The effect of the L-azetidine-2-carboxylic acid residue on protein conformation. III. Collagen-like poly(tripeptide)s

The chemical and biological properties of collagen are altered by the biosynthetic substitution of the L-azetidine-2-carboxylic acid(Aze) residue in the place of proline. The reasons for this alteration have been studied by means of conformational energy computations on single- and triple-stranded structures formed by poly(Gly-X-Y) poly(tripeptide)s, where X and Y can be Pro or Aze. The most stable triple helix formed by Poly(Gly-Pro-Aze) is collagen-like, but all low-energy triple helices that can be formed by poly(Gly-Aze-Pro) and poly(Gly-Aze-Aze) are very different from collagen. Thus, the regular substitution of Aze for Pro in position X is not compatible with the collagen structure. In the absence of solvent effects, all of these triple helices are stable, relative to the statistical coil, but the substitutions reduce the stability of the collagen-like triple helix, as compared with poly(Gly-Pro-Pro).     

Free energy of hydration of collagen models and the enthalpy of the transition between the triple-helical coiled-coil and single-stranded conformations

Interactions with water make an important contribution to the free energy of stabilization of the collagen triple helix, but they do not alter the structure of the triple helix, i.e., the packing geometry of the three strands. Conformational energy computations have been carried out on poly(tripeptide) analogues of collagen, with the introduction of a newly developed form of a hydration shell model to compute the free energy of hydration. The most stable triple helix formed by poly(Gly-Pro-Pro), obtained earlier from conformational energy computations [M. H. Miller & H. A. Scheraga (1976) J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Symp. 54, 171], with a structure that is very closely similar to the observed structure, is strongly favored over other three-strand complexes, both in the absence and the presence of hydration. The hydration shell model does not provide an explanation for the increased stability of the poly(Gly-Pro-Hyp) triple helix as compared to poly(Gly-Pro-Pro). It appears that the difference should be attributed to specific binding of water, and effect that is not yet included in the present version of the hydration shell model. On the other hand, this model accounts for the observed enthalpy of unfolding of a poly(Gly-Pro-Pro) triple helix to isolated single chains in solution in terms of intramolecular noncovalent interactions and the free energy of hydration.     

Collagen model peptides: Sequence dependence of triple-helix stability

The triple helix is a specialized protein motif, found in all collagens as well as in noncollagenous proteins involved in host defense. Peptides will adopt a triple-helical conformation if the sequence contains its characteristic features of Gly as every third residue and a high content of Pro and Hyp residues. Such model peptides have proved amenable to structural studies by x-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy, suitable for thermodynamic and kinetic analysis, and a valuable tool in characterizing the binding activities of the collagen triple helix. A systematic approach to understanding the amino acid sequence dependence of the collagen triple helix has been initiated, based on a set of host-guest peptides of the form, (Gly-Pro-Hyp)(3)-Gly-X-Y-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)(4). Comparison of their thermal stabilities has led to a propensity scale for the X and Y positions, and the additivity of contributions of individual residues is now under investigation. The local and global stability of the collagen triple helix is normally modulated by the residues in the X and Y positions, with every third position occupied by Gly in fibril-forming collagens. However, in collagen diseases, such as osteogenesis imperfecta, a single Gly may be substituted by another residue. Host-guest studies where the Gly is replaced by various amino acids suggest that the identity of the residue in the Gly position affects the degree of destabilization and the clinical severity of the disease.     

Role of proline …︁ proline interactions in the packing of collagenlike poly(tripeptide) triple helices

