Folding of A+U-rich RNA elements modulates AUF1 binding. Potential roles in regulation of mRNA turnover

In mammals, A+U-rich elements (AREs) are potent cis-acting determinants of rapid cytoplasmic mRNA turnover. Recognition of these sequences by AUF1 is associated with acceleration of mRNA decay, likely involving recruitment or assembly of multi-subunit trans-acting complexes. Previously, we demonstrated that AUF1 deletion mutants formed tetramers on U-rich RNA substrates by sequential addition of protein dimers (Wilson, G. M., Sun, Y., Lu, H., and Brewer, G. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 33374-33381). Here, we show that binding of the full-length p37 isoform of AUF1 to these RNAs proceeds via a similar mechanism, allowing delineation of equilibrium binding constants for both stages of tetramer assembly. However, association of AUF1 with the ARE from tumor necrosis factor (TNFalpha) mRNA was significantly inhibited by magnesium ions. Further fluorescence and hydrodynamic experiments indicated that Mg(2+) induced or stabilized a conformational change in the TNFalpha ARE. Based on the solution of parameters describing both the protein-RNA and Mg(2+)-RNA equilibria, we present a dynamic, global equilibrium binding model describing the relationship between Mg(2+) and AUF1 binding to the TNFalpha ARE. These studies provide the first evidence that some AREs may adopt higher order RNA structures that regulate their interaction with trans-acting factors and indicate that mRNA structural remodeling has the potential to modulate the turnover rates of some ARE-containing mRNAs.     

Thermodynamics and kinetics of Hsp70 association with A + U-rich mRNA-destabilizing sequences

Rapid mRNA degradation directed by A + U-rich elements (AREs) is mediated by the interaction of specific RNA-binding proteins to these sequences. The protein chaperone Hsp70 has been identified in a cellular complex containing the ARE-binding protein AUF1 and has also been detected in direct contact with A + U-rich RNA substrates, indicating that Hsp70 may be involved in the regulation of ARE-directed mRNA turnover. By using gel mobility shift and fluorescence anisotropy assays, we have determined that Hsp70 directly and specifically associates with U-rich RNA substrates in solution. With the ARE from tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFalpha) mRNA, Hsp70 forms a dynamic complex consistent with a 1:1 association of protein:RNA but demonstrates cooperative binding behavior on polyuridylate substrates. Unlike AUF1, the RNA binding activity of Hsp70 is not regulated by ion-dependent folding of the TNFalpha ARE, suggesting that AUF1 and Hsp70 recognize distinct binding determinants on this RNA substrate. Binding of Hsp70 to the TNFalpha ARE is driven entirely by enthalpy at physiological temperatures, indicating that burial of hydrophobic surfaces is likely the principal mechanism stabilizing the Hsp70.RNA complex. Potential roles for the interaction of Hsp70 with ARE-containing mRNAs in the regulation of mRNA turnover and/or translational efficiency are discussed.     

Phosphorylation of p40AUF1 regulates binding to A + U-rich mRNA-destabilizing elements and protein-induced changes in ribonucleoprotein structure

Messenger RNA turnover directed by A + U-rich elements (AREs) involves selected ARE-binding proteins. Whereas several signaling systems may modulate ARE-directed mRNA decay and/or post-translationally modify specific trans-acting factors, it is unclear how these mechanisms are linked. In THP-1 monocytic leukemia cells, phorbol ester-induced stabilization of some mRNAs containing AREs was accompanied by dephosphorylation of Ser83 and Ser87 of polysome-associated p40AUF1. Here, we report that phosphorylation of p40AUF1 influences its ARE-binding affinity as well as the RNA conformational dynamics and global structure of the p40AUF1-ARE ribonucleoprotein complex. Most notably, association of unphosphorylated p40AUF1 induces a condensed RNA conformation upon ARE substrates. By contrast, phosphorylation of p40AUF1 at Ser83 and Ser87 inhibits this RNA structural transition. These data indicate that selective AUF1 phosphorylation may regulate ARE-directed mRNA turnover by remodeling local RNA structures, thus potentially altering the presentation of RNA and/or protein determinants involved in subsequent trans-factor recruitment.     

