Survival of biological cells deformed in a narrow gap

Recent studies show that during slow freezing of biological cells, the cells may be also injured by not only chemical damage but also mechanical damage induced by ice crystal compression. A new experimental procedure is developed to quantify cell destruction by deformation with two parallel surfaces. The viability of cells (prostatic carcinoma cells, 17.5 microns in mean diameter) is measured as a function of gap size ranging from 3.5 microns to 16.2 microns at 0 degree C, 23 degrees C and 37 degrees C. The viability at a smaller gap size is significantly lower at 37 degrees C than at 23 degrees C, while the difference between 0 degree C and 23 degrees C is much smaller. This suggests that deformation damage is related to the deformation of the cytoskeleton rather than the mechanical properties of the lipid membrane.     

Upregulation and protein trafficking of aquaporin-2 attenuate cold-induced osmotic damage during cryopreservation

Aquaporins (AQPs) are a recently discovered family of proteins that function as transmembrane water channels. These proteins regulate the delicate osmotic balance across the cell plasma membrane. Given that osmotic damage is the major contributing factor to cell death during freezing, we hypothesized that regulation of AQPs may have an unrealized role in protecting cells from osmotic damage during cryopreservation. Rat kidney inner medullar collecting duct (IMCD) cells were treated with arginine vasopressin (AVP) to increase the amount of AQP2 in the external plasma membrane before freezing in University of Wisconsin solution at -4 degrees C for 24 h. This resulted in a significant increase in cell viability on warming. Conversely, treatment of IMCD cells with AVP and W7 (which inhibits AQP2 protein trafficking to the plasma membrane) before freezing resulted in a 55% decrease in cell viability. These preliminary data indicate that regulation of AQP2 can attenuate cold-induced osmotic damage in rat kidney IMCD cells.     

Do physical forces contribute to cryodamage?

To achieve the ultimate goal of both cryosurgery and cryopreservation, a thorough understanding of the processes responsible for cell and tissue damage is desired. The general belief is that cells are damaged primarily due to osmotic effects at slow cooling rates and intracellular ice formation at high cooling rates, together termed the “two factor theory.” The present study deals with a third, largely ignored component—mechanical damage. Using pooled bull sperm cells as a model and directional freezing in large volumes, samples were frozen in the presence or absence of glass balls of three different diameters: 70–110, 250–500, and 1,000–1,250 µm, as a means of altering the surface area with which the cells come in contact. Post‐thaw evaluation included motility at 0 h and after 3 h at 37°C, viability, acrosome integrity, and hypoosmotic swelling test. Interactions among glass balls, sperm cells, and ice crystals were observed by directional freezing cryomicroscopy. Intra‐container pressure in relation to volume was also evaluated. The series of studies presented here indicate that the higher the surface area with which the cells come in contact, the greater the damage, possibly because the cells are squeezed between the ice crystals and the surface. We further demonstrate that with a decrease in volume, and thus increase in surface area‐to‐volume ratio, the intra‐container pressure during freezing increases. It is suggested that large volume freezing, given that heat dissipation is solved, will inflict less cryodamage to the cells than the current practice of small volume freezing. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 719–728 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The cryoprotective effect of antifreeze glycopeptides from antarctic fishes.

Apparently vitrified cells and tissues often fail to survive, probably from damage from growth of microscopically invisible ice crystals. Special biological antifreezes from some polar fishes have been shown to adsorb to specific faces of ice crystals and inhibit crystal growth. Vitrification in the presence of antifreezes therefore may help enhance postvitrification viability of cells and tissues. We report here that the addition of fish antifreeze glycopeptides (AFGPs) to vitrifying solutions increases post-thaw viability in cultured immature pig oocytes and two-cell stage embryos of mice and pigs after rapid cooling to cryogenic temperatures. The criterion for viability is maturation to metaphase for the oocytes and the ability to develop into the four-cell stage for the pig embryo and the blastocyst stage for the mouse embryo. Without AFGPs, or with addition of antifreeze peptides (AFPs), the particular vitrifying solution and cooling/warming/culturing regime used in this study produced zero viability. In the presence of the AFGPs (40 mg/ml), survival of pig oocytes and embryos was increased to about 25%, and that of mouse embryos to 82%. Dose-response studies for the mouse embryos showed that the protective effect of AFGPs shows saturation kinetics and levels off at 20 mg/ml. The AFGPs appeared to preserve cell membrane structural integrity; however, an intact cell membrane did not always lead to viability. The absence of protective effect by AFPs suggests that protection by the AFGPs is unrelated to their common antifreeze property, i.e., inhibition of ice crystal growth, but probably results from interaction with and stabilization of the cell membranes unique to the AFGPs.     