Conformational energy computations were carried out on the packing of two identical collagenlike poly(tripeptide) triple helices in order to determine the energetics of favorable packing arrangements as a function of composition and chain length. The triple helices considered were [CH₃CO-(Gly-Pro-Pro)_nt-NHCH₃]₃ and [CH₃CO-(Gly-Pro-Ala)_nt-NHCH₃]₃, with n_t = 3, 4, and 5. The packing arrangements were characterized in terms of their intermolecular energies and orientation angles Ω₀ of the axes of the two triple helices. For short triple helices (n_t = 3 or 4), many low-energy orientations, with a wide range of values of Ω₀, can occur. When the triple helices are longer (n_t = 5), the only low-energy packing arrangements of two poly(Gly-Pro-Pro) triple helices are those with a nearly parallel orientation of the two helix axes, with Ω₀ ≈ ?10°. This result accounts for the observed parallel (rather than antiparallel) arrangement of collagen molecules in microfibril assembly and stands in contrast to the preferred antiparallel arrangement of a pair of α-helices. Since the preference for a parallel arrangement of these collagenlike triple helices is less pronounced in the case of poly(Gly-Pro-Ala), it appears that this preference is a consequence of the frequent presence of imino acids in position Y of the Gly-X-Y repeating triplet. In poly(Gly-Pro-Ala), most of the low-energy packing arrangements are parallel, but a few arrangements with low energies and high values of |Ω₀| occur. These packing arrangements have a high energy, however, when Pro is substituted for Ala, and thus they are not accessible for collagen with natural amino (imino) acid sequences. The computations reported here account for some of the characteristic features of collagen packing in terms of the local interaction energies of a pair of triple helices.     

The effect of the L-azetidine-2-carboxylic acid residue on protein conformation. IV. Local substitutions in the collagen triple helix

The properties of collagen are affected by the replacement of Pro by imino acid analogues. The structural effect of the low-level local substitution of L -azetidine-2-carboxylic acid (Aze) has been analyzed by computing the energy of CH₃CO-(Gly-Pro-Pro)₄-NHCH₃ triple helices in which a single residue of one strand has been replaced by Aze. When Aze is in position Y of a (Gly-X-Y) unit, low-energy local deformations are introduced in the triple helix, i.e., it becomes more flexible. On the other hand, the flexibility of the triple helix is not increased with Aze in position X. The energy of the triple helix to coil transition is not changed significantly by this amount of substitution. In an earlier study, we have demonstrated that the regular substitution of Aze in every tripeptide distorts or destabilizes the triple helix to a large extent [A. Zagari, G. Némethy, & H. A. Scheraga (1990) Biopolymers, Vol. 30, pp. 967–974 ]. Thus, it appears that a high level of substitution is required to cause the observed chemical and biological effects of Aze on collagen. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Collagen-like triple helix formation of synthetic (Pro-Pro-Gly)10 analogues: (4(S)-hydroxyprolyl-4(R)-hydroxyprolyl-Gly)10, (4(R)-hydroxyprolyl-4(R)-hydroxyprolyl-Gly)10 and (4(S)-fluoroprolyl-4(R)-fluoroprolyl-Gly)10.

For the rational design of a stable collagen triple helix according to the conventional rule that the pyrrolidine puckerings of Pro, 4-hydroxyproline (Hyp) and 4-fluoroproline (fPro) should be down at the X-position and up at the Y-position in the X-Y-Gly repeated sequence for enhancing the triple helix propensities of collagen model peptides, a series of peptides were prepared in which X- and Y-positions were altogether occupied by Hyp(R), Hyp(S), fPro(R) or fPro(S). Contrary to our presumption that inducing the X-Y residues to adopt a down-up conformation would result in an increase in the thermal stability of peptides, the triple helices of (Hyp(S)-Hyp(R)-Gly)(10) and (fPro(S)-fPro(R)-Gly)(10) were less stable than those of (Pro-Hyp(R)-Gly)(10) and (Pro-fPro(R)-Gly)(10), respectively. As reported by B?chinger's and Zagari's groups, (Hyp(R)-Hyp(R)-Gly)(10) which could have an up-up conformation unfavorable for the triple helix, formed a triple helix that has a high thermal stability close to that of (Pro-Hyp(R)-Gly)(10). These results clearly show that the empirical rule based on the conformational preference of pyrrolidine ring at each of X and Y residues should not be regarded as still valid, at least for predicting the stability of collagen models in which both X and Y residues have electronegative groups at the 4-position.     

