Probing the architecture of the B. subtilis RNase P holoenzyme active site by cross-linking and affinity cleavage

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein complex composed of one catalytic RNA (PRNA) and one protein subunit (P protein) that together catalyze the 5' maturation of precursor tRNA. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures of the individual P protein and PRNA components from several species have been determined, and structural models of the RNase P holoenzyme have been proposed. However, holoenzyme models have been limited by a lack of distance constraints between P protein and PRNA in the holoenzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report the results of extensive cross-linking and affinity cleavage experiments using single-cysteine P protein variants derivatized with either azidophenacyl bromide or 5-iodoacetamido-1,10-o-phenanthroline to determine distance constraints and to model the Bacillus subtilis holoenzyme-substrate complex. These data indicate that the evolutionarily conserved RNR motif of P protein is located near (<15 Angstroms) the pre-tRNA cleavage site, the base of the pre-tRNA acceptor stem and helix P4 of PRNA, the putative active site of the enzyme. In addition, the metal binding loop and N-terminal region of the P protein are proximal to the P3 stem-loop of PRNA. Studies using heterologous holoenzymes composed of covalently modified B. subtilis P protein and Escherichia coli M1 RNA indicate that P protein binds similarly to both RNAs. Together, these data indicate that P protein is positioned close to the RNase P active site and may play a role in organizing the RNase P active site.     

Protein activation of a ribozyme: the role of bacterial RNase P protein

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) belongs to a class of enzymes that utilize both RNAs and proteins to perform essential cellular functions. The bacterial RNase P protein is required to activate bacterial RNase P RNA in vivo, but previous studies have yielded contradictory conclusions regarding its specific functions. Here, we use biochemical and biophysical techniques to examine all of the proposed functions of the protein in both Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis RNase P. We demonstrate that the E. coli protein, but not the B. subtilis protein, stabilizes the global structure of RNase P RNA, although both proteins influence holoenzyme dimer formation and precursor tRNA recognition to different extents. By comparing each protein in complex with its cognate and noncognate RNA, we show that differences between the two types of holoenzymes reside primarily in the RNA and not the protein components of each. Our results reconcile previous contradictory conclusions regarding the role of the protein and support a model where the protein activates local RNA structures that manifest multiple holoenzyme properties.     

Escherichia coli ribosomes bind to non-initiator sites of Q beta RNA in the absence of formylmethionyl-tRNA.

Escherichia coli ribosomes and Qβ [³²P]RNA were incubated with or without fMet-tRNA under protein initiation conditions, treated with RNase A, and centrifuged through a sucrose density gradient. The sample incubated with fMet-tRNA gave a main radioactivity peak in the 70 S region, which consisted predominantly of coat cistron initiator fragments. After incubation without fMet-tRNA, equal amounts of radioactivity were found in the 70 S and the 30 S regions, but in both peaks almost all of the radioactivity was duo to three RNase A-resistant oligonucleotides, A-G-A-G-G-A-G-G-Up (P-2a), A-G-G-G-G-G-Up (P-15) and G-G-A-A-G-G-A-G-Cp (P-4). These three oligonucleotides are derived from three different RNA regions, none of which is close to a protein initiation site. All three fragments show striking complementarity to the 3′-terminal region of E. coli 16 S RNA. Ribosomes incubated with an RNase A digest of Qβ [³²P]RNA bound almost exclusively oligonucleotide P-2a; treatment with cloacin DF13 cleaved off a complex consisting of a 49-nucleotide long segment of 16 S rRNA and oligonucleotide P-2a. These experiments show that the interaction of 30 S ribosomes with the “Shine-Dalgarno” region preceding the initiator codon of the Qβ coat cistron is insufficient to direct correct placement of the ribosome on the viral RNA, and that an additional contribution from the interaction of fMet-tRNA with the initiator triplet is required for ribosome binding to the initiator region.     

