infectivity can be dissociated.     

Post‐translational changes to PrP alter transmissible spongiform encephalopathy strain properties

The agents responsible for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs), or prion diseases, contain as a major component PrP^Sc, an abnormal conformer of the host glycoprotein PrP^C. TSE agents are distinguished by differences in phenotypic properties in the host, which nevertheless can contain PrP^Sc with the same amino‐acid sequence. If PrP alone carries information defining strain properties, these must be encoded by post‐translational events. Here we investigated whether the glycosylation status of host PrP affects TSE strain characteristics. We inoculated wild‐type mice with three TSE strains passaged through transgenic mice with PrP devoid of glycans at the first, second or both N‐glycosylation sites. We compared the infectious properties of the emerging isolates with TSE strains passaged in wild‐type mice by in vivo strain typing and by the standard scrapie cell assay in vitro. Strain‐specific characteristics of the 79A TSE strain changed when PrP^Sc was devoid of one or both glycans. Thus infectious properties of a TSE strain can be altered by post‐translational changes to PrP which we propose result in the selection of mutant TSE strains.     

Prion Protein—Antibody Complexes Characterized by Chromatography-Coupled Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering

Aberrant self-assembly, induced by structural misfolding of the prion proteins, leads to a number of neurodegenerative disorders. In particular, misfolding of the mostly α-helical cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into a β-sheet-rich disease-causing isoform (PrP^Sc) is the key molecular event in the formation of PrP^Sc aggregates. The molecular mechanisms underlying the PrP^C-to-PrP^Sc conversion and subsequent aggregation remain to be elucidated. However, in persistently prion-infected cell-culture models, it was shown that treatment with monoclonal antibodies against defined regions of the prion protein (PrP) led to the clearing of PrP^Sc in cultured cells. To gain more insight into this process, we characterized PrP-antibody complexes in solution using a fast protein liquid chromatography coupled with small-angle x-ray scattering (FPLC-SAXS) procedure. High-quality SAXS data were collected for full-length recombinant mouse PrP [denoted recPrP(23–230)] and N-terminally truncated recPrP(89–230), as well as their complexes with each of two Fab fragments (HuM-P and HuM-R1), which recognize N- and C-terminal epitopes of PrP, respectively. In-line measurements by fast protein liquid chromatography coupled with SAXS minimized data artifacts caused by a non-monodispersed sample, allowing structural analysis of PrP alone and in complex with Fab antibodies. The resulting structural models suggest two mechanisms for how these Fabs may prevent the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc.     

Structural Insights into Alternate Aggregated Prion Protein Forms

The conversion of the cellular form of the prion protein (PrP^C) to an abnormal, alternatively folded isoform (PrP^Sc) is the central event in prion diseases or transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. Recent studies have demonstrated de novo generation of murine prions from recombinant prion protein (recPrP) after inoculation into transgenic and wild-type mice. These so-called synthetic prions lead to novel prion diseases with unique neuropathological and biochemical features. Moreover, the use of recPrP in an amyloid seeding assay can specifically detect and amplify various strains of prions. We employed this assay in our experiments and analyzed in detail the morphology of aggregate structures produced under defined chemical constraints. Our results suggest that changes in the concentration of guanidine hydrochloride can lead to different kinetic traces in a typical thioflavin T(ThT) assay. Morphological and structural analysis of these aggregates by atomic force microscopy indicates a variation in the structure of the PrP molecular assemblies.In particular, ThT positive PrP aggregates produced from rec mouse PrP residues 89 to 230 lead to mostly oligomeric structures at low concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride, while more amyloidal structures were observed at higher concentrations of the denaturant. These findings highlight the presence of numerous and complex pathways in deciphering prion constraints for infectivity and toxicity.     

Parallel In-register Intermolecular β-Sheet Architectures for Prion-seeded Prion Protein (PrP) Amyloids

Structures of the infectious form of prion protein (e.g. PrP^Sc or PrP-Scrapie) remain poorly defined. The prevalent structural models of PrP^Sc retain most of the native α-helices of the normal, noninfectious prion protein, cellular prion protein (PrP^C), but evidence is accumulating that these helices are absent in PrP^Sc amyloid. Moreover, recombinant PrP^C can form amyloid fibrils in vitro that have parallel in-register intermolecular β-sheet architectures in the domains originally occupied by helices 2 and 3. Here, we provide solid-state NMR evidence that the latter is also true of initially prion-seeded recombinant PrP amyloids formed in the absence of denaturants. These results, in the context of a primarily β-sheet structure, led us to build detailed models of PrP amyloid based on parallel in-register architectures, fibrillar shapes and dimensions, and other available experimentally derived conformational constraints. Molecular dynamics simulations of PrP(90–231) octameric segments suggested that such linear fibrils, which are consistent with many features of PrP^Sc fibrils, can have stable parallel in-register β-sheet cores. These simulations revealed that the C-terminal residues ∼124–227 more readily adopt stable tightly packed structures than the N-terminal residues ∼90–123 in the absence of cofactors. Variations in the placement of turns and loops that link the β-sheets could give rise to distinct prion strains capable of faithful template-driven propagation. Moreover, our modeling suggests that single PrP monomers can comprise the entire cross-section of fibrils that have previously been assumed to be pairs of laterally associated protofilaments. Together, these insights provide a new basis for deciphering mammalian prion structures.     

In Vivo Generation of Neurotoxic Prion Protein: Role for Hsp70 in Accumulation of Misfolded Isoforms

Prion diseases are incurable neurodegenerative disorders in which the normal cellular prion protein (PrP^C) converts into a misfolded isoform (PrP^Sc) with unique biochemical and structural properties that correlate with disease. In humans, prion disorders, such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, present typically with a sporadic origin, where unknown mechanisms lead to the spontaneous misfolding and deposition of wild type PrP. To shed light on how wild-type PrP undergoes conformational changes and which are the cellular components involved in this process, we analyzed the dynamics of wild-type PrP from hamster in transgenic flies. In young flies, PrP demonstrates properties of the benign PrP^C; in older flies, PrP misfolds, acquires biochemical and structural properties of PrP^Sc, and induces spongiform degeneration of brain neurons. Aged flies accumulate insoluble PrP that resists high concentrations of denaturing agents and contains PrP^Sc-specific conformational epitopes. In contrast to PrP^Sc from mammals, PrP is proteinase-sensitive in flies. Thus, wild-type PrP rapidly converts in vivo into a neurotoxic, protease-sensitive isoform distinct from prototypical PrP^Sc. Next, we investigated the role of molecular chaperones in PrP misfolding in vivo. Remarkably, Hsp70 prevents the accumulation of PrP^Sc-like conformers and protects against PrP-dependent neurodegeneration. This protective activity involves the direct interaction between Hsp70 and PrP, which may occur in active membrane microdomains such as lipid rafts, where we detected Hsp70. These results highlight the ability of wild-type PrP to spontaneously convert in vivo into a protease-sensitive isoform that is neurotoxic, supporting the idea that protease-resistant PrP^Sc is not required for pathology. Moreover, we identify a new role for Hsp70 in the accumulation of misfolded PrP. Overall, we provide new insight into the mechanisms of spontaneous accumulation of neurotoxic PrP and uncover the potential therapeutic role of Hsp70 in treating these devastating disorders.