Stabilization of triple-helical structures of collagen peptides containing a Hyp-Thr-Gly, Hyp-Val-Gly, or Hyp-Ser-Gly sequence

The single-crystal structures of three collagen-like host-guest peptides, (Pro-Pro-Gly)(4) -Hyp-Yaa-Gly-(Pro-Pro-Gly)(4) [Yaa = Thr, Val, Ser; Hyp = (4R)-4-hydroxyproline] were analyzed at atomic resolution. These peptides adopted a 7/2-helical structure similar to that of the (Pro-Pro-Gly)(9) peptide. The stability of these triple helices showed a similar tendency to that observed in Ac-(Gly-Hyp-Yaa)(10) -NH(2) (Yaa = Thr, Val, Ser) peptides. On the basis of their detailed structures, the differences in the triple-helical stabilities of the peptides containing a Hyp-Thr-Gly, Hyp-Val-Gly, or Hyp-Ser-Gly sequence were explained in terms of van der Waals interactions and dipole-dipole interaction between the Hyp residue in the X position and the Yaa residue in the Y position involved in the Hyp(X):Yaa(Y) stacking pair. This idea also explains the inability of Ac-(Gly-Hyp-alloThr)(10) -NH(2) and Ac-(Gly-Hyp-Ala)(10) -NH(2) peptides to form triple helices. In the Hyp(X):Thr(Y), Hyp(X):Val(Y), and Hyp(X):Ser(Y) stacking pairs, the proline ring of the Hyp residues adopts an up-puckering conformation, in agreement with the residual preference of Hyp, but in disagreement with the positional preference of X in the Gly-Xaa-Yaa sequence.     

The triple helical structure and stability of collagen model peptide with 4(S)-hydroxyprolyl-Pro-Gly units

Extensive studies on the structure of collagen have revealed that the hydroxylation of Pro residues in a variety of model peptides with the typical (X-Y-Gly)(n) repeats (X and Y: Pro and its analogues) represents one of the major factors influencing the stability of triple helices. While(2S,4R)-hydroxyproline (Hyp) at the position Y stabilizes the triple helix, (2S,4S)-hydroxyproline (hyp) at the X-position destabilizes the helix as demonstrated that the triple helix of (hyp-Pro-Gly)(15) is less stable than that of (Pro-Pro-Gly)(15) and that a shorter peptide (hyp-Pro-Gly)(10) does not form the helix. To clarify the role of the hydroxyl group of Pro residues to play in the stabilization mechanism of the collagen triple helix, we synthesized and crystallized a model peptide (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(4) -(hyp-Pro-Gly)(2) -(Pro-Hyp-Gly)(4) and analyzed its structure by X-ray crystallography and CD spectroscopy. In the crystal, the main-chain of this peptide forms a typical collagen like triple helix. The majority of hyp residues take down pucker with exceptionally shallow angles probably to relieve steric hindrance, but the remainders protrude the hydroxyl group toward solvent with the less favorable up pucker to fit in a triple helix. There is no indication of the existence of an intra-molecular hydrogen bond between the hydroxyl moiety and the carbonyl oxygen of hyp supposed to destabilize the triple helix. We also compared the conformational energies of up and down packers of the pyrrolidine ring in Ac-hyp-NMe(2) by quantum mechanical calculations.     

Glycosylation/Hydroxylation-induced stabilization of the collagen triple helix. 4-trans-hydroxyproline in the Xaa position can stabilize the triple helix

We have shown recently that glycosylation of threonine in the peptide Ac-(Gly-Pro-Thr)(10)-NH(2) with beta-d-galactose induces the formation of a collagen triple helix, whereas the nonglycosylated peptide does not. In this report, we present evidence that a collagen triple helix can also be formed in the Ac-(Gly-Pro-Thr)(10)-NH(2) peptide, if the proline (Pro) in the Xaa position is replaced with 4-trans-hydroxyproline (Hyp). Furthermore, replacement of Pro with Hyp in the sequence Ac-(Gly-Pro-Thr(beta-d-Gal))(10)-NH(2) increases the T(m) of the triple helix by 15.7 degrees C. It is generally believed that Hyp in the Xaa position destabilizes the triple helix because (Pro-Pro-Gly)(10) and (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(10) form stable triple helices but the peptide (Hyp-Pro-Gly)(10) does not. Our data suggest that the destabilizing effect of Hyp relative to Pro in the Xaa position is only true in the case of (Hyp-Pro-Gly)(10). Increasing concentrations of galactose in the solvent stabilize the triple helix of Ac-(Gly-Hyp-Thr)(10)-NH(2) but to a much lesser extent than that achieved by covalently linked galactose. The data explain some of the forces governing the stability of the annelid/vestimentiferan cuticle collagens.     