Intracellular freezing and survival in the freeze tolerant alpine cockroach Celatoblatta quinquemaculata

The alpine cockroach Celatoblatta quinquemaculata is common at altitudes of around 1500 m on the Rock and Pillar range of Central Otago, New Zealand where it experiences freezing conditions in the winter. The cockroach is freeze tolerant, but only to c. -9 degrees C. The cause of death at temperatures below this is unknown but likely to be due to osmotic damage to cells (shrinkage). This study compared the effect of different ice nucleation temperatures (-2 and -4 degrees C) on the viability of three types of cockroach tissue (midgut, Malpighian tubules and fat body cells) and cooling to three different temperatures (-5, -8, -12 degrees C). Two types of observations were made (i) cryomicroscope observations of ice formation and cell shrinkage (ii) cell integrity (viability) using vital stains. Cell viability decreased with lower treatment temperatures but ice nucleation temperature had no significant effect. Cryomicroscope observations showed that ice spread through tissue faster at -4 than -2 degrees C and that intracellular freezing only occurred when nucleated at -4 degrees C. From temperature records during cooling, it was observed that when freezing occurred, latent heat immediately increased the insect's body temperature close to its melting point (c. -0.3 degrees C). This "rebound" temperature was independent of nucleation temperature. Some tissues were more vulnerable to damage than others. As the gut is thought to be the site of freezing, it is significant that this tissue was the most robust. The ecological importance of the effect of nucleation temperature on survival of whole animals under field conditions is discussed.     

Contribution of extracellular ice formation and the solution effects to the freezing injury of PC-3 cells suspended in NaCl solutions

The mechanism of cell injury during slow freezing was examined using PC-3 human prostate adenocarcinoma cells suspended in NaCl solutions. The objective was to evaluate contribution of extracellular ice and the 'solution effects' to freezing injury separately. The solution effects that designate the influence of elevated concentration were evaluated from a pseudo-freezing experiment, where cells were subjected to the milieu that simulated a freeze-thaw process by changing the NaCl concentration and the temperature at the same time. The effect of extracellular ice formation on cell injury was then estimated from the difference in cell survival between the pseudo-freezing experiment and a corresponding freezing experiment. When cells were frozen to a relatively higher freezing temperature at -10 degrees C, about 30% of cells were damaged mostly due to extracellular ice formation, because the concentration increase without ice formation to 2.5-M NaCl, i.e., the equilibrium concentration at -10 degrees C, had no effect on cell survival. In contrast, in the case of the lower freezing temperature at -20 degrees C, about 90% of cells were injured by both effects, particularly 60-80% by the solution effects among them. The present results suggested that the solution effects become more crucial to cell damage during slow freezing at lower temperatures, while the effect of ice is limited to some extent.     

Factors contributing to inactivation of isolated thylakoid membranes during freezing in the presence of variable amounts of glucose and NaCl.

During freezing of isolated spinach thylakoids in sugar/salt solutions, the two solutes affected membrane survival in opposite ways: membrane damage due to increased electrolyte concentration can be prevented by sugar. Calculation of the final concentrations of NaCl or glucose reached in the residual unfrozen portion of the system revealed that the effects of the solutes on membrane activity can be explained in part by colligative action. In addition, the fraction of the residual liquid in the frozen system contributes to membrane injury. During severe freezing in the presence of very low initial solute concentrations, membrane damage drastically increased with a decrease in the volume of the unfrozen solution. Freezing injury under these conditions is likely to be due to mechanical damage by the ice crystals that occupy a very high fraction of the frozen system. At higher starting concentrations of sugar plus salt, membrane damage increased with an increase in the amount of the residual unfrozen liquid. Thylakoid inactivation at these higher initial solute concentrations can be largely attributed to dilution of the membrane fraction, as freezing damage at a given sugar/salt ratio decreased with increasing the thylakoid concentration in the sample. Moreover, membrane survival in the absence of freezing decreased with lowering the temperature, indicating that the temperature affected membrane damage not only via alterations related to the ice formation. From the data it was evident that damage of thylakoid membranes was determined by various individual factors, such as the amount of ice formed, the final concentrations of solutes and membranes in the residual unfrozen solution, the final volume of this fraction, the temperature and the freezing time. The relative contribution of these factors depended on the experimental conditions, mainly the sugar/salt ratio, the initial solute concentrations, and the freezing temperature.     