Identification of adenosine functional groups involved in substrate binding by the ribonuclease P ribozyme

The RNA component of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) binds to substrate pre-tRNAs with high affinity and catalyzes site-specific phosphodiester bond hydrolysis to generate the mature tRNA 5' end. Herein we describe the use of biotinylated pre-tRNA substrates to isolate RNase P ribozyme-substrate complexes for nucleotide analogue interference mapping of ribozyme base functional groups involved in substrate recognition. By using a series of adenosine base analogues tagged with phosphorothioate substitutions, we identify specific chemical groups involved in substrate binding. Only 10 adenosines in the Escherichia coli ribozyme show significant sensitivity to interference: A65, A66, A136, A232-234, A248, A249, A334, and A347. Most of these adenosine positions are universally conserved among all bacterial RNase P RNAs; however, not all conserved adenosines are sensitive to analogue substitution. Importantly, all but one of the sensitive nucleotides are located at positions of intermolecular cross-linking between the ribozyme and the substrate. One site of interference that did not correlate with available structural data involved A136 in J11/12. To confirm the generality of the results, we repeated the interference analysis of J11/12 in the Bacillus subtilis RNase P ribozyme, which differs significantly in overall secondary structure. Notably, the B. subtilis ribozyme shows an identical interference pattern at the position (A191) that is homologous to A136. Furthermore, mutation of A136 in the E. coli ribozyme gives rise to a measurable increase in the equilibrium binding constant for the ribozyme-substrate interaction, while mutation of a nearby conserved nucleotide (A132) that is not sensitive to analogue incorporation does not. These results strongly support direct participation of nucleotides in the P4, P11, J5/15, and J18/2 regions of ribozyme structure in pre-tRNA binding and implicate an additional region, J11/12, as involved in substrate recognition. In aggregate, the interference results provide a detailed chemical picture of how the conserved nucleotides adjacent to the pre-tRNA substrate contribute to substrate binding and provide a framework for subsequent identification of the specific roles of these chemical groups in substrate recognition.     

Recognition of the 5' leader of pre-tRNA substrates by the active site of ribonuclease P

The bacterial tRNA processing enzyme ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein composed of a approximately 400 nucleotide RNA and a smaller protein subunit. It has been established that RNase P RNA contacts the mature tRNA portion of pre-tRNA substrates, whereas RNase P protein interacts with the 5' leader sequence. However, specific interactions with substrate nucleotides flanking the cleavage site have not previously been defined. Here we provide evidence for an interaction between a conserved adenosine, A248 in the Escherichia coli ribozyme, and N(-1), the substrate nucleotide immediately 5' of the cleavage site. Specifically, mutations at A248 result in miscleavage of substrates containing a 2' deoxy modification at N(-1). Compensatory mutations at N(-1) restore correct cleavage in both the RNA-alone and holoenzyme reactions, and also rescue defects in binding thermodynamics caused by A248 mutation. Analysis of pre-tRNA leader sequences in Bacteria and Archaea reveals a conserved preference for U at N(-1), suggesting that an interaction between A248 and N(-1) is common among RNase P enzymes. These results provide the first direct evidence for RNase P RNA interactions with the substrate cleavage site, and show that RNA and protein cooperate in leader sequence recognition.     

Multiple substrate binding sites in the ribozyme from Bacillus subtilis RNase P.

The ribozyme from Bacillus subtilis RNase P (P RNA) recognizes an RNA structure consisting of the acceptor stem and the T stem-loop of tRNA substrates. An in vitro selection experiment was carried out to obtain potential RNA substrates that may interact with the P RNA differently from the tRNA substrate. Using a P RNA-derived ribozyme that contains most, if not all, of the structural elements thought to be involved in active site formation of P RNA, but lacks the putative binding site for the T stem-loop of tRNA, a single RNA substrate was isolated after nine rounds of selection. This RNA is a competent substrate for the ribozyme used in selection as well as for the full-length P RNA. Biochemical characterization shows that this selected substrate interacts at a different site compared with the tRNA substrate. The selection experiment also identified a self-cleaving RNA seemingly different from other known ribozymes. These results indicate that a biological ribozyme can contain different binding sites for different RNA substrates. This alternate binding site model suggests a simple mechanism for evolving existing ribozymes to recognize RNA substrates of diverse structures.     

Molecular modeling of the three-dimensional structure of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P), an enzyme involved in tRNA maturation, consists of a catalytic RNA subunit and a protein cofactor. Comparative phylogenetic analysis and molecular modeling have been employed to derive secondary and tertiary structure models of the RNA subunits from Escherichia coli (type A) and Bacillus subtilis (type B) RNase P. The tertiary structure of the protein subunit of B.subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus RNase P has recently been determined. However, an understanding of the structure of the RNase P holoenzyme (i.e. the ribonucleoprotein complex) is lacking. We have now used an EDTA-Fe-based footprinting approach to generate information about RNA-protein contact sites in E.coli RNase P. The footprinting data, together with results from other biochemical and biophysical studies, have furnished distance constraints, which in turn have enabled us to build three-dimensional models of both type A and B versions of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme in the absence and presence of its precursor tRNA substrate. These models are consistent with results from previous studies and provide both structural and mechanistic insights into the functioning of this unique catalytic RNP complex.     