Interstrand dipole-dipole interactions can stabilize the collagen triple helix

The amino acid sequence of collagen is composed of GlyXaaYaa repeats. A prevailing paradigm maintains that stable collagen triple helices form when (2S)-proline (Pro) or Pro derivatives that prefer the C(γ)-endo ring pucker are in the Xaa position and Pro derivatives that prefer the C(γ)-exo ring pucker are in the Yaa position. Anomalously, an amino acid sequence in an invertebrate collagen has (2S,4R)-4-hydroxyproline (Hyp), a C(γ)-exo-puckered Pro derivative, in the Xaa position. In certain contexts, triple helices with Hyp in the Xaa position are now known to be hyperstable. Most intriguingly, the sequence (GlyHypHyp)(n) forms a more stable triple helix than does the sequence (GlyProHyp)(n). Competing theories exist for the physicochemical basis of the hyperstability of (GlyHypHyp)(n) triple helices. By synthesizing and analyzing triple helices with different C(γ)-exo-puckered proline derivatives in the Xaa and Yaa positions, we conclude that interstrand dipole-dipole interactions are the primary determinant of their additional stability. These findings provide a new framework for understanding collagen stability.     

Synthesis of heterotrimeric collagen models containing Arg residues in Y-positions and analysis of their conformational stability

An Arg residue incorporated into the Y-position of collagenous host-guest peptide Ac-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)(3)-Gly-Pro-Y-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)(4)-Gly-Gly-NH(2) is reported to stabilize the triple helical structure as well as a 4(R)-hydroxyproline (Hyp) residue. Here, we synthesized heterotrimeric collagen models containing Arg in Y-positions utilizing the cystine knot strategy. Analysis of their thermal transition temperatures using circular dichroism spectrometry demonstrated unexpected decrease in the triple helical stability as the number of Arg increased. The obtained results indicated that an Arg residue in a Y-position is not always an equivalent of a Hyp residue, and that it possesses a potential helix destabilizing effect.     

Contribution of tertiary amides to the conformational stability of collagen triple helices

The collagen triple helix is composed of three polypeptide strands, each with a sequence of repeating (Xaa-Yaa-Gly) triplets. In these triplets, Xaa and Yaa are often tertiary amides: L-proline (Pro) and 4(R)-hydroxy-L-proline (Hyp). To determine the contribution of tertiary amides to triple-helical stability, Pro and Hyp were replaced in synthetic collagen mimics with a non-natural acyclic tertiary amide: N-methyl-L-alanine (meAla). Replacing a Pro or Hyp residue with meAla decreases triple-helical stability. Ramachandran analysis indicates that meAla residues prefer to adopt straight phi and psi angles that are dissimilar from those of the Pro and Hyp residues in the collagen triple helix. Replacement with meAla decreases triple-helical stability more than does replacement with Ala. All of the peptide bonds in triple-helical collagen are in the trans conformation. Although an Ala residue greatly prefers the trans conformation, a meAla residue exists as a nearly equimolar mixture of trans and cis conformers. These findings indicate that the favorable contribution of Pro and Hyp to the conformational stability of collagen triple helices arises from factors other than their being tertiary amides.     

The lattice energetics of some polypeptide chains

The interchain energetics of alpha, beta, and PGII conformations of polyglycine, the PPII and left-handed 3.30 fold helical conformations of trans poly-L -proline, and the Yonath and Traub triple helix and left-handed three fold helices of poly(gly-pro-pro) were investigated. Intra- and inter-chain stabilization energies appear to be inversely related, and the interchain stabilization energy can be as large its the intrachain energy. The minimization of the interchain energy can be described by the simultaneous optimization of interchain hydrogen bonding and intermolecular-sidechain digitation. The stability of the poly(gly-pro-pro) triple helix can be readily explained in terms of these two factors. In all cases the experimentally observed lattice packing is predicted, although the calculated lattice constants are slightly larger than those observed. The small differences between observed and predicted lattice constants probably reflect small errors in present conformational potential functions. Homopolymers are probably the best systems to use in the refinement of conformational potential functions because solvent effects arc minimized and the experimentally observed lattice constants provide a check on the configurational calculations.     