Structural remodeling of an A + U-rich RNA element by cation or AUF1 binding

Association of AUF1 with A + U-rich elements (AREs) induces rapid cytoplasmic degradation of mRNAs containing these sequences, involving the recruitment or assembly of multisubunit trans-acting complexes on the mRNA. Recently, we reported that Mg(2+)-induced conformational changes in the ARE from tumor necrosis factor alpha mRNA inhibited AUF1 binding and oligomerization activities on this substrate (Wilson, G. M., Sutphen, K., Chuang, K., and Brewer, G. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 8695-8704). In this study, resonance energy transfer was employed to characterize structural changes in RNA substrates in response to cation- and AUF1-binding events. An RNA substrate containing the tumor necrosis factor alpha ARE displayed a weak conformational transition in the absence of added cations but was cooperatively stabilized by Mg(2+). Additional assays demonstrated a strong preference for small, multivalent cations, suggesting that the folded RNA structure was stabilized by counterion neutralization at discrete regions of high negative charge density. Association of AUF1 with cognate RNA substrates also induced formation of condensed RNA structures, although distinct from the folded structure stabilized by multivalent cations. Taken together, these experiments indicate that association of AUF1 with an ARE may function to remodel local RNA structures, which may be a prerequisite for subsequent recruitment of additional trans-acting factors.     

Regulation of A + U-rich element-directed mRNA turnover involving reversible phosphorylation of AUF1

Proteins binding A + U-rich elements (AREs) contribute to the rapid cytoplasmic turnover of mRNAs containing these sequences. However, this process is a regulated event and may be accelerated or inhibited by myriad signal transduction systems. For example, monocyte adherence at sites of inflammation or tissue injury is associated with inhibition of ARE-directed mRNA decay, which contributes to rapid increases in cytokine and inflammatory mediator production. Here, we show that acute exposure of THP-1 monocytic leukemia cells to the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate mimics several features of monocyte adherence, including rapid induction and stabilization of ARE-containing mRNAs encoding interleukin-1 beta and tumor necrosis factor alpha. Additionally, TPA treatment alters the activity of cytoplasmic complexes that bind AREs, including complexes containing the ARE-specific, mRNA-destabilizing factor, AUF1. Analyses of AUF1 from control and TPA-treated cells indicated that post-translational modifications of the major cytoplasmic isoform, p40AUF1, are altered concomitant with changes in RNA binding activity and stabilization of ARE-containing mRNAs. In particular, p40AUF1 recovered from polysomes was phosphorylated on Ser83 and Ser87 in untreated cells but lost these modifications following TPA treatment. We propose that selected signal transduction pathways may regulate ARE-directed mRNA turnover by reversible phosphorylation of polysome-associated p40AUF1.     

Assembly of Functional Ribonucleoprotein Complexes by AU-rich Element RNA-binding Protein 1 (AUF1) Requires Base-dependent and -independent RNA Contacts

AU-rich element RNA-binding protein 1 (AUF1) regulates the stability and/or translational efficiency of diverse mRNA targets, including many encoding products controlling the cell cycle, apoptosis, and inflammation by associating with AU-rich elements residing in their 3′-untranslated regions. Previous biochemical studies showed that optimal AUF1 binding requires 33–34 nucleotides with a strong preference for U-rich RNA despite observations that few AUF1-associated cellular mRNAs contain such extended U-rich domains. Using the smallest AUF1 isoform (p37^AUF1) as a model, we employed fluorescence anisotropy-based approaches to define thermodynamic parameters describing AUF1 ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex formation across a panel of RNA substrates. These data demonstrated that 15 nucleotides of AU-rich sequence were sufficient to nucleate high affinity p37^AUF1 RNP complexes within a larger RNA context. In particular, p37^AUF1 binding to short AU-rich RNA targets was significantly stabilized by interactions with a 3′-purine residue and largely base-independent but non-ionic contacts 5′ of the AU-rich site. RNP stabilization by the upstream RNA domain was associated with an enhanced negative change in heat capacity consistent with conformational changes in protein and/or RNA components, and fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based assays demonstrated that these contacts were required for p37^AUF1 to remodel local RNA structure. Finally, reporter mRNAs containing minimal high affinity p37^AUF1 target sequences associated with AUF1 and were destabilized in a p37^AUF1-dependent manner in cells. These findings provide a mechanistic explanation for the diverse population of AUF1 target mRNAs but also suggest how AUF1 binding could regulate protein and/or microRNA binding events at adjacent sites.     