Approaching translation at atomic resolution

Atomic resolution structures of 50S and 30S ribosomal particles have recently been solved by X-ray diffraction. These ribosomal structures show often unusual folds of ribosomal RNAs and proteins, and provide molecular explanations for fundamental aspects of translation. In the 50S structure, the active site for peptide bond formation was localized and found to consist of RNA. The ribosome is thus a ribozyme. In the 30S structures, tRNA binding sites were located, and molecular mechanisms for ribosomal fidelity were proposed. The 30S subunit particle has three globular domains, and relative movements of these domains may be required for translocation of the ribosome during protein synthesis. The structures are consistent with and rationalize decades of biochemical analysis of translation and usher in a molecular age in understanding the ribosome.     

G350 of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA contributes to Mg2+ binding near the active site of the enzyme

G350 of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA is a highly conserved residue among all bacteria and lies near the known magnesium binding site for the RNase P ribozyme, helix P4. Mutations at G350 have a dramatic effect on substrate cleavage activity for both RNA alone and holoenzyme; the G350C mutation has the most severe phenotype. The G350C mutation also inhibits growth of cells that express the mutant RNA in vivo under conditions of magnesium starvation. The results suggest that G350 contributes to Mg(2+) binding at helix P4 of RNase P RNA.     

The effect of tRNA binding on the structure of 5 S RNA in Escherichia coli. A chemical modification study

The structure of 5 S RNA within the 70 S ribosome from Escherichia coli was studied using the chemical reagent kethoxal (alpha-keto-beta-ethoxybutyraldehyde) to modify accessible guanosines. The modification pattern of 5 S RNA from free 70 S ribosomes was compared with that of poly(U) programmed ribosomes where tRNA had been bound to both the A- and P-sites. Binding to the ribosomal A-site was achieved enzymatically using the elongation factor Tu and GTP in the presence of deacylated tRNA which blocks the ribosomal P-site. Modified guanosines were identified after partial RNase T1 hydrolysis and separation of the hydrolysis products on sequencing gels. Binding of tRNA to the ribosome leads to a strong protection of 5 S RNA guanosine G-41 and to some degree G-44 from kethoxal modification. The limited RNase T1 hydrolysis pattern provides evidence for the existence of a 5 S RNA conformation different from the known 5 S RNA A- and B-forms which are characterized by their gel electrophoretic mobility. The importance of 5 S RNA for the binding of tRNA to the ribosome is discussed.     

Identification of the gene encoding the 5S ribosomal RNA maturase in Bacillus subtilis: mature 5S rRNA is dispensable for ribosome function

Over 25 years ago, Pace and coworkers described an activity called RNase M5 in Bacillus subtilis cell extracts responsible for 5S ribosomal RNA maturation (Sogin & Pace, Nature, 1974, 252:598-600). Here we show that RNase M5 is encoded by a gene of previously unknown function that is highly conserved among the low G + C gram-positive bacteria. We propose that the gene be named rnmV. The rnmV gene is nonessential. B. subtilis strains lacking RNase M5 do not make mature 5S rRNA, indicating that this process is not necessary for ribosome function. 5S rRNA precursors can, however, be found in both free and translating ribosomes. In contrast to RNase E, which cleaves the Escherichia coli 5S precursor in a single-stranded region, which is then trimmed to yield mature 5S RNA, RNase M5 cleaves the B. subtilis equivalent in a double-stranded region to yield mature 5S rRNA in one step. For the most part, eubacteria contain one or the other system for 5S rRNA production, with an imperfect division along gram-negative and gram-positive lines. A potential correlation between the presence of RNase E or RNase M5 and the single- or double-stranded nature of the predicted cleavage sites is explored.     

Cleavage of the sarcin–ricin loop of 23S rRNA differentially affects EF-G and EF-Tu binding

Ribotoxins are potent inhibitors of protein biosynthesis and inactivate ribosomes from a variety of organisms. The ribotoxin α-sarcin cleaves the large 23S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) at the universally conserved sarcin–ricin loop (SRL) leading to complete inactivation of the ribosome and cellular death. The SRL interacts with translation factors that hydrolyze GTP, and it is important for their binding to the ribosome, but its precise role is not yet understood. We studied the effect of α-sarcin on defined steps of translation by the bacterial ribosome. α-Sarcin-treated ribosomes showed no defects in mRNA and tRNA binding, peptide-bond formation and sparsomycin-dependent translocation. Cleavage of SRL slightly affected binding of elongation factor Tu ternary complex (EF-Tu•GTP•tRNA) to the ribosome. In contrast, the activity of elongation factor G (EF-G) was strongly impaired in α-sarcin-treated ribosomes. Importantly, cleavage of SRL inhibited EF-G binding, and consequently GTP hydrolysis and mRNA–tRNA translocation. These results suggest that the SRL is more critical in EF-G than ternary complex binding to the ribosome implicating different requirements in this region of the ribosome during protein elongation.     