A triple-helical model for (Gly-Pro-Hyp)n with cis peptide units

Synthetic regular polytripeptides of the type (Gly-R₂-R₃) where R₂, R₃, or both, are imino acids have been widely studied as model compounds for collagen. One such polytripeptide is poly(Gly-Pro-Hyp), since triplets with this sequence constitute about 10% of collagen. Recently, a new model has been proposed for this polytripeptide in which one of the three peptide bonds in the tripeptide unit is in the cis conformation, and the γ-hydroxyl group of hydroxyproline forms a direct interchain hydrogen bond within the triple helix. We have confirmed this structure by model building using computer techniques, and the helical parameters obtained by us are close to the experimentally observed values. The model is also found to be comparable in stability with other models from energy considerations.     

The energy of formation of internal loops in triple-helical collagen polypeptides

The sequence-dependent local destabilization in the interior of the collagen triple helix has been evaluated by means of conformational energy computations. Using a model poly(Gly-Pro-Pro) triple helix as the reference state, a method was developed for generating local loops, i.e., internal deformations, and analyzing their conformations. A seven-residue Gly-Pro-Pro-Gly-Pro-Pro-Gly fragment was replaced by the Gly-Pro-Ala-Gly-Ala-Ala-Gly sequence in one, two, or all three of the strands of the loop region. A set of loop conformations was generated in which the ends of the loop were initially fixed in the triple-helical structure. The potential energy of the entire deformed triple helix was then minimized, resulting in a variety of structures that contained deformed loops. The conformations of the triple helices at the two ends of the loops remained essentially unchanged in many of the low-energy conformations. In numerous high-energy conformations, however, the triple-helical segments were also partially or totally disrupted. The minimum-energy conformations of the whole structures were compared in terms of rms deviations of atomic coordinates with respect to the original triple helix, and of the shapes of the loops (using a distance function derived from differential geometry). Three new geometrical parameters—stretch S, kink K, and unwinding U—were defined to describe the changes in the overall orientation of the triple helices at the two ends of the loop. It is shown that, when the number of Pro residues in a short fragment is reduced, the triple helical structure can accomodate internal loops (i.e., distortions) within a 5 kcal/mol cutoff from the essentially unperturbed triple helical structure. For structures with a Gly-Pro-Ala-Gly-Ala-Ala-Gly sequence in all three strands, the probability of finding conformations with internal loops is small, i.e., 0.06. Internal loops affect the overall orientation of these structures, as measured by the helix-distortion parameters S, K, and U. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Two types of tripeptide conformation in collagen. Calculation of the structure of (Gly-Pro-Ser)n and (Gly-Val-Hyp)n polytripeptides

Conformational analysis of polypeptides (Gly-Pro-Ser)n and (Gly-Val-Hyp)n was carried out for collagen-like triple helical complexes (coiled coils with screw symmetry). The lowest energy structure of the first polymer (helical parameters t 52,8, h 0,282 nm) is very close to that of (Gly-Pro-Hyp)n. The hydroxyl group of a serine residue does not form any intramolecular hydrogen bonds in this structure. (Gly-Val-Hyp)n triple complex is shown to unwind to t 7,7, h 0,297 nm as a result of optimization procedure. These findings confirm the assumption, made earlier on the basis of conformational analysis of (Gly-Pro-Hyp)n, (Gly-Pro-Ala)n, (Gly-Ala-Hyp)n, (Gly-Ala-Ala)n, that the collagen triple helix contains stable wound triplets with proline in the second position, while the absence of imino acid in the 2nd position facilitates the unwinding of the triple helix. Thus, a collagen helix appears to have different parameters for the sites differing in the amino acid sequence. The values measured in the X-ray experiments (h 0,29 nm, t' 36) should be considered as a result of averaging. The model allows to reconcile the X-ray data for collagen and crystalline (Gly-Pro-Pro)10 oligomer.     