Drug metabolism and viability studies in cryopreserved rat hepatocytes

Rat hepatocytes were cryopreserved optimally by freezing them at 1 degrees C/min to -80 degrees C in cryoprotectant medium containing either 20% (v/v) dimethylsulfoxide (Me2SO) and 25% (v/v) fetal calf serum in Leibowitz L15 medium (Me2SO cryoprotectant) or 25% (v/v) vitrification solution (containing Me2SO, acetamide, propylene glycol and polyethylene glycol) in Leibowitz L15 medium (VS25). The VS25 solution was superior for maintaining viability during short-term storage (24-48 hr) but was slightly toxic during longer storage periods (7 days). Although thawed cells were 40-50% viable on ice after cryopreservation, their viability fell rapidly during incubation in suspension at 37 degrees C. This decline in viability occurred more rapidly after freezing in Me2SO cryoprotectant than in VS25 and was associated with extensive intracellular damage and cell swelling. The loss in viability at 37 degrees C does not appear to be due to ice-crystal damage as it occurred in cells stored at -10 degrees C (above the freezing point of the cryoprotectants) and it may be due to temperature/osmotic shock. Both cryoprotectant media were equally efficient at preserving enzyme activities in the hepatocytes over 7 days at -80 degrees C. Cytochrome P450 and reduced glutathione content and the activities of the microsomal enzymes responsible for aminopyrine N-demethylation and epoxide hydrolysis were well maintained over 7 days storage. In contrast, the cytosolic enzymes glutathione-S-transferase and glutathione reductase were markedly labile during cryopreservation. Cytosolic enzymes may be more susceptible to ice-crystal damage, whereas the microsomal membrane may protect the enzymes which are embedded in it.     

Stabilization of frozen Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus in glycerol suspensions: Freezing kinetics and storage temperature effects

The interactions between freezing kinetics and subsequent storage temperatures and their effects on the biological activity of lactic acid bacteria have not been examined in studies to date. This paper investigates the effects of three freezing protocols and two storage temperatures on the viability and acidification activity of Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus CFL1 in the presence of glycerol. Samples were examined at -196 degrees C and -20 degrees C by freeze fracture and freeze substitution electron microscopy. Differential scanning calorimetry was used to measure proportions of ice and glass transition temperatures for each freezing condition tested. Following storage at low temperatures (-196 degrees C and -80 degrees C), the viability and acidification activity of L. delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus decreased after freezing and were strongly dependent on freezing kinetics. High cooling rates obtained by direct immersion in liquid nitrogen resulted in the minimum loss of acidification activity and viability. The amount of ice formed in the freeze-concentrated matrix was determined by the freezing protocol, but no intracellular ice was observed in cells suspended in glycerol at any cooling rate. For samples stored at -20 degrees C, the maximum loss of viability and acidification activity was observed with rapidly cooled cells. By scanning electron microscopy, these cells were not observed to contain intracellular ice, and they were observed to be plasmolyzed. It is suggested that the cell damage which occurs in rapidly cooled cells during storage at high subzero temperatures is caused by an osmotic imbalance during warming, not the formation of intracellular ice.     

Experimental study of intracellular ice growth in human umbilical vein endothelial cells

Study of the intracellular ice formation (IIF) and growth is essential to the mechanistic understanding of cellular damage through freezing. In the aid of high speed and high resolution cryo-imaging technology, the transient intracellular ice formation and growth processes of the attached human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) were successfully captured during freezing. It was found that the intracellular ice nucleation site was on the cell membrane closer to the nucleus. The ice growth was directional and toward the nucleus, which covered the whole nucleus before growing into the cytoplasm. The crystal growth rate in the nucleus was much larger than that in the cytoplasm, and its morphology was influenced by the cooling rate. During the thawing process, small crystals fused into larger ones inside the nucleus. Moreover, the cumulative fraction of the HUVEC with IIF was mainly dependent on the cooling rate not the confluence of the cells attached.     