Identification and characterization of proteins binding A + U-rich elements

A + U-Rich elements (AREs) have been extensively investigated as cis-acting determinants of rapid mRNA turnover. Recently, a number of RNA-binding proteins interacting with AREs have been described. This article presents strategies and techniques used by our laboratory to identify and characterize a family of ARE-binding proteins collectively termed AUF1. However, these techniques may be applied to the study of any protein displaying sequence-specific RNA binding activity. The techniques described here include the purification of native AUF1 from cultured cells as well as the preparation of recombinant AUF1 proteins using a bacterial expression system. Analyses of RNA-protein interactions are also described, including the use of gel mobility shift assays with synthetic RNA probes to monitor specific RNA binding activity in cell extracts or with recombinant proteins. Variations of this technique are also described to evaluate the RNA binding affinity of recombinant proteins and the use of specific RNA competitors to assess RNA determinants of protein binding specificity. Other techniques presented include the identification of specific proteins in RNA:protein complexes using antibody supershifts and the estimation of molecular weights of RNA-binding proteins by UV crosslinking. Results of individual experiments are presented as examples of some techniques. Throughout the article, suggestions are included to avoid commonly encountered problems and to assist in the optimization of these techniques for the study of other RNA-binding proteins.     

Alternatively expressed domains of AU-rich element RNA-binding protein 1 (AUF1) regulate RNA-binding affinity, RNA-induced protein oligomerization, and the local conformation of bound RNA ligands

AU-rich element RNA-binding protein 1 (AUF1) binding to AU-rich elements (AREs) in the 3'-untranslated regions of mRNAs encoding many cytokines and other regulatory proteins modulates mRNA stability, thereby influencing protein expression. AUF1-mRNA association is a dynamic paradigm directed by various cellular signals, but many features of its function remain poorly described. There are four isoforms of AUF1 that result from alternative splicing of exons 2 and 7 from a common pre-mRNA. Preliminary evidence suggests that the different isoforms have varied functional characteristics, but no detailed quantitative analysis of the properties of each isoform has been reported despite their differential expression and regulation. Using purified recombinant forms of each AUF1 protein variant, we used chemical cross-linking and gel filtration chromatography to show that each exists as a dimer in solution. We then defined the association mechanisms of each AUF1 isoform for ARE-containing RNA substrates and quantified relevant binding affinities using electrophoretic mobility shift and fluorescence anisotropy assays. Although all AUF1 isoforms generated oligomeric complexes on ARE substrates by sequential dimer association, sequences encoded by exon 2 inhibited RNA-binding affinity. By contrast, the exon 7-encoded domain enhanced RNA-dependent protein oligomerization, even permitting cooperative RNA-binding activity in some contexts. Finally, fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based assays showed that the different AUF1 isoforms remodel bound RNA substrates into divergent structures as a function of protein:RNA stoichiometry. Together, these data describe isoform-specific characteristics among AUF1 ribonucleoprotein complexes, which likely constitute a mechanistic basis for differential functions and regulation among members of this protein family.     

Correlation between intrinsic mRNA stability and the affinity of AUF1 (huRNP D) and HuR for A+U-rich mRNAs

Presence of A+U-rich elements (AREs) within 3-untranslated regions (3UTRs) of numerous mRNAs has been associated with rapid mRNA turnover; however, the interaction of specific factors with AREs is also associated with mRNA stabilization. Recently, two ARE binding proteins with putative mRNA destabilizing (AUF1) and stabilizing (HuR) properties have been described. However, no direct comparison of AUF1 and HuR binding properties has been made. Therefore, we examined the relative affinities of p37AUF1 and HuR for a diverse set of ARE-containing mRNAs encoding -adrenergic receptors, a proto-oncogene, and a cytokine. We find that high-affinity AUF1 binding appears to require elements beyond primary nucleotide sequence. In contrast, binding of HuR appears considerably less constrained. As a functional correlate, we determined the ability of these specific mRNA sequences to affect the stability of chimeric -globin mRNA constructs. Although the relative affinity of AUF1 and HuR are generally predictive of mRNA stability, we find that certain mRNA sequences do not conform to these generalizations.     