Origin of the stability conferred upon collagen by fluorination

According to a prevailing theory, (2S,4R)-4-hydroxyproline (Hyp) residues stabilize the collagen triple helix via a stereoelectronic effect that preorganizes appropriate backbone torsion angles for triple-helix formation. This theory is consistent with the marked stability that results from replacing the hydroxyl group with the more electron-withdrawing fluoro group, as in (2S,4R)-4-fluoroproline (Flp). Nonetheless, the hyperstability of triple helices containing Flp has been attributed by others to the hydrophobic effect rather than a stereoelectronic effect. We tested this hypothesis by replacing Hyp with 4,4-difluoroproline (Dfp) in collagen-related peptides. Dfp retains the hydrophobicity of Flp, but lacks the ability of Flp to preorganize backbone torsion angles. Unlike Flp, Dfp does not endow triple helices with elevated stability, indicating that the hyperstability conferred by Flp is not due to the hydrophobic effect.     

Interruptions in the collagen repeating tripeptide pattern can promote supramolecular association

The standard collagen triple‐helix requires a perfect (Gly‐Xaa‐Yaa)_n sequence, yet all nonfibrillar collagens contain interruptions in this tripeptide repeating pattern. Defining the structural consequences of disruptions in the sequence pattern may shed light on the biological role of sequence interruptions, which have been suggested to play a role in molecular flexibility, collagen degradation, and ligand binding. Previous studies on model peptides with 1‐ and 4‐residue interruptions showed a localized perturbation within the triple‐helix, and this work is extended to introduce natural collagen interruptions up to nine residue in length within a fixed (Gly‐Pro‐Hyp)_n peptide context. All peptides in this set show decreases in triple‐helix content and stability, with greater conformational perturbations for the interruptions longer than five residue. The most stable and least perturbed structure is seen for the 5‐residue interruption peptide, whose sequence corresponds to a Gly to Ala missense mutation, such as those leading to collagen genetic diseases. The triple‐helix peptides containing 8‐ and 9‐residue interruptions exhibit a strong propensity for self‐association to fibrous structures. In addition, a small peptide modeling only the 9‐residue sequence within the interruption aggregates to form amyloid‐like fibrils with antiparallel β‐sheet structure. The 8‐ and 9‐residue interruption sequences studied here are predicted to have significant cross‐β aggregation potential, and a similar propensity is reported for ～10% of other naturally occurring interruptions. The presence of amyloidogenic sequences within or between triple‐helix domains may play a role in molecular association to normal tissue structures and could participate in observed interactions between collagen and amyloid.     

The crystal structure of the collagen-like polypeptide (glycyl-4(R)-hydroxyprolyl-4(R)-hydroxyprolyl)9 at 1.55 A resolution shows up-puckering of the proline ring in the Xaa position

The collagen triple helix is characterized by the repeating sequence motif Gly-Xaa-Yaa, where Xaa and Yaa are typically proline and (2S,4R)-4-hydroxyproline (4(R)Hyp), respectively. Previous analyses have revealed that H-(Pro-4(R)Hyp-Gly)(10)-OH forms a stable triple helix, whereas H-(4(R)Hyp-Pro-Gly)(10)-OH does not. Several theories have been put forth to explain the importance of proline puckering and conformation in triple helix formation; however, the details of how they affect triple helix stability are unknown. Underscoring this, we recently demonstrated that the polypeptide Ac-(Gly-4(R)Hyp-4(R)Hyp)(10)-NH(2) forms a triple helix that is more stable than Ac-(Gly-Pro-4(R)Hyp)(10)-NH(2). Here we report crystal the structure of the H-(Gly-4(R)Hyp-4(R)Hyp)(9)-OH peptide at 1.55 A resolution. The puckering of the Yaa position 4(R)Hyp in this structure is up (Cgamma exo), as has been found in other collagen peptide structures. Notably, however, the 4(R)Hyp in the Xaa position also takes the up pucker, which is distinct from all other collagen structures. Regardless of the notable difference in the Xaa proline puckering, our structure still adopts a 7/2 superhelical symmetry similar to that observed in other collagen structures. Thus, the basis for the observed differences in the thermodynamic data of the triple helix<--> coil transition between our peptide and other triple helical peptides likely results from contributions from the unfolded state. Indeed, the unfolded state of the H-(Gly-4(R)Hyp-4(R)Hyp)(9)-OH peptide seems to be stabilized by a preformed polyproline II helix in each strand, which could be explained by the presence of a unique repeating intra-strand water-mediated bridge observed in the H-(Gly-4(R)Hyp-4(R)Hyp)(9)-OH structure, as well as a higher amount of trans peptide bonds.