Escherichia coli viability in an isochoric system at subfreezing temperatures

In comparison with isobaric (constant pressure) freezing, isochoric (constant volume) freezing reduces potential mechanical damage from ice crystals and exposes stored biological matter to a lower extracellular concentration, at the price of increased hydrostatic pressure. This study evaluates the effects of isochoric freezing to low temperatures and high pressures on Escherichia coli (E. coli) survival. The viability of E. coli was examined after freezing to final temperatures between −5 °C and −20 °C for periods from 0.5 h to 12 h, with recovery periods from 0 h to 24 h. Freezing for up to two hours to −10 °C and −15 °C had little effect on the percentage of viable E. coli, relative to the controls. However, after two hours of exposure at −20 °C, when left to recover for 24 h, a 75% reduction in survival is observed. Furthermore, after 12 h of isochoric freezing at −15 °C and −20 °C, E. coli population is reduced by 2.5 logs while freezing to these temperatures in conventional isobaric atmospheric conditions reduces population by only one log. This suggests that the combination of low temperature and high pressure experienced during isochoric freezing close to the triple point may be more detrimental to biological matter survival than the combination of elevated concentration, low temperature, and ice crystallization experienced during conventional freezing, and that this effect may be related to the time of exposure to these conditions.     

Cryoprotection and banking of living cells in a 3D multiple emulsion‐based carrier

The ability to preserve stem cells/cells with minimal damage for short and long periods of time is essential for advancements in biomedical therapies and biotechnology. New methods of cell banking are continuously needed to provide effective damage prevention to cells. This paper puts forward a solution to the problem of the low viability of cells during cryopreservation in a traditional suspension and storage by developing innovative multiple emulsion‐based carriers for the encapsulation and cryopreservation of cells. During freezing‐thawing processes, irreversible damage to cells occurs as a result of the formation of ice crystals, cell dehydration, and the toxicity of cryoprotectant. The proposed method was effective due to the “flexible” protective structure of multiple emulsions, which was proven by a high cell survival rate, above 90%. Results make new contributions in the fields of cell engineering and biotechnology and contribute to the development of methods for banking biological material.     

Cell-cell contact affects membrane integrity after intracellular freezing

The response of cells to freezing depends critically on the presence of an intact cell membrane. During rapid cooling, the cell plasma membrane may no longer be an effective barrier to ice propagation and can be breached by extracellular ice resulting in the nucleation of the supercooled cytoplasm. In tissues, the formation of intracellular ice is compounded by the presence of cell-cell and cell-surface interactions. Three different hamster fibroblast model systems were used to simulate structures found in organized tissues. Samples were supercooled to an experimental temperature on a cryostage and ice nucleated at the constant temperature. A dual fluorescent staining technique was used for the quantitative assessment of the integrity of the cell plasma membrane. A novel technique using the fluorescent stain SYTO was used for the detection of intracellular ice formation (IIF) in cell monolayers. The cumulative incidence of cells with a loss of membrane integrity and the cumulative incidence of IIF were determined as a function of temperature. Cells in suspension and individual attached cells showed no significant difference in the number of cells that formed intracellular ice and those that lost membrane integrity. For cells in a monolayer, with cell-cell contact, intracellular ice formation did not result in the immediate disruption of the plasma membrane in the majority of cells. This introduces the potential for minimizing damage due to IIF and for developing strategies for the cryoprotection of tissues during rapid cooling.     