Specific protein domains mediate cooperative assembly of HuR oligomers on AU-rich mRNA-destabilizing sequences

The RNA-binding factor HuR is a ubiquitously expressed member of the Hu protein family that binds and stabilizes mRNAs containing AU-rich elements (AREs). Hu proteins share a common domain organization of two tandemly arrayed RNA recognition motifs (RRMs) near the N terminus, followed by a basic hinge domain and a third RRM near the C terminus. In this study, we engineered recombinant wild-type and mutant HuR proteins lacking affinity tags to characterize their ARE-binding properties. Using combinations of electrophoretic mobility shift and fluorescence anisotropy-based binding assays, we show that HuR can bind ARE substrates as small as 13 nucleotides with low nanomolar affinity, but forms cooperative oligomeric protein complexes on ARE substrates of at least 18 nucleotides in length. Analyses of deletion mutant proteins indicated that RRM3 does not contribute to high affinity recognition of ARE substrates, but is required for cooperative assembly of HuR oligomers on RNA. Finally, the hinge domain between RRM2 and RRM3 contributes significant binding energy to HuR.ARE complex formation in an ARE length-dependent manner. The hinge does not enhance RNA-binding activity by increased ion pair formation despite extensive positive charge within this region, and it does not thermodynamically stabilize protein folding. Together, the results define distinct roles for the HuR hinge and RRM3 domains in formation of cooperative HuR.ARE complexes in solution.     

Cell death inhibiting RNA (CDIR) derived from a 3'-untranslated region binds AUF1 and heat shock protein 27

Regulators of programmed cell death were previously identified using a technical knockout genetic screen. Among the elements that inhibited interferon-gamma-induced apoptosis of HeLa cells was a 441-nucleotide fragment derived from the 3'-untranslated region (UTR) of KIAA0425, a gene of unknown function. This fragment was termed cell death inhibiting RNA (CDIR). Deletion and mutation analyses of CDIR were employed to identify the features required for its anti-apoptotic activity. Single nucleotide alterations within either copy of the duplicated U-rich motif found in the CDIR sequence abolished the anti-apoptotic activity of CDIR and altered its in vitro association with a protein complex. Further analysis of the CDIR-binding complex indicated that it contained heat shock protein 27 (Hsp27) and the regulator of mRNA turnover AUF1 (heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein D). In addition, recombinant AUF1 bound directly to CDIR. Furthermore, expression of another AUF1-binding RNA element, derived from the 3'-UTR of c-myc, inhibited apoptosis. We also demonstrate that the level and the stability of p21(waf1/Cip1/sdi1) mRNA, a target of AUF1 with anti-apoptotic activity, were increased in CDIR-transfected cells. The level of mRNA and protein of Bcl-2, another anti-apoptotic gene, containing an AUF1 binding site in its 3'-UTR was also increased in CDIR-transfected cells. Our data suggest that AUF1 regulates apoptosis by altering mRNA turnover. We propose that CDIR inhibits apoptosis by acting as a competitive inhibitor of AUF1, preventing AUF1 from binding to its targets.     

Tissue distribution of AU-rich mRNA-binding proteins involved in regulation of mRNA decay

Short lived cytokine and proto-oncogene mRNAs are destabilized by an A+U-rich element (ARE) in the 3'-untranslated region. Several regulatory proteins bind to AREs in cytokine and proto-oncogene mRNAs, participate in inhibiting or promoting their rapid degradation of ARE mRNAs, and influence cytokine expression and cellular transformation in experimental models. The tissue distribution and cellular localization of the different AU-rich binding proteins (AUBPs), however, have not been uniformly characterized in the mouse, a model for ARE mRNA decay. We therefore carried out immunoblot and immunohistochemical analyses of the different AUBPs using the same mouse tissues. We show that HuR protein, a major AUBP that stabilizes the ARE mRNAs, is most strongly expressed in the thymus, spleen (predominantly in lymphocytic cells), intestine, and testes. AUF1 protein, a negative regulator of ARE mRNA stability, displayed strong expression in thymus and spleen cells within lymphocytic cells, moderate expression in the epithelial linings of lungs, gonadal tissues, and nuclei of most neurons in the brain, and little expression in the other tissues. Tristetraprolin, a negative regulator of ARE mRNA stability, displayed a largely non-overlapping tissue distribution with AUF1 and was predominantly expressed in the liver and testis. KH-type splicing regulatory protein, a presumptive negative regulator of ARE mRNA stability, was distributed widely in murine organs. These results indicate that HuR and AUF1, which functionally oppose each other, have generally similar distributions, suggesting that the balance between HuR and AUF1 is likely important in control of short lived mRNA degradation, lymphocyte development, and/or cytokine production, and possibly in certain aspects of neurological function.