5 S RNA-protein complex is involved in ribosomal subunit association

The immobilized tRNA-50 S ribosomal subunit protein (TP50) complex binds the smaller ribosomal subunit. We constructed tRNA . TP50 . 5 S [32P] RNA and tRNA . TP50 . t [32P] RNA complexes and investigated the accessibility of the 32P-labelled tRNAs to ribonuclease T1. It was found that in this complex both 5 S RNA and tRNA are attacked by T1 RNase. In sharp contrast, the addition of 30 S subunit protects 5 S RNA as well as tRNA from degradation. We suggest that 5 S RNA-TP50 complex is exposed to the ribosomal interface and is involved in subunit interaction.     

Activation of bacterial ribonuclease P by macrolides

The effect of macrolide antibiotic spiramycin on RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA from Escherichia coli was investigated. Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribozyme that is responsible for the maturation of 5' termini of tRNA molecules. Spiramycin revealed a dose-dependent activation on pre-tRNA cleavage by E. coli RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA. The K s and V max, as well as the K s(app) and V max(app) values of RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA in the presence or absence of spiramycin, were calculated from primary and secondary kinetic plots. It was found that the activity status of RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA is improved by the presence of spiramycin 18- and 12-fold, respectively. Primer extension analysis revealed that spiramycin induces a conformational change of the P10/11 structural element of M1 RNA, which is involved in substrate recognition.     

The putative RNase P motif in the DEAD box helicase Hera is dispensable for efficient interaction with RNA and helicase activity

DEAD box helicases use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to remodel RNA structures or RNA/protein complexes. They share a common helicase core with conserved signature motifs, and additional domains may confer substrate specificity. Identification of a specific substrate is crucial towards understanding the physiological role of a helicase. RNA binding and ATPase stimulation are necessary, but not sufficient criteria for a bona fide helicase substrate. Here, we report single molecule FRET experiments that identify fragments of the 23S rRNA comprising hairpin 92 and RNase P RNA as substrates for the Thermus thermophilus DEAD box helicase Hera. Both substrates induce a switch to the closed conformation of the helicase core and stimulate the intrinsic ATPase activity of Hera. Binding of these RNAs is mediated by the Hera C-terminal domain, but does not require a previously proposed putative RNase P motif within this domain. ATP-dependent unwinding of a short helix adjacent to hairpin 92 in the ribosomal RNA suggests a specific role for Hera in ribosome assembly, analogously to the Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis helicases DbpA and YxiN. In addition, the specificity of Hera for RNase P RNA may be required for RNase P RNA folding or RNase P assembly.     

Rp-phosphorothioate modifications in RNase P RNA that interfere with tRNA binding.

We have used Rp-phosphorothioate modifications and a binding interference assay to analyse the role of phosphate oxygens in tRNA recognition by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) RNA. Total (100%) Rp-phosphorothioate modification at A, C or G positions of RNase P RNA strongly impaired tRNA binding and pre-tRNA processing, while effects were less pronounced at U positions. Partially modified E. coli RNase P RNAs were separated into tRNA binding and non-binding fractions by gel retardation. Rp-phosphorothioate modifications that interfered with tRNA binding were found 5' of nucleotides A67, G68, U69, C70, C71, G72, A130, A132, A248, A249, G300, A317, A330, A352, C353 and C354. Manganese rescue at positions U69, C70, A130 and A132 identified, for the first time, sites of direct metal ion coordination in RNase P RNA. Most sites of interference are at strongly conserved nucleotides and nine reside within a long-range base-pairing interaction present in all known RNase P RNAs. In contrast to RNase P RNA, 100% Rp-phosphorothioate substitutions in tRNA showed only moderate effects on binding to RNase P RNAs from E. coli, Bacillus subtilis and Chromatium vinosum, suggesting that pro-Rp phosphate oxygens of mature tRNA contribute relatively little to the formation of the tRNA-RNase P RNA complex.