Freeze-fracture and etching studies on membrane damage on human erythrocytes caused by formation of intracellular ice

The present study examined the damaging effect of intracellular ice on plasma membranes of human erythrocytes. Ice crystals of 0.2–2.0 μm in diameter were formed within the cells as the result of rapid freezing of erythrocytes at the cooling rates around 8000 °C/min. Freeze-fracture and etching studies revealed the ultrastructural alterations of membranes caused by the formation of intracellular ice.In the membrane regions which were in direct contact with intracellular ice, depressions resembling “worm-eaten spots” ranging from 400 to 3000 Å in diameter were observed both on the etched protoplasmic fracture faces (PF) and the exoplasmic surfaces (ES); no perforations were detected in the worm-eaten spots as visualized by slight etching, but artificial destructions occurred on these worm-eaten spots following the increase of etching. The most important phenomenon concerning membrane damage was that in the worm-eaten spots the fracture did not occur along the inner hydrophobic plane of membrane.It was suggested that the formation of intracellular ice in direct contact with a membrane brought about molecular disorganization of bilayer membrane. The presence of these altered membrane regions seems to be responsible for the postthawed hemolysis of the intracellularly frozen erythrocytes.     

Cooling rate dependent biophysical and viability response shift with attachment state in human dermal fibroblast cells

While studies on the freezing of cells in suspension have been carried out extensively, corresponding studies with cells in the attached state and in tissue or tissue-equivalents are less developed. As attachment is a hallmark of the tissue state it is important to understand its impact on biophysics and viability to better apply freezing towards tissue preservation. The current study reports on observed biophysical response changes observed during freezing human dermal fibroblasts in suspension, attached cell, and fibrin tissue-equivalent models. Specifically, intracellular ice formation is shown to increase and dehydration is inferred to increase from suspension to attached systems. Biophysical model parameters fit to these experimental observations reflect the higher kinetics in the attached state. Post-thaw viability values from fast cooling rates were higher for suspension systems, and correlated well with the amount of IIF observed. On the other hand, viability values from slow cooling rates were higher for attached systems, although the degree of dehydration was predicted to be comparable to suspension cells. This disconnect between biophysics and viability predictions at slow rates clearly requires further investigation as it runs counter to our current understanding of dehydration injury in cells. This may suggest a possible protective effect of the attachment state on cell systems.     

Cooling rate dependent biophysical and viability response shift with attachment state in human dermal fibroblast cells

While studies on the freezing of cells in suspension have been carried out extensively, corresponding studies with cells in the attached state and in tissue or tissue-equivalents are less developed. As attachment is a hallmark of the tissue state it is important to understand its impact on biophysics and viability to better apply freezing towards tissue preservation. The current study reports on observed biophysical response changes observed during freezing human dermal fibroblasts in suspension, attached cell, and fibrin tissue-equivalent models. Specifically, intracellular ice formation is shown to increase and dehydration is inferred to increase from suspension to attached systems. Biophysical model parameters fit to these experimental observations reflect the higher kinetics in the attached state. Post-thaw viability values from fast cooling rates were higher for suspension systems, and correlated well with the amount of IIF observed. On the other hand, viability values from slow cooling rates were higher for attached systems, although the degree of dehydration was predicted to be comparable to suspension cells. This disconnect between biophysics and viability predictions at slow rates clearly requires further investigation as it runs counter to our current understanding of dehydration injury in cells. This may suggest a possible protective effect of the attachment state on cell systems.     

A theoretical model of intracellular devitrification

Devitrification of the intracellular solution can cause significant damage during warming of cells cryopreserved by freezing or vitrification. Whereas previous theoretical investigations of devitrification have not considered the effect of cell dehydration on intracellular ice formation, a new model which couples membrane-limited water transport equations, classical nucleation theory, and diffusion-limited crystal growth theory is presented. The model was used to explore the role of cell dehydration in devitrification of human keratinocytes frozen in the presence of glycerol. Numerical simulations demonstrated that water transport during cooling affects subsequent intracellular ice formation during warming, correctly predicting observations that critical warming rate increases with increasing cooling rate. However, for cells with a membrane transport activation energy less than approximately 50 kJ/mol, devitrification was also affected by cell dehydration during warming, leading to a reversal of the relationship between cooling rate and critical warming rate. Thus, for low warming rates (less than 10 degrees C/min for keratinocytes), the size and total volume fraction of intracellular ice crystals forming during warming decreased with decreasing warming rate, and the critical warming rate decreased with increasing cooling rate. The effects of water transport on the kinetics of intracellular nucleation and crystal growth were elucidated by comparison of simulations of cell warming with simulations of devitrification in H(2)O-NaCl-glycerol droplets of constant size and composition. These studies showed that the rate of intracellular nucleation was less sensitive to cell dehydration than was the crystal growth rate. The theoretical methods presented may be of use for the design and optimization of freeze-thaw protocols.     

Nucleation and growth of ice crystals inside cultured hepatocytes during freezing in the presence of dimethyl sulfoxide.

A three-part, coupled model of cell dehydration, nucleation, and crystal growth was used to study intracellular ice formation (IIF) in cultured hepatocytes frozen in the presence of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Heterogeneous nucleation temperatures were predicted as a function of DMSO concentration and were in good agreement with experimental data. Simulated freezing protocols correctly predicted and explained experimentally observed effects of cooling rate, warming rate, and storage temperature on hepatocyte function. For cells cooled to -40 degrees C, no IIF occurred for cooling rates less than 10 degrees C/min. IIF did occur at faster cooling rates, and the predicted volume of intracellular ice increased with increasing cooling rate. Cells cooled at 5 degrees C/min to -80 degrees C were shown to undergo nucleation at -46.8 degrees C, with the consequence that storage temperatures above this value resulted in high viability independent of warming rate, whereas colder storage temperatures resulted in cell injury for slow warming rates. Cell damage correlated positively with predicted intracellular ice volume, and an upper limit for the critical ice content was estimated to be 3.7% of the isotonic water content. The power of the model was limited by difficulties in estimating the cytosol viscosity and membrane permeability as functions of DMSO concentration at low temperatures.     

Wheat tissues freeze-etched during exposure to extracellular freezing: distribution of ice

Pieces excised from leaf bases and laminae of seedlings of Triticum aestivum L. cv. Lennox were slowly frozen, using a specially designed apparatus, to temperatures between 2° and 14° C. These treatments ranged from non-damaging to damaging, based on ion-leakage tests to be found in the accompanying report (Pearce and Willison 1985, Planta 163, 304–316). The frozen tissue pieces were then freeze-fixed by rapidly cooling them, via melting Freon, to liquid-nitrogen temperature. The tissue was subsequently prepared for electron microscopy by freeze-etching. Ice crystals formed during slow freezing would tend to be much larger than those formed during subsequent freeze-fixation. Ice crystals surrounding the excised tissues were much larger in the frozen than in the control tissues (the latter rapidly freeze-fixed from room temperature). Large ice crystals were present between cells of frozen laminae and absent from controls. Intercellular spaces were infrequent in control leaf bases and no ice-filled intercellular spaces were found in frozen leaf bases. Intracellular ice crystals were smaller in frozen tissues than in controls. It is concluded that all ice formation before freeze-fixation was extracellular. This extracellular ice was either only extra-tissue (leaf bases), or extra-tissue and intercellular (laminae). Periplasmic ice was sometimes present, in control as well as slowly frozen tissues, and the crystals were always small; thus they were probably formed during freeze-fixation rather than during slow freezing. The plasma membrane sometimes showed imprints of cell-wall microfibrils. These were less abundant in leaf bases at 8° C than in controls, and were present on only a minority of plasma membranes from laminae. Therefore, extracellular ice probably did not compress the cells substantially, and changes in cell size and shape were possibly primarily a result of freezing-induced dehydration. Fine-scale distortions (wrinkles) in the plasma membrane, while absent from controls, were present, although only rarely, in both damaged and non-damaged tissues; they were therefore ice-induced but not directly related to the process of damage.     

Mechanisms of intracellular ice formation.

The phenomenon of intracellular freezing in cells was investigated by designing experiments with cultured mouse fibroblasts on a cryomicroscope to critically assess the current hypotheses describing the genesis of intracellular ice: (a) intracellular freezing is a result of critical undercooling; (b) the cytoplasm is nucleated through aqueous pores in the plasma membrane; and (c) intracellular freezing is a result of membrane damage caused by electrical transients at the ice interface. The experimental data did not support any of these theories, but was consistent with the hypothesis that the plasma membrane is damaged at a critical gradient in osmotic pressure across the membrane, and intracellular freezing occurs as a result of this damage. An implication of this hypothesis is that mathematical models can be used to design protocols to avoid damaging gradients in osmotic pressure, allowing new approaches to the preservation of cells, tissues, and organs by rapid cooling.